una delle più belle opere rock .... questo è ciò che ci hanno regalato a noi adolescenti di allora.... ai giovani di oggi regaliamo disoccupazione rabbia ansia.... e una musica che fa cagare....
Be careful what you say about the one and only Guy Pratt, bass player extraordinaire on various Floyd tours, not to mention his other work. Of course he is mainly in for the fun and to take things not too seriously is sort of his usual attitude (and what's wrong about that, hey?), best described in his book "My Bass and Other Animals".
(Rick Wright's son-in-law, by the way - so you shouldn't treat him as some bloke who just happened to be there in this session)
@PeterSpaeter96 apologies if i offended. I never questioned his talent. and everyone should be able to laugh at themselves and be laughed at, as well. we're all talented human beings in one area or another
I love this video, so much, but Guy Pratt pisses me off. He hits some sour notes in the beginning, which is understandable, it happens to all musicians. But then he starts jumping around and shit. Cool, you're into it, but come on now. The look David Gilmour gives him is like "haha you're funny, now stop."
Also, all the distortion on his stand-up sounds horrid in the beginning. Might just be me. I just don't care for when it's an acoustic set and one instrument is noticeably distorted...
@Miainferno you're absolutely right, I was going to comment on guy pratt but looked for other comments and yours is spot on. That guy annoyed me since 1993. He was good on the "On an Island" dvd concert. But this is going over the line.
4:16 and seconds after dave talks to rick in music lenguage. great response by rick .god .its like they both comunicate a lot of feelings through it..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Im a HUGE floyd fan, but....this version sucks. 50.000 Dollar guitar sounds like Mark Knopfler masturbating. Wish i had never seen this vid. Oh man, its even Sting at momentsw. Damn. Get some hippie hair or something. damn. RIP rick.
I'm so cool, i like a band so I'll put down others. listen to me I will track you down, Listen buddy, same song name, get the fuck over it. don't try to sound tough or cool by putting down other people that made a fucking mistake. stop being a prick.
What the fuck is Set Your Goals, do not ever use crappy band names in a Pink Floyd video. Further, don't you ever use any band name together with Pink Floyd in one sentence or I will track you down.
@Rozq87 Hahahaha easy man, Set Your Goals is a Punk Rock band and that band have a song called Echoes, I like SYG but Pink Floyd is Pink Floyd, MUCH RESPECT!
I tried to get tickets when he came to toronto, but they were sold to fanclubs exclusively more or less. 5th largest city in North America and ticketmaster couldn't even get any. Pissed me off. Got to see Robert Plant though.
Between 1:35 to 1:40 They confuse the order singing inviting and inviting me to rise, when it's actually inviting and enticing me to rise, years will do that too you! RIP Rick
Epic! Dave looks REALLY in the mood for this :) I see the younger gilmour in his eyes.. That look in the eyes will never disappear from his eyes.. This is the best version ever of the song, its so emotional and intimate played, especially the solo ^^ Im smiling :)
I think that this version of the song was not even planned, you see in the beginning of the video only David is playing, then Guy Pratt goes back to the double bass and Rick sits down again! That's just insane... BTW great version, those anybody knows where I can get the tabs for this one?
you dont really need tabs for this one, you can just the tabs for of the studio version, the chords and everything are the same. And for the solo at the end you only need your eyes and your ears, its pretty slow and simple :)
i also learned this "version" like that is sooo beautiful
Which ones pink? ....................hahahaha just messing with you. I don't think roger could play an upright. The intonation is hard to get used to if you don't do it often, who knows maybe he could. I just kind of doubt he ever took the time or we'd have seen it.
This is THE Echoes... maybe the greatest song in rock's history, Pink Floyd created this masterpiece even before the members of Set Your Goals were borne... f*cking asshole (*)<-------
THEY WERE JUST FUCKING AROUND, AND THAT IS CLEARLY SHOWN. They are only having a good time and it was a amazing performance just for a jam session. And it looked like Rick Wright was having a great time, it is sad he passed away. He looked like such a gentle person, soft spoken, but could also make you laugh. "ECHOES" is everything Floyd is, it is all of Floyd's career packed into one song. Spacey,melodic,meloncholic,dark,progressive,creative, and original. There will never be another Pink Floyd
It looks for me that Gilmoor started it for fun and the others camed it to that jam to finaly make an intersting "no waste of time" gift to us youtube freaks.
This was actually a secret video on the special features of Gilmours LIVE AT THE ROYAL ALBERT HALL dvd. If you have not seen this DVD it is amazing, and it is loaded with special features....
Echoes, for me, personally is one of the most epic and beautiful pieces in music. It sits quite happily next to Tubular Bells, Handel's Messiah and The Planets by Holst.
I've come here looking for Set Your Goals for years now.
LikeAGiant 4 months ago
Waters looks a little pissed at how long it takes them to get it.
infinitygoof 5 months ago
@infinitygoof Waters?
GGYBUUYBU 1 month ago
@GGYBUUYBU Ooops Gilmour.
infinitygoof 3 weeks ago
una delle più belle opere rock .... questo è ciò che ci hanno regalato a noi adolescenti di allora.... ai giovani di oggi regaliamo disoccupazione rabbia ansia.... e una musica che fa cagare....
mario7dic 7 months ago in playlist Progressive Rock
3:11 The bass player looks like a squirrel ;D
niubex 7 months ago
i love the part when john carin plays the slide guitar 3:11
FloydGilmour 7 months ago
1:00 tabs?
Teutonic1250 10 months ago
why does that bass player look like he's going to shit his pants !!! lmaoo and the rest of the band is smirking at that fact..so wrong lol smh
natewillmusic 10 months ago
@natewillmusic and Master Jancho
Be careful what you say about the one and only Guy Pratt, bass player extraordinaire on various Floyd tours, not to mention his other work. Of course he is mainly in for the fun and to take things not too seriously is sort of his usual attitude (and what's wrong about that, hey?), best described in his book "My Bass and Other Animals".
(Rick Wright's son-in-law, by the way - so you shouldn't treat him as some bloke who just happened to be there in this session)
PeterSpaeter96 9 months ago
@PeterSpaeter96 apologies if i offended. I never questioned his talent. and everyone should be able to laugh at themselves and be laughed at, as well. we're all talented human beings in one area or another
natewillmusic 9 months ago
Roger Waters create 13 accounts to hate this
przemorski 11 months ago
@przemorski jajajajaja
marjob679 7 months ago in playlist #Arsenal v Leeds United
Comment removed
EvilNoize 11 months ago
An Ummagumma moment at 2:27, a screen within a screen !
galipooh 1 year ago 2
somebody punch that bass player please..
MasterJuancho 1 year ago
Phil Manzanera on the second guitar =D
masterkarnicero666 1 year ago
Comment removed
MasterJuancho 1 year ago
Is Gilmour crying during that jam or am I wrong?
TheBenoslaw1234 1 year ago
Cannot find it on my 2-dvd copy of Remember that nigh. Why???
MatFox 1 year ago
Beautiful and Amazing! I can't say no more!
pigletized 1 year ago
Q.E.P.D Richard Wright :).
stebanloko 1 year ago
if David would have black and long hair nowadays,he would look old at all
k0stil 1 year ago
His smile at 3:36 is priceless.
shabadoda 1 year ago
Magique...
Oratorna 1 year ago
I love this video, so much, but Guy Pratt pisses me off. He hits some sour notes in the beginning, which is understandable, it happens to all musicians. But then he starts jumping around and shit. Cool, you're into it, but come on now. The look David Gilmour gives him is like "haha you're funny, now stop."
Also, all the distortion on his stand-up sounds horrid in the beginning. Might just be me. I just don't care for when it's an acoustic set and one instrument is noticeably distorted...
Miainferno 1 year ago 4
@Miainferno you're absolutely right, I was going to comment on guy pratt but looked for other comments and yours is spot on. That guy annoyed me since 1993. He was good on the "On an Island" dvd concert. But this is going over the line.
MarcBeckK 1 year ago
"A quick bullet: a tough one to dodge and no one ever does
It cuts fast and deep (keeps you from sleep)
And you just have to let it bleed
I know the pain, it's all to familiar
If I could sing words to help, you know I would
And they would end the pain
But you will have to let this make you stronger
It's difficult to overcome"
SYG! haha
roniesavage 1 year ago
this is not set your goals.
findanewgoddd 1 year ago
Everytime i watch this it just gets better. .Fuckin awesome man.
Every hair on my body stands on end to this masterpiece.
Old Dave is the man
rebelbhoy1888 1 year ago 5
I'd use that big ass bass to cover my enormous ereciton if I were jammin with them
ruufeeooh 1 year ago 57
Richard Wright, He is the best :/
RIP Wright
haitokiashi 1 year ago 9
what the hell, wheres set your goals!
StartTheShooting 1 year ago
this isn't Set your Goals :(
sethsetshisgoals 1 year ago
@sethsetshisgoals hahaha i know
findanewgoddd 1 year ago
4:16 and seconds after dave talks to rick in music lenguage. great response by rick .god .its like they both comunicate a lot of feelings through it..
bengativo6 2 years ago 4
@airrudy , is Dick Perry the saxophonist of Pink floyd , he played in some of their song like Money
VoodooThing 2 years ago
what in the world is he yelling at 6:20?? Who is Jim Parry?
airrudy 2 years ago
@airrudy "Dick Parry", he played sax for the floyd :-)
iburnedthedinner 1 year ago 3
right. he screwd up. but that's alright. it's difficult to play this on an acoustic guitar. i myself can't...
undudster 2 years ago
holy fuck i love this
lodecar69 2 years ago 4
me too, such an underrated song. Alot don't know about its existence. Well people that i've asked. One of my fav's by the floyd
Douverwynn 2 years ago 3
They should've fired the bassplayer
Volendammtje 2 years ago
I never knew Gilmore kept his guitar pick in his mouth.
duncanstpt 2 years ago
from where did u get that video !!
2743049 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Im a HUGE floyd fan, but....this version sucks. 50.000 Dollar guitar sounds like Mark Knopfler masturbating. Wish i had never seen this vid. Oh man, its even Sting at momentsw. Damn. Get some hippie hair or something. damn. RIP rick.
horrorflesh 2 years ago
@horrorflesh Do NOT make fun of Mark Knopfler
Hawk552 2 years ago
FUck you. This video is awesome
undudster 2 years ago
richard was tight at this session (not that his not normally)really enjoyed it thanks for uploading this
MaTtmAn11276 2 years ago
amazing!
wuax 2 years ago
this sucks
mlronan 2 years ago
I'm so cool, i like a band so I'll put down others. listen to me I will track you down, Listen buddy, same song name, get the fuck over it. don't try to sound tough or cool by putting down other people that made a fucking mistake. stop being a prick.
wheneverisaygo 2 years ago
What the fuck is Set Your Goals, do not ever use crappy band names in a Pink Floyd video. Further, don't you ever use any band name together with Pink Floyd in one sentence or I will track you down.
Rozq87 2 years ago
@Rozq87 Hahahaha easy man, Set Your Goals is a Punk Rock band and that band have a song called Echoes, I like SYG but Pink Floyd is Pink Floyd, MUCH RESPECT!
mikeytheghostbuster 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best song ever!!
rkosuck 2 years ago
me too MrDecable, me too
BNTBS182 2 years ago
I watch this way too often.
elessar0206 2 years ago 4
God save David Gilmour.
bonzettobonobo 2 years ago 5
i was expecting set your goals.. :O
MrDecable 2 years ago
i thought this wuzz gonna be set your goals lolzz oh well
axharshxreality 2 years ago
Comment removed
ku62jo62 2 years ago
Gilmour seems like the coolest bloke ever.
elessar0206 2 years ago 10
who is mgmt?
konstantinosmei 2 years ago
What is this set about? What was the occasion?
allnightpancakes 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i'd like to know too!
affenarsch87 2 years ago
I'd be sweating so bad
kip967 2 years ago
At 6:19 verrry funnny!!! hahah
Gilmour is the best
demetzjump 2 years ago 3
my lord, this is simply AMAZING, best band in the history !!
raulishoogallagher 2 years ago 2
its awesome how this is "Screwing around" for those guys
knoxrox167 2 years ago 3
fuck i was expecting set your goals its all good aha
LikeAGiant 2 years ago
you liked this one?
PhilippeMusique 2 years ago 2
nah aha
LikeAGiant 2 years ago
same lmfao
DropDeadRawrrr 2 years ago
Same thing happened to me, but when I realized this was Floyd, I was like fuck Set Your Goals.
putwuteverdude 2 years ago 3
Ohhhh, that guitar solo is absolutely amazing, so relaxing and tranquil.
dstauske 2 years ago 6
we'll never see a pink floyd again
OcRowen 2 years ago 5
We won't need one, what Floyd made has, obviously, already been made.
There will be another band different to them, but with the same intentions that will be just as extraordinary
iburnedthedinner 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
M G M T
doeboy736 2 years ago
mgmt sucks dude
raulishoogallagher 2 years ago
why thumbs down?
they suck it's the true
Auschwitz691 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
AZARTI5 2 years ago
it's halfway there
funkydan123 2 years ago
Imagine jamming with the Floyd.. I'd shit my pants and orgasm simultaneously, especially if I was playing Echoes. Oh my god, so beautiful.
GoldenGhettoFilms 2 years ago 3
I wouldnt be able to even grab a guitar near those guys...
radiohm3 2 years ago 3
dont know how many times ive been trippin on acid listenin to this song repeating over and over. give you some crazy visuals
jkuebler89 2 years ago
That guy on the fretless is a little over excited. lol
jesus201866 2 years ago 5
I would be too if I was jamming with Pink Floyd
GoldenGhettoFilms 2 years ago 27
@GoldenGhettoFilms Well, that guy on fretless is Guy Pratt. He sure jammed with Pink Floyd a couple of times in the last two decades... ;)
abbath112233 1 year ago 2
I wish the bass was at least acoustic-electric. it sounds out of place here
lawlshane 2 years ago
a great solo \m/
r.i.p rick wright
ludwingvanmorrison 2 years ago
... milestone of the last 50 years....
brodsky96 2 years ago
May SYD rest in peace!!!
brodsky96 2 years ago 2
Good vocals, nice instrumental variation.
Aereaunage 2 years ago
Ahhh Man.....I so adore David!! Acoustic is the best, at least for me!! love love this post..thank you!!
DejaVuSu 2 years ago
this is the kind of shit that throws you into another universe - RIP Rick
ComradeNu 2 years ago 6
i have the dvd but cant find this song on it, is it on disc 1 or 2?
pinkfloydrule27 2 years ago
it's a hidden track, check it out on wikipedia :)
omgitsmatej 2 years ago
disc 2
insanemembrane16 2 years ago
eso me hace recordar a nebuis
silverkhox 2 years ago
....wow!!!...
drinkcoffe 2 years ago 3
just amazing !!!
joaodara17 2 years ago 2
Wooooow!!!! Echoes is the best song of Pink Floyd, es una gran explosión de creatividad.
nickygilmour 2 years ago
What the Hell kind of bass is that?
therickstah 2 years ago 4
sounds amazing best ive herd for ages
676juicy676 2 years ago 2
I'm a huge Floyd fan and I never knew this video existed... thanks for the upload!
mikethetiger 2 years ago
i think, because it was a hidden feature on gilmours remember that night DVD
plusgood15 2 years ago
what do you mean by hidden?
GeezaGooderz 2 years ago
where can i find it on bluray version??
mrkd 2 years ago
im only 18, i would give anything to see david live its a shame im this young and couldnt see him on his days.
lhc232 2 years ago 4
dude, i feel the same way.....
would give anything to live in the 70's
dan21reddevil 2 years ago
im 23 an saw him in london when on an island came out best show ever
vandealex 2 years ago
I tried to get tickets when he came to toronto, but they were sold to fanclubs exclusively more or less. 5th largest city in North America and ticketmaster couldn't even get any. Pissed me off. Got to see Robert Plant though.
funkydan123 2 years ago
Absolument sublime. Gilmour a une sensibilité musicale folle, et il devient encore meilleur avec l'âge en plus !
Fazer600Powa 2 years ago
actually it is not that either. It goes like "inviting and inciting me to rise"
Blackfloydian 2 years ago
taken from across the universe by the beatles
Beatlesfan50 2 years ago
Between 1:35 to 1:40 They confuse the order singing inviting and inviting me to rise, when it's actually inviting and enticing me to rise, years will do that too you! RIP Rick
dasoxfan88 2 years ago
they usually chnaged the order deliberately...
spepper 2 years ago
i dont know who these people are, i was looking for incubutt, but, i just needed to say, they have beautiful voices...
meatpuppet128 2 years ago 4
brother, that's David Gilmour from a little band known as Pink Floyd! Glad you liked it though, best band in history, imo of course ;)
mudflapking 2 years ago 7
Best band in history!!!!!!
M0ZART 2 years ago
i dont even know these ppl
but wen they started playing..it made me feel
idk
awkward..but ina good way
i hope i can still jam wen im 60 yrs old
Curtistoocool 2 years ago 4
no joke?? thats david gilmour brother! he'll be jammin when he's 100! haha
jro3030 2 years ago 7
so true!! :)
abhifloyd85 2 years ago
that was amazing the sound gills makes !!! :) ;)
676juicy676 2 years ago
Epic! Dave looks REALLY in the mood for this :) I see the younger gilmour in his eyes.. That look in the eyes will never disappear from his eyes.. This is the best version ever of the song, its so emotional and intimate played, especially the solo ^^ Im smiling :)
Joyster2212 3 years ago 6
OMFL
Jonlindin 3 years ago
1:26 gilmour wears levis :P
Anaben11 3 years ago 3
I love the moment at 5:23 when they're making those howling sounds.
I guess Dave's sort of saying to Rick 'remember when we used to have to make these kinds of weird mouth sounds for a living'
themengsk176 3 years ago 2
I think that this version of the song was not even planned, you see in the beginning of the video only David is playing, then Guy Pratt goes back to the double bass and Rick sits down again! That's just insane... BTW great version, those anybody knows where I can get the tabs for this one?
HM3 3 years ago 3
you dont really need tabs for this one, you can just the tabs for of the studio version, the chords and everything are the same. And for the solo at the end you only need your eyes and your ears, its pretty slow and simple :)
i also learned this "version" like that is sooo beautiful
Anaben11 3 years ago 3
Fucking Rick and David like that is too much. RIP Rick
iamjezuzchrist 3 years ago 4
you deserved to be shot on site, or just have your ears cut off. Pink floyds echoes is in a whole nother league compared to sygs echoes
usasordson 3 years ago 5
Which ones pink? ....................hahahaha just messing with you. I don't think roger could play an upright. The intonation is hard to get used to if you don't do it often, who knows maybe he could. I just kind of doubt he ever took the time or we'd have seen it.
kickcableguyinnuts 3 years ago
Awesome...David makes it look so effortless and fun. How many hours did it take to get to that level of mastery?
RodneyHampton 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
BIG BUMMER
not SYG's =[
GetSome200H8 3 years ago
You can't expect every "Echoes" song to be SYG
Shadow2Monk 3 years ago
Que canción increible la concha de la lora. Te pone la piel de gallina.
elafalla 3 years ago 6
wheres waters
minimyles2323 3 years ago 2
the end is so sad
TheXPatient 3 years ago
i love the bass, so deep...
feisal70 3 years ago 3
DICK PARRY!
vardocrux 3 years ago 3
They should have shown Rick Wright (R.I.P) more in this video.
fenderjazzbass62 3 years ago 8
what an awesome guitar riff at the beginning. prolly my favorite part of echoes
sbarker15 3 years ago
IMPRESIONANTE
josefunpeople 3 years ago 2
They're just awesome
Tzan7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that bass sound sucks o.O
eedski 3 years ago
It's called an upright, genius.
randomytubeaccount 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so? does that mean it can't suck?
eedski 3 years ago
this is good
i like this version
hofnerv03 3 years ago
That sounded so good. I wish they played the rest of it acoustic...
sebeatworld 3 years ago
Folks, their just having fun at a sound check. That's all. It sounds pretty down good for a spur of the moment jam, actually.
Trycruces 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
goddammit! thought this was a set your goals vid........fuck you fuck this old sick bastard
MetalCoreOli 3 years ago
You sir, can go suck a dick.
iPig 3 years ago 4
Screw SYG...this is Floyd Territory!!! R.I.P. Rick
RunsWithScissors61 3 years ago 3
Aaaaaauuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu...
Thanks, Floyd
hugospiegel 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WRONG ECHOES
where's SYG bitch?
GetSome200H8 3 years ago
This is THE Echoes... maybe the greatest song in rock's history, Pink Floyd created this masterpiece even before the members of Set Your Goals were borne... f*cking asshole (*)<-------
JDAR001 3 years ago 12
THEY WERE JUST FUCKING AROUND, AND THAT IS CLEARLY SHOWN. They are only having a good time and it was a amazing performance just for a jam session. And it looked like Rick Wright was having a great time, it is sad he passed away. He looked like such a gentle person, soft spoken, but could also make you laugh. "ECHOES" is everything Floyd is, it is all of Floyd's career packed into one song. Spacey,melodic,meloncholic,dark,progressive,creative, and original. There will never be another Pink Floyd
SephynnXx 3 years ago 7
It looks for me that Gilmoor started it for fun and the others camed it to that jam to finaly make an intersting "no waste of time" gift to us youtube freaks.
MuffinWhaleMan 3 years ago
This was actually a secret video on the special features of Gilmours LIVE AT THE ROYAL ALBERT HALL dvd. If you have not seen this DVD it is amazing, and it is loaded with special features....
SephynnXx 3 years ago
holy fuck at all the keyboard there at the end
memkills 3 years ago
is all voices (rick and david), sampled and played at chord intervals
Organell 3 years ago 2
i mean all the keyboards.,.,around that guy at the end.,.,.,theres like 8 of emm,.,
memkills 3 years ago
Thaaaaaaaaaaaaaaankssssssssssssssssssssss
rafagisbert1965 3 years ago
at the beggining it clearly shows the bass player is figuring out the song at the spot, fine with me
but the ugly ass fuzz.. man thats awful
Organell 3 years ago 3
damn that vocal outro was killer
froze my blood
Organell 3 years ago
Echoes, for me, personally is one of the most epic and beautiful pieces in music. It sits quite happily next to Tubular Bells, Handel's Messiah and The Planets by Holst.
God bless David Gilmour.
BMUHTDER 3 years ago 3
@BMUHTDER Quite similar your list to mine's... I don't know The Planets. I'll give it a try right away
Otonium 2 months ago
Big smile... Dave is so damn relaxed and funny!
CrazyMixx 3 years ago 2
that was awesome!!!!! my favorite floyd song, really liked this version, even though it's just the last part of the song. coool!!!!
btstma123 3 years ago 3
Would be quite difficult to arrange the middle part in an acousti version,wouldn't it?^^
Bassgesicht 3 years ago 4
he is david fucking gilmour!!! he would make it work..lol
shoebert357 3 years ago