Trailer - Sonic Fanboy Vs Sonic Fag

[madnessguy010101]

Stupidity annoys me which is why tails4life annoys me

[cbsonicboy]

forget all what I said, the s-play reviews are parodies of xplay reviews, meaning it's just for lols

[cbsonicboy]

scratch that, all s-play reviews suck

[cbsonicboy]

oh and also he reviewed sonic and the black knight badly so make a commentary video on that also

[cbsonicboy]

I have a request for you. There are these reviews on sonic adventure and sonic unleashed by s-play. These reviews are horrible and I think you should make a commentary video about them.

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@SP4Mew

2. Really?

/watch?v=Zcfbit0mxcc&feature=c­hannel_video_title

Click the link, skip to 21:32 to save time.

1. Coming from the person that made a commentary on GameDude.

2. ORLY?

YoungBlood, Jiglypuff218, Roushutsu, YoungAuthorAdam... I could go on.

And again, this is coming from someone who hates GameDude >_>

3. It's not necessarily something you can agree or disagree with, it's either

"Yah, I can see what your saying" or "Dude, that's bullshit and you know it! Here's why..."

[Narateful2]

good commentary!

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@SP4Mew

Of coarse I don't hate him personally, I don't know him. Shouldn't you be asking him these things though?

He's the one praying for people over the internet.

Also I usually follow people if they keep screwing up and never learn from their mistakes. It's not just ShadowStar I've picked on, I also have had fun with Meta, MrPunchDrunk1 and BrawlMaster (before he closed his account).

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

Continued...

1. Who's to say I haven't called out other people like that?

2. If you're just trying to nitpick as a form of satire, then it's perfectly fine, but if you're going to complain about something as trivial as an intro, that's when an issue arises.

3. Just because he's admitted a few of his mistakes, doesn't mean he's admitted all of them.

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@SP4Mew

1. Well, I can't necessarily disprove that so, skipping.

2. He doesn't know the difference between flat out insulting someone, and just stating their opinion in a blunt fashion.

I think YoungAuthorAdam said it best in his 5th degree commentary.

/watch?v=Zcfbit0mxcc&feature=c­­hannel_video_title

just skip to 21:14 if you haven't seen it yet.

Continued...

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@SP4Mew

ShadowStar has never made a good commentary in my honest opinion, but let's just assume for a minute he has made some good points, what does he lack that other commentators have?

1. A sense of humor.

2. The definition of "brutal honesty"

What does he have that other commentators lack?

1. An ego.

2. An undying need to nitpick

3. The fact he won't admit to his mistakes

Also @shadsilvson11, I'm confused... you claim Shadow Star is a Sonic "fanboy", yet you gave his video an 80%... .-.

[Shadsilvson11]

@MyKrimsonUrchin But I'm a Sonic Fanboy as well. There's nothing wrong with being a Sonic fanboy providing you're not a complete idiot about it.

And whilst I lost respect for ShadowStar I feel he has made some good commentaries.

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@Shadsilvson11

If that's the case, then how come you've used it as a negative term for the majority of the video?

I will admit ShadowStar has made SOME good points in the past, but I still think his old videos are almost as bad as his new ones.

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@Shadsilvson11

Also I forgot to say this earlier but...

"There's nothing wrong with being a Sonic fanboy providing you're not a complete idiot about it."

Fanboys are the people that hated on Sonic 4 because it had green eyed Sonic. Either that or their the ones that fap to Sonic hentai all day, and create "Top 10 Hottest Sonic females lists". And the term "Sonic fag" is basically the same definition.

You are simply a Sonic FAN, seeing as how you actually listen to the opinions of others. =)

[Ollyx]

@MyKrimsonUrchin Shadowstar dosen't use humour because he makes formal commentaries

[MyKrimsonUrchin]

@Ollyx

Formal is just a fancier way of saying "boring."

[Ollyx]

@MyKrimsonUrchin Not all commentaries are supposed to be funny

[Ollyx]

@MyKrimsonUrchin Oh yeah I love how everything you say is in a list, what you got groceries on your mind?

[SonicandTails4life]

@chaosmonkey79 What did you just now find 4chan?

[SonicandTails4life]

LMAO ok I saw it he commentary was really good I wis you would have uploaded it on youtube that way I could respond but oh well. Now lol yeah I know I'm a ass a douche a jerk or whatever else you want to call me. That's just the type of person I am but I am not as full of myself as I used to be.

[Naderath]

Shadsilvson sonicandtails4lif eis improving on his commentaries and he does LP's now

[nintendoboy17]

It's not just the Sonic fanbase, Tom. Even Nintendo's fanbase is going this route. There are kinds of "fans" that think the Wii is not a true Nintendo console because the graphics aren't that strong and a majority of fans don't know what they want out of Nintendo anymore when it comes to games since the N64 era.

[bluesamranma]

@neilpiano i was thinkin the same thing shadow the hedghog was a good game and i never had the slightest problem with the controls

[Snipertoaster]

Another awesome commentary from you. Entertaining and truthful. Which IS what makes a good commentary UNLIKE the one from S&T4L

[DBDarkness]

let me get this straight this guy hates platformers with guns? I have one word to say to that UNCHARTED

[KirbySonicTeam]

FFFFFFFFF- I CANT WATCH IT OTL... I dont have a sound card =(

[superhyperdarksonic5]

i wont say this becuause i hate fanboys hut sonicandtails4life is plain stupid.

He should sop reminding us about our past problems and using 85%-90% to bash the other guy in the video.Plus I know in heart that unleased,adventure and lots of so called unorginal game are!I cant explain that well tho.

Shadowstar had many good points but a little more than the other guy.Honestly the insult rate from him was 20%-30%

Honestly whats gonna happen to sonic generations and sonic 4 eps?

[BlazeTheMovieFan]

You know, I don't have a problem with insults as long as there is an argument. But insulting someone for having a different opinion is just wrong.

[Cster91]

I'm glad that I'm not the only one who thought Sonic X was not as bad as everyone says it is!

And by the way, what was the problem you had when you uploaded the commentary to Blip?

[Shadsilvson11]

@Cster91 Well it uploaded to Blip but it couldn't play. So I had to wait. But that problem's sorted now.

[Cster91]

@Shadsilvson11 I see. Same thing happened to me when I uploaded my commentary on the Game Dude.

[ChiefShadow1750]

ShadowStar made a lot of good points in his rant, so I give him props, but SonicandTails4life acted like an asshole. Jak II and 3 had guns and they were platformers. Oh I found out he's also a hypocrite, because he hates Sonic X, but yet he uses pics of Sonic from the anime. No more from me on the fanbase because it sickens me to talk about any further. Great job.

[KingRaikou]

Another job well done! =)

ShadowStar1224 made good points, but SonicandTails4life just bashed him with petty insults and bad counterarguments. And I fail to see what's wrong with guns being in a platform game.

[Manaidr]

SonicandTails had a couple of good points, but for the most part he was just being an asshole and he repeated the exact same points over and over (and the points, btw, were HORRIBLE). As for the guns not being in platformers (which pissed me off the most in the video), megaman, enough said.

[burritodude1]

Great commentary. I pretty much aggred with everything you said.

[Zookstar1000]

Thanks to your commentary, I now see that ShadowStar's rant on Sonic Fanboys was legit and not forceful. so I'll give him props for that. I still haven't changed my mind about him though. And no comment on the other person you commentated on cause I don't want to even mention that fanbase even if it pains me.

[gameboytj]

As far as I can tell, Your commentary is excellent.

[Shadsilvson11]

@gameboytj Thanks for that. It makes all the hastle I went through to upload the video worth it. =)

[pkstarstorm1up]

@Shadsilvson11 Man SonicandTails4life is such a jerk!