Nightwish - Wish I Had An Angel (Live Hamburg, 28.09.2007)

[SerasVictoria0302]

Marco save the moment and the music.......... OMG!! Marco is more best!!!!!

[DonarsSeidr]

What a mess. It's a pity about the song

[Reebz0r]

Just sounds like a bad cover, and I wish she didn't wail over Marco singing the chorus. Its not a case her being a bad singer, Dark Passion Play is a testament to that. Its more a case of this song doesn't play to Annette's strengths and only highlights her weaknesses.

[TayLove1994]

ok, so , people think this annete can tote the bill? have her do "phantom of the opera". uh huh

[srsbsnsyo]

i wonder if she has even hit a single note in this song?.... horrible is still too good to describe this.

[NwDevotion]

Maldita sea, si no les gusta Anette, por que comentan?

Es molesto, encontrarte con estos comentarios estupidos, y tener que aguantarte las ganas de no decriles grocerias :@

[OZBOURNE3]

@NwDevotion Te asiste toda la razón, te apoyo totalmente, tal parece que estas personas solo viven para eso y te aseguro que ellos NO son mejores cantantes que Anette.

[NwDevotion]

@OZBOURNE3 Claro, estos trolles se la pasan criticando a Anette, como si a ella a estas alturas le importara, pero bueno, estos tipos solo pierden tiempo en estar ofendiendo a Anette, si supieran lo dificil que es estar en frente de miles de personas, esperando que ninguno te valla a ofender, eso tuvo que pasar ella y MAS! :D

Saludos!

[wiltzer1]

its such a bad choice... not for the voice.. annete has a great voice...but for the style.. i mean annete CANNOT I REPEAT CANNOT only sing but also bring the feeling in the tarjas songs... they sound alien to my ears... such a pitty for this band... i dont know if tarja will ever come back. all i know is that this sounds terrible

[bark00000]

alright, i like annette... but seriously, there are a few songs that she should just... avoid...

after this one i a scared for the future of "10th man down" and "wish master"

annette, should you ever read this comment

just pump out another "poet and the pendulum" or two, and you and i will get along just fine

[KhamulYT]

HORRIBLE She rapes this song!

[lkirkup]

@KhamulYT if you thinks rapes this song you should here Britney Anette Olson sing the siren

[soareloboblanco]

omg she cant sing this song

[heroesdrhouseaddict1]

you ppl cant deny that this song fits annette just as much as it fits tarja

[katy2319]

a nadie esta vieja de anette, la tarja le pega mil pata esta vieja canta feooo

[eloria1965]

i can't say that annette is a bad singer..but tarja's voice and image are irreplaceble in band of nightwish.tarja is a great artist and she doesn't need nightwish to prove it.however,annette would means to had order many good comments by being member in another band..

[katatonium]

Of course its not about Tarja or Anette, Nightwish wants to show that it is not only the singer but a whole band together is important, whoever is on vocals, they just got pissed so much that Nightwish was probably becoming kinda of Tarja "focused" / dependent ... well you know what i am trying to say. Tarja's voice is one of the best for sure.

[Lilla95h]

you're so right...those ones are Tarja's not Anette's!!!!!

it's like (for me) Tarja's dead and Anette is dancing on her grave

[WindAngel76]

Wishmaster, Sleeping Sun, The Siren, Wish I Had an Angel, Nemo, Ghost love Score...... tsss Anette kill these songs :/

[NightwishaL]

Ok, I wish to have the Angel Tarja with the angelic voice back. Anette has a good reason to wishing an angel ... -.-

[azwethinkweiz22]

i love anettes voice. she used to be sooo skinny. im not trying to poke fun at her by no means! but i feel soo bad cuz she did put on some pounds:(

[angelofdarkness49]

Wtf? How is anette too skinny? You must be fat then.

[azwethinkweiz22]

im not fat what so ever. im anettes size (when she was thinner). i weigh 115 lbs. so shut the fuck up. and im a female. i love anette i didnt say too skinny, i said she was a lot thinner before. she got bigger.

[giorgiogamo130370]

This songs like as focked mixture of metal and pop music. Tarja was the spirit of this group. Now they are dead!!!!!!

[swinepantz4]

@giorgiogamo130370 then stop listening/watching nightwish videos

[Helene494]

She's not a metal singer.She's trying to be someone she's not.I hate the way she moves as she was at the disco.

[Darkwoman007]

I hate Anette!!!!  she sucks

[Pixiebabe]

anette adapted this song to fit her singing style, the same could be said about tarja. at least in both cases the singing is done live and not lip synced.

[69daa69]

that singer sucks

[koyor]

need tarja :(

she kills the songs

[Chepiak]

totalna porażka

[krzychoruti]

Tarja to lepiej śpiewała. nie dorówna jej..

[Anyatek]

elle n'arrive pas a la cheville de tarja ...

[k84k]

Słabo to śpiewa

[h0mster]

Tarja ;(

[JediHayes]

She absolutely butchered that song

[JRadicalll]

LMFAO. Tarja is the one that butchered this song live my friend. She couldn't sing this song on key to save her life. Anette does it very well.

[slayingthedream]

anette does sooo good on this song! :] i love that girl! anette for the win!

[GothicAmy4]

I loved that band with Tarja. Really. For me, Nightwish exist to 2005 to End of an Era. Sorry, Anette.

[GothicAmy4]

sorry, no, no no! she destroyed one more song of my favs.

Love Tarja, and love Nightwish <3

don't like Anette...

[Kike3390]

totally agree...she's not a bad singer...but it's a totally different style!!!! T.T

[aspyr21]

she isn't singing she's howling!!

thats a shit

[Prin79]

No! she's a shit!! Tarja is the best and she'll ever be!

[ZiuzinMikhail]

eem... its not nightwish more...

[marcelgti16v]

i'm sorry but this song with tarja was amazing. with anette it's sound like shit. TATJA is the best for nightwish.

[Urmothafu]

nice cover!

[galopper04]

it should be forbidden that anette sings the old songs which were written for tarja!!!

[BusterDobermann]

they were written for nightwish, not only for tarja

[galopper04]

i meant for tarja´s voice. anette is alto, i think. tarja is soprano.

sry for my bad english

[KikaSeoane]

No me gusta.... no nononon muy mal canta muy mal la niña Parece Pop.

[Szapirka]

it's nice when Anette tries to sing older songs, but she fails :(

[glareO8O]

country girl)))

its just my first thought that came into my mind

like our girls from the village- voice good but strange, clothes without style but bright, moves .... her moves :)....

[lesco]

mmm noo

i don´t like it at all

she is not bad it´s just those songs where made for a soprano which she is not

[CordOfTheRings]

I perfer some songs sung by Tarja (like 'The Siren') but I really prefer Wish I had an Angel sung by Anette!

[clayman2006]

love anete! tarja is great but anete too love your voice!

[SondreSau]

Hey Anette haters!

If you rly love tarja that much, why don't listen to her own songs insted?

[MedusaCBGB]

Tarja I miss u!!!

[DXTXDXT]

Where are Tarja...? (ja,ja,ja...)

[3Dmidori]

Anette is awesome! I loved Tarja, but Anette's voice is beautiful, so stop bashing her.

[DasTenMan]

The best band of the Wolrd!

Its a nice song and the Anette is great

[Rollinpin123]

Totally agreed.

[Vaertate]

Sad imitation...

[lovestruckvampire]

God!! What is she trying to do????!! NEVER sing Tarja's songs lovey!! Sing ur own is fine bt PLS dont try to ruin all of Tarjas songs like dat!!

[luizlink64]

This isnt a Tarja song, its a Nigthwish song. And, she doesnt tried to sing like Tarja, she sungs trying to leave the song with a new voice!!! And, i think she was suceed doing this.

[mishkyn910]

True!!

[luizlink64]

I love Tarja so much, love Nightwish with Tarja...

But now, TARJA have her own career, and i love her songs. But, i like very much the Nightwish, "Band Nightwish". I will never hate my fav band because of a tottaly change of Vocals. Yea, Anette is SO different from Tarja, but, She's only doing her Job, and, She's sings very WELL. So well as Tarja, but with another tipe of sing, not melodic as Tarja.

Anette is doing a nicely done work. And the Band, it's getting the perfection.

[mishkyn910]

Yep! Anette is doing her best! I will love them forever! Marco, Jukka, Emppu, Tuomas!! They were awesome with Tarja...and they ARE awesome, no matter who the singer is!! :P

[123tetero]

guacatela

[hajimeoia]

may god

[EternalDreamspace]

This is just as good as Tarja's version for different reasons.

Both of them are such talented lovely people. :)

[i4nightmare]

у тарьи лучше получалось

[nw4p]

desde que tarja se fue, nightwish ya no es la misama banda. deberían buscar a una cante operística

since tarja is gone, nightwish is not the same. they should look for a opera singer

depuis tarja s'est allée, nigthwish n'est pas le même. ils doivent checher une opera canteuse

[BeyondxBirthday]

The best thing for this band is for anette to go hang herself! They suck Now!! Tarja Forever!!!!

[LindziBrap]

I do wish that people like your would shut the fuck up.

Why is this best? So that they can bring in another singer who will be equally hated?

Unless you believe that Anette is the only reason Tarja is not in Nightwish in which case you really are retarded. Tarja was not happy in Nightwish, she would've only stuck around another album anyway, and that album would have been a shitty one.

[vihtiboy96]

tarja is better than anette!!!

[Underaker1986]

Man this song SUCKS, this song would rule with Tarja

[stargazerOCEANBORN]

Shes not that bad... I like her and i dont compare her with Tarja

[Zimy0]

She's not that bad, at least she's on key.

[knuddelige]

anette is not able to sing the old songs because they were made for tarja...and tarja´s voice was made for that great songs.

i mean their new songs are not bad. but they lost the real touch of nightwish. before they sound mystical and tarja was singing their songs with proudness....anette can never reach her. and nightwish will never be the same again....but i still love their sound

[zsofyka29]

yuo're right, but u should agree that some faster and harder songs are better with Anette, the guys made good work (i luv Tarja, but she wont be back) but the slover songs - 4e.: sleeping sun - uhh, horrible!

[marilena6]

I can bearly hear her!! Tarja,please read your fan comments and come back!!!!!! Nightwish will never be the same without you!!

[crimrose]

Tarja cannot "come back", as she was fired. Even if she wanted to (which she probably doesn't, she's happy with her solo career), Nightwish wouldn't let her back in.

Don't misunderstand that Tarja even has the option of returning. She doesn't. She's not wanted and she's not welcome.

[LindziBrap]

LOL@people comparing poor quality audio of anette to studio recorded audio of tarja.

[marilena6]

You're wrong,personally I compare this video to another live concert with Tarja and not a recorded version,of course that would be unfair. And still I believe that Tarja has a better voice (she's a soprano after all)

[LindziBrap]

So go listen to every other nightwish 2.0 band going and get over the fact that nightwish wanted to do something else with their band.

[lefkopoulos]

of course she does dear..no offence to anette..but tarja's voice has got splendour...

[nathaniell84]

send her back to her abba cover ...

and mail tarja "we want u back or were crap without u"

[sonnengelber]

VOLL DANEBEN.....

- was habt Ihr aus Nightwish gemacht?

Eine seelenlose POP-Band.

Tarja rules

[Marcocramf14]

WE WANT TARJA!!!

Annette GO HOME!!!

[hilflosmara]

anette sucks!!!

[makismac]

she is disaster !!!

[EINEWIEALASKA]

I think she can't sing but I like her clothes xDDD

[blackfeather666]

TARAJ IS BETTER THAT ANETTE.!!

:D

[zuchary]

hey, annette aint the best with tarjas songs but wen ur seeing nightwish live and ur a fan of the old song ul wana hear them

[nonamecf]

suena como si quisiera hacer algo diferente a la version pero nooo, no sale cuekkk

[acioax]

SU VOZ NO SE PA PUEDE...

no se puede remplazar tarja!!!unica

[kplesmiz]

So sad. Pityfull...Annette is better at singing the songs from dark passion play and the albums after that...Tarja Rules!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[nunivo]

MMmmmmmmm.... this doesn't sounds like the original song. Annete needs her own songs.

[RebecaRawr]

Tarja was better,but Anette is Anette and Tarja was Tarja...Anette is great singer=)

[angelicmutilation]

She can sing,at last better than me, but this... it`s sad!

[somewherefarther]

tuomas, I'm sorry to say so, but you and YOUR band are deaf. You are ruining Nightwish with Anette and she's making a fool of herself singing songs that aren't for her. She's good singer, but not for your band, and you all know.

[AlexxxNZ]

Did you just call a guy with musical training and experience vastly superior to yours deaf? wow Also the songs are for whoever Nightwish want them too be for.

[somewherefarther]

NEW BAND NAME: SUICIDEWISH

[nemesia18]

sinceramente no me gusta esta chava no canta mal pero se oiria mejor cantando mmm womanizer o nose sus movimientos son muy toscos y creo que esta jorobadilla jaja bien critikona en fin la voz de tarja se me hacia mas finolis poes

[Yulivea]

Anette can't sing this song.

It was written for Tarja.

Anette makes it TERRIBLE.

[nemesia18]

anette is emo

tarja ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

[gjbmo]

jajajaja is true tarja writte this song and sing better the song

[elvemage3082]

first, all you anette haters. all go fuck ur selfs.

second, its tarja own fault she go kicked out the band, if she was never a fucking bitch, she wouldent never gotten kicken out.

Anette ftw!

[kraitsnake]

TARJAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!­!

[Slightlybusy]

NightWish is a lot tamer than they used to be. I think they have mellowed out their sound.

[anetteisgreat]

her voice is much better on stage than tarja's..there's so much power in her voice

AlexxxNZ you're totally right..

who said that tarja is not good.?

tarja is very good..

but anette is better

[stargazerOCEANBORN]

I don't think that Annette is better than Tarja and Tarja isn't better neither.. I consider them equal

[AlexxxNZ]

Thank you!

[stelladeppsi]

Kick that bitch off the band! She ruins it! Tarja!Where are you? Nightwish need you!

[AlexxxNZ]

Dark Passion Play awarded 5/5 by Kerrang, the longest tour the band has ever attempted, Amaranth reaching gold status in less then two days. What do they need Tarja for exactly. And don't say to sing their old songs, because if it was important for them to have a soprano singing them they wouldn't have hired Anette.

[punkfairy1976]

anette you dont belong here. Tarja was a million times better...go to sing w britney

[saphirmagier]

tarja was the best singer for this band...

annette sings well, but she shouldn't sing songs of tarja... tarja was an opra singer... annette is jus a singer...

[AlexxxNZ]

you do realise that tara never really sang opera in Nightwish. She's a soprano but no opera singer

[AlexxxNZ]

tarja*

[anaarkadievna]

and your point? you better have a pop think like this chick rather then a soprano?

[AlexxxNZ]

I would rather have what Nightwish would rather have. And if Nightwish would rather have Anette singing for them and have her sing their old songs then so would I.

[anaarkadievna]

good to you! another one in the hep hep army! pop rules these days!

[anaarkadievna]

that you are pop lover! join anette's pathetic army!

[AlexxxNZ]

I like Nightwish. Nightwish like Anette .If Nightwish like Anette, I like Anette. I don't see way this makes me a 'pop lover'(whatever that means), if anything I'd say it makes me a Nightwish lover, because I, unlike you, love Nightwish regardless of who is singing for them. Also if Anette did have an army, I doubt it would be pathetic.Amaranth/Dark Passion Play sales and the numbers of fans at Nightwish shows speak volumes.

[anaarkadievna]

you like something because... other people like that thing! ha ha! too much logic in your statement!

[AlexxxNZ]

Yeah I do like it because other people like it. The words "other people" however, refers specifically to the band members in Nightwish.

[zelenookochudoviste]

i agree...she's not a singer for this band...

tarja was better but she was an arrogant bitch...

they obviously wanted change and that's why they picked her...

she's trying her best...you have to respect that :)

[IDislikeCowards]

"tarja was better but she was an arrogant bitch..."

As much as people keep repeating that opinion after reading the band's smear letter, she never did anything arrogant that I can find. She at least never posted a letter on the Internet smearing her former band members.

[Scioneer]

Can't agree more. People seem to think Tuomas can do no wrong and therefore believe everything he wrote in that stupid letter. Tarja does not seem to be bitchy at all in her interviews, and she seemed to enjoy performing with NW despite the issues the band had. People need to realize "break-ups" are not one sided affairs, and that Tuomas, while a brilliant musician/writer, Is still human and can make bad decisions, just like anyone else.

[cesartrm]

Is very very sad see that... Is simply Terrible!!!! Annete is ok singing only the new tracks but the truth is: She´s not a singer for this band!

[XxBacardiGirl94xX]

Sry to say but her live performance AND voice sucks...Nightwish was! the best band ever with Tarja...

[jyyan]

She has got a better voice than tarja, but in this concert she doesn't show it...

[exR1z9R]

joke of the day :D

[ukrainianheim]

мтак... цікаво, на що Анетт взагалі надіялась? зроблю вигляд що не бачив цього відео...

[560yeah]

que horror la voz de esta vieja no se compara a la de tarja....

[chowzor]

she is not a rip off of tarja..she kicks ass. She is not a bitoch..and the music isn't yayaya anymore.

[jessica15lp]

knkjnsbdcsjanka.....X_X

oh my fucking ears!

someone please just shoot her dead.

how dare this dreadful banshee think she can ever replace Tarja?

[2]

[twistofme]

i just have to say thats rude, its not tarja, no its not. but she is trying her best to pelase you people and you say it sounds liek crap? then stop listening to them!

[SmashDownHLS]

I agree with you, I don't like her, but she's trying her best. Is wrong to say she's a bitch or something like just because she isn' Tarja.

[soulsong7]

ok thats going to far

[AmaranthV]

knkjnsbdcsjanka.....X_X

oh my fucking ears!

someone please just shoot her dead.

how dare this dreadful banshee think she can ever replace Tarja?

[iHaTeSpOrKs]

BAHAHA!!! Anette should stick to her own songs xD

Tarja did that 4586486 times better :]

[deathdal007]

you need more than luck! if your fans had any influence you should be on the phone to Tarja`s agent right away

this really is`nt the right sound for Nightwish

criticize me all you like thats my opinion & many others by the looks of it!

[totallynotgerman]

What the fuck?

0:40-0:53 was absolutely terrible

you are pretty annette (or however you write it), but COME ON!

that sounded so..

argh

so pop, like the background hard and the little and weak voice..

shit, good luck guys .. you really need it!

[opeth40]

In Hamburg, the Karaoke sets are really lavish....

[1337solidsnake1337]

lolololololol

[deathdal007]

lmao !

[iHaTeSpOrKs]

OMG so true! xD

[valentinahp]

this really sucks...!!!! Tarja is a million times BETTER...

[opeth40]

if you think this is bad, wait til you here her Wishmaster......

[TheCrowSoul]

she sucks!

[tankbrigade]

What a fuck is this? This is a great shit... Pff... Look the 2005 lowlands tour... That is the music....

[onenoneblond]

omg! this is so wrong!

[NlGHTWISH]

This sounds like pop, or more something like poprock ...

Just listen Anette oh my god raping my ears

Ive seen these comments which say that Anette sings good, omfg people, altho shes new to the band you still can criticize her and say your honest opinion... You need to be deaf if you say shes a good singer..

Dont fucking start saying im wrong i saw them live and she was horrible, even her clothing was ridiculous

[AlexxxNZ]

You're wrong. Why would nightwish choose a bad singer? cause I'm pretty sure they wouldv choosen the best singer they could find, and i'm also pretty sure pickings weren't slim.

[SmashDownHLS]

@AlexxxNZ

Because they wanted to change style and sound of their voice, and I can understand it, but er...they chose the wrong singer, too weak voice, Annette have anything to do with metal, and with symphonyc she's...terrible.

They should take a rock singer with enough voice, like Dolores (ex Cranberries singer) well,not her, but a voice with personaliti, I mean, not a simply pop voice.

There are millions of pop voices around the world.

[AlexxxNZ]

How do you mean too weak? If she was too weak to sing their music Nightwish wouldn't have hired her, simple as that. Also you must remember Nightwish have always had a lot of pop sensibilities about them too. There aren't millions of pop voices around the world, or there would be millions of pop stars, which clearly there isn't.

[SmashDownHLS]

She can't keep the notes, this is what I mean when I say too weak, and, of course, with the old ones the risultate is ...well,quite terrible.

They choosed her for the new songs not or the old ones, which need a powerfull voice, and this is why she isn't good to sing these ones.

However, in the world there are million of pop voices like Annettes, but there are not millions of pop stars because of the marketing, less singers,less competition.

[AlexxxNZ]

If it was as bad as you claim,don't you think Nightwish would'v noticed? Remember, Nightwish are highly skilled musicians who are very good at what they do. They are seasoned professinals who have made living off this band and continue to do so. And you are who exactly.....?

[SmashDownHLS]

A girl which best friend is an Opera singer, so, really, I know something abot music because I like to watch her training, but, first of all, I've got a pair of ears.

[AlexxxNZ]

Right so you're musical training that consists of you listining to an opera singer train compares to: Tuomas Holopainen - keyboardist, band leader and main songwriter of Nightwish, studied clarinet, tenor saxophone, piano and music theory for eleven years at a music college. Maybe Marco Hietala, often seen as an icon for the Finnish metal scene,vocalist and bassist as well as composer/lyricist for heavy metal band Tarot. You really think you're knowledge compares?

[SmashDownHLS]

I never thought I was better than Tuomas, but you don't need to be a great musician to hear she doesn't suit this style of music.

Annette have a pretty voice,but not form metal, she doesn't keep the notes,it's something you can't contest,it's a matter of fact...

By the way you seem to be able to understand just what you want....so really, darling, I got better ways to waste my time.

Bye.

[Kizzm0]

stop listen to Nightwish now when Anette is singing then if you dislike her that much, as AlexxxNZ say, you are nothing compared to the band members if the new singer is fit for the job or not.

[SmashDownHLS]

Okay dudes, you got some problems, i NEVER thought I was better than them, how many times have I to repeat it?

However, why should I stop to listen them?

Why should I stop to listen a band I like?

I dislike Annette's voice, but she is not the group, so I have the right to listen their songs and to say what I think about them.

Oh yeah, now you will repeat (again? haven't you something else to write :S ?) that I'm not compared to the band and so on...

Oh god, so boring...

[godinhomar]

oh my god...this song was so beautiful

[yoanilem]

me suenaa pop..

[Saurelius]

Ahrenet' ... Where's her own face? ...

P.S. I'm have voice, i'm wanna sing too

[sayvictor93]

tal vez si solo antara marco sonaria bien

[sayvictor93]

pareciera que se esta burlando de tarja turunen al cantar, por que esas canciones solo son para tarja

[Ghis22]

YES! grats Anette for another ruined song your good at it continue your good work!

[alessiodf]

OMFG!!! -_-'

[godinhomar]

annete é chata e canta mal....alguem cale essa mulher....

espero que o NW acabe....melhor o fim do que isso ai..

[43376goku4]

These sucks!

[diego1286k]

sounds like a pop band

[Nietochka]

Rompetímpanos annett

[maideeen94]

the sound kvality sucks xD