I really appreciate their instrumental skill, their overall sound and songwriting that makes Mastodon a cool band. What prevents them from being cool + great is the vocals, they are just not at the same level. Yes, of course, I get the tonal idea, yet it's sung wimpy and all in all not very tight. Pity, could have been so good.
Yeah their artist talent is infinite, as shown by their ability to play. Vocals aren't absolutely amazing, ... Intact they make it hard to truly love the song, oh well... Still badass
I think given the kind of music they're playing they do very well to sing and play their instruments at the same time....they're not bad either. When I went seeing them they were very good, especially the vocals.
None of these guys can sing all that well, but its because of that, that makes them even more of an amazing band. You can listen to a Mastodon song and when you hear the weird vocals you know immediatly that its them. You dont even have to listen to a chorus or something. You can tell by the first word they say.
@SlowmoLife Well studio-wise they all have great voices. but live i think troys the only one thats improved since this performance. hes great live now ^-^
@103964988 You haven't. This is the first amazing album they've done. The one before it was okay but they're first two only had one good track: Blood and Thunder.
Joseph Merrick'', ''Iron Tusk'' etc. in ''Leviathan'' and ''March of the Fire Ants'', ''Where Strides the Behemoth'', ''Mother Puncher'', etc. in ''Remission''.
You don't like ir, ok. But they are two killer albums, like ''Blood Mountain'' and ''Crack the Skye''
I have say, the singing here sounds a lot better than on their new live DVD, Live at the Aragon (and a lot better than when they were on David Letterman). Apparently they can sing and play at the same time, just not consistently.
this is way better than the letterman version. my take on it is if they're ruining their voices by the way they do death metal vocals on about half their material...how about making up melodies and singing instead and then it can all be better. problem solved.
@derekdeprator dude :\ there's a technique called screaming, iff you're doing it right (like all professionals should be, and Mastodon are) then it won't cause any vocal damage. It's all perfectly healthy, and does not vocal damage whatsoever.
@MigelMeUp folks were talking about them not singing up to par and i had an idea. that's all. but to be honest, i don't know anybody that sings like that who doesn't lose their voice really quickly. just saying. that's all.
The real problem is that Troy's vocal cords are so wrecked by all the screaming he's been doing his entire career, and the same goes for Brent. Brann sounds fine though, considering he's drumming at the same damn time.
@FourthHorseman666 There's not a single thing wrong with any of the vocals in this. Any more perfect than this would be annoyingly unreal and more like the bullshit music I try to stay away from.
2:18!! That is a fantastic addition that, for me, makes this performance so much better than the album! I watched this video once last year, and now everytime I hear this song, I hear that addition. Every Time! I. Freaking. Love. This. BAND!
Seriously, what are you guys whining about their singing? You ever heard any other bands sing live by any chance? Just seriously.. everyone sounds a bit different when they play an instrument and sing at the same time, compared to just singing.
@MegaNekke Uh, I've seen plenty of bands live that are every bit as technical and/or heavy as Mastodon that don't sound like a vocal trainwreck. Watch the fucking Letterman performance and try not to cringe like I did at the fact that a BRILLIANT band like Mastodon sounds like a bunch of high schoolers at a talent show singing over a backtrack.
The bassist and the drummer NEED to get in and work with a vocal coach.
@uhwaykin The bassist and drummer can actually sing their own shit on key in most performances. The guitarist is the biggest trainwreck of all...I haven't heard him sing a single song off Crack the Skye live that hasn't sounded like, as you said, "a high schooler at a talent show singing over a backtrack".
@Raro404 Not from what I've seen. On further review, I think the drummer just goes out of key from time to time because he's got two other guys on stage who may as well be singing different songs. The bassist, however, is consistently awful in a way that I've seen before as someone who's played in bands. It's that "Oh shit, this guy actually doesn't know how to carry a note" kind of way.
Brent is also consistently bad in another way I've seen before. He doesn't know how to sing properly.
@uhwaykin By which I mean to say, I'm about 99% positive he's singing in a way that actually physically hurts. Which would explain why he seems to steadily drift off key the longer he sings, which can easily be corrected with some instruction.
You gotta give some credit to bill. yea he plays rhythm but thats the best and most creative rhythm I've ever heard. Those are some awesome CHORDS!!!!
I don't get why everyone complains. The vocals are sub-par, sure, but they aren't really that bad. And the instrumentals are really what matters with Mastodon anyways.
Yea, surprisingly Brann is the best singer and that says a lot considering that drumming and singing at the same time is really hard...especially when it's a Brann Dailor drum part.
They're so much better when you actually see them live. Let's be honest, live recordings of metal bands of any kind just don't translate well, and that's especially true for this band. Everything is different at 120 decibels.
in the other live videos the singing is incredibly good i think they were to fucked up on letterman to remember how to sing thats why i love these guys
The vocals doesnt sound as goods as in the studio version, but is not that bat anyway. Plus, give them a break, playing that ans singing? Thats aint easy at all.
Actually, vocals were one of the things that got me interested in Mastodon. When I played Colony of Birchmen on the Rock Band videogame, I got somewhat intrigued by the "mix" of several voices (I thought all vocals were done by the same singer and just were added one on top of the other). Though I like fast songs more than slow ones, I do like Mastodon songs because they're so fresh due its vocal style
realistically, their vocal harmonies were a little off. no i could not sing better and play at the same time. if i remember right, this was early in the promo stages for crack the skye so they were probably nervous, underpracticed, and in brent's case probably a little stoned (or not stoned, whichever would fuck with his mind more). the album is also pretty hard to do justice to live cuz it is so perfect
they all sing in a different way. and their probably nervous. im sure u couldnt sing as good as they do and play an instrument at the same time. stop hating.
Well, their singing did suck just now, but since when has heavy metal of any kind been about singing?
The singing in the studio version was pretty decent, IMHO, and their musicianship is amazing, especially in a time of simple Alternative Rock riffs where clean, polished production and vocals are the main focus instead of technicality and complex musical structures.
Mastodon is a superb band. I wouldn't like it if they got a separate singer. It's not necessary. They're great the way they are.
@Ablutophobic What you said is true. I'm a big Iron Maiden fan and of course, with a singer like Bruce, singing is one of their strong points. But of course, if a metal band doesn't have a good singer, it doesn't mean they're poor and of course, if they do have one, what more do you want?
HAHAHAHA all I can say to all the haters out there...is that you are more than likely all jealous of these guys! They rip on their instruments and the fact that they can sing over top of the craziness of the music is amazing! And if you still need convincing, go see them live. Maybe shitting your pants after seeing them live will teach you a lesson about hating. Fuckin mooks!
is it just me or does the lead guitarist (cant quite seem to remember his name right now) look exactly like zach galifiniakis (aka all the fat guy from the hangover...)
im sure their vocals are 10x better when they arent trying to sing and play erection inducing music
BeefMastahFlex 3 days ago
hey camera edit guy...was it necessary to change the angle every half sec? anyhoooo great song awesome band.
slitherlock 5 days ago
vocals are awful but all the instruments sound spot on!,
fefaaa21 1 week ago
yeah the vocals are mediocre live, but at least the instrumentals are still solid while theyre singing.
daiselol 1 week ago
oh! it's fuckin awesome oblivion performance! can't believe. it's like studio-album song.. how..weird but awesome!
WastingRope 1 week ago
just make Brann the lead singer from now on
ShadowCrowX 2 weeks ago
@ShadowCrowX fuck i can't wish that because in the studio they fuckin rule
johnbad1000 1 week ago
LMAO, they can't sing at all. There's a problem when the drummer sings better than the lead.
cursedswordsman 1 month ago
Brann sings = pretty good seeming as he's also drumming
Troy sings = has a good singing tone but no vocal skills apparently
Brent sings = forces me to leave the room
zappazilli 1 month ago
Love this song, but these dudes need vocal lessons. The album version is a but suspect now. Anyway love mastodon
UtopiaMinor666 1 month ago
bass sounding is perfect on this video
LawBL94 1 month ago
I don't usually listen to Mastadon, but when I do its a lifetime experience
cheeseUout 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song!
My band 'FABLE' (from the UK) have done an acoustic cover of it ----> title: mastadon - oblivion - Acoustic cover by fable
Check it out!
itazzi12 2 months ago
Fucking awesome! Can't wait for them to write a song named skyrim
dued27 2 months ago 6
@dued27
lulz. you sir are a gentleman and a scholar. (maybe morrowind was an old demo?0
androtaz01 2 months ago
Alright let's give it up for Brann for keeping a relatively non processed drum sound compared to most metal bands today.
MrCkufu 3 months ago 5
god what a great video...it sounds even better live than from the studio.
westprice 3 months ago
I really appreciate their instrumental skill, their overall sound and songwriting that makes Mastodon a cool band. What prevents them from being cool + great is the vocals, they are just not at the same level. Yes, of course, I get the tonal idea, yet it's sung wimpy and all in all not very tight. Pity, could have been so good.
fuzermusic 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out the first single of Octania, a new experimental metal band!
watch?v=KvOdKvm96gA
OctaniaOfficial 3 months ago
Brann is so fucking talented. That beat is hard enough to play by it's damn self but then he has to sing while playing it.
Fuckin' jealous...
garrettisadrummer 3 months ago
they should have used sm57 on the drummer. even smaller diaphragm. epic band mastodon.
saradis1991 3 months ago
Yeah their artist talent is infinite, as shown by their ability to play. Vocals aren't absolutely amazing, ... Intact they make it hard to truly love the song, oh well... Still badass
Mikepwns112 3 months ago
These dudes are the evolution of metal.
poshi12 3 months ago
Comment removed
Parabellum13X 4 months ago
wow hes using a vintage modern!
McScottson 4 months ago
why is troy playing with a pick? i swear he uses his fingers
TheFive66 4 months ago
great song
stbreal 4 months ago
This song makes me think about riding a horse through space :D
NoblePAINV2 5 months ago 14
What's so awesome about mastodon is that everyone's x/vocals!
TheRiffCalendar 5 months ago
Why u interupt song?
TheRiffCalendar 5 months ago
I think given the kind of music they're playing they do very well to sing and play their instruments at the same time....they're not bad either. When I went seeing them they were very good, especially the vocals.
DeathMagneticX3 5 months ago
the cameraman obviously can't distinguish a bass guitar from an electric guitar. just watch the solo section.
ericwilbert 6 months ago 2
@ericwilbert There are at least four cameramen here :P
TheRiffCalendar 5 months ago
@ericwilbert there are multiple cameramen, and they change their focus sometimes.
I imagine no one was covering Brent and he quickly panned, or he forgot that he was supposed to have been covering him during the solo.
Mastodon fuck up sometimes too, particularly on the vocals.
:)
felixvc 5 months ago
I saw them in Toronto at Heavy T.O. and they didn't do this song pretty pissed :( they can do it live so why I ask you why ????
stevegillett007 6 months ago
They all have unique voices as well. Fucking amazing musicians.
sepultura777 6 months ago
i fucking love mastodon
Paastand 6 months ago
The Switcher on this vid need to be shot in the face for giving brent fuck all for screen time. Way to step on a great solo asshat
glokidd 6 months ago
dude the voice at the beginning freaked me out
Schectler 6 months ago
I love Mastodon. I love how into the music they are. I love how you see the passion radiating from them.
asbirdsdo 6 months ago
@asbirdsdo You see it in their writing too, especially in this album.
jbohler33 6 months ago
None of these guys can sing all that well, but its because of that, that makes them even more of an amazing band. You can listen to a Mastodon song and when you hear the weird vocals you know immediatly that its them. You dont even have to listen to a chorus or something. You can tell by the first word they say.
SlowmoLife 6 months ago
@SlowmoLife AHAH wtf xD
they are not very good live, but they sound really good on the songs, songs like this one, search for the video clip.
gothikgamer 6 months ago
@SlowmoLife Well studio-wise they all have great voices. but live i think troys the only one thats improved since this performance. hes great live now ^-^
Mastodrummer888 5 months ago
@Mastodrummer888 I do believe brent is the best in the singing area. But it's truly all opinion.
XtheXfallenXoneX 5 months ago
They're such amazing musicians. Dailor's my favorite drummer ha. They really need an actual lead singer though.
DrPerki 6 months ago
@DrPerki i disagree i know there not really any good in singing but there cool the way they are and it would tottaly change there sound i think
epicguitarbro 6 months ago
@epicguitarbro You're probably right, ha.
DrPerki 6 months ago
this is how josh homme, james hetfield, and rasputin made a side project
aditsetan 6 months ago
@aditsetan and zack galifinakis
jp1969lp 6 months ago
mastodon is really really good at everything except in the vocal department
lennythecow123 6 months ago 4
So many sexual innuendos on the comments, I know it's awesome but seriously people it's not porn...
KrossPoison1 7 months ago
Where have I been all these years?!?!?!?!?
Why didn't I look up Mastodon sooner?!
GRAAAH I've been missing out! lol
103964988 7 months ago 2
@103964988 You haven't. This is the first amazing album they've done. The one before it was okay but they're first two only had one good track: Blood and Thunder.
NOWYOURGONNABURNHOE 6 months ago
@NOWYOURGONNABURNHOE
FUCK NO!
What about ''I am Ahab'', ''Megalodon'', ''
Joseph Merrick'', ''Iron Tusk'' etc. in ''Leviathan'' and ''March of the Fire Ants'', ''Where Strides the Behemoth'', ''Mother Puncher'', etc. in ''Remission''.
You don't like ir, ok. But they are two killer albums, like ''Blood Mountain'' and ''Crack the Skye''
papafritaman 6 months ago
i think i just saw zach galifikianis in the background! :D:D:D
vypyr1 7 months ago
The chorus blows my mind. It's beautiful
Apocalypse922 7 months ago
Currently the best band on earth
dirty30jr 7 months ago 4
@dirty30jr agreed.
Wild6Child 7 months ago 3
the LP that bill is playing is gorgeous.
boogaman777 7 months ago
graspop!
tamadrumkit 7 months ago
I could have sworn that my pants were on when I started this video.
ThatKrookedVulture 7 months ago 58
this song, album and band is fucking epic, except for the fucking bassists vocals!
amithabajan2 7 months ago
I was watching this video to figure out the fast part of the solo. Freaking camera man fail.
ionfromneon 8 months ago
*Mastodon, sorry typo, kinda on my iPhone!
M1CKss 8 months ago
I love mastadon! And that silverburst fender American deluxe p-bass is freaking sweet! I want one so badly!
M1CKss 8 months ago
I have say, the singing here sounds a lot better than on their new live DVD, Live at the Aragon (and a lot better than when they were on David Letterman). Apparently they can sing and play at the same time, just not consistently.
The playing of course, is spot on, as usual.
charlesajones77 8 months ago 3
lmao at the singing hahaha
Hamgammy 8 months ago 3
Comment removed
st4976 8 months ago
can't wait to see them in Poland!
grabarian 8 months ago 3
Fk*** awesome!!!!
rhenzzo 9 months ago
Hum
Can't... I can't...I can't...... They really need a singer because it sucks during live.
TheChopeur 9 months ago
right on this song is badass love it
dilzas23 9 months ago
Thumbs up if this song KICKS ASS!
smjjohnson 9 months ago
the like/unlike bar looks like a lit up joint
domzonmosh 9 months ago 3
Dude this is only my 3rd time listening to these guy I forgot the bands name, now I remember.
They look so much like pros when they play I'm jealous.
Mrblowert 9 months ago
The Chorus is so fucking huge omg
Flammin5s 9 months ago 7
I love how the camera avoided Brent like the plague during the ENTIRE solo.
MutilationOfTheWeak 9 months ago
I always sing when I masturbate j/k Crack The Skye I love this fucking album
smjjohnson 9 months ago
amazing fucking chorus
justyn3tears 9 months ago
typing oblivion into youtube should come up with this video, not some piece of shit faggot game
Morain42 9 months ago
@Morain42 Dude Oblivion is awesome. Both the song and the game, you need a better taste in games.
Packers909 9 months ago
@Packers909 i dont play games man haha
Morain42 9 months ago
@Packers909 true dat
CSB008 7 months ago
this is way better than the letterman version. my take on it is if they're ruining their voices by the way they do death metal vocals on about half their material...how about making up melodies and singing instead and then it can all be better. problem solved.
derekdeprator 9 months ago
@derekdeprator dude :\ there's a technique called screaming, iff you're doing it right (like all professionals should be, and Mastodon are) then it won't cause any vocal damage. It's all perfectly healthy, and does not vocal damage whatsoever.
MigelMeUp 9 months ago
@MigelMeUp folks were talking about them not singing up to par and i had an idea. that's all. but to be honest, i don't know anybody that sings like that who doesn't lose their voice really quickly. just saying. that's all.
derekdeprator 9 months ago
@derekdeprator yeah, I'm just saying your idea doesn't work and makes no sense. That's all.
MigelMeUp 9 months ago
The real problem is that Troy's vocal cords are so wrecked by all the screaming he's been doing his entire career, and the same goes for Brent. Brann sounds fine though, considering he's drumming at the same damn time.
FourthHorseman666 10 months ago
@FourthHorseman666 There's not a single thing wrong with any of the vocals in this. Any more perfect than this would be annoyingly unreal and more like the bullshit music I try to stay away from.
GodsentHellraiser 10 months ago
The thing i like about mastodon all the members kinda have singing Parts even the mowhawk guys does backing growls on some songs
Norg1 10 months ago
2:18!! That is a fantastic addition that, for me, makes this performance so much better than the album! I watched this video once last year, and now everytime I hear this song, I hear that addition. Every Time! I. Freaking. Love. This. BAND!
ianguitarist4 10 months ago
@ianguitarist4 i know what you mean, even when i listen to the album version i expect to hear that bit :L
eddy2394 10 months ago
EPIC
guitarwarrior69 10 months ago
Seriously, what are you guys whining about their singing? You ever heard any other bands sing live by any chance? Just seriously.. everyone sounds a bit different when they play an instrument and sing at the same time, compared to just singing.
MegaNekke 10 months ago
@MegaNekke Uh, I've seen plenty of bands live that are every bit as technical and/or heavy as Mastodon that don't sound like a vocal trainwreck. Watch the fucking Letterman performance and try not to cringe like I did at the fact that a BRILLIANT band like Mastodon sounds like a bunch of high schoolers at a talent show singing over a backtrack.
The bassist and the drummer NEED to get in and work with a vocal coach.
uhwaykin 10 months ago
@uhwaykin The bassist and drummer can actually sing their own shit on key in most performances. The guitarist is the biggest trainwreck of all...I haven't heard him sing a single song off Crack the Skye live that hasn't sounded like, as you said, "a high schooler at a talent show singing over a backtrack".
Raro404 10 months ago
@Raro404 Not from what I've seen. On further review, I think the drummer just goes out of key from time to time because he's got two other guys on stage who may as well be singing different songs. The bassist, however, is consistently awful in a way that I've seen before as someone who's played in bands. It's that "Oh shit, this guy actually doesn't know how to carry a note" kind of way.
Brent is also consistently bad in another way I've seen before. He doesn't know how to sing properly.
uhwaykin 10 months ago
@uhwaykin By which I mean to say, I'm about 99% positive he's singing in a way that actually physically hurts. Which would explain why he seems to steadily drift off key the longer he sings, which can easily be corrected with some instruction.
The bassist is the real vocal problem, though.
uhwaykin 10 months ago
MUY BUENO MASTODON!!!! ES UNO DE MIS GRUPOS FAVORITOS
PINGOPRODUCCIONES1 10 months ago
You gotta give some credit to bill. yea he plays rhythm but thats the best and most creative rhythm I've ever heard. Those are some awesome CHORDS!!!!
ThatWasMyPoptart 10 months ago
uhh i sorry but troy what the fuck man... that sounded weak. like he was trying to push it out to hard.
xXyourmomsballsXx 10 months ago
This thread about singing is absolutely unecessary. Mustaine sings until this very day, right?
Arthurxisde 10 months ago
drum and sing? i cant even jerk off and sing
dannycatastrophe 10 months ago 180
@dannycatastrophe
You should learn. Multitasking those two things changed my life forever.
LittleJackHorror 9 months ago
@LittleJackHorror what jacking off and singing? lol just joking man
Morain42 9 months ago
@dannycatastrophe I can!!! LAAAA!!! :D
GodsentHellraiser 9 months ago
@dannycatastrophe best comment in this f*cking community!
Olfoe 9 months ago
@dannycatastrophe *cough* Phil Collins
donnishark 7 months ago 3
@donnishark Phil Collins can sing and masturbate simultaneously?
HumansAreDead 7 months ago
@HumansAreDead LOL i dont even know who phil collins is
dannycatastrophe 7 months ago
@HumansAreDead No, Collins can't sing but he IS a total wanker
LordMontystink 6 months ago
@dannycatastrophe actually drumming and singing is easier in my experience.
Flatliner0452 5 months ago
@dannycatastrophe Chuck Norris can jerk off and drum
Ananth22by7 4 months ago 2
@Ananth22by7 Chuck Norris also has a third fist as a chin so I'm not surprised he could jerk off and drum.
HeyMan674 4 months ago
@dannycatastrophe Just wait till they play "Dry Bone Valley" live
uiruu 3 months ago
Comment removed
dannycatastrophe 3 months ago
Damn, Troy vocals made me shit all my pants D:
What an emotional sing...
FeehDeedo 10 months ago
I'm not too big on the idea of getting a singer or anything like that, but seeing Josh Homme sing for Crack The Skye would be phenomial..
loganzilla 11 months ago
Instrumentaly is perfect.
CalifornianSoul 11 months ago
the hangover anybody? omg.
jkav2003 11 months ago
damn these guys needauto tune live but mastodon is still kickass!
ryanthemadman1 11 months ago
I don't get why everyone complains. The vocals are sub-par, sure, but they aren't really that bad. And the instrumentals are really what matters with Mastodon anyways.
jr34v3r 11 months ago
Brent needs to sing his part alone
xxEPICSHOOPDAWHOOPxx 11 months ago
unique,
jstarlyftw 11 months ago
nice
jstarlyftw 11 months ago
So 3 guys sing ? That's cool refreshingly original .
Albanijac 11 months ago
great song but srsly. those live vocals sucks fucking ass :/
whitepony1986 11 months ago
@whitepony1986 I admit, I'm not a huge fan of live vocals. I like the clean polished studio version better, but the song is bad ass.
xxIncognitoxx 11 months ago
@xxIncognitoxx the song is totally bad ass crazy fucking awsome, but this live vocals suck terribly.
whitepony1986 11 months ago
Best Mastodon song!
karriondiir 11 months ago 3
they could of been having monitor issues,kinda hard to sing when you cant hear yourself, the letterman show was even worse than this one vocally...
noisepsalm 11 months ago
must. go. to. the... bathroom.... but I cant!
pabsensi 11 months ago 45
No dejan de sorprenderme estos tipos...absolutamente geniales!!!!!!!
TheClutched 1 year ago
Yea, surprisingly Brann is the best singer and that says a lot considering that drumming and singing at the same time is really hard...especially when it's a Brann Dailor drum part.
TbTReviews 1 year ago 6
holy crap i just realised Brent is plugged into a vintage modern in this vid!
ScottysGuitar 1 year ago
They're so much better when you actually see them live. Let's be honest, live recordings of metal bands of any kind just don't translate well, and that's especially true for this band. Everything is different at 120 decibels.
Damianlkh 1 year ago
Damn they plays their songs so well live... man, Ive been listening to Metallica way too much
ripa9 1 year ago
to those who think mastodon needs a vocalist....watch brann play, you'll forget about the vocals :)
Stratocoaster08 1 year ago
2:43 The monster awakens
Simonkpedersen 1 year ago
in the other live videos the singing is incredibly good i think they were to fucked up on letterman to remember how to sing thats why i love these guys
jorgon545 1 year ago
@jorgon545 well not incredible but pretty good.
jorgon545 1 year ago
The vocals doesnt sound as goods as in the studio version, but is not that bat anyway. Plus, give them a break, playing that ans singing? Thats aint easy at all.
cutiko 1 year ago
Actually, vocals were one of the things that got me interested in Mastodon. When I played Colony of Birchmen on the Rock Band videogame, I got somewhat intrigued by the "mix" of several voices (I thought all vocals were done by the same singer and just were added one on top of the other). Though I like fast songs more than slow ones, I do like Mastodon songs because they're so fresh due its vocal style
Marskill 1 year ago
i mean none of them are real singers. lol this is the first album were they have actually as you say "sung" but its so dramartic it makes up for it
TheGerthax 1 year ago
At least we know its live performance for sure :D
jameat3r 1 year ago
where is brent? oh there he is
markbray69 1 year ago
where is brent?
markbray69 1 year ago
the drummer is a vocalist? 0_o wow thats awesome
animemonarch888 1 year ago
realistically, their vocal harmonies were a little off. no i could not sing better and play at the same time. if i remember right, this was early in the promo stages for crack the skye so they were probably nervous, underpracticed, and in brent's case probably a little stoned (or not stoned, whichever would fuck with his mind more). the album is also pretty hard to do justice to live cuz it is so perfect
Ploj102 1 year ago
they all sing in a different way. and their probably nervous. im sure u couldnt sing as good as they do and play an instrument at the same time. stop hating.
MetalliDeth1223 1 year ago
i actually like the singing.
notjohn100 1 year ago
This isn't a band about singing. This is a band about great instrumentals backed up by singing.
rbogart123 1 year ago
lol, i think they look like gimli ! they even got some pretty good axe skills to
FilipPS3 1 year ago
good live performance.
I like... actually, really like....
Anyone who gotta problem wit the vocal, GFURS.
\m/\m/ long live mastodon!!!!
vrydee 1 year ago
theres a problem when brent has the best vocal performance lol
indoninjaa 1 year ago
Well, their singing did suck just now, but since when has heavy metal of any kind been about singing?
The singing in the studio version was pretty decent, IMHO, and their musicianship is amazing, especially in a time of simple Alternative Rock riffs where clean, polished production and vocals are the main focus instead of technicality and complex musical structures.
Mastodon is a superb band. I wouldn't like it if they got a separate singer. It's not necessary. They're great the way they are.
Ananth22by7 1 year ago
@Ananth22by7 actually, black sabbath, with dio and ozzy had ALOT to do about the singing, otherwise I agree with you.
Ablutophobic 1 year ago
@Ablutophobic What you said is true. I'm a big Iron Maiden fan and of course, with a singer like Bruce, singing is one of their strong points. But of course, if a metal band doesn't have a good singer, it doesn't mean they're poor and of course, if they do have one, what more do you want?
Ananth22by7 1 year ago
@Ananth22by7 Couldn't have said it better myself.
Ablutophobic 1 year ago
Damn, This version is better than the music video.
Ablutophobic 1 year ago
maybe not a new singer but some classes wouldn't hurt...
moretimetokill31 1 year ago
@moretimetokill31 i agree.... people are Full of it, they suck at singing
stagm3 1 year ago
first time i ever heard mastodon was from this video..... hooked ever since!
sux0rz 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thumbs up if you clicked this vid hoping to see a live play on the game Oblivion.
TheBlaziken437 1 year ago
@TheBlaziken437 You realize it was an xbox 360 launch game right?
Ablutophobic 1 year ago
vocalist required,,,,URGENTLY
madatak 1 year ago
@madatak ummm yeah, STAT
stagm3 1 year ago
Orchestration and vision is brilliant for song.......truly a modern gem and breath of fresh air for the genre.....kudos!
beyonder3000 1 year ago
HAHAHAHA all I can say to all the haters out there...is that you are more than likely all jealous of these guys! They rip on their instruments and the fact that they can sing over top of the craziness of the music is amazing! And if you still need convincing, go see them live. Maybe shitting your pants after seeing them live will teach you a lesson about hating. Fuckin mooks!
cosm7 1 year ago 5
is it just me or does the lead guitarist (cant quite seem to remember his name right now) look exactly like zach galifiniakis (aka all the fat guy from the hangover...)
thats fuckin sweet
rockallevil1324 1 year ago
dear lord get your eyes checked you fucking ass
cosm7 1 year ago
Brann Dailor gives me more orgasms than my girlfriend. Do I fail or does Brad win ? o.O
MrCayuga 1 year ago 2
And, it just wasn't mixed very good.
LeeChavezMusic 1 year ago 3
Needs more Reverb and Delay.
LeeChavezMusic 1 year ago
They have a vocalist ....they all all the members of the current band singing. People see a problem with this? Are you serious?
ShotGunRoleModel 1 year ago
deffinatly not one of the best live bands.... vocally anyways
TheGerthax 1 year ago
Brann Dailor is the new Lars Urich.
Only this time... He's actually good.
NightShade1218 1 year ago
@NightShade1218 better than lars ulrich
franliberty 1 year ago
@franliberty true that
TheGerthax 1 year ago