Added: 4 years ago
From: janusego1
Views: 316,433
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (314)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • <3

  • Wow, this is the first YouTube video I've found with a bunch of random clips and a song playing that doesn't make me want to reach through the screen and bang the author's head against the wall until their eyes pop out. Not only that, it's actually a really GOOD song, a nice reprise of the famous Donnie Darko favorite, and some really, really nice visuals; very soothing and appropriate. Only regret? It's not in HD! I want to download it for my music vid collection! You should re-master in HD!

  • outstanding.

  • very good job tu

  • What's that vertical yellow bar on the time line at time 10?

  • @jaker5555 That is when the advertisement comes up.

  • @PerhapsYa123 thanks. I'm too young too wake up to things I guess

  • @janusego1 ...you own "thousands" of CD's...oh...gee...am I so fucking jealous! Look after your collection.

  • Nicht Schlect.

  • COOL

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • PS

    Were not under the milky way...

    We are in it!!!

  • The videos are extreme, magnifying everything ...even the sun....great. Just imagine if you could 'see' billions of light years in a flash..."under the milky way tonight..."

  • @001GenLee it is cool. Thanks for your story, made me smile.

  • the boys from victoria Ah Memories

  • I love the video work. Good job.

  • 01genlee that's were I saw it

  • I'm glad i found this song & the mystery is solved as to who sung it. I actually caught the ending of it on MTV's One Hit Wonders a few nights back. I first heard it when i was 7 in the late 80's at the Wings store that used to be across the street from the Myrtle Beach Pavilion amusement park. It's cool how little memories like that stick with you when you're young. Hearing this song definately took me back to that day i was in Wings shopping with my parents. lol

  • @001GenLee

    Cool bit of nostalgia there. Thanks for sharing!

  • This song mellows me out. I love it.

  • Does anyone know where I can find tabs for this version of the song?

  • I think this is quite beautiful and done in very good taste. It does have an edge to it, so does the original song. This version just brings it out more.

  • Always loved this song

  • thank you ..i loved it xo

  • Comment removed

  • Is it only me that picks up on the scary"1."

  • Everybody`s down on their knees

    Listen like thieves

    But who needs that

    When it`s all in your hands

  • Beautiful song. It hits so many emotions of sadness, wonder, depression and hope.

  • This song is sad.... sadness and redemption.... I wish I knew what you were looking for... so simple, so straight, and still so unreachable...

  • purely entertainment! nice job janusego1!

  • First hear this song because of the coheed version...so glad i found the original and then this version after that... mind blowingly good

  • WONDERFUL!!! deep song, gets my soul....

  • Soooooo beautiful. :o)

  • i loved this video, liking the church since i was 13...

  • So soothing...

  • Thank you so much for sharing this brilliant piece of artwork...perfect video with the perfect song...bravo!

  • Visually stunning!!!! Awesome video, thanks!!!

  • Absolutely beautiful version, thanks for sharing :)

  • @57kez - how is this theft? I have their albums, but as far as I know I can't buy this video clip (I will if they offer it for sale). I can listen to the song on my CD player (or my iPod) but I like to watch the video as well.

  • I'm sorry your original choice was blocked ... but OTOH I love your "second best" song and the video is amazing! I am just rediscovering Mike Scott and The Waterboys and YouTube clips like yours have helped me to sample their vast catalogue. I am now buying their music so, hopefully, some benefit is flowing to the artists.

  • fuck all you humans.....you have what is coming to you....look to your feet for the second coming

  • sh!t

  • @janusego1 you know charlieissocoollike has a very interesting opinion on this very subject. it shouldn't be too hard to find on his page, and i seriously recommend you take a look at it.

  • Nice work!

  • music is a skill just like fixing a car is a skill and the musicians who have been given this skill should be compensated

  • ENJOYED THE VIDEO & MUSIC!!

  • great vid! amazing that they wouldn't let this post to Under the Milky Way. Have you seen the "official" video:) It is so amazingly 1980's it hurts...the record co. halls are echoing empty these days...

  • Best music video I've seen -- bar none.

  • The greedy record companies - I really loved this to Under The Milky Way. Beautiful video anyway regardless of the track.

  • one of the best songs/videos ive seen

  • At 3:39 where is that . . . that place seems awesome!

  • I want to be there.

  • Since you can hear the song on other videos, could this not be considered censorship?

  • The video is nice, it's cool the lonely man in that desert

  • Charlatan's Lament works so incredibly with this video - change the video title .... it just works so well!

  • 'janusego1', I wholeheartedly agree with you! I have bought many CD's and MP3's after discovering new bands posted on facebook or here! These stupid stupid record companies are shooting themselves in the foot!

  • Man I loved watching your video with the Milky way soundtrack. I wish I could get emailed a copy...

    It reminds me of road trips with good friends. Stay cool bro.

    C.

  • Goldensalamander, try this: open a YouTube window with The Church's original video for "Under the Milky Way. Then open a second YouTube window with Janusego1's super-cool video above, so that it appears over The Church's video, but mute The Waterboys song. That way, you can watch Janusego1's video while listening to the "Milky Way" tune, as you previously were able to before the numb-nuts at the record company disabled the audio for it.

    (No disrespect intended for The Waterboys.)

  • janusego1.....I totally agree with everything you said in your post.....FUCK the Record Companies. They ripped people off for years but the writing is on the wall now.....hope they die a painful death....

  • When they block this music they stifle our creativity!

  • Wow! I never heard of the Waterboys and really love this song!!!!

    You really should repost it under the correct Band Name and Song Title because this is the only version of The Waterboys..The Charlatan's Lament on here or anywhere!!

    The video posted is AWESOME!!!

  • Look, almost two years later, the record industry is realizing they are dying, and soon will be dead. I'm sure musicians and fans abroad will be pissing on their tombstones when they croak.

  • I LOVED THAT SONG! Amazing... it was very difficult to find it!

  • Sometimes a record company does this kind of thing, and they don't even really own the rights to the music. But youtube (like so many others) are so afraid of the power they wield that they will cave at the slightest notice.

    Edwyn Collins was recently denied from posting his own music on his myspace page, because Sony, WB or some other fuckwad company was laying claim to it. After showing that they actually had to claim on the music, he was allowed to post it, free for the people.

  • The Charlatan's Lament - The Waterboys. Never heard this song before, but this is AMAZING!

  • what is the POINT, record companies? jesus.

  • Hey guys: you can open the video that has audio only; play that one. Then open this 1 (muted) & watch the vid (synchronized, of course, to audio). I know it's a pain but it works great! PS Please don't remove your lovely video!

  • GOOD DESCRIPTION!

  • So what is this music? Makes for good practice exercises I suppose.

  • Youuuuuu cocksuckers! I only looked up the song because I just saw it on a car commercial. Thanks for making me commit to never buying anything from this artist or quite possibly anyone in your stable of artists which can't be many if you think this is going to win you more fans...oh, and I'll find it on here somewhere else anyway!

  • Look for it under Louvers..... ;-)

  • @XLintLuvR You're retarded.

  • @XLintLuvR wtf? clear me up^^

  • Fuck you for wasting my time.

  • Love it! Video is absolutely incredible! Beautifully appropriate for this song!!!

  • lol you guys are funny

  • u fucks

  • Fuk WMG! Boycott all things Warner!

  • Stupid move, whichever record company you are. This is one of the best songs of all time, and it gets absolutely zero airplay on the radio. Do you think anybody under 35 years old is going to hear this song anywhere else? Get a fucking clue.

  • Pff. I heard it on the radio today. So it gets radio play.

  • WMG is only hurting the fans of theartists, group and music, the same fans who go to the concerts, buy the CDs and DVDs, introduce the music to their friends. Without all of you, the fans...these groups and labels would be nowhere.

    Collectively, all of you have the power...not the labels...vote with your wallet. There are other labels who are much more fan friendly, support their artists and groups. Support them instead.

  • I would like to know what Steve Kilbey thinks of all this.

    vs. Spy vs. Spy (another Australian band) are uploading all their music onto their website for free, coz it's all about the music. I think that's cool.

  • Your video clip with the song Under the milky way was "brilliant". I brought the song on itunes after seeing "your" inspirational video. So... yes! I agree with you, that "some record companies are short sighted, not seeing the bigger picture and benefits. They need to think outside the square.

  • 57kez, tell me, were you born mentally retarded or did it just develop from watching too much tv. The only thing labels do is let artists be unoriginal and still get promoted. They act as a middle-man and jack up the price on the art so they can become a billion-dollar industry. Record companies just publish the music in exchange for the rights; even the shitty stuff, so now even the good artists need to sign a contract to compete with the shit, whereas before their talent would get them noticed

  • I give you a five simply because you can back-ended by corporate media.

  • Well breastimus, you can take up for these record labels if you want but up until about 3 years ago I would buy new retail, I probably have bought over 500 albums. Over the years I probably have spent $7000.00 worth of music. Never again will they get one dime from me and yes, I have been known to put patch cable on my tuner and tape a song, and there is nothing the labels can do about it. they can come after me if they want, bring a warrant

  • in the record companies defense, you say you buy a number of music AFTER listening to the free ones you get can on youtube or p2p share programs. Think about how many people DON'T buy the music because they can just listen to it for free :) You are DEFINITELY a minority. Never the less, you're good people!

  • Because WMG has been assinine in the way they block music on You-Tube I do not buy CD,s I do not buy music that I cannot listen to first.

  • To all the greedy music companies WMG in particular. Because of your making You-Tube remove music from all the videos that you own the rights to, I no longer buy ANY music from ANY artist that are signed to major labels. I only buy used CD,s or music from unsigned artist. I also use a tape recorder and make tapes of music off the radio, what are you going to do about that? You have been screwing the artist and now screw you~!

  • yea...you're not going to record music off the radio and you know it, I know it, and THEY know it. If what you are threatening them with (Stealing music off the radio) were a problem then I'm sure they would be doing things about that also. I mean, don't get me wrong, I haven't paid for most of my music since MP3s but the artists that I REALLY appreciate as TALENT, I WILL buy the cd regardless of how easily I could download it 4 free. Just for the respect of the artist.

  • Well this, as always, is a loaded topic!! We get it... already. Stealing bad, but I think we all agree if you wanna show your love/support 4 an artist go out an buy it!!

  • i'll admit im a thief, and im proud to steal from those greedy fuckers. fuck them and you.

  • YEAH! Fuck those greedy motherfuckers!

  • hahahaha!!! poor stupid record companies.. they need to censore the music of an obscure great but largely unknown aussie group.. you are at the end, you are touching the ground poor stupid idiots...

    USE ONLY PEER TO PEER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

  • Row row fight the powah! This is what I like to see.

    Screw the record companies. They've always been reprehensible, screwing the artists six ways from Sunday. Now they're getting a taste of their own medicine, and they don't like it.

    The day I first saw, "The audio on this video has been disable due to a copywrite claim from Time Warner", was the day I boycotted the compact disk market. Youtube should grow some balls.

    They'll never get another *cent* out of me. Their greed will be their doom.

  • IDIOTS ! I'm gonna grab the torrent instead. Fuck record companies- I'm not giving you a dime.

  • Good rant janusego1

  • record company fags.

  • I yoused to love watching this vid to the Church... Very well edited and done. I wish I could see it again

  • VERY DISAPPOINTED!!! Can't even enjoy a great song and video. Thanks You Tube.

  • we write free open source software. but the record companies wont put out free music. dont the artists get paid to perform? what has becomeof art?

    we are going broke and homeless. the banks are stealing what we had and moving off shore, away from this bottomless pit that they have created for us.

    to hell with the fat, old, ugly, youtube, corporate, establishment, bullshit, filth.

    freedom at all costs!!!

  • cigar-chewing record company fat cats must go down. we don´t need them, the artists don´t need them. they are redundant, obsolete, and desperate. they must come to terms that they don't own the music anymore. they should be taken out back and shot for ruining the music business over the last 50 years.

  • let alone the origina !! that all I wanted to hear, the live versions arent so great unfortunately- sucky sucks

  • I don't know this band, I just saw them in 'related videos' section and thought about checking them out. The sound is disabled and now they've lost a potential fan, I hope they're happy -_-

  • I am a DJ and I download music ONLY after I sample in You Tube .I also have more than 10,000 Cd All originals. Record Companies Stop Hurting Yourself. I am going to start buying second hand from now on.

  • I am going to stop buying CD's until the day the record companies smarten up. If they only knew how many I bought from listening to youtube. I, like many others use youtube to find out what I like. Then I will buy the orignal CD.. but their behaviour has pissed me off and I shall no longer purchase CD s from companies that disallow their music on youtube. I hope they end up bankrupt

  • You can get around the audio suppression for this video by opening two YouTubes and playing the actual song on one and the running the video (turning off the sound) on the other. Works great if your computer handles it.

  • I haven't bought a new CD for some years because the record companies are only greedy for the quick penny and are against music art. If they wanna go ahead and censor all music posted on the net, well, go ahead... hrad work, like putting doors in the country-side or building a swimming pool in the ocean... what they are achieving though is to create a new majority, a new generation of music users outside their "system"-- time will tell who wins this war

  • Yep, I'm also going to buy all my CD's secondhand from now on. It doesn't really hurt the artists anyway. They make practically nothing from CD sales. They make money off live performances, radio play and other things.

  • GRRRRRR. I miss the old YouTube. Every vid I try to watch is now ruined. Way to go, now maybe people will stop using the site all together and nobody will win.

    It's a great song, if I can even find the video ever again. :(

  • i always open up two pages one with the song and the other with this video on cause it just goes perfect with the song.

  • Oh my God !!

    With this ' silenec and spirit' guitar playing

    lonelyny in front of the video .. that is just so beautifull !!!

    Thank you corporate people !! Thank you money lovers !! you want to bias and you give wonder and fun !!

    ( I just go back to the booze ! .. be back !! . ^^ )

  • *silence and spirit

    ( not silenec .. typo .. )

  • How absurd, Selfish Bitches.!

  • this video would have gone so great with the song

  • Fuckin-A i like this song and you greedy record companys have to take our music away! Them why ever produce it is you don't want people to hear it else where??

    Whats the diffrence if I turn on the radio and hear it 5 times aday or listen to it on here? Either way your not making money.

    We must put a stop to this bullshit, and speak out and be heard! If you don't like me then get out of my face (Fucking corporations)

  • fuckin retards, I wanted to make sure this was the right song that I was going to propose to, thanks greedy assholes, now I'll just pirate it i suppose. Fuck you all in your stupid asses

  • pfft, I just tried iTunes pathetic shit, I can't even preview to buy. Set sail for fail you douchebags, I can propose with a different song.

  • Record companies ought to be charged with stealing. They charged $18 for CDs when they came out when they only cost a few pennies to make. TALK ABOUT STEALING!

  • wmg hypocrytes. U steal money of bands and its only for your benefit u close the songs of here. Ive paid for 10 songs on bigpondmusic coz ive seen the songs on youtube.

  • WMG you are a pack of arseholes.... you might as well be burning books...

    it's the equivalent...

    you sons of bitches... give us our music back you fuckers!

  • F*** off WMG - I wanted to show my son some awesome music but he can't see it to appreciate it and buy it - so guess what? You suck and you are not getting any of our money. What dumbass at corporate decided to hide this music so it is forgotten forever and never purchased again? Corporate morons - probably don't even make 6 figures and now you know why

  • Yeah!....fuking idiot....you are ok my friend... eat this WMG 8=====D

    Kill all music discographic

  • why would you say that if your a father? not to be mean but thats not father like.

  • Great Song! Greetings from Germany!

  • Well I was considering buying this tune on itunes but since I can't sample it first I don't think I'm going to spend my dollar on it after all.

  • They're all Jews, that's why . Its the Jews

  • LOL.

    they get the blame for everything.

  • Good thing stupid don't hurt; you'd be hooked up to a morphine bag.

  • Stupid Frequently does hurt. It's even been lethal. Look up the Darwin Awards. :-D

  • Been there. You know Georo's working for an entry, unknowingly of course.

  • Bronfman you greedy bastard! You think this is good biz? You have personally pissed in your own soup. Do you honestly believe this somehow solves anything? I own well over 1000 CD's and even more LP's. I am the guy that made you. I have never illegally downloaded a song. Not one. Not fair to the artist.

    See below-

  • You will be met in hell by Bernie Madoff and shown your new quarters just down the hall from Getty, Rockefeller and the rest of the robber barons..... I will never again buy anything that you are connected to. EVER! Ya ever think that the music biz is what it is because of guys like you? You wonder why people rip off music? Because you do not offer value.... You just anger the consumer. Artists deserve to be paid. You do not. You didn't earn it.

  • Big companies sucks hard time!

  • I played this song on my guitar on video responsed above... lets see if warner pulls it!!!!! LOL

  • What a bunch of douche bags from WMG ! These days, America is of, for and by the executives and if you are not an exec, you are treated like sh*t !

  • They need to get rid of the Copyright crap. Youtube has ruin alot of great video`s cuz of this................... ) :

  • God forbid the band gets paid, right? I mean they should just put this stuff out for free. There should be no profit. The bands should have to work in cubicles during the day and make music for free just for you and me.

  • The biggest load of bullshit is that we are somehow cheating the artists. Record companies have been screwing the performers from day one and that's no lie. Johnny Cash said of his first royalty check: "When I got my first RC,I bought a pack of cigarettes, a loaf of bread and a bottle of whiskey. Then I was broke again."

  • Ok, so do you think Johnny Cash stayed poor with each successive royalty check??

  • No but my point was the record companies will short you whenever possible. Eventually he (as do most) got wise. Loads of performers have had to go to court to collect.

  • Fucking corporations ruin everything, even corporations

  • nooooooooooo was the best video with t best song dam it

  • agreed... only thing that can come of this is one less potential fan knowing

  • This planet fucking sucks.

  • I read your video description and you are exactly right, right on man.

  • I also agree. These companies dont knw what they are doing. Youtube is actually paying to play the songs, and advertising the songs. They are doing the companies a favour. But now, youtube wont pay or advertise for them anymore, and people jst download music for free on softwares. So, these music companies loos out BIG time!

  • I totally agree with what you wrote, janusego1 - these record companies are now run by greedy idiots. Don't they know that music like this will be FORGOTTEN if not allowed to play on websites such as Youtube??? THEY'RE STUPID!

  • Grrrr......so flippin' LAME!!

  • Why not play the song on your MP3 or iPod and watch the video at the same time?

  • I did that and cued it up pretty cool video to music

  • Lindo clipe, assisti sobrepondo a música em cima, não faz mal q eles não deixem a gente ouvir, ficou ótimo do mesmo jeito, lindo, lindo... belissimo!

  • obrigado

  • This is ridiculous. I love this song and this video. Also, if record companies don't want their music to be played for free, why do they let radio stations play their music? The idea of paying for music is absurd when you really think about it.

  • what a pity ! This video was terrific, even better than the original.

  • Oh no! This was one of my favorite videos! I too will boycott anything from WMG. Very disappointing.

  • I agree. I have often bought CDs after hearing something new on Youtube. It is a great way for new customers to learn about music before they buy it. I too will not purchase anything from WMG and I will recommend that everyone I know does the same. This is the kind of reasoning that has caused our economy to be in such bad shape. Can't they hire anyone with brains to work for them?

  • I hereby certify that I stop buying anything original edited by WMG unless they drop this stupid and arrogant attitude.

  • I couldn't agree more with janusego1

  • you record companies are so selfish. we're not gonna earn money by just watching these videos. whats the point, go ahead and eat ur videos if thats what makes u happy, wtf....

  • you can easily resolve this. Just say you gave them credit and by doing so you are actually helping them and in no means is giving credit to the company stealing.

  • what's up with this  wmg ruining everything on youtube!!!!!!! wtf

  • It is the end of the music business as they know it and they are just freaking out like rats in a bucket filling with water. It is going towards not needing a middle man, and people can just as easy make their own music.

  • What is the point of blocking the sound??? Soo many people would go out and buy an album they liked having heard a few songs on u tube. The majority of people download a song or two by certain artists and then go out and BUY an album they wouldn't have done had they not downloaded a freebie off the internet. It's basically try before you buy.

  • Janusego your video is great and it bought back a great song that would just fade into black if anyone would have to look at the original stupid video they shot it with in the 80's Warner should pay YOU!

  • i have cd of this song, i just want to hear the music when i'm in the office...shit!

  • I uploaded a video with a copywrited song and they said something about it and claimed they owned the song , but the didnt remove the video. I posted another video on myspace and they removed it and I had to read the TOS to get my account back.

  • fuck ya corporations

  • I fear this as sign of things to come because like i said before technicaly everything on the internet that is not home made is being used without consent. I can foresee a day when almost everything of arts or entertainment on the internet is pay only.

  • That includes Flickr and You-tube.

  • Any idea where's the place shown on 1:55?

  • grrrr....damn wankers...i hate record companies!

  • Stupid assholes ! F*ck the executives ! They are so f*cken greedy that we have to put up this bullshit ! It is due to their greed why we are in such the economic mess we are in and not only that, this stimulus bill won't help the ordinary person, it is an executive bailout !

  • Yes...Boycott them...those that want to rip artists off will always find a loophole...If I like an artist enough I will purchase their albums, go to their concert...I have virtually all the vinyl including singles, virtually all their CD's and must have seen them 100+ times...I will be boycotting WMG if I can help it...I will definitely check the labels in future,......it is like those insidious poisons in some foods...now we have to check the CD labels!!!

  • UNBELIEVABLE!!! I want them to know that I actually went out and PURCHASED the album that this song is on as a result of hearing/seeing this video! What a bunch of dolts!!