True Anarchy is the Freedom to do whatever you want but, trusting enough in yourself and others to know what is right and wrong, and the ones that aren't mature enough to see that should keep the fuck away from anarchism and crawl back up there mothers cunt.
Don't forget "rights" don't exist they are simply documents and thoughts of what your freedom should be, that is not freedom, that is manufactured happiness.
wow what a stupid statement. who was this hobbes a sociopath? and answer me this question:
arent gouvernments also made of people? a small group of privileged and powerful people ruling over everybody else? enforcing an inhuman, corrup system. right this works! lets just take it and swallow all their might.
@chopspridgen ahahahahahahahahaha.....ok..., i dont need ppl to do violence for me, i prefer to do it myself thanks. Sleep soundly, soundly? and hard? baby, you dont know hard, aw yeah... bitch you dont know me so why dont you fuck off and die already
The whole point of this song, is government debases the human being. The existence of the police turns us into social cowards. Got a 'problem child' - don't listen, don't emphasise. Just turn them over the police or mental institutions. Kropotkin said that if someone was a kid was drowning in a lake - that kid is more likely to be saved in an anarchist society. For we take initiative and responsibilty. Government suffocates our mutualist instincts.
I agree in part with Crass philosophy. Howadays we depends so much from a Government and a overpowered Estate that we wouldn't live a single day without it. We are a sort of junks under heroin effect...Individuality has been murdered with our free choice and our human resources.
ok the anarchy sign is A for anarchy and the circle actually is an O for order, really i used to think anarchy was stupid, didnt work, but i relalized that its a political view like anyother involving peace and no rulers. Theres no authority but yourself, which means that anarchy actually has authority, and that authority is set by human natural laws. so really anarchy is really all about peace amd self control, you dont need a leader to be proficient.
dont forget, there was a time in the world when humans had no form of government, just ritual understanding of right and wrong... and though it will eventually come back even if you get rid of it, humanity has already proven you need none of the things in this song to survive... the point is that material possessions and comfort are not an excuse for a police state ;)
think you missed the point of the song people... hes pointing out the fact that chaos and anarchy would be unpleasant and would mean giving up the luxury of stores, medicine and hospitals and what not.... anarchy is silly, but freedom is personal ;)
whoever says anarchy is chaos is a cunt... this is irony! something the crass really liked to use... helps to seperate the thinkers from the fuckers (followers)
i dont understand if we were in a state of nature and there was no rule. wouldn't government just rise again? eventually people would realize that this sucks and they want to be protected. then people would ban together with guns an promise to protect people, then people would be like oh shit lets be protected, then bam theres a way of government organization again.
yeah lol, i dont understand how people think anarchy and peace can go hand in hand. to be honest if there was no body to tell me anything i would shoot anyone in my way. im sure loads of people would think the same as me though
@khoroshoorange if there was no government you will be powerless against the guy with the most guns and fallowers. no shit the governments actions arent in my best interest, im not rich but theres nothing i can do about it. the government will colapse on its own b4 it gets taken over. things have to run their course.
When full scale riots happen 95% of the rioters would never even dream of doing such a thing, but get caught up in the moment.
Suddenly they find themselves without a police force. Your Mum is being raped by men in masks, you 'think' you know who it is so mob justice is done. But your wrong, innocent man dies guilty rapes again, because mob rules rule. Emotions run over investigation. Anarchy in principle good in practice Not workable
In anarchy there will be protection and law (customary law) but not provided for government. "Police" will work for the people in anarchy through democratic links, not for the gov't.
It is human nature, we are social animals and all social animals require a hierarchy.
To have anarchy we need leaders to start the revolt. Then the followers to act upon it.
Then if anarchy is ever achieved we still need administrators or you will have millions of misguided so called punks taking advantage, then you have eye for eye justice, without fair trial just word of mouth.
Without rigid laws we have groups making their own laws. The more powerful group will naturally overtake the weaker group and install its own brand of 'anarchy' which by nature is different as all societys hold different values.
Anarchy can only be achieved if there are no humans.
Stop kidding yourself. It cant and will never happen, unless you want every human to think exactly the way you do, which goes against the very concept of Anarchy. Its an Oxymoron
1.) 1930's Catalonia (the CNT and FAI) had no problem avoiding every scenario you're pulling out of your ass.
2.) Each community will have their own unique values and laws, yes. What motivation will one commune have to force their way unto others? What will make one group more "powerful" as you say? What IS power in an anarchist society?
"Human nature" is an abstract term at best. There isn't an absolute and solid definition for it; What is human nature? I.e., What does it mean to be human? How does that magically transform into a motivation? Any answer is you give will either fail to debunk Anarchism, or be debunked istelf by examples of people who went against that "nature." (Catalonia?)
How does being better off equal power? I know I'm better off than a lot of people I know, I haven't seen myself telling them what to do.
What makes you think the mob can be controlled, epecially after they've been indoctrinated with Anarchist ideals? Are there any real world examples of this?
I know one of many real world examples that conflicts with that: It starts with a "C."
The only fucking listenable part of 'Yes Sir I Will'.
PartisanArtisan 1 month ago
True Anarchy is the Freedom to do whatever you want but, trusting enough in yourself and others to know what is right and wrong, and the ones that aren't mature enough to see that should keep the fuck away from anarchism and crawl back up there mothers cunt.
69ihjertet 2 months ago
Don't forget "rights" don't exist they are simply documents and thoughts of what your freedom should be, that is not freedom, that is manufactured happiness.
BeardleProductions 3 months ago
its a documentary called living utopia.
khoroshoorange 3 months ago
watch?v=jPl_Y3Qdb7Y
Thumps Up for Anarcho Syndicalism!
khoroshoorange 3 months ago
Comment removed
khoroshoorange 3 months ago
Comment removed
khoroshoorange 3 months ago
theres no point in trying so im just gonna hate humanity and play the game.. fucked up bullshit!
the moment i agree with that theres no point in living anymore!
khoroshoorange 6 months ago
wow what a stupid statement. who was this hobbes a sociopath? and answer me this question:
arent gouvernments also made of people? a small group of privileged and powerful people ruling over everybody else? enforcing an inhuman, corrup system. right this works! lets just take it and swallow all their might.
khoroshoorange 6 months ago
@khoroshoorange yeah im sure that ull fight and die on the front lines. have u ever even shot a gun?
rocknrollporn 6 months ago
@chopspridgen ahahahahahahahahaha.....ok..., i dont need ppl to do violence for me, i prefer to do it myself thanks. Sleep soundly, soundly? and hard? baby, you dont know hard, aw yeah... bitch you dont know me so why dont you fuck off and die already
blobperson 7 months ago
Crass had a romanticized view of humanity and this is coming from a former anarchist and a lover of Crass music.
deathtotheism 7 months ago
The whole point of this song, is government debases the human being. The existence of the police turns us into social cowards. Got a 'problem child' - don't listen, don't emphasise. Just turn them over the police or mental institutions. Kropotkin said that if someone was a kid was drowning in a lake - that kid is more likely to be saved in an anarchist society. For we take initiative and responsibilty. Government suffocates our mutualist instincts.
dm18876 7 months ago 3
@dm18876 your a Mutualist!? wow, your the first I've found haha. Individualist Anarchist speaking. Hard to find Mutualists nowadays.
allwittynamestaken 7 months ago
I agree in part with Crass philosophy. Howadays we depends so much from a Government and a overpowered Estate that we wouldn't live a single day without it. We are a sort of junks under heroin effect...Individuality has been murdered with our free choice and our human resources.
talissin 9 months ago
Hey I have a joke for everyone on here: How many Punks does it take to fix a lightbulb? 0 . Punks don't do anything.
Condemnesis1 10 months ago
@Condemnesis1 ok, first off it goes- how meny punk does it take to CHANGE a lightbulb? none, punks dont change anything... and second ha-ha
blobperson 9 months ago 3
@Condemnesis1 Sometimes smash some dick-face.
talissin 4 months ago in playlist Preferiti di talissin
ok the anarchy sign is A for anarchy and the circle actually is an O for order, really i used to think anarchy was stupid, didnt work, but i relalized that its a political view like anyother involving peace and no rulers. Theres no authority but yourself, which means that anarchy actually has authority, and that authority is set by human natural laws. so really anarchy is really all about peace amd self control, you dont need a leader to be proficient.
teddypr8de 1 year ago
Minarchism ftw!
Amilitantatheist 1 year ago
dont forget, there was a time in the world when humans had no form of government, just ritual understanding of right and wrong... and though it will eventually come back even if you get rid of it, humanity has already proven you need none of the things in this song to survive... the point is that material possessions and comfort are not an excuse for a police state ;)
Jedi206 1 year ago
think you missed the point of the song people... hes pointing out the fact that chaos and anarchy would be unpleasant and would mean giving up the luxury of stores, medicine and hospitals and what not.... anarchy is silly, but freedom is personal ;)
Jedi206 1 year ago
Crass is fucking awesome!!!!
TheShadeauPerez 1 year ago
whoever says anarchy is chaos is a cunt... this is irony! something the crass really liked to use... helps to seperate the thinkers from the fuckers (followers)
maxeskorbu 1 year ago
@maxeskorbu Hmm I kind of like that sentence: "Irony helps to seperate the thinkers from the fuckers (followers)"
Nice one
wodidos 1 year ago
lol this band is terrible
RevLeft26 1 year ago
...and what if told you to fuck off
RenardRoberts 1 year ago
i dont understand if we were in a state of nature and there was no rule. wouldn't government just rise again? eventually people would realize that this sucks and they want to be protected. then people would ban together with guns an promise to protect people, then people would be like oh shit lets be protected, then bam theres a way of government organization again.
TerminalLove77 2 years ago
@TerminalLove77
maybe it would, i dont know, but if it happened when i was alive id be there to knock it down if it did.
blobperson 2 years ago 5
yeah lol, i dont understand how people think anarchy and peace can go hand in hand. to be honest if there was no body to tell me anything i would shoot anyone in my way. im sure loads of people would think the same as me though
TerminalLove77 2 years ago
so ur gunna go to war with them huh? kinda defeats the purpose, dont you think?
we live in a sick world u and i. u wouldnt like it without order. trust me
rocknrollporn 11 months ago
@rocknrollporn fighting to defend my ideals does not defeat the purpose of autonomy. And we already live in a world with no order, its just a facade.
blobperson 11 months ago 3
@blobperson So fuckin true
megacracker455 10 months ago
@rocknrollporn
your powerless they got you and are ruling over you! and not in your best interest.
khoroshoorange 6 months ago
@khoroshoorange if there was no government you will be powerless against the guy with the most guns and fallowers. no shit the governments actions arent in my best interest, im not rich but theres nothing i can do about it. the government will colapse on its own b4 it gets taken over. things have to run their course.
rocknrollporn 6 months ago
In a nutshell Yes.
A person is smart, people are stupid.
When full scale riots happen 95% of the rioters would never even dream of doing such a thing, but get caught up in the moment.
Suddenly they find themselves without a police force. Your Mum is being raped by men in masks, you 'think' you know who it is so mob justice is done. But your wrong, innocent man dies guilty rapes again, because mob rules rule. Emotions run over investigation. Anarchy in principle good in practice Not workable
666daedsidog 2 years ago
@TerminalLove77 You miss the point of this song. I hate people like you, All of you Have the same Argument. When we stomp you, you become Bigot's.
tra93 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77 You know this song is about people like you. And what if I told you to Fuck Off?
tra93 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77 would it suck in the first place? that's the question
GuiMarquito 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77 or their commune would live happy and free of the tyranny of government.
and anarchy doesnt mean no organization or chaos. just means no rulers.
nomoreyou1212 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77
shhhhh people who speak out against the system will be killed
DannyStCool 1 year ago
Comment removed
AllyTheIrishFaire 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77
(I'm sure people already responded but...)
In anarchy there will be protection and law (customary law) but not provided for government. "Police" will work for the people in anarchy through democratic links, not for the gov't.
Statism:
State --> Police --> People
Anarchy
People --> "police"
GodOfTheInternets 1 year ago
@TerminalLove77 thats true and kudos for thinking outside the box, but its worth a try
blackorpheliac1 11 months ago
@TerminalLove77 "People are shit, so lets make a State made entirely of People to shoot at us" - Hobbes.
Antharmo 8 months ago
Comment removed
khoroshoorange 6 months ago
Anarchy IS Order! The State is chaos!
evilmick66 2 years ago
O_0
blobperson 2 years ago
Just making a shout out comment like menneskeabe an Nederlandac did lol.
evilmick66 2 years ago
I know, it just made me laugh, being a complete oxymoron.... but I know what you mean...
blobperson 2 years ago
It's not an oxymoron. The first anarchist, Proudhon, made it abundantly clear and it's the very meaning of the Circle A symbol.
The State IS Chaos. Look at how many laws it takes to keep it from falling apart. Anarchism is an absence of that chaos.
evilmick66 2 years ago
dude.... chill the fuck out.... im on your side, and yes your right anarchism is with out political chaos...
blobperson 2 years ago
@evilmick66
People will always look to leaders.
It is human nature, we are social animals and all social animals require a hierarchy.
To have anarchy we need leaders to start the revolt. Then the followers to act upon it.
Then if anarchy is ever achieved we still need administrators or you will have millions of misguided so called punks taking advantage, then you have eye for eye justice, without fair trial just word of mouth.
Then you get media Anarchy not real Anarchy.
Its false Idealism
666daedsidog 2 years ago
@evilmick66
Without rigid laws we have groups making their own laws. The more powerful group will naturally overtake the weaker group and install its own brand of 'anarchy' which by nature is different as all societys hold different values.
Anarchy can only be achieved if there are no humans.
Stop kidding yourself. It cant and will never happen, unless you want every human to think exactly the way you do, which goes against the very concept of Anarchy. Its an Oxymoron
666daedsidog 2 years ago
1.) 1930's Catalonia (the CNT and FAI) had no problem avoiding every scenario you're pulling out of your ass.
2.) Each community will have their own unique values and laws, yes. What motivation will one commune have to force their way unto others? What will make one group more "powerful" as you say? What IS power in an anarchist society?
evilmick66 2 years ago
The motivation is human nature.
The power comes from better developed resources and more intelligent and healthier inhabitants.
The strong naturally rise to the top.
666daedsidog 2 years ago
"Human nature" is an abstract term at best. There isn't an absolute and solid definition for it; What is human nature? I.e., What does it mean to be human? How does that magically transform into a motivation? Any answer is you give will either fail to debunk Anarchism, or be debunked istelf by examples of people who went against that "nature." (Catalonia?)
How does being better off equal power? I know I'm better off than a lot of people I know, I haven't seen myself telling them what to do.
evilmick66 2 years ago
Physical strength doesn't mean jack shit when everyone owns a gun.
evilmick66 2 years ago
Their isnt a specific individual human nature.
But there is mob mentality.
Individuals will rise to the top, then control the mob.
666daedsidog 2 years ago
What makes you think the mob can be controlled, epecially after they've been indoctrinated with Anarchist ideals? Are there any real world examples of this?
I know one of many real world examples that conflicts with that: It starts with a "C."
evilmick66 2 years ago
We dont need any leaders! The people can think for them self!
Long Live Freedom!
One Solution - A Revolution!
Anarchy and Peace!
menneskeabe 2 years ago
crass rules!
spankysteez 2 years ago 4
in a non-authoritarian way of course. ;-)
anarchodolly 2 years ago 12
ha ha....X)
blobperson 2 years ago
ANARCHY IS fredom.
Nederlandac 2 years ago 15
ANARCHY AND FREEDOM IS WHAT I WANT!
StephHuegi 2 years ago 4
Nice song, Crass rules.
Anarchy and peace!
mckeegaunt 2 years ago 5