i love how theres a thumbs down for the right answer and nobody thumbs down the wrong answer..its not list of demands its black history month. get your saul bars up!
you get a thumbs up AND a comment. cause people should know this. cause they should BUY the freaking album instead of always listening to it on youtube :)
@shonuxs: the song in the beginning was called 'Black History Month'. it was the first track of the album 'The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of Niggy Tardust'.
Truly, in some cases. In an interview with Trent, he said that unused pieces from the Fragile sessions or pieces that never fit with NIN albums were used on Tardust. Saul is a great MC and poet, but I think a lot of the music on his albums has been collaborative.
hijacked? Bull. This was a collaboration, purposeful and focused. Hijack gives the feeling that something unnatural and criminal has occurred. Because hip-hop HAS to be about crime right?
Beyond that I don't know that this can be qualified as hip-hop. While the vocals are indeed rhythmic, they are not characteristic of rap in pattern or intent, and Reznors beats aren't really hip-hop in nature.
So if the vocals and the music aren't hip-hop... why do you call it that. Gee. I wonder.
It's not about you or what you define things as. And where you took offense to the single use of 'hijack', another could easily take offense of your willingness to assume what someone else believes when they use the word.
Another possibly positive comment ruined by people trying to define the world and words of others under their own terms. Keep up the great work!
@thePolerin The vocals are nearly hip hop(speaking poetry and then singing a hook )and the music isn't totally unhip hop. The verse part is very influenced by music that is very NIN/Bjork, and both of them are totally influenced by hip hop. Its very dancable. You're overly sensitive.
the instruments sound like an out-take from nin's The Fragile (this is a compliment), the percussion and those freaky sounding strings. i also like the ending with those female sounding vocals. probably my favorite track off this album.
I almost wish he'd simplify his message?! I find his words so heavy and hard to unravel and digest.... which is part of the reason they are so great. I just wish there was a way to expose his truth and wisdom to a wider audience....
this shit encourages me.he talks bout reality and beyond any mans ideal and thinking.i wish i had a mentor like him.thanks saul williams.we need more people in the world like you.
i loved this. love is an honest word in this context. saul williams is a friend i've never met but have in my heart. beautiful. everything he touches.
It's unfortunate that the beginning is grayed out and blurry, but I guess it was a side-effect of the encoding. For anyone that can't read it, it just reads "Skin of a Drum / Saul Williams"
saul and trent could flip hip hop on it's ass if they wanted to. it could change everything.
gleader 10 months ago
This is my favorite song on the album!
Juggalo4eva313 1 year ago
This song is fucking AMAZING.
blahblahblahman 1 year ago
I agree dude. Lovin TRENT, SAUL WILLIAMS,EL-P, B.DOLAN, and ALLFLAWS
kind of all on a mad type of level
RAFAELDUNCANFILMS 1 year ago 7
amazing!
ChaveeBleu 1 year ago 2
i love how theres a thumbs down for the right answer and nobody thumbs down the wrong answer..its not list of demands its black history month. get your saul bars up!
labrat420 2 years ago
you get a thumbs up AND a comment. cause people should know this. cause they should BUY the freaking album instead of always listening to it on youtube :)
CaptainSolid 1 year ago
What is the song at the begining?
shonuxs 2 years ago
I don't remember exactly, but I believe it was from the first track of the same album.
dougstewartorg 2 years ago
@dougstewartorg black history month
labrat420 2 years ago
Black History Month
sergeantsmeg 2 years ago
list of demands
prometheusjohnson 2 years ago
list of demands =)
thesunna 2 years ago
@shonuxs it's black history month
SpookyDS 1 year ago
@shonuxs "Black History Month" from The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of Niggy Tardust
ArchSynDrum 1 year ago
@shonuxs Black History Month
DreadAle 1 year ago
@shonuxs "black history month" if you haven'
t found out since posted this comment last.
zipppit89 1 year ago
@shonuxs
The first 5 sec if from list of demands
skoneintex 1 year ago
@shonuxs The first 5 sec are from list of demands
skoneintex 1 year ago
@shonuxs "List of Demands"
hckr4evr 1 year ago
@shonuxs it's called black history month
acsmilf 1 year ago
@shonuxs: the song in the beginning was called 'Black History Month'. it was the first track of the album 'The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of Niggy Tardust'.
TallNegro 1 year ago
@shonuxs Convict Colony
merauxshere 11 months ago
@shonuxs Black History Month from The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of Niggy Tardust
newunited0606 11 months ago
@shonuxs Black History Month.
COOPstercopter 8 months ago
@shonuxs its list of demands
simonk512 6 months ago
Beautiful song.
Opheliac666 2 years ago
Trent Reznor, Saul Willims, EL P and new comers AllFlaws and B Dolan.
all so fresh and talented
wonnatryit 2 years ago 31
@wonnatryit tRENT REZNOR HAS BEEN AROUND FOR 20 + YEARS .. tRENT IS nin
sickmessiah 1 year ago
Comment removed
wonnatryit 2 years ago
I love this song :)
Canteatpancakes 2 years ago
umbrella seance is the greatest rapper alive
and poet
musudi 2 years ago
its just so... good!!
ceedog76 2 years ago 2
and the Fragile was an amazing album.....i like that saul williams is trying to bring his music to a new level and bring in new influences
reefrugger 2 years ago
great job!
afrikahnoir 2 years ago
skin of a drum = the fragile gets hijacked by hip hop
Anjiruu 2 years ago 5
Truly, in some cases. In an interview with Trent, he said that unused pieces from the Fragile sessions or pieces that never fit with NIN albums were used on Tardust. Saul is a great MC and poet, but I think a lot of the music on his albums has been collaborative.
dougstewartorg 2 years ago 5
hijacked? Bull. This was a collaboration, purposeful and focused. Hijack gives the feeling that something unnatural and criminal has occurred. Because hip-hop HAS to be about crime right?
Beyond that I don't know that this can be qualified as hip-hop. While the vocals are indeed rhythmic, they are not characteristic of rap in pattern or intent, and Reznors beats aren't really hip-hop in nature.
So if the vocals and the music aren't hip-hop... why do you call it that. Gee. I wonder.
thePolerin 2 years ago 8
I took his use of hijack to be a positive thing.
It's not about you or what you define things as. And where you took offense to the single use of 'hijack', another could easily take offense of your willingness to assume what someone else believes when they use the word.
Another possibly positive comment ruined by people trying to define the world and words of others under their own terms. Keep up the great work!
dougstewartorg 2 years ago 6
except that hip hop isnt a defined genre.
hip hop is able to fuse nearly all other music genre's into it, you can use an electro beat, rock melody, whatever. and still turn it into hip hop.
and saul's vocals are definitely hip hop in this song,
it may not be the "gangsta rap" you associate with hip hop.
and furthermore, why did you have to pull out the crime card?
noone mentioned hip hop being about crime at all.
stop creating arguments where they dont need to be and just appreciate the music.
CaptainSolid 2 years ago 5
@thePolerin i see what you mean, and, if my vocabulary interpretation, and if the comparison irked your sensibilities, i apologize.
truly, today i realized i used to be very ignorant, and that i've only become a more self-aware variantt of the such.
Anjiruu 1 year ago
@thePolerin The vocals are nearly hip hop(speaking poetry and then singing a hook )and the music isn't totally unhip hop. The verse part is very influenced by music that is very NIN/Bjork, and both of them are totally influenced by hip hop. Its very dancable. You're overly sensitive.
n0thank7 1 year ago
@Anjiruu exactly!
inimical01 1 year ago
@Anjiruu You clearly have never heard hip hop if you think Saul Williams is hip hop.
merauxshere 11 months ago
i love when that dark guitar tone comes in, truly amazing, and trent's tone does sound similar to his fragile albums
iCruzader 2 years ago
Favorite song off the album.
crazyamerican187 2 years ago
wundervoller Song
vigilantmutant 2 years ago
I saw him at his gig last year. Was right at the front the whole time and also got to shake his hand (twice! :p). Was the best gig i have been to!!
This guy is amazing!!
afthefragile 2 years ago
when u meet this man its like heaven on earth,
he is a genius and deserves to be praised as such
slatonsun 2 years ago 4
He performed as part of the oddity faire in March, and his performance blew my mind.
fortunatebystander 2 years ago
Saul is a genious. Pure and simple.
Roooobb 2 years ago
for sure my favorite song off this album, probably my favroite song so far from Saul, great stuff
molitor88 2 years ago
the instruments sound like an out-take from nin's The Fragile (this is a compliment), the percussion and those freaky sounding strings. i also like the ending with those female sounding vocals. probably my favorite track off this album.
theratking 2 years ago 2
its even better than i had hoped this is some kind of incredible...
trent obviously knew somthing..
photography vs. timing and
insight takes flight....
you saul, have been one of my biggest inspiration's
i really listined.and i've really learned alote
to all the creators within this
and dougstewartorg for uploading
i thank you
cronodob 2 years ago 2
This has to be one of my favorite songs off this incredible album...what an awesome collab.
ngough 2 years ago
Comment removed
cronodob 2 years ago
Comment removed
cronodob 2 years ago
these two are the next batman and robin, friggin they were made to collaborate this shit is giving me goosebumps
spitndecay 3 years ago 2
I almost wish he'd simplify his message?! I find his words so heavy and hard to unravel and digest.... which is part of the reason they are so great. I just wish there was a way to expose his truth and wisdom to a wider audience....
More catchy pop choruses Saul! Haha
kingafrokyle 3 years ago
Gosh, I hope he doesn't do that.
CelorElderOne 2 years ago 2
I second that.
unanimation 2 years ago
I find a lot of his lyrics hard to take in too but thats saul!!
I wouldn't like him if he was just another rapper with little depth in his lyrics and music!
afthefragile 2 years ago
awesome song. saul williams and trent outdid themselves with this one
drewhadou 3 years ago
Saul Williams lyrics and vocals go so well with Trent Reznor's musical style.
sarah12333 3 years ago
Yea I freaked out when I heard they were working together...it's so good :)
DRIZZY2005 2 years ago
Deep deep and more deep. The power words have when used properly. BIG UP SAUL
TropicalPrincessI 3 years ago 4
I forgot this video was unofficial while watching it, it's pretty jarring but that's what's good about it.
lawjokel 3 years ago 2
when u meet this man its like heaven on earth,
he is a genius and deserves to be praised as such
vthokiefan0007 3 years ago 4
this shit encourages me.he talks bout reality and beyond any mans ideal and thinking.i wish i had a mentor like him.thanks saul williams.we need more people in the world like you.
we232 3 years ago
haha this is so trent
sulimon510 3 years ago 2
good shit... peace
saint357saint 3 years ago 2
no
those are tadpoles
mikieazz 3 years ago
Def sperm.
SqueakNinja 3 years ago 4
tadpoles of progress born of sunsets, as Saul probably would put it.
Mike209000 3 years ago
is that...sperm?
HairballandCo 3 years ago 2
great video! goes great with the song
this guy's music is the best.
daveglove 3 years ago
i loved this. love is an honest word in this context. saul williams is a friend i've never met but have in my heart. beautiful. everything he touches.
ErikBN3012 3 years ago 13
Trent helping others to desolve trent and strengthen all of us
jbkbox 4 years ago 4
This is my favorite track off the album, next to DNA.
sevenleggedinsect 4 years ago 5
Good Job. One of my favorite songs on the album.
213millst 4 years ago 5
yep i like this song of course trent has hands on it
alperoz49 4 years ago 4
I'm liking it a lot. It kinda reminds me of the drum circles friends of mine would have just to jam.
deathneedslove 4 years ago 4
This is song is very good, first heard this from a friend. Hope more good songs like this is coming.
Segmentorr 4 years ago 4
Yay!
andsum1 4 years ago 4
It's unfortunate that the beginning is grayed out and blurry, but I guess it was a side-effect of the encoding. For anyone that can't read it, it just reads "Skin of a Drum / Saul Williams"
dougstewartorg 4 years ago