Added: 4 years ago
From: sephirothsgaybitch
Views: 73,607
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (422)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • PEOPLE PLEASE! Eden is AMAZING. Idina is AMAZING. Every woman who's played Elphaba is AMAZING.

    I LOVE Idina Menzel, Eden Espinosa, Kerry Ellis, Rachel Tucker, Teal Wicks, Shoshana Bean, Felicia Ricci, Nikki Davis-Jones and every other woman I've ever heard sing these songs on Broadway/in the West End/on US tours.

    Why do we have to focus on who's the best? It gives us a bad name as a group of fans when they're clearly ALL the best!

  • Hell, If you want to praise your wonderfull Idina watch her videos ;)

    Eden has an amazing voice, loud maybe, but absolutely powerful, too.

    Eden kicks ass and IF you aren´t on the same opinion, be it, but don´t post all your hater comments under Edens Videos. Get it?^^

    So, excuse my rare English, I am from Germany ;)

  • 1:12 - 1:24 is Gross! IDINA WOULD NEVER! This hoe is screaming from her gut!!!!

  • @cococrane1 it's ho not hoe, hoe is a garden tool, get yo facts straight..

    and that "screaming" you say she does just shows how much Eden is in character..she's not the Wicked Witch of the West for nothing. >.>

  • @ashleylucaslover Ooops. I was just upset because of the Idina put downs I have been hearing. Eden is good(as all of the Elphabas are)...but not good enough for anyone to reference Idina in a negative way. I know a little bit about singing and 1:12 - 1:24 is pitchy and tight. Besides that, Idina was the first Elphaba. So, for her, it wasnt a contest she took alot of the phrases and lines up in this song when she got the role. Lisen to her performance of this song in wokshop. Unbeatable

  • @cococrane1 Shut up about Ms. Asthma.

  • Do you know anyhting about singing?

  • @cococrane1 been singing for five years going on six thanks.

  • Anyone agree that Eden's effectively trademarked this 'Fiyero' riff?

  • @Elwingda I'm an Idina man, but Eden rocks that 'Fiyero' for sure...

  • Oh my gosh.....her "Fiyero".....I think they just got their roof blown off. X)

  • @2:27- YEAAAAAA BABY! That's all. ;-D

  • lets say eden hast the best angry strong songs and idinas is more soft and better in the romantic songs

    Eden is amazing in no good deed ,but idina is better in the wizard and i ,because eden is often very flat

  • I love this musical.

  • Kerry Ellis FTW

  • i don't think there's the "best elphaba". each one has a song that they sing better than the others. idina has the best "i'm not that girl". eden has the best "no good deed".

  • @spazzmuffinz36 You're totally right!

  • where did eden perform??

  • Her "wicked" is the best!

  • I do love Eden... but my personall favorite is Marcie Dodd

  • @222lostgirl me too, im desperate to hear marcie's last no good deed in SF

  • Her "Fiyero" was Epically Awesome.

  • chills... wow

  • EDEN FTW

  • Imma see her tomorrow in the Orpheum Theater in SF :D im soo frikkin excited!!

  • i love her "again"!i love eden!

  • Eden is insane. Amazing!

  • Dude, people, if all the actresses who've been green were like Idina, the show would ahve closed AGES ago. Each performer brings a new life and spin to the role. Deal with it.

  • I really liked how Idina acted and sang the role of Elphaba, but I agree with you. The role has to evolve over time, and adding riffs here and there is not a bad thing for that very reason!

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 and why would it have been closed ages ago, when she originated the role and made a name for the musical? SHE started the role, and yes, it's great when Sho, Eden, Kerry, Stephanie, Shona, Marcie, the rest can add their own things to it, but saying that if everyone was like Idina the show would have closed ages ago is a little ridiculous,seeing as the show never closed with Idina as Elphaba. Just sayin'.

  • @floritka85

    You semi-missed my point... I know Idina originated the role and basically is the reason it's such a hit. And imagine if every actress sang the score and had the same acting choices as Idina... Would you not be bored with the show? Honestly, I would. "Hey, that's the exact same thing as so-and-so did..."

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 No no, I get your point, and I wasn't trying to be snooty or rude or whatever, really. I just said it's also great when the others add their own things to it. I can actually compare the acting, and some do better than the last (and so on.) But seeing as I have never seen a show, only clips here and there, if they were all like Idina (or all like Kerry, etc.) I wouldnt know the difference one way or another when I would see the show, since I wouldn't be able to compare anyone.

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 agreed.

    when people comment on videos to troll on the fact that performers aren't idina bugs the baheezus out of me.

    if you want to rave about idina, go to her videos.

    this is a completely different and incredible performer.

    and to be honest, you can't really compare elphabas with their different styles of singing and whatnot.

    I LOVE EDEN <3

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 AMEN TO THAT... people just can't compare them because they're so different and bring their own incredeible touches to it.

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 I agree!!!!! They are all great! Thats why they got the part. And no one can say that one is better than Idina. She was the first. They all built off of her.

  • @BlueJeanBaby012 Well said! Well said indeed!

  • @Bennycoco25 thats such a ridiculous thing to say,as good as Idina May be I'd like to see her pull of this fiyero riff!!

  • I don't know that Idina could pull off the Fiyero riff, but she can come extremely close to the Again riff.

  • when I saw Idina in the middle of her b-way run she did a very sim. thing to the fiyero riff

  • that would have been awesome to see!

  • @mattcookie

    Deff. not. Idina basically stuck to the score as it was written. Which, it IS a goregous score on its own, but adding riffs adds color. And I dont think Idina could have pulled off high riffs like this with the way her voice was in the middle of her run.... Not a secret that her voice was geting a bit beaten up night after night. Though I LOVE her in her West End days.. Her voice was golden. <3 (the wonders of vocal rest...)

  • @Bennycoco25 I'm pretty sure almost all of the women that have played elphaba can sing a song without having an asthma attack or killing their vocal chords.

  • Problems with the video? It won't play.

  • i don't see the point of people who are fans of other people commenting being like "____ is better."

    but anyway! this is brilliant and amazing and unbelievable! love eden!

  • Eargasm (;

  • Pheonomenal. Omigosh I love her voice!!!!

  • I think Eden's voice is one of the great instruments in Broadway, and she'll always be one of my favorites. I feel that Kerry's slightly simpler and more full voice does this song justice, but Eden has great control and makes everything so easy sounding. Idina is the more complete actress out of all of them followed by Julia, and Stephanie and Sho are up there with them along with Nicole and Willimejin.

    They're all just absolutely brilliant ladies.

  • Comment removed

  • i love her FIYEEEEEERROOOOOO!!!!

    donna vivino does the same thing:D

    eden is amazing:)

  • Shes good but Kerry Ellis will always be Elphaba for me :)

  • thats what i think, too. not because i think shes amazing, but because the first wicked video on i've ever seen was her and dianne's catfight scene.

  • same

  • Except that she doesn't emote at all.

  • ummm...WTF are you thinking ekawapeelsa?

  • WHAT??!?!?!?! you should see her acting not just the sound - she is putting TON of emotion in!

  • really?

    i like idina and then shoshona for defying gravity

    but yeah, eden wins no good deed hands down. her fiyero riff is incredible!!

  • I don't think it's her best performance...it's got her usual passion and amazing vocals, but she seems tired.

  • ... that comment just made me widen my eyes. Is that what usually goes through your head? lol

  • haha roflmao!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • most orgasmic version got to be kerry ellis' last night on the west end. AMAZING!!!

  • holy crap, i agree!!! so so amazing. kerry ellis is AMAZING! so much emotion. FANTASTIC!

  • ...kerry is like the absence of emotion...

  • Thank you.

  • Kerry owns...

  • except for how she doesn't. but hey- we're all entitled to our own opinions. I think kerry has a pretty voice, but she uses terribly relaxed diction and sounds lazy and non-committed to me. so, personally, i don't see the emotion or the hype.

  • @richshillitoe omg shut up if you want to bitch talk about kerry go watch her you tube clips!

  • @101MyActor OMG people aren't allowed opinions now?! There were much better singers... This was not a good one... Loud does not mean good.

  • idina was the best. shoshana was amazing defying gravity. eden is amazing with no good deed. but i still think idna was best ever. after all, the key was WRITTEN for her

  • Actually, it was originally written for Stephanie J. Block. It was supposed to be sung in a higher key, but Idina couldn't quite do it, so they took it DOWN.

  • o. wow i didnt think any one could go higher then that. lol. but the key they wound up using was written for her. and in the end, she wound up shaping the part

  • @NikkiMarie12192

    Poeple who know their facts make me happy.

  • Idina just gets all the hype. She's decent, but, the best? Definitely not.

  • Well, she did win a Tony over Kristin Chenoweth... People are going to hate me for saying this, but I really think Kristin should've won the Tony. Her role just seemed more complete to me. I think Idina's great in the part, but my personal favorite is Eden.

  • @STUPIDxxSITE YES YES YES YES YES.

    FINALLY. I've found someone who agrees!

  • @STUPIDxxSITE amen!!

  • you took the words right out of my mouth idina shoshana then eden

  • no no no....you want to here a truly ORGASMIC version....you can go holla at Alexia Khadime!!!

    OMFG!! LIKE NO OTHER

  • does anyone know who plays elphie in san francisco???please let me know!!!im going there this summer and i really want to watch it....

  • I saw it in San Fran in late may and it was Teal wicks half of the week [voice issues] and Dee roscioli the other half. I asked Dee when she was at the stage door. So those two unless it changes! Hope that helps.

  • hey thanks!I've seen some of their videos here on youtube.i think i prefer teal over dee but watever.i would've love to see eden or sho as elphie but i don't think they're doing wicked anymore.or are they?

  • Dee was amazing, but I was definitely wanting to see Teal. Eden's last show was in January in L.A and Sho did broadway then the tour a few years back but they're done [hopefully not forever :) ]

  • @theafranco Eden's playing Elphie in San Fran this summer. Kenra Kassebaum is Glinda. They're absolutely amazing together.

  • @Altakeeper1 I've been dying to see it with Eden!! I'm probably going to go see it next weekend so I'm so excited, especially since both Eden and Kendra are AMAZING.

  • Honestly, I never liked Shoshana Bean. Hate me if you want, but that's the truth.

  • I am so happy I got to see Eden!

  • So which country has Eden as their Elphaba?

  • Los Angeles, CA America

  • Nobody anymore...she finished playing Elphaba along with the show finishing on January 11th 2009. Sorry..

  • i really didn't like this , i think kerry and stephanie do it an awful lot better

  • Exactly, thats what i keep saying and thinking, and i'm getting the negatives, its just an opinion lol !

  • After Idina, this is THE best No Good Deed sang!

  • it is really orgasmic LOL

  • Eden is pure brilliance :)

  • ehh i don't like her much in NGD... just not the best song for her... sorry i love idina on this song like a kazillion and one times more than eden

  • Eden is def my favorite for NGD. She LuPones. Guh! just love her!

  • i saw eden live.

    it was the greatest ever.

  • i know wut u mean i saw her live 3 times and each time was utter brilliance nd she so owns this song... no other elphaba can touch her NGD!!!!!!

  • Well Indina's version of this song... don't like it at all, it bores me.

  • theres no emotion in it

  • You obviously didn't see her in London. She was incredible.

  • Just hearing her in videos is enough to not really like her NGD, although she does good on *other* songs.

  • i absolutly agree... Kerry is my favourite Elphaba, in my own opinion she is the best :D yu may have a difo opinion, but thats what i think

  • idina all the way...

  • Comment removed

  • Okeydokey! :)

  • Shoshana Bean kills this

  • I think that they all have their good parts:

    Eden-no good deed

    Shoshana--Defying Gravity

    Kerry-----just a suuper powerful voice, but watch her face closely: its sorta blank

    Teal: i just love her

    overall: EDEN ESPINOSA ALL THE WAY

    then shoshana, then teal, then kerry, then idina, then stephanie

  • This just gives me, like, chills all over. EDEN YOU ARE AMAZING!!!

    Peace!

    ~Tree Hugger <3

  • Holy crap. This is amazing. o.o;

  • meh. i'm not moved by it... :S

    kerry is fabber.

  • gamlovesjohnnydepp3 - Me neither. Not really moved by it. Eden is amazing though. And I was lucky enough to see her in LA in 2006. And you are right, Kerry is, as you put it, "fabber". And not just that, but fabbest.

  • Oops! My mistake. I saw it in 2007. It hadn't begun in LA in 2006. I saw it March 2007. About a month after its opening night.

  • The answer is: Natalie Hawkins

  • SHE IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • um.... ew, that was jus... ew give me idina and shosona (however u spell it) anyday

  • definently!

  • her second fireyo was good. but personally I like Donna Vivino's better. but I saw donna live, maybe if I saw eden live It would change my mind.

  • Defying gravity Favorite: Shosanna Bean

    No Good Deed Favorite: Eden Espinosa

    FAVORITE GLINDA: MEGAN HILTY

  • i COMPLETELY agree!!!!

  • you are SOOO right!!!!

  • Shoshana is one of my favorites but i think Kerry Ellis has the best Defying Gravity...I like shoshana's no good deed too...hands down best glinda is Megan Hilty but i love Chenoweth too!!!

  • shoshanas no good deed is my favorite

  • Hands down the best version

  • agreed.

  • I was expecting more...

  • sorry my votes for Idina

  • i can't choose!

  • Mine is too. Julia's my second favorite, but Eden's def. #3!

  • LMAO

  • wow i love how she makes the song her own

  • i don't even know what i'm READ!!!!!ing

  • how do you record audio?

  • you're so right. this is orgasmic.

    =]

  • Actually, her best ever was on April 4th, 2007. Because my technology rebelled against me, I unfortunately have no proof.

    Sad.

  • she is amazing.

    when I went a few weeks ago I got her understudy :l

    she was good, but Eden is like WOW.

  • amazing i love herrrrrrrrrr!

  • I love Eden's "Fiyero!" riff. It's so original :)

  • seriously. she TEARS this up.

  • Wow you're so ignorant.  They're fat? Are you mentally retarded or something?

  • I'm only going to agree with what half you said. Yes Lucy & Kristin are awesome and Kerry's good as.

    BUT, with Galinda's character...ugly voices? Too old? They're FAT?!

    Seriously, kid, you need to move on...

  • You're shitting me. Kristin was in her 30's when she did this. Annaleigh Ashford, one of the best ones, was 18. And Kerry has NOTHING on Eden, Sho, or Saycon. And none of them are fat. You're just ignorant. Megan Hilty has one of the most beautiful voices i've ever heard. Douchebag.

  • I wasn't saying anything against any of the women who play(ed) Galinda. They are all amazing, no-one can deny that.

    None of them are fat, they ALL have beautiful voices and NONE of them are too old. That was the point I was trying to make to d3fyinggr4vity...

    Megan, Cheno & Annaleigh are my idols

  • I meant to hit reply to him. Sorry. lol

  • hehe good, no biggy then

  • i belive erin mackey was the youngest galinda 20

  • Well, Annaleigh is one of them then. And she's amazing at it. Erin does not look like the youngest to me.

  • now, i don't want to get involved in a fight here, but did you guys know that eden is like, almost 31?

  • We're talking about Glindas though. The age of the Elphaba doesn't really matter to me. I was just showing how Annaleigh and Erin are that young, and they are amazing. Hell, Willimjen is around her forties and she is spectacular.

  • haha. yeah. talking about glinda's varying ages, i actually heard that kristen was just under 40 when she did wicked. am i right or wrong?

  • Yep. And she ages gracefully I say. She still looks like she's in her 20's. Not a lot of the OBC was under 30.

  • i have to agree with you. both kristen and idina look a LOT younger than they really are. if u look at idina in old rent vids and compare them to her now, she seems to get younger as she gets older. it's like freaking 'Benjamin Buttons'!!! haha. but seriously.

  • Haha, yes. Idina's gonna be...39?! this year?! Holy crap! Is that right?!

  • 38 =)

  • I think it's 39...cos I remember she's one or two years younger than my mom...

    You could be right...I don't want to do the math though.

  • She's going to be turning 38

  • she is 39 she was born in 1971 and i know that for a fact because i know like everything about eden tracie and idina because they are like my idols and eden is turing well turned 31 on febuary 2...yea i know all of their birthdays not just years :)

  • AH-HA! I KNEW IT! I double checked and we were both right!

    XP