DREAM Act

[onstageagain]

No. I do NOT want the Dream Act passed. Me and my family came here LEGALLY. So why should illegals get a pass with this bastard Act?

I can understand your desire to beome a better person...but how do you expect anyone to take U seriously when U break our laws AND expect to be rewarded with Citizenship? The US owes U/illegals nothing except deportation for breaking R laws.

Ur parents put U in this situation is NOT for me or our Government to solve. That is between U & Ur parents.

[onstageagain]

cities have declared themselves "safe haven" for illegal aliens and refuse to enforce immigration laws. LA Chicago, San Francisco, Seattle, NY & even Falls Church, Virginia , sight of the Pentagon, have all declared to be sanctuaries 4 illegals. NYMayor Michael Bloomberg announced that, people who are undocumented do not have to worry about city government going to the federal government. In other words, these city governments refuse to uphold federal law or defend American borders.

[onstageagain]

n California, the losses are calculated to be about $79 million, with $74 million in Texas, $31 million in Arizona, and $6 million in New Mexico. All of these costs are dumped on American taxpayers simply because the Mexican government, void of protest from the U.S. government, has decided to raid the American cookie jar.

[Twilightifyable]

3/3 C SPAN “Black Republican Forum” Session 2 (begin at 11:30) West said one of the 1986 caveats was to secure our borders, enforcement our laws, but we’re still talking about new amnesty like DREAM Act. We can’t allow local cities to make sanctuary cities policies, because they will bring our inner city turf wars to epic proportions by bringing in the drug cartel and Columbian gangs. (Mexican Gangs don’t recognize our borders established by the Treaty of Guadalupe)

.

Allen West 2012

[Twilightifyable]

2/3 In November 2010, 15.1 million were unemployed (9.8%). 154 million are able to work in workforce (15.1 million/9.8%). GOOGLE “illegal immigration counters”, There are 11,941,812 (or 11.9 million) skilled jobs provided to illegal immigrants. the 15.1 million unemployed could take the 11.9 million available jobs. The unemployment rate could be reduced to 2.1% {{15.1-11.9)/154}.

[Twilightifyable]

1/3 Immigrationcounters com 97% illegal immigrants are from Mexico. Illegalimmigrationstatistics org $1117 - The average amount you and your family paid in taxes this year to support illegals. 51% - The percentage of Mexican immigrant households that use at least one major welfare program. 28% use more than one.

[TeaPartyFuture]

When a citizen of the United States breaks the law they pay full price.

Fines/Jail Time/Prison time/ And sometimes we pay with our lives.

So you tell me why ANY person from ANY other country should be given a free pass after they sneak into the USA without invitation of permission.

And if they happen to have kids while they are hiding in my country, OHH WELL.

perhaps they should have thought about their children when they were busy breaking the law.

No sympathy here.

[52mez]

By opposing this act, the GOP is asking for trouble. Most of the illegal immigrants are from Latin America, and polls show that 85 percent of them favor such a law. They are the fastest growing segment of our population, and the day is fast coming when there will be more of them than there are of us. They will surely remember the party that stood in their way.

[TeaPartyFuture]

@52mez Dont hold your breath, Only CITIZENS of these united states have the right to vote, And the GOP and Tea Party now have the numbers to inforce the E-VERIFY id card.

lol ULTRA FAIL.

go home to mexico before we send you back in handcuffs.

[52mez]

@TeaPartyFuture hahaha okay but it will happen i dont know if u will be around to see it but it will happen.

[Chunkylove84]

THE ILLEGAL CRIMINAL BEANER ACT

[tanarus77]

This is all pure bs. They want to dumb down society, not make people smarter. And of course its always about the money. The control and folks, it's gonna get a lot worse.

[Alan00170]

Next thing you know "Bank Robbery" can be excused as an "Undocumented Bank Withdrawal".

[AR15fan]

Kill the Democrat Party Wet Dream Act.

[dreamstasher]

It's nice of you to forget overpopulation in that dream? A livable infrastucture surely isn't there! Mother nature doesn't care that you want to have 6 to 10 children! Or that you can't pay or feed for them! But I do, not that worry about the world counts for much! If you want to invade my country uninvited because you cowardly left yours without a fight for your rights? Then no I don't want you here! GO HOME AND LEAVE MY CHILDREN LIVE IN PEACE!!

[jennyg1991]

@beatdisnutz great to hear someone speak of compromise:) Since many illegals do pay taxes (yes its possible) they should have the right to such financial aid (if they can prove they did). on the terms of requesting family members (yes im support of dream act for the most part), i feel they should be able to request their parents at most after a certain period of time after a college graduation. requesting status for relatives as a natural born citizen (yes i am) is hard enough...

[Blackstar1401]

How can we have two classes of citizens when one group is not citizens?

[azamar1000]

Oscar de los santos, thank you for posting this video, it is short but it manifest the reality of the issue, and just like you said : IT IS TIME TO ACT, IT IS TIME TO FIGHT AND LIVE OUR DREAMS!

[greg7551]

here is a question for those people that hate illegals. god made this world for every one to live in pice and enloy your live not to be worried if the next day you are getting deported for not having a piece of green papers is really retarded that only cause some one was born in a nother place of this world they be making a crime.

[handsomepo]

it not racist u dump mexican to deport you mom for being here illegal can cNT Sy u not commiting a crime u breaking our immgrantion law u have to go threw the paper work get that in every mexican head u are breaking immgration laws get that in ur head u commiting a crime it not racist it the law illegals need to follow dam

[jxcelynn]

It's VERY unfortunate that selfish Americans like you exist. All illegal children are asking for is an opportunity for higher education, something that judging by your spelling and grammar, is something that you AREN'T pursuing effectively. Additionally, if you fear that an illegal immigrant will steal your job, then you deserve it because then your as dumb as it gets.

[SBabyLovee]

i pity those who are racist and closed minded. hopefully you guys dont have children because then there will be more of you dumbasses.

[xjthg187187x]

@SBabyLovee lmao

[lvll138inrs]

if a bulgar breaks into my home he is an invader and I deserve to shoot him. same with illegals they try to cross into our borders they need to be shot.

[babyshadye]

you are a very ignorant person. your ass couldn't live the way it's living if it wasn't for immigrants.

u deserve to be shot just for having such a retarded mentality :)

[bfashion2]

omg that is the most idiotic example i have ever heard! you need to be shoot lol! for being illetarate, immigrants dont break in the country to still anything they work and believe me very hard to get anything.. people like u take what u hav for granted.. there is a lot of jobs out there that u dont want to do guess who does? n they wont ask you for nothing but maybe for a job, unlike many "legal" people in the streets asking u for a quarter...you need to get educated

[beatdisnutz]

Folks from both aisles must compromise. Students should earn their residence but no free money and they can't request status for other relatives. If activists who are pro-dream act take this approach, it will much easier to pass this bill. I guarantee you that most Americans, specially conservatives like myself would be willing to support a bill that breaks the chain of illegal immigration but helps those students who are attending school.

[commissionville]

I appreciate the constructive tone. We need less ridiculous rhetoric. Hopefully people on both sides of the spectrum can come to a compromise on this bill, as it is extremely important to immigrant students and the nation alike. By the way, you are the first conservative I meet with a name like "beatdisnutz."

[jennyg1991]

@beatdisnutz@beatdisnutz great to hear someone speak of compromise:) Since many illegals do pay taxes (yes its possible) they should have the right to such financial aid (if they can prove they did). on the terms of requesting family members (yes im support of dream act for the most part), i feel they should be able to request their parents at most after a certain period of time after a college graduation. requesting status for relatives as a natural born citizen (yes i am) is hard enough...

[onstageagain]

@beatdisnutz This DREAM ACT is clearly Amnasty, and a road to votes for liberal politicians. The only thing Illegals deserve , is the introduction to a jail cell for the crime they have committed , which is invading our country for starters. Illegals do not deserve to use our sidewalks.They do not deserve to breathe our air, & they sure as heck do not deserve to receive student loans. We need to keep the seats in college open for those who are legally entitled to be here.

[kingkong113]

So thinking that all immigrants dont pay taxes Is just ignorant .believe it or not parents actually care about their childs education and medication enogh to invest their taxes in without much hope of getting it back.

[kingkong113]

some of you guys are really so fucking ignorant when it comes to this issue. Why should the children who are here be punished for coming to this country illegally because it was their parents who brought them in the first place. i personally believe if you study here from elementary to high school and recieve some type of diploma from a college or university (and have a clean record) then you should absolutly be eligable to be a U.S. Citizen.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

So essentially, by your reasoning, if the parents break into the U.S. and successfully steal an education for their offspring from American taxpayers, the child should given an additional benefit of legal residency after living off the taxpayers' largesse unlawfully for X number of years. You're right. That's simply brilliant. You've nailed it on the head. Everyone else is "so fucking ignorant" and not equipped with your superior faculties, Einstein.

[kingkong113]

Illegal immigrants are paying taxes. Just how much they pay is hard to determine because the federal government doesn't fully tally it. But the latest figures available indicate it will amount to billions of dollars in federal income, Social Security and Medicare taxes this year. One rough estimate puts the amount of Social Security taxes alone at around $10 billion this year.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

It is a minority of illegal aliens who file income tax returns, and in total tax money, they take far more out of the system in social service costs and education than they pay in. In California alone, the net drain is over 9 billion annually.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

It is ridiculous for Barack Obama to protest that he doesn't want "two classes of citizens" in this country. Ilegal aliens, which is what would-be DREAM Act beneficiaries are, have no claim to U.S. citizenship nor any right to be present in the country.

[Willstruth]

We demand that our government commit to comprehensive immigration enforcement,NOWTheir parents came here illegally in an effort to put themselves at the front of the line while you did nothing except to entertain the ridiculous idea of rewarding them for their criminal behaviour.Now you want us to put their illegal kids at the front of the line and reward them with special priviledges above and beyond what is availible to our children.This idea is treasonous at best.Fuck Obama!!!

[kingkong113]

give an example of these "Special Priviledges" and shouldnt one be placed ahead of the line by their Grades and accolades to wich the result sof this Dream Act would be irrelevant for U.S. born citizens?

[Willstruth]

No matter how much we give these parasites it will never be enough.Go back to Mexico

[DIJV79]

WOW ! A blackman gets elected president and wants to help the mexican community, and this how these fucking spic mongrel raped indians repay him, fucking mutts I hope they all die of AIDS and swine flu.

[kingkong113]

arent you late for a white rally or some shit what makes you so important you racist prick.

[quemeister]

God wants this act to pass.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

How do you know?  Are you his spokesman?

[quemeister]

I am home, dumb fuck.

[mauricio77043]

yOU GO OBAMA YOUR THE BOSS NOW HAHAHA AND PASS THE ACT AND PEOPLE IF YOU DO NOT KNOW WHAT THE SITUATION IS PLEASE GET EDUCATED HOPEFULLY NOT ALL AMERICANS ARE TURDS LIKE THE BUNCHES HERE GET A LIFE PEOPLE AND STOP BEING SO IGNORANT THANK YOU !!

[notoriousmaze619]

For those who spent their whole lives here since they were children...they are home...

[joshbernstein]

Karma. May the above commentators one day have the chance to be judged and treated by the same standards they advocate for these young people who have grown up in this country. May they wake up without the privileges they obtained solely by being born here. May they be hunted by the authorities because of decisions their parents made years ago. May the youth they deride—who have struggled to make the best of the life they were given—have the chance to judge THEM Judge not lest ye be judged

[Willstruth]

It should be called the "Criminal Dream Act"!I'm sick and tired of these corrupt and immoral politicians trying to ram this crap down our throats.They want to put criminals at the head of the line in front of our own people.Every one of these bastards should be shot!

[seriouslysad]

It's the CRIMINAL REWARDS PROGRAM! All you have to do is break into the country and have a fake I.D.

[seriouslysad]

Illegal Alien children that were not born in the United States are not citizens so how is it that by not allowing them to get a higher education is that creating to classes of citizens? Depot them right along with their parents.

[1martinez8]

Hey retard its a metaphor, because by not giving them an equal opportunity its labeling them as different. And next time use spellcheck dumbass!!!

[seriouslysad]

They are different. They are not Citezins of the United States.

[Ricvzq]

yea. but different in what way?. we are people like you and your family, we're not animals, even an animal would be smarter than you to know that. the only pride you have is that your country is #1 and you believe you shouldn't give a chance to others, but that will serve you as useless, because it will affect your country in many ways. and its spelled "citizens".

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

Different in that his family members are in the country lawfully, whereas illegal aliens are not. Regulations and rules are such a pesky annoyance to you, aren't they?

[Ricvzq]

Well first of all i was brought here young without knowing a single thing or word how would you expect me to obey a rule such as not entering a different country illegally?, so what? i went to school, i learned the languages, and i adopted the country as my own. And you expect me to feel guilty and think in way like its my fault? what do you know?. you should be happy it didn't happen to you!.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

No, you should feel guilty that you are in possession of something that rightfully belongs to someone else. And you're right, I'm happy my parents are not criminals with no regard for the rights of others, like yours.

[Ricvzq]

i dont feel as if i broke anything, you know why? cause im a good hard working person but you only say what you say, because there's so many of us here. still, i dont feel guilty, i feel lucky to be in this country and being able to do my best. my parents might have broken the law, but if it happened to you, you probably wouldn't say the same thing, we do have regard for others, we dont bother americans or any other people. we only thing we did wrong is to come inside the way the way we did.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

You're feelings are irrelevant. You were raised by criminals and you rationalize your behavior like a criminal. Everything else is simply conversation. The country will be better off when you're gone.

[Ricvzq]

irrelevant?, you dont know what your talking about and you dont even know me, but what i do know about you is that you are a very ignorant person who doesn't seem to cap the message of illegals being people like any others, and im not speaking just "conversation" im being truthful and i dont consider to be a criminal with a criminal "behavior" since i never harmed or harrased anyone in any way. and you know what? i dont need to leave, your country is already messed up as it is.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

What needs to be known? You're in the U.S. unlawfully, have been taking what doesn't belong to you, and are now insisting that you be given more. Like lots of illegals, you're completely narcissistic about your "dilemma," view yourself as some manner of innocent, and the proposed solution you mouth predictably involves you being given add'l handouts. Never harmed anyone? Tell that to taxpayers on April 15 or a would-be legal immigr. family still waiting overseas, you self-centered parasite.

[Ricvzq]

You know what? Noons really gives a shit about what you think,you could never understand the needs of others, since you are "supposivley" helping your country, why don't you help your get back from

[Ricvzq]

Continued... Why don't you help your soldiers to leave the war and stop killing innocent people?, at least you'll do something good that way, cause without illegals, your country is nothing!, Barrack Obama knows the truth and will amnesty to my people, and then you're gonna

Cry buddy, just remember that.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

Not true. You do, quite a bit. That's why you keep answering. The truth has its own sort of hypnotic appeal and I've been dealing it to you in spades.

[babyshadye]

hm so he's the self-centered parasite when you're the one stating that you don't want immigrants to have the same opportunities you have.

no offense, but you're an idiot.

[xjthg187187x]

@babyshadye I second that but WITH offence :)

[babyshadye]

oh please. immigrants aren't taking anyone's spots anywhere. legals/illegals have the same chance in getting a "spot" anywhere, it's just that immigrants are better working and less lazy than you so called "real" americans.

so get over urself.

[DerailAmnestydotcom]

The issue is not "immigrants." If it were, this video wouldn't exist. The topic is illegal aliens, and all the personal insults you choose to post change none of that.

[babyshadye]

illegal aliens ARE immigrants. :PPP

[xjthg187187x]

@DerailAmnestydotcom they're both the same numb nuts, are they always numb? lol dumbass

[seriouslysad]

The difference is that you are a Citizen of another Nation! All Nations have immigration laws. The USA is quite generous in allowing people to legally visit and move to the USA. The people that take it upon themselves to decided that they do not need to follow the rules or laws simply will not make good citizens. They all had the CHANCE to apply to come here Legally. Instead they CHOSE to break the Law!

[Ricvzq]

yes, breaking the law for a better life. if you knew that, you would know that's exactly why your european ancestors came to this country. so the native americans must have thought they were intruders too and not human beings. yea but i know whats probably your excuse for that, "it was completely different time, with no laws", but sounds more like hypocrisy to me. its the principles that matter.

[seriouslysad]

This is the 21st Century, a developed world, were laws are necessary for an orderly society. Most illegal aliens come here for a more affluent lifestyle. They are unwilling to make their countries a better place to live!

[seriouslysad]

At some point these children of ILLEGAL ALIENS become aware that they are here illegally! They drive without licenses or insurance and obtain jobs! So they follow in their PARENTS footsteps and disobey the law willingly! The Dream Act rewards them and sends a message to others to do the same thing. It's a nightmare for the folks who have been in car accidents with these people. They are financially devastated and crippled for life!