Dr. Helen Caldicott and George Monbiot: Nuclear Energy 2-2 Democracy NOW!

[telemetry9]

looks like george has been having coffee mornings with the atomic energy commission.

This stuff is deadly and has to be stopped - TODAY!!

Fundamentally; people like George are selfish. Until it effects one of his children or someone he loves - they believe that science is God. Well; science has been paid off on this one.

I lived near Hunterston nuclear power plant outside Glasgow - I KNOW the reality. So many in the area have died from cancer. Nuclear Power = broken hearts and broken lives.

[creedstat]

of course they are all in on the conspiracy we can't even get any news updates related to whats happening in Japan ...it's a blackout and anyone involved in this disaster/ conspiracy shoud be sent to live in fukushima with their families .....

[creedstat]

if anyone sees this douche please do the world a favour and feed him a bullet!!

[Tomta20012]

Lets all take a minute and pray that George Monbiot gets cancer and dies.

[Deradune]

5,000 Russian studies is what George calls "few outlying papers." GEEZ...Hello?!! By the way, I have read the entire Chernobyl Report put out by the NY Academy of Sciences in 2009 (over 31 YouTube files) for those who are blind or would rather listen than read at my YouTube Channel called Deradune. If you go to the channel and click on 1 of 31 then it will automatically open from one to the other in order.

[ThisBoyTV]

@Deradune

excellent documentary on YouTube done by Russian scientists

watch?v=yiCXb1Nhd1o

[eijsbrand]

hi George! i lately heard a NIST examiner doubting that Building 7 came down on 9/11. Have to prove it first! I suppose you agree, as i also presume you have no kids. As long as this George-man gets his paycheck, he'll protect the cover-up. Shame on you!

[benthejrporter]

I see Georgie-Boy couldn't resist his habitual dig at "Climate Change Diners"! There is no "Climate Science", only propaganda dressed in a pseudoscientific cloak!

[spiritfired]

Why isn't there a solar panel on every roof? Let me quote from Jim Marrs: "Cuz' the electric company can't figure a way to make a cloud come over your house if you didn't pay your electric bill."

UN is the central NWO system.

There is no global warming. Research. I also thought once that it was true once. Youtube search Conspiracy Theory for simple facts.

Seriously George you FAIL. I'll go to a coal mine while you go to a field with 1 pound of plutonium. Let's see who fails. YOU, or me.

[ThisBoyTV]

@spiritfired

and to quote comedian Lewis Black "we don't have solar energy because the senate doesn't know where the sun goes when it sets..."

[spiritfired]

@ThisBoyTV AHJAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH good one! XD

[benthejrporter]

@spiritfired Well said! What's more Zero Point Energy has been discovered and engineers have designed ways of harnessing it. But you can't put a meter on it! It's freely-available and can't be rationed by the government. It sets people free and ends environmental destruction. That's why it's been classified TOP SECRET!

[spiritfired]

@benthejrporter Really?! Well I didn't actually ever think of it as top secret coz' it's like...so, duh. I don't know how free energy works, I don't know what exactly makes up free energy but it's damn there! Geez. Thanks dude. I'll try to find out free energy on more of my time :)

/watch?v=SSOjXWHZZYg

Here's a vid VERY understandable even without advanced knowledge and she mentioned why nuclear power came to exist. You won't regret it! Nuclear power is "Queenie's" fault :D

[benthejrporter]

@spiritfired Thanks for the vid. Yes, she seems to be behind everything! There's so much information on Free Energy that it's hard to know where to start! Many scientists worked on it, like Wilhelm Reich, Nikola Tesla, Viktor Schauberger and many more. There are a dozen different ways Zero Point Energy can be obtained. Even with very simple methods, like hydrodynamics, re Schauberger, or AntiGravity, as with the Nazi's "Bell". Tesla found that the Earth's atmosphere is brimming over with energy!

[zelig108]

Chernobyl was a level 7 and sealed up in 10 days. Fukushima is a level 7 and still leaking after 2 months. Fuk u ma plant is also dumping into the sea as well as the air. How can anyone really dare to minimize the potential health damages!?

[hairymarx]

Dr Caldicott sounds like a somewhat unhinged, drunken shrill conspiracy theorist who is wrapped up in dogma. It is arguably one of the most extraordinary exchanges I have ever witnessed,

[Hogweed2543]

"Doctors can't lie"

So hang on, Doctors can't lie, but the WHO do...... okay.

[Djhona82]

He says that it's not that bad?

Tell that too the dead people.

If I get cancer, I'd like too kill him before I die.

Maybe in his last second he'll understand that energy is not worth 1 life.

[chondram]

solar would be good, but the wind power fields (although a good idea as well), kills massive flocks of birds continuously. Something would need to be added to wind mills to emit sounds to deter the birds in another direction. Not for nukes...be sure to get update on Fukushima (not from msn)...it is dire! (this report is almost a month old)

[ThisBoyTV]

@chondram

we have plenty of updates on Japan since this was posted

[panstriato2]

There is not the capacity to scale up solar and wind to get as much energy as we use now much less in 2040. IOnly way is to reduce energy consumption.

Monibot does not see a diference between radiation and radioactivity. low level radiation reaching you may not make you sick, but if you have radioactive particles in your body, they may emit low level radiation inside you for years. Not the same

[ThisBoyTV]

@panstriato2

We could have the solar energy to light up cities within a few years. The huge oil, coal and nuclear companies have created lots of propaganda in order to distract people from the only viable alternative.

[felixq78]

@ThisBoyTV Yes but what about the elephant in the room. Zero Point energy systems work they are ready to roll, except for the suppression and ridicule coming from the Military Industrial Complex, Oil . No one wants to discuss this because of its direct relationship to extraterrestrial craft found crashed by the US military. What they don't realise is that we have developed similar technology here on Earth so forget about the ETs and get on with it.

[zelig108]

Monbiot works for the UK Guardian. GE (the makers of the the Fukushima reactors) is the parent company of NBC. Anyone know if GE also has some connection with British media?

[hairymarx]

@zelig108 So Monbiot's in on the giant conspiracy too?...Lol.

[zelig108]

@hairymarx That is just too simplistic. Giant conspiracy? Statistically improbable. But the various media are clearly in bed with their resources. For example, you will not see NBC, whose parent company is General Electric (makers of nuclear reactors, washing machines, and weapons) report on certain issues that will imperil their businesses. I was only questioning Monbiot's independence and wondered if the nuke industry had a stake in the Guardian.

[diodoro73]

Did Monbiot read the Russian reports that showed that over a million died from Chernobyl. And how can this guy come in and say i read "part of the study" and say that others are cherry picking- Lord!!!

[exadverso]

In other words, the WHO grants the right of prior approval over any research it might undertake or report on to the IAEA – a group that many people, including journalists, think is a neutral watchdog, but which is, in fact, an advocate for the nuclear power industry.

[exadverso]

The IAEA's founding papers state: "The agency shall seek to accelerate and enlarge the contribution of atomic energy to peace, health and prosperity through the world."

[exadverso]

The IAEA's founding papers state: "The agency shall seek to accelerate and enlarge the contribution of atomic energy to peace, health and prosperity through the world."

[exadverso]

28 May 1959, at the 12th World Health Assembly, WHO drew up an agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA); clause 12.40 of this agreement says: Whenever either organisation [the WHO or the IAEA] proposes to initiate a programme or activity on a subject in which the other organisation has or may have a substantial interest, the first party shall consult the other with a view to adjusting the matter by mutual agreement."

[71pwnd]

wow. completely pwns her. a brilliant expose of a conspiracist nutbar.

[TitusSviatoslav]

Here' s some more rope George, just keep tying and get on the stool!

[ThisBoyTV]

@TitusSviatoslav

ouch :)

[rochey1010]

Someone got a 'back hander', I wonder how much, It must of fried his brain, MONBIOT YOU ARE AN IDIOT, AND SHAME ON YOU, "nobody has died yet" It's been 4 fuckin weeks, Just wait, It's leaking into the sea too, and damn right, It's not LOW LEVEL, Reducate yourself, You sound dumb with all your so called education!

[ThisBoyTV]

@rochey1010

Japan is now dumping radioactive waste water millions of times over any "legal" limit into the Pacific Ocean. It is highly toxic with radioactive iodine-131 plus all the other goodies from a nuclear reactor.

[rochey1010]

@ThisBoyTV I heard, 7.5 million i think, God help us all, Hey, if you want some excellent sources, I'd recommend 'arnie gundersen', He's an expert on nuclear physics, and he explains what TEPCO/JAPAN won't. I'd recommend 'leakspinner' too, he's excellent with his info, even someone with half a brain wouldn't swallow the blatant manipulations/lies from these peoples mouths, Take care <33

[shellius]

Everyone needs to read the latest response on this by George Monbiot in his latest article, very long and detailed titled Evidence Meltdown. It includes correspondence (snarky and condescending) from Caldicott herself sent to GM. She is a piece of work! Monbiot dot com.

[sdmatt1975]

So the first part was civil. Then part on two it turns into an episode of AM talk radio. Yup I still think it's a crap venue.

[ThisBoyTV]

@sdmatt1975

thank u for taking the time to watch both parts...

"Those are my principles, and if you don't like them... well, I have others" ...Groucho Marx

[sdmatt1975]

What a pile of crap venue.

It gives the first speaker an uninterrupted turn and then allows the second speaker to be interrupted by the first. No wonder there is only 257 views.

[ThisBoyTV]

@sdmatt1975

did u watch Part 1?

[86kinky86]

wow, this guy is such a clown.

[newsworthyable]

You Go Girls!!! No Nukes!!!

Is Monbiot on the Nuclear Payroll or what???

It blows my mind that any one who calls themselves an "Environmentalist" would support such a dirty filthy deadly source for power, Nuclear power that is.

I read his bio on the web and he has quite a history, but somewhere he took a right turn, He bought the propagand. Why are the Environmentalists arguing with each other? This seems very wrong. I like what Caldicott says about our Perscription for survival.

[TripleSpeak]

Wow. Amy did try to cut off their argument nicely ;o)

It leaves one wanting a longer debate.