Jason Castro - Memory (4-22-08)

[80Xdeath]

Im a man but  really love his hair..

[truongphan90]

the worst Idol contestant ever to have made into the top 4

[jaypawhollypawcatz]

dreds.

[ceheape]

for me for you, for you for me for you.

[crocant24]

Fanrastic.. Jason Castro can really sing... and I do like his style.. =)

[angelofmusic700]

never was a fan

[thisvideoiscool]

his in American idol? i dont even notice him

[misslucygirl95]

Jason. Castro. Sucks.

[xshandrakilz]

hahaha., he didnt knw.., hahaah thats funny.., well i dont have a clue either.., nyhahha

[jaspar38]

Wait . . . He didn't know that a cat sang this song. A song from the musical "CATS." Who exactly did he think sang that song? What exactly did he think the musical was about? I'm stunned. I'm just stunned.

Anyway, about the song. I thought it was an awesome concept but it fell short a bit. Still, it still had a twinge of sadness and despair (and I'm not being sarcastic!) that was beautiful. Was it the best ever? No. Was it the worst? No.

[jaspar38]

Oh yeah, and since when is "The Best of Broadway" synonymous with Andrew Lloyd Webber.

[Ninaki13th]

his voice is weak

[LZeppelin74]

Simon: It's not your style of music.

WTF lol? They GIVE him an Andrew Webber song list and complain it wasn't his style? How on earth can the kid help that? People do amuse me.

He had a fever of 104 that night am I right? VERY impressive performance. He was a drummer in a rock band, is a guitarist, a singer-songwriter yet he managed to pull off an Andrew Lord Webber song lol. He has my absolute respect.

And might I add, the Studio version is FANTASTIC.

[carnivalfreakshow]

he didn't pull it off though, that's the point...

You win some you lose some,

[LZeppelin74]

Went off this guy 8 months ago lol

[xXtEiYaXx]

uhh..well..no comment!!

[galileo30]

our own resident glamourpuss...Simon...HAHAHAHA

GO JASON!

[gillmacd]

OH MY GOD

OH MY GOD

HOW DID THIS HAPPEN!?

"I didn't even know it was sung by a cat..."

KILL

ME

NOW

This makes me ashamed of the music world. And American Idol. You let this happen. Uggghhhhh.

He BUTCHERED this.

Jason Castro, please never sing Broadway again. Ever. Please. I beg you.

[xXDarkBlueDarkBlueXx]

if people just stop looking at his face (even though its Beautiful) we may actually get somewere with this show!!!!!!!!!!

[miyukiamakusa]

his *gasp* gasps *gasp* are *gasp* rather *gasp* a *gasp* bit *gasp* too *gasp* loud *gasp*, aren't they?

[NeCiFiX]

He had the flu when he sang this, so he was really clogged up and couldn't breathe well.

[buddyholly429]

Oh, come on guys, don't give him negative points for that comment. It's funny, not mean. :)

[neccity]

jason is AI joke.

[MayanEndTimeDec2012]

Jason and Brooke should have been in the bottom two, with Jason taking a walk home into the sunset playing his ukulele. Definitely a popularity contest, with talent coming in second.

[snowvamp3]

The eyes have it but they couldn't even keep me awake through this.

[italiangirl55]

YEAH italgirl!!! as always - im with you on this one! hahaha GO JASON!!! WE LOVE YOUUU!! HE'S SO TALENTED AND GORGEOUS - IT SUCKS US FOREIGNERS CAN'T VOTE FOR HIM BUT WE ARE COUNTING ON YOU AMERICA!!! COME ONNN!!!

[urmom27]

he's one of my favourites but i'm not too sure about this one...it's a tough song and bc it's so known i'm thinking i automatically compared it to the original which makes his performance sounds kind of sucky

that said, he's still one of the best ones and he's great

[kristaholic]

I wish I could vote but I don't live in the US :( ..I'm so glad he got to stay another week though.. he better bring the house down for his next performance so all that voting will be worth it

[alexjtx]

How did he make it this far?

I mean, don't get me wrong, he isn't tonedeff or anything...but he has no range and his voice bores me to tears.

[KennedyGurl2011]

i voted for the whole 2 hrs on 2 phones....man im worried but i hope my voting paid off

[roxyboo17]

ive been to Cats and no offense but that SUCKED!

[redatpct]

paula, doesn't make much sense

[bubbutuby]

As charming as he is...

eh.

[islawmagalaw]

it sounds like an asthmatic cat with its tail trapped in a snare. don't watch and just listen to it and you'll know what i mean. sorry...

[greatbreeder]

i melt in his eyes, jason... more than that, i bubble under his voice... *sigh*

[Tlatz]

I give Jason a LOT of credit for tackling this one. I thought he did a good job considering the difficulty. I really want to hear the studio version of this one. I bet he sounds more comfortable in it. I hope this doesn't send him home.

[theluebandit]

That sucked.

[dreamer13579]

Jason is AMAZING! This was haunting and beautiful..I loved it!

[bak9986]

I thought it was beautiful

[tsenrae]

Simon not answering Ryan's question but says he's not voting him instead was MEAN!!!

[dgaller06]

ryan deserves it...the way he plays games with the contestants on the results show...he actually smiled when he said michael johns was going home

[dgaller06]

ooooh i get it simon said he wasn't voting for jason ok then ignore my previous comment

[hci3inxu]

HAHAHAHAHAHA

[kaedyilove]

lolol

he saved brooke

[krzl09bggsh]

i love him. he is good. i want carly out. TOTAL FAILURE CARLY. if carly wins i bet my ass she won't sell,

[jendakub]

He must go home, I can stand him...

[sweetpea7s]

Voting for 2 hrs staight, got blisters on my fingers!

[italgirl08]

way to go sweetpea7s!!! i'm from canada so i cant vote but i'm counting on ppl like u to vote jason to be the next idol!!!!!

[Ferdefi]

please america, get him out for the love of Crist!!!!

[italgirl08]

u might wanna learn how to spell Christ first

[detsnor]

vote for him !