Debate: Islam or Atheism? With Hamza Andreas Tzortzis & the president of American Atheists

[HazardExtreme]

PROUD TO BE A MUSLIM !

[Safmohibi]

just WONDERFULLY, an AMAZING VID...jazzakallah khair 4 the upload

[MrAbadi0]

PLEASE need subtitles the rest of the debate

[navynmr]

Brother Hamza is an asset to the ummah. Mashallah. May Allah SWT increase him and us too.

[Ogou123]

What a great opening statement by Mr.Hamza Tzortzis.

[juujuubie]

I have a questions which i really been dying to find out till now. Will atheist really continue to be atheist even after they have reached to a very very old age, maybe like 90 or 100 years old, and with many terminal illness and sickness too, just waiting for probably another 1 or 2 more years to die? Bottom line is, i really would love to hear some words from a real self confessed 90 or 100 years old atheist here in youtube, IF there really is one!

[MyPortsmouth]

PROUD TO BE MUSLIMS

[HDuranii10]

JazakAllah khairrr brother Hamzaaa!!! you are an amazing speaker mashAllah and have a great knowledge of islam! May Allah swt reward you for your efforts and dawah!!!

[Rascaduanok]

So is this guy really the next Ahmed Deedat?

[chaosbringer127]

A true muslim would not get angry even in a debate. Hamza demonstrated that trueness to Islam. A true humanist would understand the reason people flock to religion and not show hostility towards it. the president of AA displayed that. When people who are true to their cause communicate, true connections and understanding can be formed. Anything else is just hatred (i.e people using atheism as a banner to hate religious folk, likewise for Islam).

[Belthernel]

I love the ending at 2:22:35!

I believe both of them are nice guys and love an ethical approach of life as we generally know it.

This is a pretty mature debate. Not like the one full of hatred and in complete disregard of ethical values.

[MrBrational]

What is this debate about exactly?

[krazyville]

The problem is that Dr. Ed Buckner hasn't read the Qur'an and doesn't know much about it.

[StilKickinKnowledge]

Allahu Akbar, truth has come, falsehood has perished.

[MrGrandDragon]

I was fascinated when I found out how the Human body copes with diseases without me even knowing, on a daily basis.

I cried. How complex and amazing living organisms are.

Yes I believe in god, the only author of such complexity.

[nasreen51]

Poor guy, if i was him i would faint or jump out of the window. humza buried him!! HAHAHAHAHAHAH, funny debate

[afglionheart]

hahahahaha islam!!!!! mashallah what a debate i wanna see hamza debating dawkins i hope dawkins would agree n accept debating hamza in public may allah guide us all..

[JabrilAbdullah]

Masha'Allah! Brother Hamza did a wonderful job in this debate. Very intelligent.

Salam.

[cby786]

mashallah brother destroyed it. smacked the argument.

[nobazter]

my muslim brother won this... mashallah really educated

People usually become atheist questioning trajedies that occur in their lives or other peoples lives..

[minisci15]

Shout out to Erick for linking me the vid. Finally got to use my mate's computer again and watch it haha.

While I tended to side with the arguments of Dr. Ed, the way in which Hamza presented his information was much better. I agree with AmazinMaz1 in wanting to see a more prolific speaker such as Richard Dawkins or someone who actually read the Koran for the sake of a better back and forth debate.

[khalilrabee]

did the first questioner start laughing at 1:40? :)) exactly at that point i started laughing too..."we dont know but dont go on calling it god"...atheists think that god is simply a name and not a concept...

[EarthisnotFlat]

I am infidel

أنا كافر

[DanGRtheMan]

Hamza Andreas Tzortzis also looks like an arab and has a british muslim accent. noone can deny that, so why does he says he's greek when any arab can see he is an arab?

[itaqullah]

@DanGRtheMan because he is a Greek convert to Islam. Do you know how ignorant you sound?

[DanGRtheMan]

@itaqullah that doesn't make sense. how can being a greek convert to islam make you look like an arab? so if i become a buddhist, i suddenly will look like a tibetian?

[itaqullah]

@DanGRtheMan Many if not most Greeks have darker/tanned skin. Now that he has a beard, he looks more "middle eastern". *facepalm*

[QuranTafseer]

@DanGRtheMan Lol? Come on don't be so narrow minded, would somone lie about their heritage on a public Plat form. As though being Greek is somone how superior of being English, Arab, African.. In Islam there is no such thing as nationalism ALL men Are created EQUAL they only differ in regards to Piety and Good deeds!

[DanGRtheMan]

@QuranTafseer the platform isnt that public. and dont you think its too much of a coincidence that he looks pakistani arab and has a british muslim accent? (i know because i have british asian friends) ive debated this on another video. my argument is he uses the idea that he is a converted greek man to avoid his opponent suggesting he was born into islam and not evangelised into it. remember, nearly all arabs are muslim. he must have been brought up with muslims anyway to explain his accent.

[itaqullah]

@DanGRtheMan oh my.... there's a "british muslim accent" now? *facepalm*

[oglow100]

@DanGRtheMan having a beard doesn't always mean an arab you know... greeks do happen to look similar to arabs btw...

[Darknss2Light]

@DanGRtheMan haha, thats soo ignorant, a little effort is needed to realise that his name is Andreas Tzortzis a greek name, the only muslim bit is his 1st name Hamza, which he included after he became a muslim.

[DanGRtheMan]

Hamza Andreas Tzortzis is very argumentative and his debating style is very abrasive and self opinionated

[xChillDude]

This debate truly opened my eyes, not only on Islam, but on knowledge and perspective. Unfortunately I'm not as articulate as Hamza, but throughout the debate I couldn't help but feel and know what Hamza spoke was the truth. It rang true for me all the way through, and starting today I'm going to work on increasing my knowledge of epistemology, ontology, theology, command of languages, and the ability to discern truth from fiction and create rational criteria for them.

assalamualaikum

[Ezeibe7]

if Atheists do not belive in anything how do us as belivers belive them.

meaning generally like judges, government, lawyers, people (belivers),

the1st amendment right, and god.

[felisleo101]

@Ezeibe7

That is the most utterly vapid, dishonest statement I have ever read. Where does it ever say that "atheists do not believe in anything"?

[a2ssm]

Honestly how can Ed Buckner be given the title of a Doctor?

1. He cannot talk properly.

2. He cannot even devise a rationale argument

3. He believes that something can come from nothing

4. He cannot understand that cause refers to something that has an existance

5. The concept of God is that He did not come into existance

6. Had there been a cause for God we would not be here

I think he's afraid of giving up the mistress :-) Any longer and the Doctor would have fainted.

[Tote21]

This particular doctor will eventually recognize his universal short-coming within humanity.

[izaccy]

Ed Buckner I agree as an atheist made so weak points, that i couldnt even listen to him, however I listen to all what Hamza said.

I was expecting him to talk about the evolution, the false claims in these books

how they first claimed that the earth was evolving around the sun,

and not the opposite, How they claimed that there is only one sun

and one moon,

which is not true, there is many more, and how their are many more universe,

as we develop we see more pics from the space.

[Lunarek]

you can hear a lot of confusion in Ed Buckner's voice, he sound so disturbed by his theories as well.

[os75]

dr buckner is a weak debater hamza just ran circles around him with facts and presenting evidence all dr buckner did was saying god doesnt exist and thats that..come on now hes the president of the atheist society in the US???..weak rebuttals from dr buckner. as hamza said wishy washy comments from dr buckner..again another debate won by a muslim

[ferdowsi88]

SUBHAN'ALLAH

Brother Hamaza Andreas Mash'Allah, you have surpassed the computer with your remarks, its logical, rational reasoning, Always to the point-distinguishes between which may seem like a fine thread epistemology and ontology but they are not-He clearly deducts his points to a logical coherent cogent conclusion making it understandable, comprehendable to the wise and the curious-

What a rare gift- Hamaza your are a Bonanza to the muslims & non-muslims

peace and blessing be unto you..

[radhiya2006]

to atheist... u just another "Goyim" that deceive by zionist propaganda.....

[bass109]

islam believes in jesus christ! and muhammed was a righteous man of god! the prophets love is the only way. Live long and happy!

[manurocks4ever]

nice debate and good perspectives offered by both sides

[rezsul]

To the atheist.. there was a room closed for a number of years suddenly it explored

and wow you got a number of update computers, update of phones and everything in the room were extra-ordinary.

[Zapata85]

@rezsul Um... what? I have no idea what you're trying to say. Kindly try again.

[afglionheart]

2- cuz ur compairing him with his creation. there r typical questions like this for ex.. can allah creat a stone wich no one including himself can not move these r questions wich ignorants have but islam answers that very clearly unfortunately even muslims nowasays have question like this pls do ur research u will find islam answer these questions very clearly..?? well here is a good answer.. /watch?v=rRT_qNN7Pvw

[schumiisking]

@afglionheart

please show me some decent evidence for god then i'll convert. ok?

[dbrifkani28]

@schumiisking Exactly what kind of "evidence" would convince you?...

[afglionheart]

the problem with ed buckner is that he is compairing the creator with his creation just because he sees allahs creation that had a beggening that doesnt mean allah himself need to have a beggening.. in islam we belive that allah is al mighty he is enernal he had no beggening nor he has an end.. and that there is nothing compair to him(NOTHING) so you can not compair his creation with him n therefor say since universe must have a creator then that creator must have his creator doesnt make sens-

[almao2006]

Only Islam can stand against the Atheism

Christianityy produce Million of Atheist in the World

THe Brother Hamza can demantel all those Atheist like Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens

Allahu Akbar

[afglionheart]

hamza destroooooooooooooyed this guy so bad poor guy was so confused anyways may allah guide us all...

[KARAMUSLIMAN]

@aydemirbeslenay we can know thru revlation; that's exactly the issue, check out and find out if Islam (submision to God) is what God wants, that's what it teaches. Qur'an tells u dat if it wasn't from Him you'd find contradictions (4:82), and it challenges humans to produce a work like he qur'an (17:88,2:23,10:37,11:13,52:33)­, etc. it criticizes tose wo just folow ancestors' way(2:170). God orders u to use ur intelect to find out the truth, n it challenges to prove that Quran is not from Him.

[got2sho]

ALLAHHUAKBAR..advise to all critics. MUSLIM loves to see anybody tries to proof ALQURAN is wrong. so educate yourself on ALQURAN. because if you cant, that gives great satisfactory to MUSLIM and increase their IMAN (faith).

[aydemirbeslenay]

could some body be as so kind as to answer my question with an intelligent answer

one question that gets me is, if God is so powerful, and so different from human beings, how can we inferior human beings possibly work out and follow what the superior God wants from us ? when according to Islam we are so unlike, by following Islam; arnt we contradicting ourselves by assuming this is what Allah the greatest wants ?

[AmazinMaz1]

@aydemirbeslenay Because He sent the Quran, mercy upon human beings. In the Quran it says to follow what is said in it(gods words).

[adnanabbas14]

@aydemirbeslenay God doesnt really want anything... we need God.. so with his mercy to humankind he sent down prophets and Holy Books such as the Holy Qur'an which btw has no contradictions :)

[afglionheart]

subhanallah amazing ho people still dont belive in allah..

[lightingrings]

so if something cant come from nothing, where did god come from ?

[M45H11]

@lightingrings

To claim that something "comes" from nothing, requeires that something to have a begining. And since God has no begining and being the Only uncaused being that is the cause of the universe, shows that he was always there.

[lazurm]

@lightingrings Something can come from nothing. It's called a Quantum Fluxuation.

[agreeableviews816]

@lightingrings Read the Qur'an and find out.

[HIMAZZZ1991]

@lightingrin a typical ques. from a typical atheist....see,thats the problem with non muslims in general.they know nothin about islam or how it works or whats its principals,they just attack(no offense).look,i'll give other quest. so that u can offend muslims with:"can god do anything? can god die? is he eternal? he cant die? i thought he could do anything? can god make a very big rock that he wouldnt be able 2 carry it?"......want some more? i'll pm the answers 2 u(in a brief way though)

[brotheryusuf1]

@lightingrings God didnt need to be created, he is too powerful.

[COWBOY112233]

@lightingrings (1/2) that's an irrational question, because you're confusing the attributes of the creator with the attributes of creation. for instance, I made a rubber ball. who created this ball? ME but I ( who's the creator of this ball ) eat, talk, sleep, think , marry. does the ball do the same things? of course not because its ability is limited ,it's beyond its ability to do all these things.

to be continued

[COWBOY112233]

@lightingrings (2/2) So you assume that God ( the creator ) must came from something because you ( creation ) came from something, logically it’s a wrong question.

Also, Mr.Hamza has explained why the nature of this cause (which is God )that created the universe must be uncaused ( go and check the video again from 15:00 to 16:00 )

My friend I advise you to watch the video again.

Peace! :)

[adnanabbas14]

@lightingrings DID YOU ACTUALLY LISTEN TO WHAT HAMZA RESPONDED TO THIS ED GUY?

SRRY FOR THE CAPS.. :P

[balaalalaslk]

@lightingrings or i have a question for you

Your brother gave birth to a child. Is it a boy or a girl?

the question is illogical because a man can't give birth to a child.

God. Where did he come from?

its illogical because by definition God doesn't have a creator or doesn't come from anywhere.

[albanianwizard]

@lightingrings

GOD have HIS characteristics , and among them is that HE IS NOT LIKE THE CREATION, and the Creation have a beginning and have an end.

Also, before trying to understand the Nature of GOD, I will suggest you trying to understand your nature, and your soul (if you can).

[kandousha]

@lightingrings Let me ask you this if you are presented with a strange machine that has never ever been seen before and I ask you who is the first person I would go to so that I would learn how this machine works what would you say?

[SuperSpiritedaway]

@lightingrings good question.... god only knows...

[ShadowSoundsUK]

@lightingrings This statement is fair enough until you consider the idea of God. As Muslims we believe God created everything. We cannot therefore bind the Creator to the limits of his creation. So we would say God created mass, therefore we cannot constrict God by suggesting he has mass. Similarly God created time, therefore we can not assign time to God, and therefore there is no linear sequence of events - to God there is no before and after, therefore no need for a source.

[QuranTafseer]

@lightingrings His 1st position was that God is the uncreated Cause! i.e. the starting point before there was nothing otherwise there is no point debating, the way i see it look at the world look at your phone, if you can believe that a phone can evolve from sand and rock on its own over millions of years then stick to athiesm lol and a phone compared to the universe in insignificant

[Xgya2000]

@QuranTafseer

Just because you can't figure how it can happen, you assume that a magic man did it.

If we never saw a star form by itself, and many other stars in various stages of formation, we might assume that they were created. But we did see a stellar system form. So we know it happens by itself without anyone helping.

Science has proven that amino acids will form by themselves in an environment similar to the early earth.

[soyabmd]

@Xgya2000 but the amino acid does not have the ability to create a protein molecule.creation of protein in a cell is a very complex method and need data to contract protein with amino acid.data is carried in DNA.Now tell where the data came from and don't say it happened by chance like theory of big bang and neo Darwinism

[loonietoonie0123]

@lightingrings hamza gave a reply to that. God is eternal no beginning no end. If God needed to be created by God #2 and God #2 needed to be created by God #3 who needed to be created by God#4 and so on for infinity then nothing would ever be created, yet you and I will both agree that creation exists.

[SIMPLEMAIL2004]

Atheists are emotional people rather than rationalists, they don't have valid explanations, life purpose, and moral basis. Yet they claim that they adopt scientific approach to explain life. They forgot that science is very limited and can't give us all the answers. They forgot half of the reality of the human existence which is the spiritual aspect of us. Allah said in Surah the Romans "they know the surface of things".

[lazurm]

@SIMPLEMAIL2004 Everyone is emotional. Atheists, that is Secular Humanists, definitely have purposes usually having to do with benefiting life on this planet based on reason and fairness and the Bill of Rights. Science may not have all the answers but it has a great track record for improving life, more than any other discipline yet. I can list thousands of benefits that science wrought, but not nearly as many for other paths.

[ConsideringPhlebas]

@SIMPLEMAIL2004

I'm an atheist, and I'm very happy to engage in rational debate with Muslims about Islam.

And perhaps you're not familiar with the many philosophies of secular ethics, deontological, consequential, utilitarian, etc.?

[b0yk0]

I am atheist myself but I think Ed Buckner is very poor debater. Hamza has better attitude to win a debate, although his side is completely ridiculously wrong.

[shq007pk]

@b0yk0

at least you did agree on one point. may we all be guided.

[HIMAZZZ1991]

@b0yk0 what do u think is wrong with hamza's arguments?

[KARAMUSLIMAN]

@amazinmaz1 I also want to, but the Shaytan Dawkins says he doesn't want to debate -of course he debates with teenagers and some priests-. I even believe Harun Yahya proposed him to debate and he refused because "he vowed not to debate and he'll keep his word". So i don't think we'll have the pleasure to see it...

[AmazinMaz1]

I really really want to see a debate between Richard Dawkins and Hamza Andreas Tzortzis.

[shq007pk]

@AmazinMaz1

that would be worgth a watch for sure!

[girocraz]

@AmazinMaz1 Richard Dawkins is too scared to debate most of the theists, of his lack of philosophical knowlodge.

[QuranTafseer]

@AmazinMaz1 Dawkins said he doesn't debate debaters " his lame excuse! "

[twan903]

This video disgusts me. Buckner is more informed about how the universe truly exists but gave "wishy washy" generalized arguments. Hamza is a much more talented and aggressive speaker. However he made not one truly convincing argument. Continuously pointing out that Buckner hadn't read the Quran didn't prove anything to me.

[DroppinTruth]

@twan903

ahahahahahaha get out of here

[QuranTafseer]

Please add captions and subtitles please jazakallah

[khalifahklothing]

@QuranTafseer Any volunteers?

[4evertruthful]

@khalifahklothing I want to reupload this video of yours.

[HaligonianType1]

@khalifahklothing LOL at any volunteers. Great video... SubhannAllah... May Allah (swt) reward ahki Hamza for his amazing dawah.

[ArabianRuLeS]

@khalifahklothing

I will volunteer in sha Allah but give me sometime please :)

[QuranTafseer]

@QuranTafseer you can add captions automatically on youtube by clicking on captions and the clikc on download captions in english, if they are not accurate, i will volunteer lol, but it might take me a week or so to complete the video

[aijaz777]

This debate was interesting but not necessarily productive. Mr. Buckner made compelling points from an athiest's stand point. Br. Hamza has an entertaining and assertive style of debating but him using science to prove God exists does not make sense just like you cannot prove heaven exists using Science or logic. Religion is faith based... if you believe in God great if you are an athiest you cannot be convinced.

[QuranTafseer]

@QuranTafseer I done half well almost a quater and it sadly got deleted, inshallah during the holidays, its been forever but inshallah i still intend to get it done.

[SirJasperFitzwilliam]

I may not be Muslim...but I am British...and this guy makes me feel proud to be British.....:D

[ok748]

Atheist....you waste time wid them...Quran has already said that in intelligence they are even below animals...

[mohammedsalmanbutt]

Poor Hamza must have felt so annoyed when Ed Buckner started speaking, I can imagine him screaming in his head, "Did you not listen to a single word I said?!?!!"

[ok748]

hamza a great scholar among all converters whom i have heard on internet.

[nejad1982]

If you can`t convice them counfuse them Hamza

"All truth passes

through three

stages. First, it is

ridiculed, second it is

violently opposed, and

third, it is accepted as

self-evident."

[denoum]

we muslims don't believe that god causes harm and catastrophy to happen because he likes or enjoys it.we believe that god does that to test us and see how faithful to our religion we are.there could be harm and evil but there is also good and happiness.we shouldn't look at the empty half of the glass only,we should look at the the filled half of the glass too.god said that he tests us with hardships in the quran.

[LordIchwan]

HAHAHA THIS ATHEIST GUY IS SO PATHETIC... HAHHA PURE IGNORANTS

[inaveneanar]

Dr. Ed Buckner got owned in this debate. His arguments are WEAK. If I were an atheist, I'd be ashamed that he is my leader.

[afglionheart]

from holy quran chapter 17 verse 81. And say: "Truth has (now) arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish."

[Fullmetalsnake54]

This video thought me Atheism is really hopeless and this guy is stubborn. He couldn't disprove the prophet's life and he didn't know much about Islam. He lost.

[OwnsWar]

Great debate. There were 2 other debates during this event, does anyone know when they'll be online, or if they already are?

Thx

[asjadjawed]

Very nice debate.. MashaAllah..

Atheist is someone who does not believe in God. So the whole debate was centered around the first argument...

However there is a saying "Absence of proof is not proof of Absence" Dr. Ed should deconstruct Hamza's first argument to prove him wrong... and show he was right...

Which he was unable to do or for that matter the entire philosophical history of mankind...

[Halludba86]

ALLAH HU AKABR!!! truth has come and falsehood has vanished

[rangga1991]

i'm a muslim and Hamza Tzortis had really good views to both sides of Islam vs Atheism but I'd wish That buckler guy knew about Islam, the Qu'ran before attending a Philisophical Debate about Islam coz that would of been awesome to watch. Assalamuakum

[Citrusontheuke]

Ed did a horrible job here. Humza did a very good job, even if I don't agree.

In response to Humza's opening remarks

'No such thing as infinity' - Somehow doesn't apply to his god. But infinites do exist, what's the last number of Pi?

'Argument from document' - It doesn't work because you can just compare it to any other god or religion. How much textual evidence would I have to show you to prove that Quetzalcoatl existed?

[HIMAZZZ1991]

@Citrusontheuke no no,u got it wrong(concerning the infinity issue).i guess ur an atheist,right? thats a misconception almost all non muslims believe in general.u see,we believe that ALLAH is an entity outside the rules,bounderies,logical limitations of our world.he created it with its rules 2 govern it,he's not 2 b dragged in2 its conceptions n regulations n we shouldnt bound such "unlimited,unbound" entity 2 his limited laws that he himself created..(thats as brief it can get)i hope i helped u

[reedtopcoder]

what if I say that there cannot be a last number of Pi because the lack of our base 10 numbering system to exactly reflect the number of Pi. What if I have a new Pi based number system namely 1Pi 2Pi 3Pi.. so that the last number of Pi would be Pi itself ?Take a look of the size of your monitor, what if we count the length in cm,mm, micro,nano,..(infinte), now does that means the monitor have infinite size ?

What I took from his word is that we live in 'finite world' that god has created

[alcapon2]

Dr. Buckner is saying that he doesn't have to read all books of all religions to make the conclusion he's made and on that basis he hasn't ead the Quran. Well, with all due respect but a religion that currently has 1.5 billion followers deserves to be read and studied. That should be the logic of an intellectual person.

[yazir123]

i think we can rightly say dat hamza jus owned ed and wiped da floor wif him

[iloveallah22]

ALLAHU AKBAR

الله اكبر

[hira12jan]

this other guy is telling muslims to be openminded and read other books and he himself is like...i dont know much about quran..:S

[afghound58]

Mashallah,, eventhough Hamza brother is young enough to be his son but he made Dr Ed B uckner like a baby, with his knowledge of truth,, subhanullah..

Truth always wins and this debate was an example..

[zeshawnable]

Quran really gives a guideline to what is permissible in keeping slaves, treating them, and never says you should take them. This

[MrTaloul]

death to the athiesm ideology that promotes injustice and homosexuals and wars across the world from japan to vietnam to Iraq to Afghanistan to using blacks as slaves to get ahead to creating 9/11 for global dominance of the oil and gas supplies in the world

[edlgotbanged]

The atheist the Christians and Jews always get owned 

[saladinswarrior]

Interesting debate!MashaAllah.

I hope to see more Hamza Tzortzis videos in the future

[abdullah0530]

كنت أتمنى لو أن هذه المحاضرة مترجمة إلى اللغة العربية :)

[ybasman99]

@abdullah0530 this is an invitation to brothers and sisters that can command translation and video editing to add Arabic subtitle to this video, Arab world really need to learn about this great debate, maybe our brother who uploaded this video in the first place can help in this issue , since uploading such large file ( after translation and the Arabic subtitle addition ) is not usual on youtube .

[jonpiasente]

It seems the only atheists debating Islam have not done any homework on it..

Intellectual arrogance = fail. Every time.

[evilarm1982]

Hamza's really not listening to Buckner, he totally avoided his question on reading the Mormon bible which shows that he really hasn't.

[itaqullah]

@evilarm1982 He did not avoid it, he said that he has read it.

[ybasman99]

@evilarm1982 i think the opposite is true , Dr. buckner didn't do his home work and read the Quoran ... what did he expect in a debate between Islam and Atheism ??? to talk about chocolate for instance ??? Atheists are bathetic .

[MahyarAkbar]

assalam alaikum, hamza is a smart brother, i would love to meet him... inshallah

[TurkishMujahid]

Because if we did not know evil we could not differentiate from good and yes the tsunami was very devastating but out of that tsunami there came so much good the entire world was set in to action every country held benefits for the victims etc and besides if those people didnt die in the tsunami they would have died somewhere else in another way so basicly what the atheist is saying is that " dieying " itself is evil ..

[TurkishMujahid]

so what the atheist is basicly saying at 1:48:0 is that because Allah SWT allowed the tsunami to kill so many people that therefor He is cruel ? what kind of illogical nonsense is that that is a typical atheist response i have waited and waited for brother Hamza to say this but he never did " without evil how could we know good ? " that 1 scentence is enough to shut the atheists up , because if there was no evil there could also be no good(atleast on earth i mean not in paradise) because

[ybasman99]

@TurkishMujahid ur right .. i agree ... one of the major problems of Atheists that they don't believe in next life in the first place, which will interpreter all this confusion they have , for this, its normal to say floods are cruelty from a god if he exist, forgetting to mention that their mother nature is cruel if god doesn't exist !!

[ku8890]

He it is who hath sent His messenger with the guidance and the Religion of Truth, that He may cause it to prevail over all religion, however much the idolaters may be averse. [Quran Surah Tauba V33

[lalalovelylady]

the sound is awful! I was excited to watch this, but I can't understand a word they're saying. what a shame.

[ybasman99]

@lalalovelylady voice is good , check ur speakers , or maybe sound card, for me i used the headphone ;)

[muna044]

I would say Atheist are Just ignorant Simple

he has no knowledge of the holy quran and yet still denies religon and God that Just plain Simple ignorance and does not bother studying the Quran the torah and the Gospel hypocrisy

and i believe when your Ignorant your Stubborn at the same time .

[ybasman99]

really good, marvelous, thanks for posting this video

I've learned many things here , atheists are stubborn, plus , they never do the necessary homework that should be done cz this will finally reveal to them the truth that they are fighting all their lives against.

go atheists , as for the change, read Quran once ... subjectively

Thanks again, i do appreciate this video upload.

[TheMuslimahSouljette]

Alhamdulillah, may Allah preserve Hamza. 'Ameen!!

[salafipaki]

mashallah , jazakllahu khayran

[indiebum]

I really liked this debate, there should be more like this as there aren't many Muslim speakers who tackle Atheists using western philosophy and ideas as well as Islamic ones. MashaAllah

[dhyleck]

MasAllah JazakAllah Khair ! this video was taken down. Good to see that it has been put up again.

[TRUTHvsDECEPTION]

Ash haduo Allah Illa ha Illal lah Wa ash haduo anna Muhammadann habduo wa rasool

[sharafudin2]

LA ILLAHLA ILLAHLA ISLAM IS PEACE ISLAM IS TRUTH ISLAM IS THE FINAL.

[snoiprocs16]

LA ILAHA IL ALLAH. There is No Deity worthy to be worship except Allah.

[aloha090]

LA ILLAHA ILLAHLA . 

[nokia5095007]

There is No God ! butt Allah , And Mohammad PBUH is the Last Messenger of God

[MrLovepeace2009]

MashaAllah ,None worthy of Worship except Allah ,our Creator. Muhammad is Allahs Messenger.Please Thumps up if you liked the video.It helps others to find it easily.

[aloha090]

1st! plus. LA ILLAHA ILLAHLA. Islam is the greatest relgion in the WORLD :)

[Berni0707]

@aloha090 I TOTALLY agree. It's the ONLY religion, THE TRUTH. God bless you brother.