I got a VHS years back called 'Industrial revolution'. It had a Willam Bourrows clip and later on had this live clip. I was floored, I didn't know what I'd seen but I was sure it was sincear. Like it or hate it this was brave emotional music.
@allmenarerapists That's pretty awesome. I tend to listen to their live performances (which were released on cassettes back in the 70s and 80s and can actually be found on the internet) when I study or just read for pleasure. They tend to be mostly instrumental, and I honestly think they're better than their official albums (which happen to incorporate live performances in them as well... other than 20 Jazz-Funk Greats).
When watching this video. You have to put yourself in the time period. When is this from the late 70s?? That is completely fucked... These guys are fucking pioneers.
@GarrettIsTheDinosaur I don't understand how you can make the comparison. One is pop and the other is experimental... both are on two completely different ends of the musical spectrum in rock (if you can even call TG "rock").
@JaackPat It was just a joke. I dont like nickleback at all so i could say that about every band. sorry for the confusion. thanks for not being a dick about it though. guys on the internet are nuts sometimes. hahaha
@GarrettIsTheDinosaur No big deal. Honestly, I don't let the anonymity of the internet turn me into a complete jackass... something many others should do. :)
If this was the first real industrial music, then The Doors was the first prog band, The Yardbirds was the first heavy metal band, and James Brown was the first rapper.
No they didn't, they had a drum beat, a guy crying, or screaming, I can't tell which, and a guy controlling the sound on his mic. Making noise come through a speaker doesn't make it music, you shit.
So? Steppenwolf coined "heavy metal", but no one thinks of them when they think of early heavy metal. Most people don't even know who they are. Creating a genre doesn't make it good music. It's literally just a fucking guy whining over a beat.
Because they are an abomination, an abortion of music. They are a dying fetus that the 1970's shit out, and allowed to live. It's fucking stupid. They shouldn't have been allowed to make music. Anyone who listens to them is stupid. Plain and simple.
To say something that wouldn't sound like i'm pretending be an expert... or capable to appreciate this, i have to say i got to this link because de amazing Dj MAGDA SAID THIS WAS ONE OF THE THREE GROUPS THAT INFLUENCED HER THE MOST
@MrGutley This was made back in the 70s before there was proper technology. The Industrial artists we see today are blessed with technology. I'd like to see you create a fucking genre with hardly any resources.
@JamesManes I don't think it was the lack of resources so much as the lack of songwriting ability or vocal talent on display here. Any halfwit can make a hideous noise, even an original hideous noise. Real talent involves making a racket that sounds good. TG achieved that for a small handful of songs, but not here.
@MrGutley Honestly it just sounds like you lack the ability to understand that other people have different tastes. Go listen to the song 1930 by Merzbow and get back to me. It sounds like nothing in music theory, but it had to be edited and produced. He took time to make sure it sounded right to him just as TG did.
@MrGutley The thing is, TG wasn't trying to sound good. You're fundamentally missing the point of TG. They were a shock art group. They were trying to be abrasive, and they succeeded. I like this song because of the awesome shifting polyrhythm and Genesis' amazing stage presence, as well as his tormented vocals. If you look under all the layers of noise the song is really quite an incredible piece of work.
@khoroshoorange yes like cattle to the slaugther, nobody seems to rebel anymore, kids these days maybe...when mommy and daddy dont buy them an new iphone
i dont know there is potential out there. like the occupy movement.
and a lot of good opinions but everybody gets screwed and oppressed.
in the end some people think "its no use" and submit. but i dont think this can go on forever. eventually things will peak.. i mean a lot of positive things have been achieved through dissident.
do anybody else's suggestions on the right there include a justin bieber christmas song featuring mariah carey? what a truly bizarre world we live in. i guess throbbing gristle and current child pop are now the same thing?
England had, this. I don't even know what to call it. I could call it "industrial". But I'm not going to. I'm going to call it "this". But "this" is very good.
I make music with a very heavy Throbbing Gristle influence. If you like throbbing gristle you may (or may not, I don't know) enjoy my style of industrial music.
industrial music got much more complex as time went on thanks to people like trent reznor, but throbbing gristle gets under my skin more than pretty much any band. this is a great track that's also harrowing to listen to.
@gpenn2 you say complex. I say polished and for the most part souless :(. I mean did NIN actually SHOCK anyone like throbbing gristle did? Throbbing Gristle even shocked the punks...
@Silenceless NIN shocked lots of people when Downward Spiral became popular, but it's likely none of those people were remotely aware of Throbbing Gristle. I think there are more layers to NIN's music but Throbbing Gristle is more unsettling, in general. Both are great groups; they're rather different but I think both of have pushed lots of boundaries musically speaking. Just cause they have cheap imitators doesn't diminish what they've done.
@rivet138 have you really listened to nine inch nails? it's clearly industrial rock. just cause it's not purely industrial doesn't mean it doesn't fall under that category.
After purchasing the third report by TG I started hunting for their other works but nothing is as good. In fact most of there stuff other than that album is pretty weak. TG doesn't even compare to the second wave of industrial music.
@rikolasdf What you say implies a very narrow minded definition about music. Music is a form of art, and art is the freedom of self-expression. It means it has no rules, no laws, you do it whatever you think would get your point across.
When a medium is guided by strict rules it ceases being art, and makes the first step to becoming a product. Just because this is harder to consume than, let's say, pop music, you can't just go and say it's not music. Not liking it is personal preference.
@MrCl1nt I'm not trying to apply strict rules to the medium of music, but if there are no rules, how can something be considered a part of such a medium? All I'm saying is I feel that, if someone were to write up a list of very loose rules that describe what music is, this would not abide by enough of them to be considered music. I'm not saying you can't like listening to this, but I really don't see how it is music. It is certainly art, but I do not consider it music.
@rikolasdf Music is the expression of experience via sound. What differentiates music from noise is that There's intent to express experience behind it. Your claim that this is noise is unfounded.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Why anyone would like this "band" is beyond me. Genesis P. Orridge is so annoying. I can actually stand some of the songs where he doesnt sing like that one D.O.A song, but all he does is just scream or mumble. Boring, Uninspiring, unmanly, and a wimpy fag who wants to be a girl....yep thats throbbing gristle.
This band grew on me. This whole genre is not big on the talent concept. In other words that doesn't make a band good. Also this band it self is out there and not easy to relate too. Especially cause their flow is a bit odd and the mind set of Genesis is nutters, although the whole of the dark 70-80's thing is that way. But they got a song "Don't do as your told do as you think". So at least their not combative to haters like other band and genres, they are open people.
Jesus fucking christ this is terrible! And all you fags pretending you like it because its as you so bluntly put it "Its anti-music, its not supposed to sound good" "The more terrible the better!". My 7 year old brother with down syndrome does shit just like this on my casio all the time. [random key smashing/demo beat on keyboard] [Screams gibberish into mic so hard that it crackles]
So because you don't like the song, you feel the need to not only imply that anyone who likes it is not only a "Fag" but is only pretending to like to be cool, but you also feel the need to exploit the fact that your son has down syndrome to prove your point on the internet.
I got a VHS years back called 'Industrial revolution'. It had a Willam Bourrows clip and later on had this live clip. I was floored, I didn't know what I'd seen but I was sure it was sincear. Like it or hate it this was brave emotional music.
Mondriantestpattern 22 hours ago
Product of wealthy and dysfunctional family.
Couldn't always get his way, so became an angry punk, nihilist and homosexual in the same day.
spunkets 23 hours ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Throbbing Gristle
Giving him discipline will result in being kissed.
S3fb 1 day ago
The guy at 8:58 - 9:20 is now an important member of the UK Independence Party.
richievegas01 2 days ago
What a crock of shit. This is stupid. Watching retarded and mentally ill jackoffs with a microphone is not a musical performance.
KickDownDoors 2 days ago
I wish I was in that crowd
MissMurder1243 1 week ago
@MissMurder1243 Me too!
tracyvanity 5 days ago
8:57
pedroincendio 1 week ago
Comment removed
pedroincendio 1 week ago
this helps me study anatomy and physiology.
allmenarerapists 1 week ago in playlist anarko
@allmenarerapists That's pretty awesome. I tend to listen to their live performances (which were released on cassettes back in the 70s and 80s and can actually be found on the internet) when I study or just read for pleasure. They tend to be mostly instrumental, and I honestly think they're better than their official albums (which happen to incorporate live performances in them as well... other than 20 Jazz-Funk Greats).
JaackPat 1 week ago
When watching this video. You have to put yourself in the time period. When is this from the late 70s?? That is completely fucked... These guys are fucking pioneers.
ibanezgeorge 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
@ibanezgeorge This is actually from 1981. It's a clip from their last performance... which was in California.
JaackPat 1 week ago
@JaackPat Wow cool. Thanks for the info.
ibanezgeorge 1 week ago
mommy the bad man is screaming at me^^
Tobiemoss 1 week ago
He's trying to act scary but he's not fooling that audience haha.
christophebassett 1 week ago
@christophebassett Nah, I seriously doubt Genesis gives a fuck.
JamesManes 1 week ago 3
haaahaaa this is why like music like the residents, captain beefheart, primus, devo,.. it puts a big smile on my face.
dhaeze 1 week ago
someone give the dude discipline already
geekusa59 1 week ago
omg was ist das für ein unglaublicher dreck!
ironman10005 2 weeks ago
these guys are so much better than nickleback.
GarrettIsTheDinosaur 2 weeks ago 8
@GarrettIsTheDinosaur I don't understand how you can make the comparison. One is pop and the other is experimental... both are on two completely different ends of the musical spectrum in rock (if you can even call TG "rock").
JaackPat 1 week ago
@JaackPat It was just a joke. I dont like nickleback at all so i could say that about every band. sorry for the confusion. thanks for not being a dick about it though. guys on the internet are nuts sometimes. hahaha
GarrettIsTheDinosaur 1 week ago
@GarrettIsTheDinosaur No big deal. Honestly, I don't let the anonymity of the internet turn me into a complete jackass... something many others should do. :)
JaackPat 1 week ago
It's weird too, industrial was one of the most anarchic and chaotic music genres, and it's now one of the strictest :/
JanitorPride2 2 weeks ago
Musical chaos, love it! I
love Einsturzende Neubauten more though, I recon they took it even further.
JanitorPride2 2 weeks ago
@socioistic - so fucking what. who cares what you think.
jonnyjaywick 2 weeks ago
I haven't looked at this comment page in years.
Without digging too deeply into the pages and pages of comments, I think it's clear the same arguments are just being recycled over and over.
I'm sooo glad I turned off E-Mail notifications.
lelliesandremains 2 weeks ago 3
If this was the first real industrial music, then The Doors was the first prog band, The Yardbirds was the first heavy metal band, and James Brown was the first rapper.
Socioistic 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic They pionerred Industrial music dumb ass.
IndustrialMilitia 2 weeks ago
@IndustrialMilitia
No they didn't, they had a drum beat, a guy crying, or screaming, I can't tell which, and a guy controlling the sound on his mic. Making noise come through a speaker doesn't make it music, you shit.
Socioistic 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic Have you ever heard the Industrial moto? "Industrial, because noise matters"
IndustrialMilitia 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic sound like your kind of industrial music is the multitude of bands doing heavy metal with electronic trappings!
the TG motto was Industrial Music For Industrial People. they coined the frase Industrial Music. they are the originators.
wwwescapeartistsdk 2 weeks ago
@wwwescapeartistsdk
So? Steppenwolf coined "heavy metal", but no one thinks of them when they think of early heavy metal. Most people don't even know who they are. Creating a genre doesn't make it good music. It's literally just a fucking guy whining over a beat.
Socioistic 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic then don't fucking listen to it, and let those of us who enjoy it listen in peace. It's that fucking simple.
WitchfinderGeneral56 2 weeks ago
@WitchfinderGeneral56
Because they are an abomination, an abortion of music. They are a dying fetus that the 1970's shit out, and allowed to live. It's fucking stupid. They shouldn't have been allowed to make music. Anyone who listens to them is stupid. Plain and simple.
Socioistic 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic Huh, sounds like you need some discipline
WitchfinderGeneral56 2 weeks ago
@Socioistic Also, a life. One not devoted to insulting a band you don't like.
WitchfinderGeneral56 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
Socioistic 2 weeks ago
To say something that wouldn't sound like i'm pretending be an expert... or capable to appreciate this, i have to say i got to this link because de amazing Dj MAGDA SAID THIS WAS ONE OF THE THREE GROUPS THAT INFLUENCED HER THE MOST
susanaosusu 2 weeks ago
oddly, not my thing
shambrawk 3 weeks ago
all the filth in the world
Muszynianka2 3 weeks ago
put the snowflakes on and everything will be alright
aprilbucklin 3 weeks ago
HOLY FUCK!
NTVRDfmv 3 weeks ago
They where a revolution and my bands from industrial, ebm, trance, noise, ambient, wtf-ever still "borrowing" from them till today.
Madowstone 1 month ago
Love Gen.
nervsykins 1 month ago
i like how the audience really isnt moving at all.
Cidantis 1 month ago
Woah Gen! This is amazin'...would have loved to be there! So out there it's a bit scary!
TheeHitch 1 month ago
anyone know what year this was?
knppl 1 month ago
While it is fine for musicians to experiment, it is best to hide your failed experiments in the studio where they belong.
MrGutley 1 month ago
@MrGutley You definitely don't get the point of industrial, do you?
NightmareGanon 1 month ago
Comment removed
GrognakTheTroll 1 month ago
@MrGutley This was made back in the 70s before there was proper technology. The Industrial artists we see today are blessed with technology. I'd like to see you create a fucking genre with hardly any resources.
JamesManes 1 month ago
@JamesManes I don't think it was the lack of resources so much as the lack of songwriting ability or vocal talent on display here. Any halfwit can make a hideous noise, even an original hideous noise. Real talent involves making a racket that sounds good. TG achieved that for a small handful of songs, but not here.
MrGutley 1 month ago
@MrGutley Honestly it just sounds like you lack the ability to understand that other people have different tastes. Go listen to the song 1930 by Merzbow and get back to me. It sounds like nothing in music theory, but it had to be edited and produced. He took time to make sure it sounded right to him just as TG did.
JamesManes 1 month ago
@MrGutley The thing is, TG wasn't trying to sound good. You're fundamentally missing the point of TG. They were a shock art group. They were trying to be abrasive, and they succeeded. I like this song because of the awesome shifting polyrhythm and Genesis' amazing stage presence, as well as his tormented vocals. If you look under all the layers of noise the song is really quite an incredible piece of work.
Demonologique 1 month ago
@MrGutley It's best if you just keep your pie-hole shut when it comes to something you obviously have no authority in.
thatvideosuckedhard 3 weeks ago
I'm not sure if I like it or not, but it's interesting.
Mertule93 1 month ago
All underground snobbery aside, this is thoroughly unenjoyable.
TheChirpingAssholes 1 month ago
@TheChirpingAssholes i think you mean to say its really awesome...
skrapyard444 1 month ago
I'm not sure whether this is supposed to be comedic or serious.
cadmus98 1 month ago
Throbbing Gristle is like a lost fetus in a dumpster. No one likes to talk about it, but its out there. Awesome music.
texasB666 1 month ago 12
@texasB666 best analogy
Decades81 1 month ago
esa tipa como que anda en drogas???
DarkOrlanD 1 month ago
@DarkOrlanD Drogas my friend definitely drogas ;P
dekiserbia 1 month ago
Our society turns people into fucking sheeps.
khoroshoorange 1 month ago
@khoroshoorange yes like cattle to the slaugther, nobody seems to rebel anymore, kids these days maybe...when mommy and daddy dont buy them an new iphone
gohan11223344 1 month ago
@gohan11223344
i dont know there is potential out there. like the occupy movement.
and a lot of good opinions but everybody gets screwed and oppressed.
in the end some people think "its no use" and submit. but i dont think this can go on forever. eventually things will peak.. i mean a lot of positive things have been achieved through dissident.
who knows whats going to happen in the future.
khoroshoorange 1 month ago
do anybody else's suggestions on the right there include a justin bieber christmas song featuring mariah carey? what a truly bizarre world we live in. i guess throbbing gristle and current child pop are now the same thing?
allmenarerapists 1 month ago in playlist anarko
America had hardcore punk.
England had, this. I don't even know what to call it. I could call it "industrial". But I'm not going to. I'm going to call it "this". But "this" is very good.
spicyMcHAGGIS9green 1 month ago
@spicyMcHAGGIS9green Do you like hardcore punk?
ohgr919 1 month ago
this is what it sounds like in my head every day at work, then i clock out, and pour some booze on the head and it sounds like LMFAO.
devoutheretic 1 month ago
love this!
jorave777 2 months ago
dis is eng-land
LenasAK47 2 months ago in playlist Weitere Videos von lelliesandremains
The best Song from TG!!!!
brutalmaster 2 months ago
this is fucking HORRIBLE whilst baked
ColtClockwork 2 months ago
fucking drugs
Suchinarov 2 months ago
LOL
zunaout 2 months ago
I just saw Genesis perform today. Man, he looks like a mess, but what a commanding voice. Absolutely fab.
GrogMindwhip 2 months ago
@GrogMindwhip Sorry, s/he looks like a mess, of course.
GrogMindwhip 2 months ago
Original industrial! I cut my teeth on this )
Thanks for putting it up!!!!
mitterben 2 months ago
WTF it got all gay at the end.
normtheclone 2 months ago in playlist normtheclone's favorites
I can't wait for the industrial version of the rapture.
liveatthewitchtrials 2 months ago
cmon you sheep want to get diciplined by Orridge, dont you?
khoroshoorange 2 months ago 3
@khoroshoorange I'd be a happy participant in an Orridge dictatorship
liveatthewitchtrials 2 months ago
@liveatthewitchtrials
haha okay i get the wood you get the oven..
khoroshoorange 2 months ago
somebody Discipline this dude, lol
NeoZource 2 months ago 3
Comment removed
PolichinelaAzul 2 months ago
Comment removed
PolichinelaAzul 2 months ago
i think he wants discipline
ohgr919 2 months ago 2
I make music with a very heavy Throbbing Gristle influence. If you like throbbing gristle you may (or may not, I don't know) enjoy my style of industrial music.
Lovejoydistribution 2 months ago
My speaker just fallen on the floor, while I listen to this.
letecagitara 2 months ago
fucking excellent
melbatunes 2 months ago
industrial music got much more complex as time went on thanks to people like trent reznor, but throbbing gristle gets under my skin more than pretty much any band. this is a great track that's also harrowing to listen to.
gpenn2 2 months ago
@gpenn2 you say complex. I say polished and for the most part souless :(. I mean did NIN actually SHOCK anyone like throbbing gristle did? Throbbing Gristle even shocked the punks...
Silenceless 2 months ago
@Silenceless NIN shocked lots of people when Downward Spiral became popular, but it's likely none of those people were remotely aware of Throbbing Gristle. I think there are more layers to NIN's music but Throbbing Gristle is more unsettling, in general. Both are great groups; they're rather different but I think both of have pushed lots of boundaries musically speaking. Just cause they have cheap imitators doesn't diminish what they've done.
gpenn2 2 months ago
@gpenn2 NIN is NOT industrial. It is alternative rock with influences of electronic music.
rivet138 2 months ago
@rivet138 have you really listened to nine inch nails? it's clearly industrial rock. just cause it's not purely industrial doesn't mean it doesn't fall under that category.
gpenn2 2 months ago
still got my Marc Almond Flexi...
futuristfood 2 months ago
After purchasing the third report by TG I started hunting for their other works but nothing is as good. In fact most of there stuff other than that album is pretty weak. TG doesn't even compare to the second wave of industrial music.
shamelessfootfucker 3 months ago
hmmm... nice pants
klawtheclown 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
........ What.
xXPurpleLoliTranceXx 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thumbs up if you can't stop laughing and you don't want to stop.
FuDuBuKu 3 months ago
the insects shall prevail !!!
davidaburdick 3 months ago
8:58 hahahahahah xDDDD
BioAbrax 3 months ago
うるさい。
kuinosenmonkey 3 months ago
someone didn't get enough hugs as a kid.
MrBlairblack 3 months ago 23
I pulled this album out at a acid party once and the reaction of my buds was like "wtf is that, where am I? I need to get out of here!" Priceless.
Thraxter 3 months ago 2
6:24 Look closely, it's Jello Biafra from Dead Kennedys.
Huaynocore 3 months ago 4
@Huaynocore I think it is. Or his clone Gummi Darfur.
S2Cents 3 months ago
yo nigguh i put this shit n i go rollin man just rolling around with this dope shit
atonsolaris 3 months ago
Comment removed
quicklern818 3 months ago
Little known fact: the guy at 8:58 is now one of the senior directors of Santander Banking group.
richievegas01 3 months ago 3
@richievegas01 pics or it didn't happen
SpleenMeurtrier 1 month ago
Comment removed
richievegas01 3 months ago
I'm so straight that I could kiss him too
luisDARTHvid 3 months ago
Wow this kind of stuff really grows on you...
Beenyad 3 months ago
Alot of eyeglasses in the audience...our current scientist???????????? hope so
sabalouie2000 3 months ago in playlist industrial.
Fuck yeah to everyone!
sex6cult9revolution 3 months ago
thats where electro and industrial came from
JAMROCK344 3 months ago
This really does seem to throw the musical rule book out of the window. Possibly the most fabulously original thing I've ever seen in my entire life.
johnwolcot 3 months ago in playlist johnwolcot's Favourited Videos 29
Seizure time!
LilxPipi 4 months ago
aslyum is the word that comes to mind.....
clipekamini 4 months ago in playlist Teeth: Electronic Punk
Clearly he NEEDS discipline and for someone to take that mic away from him...
PanicMaiden 4 months ago
@PanicMaiden you need some discipline.
pammenjk36 4 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
13 years old. I love it
TBoutwood 4 months ago
...and they call NIN industrial
andrewburton12345678 4 months ago
I CAN`T GET UP!
ninfan98 4 months ago
ps: this is punker rockcorock
tuber232rebut 4 months ago
@tuber232rebut nope its industrial
almanacofsleep 4 months ago
comments include: thanks for the video of my favorite band playing my favorite song and fuck the detractors.
tuber232rebut 4 months ago
Chaos...great.
2020kei 4 months ago
This is NOT PUNK ROCK!!
cyberduke23 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out many rare TG tapes to download at dieordiy.blogspot.com
YearZeroRecords 4 months ago
So good.
LupiWolfman 4 months ago
Jazz isn't dead, it just smells funny...Frank Zappa
Thraxter 4 months ago
people like this should just die
Geoffrey44111 4 months ago
I have a cold right now. This is so therapeutic =w=
PoisonInc 4 months ago
I think without Throbbing Gristle, electronic music wouldn't have gone agressive and noisey. This is the best!!!
tie32101 4 months ago
@2:54 haha i like the expression on that man in da audience
sleepyfish 4 months ago
who cares if it's noise, it's fucking awesome noise
truthemulator 5 months ago 18
@truthemulator fuck yes its fucking awesome fucking noise as fucking awesome as fucking awesome fucking noise has fucking ever fucking been
swzaworski 2 months ago
I'm not constipated anymore...
MirrorballJack 5 months ago
im 12 what is this
hlakeffol 5 months ago
@hlakeffo 89127p
davidgrahamscott 4 months ago
8:58 : mind=blown
bloodpollen 5 months ago
Brutal, Beautiful
ciaobella65 5 months ago
Is it just me or does the first four seconds of the video remind you of those inspirational posters?
panasonic1978 5 months ago 2
All of you are, like, slaves to the corporations...and shit!
TheEloeo 5 months ago 4
272 don't know their industrial roots.
perdedoronline 5 months ago
Isso que é música do absurdo ! Maravilhoso!! hahaha. Que performance? Me caguei de felicidade. Muita arte.
henriqueverleun 5 months ago
the best kátharsis!!!><
Tanoos 5 months ago
Fabulous
seanus4508 5 months ago
Pretentious.
sirderam1 5 months ago
@sirderam1 Yes, because I see these guys plastered everywhere like they were the next U2.
headbangin1 5 months ago
MORE FUCKING FILTH AND HORROR
av949 5 months ago
nice stuff ^^
PenguLala 5 months ago
Omg this is sooo AMAZING. Its first time i listen to this band, one guy send to me like "the most horrible song" but i liked it so much!!!
SuperYiff 5 months ago
I like the part where everyone is on acid listening to great music. :DD
swzaworski 5 months ago
If you don't like it, then fuck off.
Simple.
pammenjk36 5 months ago
This guy must have gotten his hands on a bad batch of blotter... just sayin.
jlm420 5 months ago
It's impossible for people to like this as music. Maybe they like it as noise, but this is not music.
rikolasdf 5 months ago
Comment removed
teledynepost 5 months ago
@rikolasdf What you say implies a very narrow minded definition about music. Music is a form of art, and art is the freedom of self-expression. It means it has no rules, no laws, you do it whatever you think would get your point across.
When a medium is guided by strict rules it ceases being art, and makes the first step to becoming a product. Just because this is harder to consume than, let's say, pop music, you can't just go and say it's not music. Not liking it is personal preference.
MrCl1nt 5 months ago
@MrCl1nt I'm not trying to apply strict rules to the medium of music, but if there are no rules, how can something be considered a part of such a medium? All I'm saying is I feel that, if someone were to write up a list of very loose rules that describe what music is, this would not abide by enough of them to be considered music. I'm not saying you can't like listening to this, but I really don't see how it is music. It is certainly art, but I do not consider it music.
rikolasdf 5 months ago
@rikolasdf Music is the expression of experience via sound. What differentiates music from noise is that There's intent to express experience behind it. Your claim that this is noise is unfounded.
Distortion0 5 months ago
@rikolasdf music is a sound deliberately engineered for conveying a concept.at least that's the way i think of it :)
gramOneEpoha 5 months ago
@rikolasdf I would understand if you said that about something like a Nurse With Wound song, but this is pretty rhythmic.
Beenyad 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Why anyone would like this "band" is beyond me. Genesis P. Orridge is so annoying. I can actually stand some of the songs where he doesnt sing like that one D.O.A song, but all he does is just scream or mumble. Boring, Uninspiring, unmanly, and a wimpy fag who wants to be a girl....yep thats throbbing gristle.
MushroomBluex 5 months ago
paint it any way you want you fucking todd browingh freak show fucks, this is magic mushroom fodder!!!! cunts!!
ThePiginshit 5 months ago
This is awesome.
Blockhausofficial 5 months ago
they all look like they're on yellow cake.haha
KittyKat1e95 5 months ago
9:00: classic!
vichilicsful 5 months ago
This band grew on me. This whole genre is not big on the talent concept. In other words that doesn't make a band good. Also this band it self is out there and not easy to relate too. Especially cause their flow is a bit odd and the mind set of Genesis is nutters, although the whole of the dark 70-80's thing is that way. But they got a song "Don't do as your told do as you think". So at least their not combative to haters like other band and genres, they are open people.
Jiveturkey68 5 months ago
Jesus fucking christ this is terrible! And all you fags pretending you like it because its as you so bluntly put it "Its anti-music, its not supposed to sound good" "The more terrible the better!". My 7 year old brother with down syndrome does shit just like this on my casio all the time. [random key smashing/demo beat on keyboard] [Screams gibberish into mic so hard that it crackles]
gorillailla202 6 months ago
@gorillailla202 someone should give your little brother a record deal
almanacofsleep 5 months ago
@gorillailla202
So because you don't like the song, you feel the need to not only imply that anyone who likes it is not only a "Fag" but is only pretending to like to be cool, but you also feel the need to exploit the fact that your son has down syndrome to prove your point on the internet.
Congratulations, you are a piece of shit.
ScrewLimbBizkit 5 months ago 4
@ScrewLimbBizkit Thats some hilarious shit man :D
texasB666 4 months ago
I wuv ooo
babawawaba1 6 months ago
Anti-music at its finest.
xNukeUx 6 months ago