Hilary Duff - Stranger live

[Bongggggggggggg]

Sad that she always lip-syncs...

[eulermg20]

She is voicing for sure. I'm a fan of Hilary and I know a few presentations that she can sing really well live too. Live music are often better than the studio, even if any singer out of tune sometimes. Finally, there can´t be so faithful live performance recorded music like this and some of Hilary.

[lilsakli]

She is singing live. The part "your secret's safe" (2:10) you can hear her breathe out 'safe-huh'... lol. >.> And the part "such a long way back" (2:46) you can hear her inhale sharply. That's my take. T>T

[TheUrBlablabla]

нужно быть глухим чтобы не услышать идентичность этого "живого исполнения" с записью...

[Alexzandraponce]

doesnt anyone ever figer that she sing live on everythin n she actully sings like that ?i have actaually met someone that talented

[Mariezee44]

=[ I've been looking for a live version of this where she actually sings but I can't find one! I'd love to hear this with her actually singing, the little imperfections of live performances are what make it special.

[hoopsnyoyo15]

@Mariezee44 this is live. ... she sings soooo well ... that is what she is known for

[MegaMegaAlex]

omg i love her!! like she is really sexy without being sleazy ;)

[starmaker28]

you can't lip sing with a microphone people she only has a back up track she is singing live

[hannahISthepanic]

@starmaker28

Umm. She was obviously just holding the mic while lip-syncing?

Haha.

[notavailable9393]

she is singing live ppl.. just because certain porcelain disney chicks cant sing live doesnt mean hillary isnt singing live..

[beckyjokerwhite]

hilary duff never is singing live, its to risky cuz shes not a naturel singer!!

[mikaylahx06]

@beckyjokerwhite I have seen her in concert,

and she deffinitley sings live. She is just very good at singing. She has backup tracks, but that's her.

I know this because at one point in the concert, Hilary started crying and you could hear her voice crackle whenever she got upset.

[xfernydrummerX]

man i wish i was her drummer

[cbba18]

i dont likehow she looks here...her hair is too dark for her skin, needs to go back to blonde

[kivancis]

this girls can't sing

[TheSpeedyboy77]

@kivancis shut up !!

[TheSunshineKisses]

who cares if shes not singing live... who does? not very many people!

[miley1277]

i just her thunder

[xxchristinenguyenxx]

Why does she have to be lip syncing?

Why can't ppl just realize that she's a great singer

rather than singing horribly for them to see its live?

[swphotos]

@xxchristinenguyenxx but she is lip syncing.. no one's voice sounds synthesized/computerized naturally.

[mattz10101]

@xxchristinenguyenxx She's miming. Exact same as the CD vocals.

[TheSpeedyboy77]

@mattz10101 shut up !!

[7891midnight]

why does she always lip sing? thats so damn lame. why bother going to her concerts if shes not even going to sing? shes not even into her music you can totally tell

[3333alex]

there are a lot of reasons a singer can lip sync, maybe she didn't feel like it... maybe she was sick.-.- honestly, stop stomping because someone lip syncs... it's not like it's a concert..-.-

[bambiblue96]

that is so not live

[cortana74]

This Song is okay,but this is not live!!No Way!!!!

[jonasluverx397]

Is she singing live ?

[burnXliesX]

Ok I am a hilary fan but I dont get why she lip synchs. I get why britney does because she dances and puts on a big show. but hilaary doesnt dance like britney does. Its lame!

[RayRayRayVideos]

en sus shows en vivo usan las mismas pistas de voz que usan en sus discos, nada mas que con un poco menos de correccion del melodyne.

lo que si es en vivo es su banda.

[RayRayRayVideos]

@BoaFanMade te lo escribo en español porque mi ingles no es perfecto.

la unica vez que hilary duff canto en vivo fue en MTV NEW YEAR 2004

pero solamente la ultima parte, porque su lipsync dropeo y no le quedo otra que seguir con su pobre voz...

canta en sus discos, eso es verdad, pero su voz esta toda maquillada con melodyne, como cantante en vivo es pesima

[alvaro6968]

hay un error en el minuto 3:37 jaja derrepente se cambia el micro de lado en una esecena a otra y no le ha dao tiempo a levantar el brazo, joee con lo q me gusta hilary como puede tener esos cortes y falos

[jortiz612000]

ur awesome hilary and u sound awesome i luv u

[avrilanum]

she reallly should sing live, its better than lipsinging, dont matter its good or not

[RayRayRayVideos]

she never sings live

[BoaFanMade]

@RayRayRayVideos -.- Shes been singing for years. She has sung live..just not this song

[TheDeutch119]

i like this song)but i don't think that its a live show(((

[bentla17]

I wish that she would just sing live at least once!

[oxXxPaulinaxXxo]

her outfit is wow

[AlexsisProductions]

@oxXxPaulinaxXxo wow good? or wow bad :P lol im not so sure im liking it lol

[LilShortyr888]

it is live, they just put the playback on also, and it just so happens that hilary sounds amazing live, almost the exact same as the original

they use effects to enhance her voice but it is live.

you're just used to lots of celebrities nowadays who sound like crap and nothing like the original live.

[LOTRrulz]

yes there is playback but she is still singing with the playback... she's doin the harmony that you hear & the playback is the melody. I can point this out b/c i love music its my passion & i've been round it since i was born!

[LiiLBreakeR]

oh lol how stupid r u ?

ever heard something about cutting?

[LiiLBreakeR]

this is so fucking not live!

[MakeupByClarissa]

@LiiLBreakeR Yes it is, she just fuckin lip synchs all the time. Shes super fake.

[MAYOUCHKAYA]

@MakeupByClarissa yes I think it really is a pity what's the "use" of a "live" if the "singer" doesn't sing ????? just being there, well-dressed and all ??

[MakeupByClarissa]

@MAYOUCHKAYA Lol, Exactly.

[Azn1563417x]

o_o 3:37 how did the chair end up being behind her dance when she was dancing behind the chair? xD talk about pausing and resuming the show after switching the chairs lol

[JustMeD902]

lol the dancers brought the chair out

[sexychick997]

inncorrect belly dancing moves and her mouth isn't in key with the words half the time

[Jenny724bby]

She is soo pretty!! I love her!

she is like my role model!!.

AMAZING!!<3=]

[Cvacrockstheworld]

ok then

[NiniHoa]

I love this song!!

Hilray, you´re amazing =)

[laughoutloud131]

miss the old hilary.

[birdmanbubba]

she is more beautiful then Britney and sexier Britney is a little whore

[JCWT07]

Famous Whore.

[limepunkrocker]

@birdmanbubba Please, don't say mean words just to compare.

[landgay101]

@birdmanbubba lol she's not hotter than britney.

she may be a whore but shes a hot whore

[Abercrombito]

@birdmanbubba maybe a whore but a whore that everyone wants to fuck.... and you? forever alone dumb fuck

[Ahgwenas]

@birdmanbubba u have no right to say that. U CAN'T EVEN SPELL!

[PinkPaw187]

totally brunabessamusic

[brunabessamusic]

I love her!

Doesn't seem like shes singing live though =/

[purplegummibear89]

She doesnt you can tell cause she sounds the same and makes no mistakes and thats impossible no ones perfect. And they ALWAYS change singers voices so she should saound at least a lil different

[nikowlhd]

@brunabessamusic this is live sounds different her voice listen the studio version

[kingzach74]

@brunabessamusic She is singing live, you can hear her breathe in deeply if you listen closely.

[kingzach74]

@brunabessamusic She is singing live, you can hear her breathe in deeply if you listen closely. I can make my voice sound robotic when singing, it takes a lot of practice but I've done it in front of my friends just to show them it's possible. I can even change my voice from country sounding to pop, to rap and back again in the middle of a song. It just takes practice.

[Peteluver145]

I remember watching this performance on TV when i was like, in 6th grade.. aw memories :)

[Mileyanze]

Have a look: At 3:37 shes standing behind the chair. And after shes in front of it. Love her, though =)

[jintheband]

omg that is sooo funny

[amirulmanaf]

O_O how is that even possible??? I was trying to figure out whether her dance move at 3:37 could've ended with her being in front.

[lololHAHAyeahwooYEE]

I'm not a fan of Hilary or Britney,

but at least miss duff has more class.

[ThebestisHilary]

si fuese una de esas espectadorass :D te amo muchisimo hilary

[HugeFanOfBritney]

Hilary is nothing comparing Britney,they have 2 different styles,they both can sing!

[asia4ya]

i think ppl should just drop it because everyone has different opinions so plz just drop

[mamurrr]

she is not singing live right now....

[nikowlhd]

i love Hilary Duff and shut the fuck up the fans of Britney please go to see the fucking videos of the britbitch...Hilary The Best always and forever

[brown637]

I like britney and hilary and thanks for telling me to shut the fuck up, so much for having class.

[RuuBjAh1]

I absolutely adore hilary but Britney is also one of the best of the world, so... you should dhut up about britney

[HugeFanOfBritney]

exactly! Hilary is a great singer but her fame isnt even close with Britney's. I Loveee Hilary,hope she gets more attention

[andreadastoli]

hilary it's better that britney in everything!!

[MrShawtyshorty]

plz britney is like a million times more sucessful,britney can dance better has earn a grammy and has sold 80 millions copies more than hilary if you gonna talk shit at least get it right

[prettygrl222]

hey only britney gets away with lip syncing...lol cause she dances her booty off

[AliskaKiska7]

It's a playback. yon can tell.

I'm a HUGE Hilary fan and she has such a great voice so why not to use it and use playback?!

Her Dignity tower performances were totally live and she was AMAZING!

[Rebellion4BritneyV]

Its cos she doesn't want 2 sound bad on tv, while cameras arent supposed to be brought on her concerts.

[reeeeita]

er yes they are. dignity tour dvd!

[Rebellion4BritneyV]

They're the official cameras. Cameras arent supposed to be brought by public members. Everyone does it though...

[XannyxTokioHotel]

She sings very good, because she sounds live the same as on a cd. Some artist can't do that, like Katy Perry... (if you are a fan from her, I don't hate her or so, I just think she can't sing)

[sexidreamgurl]

cause she lip synced duh

[kennyemerson2]

i dont fully agree with the whole Katy Perry can't sing live, she can, but most of the time she is running around or something (making her sound bad) but ive seen her sing where she just stands there and she sounds great then :)

[Andrea0one]

ツHiLaRy ThE BeST !!!

[AimeeHopeGirl1234567]

shes got juno hair!!

[ArtistWoOoOo]

cool nice clothes,but it's not a live

[pmorerules]

im sorry, i really love hilary and all, but her vocals here sound way too much like the vocals in the original, recorded song.

[pmorerules]

♥♥

[jess91496]

I <3 this song!

[Rushmoney123]

She is hot, I love hilary.. xxx

[YourCathe]

Nice vid ;)