she is so adorable!!! gosh, people, i've never heard such a wonderful voice! no, honestly, i've heard a lot of amazing singers, but this!... oh i just ran out of words! she's perfect!
@sport3888 yeah, me too!!! :D i think the emotion was just right and hearing this song in the night kind of makes me want to cry hahaa......for some reason, i think this version is better than the original since in the original hebe doesn't seem to convey this sad feeling as well as Jing
@coolchi totally agree! I also think the original bye Hebe didn't convey the sadness that Jing could in this live version! But nonetheless Jing's emotional singing is her specialty =D
好獨特的音 好聽阿
a609178919 1 day ago
张芸京穿裙子嗎?
k0989436608 1 week ago
好難聽....佢唱到好辛苦
lamhiowai 2 weeks ago
@lamhiowai 因为重感冒还没好,也不是芸京的key,对她而言这个key太高。
chintsTS 2 weeks ago
@lamhiowai
也不算難聽吧..
ka2ss501 1 day ago
有時懷疑佢係男定女??連把聲都係男聲...
JUMBOIONG 2 weeks ago
@JUMBOIONG 係女!其實聽真啲,都會覺得係女聲,我啲fd都話係女聲:)
loveJingForever96 1 week ago
不错~很好了~男生的key唱女声歌~不错
devillee89 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@devillee89 阿京是女生 ~ :)
yeesheng89 3 weeks ago
還是寶刀未老:))
超偶裡面數一數二的場唱將!!
jenascia8149 1 month ago 3
阿京的key原本就是偏向男生的音域,加上重感冒,唱到這樣也不錯了吧
Fahren520 1 month ago 7
jing jing
ilovejingchang 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
怪怪的說~~菸嗓
race1222 2 months ago
京的key不適合唱這首個,但她還是勇敢的挑戰了,很棒啦!!
minwei980728 2 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
他真的不適合這首歌
940039martin 2 months ago
假音真的很棒
i861114 2 months ago 6
好厲害啊! 病了還到這樣! :)
這歌真的好難唱!!
tracylauloveeason 2 months ago 10
Hahaha! Ending hilarious! Love her cute English! :)
o0ThatGirl0o 2 months ago
田馥甄
s27945 3 months ago
就算感冒了也还是很好听~ 加油!
AlbeeXiao 3 months ago 4
晕!!!走到完。。。。。
yiaphwee 3 months ago
哎唷!!!我說小京京呀..唱就這麼辛苦就別唱了嘛.你唱得辛苦.害我看得更辛苦/___\超心痛的說/口\
WasabiKitYee 3 months ago 11
阿京的精神讓人佩服 都生病了還唱這首 很棒
firegodone1 3 months ago 11
好心疼喔0..一定很痛><
mi574351 3 months ago
wahaha it's really just like shen me dou mei you, and she stopped cause there wasn't anything for her to read.
genetic87 3 months ago
啊京唱得好辛苦喔........好心痛哦..........聽得出來.......
angelliu0121 4 months ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
難聽...走音冇氣上唔到真音轉假音..佢唱得辛苦時..我聽得都好辛苦
barrydconm 4 months ago
@barrydconm
呢首歌唔易唱嫁.
人地岩岩感冒. 你睇下cm先批評啦.
lukyauyip 4 months ago 7
@barrydconm 我都覺得你做人做得好辛苦,咁得閒嚟批評人,不如去睇返你鍾意既人唱算啦,咁呀京個日感冒,梗係唱得無咁跟返原唱-唱架啦,而且唱歌要有自己個人風格,唔通真係要唱到跟原唱一模一樣就叫個人風格??我睇你係度批評都覺得你好辛苦;@
loveJingForever96 2 months ago 5
好怪=口=
她聲音感冒了...不太適合唱這首
他的聲線
kino71126811 4 months ago
...
peter60207 4 months ago
我覺得他不會不適合啊
唱的很好聽耶...
fahrolhejp951052 5 months ago 9
she is so adorable!!! gosh, people, i've never heard such a wonderful voice! no, honestly, i've heard a lot of amazing singers, but this!... oh i just ran out of words! she's perfect!
VojnaZakon4itsja 5 months ago 3
阿京感冒好像很重的样子 唱着的时候样子看起来很难受...心痛了啊T.T..
a674594069 5 months ago 12
為呀京感到心痛了T^T
就算感冒了也努力唱,
她的音其實本來就不適合唱這首歌,
但她也唱下去了..值得讚賞
我個人覺得她唱得不錯~!!
loveJingForever96 8 months ago in playlist :) 15
Hebe's version better than this!
kuterabbit1010 8 months ago
hahahaha, "theng theng theng" - wow
Raymetrious 8 months ago
加油~阿京
jennylam30 8 months ago
聽的出她感冒了~加油~
baby60318 8 months ago 9
生病了,就不要勉强
chuacalyn 8 months ago
早點看破才看的見以後
SpeShow2012 8 months ago
JerryC
s27945 9 months ago
omg!!! he is a she?
eltinxd 9 months ago
It's too high for her. Her vocals must've been tired xDDD
kathportula 9 months ago
恩 這首歌不是他的音域 鼻音也真的好重... 我自己是每次感冒就會氣喘併發,不知道京爺是不是也這樣?如果是的話,那真的很難唱歌欸,氣會變很短
kodog2259 9 months ago
@kodog2259 應該是吧,她本來都有氣喘病,那天她也有感冒..TT
loveJingForever96 2 months ago 3
WOW i thought she was a GUY... looks so much like a guy.. and the singing as well O___O" nice attempt though!!!
opie474 9 months ago
喉嚨聲很緊。其實真的很棒!!阿京,心疼你!!!
Callme1stFloor 10 months ago
雖然阿京感冒,這首個也不是阿京的range,但阿京唱的很有感情,讓人看到都心疼了。當然,hebe的技巧等等都比較好,但每個歌手都有自己吸引人的地方,而阿京的獨特魅力,就是來自她對歌的演繹,感情的投放,每一首歌經過她嘴裡都會變成她的歌
vanessaleeht 10 months ago 16
The original sings it better but good attempt! I know it's not her range.
jwutaijung 10 months ago
我只能說她很敬業!!你們是不會懂的!!辛苦了老大~妳唱的很棒!!真的!!
.
shuwei5320 11 months ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
真難聽 還是田馥甄真好,
合聲還比現場唱的人好聽~
bib114 1 year ago
病了也唱,好心痛喔.......
Ms3baby 1 year ago 3
其實也沒什麼好比較的吧~ :) 張芸京的range不適合唱到那麼高~ 中低音的range比較是她發揮的範圍~ 吊了3天點滴, 感冒還沒好, 但是還是選了挑戰這首歌, 只能說, 她是真的喜歡這首歌~
sherleen0407 1 year ago 161
@sherleen0407
981142981142 1 month ago
只能说阿京不适合唱这首歌,真音的地方她都用假音唱上去
live唱得好听的就只有原唱本身和她的粉丝郭映均,算是目前听过最好的两个版本live
TheLawrenceyong 1 year ago 4
這首歌先不說唱功,光是你跟音響的搭配(專業級),丹田用力忽大忽小的,再加上感情的投入。能夠百分百跟CD一模一樣,真的是太強能所難囉!!!PS:能勇敢挑戰這首歌的人都是值得嘉獎滴!
e2582257 1 year ago
I don't usually listen to Hebe's songs but I think Jing sang this very well, gave this emotional/sad feeling =(
sport3888 1 year ago
@sport3888 yeah, me too!!! :D i think the emotion was just right and hearing this song in the night kind of makes me want to cry hahaa......for some reason, i think this version is better than the original since in the original hebe doesn't seem to convey this sad feeling as well as Jing
coolchi 1 year ago
@coolchi totally agree! I also think the original bye Hebe didn't convey the sadness that Jing could in this live version! But nonetheless Jing's emotional singing is her specialty =D
sport3888 11 months ago 3
感冒了..这首歌有够难唱的..
being0710 1 year ago 96
這首田馥甄現場的確比較好聽
但其實田的現場跟cd也是有差距
v3071490203 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
田馥甄唱這首歌的live是好聽的。但這首歌唱live真的很難... 田馥甄的live演唱也只有在聲音沒那麽沙啞時才會唱的好=)
阿京的音域沒有那麽高所以唱的很吃力,加上感冒所以跑調了
shangyi 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
shangyi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
就算是田馥甄的live也沒有特別好聽 這歌真的太不好唱 最好聽的版還是CD版=)
rubytam0630 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rubytam0630 作人要服輸啊..
kizegel 5 months ago
love this song!
Monkeycraze 1 year ago 8
田馥甄唱得比较好听
daisyyan1 1 year ago 8
心痛死了T^T 阿京快點好起來......看著你這樣還要唱歌 真替你辛苦..
boy023489 1 year ago 2