You have a pretty voice but the way you sing this song alteres it completely. I prefer widely the original version. I wish you all the best if you want to belong to a boysband.
I agree, very, very good work on the keys, voice is not to bad, either. But maybe a bit too much vibrato here and there. I also have the 120s, had a Steely Dan Song book once, but I brought it back, because the arrangement was really bad. I like your playing quite a lot. I hope you can live with my little critique. Keep playing!
Hi Justin....is that in the right key?....lol...only kidding. Thiis a fantastic video, cool piano playing and a very natural singing style. Much respect. Andy :)
nice, u sounds good man i love steely dan and u do a hell of a cover let me know if u ever come down south a bit to phila or jersey i gotta cover band and we do alot of steely dan. Thanks
Absolutely amazin, man. My uncle got me into Steely Dan when I was in high school. Your versions of both SD and Billy are literally the best I have ever heard/seen. Keep it up. Always lookin for more from you. Love it!
oh my god dude, you ROCK!! brilliant singing. and that is one of my all time favorite songs, from my favorite album. keep up the good work, subscription added!
ps... some time when you're bored, PLEASE give "Don't Take Me Alive" from The Royal Scam album a cover.. Also, "My Old School" from Countdown to Ecstacy. :)
Great job! I remember when Katy Lied had just been released. I must have been about 20 years old. It's great to see a new generation appreciate and interpret this great music. You rock!
Keep it up. Donald Fagan is surely not unhappy to have you playing his compositions. Your versions are well done and you are clearly enjoying yourself. I will keep on steering people your way.
Re-read my commentary. I have no advice for JaYSpRE, just positive feedback. On the other hand, your negativity and poor reading comprehension is not welcome here. Next time try to portray yourself in a positive light or just put some maple syrup in your hair.
As I said, you are crazy, and this young piano player should disregard your wild rants and raves about his playing. As I said, I was just messin with you Sasquatch, but since you feel the need to demonstrate my point, I'll thank you for perfectly illustrating my original point, as I said. Rain Dance!
As I said, As I said, As I said. You are crazy man, you are crazy. I like you, but you're crazy. You act like you have an elephant tranquilizer dart stuck in your juggler. Put some ear muffs on when you are reading these comments and "Let it Rain". Don't forget your are not Columbo or for that matter Christopher Columbo.
Nothing preplanned, but you are correct in that we know each other. In fact we have been friends for over 35 years. As you can see there is some syncopation in our responses.
You are amazing! I love Steely Dan they are def. some major dudes! I admire you putting your own flavor into the song as well as keeping it balanced originally. Keep doing what your doing cause your amazing at it. paz, Angie Aries V
Just imagination... You weren't even born when SD were big! Nice versions. Nice voice. Just need to be aware of your tempo and attitude. Fagen always injects alot of sarcasm and wit in his vocal technic.
However, as a die-hard fan of Steely Dan, I need to say that if you were to play this song for a Steely Dan audience, I think you would have to take some of the drama out of it. I think the bit of perceived emotional detachment of Steely Dan music is part of what makes their music so ingenious. In the end, though, it winds up adding more emotional meaning to the songs at a higher intellectual level. Fagen and Becker don't give us "that cotton candy."
Justin, you're piano playing is very musical, and you have a great voice. If you were going to play Steely Dan to the general public, this is how you would want to do it.
To hear someone as young as you tackling these songs, I have to give you props,
as a Dan fan and musician I call it like it is... good work dude.
KATAO333 1 year ago
what are the chords?
Norocmorth 1 year ago
Great job :-)
Jacquie88 1 year ago
You have a good voice....but not a good voice for Steely Dan songs.
ThankGodforEvolution 1 year ago
Highly Disagree!
Jacquie88 1 year ago
@ThankGodforEvolution you know how to type well, but not much thought behind it.
firesidechet 1 year ago
nice...............
SurftarProductions 1 year ago
this is fantastic.
thomasrabon666 1 year ago
You have a pretty voice but the way you sing this song alteres it completely. I prefer widely the original version. I wish you all the best if you want to belong to a boysband.
Madimini 1 year ago 2
@Madimini
I agree, very, very good work on the keys, voice is not to bad, either. But maybe a bit too much vibrato here and there. I also have the 120s, had a Steely Dan Song book once, but I brought it back, because the arrangement was really bad. I like your playing quite a lot. I hope you can live with my little critique. Keep playing!
nettzwerg82 1 year ago
Nice playing and singing, five stars. - Makes me wish there were a bit better quality for the recording (or the video enconding).
HesleyCapey 1 year ago
what a great job man. you have a great voice and great piano playing too man. steely dan forever!!!!!!!!!
Bastiodon13 1 year ago
bravo 6star ciao massimo roby
campa3192 1 year ago
Cool! 5 stars
RazorShaw 2 years ago
Thank to "sistermoonshine13 " I could listen to this beautiful performance.
Thanks to all you
FAUSTORICCARDO 2 years ago
well done
northendnorman 2 years ago
Thanks to SIS for this great share! 5 glittering stars to you Jay and Love and Light - Sharine
SharineONeill 2 years ago
great job jay 5***** nice vocal cords man =)
chazdaspazman 2 years ago
Well done.
Donald Fagen always writes interesting lyrics and this song is no exception.
5*****
Thanks for the share Sis.
sproutcentral 2 years ago
Excellent.
monarch1957 2 years ago
very nice!
Jolie028 2 years ago
Good ! 5*****
litospain 2 years ago
Very good~~~~
slmwv34 2 years ago
Like your sincere personality...excellent performance.
MrSoftshoe 2 years ago
Good stuff...kudos!
FreakofFury 2 years ago
One man show!!Great voice and playing as well.Injoyed watching the video very much.((Thank you for sharing))
papadarby 2 years ago
Awesome Job!!...\mm/
MATTNMISSY 2 years ago
wonderful........thanks
foo2Le 2 years ago
Brilliant- you are very talented.
skylark51 2 years ago
Damn Good!!!!!*****
Nice chops.
Jak
RUBYMAIPRODUCTIONSJM 2 years ago
very good...no, excellent.
SNL0907 2 years ago
This is awesome..5*****
adamaeosvagabundos 2 years ago
Very nice. Really enjoy it :-))
plattform5163 2 years ago
Thanking Sis for sharing your talent with us!! I love Steely Dan & have never heard anyone play this on YT before!! Great piece!!
imafishgod 2 years ago
wow this is amazing..hellya!
sevenender 2 years ago
Very good!
franpanama 2 years ago
Nice Work Man!
*****
Thank's!
Curt
buster541 2 years ago
BRAVO!!!*****
wizhack 2 years ago
coolly done,, Salute
5 stars,,,,
not an easy song to play, vocals spot on.
natobaden 2 years ago
amazing !!! 100 stars
Melissa11rocks 2 years ago
great playing and vocals !!!
thx. fir share sis.
RITERAMETAL 2 years ago
great my friend 5*****
drago11311 2 years ago
thumbs up for you dude!!!
fantastic!!
daveebella09 2 years ago
awesome video...thanks sis...you send only the best....great job....10*...
KATLINRIMER08 2 years ago
amazing job!!!
rockguitarrabit 2 years ago
nice voice and good work on piano. +5 stars
beavismaxim 2 years ago
fantastic my friend great coice 5 stars
pinocantautore 2 years ago
Lovely , romantic piano sound !! Wonderfully played and great song // vid ! ***** :)
GCON3000 2 years ago
cheers Sis for the SUPER share
Hugs
Natasha, Georgina and the Global Family x
CDmagz 2 years ago
Great stuff here .
linktronics 2 years ago
Great cover ..Thanks Sis for sharing great music *****
Rocket
Ottawarocket 2 years ago
Very nice my friend regards
ashok
jadugarbhandari 2 years ago
very good
sabbia12 2 years ago
good video
kiwua1963 2 years ago
BRAVO *****
alrofril 2 years ago
Nice awesome song
well done 5 starts man, great job !
Thanks SIS.....
YShattered 2 years ago
You have great promise.I see you enjoy what your doing, and tht pleases me no end. more power to your broncho.
beachfrontal 2 years ago
awesome********
mktmic7 2 years ago
Great job
fendermac 2 years ago
Nice rendition of a cool song. Good rhythm, mighty fine vocals.
alternatemonkey 2 years ago
Cool sound and wonderfully played....
Fintolgano 2 years ago
***** :)))
IlSignoreNeroo 2 years ago
Oh..nicely done son...:) Thanks for the Satuday share Sis...:)
Kappa
Kappadanielson 2 years ago
Great sound !
ood2112 2 years ago
Enjoyed this one. Great talent. Thanx for sharing sis.
Jannen100 2 years ago
Very Good!
videoclipsmiami 2 years ago
yep...nicly done..!
externalcontrol 2 years ago
COOL!
sweetthing77203 2 years ago
you done good man
anden4fr 2 years ago
maravilloso!!!
1000*
un beso
LaLi1561 2 years ago
Good!
relwark 2 years ago
Hi Justin....is that in the right key?....lol...only kidding. Thiis a fantastic video, cool piano playing and a very natural singing style. Much respect. Andy :)
AndysOriginalSongs 2 years ago
wouah !!very good !!bravo !!*****
cogermax91 2 years ago
very cool
JonathanHasTalent 2 years ago
nice performance...!
drumsjillu 2 years ago
Like it!!
jooraye 2 years ago
fantastic....love it
timmyguitarmoore 2 years ago
Hollywood here ur star
gogocartoon11 2 years ago
That was truly beautiful
gogocartoon11 2 years ago
Sounds great and beautiful
Thank you very much for sharing Sister.
Friendly greetings,
Michael
michaelplaying 2 years ago
Awesome Man, Thanks to SIs for pointing me here !~ ~8^)
TDM
TheDigitalMafia 2 years ago
nicely done
djmerc135 2 years ago
very nice you have talent thanks for sharing sis
drnorris56 2 years ago
One word.........excellent.
baldyholly79 2 years ago
Love it! Pretty impressive. Love their music and some of it is hard to sing and play.
basicband 2 years ago
5 stars ! Your sounding good. ! --:)Rod
Cliffbrock 2 years ago
SOunding Sweet...thanks Sis
reliablebow 2 years ago
This is great!
Grubenpony12 2 years ago
Thanks Sis :o)tm ***** Good work
uncledave10 2 years ago
You did a good job man.
senorsquiid 2 years ago
Donald and Walter would approve!
MikesMusic123 2 years ago
Wow!...impressive
lukessummer 2 years ago
about sixth time now
your diction and phrasing has even made this song better for me
and that was a tall order after about 30 years
MehefinHeulog 2 years ago
this is JUST WONDERFUL
you have REAL TALENT!!
MehefinHeulog 2 years ago
Man, as a life long Steely Dan fan, I gotta say this is pretty damn good. You have a great voice and a Fagen-esque touch of soul. Keep doin it, man.
One SMALL thing -- there's a chord change after "so alone" that you seem to be leaving out. Other than that, everything works!
jaymusic143 2 years ago
Really good! Come out to California ( Just to play in my band!)
Vinnybrain 2 years ago
where are you from bro?
rdeberardinis22 2 years ago
Connecticut
JaYSpRE2007 2 years ago
tru we got an alternative/light rock band in jersey always culd use talent like urs
rdeberardinis22 2 years ago
nice, u sounds good man i love steely dan and u do a hell of a cover let me know if u ever come down south a bit to phila or jersey i gotta cover band and we do alot of steely dan. Thanks
rdeberardinis22 2 years ago
Fived and Faved I LUV THIS!!!
sistermoonshine13 2 years ago
Freakin' Amazing:)
steelywho77 2 years ago
Dude! ^^ I love it, nice version you did.
trigunlover11 3 years ago
Nicely done, young man!
theblobber 3 years ago
Absolutely amazin, man. My uncle got me into Steely Dan when I was in high school. Your versions of both SD and Billy are literally the best I have ever heard/seen. Keep it up. Always lookin for more from you. Love it!
spattered73 3 years ago
oh my god dude, you ROCK!! brilliant singing. and that is one of my all time favorite songs, from my favorite album. keep up the good work, subscription added!
godron 3 years ago
ps... some time when you're bored, PLEASE give "Don't Take Me Alive" from The Royal Scam album a cover.. Also, "My Old School" from Countdown to Ecstacy. :)
godron 3 years ago
great song and a brilliant cover
well done mate
NPBluebird 3 years ago
YOU ARE GREAT! And I LOVE Steely Dan...Bad Sneakers is a hard one to cover in my opinion and you nailed it!
Subbed!
Cheers from NY
gtristdan 3 years ago
got hooked on them and still can't let them go... great rendition...
tjmpiano 3 years ago
Great job! I remember when Katy Lied had just been released. I must have been about 20 years old. It's great to see a new generation appreciate and interpret this great music. You rock!
LionheartVegas 3 years ago
Many talent,beatifull voice,young age....all perfect...Italy comment!! lol
andreaszx10r 3 years ago
i was gonna say...wtf ??? wrong key. lol like anyone would know.
RenoRaider 3 years ago
i give this a thumbs and arms up great job i like it you were great awsome i added you to my favs ok love it
sealteem5 3 years ago
Great job man you really sound good
xpac09 4 years ago
wow dude that was amazing. props.
amplifya 4 years ago
Thanks a lot.
JaYSpRE2007 4 years ago
Nailed it. Katy Lied is my favorite album. Most kids your age play bullshit. You've got class my man!
igot1i 4 years ago 7
Sweeeeeeeeeet. Brought tears to my eyes. You really did this song justice. Donald would be proud of you my man.
Totally awesome.
Keep up the great work..:-)
ronandlane 4 years ago 3
ooh..nice ! great !!
eikels 4 years ago
Keep it up. Donald Fagan is surely not unhappy to have you playing his compositions. Your versions are well done and you are clearly enjoying yourself. I will keep on steering people your way.
mpobuck1 4 years ago
Don't listen to this guy, he is crazy. Just play normally, and try not to encourage him.
thesquonkstear 4 years ago
Re-read my commentary. I have no advice for JaYSpRE, just positive feedback. On the other hand, your negativity and poor reading comprehension is not welcome here. Next time try to portray yourself in a positive light or just put some maple syrup in your hair.
mpobuck1 4 years ago
As I said, you are crazy, and this young piano player should disregard your wild rants and raves about his playing. As I said, I was just messin with you Sasquatch, but since you feel the need to demonstrate my point, I'll thank you for perfectly illustrating my original point, as I said. Rain Dance!
thesquonkstear 4 years ago
As I said, As I said, As I said. You are crazy man, you are crazy. I like you, but you're crazy. You act like you have an elephant tranquilizer dart stuck in your juggler. Put some ear muffs on when you are reading these comments and "Let it Rain". Don't forget your are not Columbo or for that matter Christopher Columbo.
mpobuck1 4 years ago
Pick and Roll-- Outlet! White Chocolate!
thesquonkstear 4 years ago
This seemingly preplanned dialogue has made my night... That was hilarious! How long have you two known each other?
JaYSpRE2007 4 years ago
Nothing preplanned, but you are correct in that we know each other. In fact we have been friends for over 35 years. As you can see there is some syncopation in our responses.
mpobuck1 4 years ago
Yes, it was either mumbo jumbo or inside jokes... I couldn't tell... It was hilarious though...
JaYSpRE2007 4 years ago
I suspect you mean jugular.
RenoRaider 4 years ago
nice job man!!!
zelopes2007 4 years ago
You are amazing! I love Steely Dan they are def. some major dudes! I admire you putting your own flavor into the song as well as keeping it balanced originally. Keep doing what your doing cause your amazing at it. paz, Angie Aries V
thebrokenrose 4 years ago
Just imagination... You weren't even born when SD were big! Nice versions. Nice voice. Just need to be aware of your tempo and attitude. Fagen always injects alot of sarcasm and wit in his vocal technic.
smondello 4 years ago
This is very good
themango90 4 years ago
Really enjoyable and a nice version a classic.
WashCommoner 4 years ago
You are exceptionally talented. 5 stars!
Stratman1920 4 years ago
However, as a die-hard fan of Steely Dan, I need to say that if you were to play this song for a Steely Dan audience, I think you would have to take some of the drama out of it. I think the bit of perceived emotional detachment of Steely Dan music is part of what makes their music so ingenious. In the end, though, it winds up adding more emotional meaning to the songs at a higher intellectual level. Fagen and Becker don't give us "that cotton candy."
rogersat 4 years ago
Justin, you're piano playing is very musical, and you have a great voice. If you were going to play Steely Dan to the general public, this is how you would want to do it.
rogersat 4 years ago
kline and edgar, hes already said its in a lower key, cut him some slack, i think this is very admirable effort, well done!
Mikeya85 4 years ago
Great version.
Can you do Kid Charlemagne?
captadama 4 years ago
That isn't in the right key...
edgarallanpoet 4 years ago