The cast is all wrong. Starfleet would likely have never even re-launched the USS Voyager. It would have been dissected and studied. If they did, I seriously doubt the same crew would have been stationed aboard. Janeway becomes an admiral somehow after they return anyway, as evidenced by "Nemesis".
@derkomissar100 The Voyager relaunch books talk about how Voyager, along with a few other ships, use slipstream drive to return to the Delta Quadrant deliberately, and a lot of the Voyager crew go with them, being the closest thing Starfleet has to experts on the region. I do believe a lot of the future tech (ablative armor generators, transphasic torpedoes) were pulled, though, and Starfleet does use transphasic torpedoes during an invasion by the Borg, so take that for what you will.
The more I think of it the more I like the Ideas of Kevin Sobo and Lisa Ryder. Also Amanda Tapping is a great idea. Last start emailing paramount folks. Time for a new Star Trek Series!!!!!
For a good laugh try " The Star Trek Bible " parody thesis, read by scholar Robert M. Price on ' The Bible Geek ', 18th September. Are some Bible verses actually reporting sightings of UFO ? Did humans travel here from another galaxy ? Was Jesus a spaceman ? Was the sighting of Jesus going up in the sky [Acts 1v9] actually him being teleported ? Or just dreamed up ? Were the living dead people seen in Jerusalem [Matt 27v53] actually imperial guards beamed down to save Jesus? Or just fiction ?
Captain Chakotay = Yes, Fleet Captains don't exist any longer, Commodore Eden (name change maybe), First officer Paris = No, B'lana Tores = No (where's the kid), Lt. Com Barcley atleast (who's the chief engineer though?), Lisa Ryder (hard blonde one too many), Sorbo = councillor (a bit gay = No), Lt. Aneka Hansen (7 of 9 no more), Lt. Kim = Yes, Dr Richard Zimmerman (good fitting name and rank of Lt. Com) = Yes! Otherwise I'd watch it lol...
You mean 53 years lol but you are right that would be a hindrance! Nether-the-less a hypocondriac officer with phobia's and addictions is going to be a bad leader even if he does go through the ranks an engineer not that of command!
One thing i would change is by the end of voyager 7 of 9 had mostly reclaimed her humanity so by the time this show would begin i believe she would be going by Annika Hanson not 7 of 9.
Harry never gets promoted because everyone hates him. Don't believe me, look how often he was the surviving redshirt, for whom death would be too honourable.
Janeway never gets killed because the Reaper is too damn scared. To kill Janeway would prevent her from having another cup of coffee, we all know what happens to people/sentient nebulae/interstellar empires/Borg who come between her and coffee.
IMHO I don't like it. It's too crudely done and the music doesn't keep with some of the footage used. But it is a very good effort and given time, you could make a truly spectacular intro.
@TheCharlie359 No offence taken - I am trying consider myself as a "neutral" - but even so, I have to disagree with you on your last point - (yes, I am also against mixing of different universes.) - but objectively, there is Star Wars as well. And no matter how much you maybe don't like it, with all its various worlds, cultures, planets, races and mythologies, one can only hardly claim Star Trek as the best. No offence.
@SirGalahadCtny Well, in the end...it comes down to two things. What you personally like, and what popularity/influence a show had on the public and the marketplace. In this regard, ST and SW are on top...with 40 plus years running for Trek, and 30 odd years for Star Wars. A person has a right to like/dislike what they want. (I.E. I don't care for McDonalds because of health/food issues), but I can hardly say they aren't the best at what they do. The market says they're the ones to beat. I.E. #1
@SirGalahadCtny Well, in the end...it comes down to two things. What you personally like, and what popularity/influence a show had on the public and the marketplace. In this regard, ST and SW are on top...with 40 plus years running for Trek, and 30 odd years for Star Wars. A person has a right to like/dislike what they want. (I.E. I don't care for McDonalds because of health/food issues), but I can hardly say they aren't the best at what they do. The market says they're the ones to beat. I.E. #1
@eddielung31 Yeah! Killed by mutant borg! Nearly cried to hear 1 of the most favourite star trek characters of mine is killed of! Captain chakotay just doesnt sound right...
@msinvincible2000 of course she was(!) so Jeri Ryan/Seven of Nine was what.... just a bit-part character??? Jeri Ryan was brought onto the show because it needed some eye-candy. Janeway was annoying. The series would've been better if she'd have died and the crew get home "for her", with Chakotay as Captain... but that's just my humble opinion
yeah Eden is black and also Voyager doesn't have that future armor anymore.. Part of Project Full Circle was that they stripped the ship of all future technology for studying and the Dept of Temporal Investigations thinking they contaminate the timeline. The only things they got back were slipstream drive and transphasic torpedoes. I think Janeway dying made for great stories.. I'm really loving all the post-Nemesis books.
I just saw Becka Valentine and Dylan Hunt. Until I watched this video, I'd almost completely forgotten about Andromeda. I'm now off to watch some eps of it. Also, Carter's awesome and SG-1 rules all!
@jmarnock those books don't effect the telivision series because acording to paramount only what is seen on tv or in the movies are 'real' so officialy janeway isn't dead, which personaly i am VERY thankfull for, i'm probably an awful trekkie for saying this but janeway is my favorite captian and to me the best, to me its not a question of kirk or picard, rather how much are you going to hate on my for saying janeway :P
@jmarnock Wonderful series, awaiting the third book. It was sad when janeway died, but the story is very good.
Also, to dan32280, Tom is Lt. Commander, (for some reason, he really should be a commander =/) and if there was an officer the same rank as the 1st officer...meh.
@jtkirkfan2002 Perhaps a Lt. Commander, unless there is a middle between Lt. and Lt. Commander. Barclay never appeared to show the initiative to step up his position, although he has the intelligence.
After reading the novel 'Unwothy' I felt that if it were ever to be made into a series that Amanda Tapping might be goo at the character Afsarah Eden.
Nope she's An admiral it shows in the star trek movies
mikedraven26 6 hours ago
The cast is all wrong. Starfleet would likely have never even re-launched the USS Voyager. It would have been dissected and studied. If they did, I seriously doubt the same crew would have been stationed aboard. Janeway becomes an admiral somehow after they return anyway, as evidenced by "Nemesis".
derkomissar100 2 weeks ago
@derkomissar100 The Voyager relaunch books talk about how Voyager, along with a few other ships, use slipstream drive to return to the Delta Quadrant deliberately, and a lot of the Voyager crew go with them, being the closest thing Starfleet has to experts on the region. I do believe a lot of the future tech (ablative armor generators, transphasic torpedoes) were pulled, though, and Starfleet does use transphasic torpedoes during an invasion by the Borg, so take that for what you will.
kantlavar 1 week ago
I love Stargate, I love Andromeda and I love Star Trek TNG/VOY. So I love this video. :D
Have a nice day. :]
7514Shades 3 weeks ago
The more I think of it the more I like the Ideas of Kevin Sobo and Lisa Ryder. Also Amanda Tapping is a great idea. Last start emailing paramount folks. Time for a new Star Trek Series!!!!!
Mutts2020 4 weeks ago
bad
LakakuOo 1 month ago
i suggest spelling "adventures" correctly
MSKproductions123456 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
For a good laugh try " The Star Trek Bible " parody thesis, read by scholar Robert M. Price on ' The Bible Geek ', 18th September. Are some Bible verses actually reporting sightings of UFO ? Did humans travel here from another galaxy ? Was Jesus a spaceman ? Was the sighting of Jesus going up in the sky [Acts 1v9] actually him being teleported ? Or just dreamed up ? Were the living dead people seen in Jerusalem [Matt 27v53] actually imperial guards beamed down to save Jesus? Or just fiction ?
zytigon 1 month ago
Oh and no offense to Sorbo, but I don't think he could pull off Cambridge. But Lisa Ryder would make a good Nancy Conlon. :)
asteadham 1 month ago
One little problem: Afsarah Eden is Black (or at the least, very dark-skinned), according to the novels Full Circle and Unworthy.
asteadham 1 month ago
Amanda Tapping would do it, she'll do anything. She's the Nicholas Cage of Sci-fi TV. But, then you lost me at Kevin Sorbo.
satyrquaze 1 month ago
nice you managed to add Dylan and Becca from Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda to the mix
woodclear5606 1 month ago
Actually, Word of God has it that Hugh Laurie was the author's pick to play Counselor Cambridge.
kantlavar 1 month ago
where is seven.
proud2bbritish2 1 month ago
Captain Chakotay = Yes, Fleet Captains don't exist any longer, Commodore Eden (name change maybe), First officer Paris = No, B'lana Tores = No (where's the kid), Lt. Com Barcley atleast (who's the chief engineer though?), Lisa Ryder (hard blonde one too many), Sorbo = councillor (a bit gay = No), Lt. Aneka Hansen (7 of 9 no more), Lt. Kim = Yes, Dr Richard Zimmerman (good fitting name and rank of Lt. Com) = Yes! Otherwise I'd watch it lol...
2490debrick 1 month ago
Come on Lt. Commander Barcley at least. Reg deserves it.
teachj95 1 month ago
Huge cast. Did anyone noticed that Barcley even when leading the pathfinder project keeps Lt.?
He is commander in the shows finale "Endgame".
ChicoTorera 1 month ago
@ChicoTorera Might be his mental health that keeps his rank held back look at Tuvok 120+ but still only a commander in the Titan books!
2490debrick 1 month ago
@2490debrick Tuvok resigned Federation in 2298 and rejoined 51 years later. Thats why he is still a commander there.
ChicoTorera 1 month ago
You mean 53 years lol but you are right that would be a hindrance! Nether-the-less a hypocondriac officer with phobia's and addictions is going to be a bad leader even if he does go through the ranks an engineer not that of command!
2490debrick 1 month ago
nice
toshalaska 2 months ago
Janeway was one of a few even 7 of 9 and Kess! :) to name a few
darian1968 2 months ago
Carter's first line: Oh, so that is the famous "Voyager"
eddielung31 2 months ago
Harry finally earn his rank, good
eddielung31 2 months ago
Hercules as a counselor?! ha ha ha ha you make me laugh!
lcromy 2 months ago
It would not the same without Janeway it's like bringing back star trek enterprise but without tucker. It's just not possible !
startrekker99 2 months ago
Good attempt. It jumps around a bit at the end, but a great attempt nonetheless.
:)
Top7Hat 2 months ago
0:31
This is Samantha Carter from Stargate (Atlantis).
You can see it in the background.
MaexxDesign 2 months ago
u gave harry kim a promotion lol. never thought he'd make it pass ensign lol
norrock1 2 months ago
One thing i would change is by the end of voyager 7 of 9 had mostly reclaimed her humanity so by the time this show would begin i believe she would be going by Annika Hanson not 7 of 9.
dmaleod66 2 months ago
I would LOVE to see Lisa Ryder in a Star Trek series. Great actress. She was great on Forever Knight!
enterprise160 3 months ago
I watched star trek in the wrong order. I started with ENTERPRISE, then Watched VOYAGER, Im Stil working on Next Generation
samman190 3 months ago
horray Harry got above Ensign lol
AAS0009 3 months ago
Harry never gets promoted because everyone hates him. Don't believe me, look how often he was the surviving redshirt, for whom death would be too honourable.
Janeway never gets killed because the Reaper is too damn scared. To kill Janeway would prevent her from having another cup of coffee, we all know what happens to people/sentient nebulae/interstellar empires/Borg who come between her and coffee.
randomface54 3 months ago
One word: shit
iAmNotAnAnus 3 months ago
WTF??? Harry still can not get a promotion?
WesOrion 3 months ago
@WesOrion
I was thinking the same thing! Starfleet does not like Asians!
davyman2000 3 months ago
IMHO I don't like it. It's too crudely done and the music doesn't keep with some of the footage used. But it is a very good effort and given time, you could make a truly spectacular intro.
BMWM3GTRLOVER 3 months ago
Not bad but I think harry should have a higher rank being that he never got promoted in the voyager series. Mabt lt. Commander
Dan32280 3 months ago
Captains never die, They come back next season
winnerkid1 4 months ago
No offence intended to other sci-fi fans but please stop mixing "lesser" shows with trek, it was and is the original and best by far sci-fi universe.
TheCharlie359 4 months ago
@TheCharlie359 No offence taken - I am trying consider myself as a "neutral" - but even so, I have to disagree with you on your last point - (yes, I am also against mixing of different universes.) - but objectively, there is Star Wars as well. And no matter how much you maybe don't like it, with all its various worlds, cultures, planets, races and mythologies, one can only hardly claim Star Trek as the best. No offence.
SirGalahadCtny 4 months ago
@SirGalahadCtny Well, in the end...it comes down to two things. What you personally like, and what popularity/influence a show had on the public and the marketplace. In this regard, ST and SW are on top...with 40 plus years running for Trek, and 30 odd years for Star Wars. A person has a right to like/dislike what they want. (I.E. I don't care for McDonalds because of health/food issues), but I can hardly say they aren't the best at what they do. The market says they're the ones to beat. I.E. #1
Luvcreole 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SirGalahadCtny Well, in the end...it comes down to two things. What you personally like, and what popularity/influence a show had on the public and the marketplace. In this regard, ST and SW are on top...with 40 plus years running for Trek, and 30 odd years for Star Wars. A person has a right to like/dislike what they want. (I.E. I don't care for McDonalds because of health/food issues), but I can hardly say they aren't the best at what they do. The market says they're the ones to beat. I.E. #1
Luvcreole 4 months ago
Janeway dies? The person who wrote that should be the one to die! Janeway was the reason many watched Voyager
msinvincible2000 5 months ago 19
@msinvincible2000 Very true, but Seven of Nine's skintight outfits weren't exactly a detractor, either...:D
ijnfleetadmiral 5 months ago
@msinvincible2000
In the books.........that is.
Usul573 4 months ago
@msinvincible2000, It was the ONLY reason i did!!!
TheCharlie359 4 months ago
@msinvincible2000 don't worry. Janeway's death is not canonical i.e. not true to the Star Trek timeline
BMWM3GTRLOVER 3 months ago
@msinvincible2000
Janeway doesn't die within Voyager itself unless you count a weird temporal thing.
But Janeway is promoted after return and makes a cameo in Star Trek Nemesis.
horusrage 2 months ago
@horusrage I know that. I just don't agree with this novel in which Janeway dies :)
msinvincible2000 2 months ago
@msinvincible2000 fair enough :)
horusrage 2 months ago
@msinvincible2000 That and Seven.
hammerman6842 2 months ago
@msinvincible2000 Janeway is then Admiral Janeway and is working on a desk job at Starfleet HQ
eddielung31 2 months ago 3
@eddielung31 Yeah! Killed by mutant borg! Nearly cried to hear 1 of the most favourite star trek characters of mine is killed of! Captain chakotay just doesnt sound right...
Startrekkevster 1 week ago
@msinvincible2000 She was the reason I avoided the series. :)
CatherineB1988 3 weeks ago
@msinvincible2000 of course she was(!) so Jeri Ryan/Seven of Nine was what.... just a bit-part character??? Jeri Ryan was brought onto the show because it needed some eye-candy. Janeway was annoying. The series would've been better if she'd have died and the crew get home "for her", with Chakotay as Captain... but that's just my humble opinion
fraze1976 2 weeks ago
@msinvincible2000 Seven of Nine had me at hello......sorry :(
Spacegoat92 6 days ago
Isn't tom Paris a full commander in the book? Because he is the first officer, no?
gianderosa1990 5 months ago
yeah Eden is black and also Voyager doesn't have that future armor anymore.. Part of Project Full Circle was that they stripped the ship of all future technology for studying and the Dept of Temporal Investigations thinking they contaminate the timeline. The only things they got back were slipstream drive and transphasic torpedoes. I think Janeway dying made for great stories.. I'm really loving all the post-Nemesis books.
Castrofate 5 months ago
'Bout damn time Harry got promoted.
ExanRev 5 months ago
I just saw Becka Valentine and Dylan Hunt. Until I watched this video, I'd almost completely forgotten about Andromeda. I'm now off to watch some eps of it. Also, Carter's awesome and SG-1 rules all!
valiare1947 6 months ago
In the book Captain Eden is black -_- LOL.
drevolutionary1 7 months ago
nice except the music, i would change it because it doesn't fit the video
mmarko001s 7 months ago
Where's Janeway?
MelodyStark 11 months ago
@MelodyStark
Janeway dies in the TNG book Before Dishonor
jmarnock 10 months ago 2
@jmarnock those books don't effect the telivision series because acording to paramount only what is seen on tv or in the movies are 'real' so officialy janeway isn't dead, which personaly i am VERY thankfull for, i'm probably an awful trekkie for saying this but janeway is my favorite captian and to me the best, to me its not a question of kirk or picard, rather how much are you going to hate on my for saying janeway :P
trueme0406 6 months ago
@trueme0406 i loved janeway the most too :D
miloootic 6 months ago
@trueme0406 Your not the onley one.
jdaku67 5 months ago
@jmarnock I don't get why Janeway got killed off like that. For me, VOY ended with "Endgame."
Frost3784 5 months ago
@jmarnock Janeway never dies. Janeway kills.
KevServo 4 months ago
@jmarnock Wonderful series, awaiting the third book. It was sad when janeway died, but the story is very good.
Also, to dan32280, Tom is Lt. Commander, (for some reason, he really should be a commander =/) and if there was an officer the same rank as the 1st officer...meh.
LEGOALEX97 3 months ago
@jmarnock no janeway doesnt die >:/ she was a good captain
UnitedEmoImperium 2 months ago
@jmarnock How does she manage to go back in time and get Voyager home if she dies before the future parts of VOY:End Game?
Telionis1 4 days ago
@jmarnock She does? I don't remember that...or maybe wrong book im remembering.
miack84 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and i thought of Cambrigde as Hugh Laurie in House, surly Brit lol
sherbertpi9 11 months ago
and i thoght of Cambrige as Hugh Laurie in House, surly Brit lol
sherbertpi9 11 months ago
maybe I've missed something, but I always thought Eden was black, I pictured Agent Hightower from the Mentalist
sherbertpi9 11 months ago
I like it for the most part. I would watch the series, but I am curious as to how Kevin Sorbo would make a ship's counselor.
rarobins17 1 year ago
All those years in Starfleet, figuring out how to contact Voyager and Barclay is still just a lieutenant? He'll never make captain, but come on.
jtkirkfan2002 1 year ago
@jtkirkfan2002 Perhaps a Lt. Commander, unless there is a middle between Lt. and Lt. Commander. Barclay never appeared to show the initiative to step up his position, although he has the intelligence.
rarobins17 1 year ago
the only problem is these actors are just about in the old fokes home.
ChildePC 1 year ago
really cool
why a actor from SG-1?
rbrtpongo 2 years ago
After reading the novel 'Unwothy' I felt that if it were ever to be made into a series that Amanda Tapping might be goo at the character Afsarah Eden.
jmarnock 2 years ago
@jmarnock She's busy with "Sanctuary."
Frost3784 5 months ago
great job :)
dtiner2005 2 years ago
Nice. I like it.
movieman33843 2 years ago