I prefer Kate's Bush version, but I like this cover very much. I wonder, perhaps this might even be more like Kate meant it. She originally wanted to call it 'a deal with God', but her producers wouldn't let her.
Kate's version is still very sereen, this is wilder. I like both versions for their own identity, but I am more the silent type, which is why in the end I prefer Kate's version.
l also do not like the attempt to make this song "cool" for metal heads who thought the song was cheesy.But the girl really is a good singer. l'm sure she had something to do with them covering it in the first place. she sounds well rehearsed...like shes known it for a while
I like this version but I like the placebo version better, I think he sings it better, but that's just my opinion. this version has a better intro though.
I like the chorus, but the verses seem... I dunno, out of beat? Anyway, I think Placebo's cover is betetr, though if the quality of the entire song was like the chorus, this version would be pretty good IMO.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ei ijos de puta ingleses,menos critikas ke xa os gustaria cantar kmo la piba esta, aora en ingles xD.
ey you hopless bastard, you suck, you will die, because you say wich song is a fuck shit, but you must wish sing same her, and view you close you bitch and big mouth, asieske os callais la uta bocaza gilipollas, putos ingleses
Not even a touch on Kate Bush's version, but then again, it's Kate Bush so nobody could be expected to get anywhere near her in terms of brilliance. Nice cover though, prefer it to Placebo's as it keeps closer to the original meaning.
I like the original better, but thats usually the case with any cover song though. Even so, I think they did a good job on their cover, making it their own. And her voice as always sounds amazing.
Placebo's version is so much different to WT's, neither are rubbish, they both have different emotional takes on the song. Personally I prefer WT's because it's more of positive upbeat cover than Placebo's.
@kain625: DAMNIT! Excuses als je christelijk bent. Ik droom er gewoon van om ooit eens naar ze te kunnen. Ben echt ongelofelijk jaloers op je. Nou ja, veel plezier bij het concert iig x']
Eh, not bad. I like Kate Bush's original version and Placebo's cover better. But then again, I like appreciate a lower range than the singer sings in this version.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ok.. help me.. this can't be.. the cover is terrible... and I think that Shanon is responsible for that... she sings bad.. no,no bad.. she sings awful.....
ok.. help me.. this can't be.. the cover is terrible... and I think that Shanon is responsible for that... she sings bad.. no,no bad.. she sings awful.....
THIS BEATS THE KATE BUSH VERSION ALL TO HELL!!!!!
trish2658 1 month ago
THIS BEATS THE KATE BUSH VERSION ALL TO HELL!!!!!!
trish2658 1 month ago
I am in love with Sharon, thanks to my girlfriend :) Look at her!! :O
SummerHaze90x 2 months ago
i love within temptation, but i'm not a fan of this cover :( i do like placebo's though, i think i just it sung softly and sadly
gorguzzcat 3 months ago
I prefer Kate's Bush version, but I like this cover very much. I wonder, perhaps this might even be more like Kate meant it. She originally wanted to call it 'a deal with God', but her producers wouldn't let her.
Kate's version is still very sereen, this is wilder. I like both versions for their own identity, but I am more the silent type, which is why in the end I prefer Kate's version.
Sunshineflower94 3 months ago
Awesome singer, awesome band (I love WT)... but as a fan of the original song I'm going to quietly pretend this cover doesn't exist....
rayjaymor85 7 months ago
l also do not like the attempt to make this song "cool" for metal heads who thought the song was cheesy.But the girl really is a good singer. l'm sure she had something to do with them covering it in the first place. she sounds well rehearsed...like shes known it for a while
livelylunatic 7 months ago
What THE FREAK?
this is terrible
samlovesisaiah 7 months ago
lacks all the emotion and individuality of the original by kate bush and the cover by placebo. :\ nice try though
cheesemaker3000 8 months ago
This version of the song sucks
twittermonz 9 months ago
........nope, still not as good as the original.
TheCookieDookie 1 year ago
the guitars are cheesy
bigsunman 1 year ago
I think the Placebo is the best
megan8rox 1 year ago
Kate Bush all the way!
sorcerer101567 1 year ago 2
OH
MY
GOD
NO
STOP IT
They totally killed this song :(
xolo222 3 years ago
I like this version but I like the placebo version better, I think he sings it better, but that's just my opinion. this version has a better intro though.
Ordosmentat 3 years ago
I like Within Temptation's cover better than Placebo's. But I like WT overall better than Placebo, so that might explain it xD
Sharon's voice is really amazing, perfect for this song I think (:
WanderingCarrot 3 years ago 7
I like the chorus, but the verses seem... I dunno, out of beat? Anyway, I think Placebo's cover is betetr, though if the quality of the entire song was like the chorus, this version would be pretty good IMO.
Glittersong 3 years ago
I agree there's something off about the verses...maybe it's because I heard Placebo's cover first...huh i dunno but it's a great song!
Cadence87109 3 years ago
the best version..if u dont like it go watch the 1 u prefer intsead of wastin ya time moanin
aronpo666 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
RUINED THE SONG.
placebo's cover isnt even that great, but it was so much better than this.
emileeeena 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
God, this cover is so bad :|
*going to throw up*
stav181 3 years ago
still a great cover, but I prefer the Placebo version. tough call though... I think it depends on mood.
spritzertog 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ei ijos de puta ingleses,menos critikas ke xa os gustaria cantar kmo la piba esta, aora en ingles xD.
ey you hopless bastard, you suck, you will die, because you say wich song is a fuck shit, but you must wish sing same her, and view you close you bitch and big mouth, asieske os callais la uta bocaza gilipollas, putos ingleses
fukingcrack 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this cover sucks
Bailio672 3 years ago
Yay 8D
The one and only good version :D
AkimasaChan 3 years ago 4
Within temptation Have the best Version !
Nice Voice nice Video Clip
althought it is a little old
From 2003 but it is Nice !!
itisthefear 3 years ago 3
gadverdamme wat een troep
Mariokaaa 3 years ago
Wat nou troep?
Je weet gewoon niet wat goede muziek is ^^
EvanescenceWTfreak 3 years ago
Waarom luister je het dan? Wie weet vinden andere mensen die jouw muziek luisteren wel troep, nou en? Laat ze toch!
Je hoeft het toch niet te luisteren? :}
30STMxBritt 3 years ago
this version-not my fav. personally prefer placebo's version, but at least WT sticks to the meaning of the song.
Neither holds the creepy and eerie feeling that forces its way out like Kate Bush.
kasumi421 3 years ago 2
Heks
Placebo rocks !
iLoveEmoooo 3 years ago 2
Houd je bek emo.
Met je heks.
Scheldnietmet heksen.
En deze versie is duidelijk beter
EvanescenceWTfreak 3 years ago
Not even a touch on Kate Bush's version, but then again, it's Kate Bush so nobody could be expected to get anywhere near her in terms of brilliance. Nice cover though, prefer it to Placebo's as it keeps closer to the original meaning.
ourbovinepublicxx 3 years ago
great video&I love her...:x
krasavitam 3 years ago 3
I like the original better, but thats usually the case with any cover song though. Even so, I think they did a good job on their cover, making it their own. And her voice as always sounds amazing.
timbrelelaynebilbrey 3 years ago
Placebo's version is so much different to WT's, neither are rubbish, they both have different emotional takes on the song. Personally I prefer WT's because it's more of positive upbeat cover than Placebo's.
HayleyShark 3 years ago 3
im a fan of placebo,and in comments i saw that this version is better,i expected ''something'' im sorry,but i really don't like this version
Mijatboki 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song is TERRIBLE
legolove21 3 years ago
I don't think I've ever heard a band butcher a song as viciously as this. That's just comedy gold.
SoulDischarge 3 years ago 2
I love this song!
martunia2205 3 years ago 2
Mein Lieblingslied von WT.
^____^
katechan3 3 years ago
the are super!and sharon rocks
spyros90909 3 years ago 3
Kzie ze in novemberXD WT is gwn zooo goed (khoop dat ze wat oudere nummers ook spelen inplaats alleen maar van Heart of Everything )
Kain625 3 years ago
@kain625: DAMNIT! Excuses als je christelijk bent. Ik droom er gewoon van om ooit eens naar ze te kunnen. Ben echt ongelofelijk jaloers op je. Nou ja, veel plezier bij het concert iig x']
MedusaSeduca 3 years ago
Eh, not bad. I like Kate Bush's original version and Placebo's cover better. But then again, I like appreciate a lower range than the singer sings in this version.
stuffinsthegreat 3 years ago
I love how she sings "But see how deep the bullet lies" the way she sings it just sounds so bad ass XD
humansr4teddybears 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow this video and cover are embarrassing.
bobajob69 3 years ago
this video is too cool !!
itisthefear 3 years ago
indeed :)
iLoveEmoooo 3 years ago
perfect as many other perftect songs (:
killlingRulz 3 years ago
Is this on an album or is it a single? and if so then which 1?
taylorswann7 3 years ago
it's from the 2003 Running Up That Hill single.
Geckorine 3 years ago
the first 36 seconds sounds so naruto-like
RyukoSatoko 3 years ago
this video was there before naruto went successful over europe anyway :P
Moehre01 3 years ago
good song
fanuchiha7 3 years ago
This is the best song ever..
TrannySmella 3 years ago
In my opinion this is one of their more creative videos. I'm glad they mad it into a single.
AttackOFTHEPIE 3 years ago
made*
AttackOFTHEPIE 3 years ago
Is this about some higher spirit merging with her body self? or something looks awesome.
Sambucacat 3 years ago
It's a remake of a Kate Bush song. I think it is about women and men not understanding each other.
metalguyx25 3 years ago
Woot, gothic rock!
Raziel167 4 years ago
At the end? Feather... Angel Feather
TKeeey 4 years ago
yes an angel feather
itisthefear 3 years ago
what is she holding in her hand??
krockbonebreaker 4 years ago
a feather
itisthefear 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok.. help me.. this can't be.. the cover is terrible... and I think that Shanon is responsible for that... she sings bad.. no,no bad.. she sings awful.....
Denchoooo 4 years ago
Her name's Sharon.
And she's an excellent singer in my opinion.
corruptedbylove 4 years ago 10
sorry.I know her name :) She is excellent singer,thats why I was so disappointed.... :)
Denchoooo 4 years ago
Why are you disappointed? She is BRILLIANT in every sing she sings!!!!!!!
taylorswann7 4 years ago
not in this one.. but this is my opinion...
Denchoooo 4 years ago
you don't make any sense
RyukoSatoko 3 years ago
she is COOL
itisthefear 3 years ago
ok.. help me.. this can't be.. the cover is terrible... and I think that Shanon is responsible for that... she sings bad.. no,no bad.. she sings awful.....
Denchoooo 4 years ago
waiting for it to load...
TophBeifong2272 4 years ago
luv the band, but not impressed with the song or the vid.
TophBeifong2272 4 years ago
LOVE IT!! Such a great and skilled band! I haven't found a song yet that I don't like!
buffshakey 4 years ago 2
Sorry aber des is ja ma grauenvoll -.-
HelenameetsEmily 5 years ago