I cry every time I watch this... It makes me so sad.. To follow the Doctor through thick and thin... Though, it's truly beautiful ^^ Fantastic song choice, clips are chosen perfectly...Rose and the Doctor were perfect together. <3 Thanks for putting this together (:
This is brilliant! I think this is the best match up of video and music on the whole of youtube! This is PERFECT. It made me cry and it made me laugh. It's simply brilliant
I watch a ton of Dr. Who fan videos and I only ever comment on the truly amazing. the ones worth my time, this video nearly made me cry, it is sweet, beautiful, and sad all at once. It captures the essence of the love story for the Doctor and Rose. Very very well done indeed.
This video is absolutely brilliant. I cry every time I watch it! One of the best videos I have seen in a long time. That part at 2:57 gets me every time. The tempo of the music speeds up perfectly. Great work, Darling. :)
This song is already enough to put me in tears all on its own (throwback to highschool angst and a heart-rending Kirk/Spock fanvid set to it), but this...
The use of color and b/w, the cuts, the *amazing* editing & manips and the specific clips you chose, the bits of dialogue that float through...oh my...
Really, really lovely. One of the best vids I've ever seen <3
I had to watch this 3 times. It's so beautiful, and it makes me wish I had a friend like the Doctor. Someone who can make me smile, hold my hand, share pains and joys, say "I love you" to. The Doctor and Rose's relationship is so strong and so deep, it's much more than a romantic relationship. This is the type of friendship that goes beyond everything and anything. We all need a friend like this ♥
I really wish David didn't go....I like Matt as the Doctor, but the expressions David pulls off are so intense and deep....like he's really had a troubled past.
O.O................E.P.I.C.!!!!!!! Ugh, SOO beautiful, and the clips are timed perfectly. Usually when dialogue is put into a video, it sounds sort of awkward but this one REALLY brought an amazing feel to it. So incredible.
that was so fantastic that I had to look up synonyms to express the awesomeness of this video. my top three are astounding, extraordinary, and overwhelming
It's back!!!!!! And now I must refine my previous comment. This is not just one of your best videos, it's the best. And not only is it your best, it's probably the best Doctor who video I have EVER seen!!!!! Every part of this video is perfection! THANK YOU!
Your video editing is so amazing I am in awe of it. This video and all the videos I have seen of yours are so wonderful! This one especially got me. Thank you for sharing it!!
What amazes me about this video is that this song usually comes across SO cheesy and cliche. Yet somehow you have managed to make it heartbreaking-ly beautiful. The way you cut the clips together is very original and I must say that the clip at 1:30 is simply stunning. I miss seeing your videos pop up on my new subscriptions! I hope you are working on a new one. I love them all.
@flightlessphoenix Thank you so very much. When I started this video, i knew I had to take my time and create a very refined and emotional piece, as it had been so overused across all fandoms. I'm so thrilled it is still being enjoyed after all this time.
i thought maybe i was moving on then this just broke me down and made me bawl my eyes out. Thanks for making me realise that you just can't move on from these two- your vids are the best!
Wow, the most brilliant fan video I have ever seen! At the beginning I had tears in my eyes, my the middle, tears were streaming down my face. I just love this so much! I've always been a huge Doctor+Rose fan, and this was amazing. When the Doctor thinks he sees Rose coming into the TARDIS but she's isn't just killed me! It's fantstic! GREAT job!!
I am seriously obsessed with watching Doctor/Rose videos so i've seen a lot, probably hundreds by now. This one is by far the best. The scenes used, the way you've ordered and edited and everything about this video is simply fantastic and i'll probably be watching it again and again. I almost never comment but i couldn't help myself, i've never found a video so well done before. Thank you :)
I don't normally comment on anything really but when I found this I was amazed. I just want to say thank you for giving this to us, this film clips and the music clips have been put together fanatastic When watching this video if you are are a Doctor Who fan of 'David Tennant and Billie Piper' I really think you will be moved. :)
This is seriously the best fan video i've ever seen. I love it so much. I cry so hard when I watch it lol ty, you're brilliant and i'm grateful for talented people such as yourself.
I absolutely love this vid, the song is perfect. i well up every time at 2:55 to 3:00, every time!!! this is perfect for the doctors love of rose. the editing is so amazing! thank you for putting this out in the world for all of us to love!!
this song reminds me that there will be peace in the united states for all people and the soldiers that are at war they want to come to there families.
AdaratheDarkSage: 0:39-0:41 is from Runaway Bride Series 3. 2:55-2:59 is also from Series 3 but this time out of Daleks in Manhattan. Glad you enjoyed it. :)
I absolutely loved it. After I saw the end to season two, I cried. It was so not fair. This video is a perfect dedication to these two. Well done. ^_^ And to all the tools out there who decide to be cruel, one thing is to be said: A life without love is terrible.
IT'S CALLED A FAN VIDEO. Idiot. No one cares about the 'TECHNICAL' crap. If you've SEEN the current show, you'd see that he shows strong feelings for Rose, even if - in your eyes - it isnt Love. People have a right to like whatever shipping they like so why bother commenting pathetic one liners on popular fan video?
toched a nerve? why would that 'touch a nerve'? seriously, you have clearly never seen the show. 'truth hurts' yeah, maybe if there was some truth in what you were saying except there wasnt so stop spamming!
yes he loves her, as a FRIEND! but hes not in love with her, time lords cant fall in love, its well known by everyone who has watched the show ecspecially the older series, why do u think he could never say he loved her until the last episode of the last series, coz hes not in love with her but his part human form cud tell her coz hes part human and has the ability to love, its very simple stuff, sorry to burst ur little bubble,
LOL that doesnt 'burst my little bubble', seriosuly, your fighting a loosing battle. You don't cross 10/Rose fans. Simple as. You can say that he didn't love her but that's just you not wanting Doctor Who to progress. Even people who have worked on the show have said that he was going to tell her he loved her (at Bad Wolf Bay the first time). Even David Tennant has said that they are a love story! Open your ignorant mind, PLEASE.
thats bullshit and u know it, look i didnt write or come up with the idea of doctor who or decide his characteristics, i just said a simple fact that time lords cant fall in love which is one of the charcteristics that they came up with, its well known
RTD could sit me down and tell me it was all "friendship" love blah, blah, blah and I would still say that they were IN love, so to me, it is an opinion. get over it.
nothing you can say is going to change anyone's mind so you are pointlessly going around vidoes and going "time lords cant love !"
why dont you just leave people to like a fandom they like? if they wanna believe that they are in love, then let them. who the hell are you to go around and challange their adoration?
omg dude HE HAD A WIFE!... AND KIDS he talks about loads of times even in the new series, an example? - Season 4 The Doctors Daughter he tells Donna how he used to have a wife AND (if youve ever watched a william hartnell episode) SUSAN is his Grandaughter and honestly dude theres never been anything in the doctor who universe where they say time lords cant love, new series or old-old seriesLeela stays on galifrey with andred because there IN LOVE-new series.. common man he was in love with Rose
haha funny how i say something and ppl get really upset about it, even tho i cud be right or wrong seeing as we dont know for sure as it was never said or never said he didnt, bit like the whole religion thing, i bet u believe in god
actually we dont know for sure, we only have hints so your wrong there unlucky son. and dont mind DW confidential plenty of things have been said on that before that isnt true and contradicting, all we know is when he was a time lord he cudnt say he loved her and when he was part human he could so facts are facts,
@atemuamadare actually im a really big atheist, and what facts are these son? point them out to me coz no one else has so far, and once again doctor who commentatories are not to be taken seriously, plenty of things have been said in those that have turned out to be false,
@atemuamadare u dont want to argue with me coz u have nothing to argue with, u havent pointed out any facts, u just resort to pathetic insults on grammar on youtube which is quite sad, and once again commentatories have proven not to be taken seriouriously as it sjust oppinions of the actors even when RTD has said stuff in it he has contradicted himself on what happens in de show, so i suggest u take a deep breath watch the shows again and come back with a better arguement, USE YOUR BRAIN
@atemuamadare no actually they are facts what i have pointed out, why was he sad? think about it u muppet, wudnt you be distraught if u lost ur best friend, ur one and only friend? wudnt u? of course u wud
ur are the biggest moron on youtube i have ever come accross, wrapped in ur own little world, learn to use ur brain
@atemuamadare thats coz they are oppinions, u believe what ur told to believe, u just take in whats in front of u and dont read between the lines ,dont think for urself, for your own good u shud learn this as it will help u in life, children just believe wats in front of them, thats why the believe in santa coz they dont think outsdie the box, sorry i didnt just ruin next christams for u did i?
There was a long standingtaboo during the classic series against any form of romance, but they never said a 'timelord cant love' (He had a grand daughter), but when RTD introduced rose, he decided to break the taboo and create a new dynamic in order to attract new fans, which worked.Evidence? She told him 'I love you', and he replied 'rose tyler...I'...I wonder how that would have ended, hmmm...
@JadesVidz u dont have to love anyone to have sex with them, plenty of gay men have kids for example, and we dont know what he was gonna say,, also atemuamadare is a bit pathetic for deleting all her comments haha how sad...
He got married (they said it plenty of times) and you do get married for love, and the whole of the staff said he was gunna say I love you, and when he finally got to say it, she kissed him, And confidential isnt 'messing about' its an in depth behind the scenes, and everyone said, 'its a love story'.
If you dont believe that, then I dont care, but stop causing arguments on a FANvid routing the couple :S
I cried through the whole thing. Great video
iminlalaland4ever 2 weeks ago
I cry every time I watch this... It makes me so sad.. To follow the Doctor through thick and thin... Though, it's truly beautiful ^^ Fantastic song choice, clips are chosen perfectly...Rose and the Doctor were perfect together. <3 Thanks for putting this together (:
15xXDFTBAXx15 2 weeks ago
Damn it. I was happy.
LittleMissAlvii10 1 month ago in playlist More videos from seduff
And now I'm sobbing.
katlynbirdie 1 month ago
This is brilliant! I think this is the best match up of video and music on the whole of youtube! This is PERFECT. It made me cry and it made me laugh. It's simply brilliant
ThirdTwin3 1 month ago
I watch a ton of Dr. Who fan videos and I only ever comment on the truly amazing. the ones worth my time, this video nearly made me cry, it is sweet, beautiful, and sad all at once. It captures the essence of the love story for the Doctor and Rose. Very very well done indeed.
LadyKitteh 2 months ago 2
@LadyKitteh Couldn't agree more. I'm borderline crying.
LittleCraven 1 month ago
This video is absolutely brilliant. I cry every time I watch it! One of the best videos I have seen in a long time. That part at 2:57 gets me every time. The tempo of the music speeds up perfectly. Great work, Darling. :)
guitargirly66 2 months ago
Oh no...this is just too good...
This song is already enough to put me in tears all on its own (throwback to highschool angst and a heart-rending Kirk/Spock fanvid set to it), but this...
The use of color and b/w, the cuts, the *amazing* editing & manips and the specific clips you chose, the bits of dialogue that float through...oh my...
Really, really lovely. One of the best vids I've ever seen <3
CalifornicationDani 3 months ago
I love this so much! Rose was my favorite. I've never cried so hard. :(
Ravenclaw742 3 months ago 2
This is so good!
Omg I cried at their goodbye! :,( saddest thing I've ever seen no joke!
OwlCityFan26 3 months ago
What episode was 2:37
Ferninator1996 4 months ago
sooooo sad david tennant is my favourite doctor and billie piper is my favourite companion....
Emilydaffern4 4 months ago
As much as I don't like the song, this video is absolutely brilliant. Easily my favourite DW video. Excellent job!
TwoHeartsFilms 4 months ago
I had to watch this 3 times. It's so beautiful, and it makes me wish I had a friend like the Doctor. Someone who can make me smile, hold my hand, share pains and joys, say "I love you" to. The Doctor and Rose's relationship is so strong and so deep, it's much more than a romantic relationship. This is the type of friendship that goes beyond everything and anything. We all need a friend like this ♥
CrazyGrrl12 4 months ago
Comment removed
XoxKittehFacexoX 4 months ago in playlist CoolSongsYo.
Perfect use of an almost-always-cliche'd song, complementing a beautiful, tragic, underappreciated couple. Ugh, I'm weeping.
Thank you.
fluidstatic 5 months ago
OMG I CRIED!!!
Wildatheart114 5 months ago
This was AMAZING. So emotional and real.
IrishLuchair 5 months ago
I really wish David didn't go....I like Matt as the Doctor, but the expressions David pulls off are so intense and deep....like he's really had a troubled past.
nera789 5 months ago 2
O.O................E.P.I.C.!!!!!!! Ugh, SOO beautiful, and the clips are timed perfectly. Usually when dialogue is put into a video, it sounds sort of awkward but this one REALLY brought an amazing feel to it. So incredible.
nera789 5 months ago
Your videos of Rose and the The Doctor always make me tear up. This one got me literally bawling. :)
Coacoabean101 5 months ago
They always get to me!! Poor doctor :( *cries*
tatataters 5 months ago
I have a question. How do you make YouTube videos like this?
ashtonkutcherfan09 6 months ago
Beautiful.
ForeverDreamable 6 months ago
Why is Martha's mum in it when it's about Rose?
slitheenplanet 7 months ago
that was so fantastic that I had to look up synonyms to express the awesomeness of this video. my top three are astounding, extraordinary, and overwhelming
catelikesmilkandeggs 7 months ago
This video makes me cry every single time I watch it. So perfectly edited.
exterminateregenerat 7 months ago
THAT was the stuff of legend!! EPIC!!!!!!!
angeldesigns2002 7 months ago
I bet I've watched this a hundred times. Love it. Thank you!
SugarVenomMama 7 months ago
Easily my fave Ten/Rose vid. I watch it often. :P
Clemontine7 8 months ago
It's back!!!!!! And now I must refine my previous comment. This is not just one of your best videos, it's the best. And not only is it your best, it's probably the best Doctor who video I have EVER seen!!!!! Every part of this video is perfection! THANK YOU!
Perinlyn 9 months ago
I like this video !!
TheBadWolfxx 9 months ago
I love you for doing this.
LittleVampirette 9 months ago
2:57, woah! my heart nearly got riped out
12793lexilou 9 months ago 2
p.s. I meant 1:30 left in the video...not 1:30 into it. Plus, I needed to 'Like' it twice. It's that good!
poptartmal 10 months ago
So you had me within the first five seconds, but when the song picks up at 1:30, I got chills and started sobbing hysterically. This means two things:
1. You have done SUCH an amazing job telling the story of Rose and the Doctor's love, that it truly feels real. And...
2. I am an emotional basket case/ super nerd for getting so involved and emotionally invested in a television show romance.
Either way, THANK YOU for being so gifted :)
poptartmal 10 months ago
i miss david and rose
danamiles1 10 months ago
i hated doomsday because it made me cry so much!
TheHolly365 10 months ago
i know they can't keep billie on there forever. but really, he could be with rose forever. but i guess the writters have other plans
Rachulie 10 months ago
makes me cry every time :')
hotaruthefirebender 11 months ago
Incredible
ColinKazunasNetwork 1 year ago
just... epic. absolutely amazing, heartbreaking, i love it!
going to see your other videos right now :)
juissimakkis 1 year ago
ive never really cried over a vid before, but youve succeded in making it happen. so adorable. -/3
kitkatsaysrawr 1 year ago
This is absolutely gorgeous, seduff! your videos are brilliant, and this is one of my favoties!!
Perinlyn 1 year ago
@Perinlyn favorites. yeah, i can spell!
Perinlyn 1 year ago
2.55 and 3.15 get me every time T-T Haven't watched this in over a year and started crying again
TheErin97 1 year ago
i love the video song and where most of these scenes are shot in cardiff is close to my home !!!! ho yes ive walked in the dr's footsteps !!
mrsdaipunk 1 year ago
Omg, I actually cried at this! :L
It is amazing. ♥
Elle3061995 1 year ago
2:55 always makes me cry. :'(
thank you for this wonderful video. <3
lillalilaprick 1 year ago
Rose Tyler: The only woman on earth the Doctor EVER fell in love with
blackdragonrider3 1 year ago
Gasp! This was a pleasant surprise in my search! I love this show!
invaderpink 1 year ago
Your video editing is so amazing I am in awe of it. This video and all the videos I have seen of yours are so wonderful! This one especially got me. Thank you for sharing it!!
BrightStar5407 1 year ago
I really don't get tired of watching this :D
SummerRain210 1 year ago 18
My favorite one of all.
SummerRain210 1 year ago
I cried. this was brilliant.
SummerRain210 1 year ago
Where is 1.24 and 1.28 and 1.30 from ????
mathkc333 1 year ago
@mathkc333 I actually manipulated those scenes together from The Parting of the Ways (S1) and Utopia (S3). :)
seduff 1 year ago
@seduff Okay thank you :) I love this video 10 doctor and rose 4-ever :)
mathkc333 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love the way he looks at her at 2.12
mathkc333 1 year ago
What amazes me about this video is that this song usually comes across SO cheesy and cliche. Yet somehow you have managed to make it heartbreaking-ly beautiful. The way you cut the clips together is very original and I must say that the clip at 1:30 is simply stunning. I miss seeing your videos pop up on my new subscriptions! I hope you are working on a new one. I love them all.
flightlessphoenix 1 year ago 4
@flightlessphoenix Thank you so very much. When I started this video, i knew I had to take my time and create a very refined and emotional piece, as it had been so overused across all fandoms. I'm so thrilled it is still being enjoyed after all this time.
seduff 1 year ago 2
It´s fantastic! Thank you!
believeinendlesslove 1 year ago
Wow. Just... wow.
2:57 makes me die inside :'(
eighttimesacharm 1 year ago
wonderful video ive seen a lot of Doctor rose videos and i loved this one the most i loved 238 till the end even the part from dalek in manhattan
animeproductions10 1 year ago
Comment removed
doctorwhofan4point4 1 year ago
What episode is 2:56-3:00?
VulcanJinni 1 year ago
@VulcanJinni Its from series 3 its daleks take manhattan or something like that
animeproductions10 1 year ago
Comment removed
VulcanJinni 1 year ago
Love the way he looks at her at 2.12
SamarkandChan 1 year ago
i thought maybe i was moving on then this just broke me down and made me bawl my eyes out. Thanks for making me realise that you just can't move on from these two- your vids are the best!
DoctorAndRose4ever 1 year ago
This is great! It made me cry...really. Love the Doctor and Rose, best couple ever! :)
NovemberDirge 1 year ago 3
This is seriously amazing.. just wow! your fantastic... i love the doctor and rose :'(
the doctor and rose foreverr :) x
Ladylozzii2008 1 year ago
Wow, the most brilliant fan video I have ever seen! At the beginning I had tears in my eyes, my the middle, tears were streaming down my face. I just love this so much! I've always been a huge Doctor+Rose fan, and this was amazing. When the Doctor thinks he sees Rose coming into the TARDIS but she's isn't just killed me! It's fantstic! GREAT job!!
blackdragonrider3 1 year ago 2
This really is the best fan vid of these two that i've seen. well done. oh i love them
cheekymonkeyafb 1 year ago
I am seriously obsessed with watching Doctor/Rose videos so i've seen a lot, probably hundreds by now. This one is by far the best. The scenes used, the way you've ordered and edited and everything about this video is simply fantastic and i'll probably be watching it again and again. I almost never comment but i couldn't help myself, i've never found a video so well done before. Thank you :)
CrackedMetal1 1 year ago 3
Rose and the tenth Doctor forever
GriffithAMPS 1 year ago 2
I don't normally comment on anything really but when I found this I was amazed. I just want to say thank you for giving this to us, this film clips and the music clips have been put together fanatastic When watching this video if you are are a Doctor Who fan of 'David Tennant and Billie Piper' I really think you will be moved. :)
ktcornet 1 year ago 3
You captured the Doctor's and Rose's relationship perfectly. This video was hauntingly beautiful... that's all I can say.
TenIsMyMan 1 year ago 2
Brilliant.
21SoSayWeAll 1 year ago
So sad. So poignant. Beautiful.
tshen6 1 year ago
This made me cry ! Seriously I know I sound crazy but I love Doctor Who.
MiszBxRoyalty 1 year ago
who ever you are you have a real talent for this!!!! you have captured the emotion... perfect... Brilliant. x
Gemmamoviemaker 1 year ago
i cried. yeah. yeah i did. i cried :')
tears STREAMED out when he wanted the dalek to kill him because he lost rose :'''(
and when he was in the ain thinking about her+when she 'came' into the tardis+she really didnt, so i started crying :((((((((((((((((((((((
RpattzGirlx 1 year ago
By the wayy this video is AMAZING, i cry every time i watch it:( its proper heartbreaking:,(
Really well edited and the clips fit so well to the song!
jessylovindavid10ant 1 year ago
This is brilliant,i mean it so emotional and brilliant clips put together and Aerojuanas you totally right I'd rate this a million and one times
badwolfgirl1 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
I think this vid is great, the music fita perfectly!
LupinusMaximus 1 year ago
Amazing
Your sad videos are really good.
EloraSmith 1 year ago
Beautiful :)
TenneBama23 1 year ago
*come. I meant "come" not cone. Lol.
wolfotaku7 2 years ago
I still cone back to watch this one over and over. This, and the Don't Hold Back video. I will miss Tenant terribly :(
wolfotaku7 2 years ago
This was amazing!
Rayvah 2 years ago 3
BRILLIANT VID :D
MrN3J542 2 years ago 3
This is seriously the best fan video i've ever seen. I love it so much. I cry so hard when I watch it lol ty, you're brilliant and i'm grateful for talented people such as yourself.
Aerojuanas 2 years ago 18
Still my favorite video. Even after a year. so profound, its amazing
LadyRii 2 years ago 10
Oh My poor Doctor, why did He have to regenerate???
This seriously is such a beautiful video. I love them so much, these videos make Me cry everytime I watch them. :'(
rach3vz 2 years ago 4
mute this video and play adieu by enter shikari over it! Works perfectly trust me
xoxJemsiieexox 2 years ago
i'm going to miss david!
xoxJemsiieexox 2 years ago
I absolutely love this vid, the song is perfect. i well up every time at 2:55 to 3:00, every time!!! this is perfect for the doctors love of rose. the editing is so amazing! thank you for putting this out in the world for all of us to love!!
katsangel 2 years ago
Brilliant video, had me welling up.
I love them so much! Just fantastic characters!
MaverickVRT 2 years ago
this song reminds me that there will be peace in the united states for all people and the soldiers that are at war they want to come to there families.
Yellowplume01 2 years ago
wow cool at time 3.00
angelica694 2 years ago
GREAT VIDEO
doctorwhonrose 2 years ago
makesme cry everytimee :'(
love itt
so amazingg,, your actually incredible !!
x
NatalieB95 2 years ago 5
Excellent in every way. Brilliant and beautiful video of my favorite couple. The Doctor and Rose Forever.
1Lestatslover 2 years ago
i havnt watched this in ages cos my computer was down. it still makes me cry its just so beautiful xx
shockwaves10 2 years ago
for all those who believe that Rose and the Doctor were only mates
1) Bad Wolf- when Rose gets hit by Ann Roid watch the Doctor's face.
2) School Reunion- Almost confession. "I'm a time lord. I'm going to live forever watching you get old. Watching the person I.. then he breaks
3) Doomsday- The Ghost Room as Rose falls into the Void.
4) Bad Wolf Bay- Rose isn't crying because she lost her best mate. The Doctor crying after the hole closes.
5) Daleks in Manhattan- Another confession almost.
mikawhofan 2 years ago 2
what the heck?? as if you wouldnt mention where she ACTUALLY SAYS she loves him at the end of doomsday and hes about to but disapears
CartBel 2 years ago
oh my gosh this is so good you actually have the bit in the middle where there's all the guitars and stuff I hate the wimpy version without it
AngelaWhoable 2 years ago 3
Amazing video. Definitely my fave of your Doctor/Rose vids.
Clemontine7 2 years ago
The vid is great very super
das vdeo ist super wirklich super
RoseTyler02 2 years ago
brilliant!!! well done!!! just curious: what episodes did you use at :39 - :41 and 2:55 - 2:59?
keep up the good work!!!
AdaratheDarkSage 2 years ago
AdaratheDarkSage: 0:39-0:41 is from Runaway Bride Series 3. 2:55-2:59 is also from Series 3 but this time out of Daleks in Manhattan. Glad you enjoyed it. :)
seduff 2 years ago
I absolutely loved it. After I saw the end to season two, I cried. It was so not fair. This video is a perfect dedication to these two. Well done. ^_^ And to all the tools out there who decide to be cruel, one thing is to be said: A life without love is terrible.
Jeharia 2 years ago
hear hear
youre abseluteley rigth jeharia
maiamkaia 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
time lords dont have the ability to love
irishdan2007 2 years ago
IT'S CALLED A FAN VIDEO. Idiot. No one cares about the 'TECHNICAL' crap. If you've SEEN the current show, you'd see that he shows strong feelings for Rose, even if - in your eyes - it isnt Love. People have a right to like whatever shipping they like so why bother commenting pathetic one liners on popular fan video?
xfreck1esx 2 years ago 3
touched a nerve? truth hurts dont it:)
irishdan2007 2 years ago
Wow. You are a tool.
Jeharia 2 years ago
toched a nerve? why would that 'touch a nerve'? seriously, you have clearly never seen the show. 'truth hurts' yeah, maybe if there was some truth in what you were saying except there wasnt so stop spamming!
good day :)
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
yes he loves her, as a FRIEND! but hes not in love with her, time lords cant fall in love, its well known by everyone who has watched the show ecspecially the older series, why do u think he could never say he loved her until the last episode of the last series, coz hes not in love with her but his part human form cud tell her coz hes part human and has the ability to love, its very simple stuff, sorry to burst ur little bubble,
irishdan2007 2 years ago
LOL that doesnt 'burst my little bubble', seriosuly, your fighting a loosing battle. You don't cross 10/Rose fans. Simple as. You can say that he didn't love her but that's just you not wanting Doctor Who to progress. Even people who have worked on the show have said that he was going to tell her he loved her (at Bad Wolf Bay the first time). Even David Tennant has said that they are a love story! Open your ignorant mind, PLEASE.
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
thats bullshit and u know it, look i didnt write or come up with the idea of doctor who or decide his characteristics, i just said a simple fact that time lords cant fall in love which is one of the charcteristics that they came up with, its well known
irishdan2007 2 years ago
its not bullshit so I dont know it but I'm getting kind of bored of this, we're all entilted to our opinions, so why don't we just leave it?
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
but its not an oppinion its a fact of a characteristic
irishdan2007 2 years ago
no. its an opinion. and you can say again and again that its a 'fact of characterisitc' but i'm just gonna keep saying that its an opinon
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
but it is a fact, get over it
irishdan2007 2 years ago
opinion.
RTD could sit me down and tell me it was all "friendship" love blah, blah, blah and I would still say that they were IN love, so to me, it is an opinion. get over it.
nothing you can say is going to change anyone's mind so you are pointlessly going around vidoes and going "time lords cant love !"
why dont you just leave people to like a fandom they like? if they wanna believe that they are in love, then let them. who the hell are you to go around and challange their adoration?
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
Comment removed
mikawhofan 2 years ago
Comment removed
JadesVidz 2 years ago
yes its kind of a love story but not in the way everyone thinks
irishdan2007 2 years ago
What makes you think that? A love story is a love story, not friendship.
If it was, then what was he going to tell her when he said ''Rose tyler...'' then vanished? What, I love you as a mate..? lol
JadesVidz 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
look time lords cant love alright! get over it
irishdan2007 2 years ago
omg dude HE HAD A WIFE!... AND KIDS he talks about loads of times even in the new series, an example? - Season 4 The Doctors Daughter he tells Donna how he used to have a wife AND (if youve ever watched a william hartnell episode) SUSAN is his Grandaughter and honestly dude theres never been anything in the doctor who universe where they say time lords cant love, new series or old-old seriesLeela stays on galifrey with andred because there IN LOVE-new series.. common man he was in love with Rose
CartBel 2 years ago 2
LOL!
xfreck1esx 2 years ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
haha funny how i say something and ppl get really upset about it, even tho i cud be right or wrong seeing as we dont know for sure as it was never said or never said he didnt, bit like the whole religion thing, i bet u believe in god
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
actually we dont know for sure, we only have hints so your wrong there unlucky son. and dont mind DW confidential plenty of things have been said on that before that isnt true and contradicting, all we know is when he was a time lord he cudnt say he loved her and when he was part human he could so facts are facts,
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare ur still overlooking the facts during the series, and the many points i have made on this video, im not gonna repeat it,
1. "unlucky son" its a phrase
2. i dont care if i got ur gender wrong, i actually didnt even think to what gender u are
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare actually im a really big atheist, and what facts are these son? point them out to me coz no one else has so far, and once again doctor who commentatories are not to be taken seriously, plenty of things have been said in those that have turned out to be false,
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare em what shud be taken seriosly is de facts which i have pointed out, i still waiting on de facts from u....
even if im wrong, (which im not) at least i can make an arguement, u havent made any good points
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare u dont want to argue with me coz u have nothing to argue with, u havent pointed out any facts, u just resort to pathetic insults on grammar on youtube which is quite sad, and once again commentatories have proven not to be taken seriouriously as it sjust oppinions of the actors even when RTD has said stuff in it he has contradicted himself on what happens in de show, so i suggest u take a deep breath watch the shows again and come back with a better arguement, USE YOUR BRAIN
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare haha good to know im getting to u, im still waiting on those facts....
ur failure to say any just lets me win this arguement, better luck next time
irishdan2007 1 year ago
@atemuamadare and ppl who give ot about grammar on youtube are pathetic, its youtube not an exam, get a fuckn life
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare dat was a stupid comment
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare not really, pointing on grammar mistakes on youtube is pathetic
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare wat has that got to do with ur sadness of pointing out spelling mistakes on youtube?
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare still waiting on those facts....
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare coz u dont have any facts, thank you :)
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare haha u clearly care, still waiting on de facts.... but u dont have any
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare
1.course, he likes to be the boss and the king of time, jack was threatening that,
2.not really...
3.i love women but might no be in love with them aka, mother ,sister, good friends
4.dr.confidential-not to be taken seriously as explained to you before as they are just oppinions.
5. another oppinion,
im sorry do u know what a fact is?
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare no actually they are facts what i have pointed out, why was he sad? think about it u muppet, wudnt you be distraught if u lost ur best friend, ur one and only friend? wudnt u? of course u wud
ur are the biggest moron on youtube i have ever come accross, wrapped in ur own little world, learn to use ur brain
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@atemuamadare thats coz they are oppinions, u believe what ur told to believe, u just take in whats in front of u and dont read between the lines ,dont think for urself, for your own good u shud learn this as it will help u in life, children just believe wats in front of them, thats why the believe in santa coz they dont think outsdie the box, sorry i didnt just ruin next christams for u did i?
irishdan2007 1 year ago
Comment removed
atemuamadare 1 year ago
@irishdan2007
Lordy, Irishdan, heres a fact for u;
There was a long standingtaboo during the classic series against any form of romance, but they never said a 'timelord cant love' (He had a grand daughter), but when RTD introduced rose, he decided to break the taboo and create a new dynamic in order to attract new fans, which worked.Evidence? She told him 'I love you', and he replied 'rose tyler...I'...I wonder how that would have ended, hmmm...
Stop getting worked up about a show!
JadesVidz 1 year ago
@JadesVidz u dont have to love anyone to have sex with them, plenty of gay men have kids for example, and we dont know what he was gonna say,, also atemuamadare is a bit pathetic for deleting all her comments haha how sad...
irishdan2007 1 year ago
@irishdan2007
He got married (they said it plenty of times) and you do get married for love, and the whole of the staff said he was gunna say I love you, and when he finally got to say it, she kissed him, And confidential isnt 'messing about' its an in depth behind the scenes, and everyone said, 'its a love story'.
If you dont believe that, then I dont care, but stop causing arguments on a FANvid routing the couple :S
JadesVidz 1 year ago
@JadesVidz look ur just repeating what dat other dope said, and i made her look like a fool, so im not gonna bother repeating myself
irishdan2007 1 year ago
@irishdan2007
Thtas good, maybe then you can get out of your mothers basement and stop trying to pick pathetic fights under videos ehh?
Believe what you want to believe. If a writer and his whole production team is telling me something about a programme, then im going along with it.
JadesVidz 1 year ago
@JadesVidz then ur a bigger fool then i once thought, learn to think outside the box
irishdan2007 1 year ago
@irishdan2007
Im a fool for going against a jerk who has no life?
Its just a tv show, people can believe what they want to believe, everyones different, stop being ignorant and move on!
SADDO
JadesVidz 1 year ago