i think rafi is better than other singers because all other singers have their speciality in single type of songs..bt rafi is best for all types whether sad songs or funfilled songs...
Kishoreda and Rafi Saab , equally great ... Kishoreda was a true genius with a great timbre and resonance to his voice, his energy and understanding of the needs of a song are truly outstanding. Rafi on the other hand was the epitome of Bollywood playback, with a golden romantic , silky sound . Rafi was able to evoke all emotions to its maximum. Both singers acknowledged each other's greatness. We were blesssed with these two Gods
All old singers are excellent but I like Mannadey more than others. This is the greatness & simplycity of Mannadey the statement he said about rafi - No doubt rafi is one of the best singers but u cant say Rafi is better than Mannadey or Hemant or kishore or mukesh or any others. All have their unique clas of singing. All are the best.
I am a great fan of Manna Dey. He deserves much more praise and status. Great people like him can better understand the real greatness of Rafi. He admired Rafi as he deserves. Rafi sahab, you are the King of Palyback.
Manna Day is a not only a excellent singer in his own right but a honest getleman. what he has said about Rafi saab is very true and in my view places Mr day at a very respectabel and honourable person. Kishore saab was an excellent singer but Rafi saab was a legend.
Really I don't know what is the problem with Kishore fan ,,in the dark you see ever thing is black but that not mean everthing is black....Kk fans you should know Kishore sent his son Amit Kumar to learn music from Manna dey.......Manna day said that from 1 to 10 is mohd rafi and we come after that and he said only me and mohd rafi only the singers we was able to sing all tape of songs......
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
All three were great. Kishore could gain the highest ratings only when Rafi sahib and Mannada faded out slightly, which often happens in show business. Kishore was a very good singer but Rafi and Mannada were par excellence. They had the raags in their voices, rendition whereas Kishore sang plain numbers. Certainly it were these two who had ';sangeet' in their voices and Kishore had 'geet'.
@bhagwanmaalik i agree with u ..Rafi was the best and legends should not b compared by morons who listen to hip hop n remixes n they think they know wat music is ...
@SeaBreezeCenter Yes very well said. I love the way Manna De ji said the Truth from his heart. He is our great living legend and he said the Truth that Rafi saab is the greatest ever in whole world. No one like Rafi saab and thanks to Manna Dey ji for honesty.
@vaseemym koun chutia kehta hai kishor no 1 singer tha abe chutia music ki knowledge hai tujhe sabka baap music main sirf rafi sahab the samjhe unhone har tarah ke songs gaye kishor ne kya gaya ghadhe ka lund...pehle music seekho phir comment karo itna bada...AB KABHI RAFI SAHAB JAISA KOI PAIDA NAHI HOGA SAMJHE
in what world do you live in? kishore is nothing compared to rafi or manna dey.. he is MAYBE #3.. but then again, sureshji is miles ahead of him as well.. so perhaps not.
@vaseemym Thats right my friend, Manna Dey was and still is more FAR classically and technically trained and accomplished then both Rafisahab AND Kishoreda! its tru, almost all ardent fans and followers of music (and hindustani sangeet) can vouch for this... What Manna Dey says will always ring tru bcuz HE was the one who has known both of these legends on a professional as well as personal level...
today better singers are than rafi ......udit narayan,abhijeet and the great sonu nigam if rafi was here today i had tough competition with these guys lol
RAFI SAHAAB LOVED MANNA DEY, HE USE TO SAY THE WORLD LISTEN TO MY SONGS BUT WE SINGERS LISTEN TO MANNA DEY . IMTIAZ FARUQUI USA
imtiazf10 1 week ago
Old magic still shine immensely... through Manna Dey a time stood still. My profound respect to living legend.
imrank340 1 week ago
derka derka mohammed jihad.
KillinDaWelfareMCs 1 month ago
at 4:30 its Salim???
87prak 3 months ago
Mohd Rafi Was indeed an example for everyone, He was King of Songs, There will no one will like him, Rest in Peace Sir, Always Love You.
moeali100 3 months ago
very good i need full this video sa re ga ma palezzzzzzz
shahzaibkhan110 4 months ago
very good i need full this sa re ga ma palezzzzzzz
shahzaibkhan110 4 months ago
amazing tribute to Rafi Sahab by Manna Da...very very well said. I love u Manna da..
islamazimul 4 months ago
i think rafi is better than other singers because all other singers have their speciality in single type of songs..bt rafi is best for all types whether sad songs or funfilled songs...
vinay4780 5 months ago
Manna De is a true gentleman
sam7748 6 months ago 2
ye jo sonu hai na...jis dhang se bolte hai...hai mar jawa...
alicefant 6 months ago
shamadam1
shamadam1 (1 second ago)
Spam Marked as spam
Kishoreda and Rafi Saab , equally great ... Kishoreda was a true genius with a great timbre and resonance to his voice, his energy and understanding of the needs of a song are truly outstanding. Rafi on the other hand was the epitome of Bollywood playback, with a golden romantic , silky sound . Rafi was able to evoke all emotions to its maximum. Both singers acknowledged each other's greatness. We were blesssed with these two Gods
shamadam1 6 months ago
Song sung by Mannada was composed by Madan Mohan in 1973 film Dil Ki Rahen.
RealMusicKing 6 months ago
Rafi himself had very high regards for Manna day, in one interview he said you listen my songs but I love to listen to Manna da's songs.
Premshri2008 7 months ago
Comment removed
Premshri2008 7 months ago
All old singers are excellent but I like Mannadey more than others. This is the greatness & simplycity of Mannadey the statement he said about rafi - No doubt rafi is one of the best singers but u cant say Rafi is better than Mannadey or Hemant or kishore or mukesh or any others. All have their unique clas of singing. All are the best.
ABCDPQRSXYZ1234 7 months ago
Manna Dey saab's voice is to die for!
xfmaverickd 8 months ago
Mannada a great singer
atulmina 8 months ago
I am a great fan of Manna Dey. He deserves much more praise and status. Great people like him can better understand the real greatness of Rafi. He admired Rafi as he deserves. Rafi sahab, you are the King of Palyback.
fsagar711 1 year ago 2
sonu is shit. he flopped in london
londoniran 1 year ago
Manna Day is a not only a excellent singer in his own right but a honest getleman. what he has said about Rafi saab is very true and in my view places Mr day at a very respectabel and honourable person. Kishore saab was an excellent singer but Rafi saab was a legend.
786maq 1 year ago 6
No one can sing like Rafi Saheb, KK was an ordinary singer... living legend Manna Dey is right here to say about the greatest Rafi Saheb...
tasveeeren 1 year ago 2
i am a big kishore fan, but rafi is divine
onkar4in 1 year ago 4
rafi sab u r legend n great singer ever
browzersz 1 year ago
Really I don't know what is the problem with Kishore fan ,,in the dark you see ever thing is black but that not mean everthing is black....Kk fans you should know Kishore sent his son Amit Kumar to learn music from Manna dey.......Manna day said that from 1 to 10 is mohd rafi and we come after that and he said only me and mohd rafi only the singers we was able to sing all tape of songs......
peacebird2peacebird 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
just enjoy their work, don't compare
ffajil 1 year ago
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
just enjoy their work, don't compare
ffajil 1 year ago
i don't understand why we fans of these legends fight among ourselves....look at these persons, they adore and respect each other so much
even kishor stopped singing temporarily after rafi saabs death.....hemant kumar then again forced for playback, and the first song after that break was a bengali song, paying tribute to rafi ( se jeno aamr pase ajo bose ache)
and rafi ji also once said that you people listen my song and I listen to Manna dey.............
just enjoy their work, don't compare
ffajil 1 year ago
kishore is zero compared to rafi
MrNiceguy007007007 1 year ago
All three were great. Kishore could gain the highest ratings only when Rafi sahib and Mannada faded out slightly, which often happens in show business. Kishore was a very good singer but Rafi and Mannada were par excellence. They had the raags in their voices, rendition whereas Kishore sang plain numbers. Certainly it were these two who had ';sangeet' in their voices and Kishore had 'geet'.
bhagwanmaalik 1 year ago 2
@bhagwanmaalik
geet and sangeet!!! what a great analogy!!!
orawal 1 year ago
@bhagwanmaalik i agree with u ..Rafi was the best and legends should not b compared by morons who listen to hip hop n remixes n they think they know wat music is ...
vijivihar 1 year ago 21
rafi sahab You r the best always
taufique1000 1 year ago
True, true, true...
No one like Rafi Sahab...!
Peltonwheel 1 year ago
Mohd Rafi is a legend of music no doubt his services ever remember in industry
may God belessed his sole , ameen we love u Rafi sahab .
MySirjee 1 year ago
Totally agreed with Manna Dey!
The greatest and evergreen singer in the Indian Film Industry!
SuperAlphaandOmega 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
everybody knows kishor was always no 1 and then rafi i dnt why manna dey is saying no one can be like rafi in india???
vaseemym 1 year ago
Because Manna Dey knows more about music than any body else.
SeaBreezeCenter 1 year ago 32
@SeaBreezeCenter
Absolutely! A maestro par excellence!
orawal 1 year ago
@SeaBreezeCenter Yes very well said. I love the way Manna De ji said the Truth from his heart. He is our great living legend and he said the Truth that Rafi saab is the greatest ever in whole world. No one like Rafi saab and thanks to Manna Dey ji for honesty.
ekdesiandy 1 year ago
@SeaBreezeCenter absolutely right....i totaly agree with u....
pankajagnihotri1 1 year ago
@SeaBreezeCenter hahahaha,that`s right
mukeshmahr 4 months ago
@vaseemym koun chutia kehta hai kishor no 1 singer tha abe chutia music ki knowledge hai tujhe sabka baap music main sirf rafi sahab the samjhe unhone har tarah ke songs gaye kishor ne kya gaya ghadhe ka lund...pehle music seekho phir comment karo itna bada...AB KABHI RAFI SAHAB JAISA KOI PAIDA NAHI HOGA SAMJHE
sabirrafi 1 year ago
in what world do you live in? kishore is nothing compared to rafi or manna dey.. he is MAYBE #3.. but then again, sureshji is miles ahead of him as well.. so perhaps not.
cricketlover1117 1 year ago 2
@vaseemym Thats right my friend, Manna Dey was and still is more FAR classically and technically trained and accomplished then both Rafisahab AND Kishoreda! its tru, almost all ardent fans and followers of music (and hindustani sangeet) can vouch for this... What Manna Dey says will always ring tru bcuz HE was the one who has known both of these legends on a professional as well as personal level...
Maaz7294 3 months ago
today better singers are than rafi ......udit narayan,abhijeet and the great sonu nigam if rafi was here today i had tough competition with these guys lol
vaseemym 1 year ago
Each and every word of Manna Dey is totally based on reality.
God bless you Rafi Saheb.
SuperAlphaandOmega 2 years ago
Very true!!!
mrcoolchap89 2 years ago
what a nice vdo.
Thanks for upload.
Asiftabrez 2 years ago
Very well and true said by Manna Dey. Rafi Saheb is still the best singer in India. RAFI SAHEB KI JITNI TAARIF KARO KAM HAI.
tasveeeren 2 years ago 2