Added: 3 years ago
From: Windgrace
Views: 791,412
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (883)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • perfect singing!The best Russian singer!

  • I wish I was that photogenic <3

    

  • Semplicemente Bellissimo.

  • Helllo! I definitly love this video and this song, for this video i discover how wonderfull is Anna, thank you so much fot that, now i have a little request: if you don´t mind, can you tell where can i find this lovely pictures?... i just found a few but i love every single one. Thank you so much and congratulations :)

  • Si Dios no acaba con el mundo, es porque a Él también le gusta la buena música

  • anna netrbko , sara brightman , jackie evanchio , tres voces angelicales

  • @gu4d4lup4no te falto la voz de el cielo Sumi Jo

  • She has an angelic voice. Let's appreciate her talent, her natural charm and beauty! Amazing

  • Congratulations, i can not to find the right words:)))) I love this song very, very much:))))

  • I am breathless. Tears fall. Angelic vocal blessing to all earthlings.

  • hmm jesus pie. better than apple pie but harder to get

  • @PSEK LOL TFF

    

  • One of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard..........

  • nádherné!!!!!!!

  • I think the visuals really take away from the spirit of this simple hymn for the dead

  • she is from this earth buth came from heaven

  • Amazing makes my heart FLY 

  • IMO it's one of Netrebko's best pieces which I favourited long ago and listening again now. Such beauty! Brava Anna!

  • Bewitching beauty with an ethereal voice, a simply compelling combination. Thank you :-)

  • Gorgeous, sung like it should be sung!

  • oh my goodness, feeling every note and space, I am crying. Thankyou, I hope you sing forever!

  • watch?v=r7bOGsoRIYs - second Anna Netrebko!

  • cool

  • анна ты богиня

  • Beautiful. This is the way it should be done (and I am not exactly a Netrebko fan but she did an amazing job)

  • What can I say? Wonderful !!!!

  • Cheesy tat

  • @Snutih - it seems you have little feeling and are simply too aesthrtic for the rest of us but I know (and I do know sacred music friend) when a song strikes a chord, and I don't care what the orientation of the composer is. having exopperienced 9/11 in a very personal way, II have an idea of what cleanses. you might try that with your aesthete's mind

  • I have tears in my eyes.

  • @icebolt26 me too!!

  • wow

  • A voice from above.

  • Bu musiqiyə ilk dəfədən aşiq oldum. Kaş ki bütün musiqilər belə gözəl olardı.

  • BRAVOOOO********

  • S[ bella, bella

  • This was sung for our 9/11 Memorial Mass tonight a Mass of Remembrance and Forgiveness. Perfect, fitting music for the evening and so beautifully rendered.

  • @MultiTeddd It s cheesy though. Most likely americans can t cope with real music and need some Broadway gays to write their religious pieces lol

  • @Snutih

    oone further point the Pie Jesu with different orchestration was written by Gagriel Faure as part of his Mass. As far as I know he didn't wite for Broadway and wasn't gay but then you may have greater knowledge than I. you certainly seem to think you have.

  • Божественно!

  • such a clear tone...she has a magnificent voice, very angelic! :)

  • She is good at sacred songs, too.

    Wish she would, like Hvorostovsky, record a Russian Orthodox album.

  • If Anna Netrebko is here on earth then heaven must be seriously missing out! I aspire to be the next Anna Netrebko, she is beautiful inside and out and the voice proves it! Brava Anna, Brava!

  • She really is beautiful in every facet. Brava!

  • Angelical la voz de la Netrebko.La amo apasionadamente.

  • I'd totally tap that.

  • i sang this when i was a treble/soprano at church. this is really special.

  • *****.

  • Far too plummy

  • It boggles the mind...such physical beauty combined with THAT voice...there is something Divine going on here.

  • @Bruce99100 Amen

    

  • Ощущаешь подлинное счастье когда слышишь такой прекрасный божественный голос это чудо!!!

  • 84 people don´t like or they really don´t understand the classical music, because all those, who like this wonderfull music can´t stay untouched by anna netrebko´s way of singing this piece.She is a very very great woman with a unimaginable, beautiful voice!

  • Awful piece. Not one note of originality. Just CATS in disguise as a classical piece.

  • @organboi Do you really believe that? or are you discriminating the piece without really listening to it? Just because Weber doesn't usually write music like this doesn't mean it's of any less quality.

  • Old Lady at Opera: Did you like the opera, dear?

    Vivian: It was so good, I almost peed my pants!

    Edward Lewis: She said she liked it better than Pirates of Penzance.

    That one always comes to mind when I hear La Bellissima sing.

  • Dios Mio! I love it when people bitch in Spanish. I'm just glad that La Bellissima decided to record this particular album. Her voice has grown and she has a great range, but it's her middle that really gets me. One can feel the passion and feeling in her voice and in the delivery of the words, who cares if you know what she is saying. Like that Julia Roberts movie line said " It was so good, I almost peed my pants" not "The Pirates Of Penzance".

  • nossa, que moça bonita, dve ser um anjo que veio do céu cantar para mim.gostei dela e sua maravilhosa voz,. beijos :)

  • She sings wonderfully, but after hearing Sissel violin-like voice singing this song.........every other version pale.

  • @SebaRasta Have you heard Edita Gruberova. She's better than both of them.

  • A true nightingale, pure beauty of sound.

  • Wow!!! Cannot believe how great she sings!!!

  • FINALLY! Someone with a classical voice I can relate to! Everyone else I've been hearing sounds like they are singing it through the back of their throat or they think they are on broadway!! Bah!

  • Wonderful !

  • Her voice is like chocolate gold, idk why but thats the first thing i thought of ..

  • odié la imprudencia de Groupon colocando un anuncio de asado parrillero que era imposible de cerrar y dejé de ver/escuchar a la Netrebko. es un ABUSO INTOLERABLE ESTE TIPO DE INTERVENCION PUBLICITARIA en videos como éste. estoy indignada.

    aliceanam

  • She sings this so wonderful!

  • Tout simplement beau ! Great !

  • C'est Anna qui m'a fait découvrir la musique classique

  • I'm looking to get into classical singing...and this lady is most certainly someone to aspire to, a pure sound x

  • Bravo!!!!!!!!!

  • 80 people are clearly deaf.

  • She is amazing!

  • I am a diagnosed Schizophrenic and we think she is exquisite.. don't we? Yes we do! Stunning!

  • Speechless ! 

  • Excellent.

  • So beautiful, I love songs that make you cry like that.

  • Louise Florence & Niall Cahill performed Pie Jesu at the Living Links Service of Remembrance at Cavan Parish Church on 15th May 2011, remembering friends and relatives who have died by suicide.

    youtube.com/watch?v=zygZ3PrOVc­Y

  • She is not from this earth...

  • @marcelomammana SHe's from Russia , go buy a map

  • @russzkij - I, too, would like to kick @ericrub1 in the nuts for that comment. Because Lloyd Webber's Pie Jesu is utter shite, regardless of who sings it.

  • @Comodusprimus Do you prefer another version of Pie Jesu- if so, which one?

  • @Beeshitten - yeh - by Tom Waits, with a heavy cold 

  • It's nice to hear this sung by a legit voice.

  • this song cheers me up whenever i listen.

  • Ethereal and evidence that music is discovered not created, ie God mad music and we fid it.

  • @2007ablack Beautiful way of putting it! :)

  • @2007ablack ALW certainly fids it!

  • Wonderful.

  • Just beautiful !

  • Beautiful angel looking diva who sings just the way she appears.

  • Comment removed

  • brava anna

  • As hobby musician (violin, keyboard, guitar) my ears tell me that Anna sound fantastic and also better than Jackie Evanchos ... but I understand Jackie better (although I have problems with latin) and I like Jackies voice a lot because it is so soft like velvet. I hope Jackie will not change her voice too much ... I would miss it.

    Why not listening to very different sounding singers?

  • WOW! I have to go back to Gundula Janowitz to find a soprano who's voice is this exquisitely effortless.

  • Squisito! Mille Grazie a te.

  • i would love to be able to sing this its AMAZING

    

  • Her voice in this song could calm a raging schizophrenic. I love it! Such unimaginable beauty!

  • @lydiadugan I have often wondered whether this vocalization could stay a wild beats...perhaps it could.

  • Holy Jesus! What a voice....and beauty.

  • OMG what a voice!!! I'm in heaven!

  • She sounds like a violin when she hits those high notes. In a good way. :S

    Ahh, beautiful.

  • música para las masas

  • Impresionante...

  • I think this fine singer just opened my cold cold heart to know that for a brief sliver in life there is love....

  • What a beautiful voice!

  • All mentioned are quite different. Some are trained professionally. I think Hayley has little training and none in opera. And in fact, I like Netrebko better than anyone in the opera scene today! But I can say is that I have never heard any of these ladies compare themselves to another singer and say, "I am better!" They leave that to regular fans, and a few opera snobs! In truth, I love them all, and for different reasons.

  • @Quasimoto44 Kindly try Sissel's Version

  • @narayanan26 thanks so much for the advice but a caution to any trying this - don't try Sissel's version too soon after this one - too high a concentration of wonderful.

  • hey, i have uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)

  • Simply flawless

  • Beautiful. Stunning. Wow. Thankyou Anna. I can't help myself ...sorry...but it floors me that someone like Hayley Westernra gets over 2 million views and this exquisite Diva doesn't even come close. Just shows you how ignorant the masses are. :( Each to their own I guess.

  • Amazing

  • Die tollste Frau der Welt!! Sie singt wie ein Engel. Herrlich!

  • No Pop icon can occupy the same space as his angel!

  • She's as stunning as her voice which can best be described as ethereal.

  • Beautiful woman with a beautiful voice. Very lovely!!

  • О падении культуры музыкальной до уровня "ниже плинтуса.", особенно среди молодёжи, недавно в своём интервью сказал Хворостовский - тоже Великий дар от России. И опять же - Россия осталась и без этого сокровища

  • Jackie Evancho sounds better, unless you like the forced bottom-of-the-barrel sound of Netrebko. Who knows, maybe this was just a bad recording.

  • @LouieInSeattle Comparing Jackie Evancho to a professional, trained opera singer with a mature voice just doesn't seem to work. Jackie is a self-proclaimed crossover singer who has done covers of everything from pop music to popular arias. Anna Netrebko is an opera singer, who sings opera. The genres are completely different. This version of Pie Jesu is effortless, ethereal, and absolutely beautiful...the best I've heard, out of the dozens of versions I've listened to.

  • @Procrastimaster I almost forgot how good Netrebko's was. Haven't listened in a while. Makes Jackie sound bad.

  • @LouieInSeattle Go back to your Wackie Jackie.

  • @LouieInSeattle I guess everyone is entitled to an opinion, but anyone with any kind of voice training knows that Anna Netrebko & Jackie Evancho don't even live on the same planet. Anna Netrebko is a goddess. Maybe Jackie will be too some day, but that hasn't happened yet.

  • Россия должна дарить миру только подобное Анне! Жаль, что Россия осталась без неё. Спасибо, что есть хотя бы You Tube, чтобы наслаждаться талантом этого сокровища!

  • @38wladimir1 Как точно Вы сказали- СОКРОВИЩЕ!!! Именно так нужно называть красоту и наслаждение.... Спасибо Вам за солидарность. Вы видите- на русском то и пишут мало отзывов.... а я после прослушивания не могу не написать.

  • Simply extraordinary!

  • pues tienes mucha razon mi estimado myntikagaroo!!!

  • Definitive version of Requiem Mass is by Gabriel Faure- who, unlike Andrew Lloyd Webber, was a genius.

    However, only Webber got to fuck Sarah Brightman.

    So it's a tie.

  • @jessicafischerqueen Not sure how giving Sarah Brightman one gives A.L-W any credibility whatsoever.

    Granted he was punching well above his weight what with him being a scrotum-faced dwarf, but being a millionaire is a more than adaquate lubricunt(sic) with some women.

    Allegedly... :-)

  • In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Dumbledore's Phoenix sings a lament for his master after he has died. I can't imagine it sounding any more beautiful than Anna in this performance.

  • Who is singing the mezzosoprano part here? Garancha?

  • @irinadz Anna sings both parts.

  • Oh, cuz it's not... sorry :)

  • That doesn't sound like Sarah... hmmm

  • it's really magic...

  • I made love with my girlfriend while her ''Souvenirs'' album was playing. Orgasmic in every way you can think of!

  • @officialjadenrhodes I'm sure your girlfriend would feel really special if she knew you where lamenting your manliness by posting stories of what goes on behind your bedroom door on YouTube.

  • @rodhatte Haha! Get a life!

  • I listen to this on my ipod all the time.

  • This voice is beautiful, this song is beautiful, this women is beautiful!

    I love Anna!I wish - come to Czech republik!

  • БОЖЕСТВЕННО ! ! !

  • I love the rich timbre of her voice!!

  • Это очень красиво... Я слушал в записи Сары Брайтман, там тоже красиво.... Но здесь - всё просто замечательно! Я не ожидал! Вернее ожидал, что будет супер, но не ожидал, что на столько!

  • nice

  • Well done.

  • BEAUTIFUL is not enought to describe this....

  • BEAUTIFUL IS NOT TO DESCRIBE THIS....

  • Beautiful, absolutely incredible voice. I love this. This piece always brings tears to my eyes, when done well.

  • Совершенство! Браво, Анна. Уж получше его женушки! :(((

  • @Varangianguest Ch'ei zhenushki?:-)

  • @serenaluce

    Ну, как? Сара Брайтман была женой Уэббера

  • Angelic.

  • I like Jackie Evancho's better

  • Удивительно!!!!!!!

  • This is the most beautiful version I have heard of this piece. Well done, Anna.

  • Anna you are great singer!!!!

  • What's not to love about this Angel and her lovely singing voice!

  • Wow!

  • Comment removed

  • How can some of you even put Netrebko and Church, Brightman, Aguilera or Evancho in the same sentence? Please stick to what you know, which must be Paris latest fragrance or the Kardashian's latest love fiasco and leave any kind of musical commenting to the experts! Netrebko is a one of a kind Opera Diva in her prime, the rest are extremely bad popular versions of what a singer should strive for!

  • @ericrub1 How? Because that is how the connections are made within them. We cannot tell someone how to perceived music, it is a very personal thing which relates to their life's experience and level of uderstanding about music. We just respect each other, wish the best from their musical experiences and allow each to learn and grow musically at his own pace.

  • @pbj4toast Perfect answer!

  • @MrRagtimer The reason I am a Brightman fan as well as Netrebko is that Sarah's voice reminds me of my mom's. When I was about 15 I began to realize what a high voice mom had. I walked over to the piano and asked her to show me how high she could sing. Without a warmup I began playing up the scale and she hit an E or F above high C. If only she had had musical training when young instead of being homeless during the depression.

  • @ericrub1

    OK, i'll put them in the same sentence: Anna Netrebko is the ONLY one on that list who is better than Jackie Evancho.

    Is it remarkable that the best operatic soprano in the world is better than a TEN YEAR OLD GIRL? Not to mention the fact that the best part about this is the contrapuntal line with Andrew Swait.

    Your comment is fair regarding the other adult singers, who obviously don't compare to AN, but give Jackie a few years & we'll see.

  • @ericrub1Please don't group Jackie Evancho in with the rest of those people. She's only 10/11? and is so much better than the others you mentioned, and will only get better with age. I just listened to this song by Brightman and Church, and both were really terrible sounding. Jackie hits notes that send chills down my spine, unlike this Anna girl does. :)

  • @SeafoamStymphalian these singers like sarah and anna, are only different because of age, and the type of opera in which they know. Jackie evancho is much more modern, for she learned the modern versions of this song. These singers sing the real versions, and in the right wayss. no saying jackie evancho isn't bad, because her voice is ammaazzingg. but just saying that this sounds different because the type of opera and the time at which they learned this.

  • @SeafoamStymphalian then your spine is quite soft no?

  • @ericrub1 I think your response to people's ignorance is one of the reasons people are scare of opera... No one whats to fell dumb. You do no credit to the opera community by being judgmental of their unlearned opinions. You are quit ignorant if you can't see the beauty of Church's and Brightman's voices, just because they are different, and not up to par with greats like Fleming and Netrebko.

  • @ericrub1 Yes, but only one of them has time to catch up : )

  • Comment removed

  • @ericrub1 "Stick to what you know" is the worst music related advice I've ever heard. So what if someone is a pop music fan - surely if they are exploring and finding they like classical music this is a GOOD thing, not a reason to abuse them?!