[Tariq Jameel Tableeghi Jamaat ] Is There Such Thing As Good Bid'ah.

[MUSLIMHERON01]

Ahlehadees is ajamat of super idiots all liars all munafik.they fabricate the sentences from tabhleegis book and misguide the muslims.

[983821]

Yes you are good misguided saytan

[Militant7861]

the sahaba would take over countries and not go door to door and dawah means invitation to ALLAH so when u give dawah to muslims what r u trying to say they r not muslim??? dawah is for kufaar and nasiha is for muslims and think abt this did rasoolullah saw go for 3 days or 40 days or 4 months?? and if muslims werent doing what they supposed to be doing they were murtads and fought against ill leave u to think abt that asalaamu alaykum warahmatullah

[acejamal1]

SILLY WAHABI HE HAS DOEN A 40 COURSE IN MADINA UNIVERSITY(OF MEMORISING TWO WORDS SHIRK AND BIDDAH) AND HE HAS SURPASSED HIS SHAYKH UL ISLAM (iBN TAYMIYYAH)

WE ASK THIS JAHIL WAS THERE A MADINA UNIVERSITY IN THE TIME OF THE PROPHET ARE THE SAHAB?

NO THEN THIS IS BIDDAH,AND TO SAY BIDDAH IS LIKE SHIRK IS IGNORANCE IBN TAYMIIYYAH HAS WRITTEN A WHOLE CHAPTER ON THE ACCEPTABILITY OF SOME BIDDAH (BIDDAH SHARIYAH AND BIDDAH SAYIA)

SO LET THIS IDIOT FIRST GIVE FATAWA OF SHIRK ON IBN TAYMIYYAH!

[billy653]

I assume this also applies to milad un nabi

[horizongalaxy]

bismillah..the title of this video is totally wrong! its just insulting one of the biggest alim e deens....i have listened to a lot of lectures n speeches of maulana tariq jameel sahab n he has never appreciated any bidat n never said anything like GOOD BIDAT BAD BIDAT! n about this speaker he is always criticizing others ! i have never seen tariq jameel sahab criticizing any single sect of islam...he always says call urself a MUSLIM! not sunni shia etc! but this speaker is surely childish!

[newport251979]

BACK BITING IS HARAM !

[yusufulhas]

Ibn qayyim al jawzia brought up good innovation in his book tablis iblees. it is highly heretical to call tablighi jamat a bid'ah. there is no difference between tj and reading riyad as saliheen after isha everyday.

“Verily those who disbelieve spend their wealth to prevent people from the path of Allah” (8:36)

[kayajayj]

@salahkurla you not really gaining anything but haram from those disgusting words you speak they are the weapons of kafir, muslims speak with kindness. salam.

[apatel78692]

I didn't know that ALLAH (Azawajal) or the Prophet (PBAH) recorded or said to record your lectures and put them on youtube for people to watch!!! if they did am the fool if they didn't isn't this Bid'ah. using microphone bid'ah, using a camera Bid'ah, wearing glass Bid'ah, using the computer bid'ah. he is commiting bid'ah just to tell us y/how us SUNNI's comment bid'ah. I would say if you follow this Idiot ur a fool coz u cant tel some1 they are wrong when ur doing the same thing.

[emzo18]

"If theres good bidah then its Good Shirk", This guy does not relate to what a true Ulema has said about this, but his OWN little understanding...

[muhammad0309]

Listen Shiekh Faisel he will give u very good examples about this" devil decetption of .....

[lumbogeinee]

Umar farook r anhu changed the way we pray taraweeh. 20 rakaats. where as the prophet saw prayed 8 rakaats. What type of bidaah is that then. Is that not an innovation by umar farook r anhu.

[snkammar]

i rather be a big sinner who repents to Allah SWT then a person who brings a innovation to the religion of islam. Innovation is so evil.

[henzay]

bro'z and sisters.... no disrespect to anyone at all but tableegh jamaat is not a sect... it's a form of self rectification and spreading deen when was da'wah ever limited... didn't sahabahs go to different places to give dawah? and jamaat isn't calling the most beloved sallallahu alayhi wasallam a betrayer or anything ...

salaam and peace bro;z and sistahz

[StriderBlade1]

16 Dislike Jameel Tableeghi 

[bahmed06]

ALL BROTHERS ON YOUTUBE DO NOT LOOK FOR FATAWAS(LAWS/DECISIONS) ON YOUTUBE, PLEASE ACTUALLY CONTACT A PIOUS RIGHTEOUS SCHOLAR WHOEVER HE MAY BE AND GET YOUR KNOWLEDGE FROM HIM. WE SHOULD LISTEN AND INCREASE OUR IMAN BUT NOT LOOK FOR FATWAS ON YOUTUBE. THERE ARE MANY SCHOLARS AROUND THE COUNTRY AND ALHAMDULILLAH IT IS VERY EASY TO CONTACT THEM. MAY ALLHA SAVE US FROM THE FIRE AND ENTER US INTO PARADISE. AAMEEN

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral You cannot further yourself in Deen if you just seek knowledge but do not convey it nor do you try to practice upon it. To every hadith, Imam Ahmad learnt, he would then practice it and so as well teach. So for you to say that going out distracts one from seeking it - this is only your opinion and your opinion only, but others around the world may share your opinion however this is not the majority.

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

what has the brother in this vid said wrong?

and have you even read the fatwas about the tabeelgi

[cyberspiral]

@cyberspiral /watch?v=TC1mZO9RTGI&feature=r­elated

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral You are only depriving yourself and confusing yourself. When you quote the verses of ALLAH - you have no understanding, as in, you display a subject but cannot simply provide any proof, thus you should just keep seeking some better knowledge rather than accusing people...and if you don't know the punishment for wrongly accusing someone then i suggest you ask your scholars or research for yourself and when you come to a better understanding, don't waffle- make clear point + evidence

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral

Abu Abs RA reports that he heard the Rasulullaah S.A.W say, "Allaah has forbidden Jahannam for the person whose feet become dusty in the path of Allaah." [Bukhari Vol.1 Pg.124; also narrated by Imam Ahmad Vol.3 Pg.479 and Bayhaqi Vol.9 Pg.162]

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

i have only quoted what the scholars have said,

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral You say you only quote from what the scholars have said, so do you consider i am making up the sources and evidences as i go along? - Since the scholars you have used, have they ever given you proof from the Qur'an and Sunnah, and the way of the Sahabah, to back up the accusations that you are making against (that is, that you stand by against these false accusations) tablighi jamaat? If not, then surely the 'knowledge' you have gained from these 'scholars' amounts to zero....

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

and path of allah could have many meanings

[mohammedislam12]

From all the examples given: we learn that within 40 days, a person develops a habit, some form of character-change takes place, freedom from Jahannam results, one is safeguarded from ‘nifaaq’ (hypocrisy), personality alters with new levels and phases being achieved, barakaat (blessings) of Allaah are earned, rewards multiply and person’s being itself undergoes revolutionary changes and closeness to Allaah.

[TheAuraMystic]

@mohammedislam12 I agree that 40days play an important role in Islam, but creating separate sects in Islam is not permissible. The Muslims all over the world should follow the Quran and Authentic Hadith and we all should call ourselves 'the followers of Muhammad(pbuh)' not like i am a murid of him, i do tabhlighi jamaat, etc, etc. :)

[mohammedislam12]

@TheAuraMystic Does tabligh jamaat really a different sect or just another branch of our Deeni tree? Does tabligh jamaat not unite the muslims?...-Or is it simply dividing the ummah today? Isn't Dawah fardh upon every muslim?-Or is Dawah only for the scholars? Allah takes away knowledge from the world by taking away the scholars. If dawah is only for the scholars, then know this, you are disobeying the commands of our Nabi Muhammad S.A.W. Did the Prophet S.A.W say follow "Authentic Hadith"?

[mohammedislam12]

Example 7 on "Why 40 days?":

40 days – Hadhrat Musa A.S on the mountain.

Allaah says (Qur'an Al A'raf 7:142), "We appointed for Moses thirty nights, and completed (the period) with ten (more): thus was completed the term (of communion) with his Lord, forty nights..." (Yusuf Ali's Qur'an english translation)

[mohammedislam12]

Example 6:

When a man once came to Hadhrat Umar RA, Hadhrat Umar RA asked, “Where have you been?” “I have been guarding the borders,” the man replied. Hadhrat Umar RA asked further, “How many days did you spend on guard?” “Thirty days,” was the reply. Hadhrat Umar RA commented, “Why did you rather not complete forty days?”

[Al Bidaaya wan Nihaaya Vol.4 Pg.157]

[mohammedislam12]

40 days change of foetus: [Bukhari - hadith 976]

[mohammedislam12]

Example 3:

40 days change

Hadhrat Abdullaah RA narrates, "Rasulullaah S.A.W who was Saadiq and Masdooq said to us, 'Each one of you collects in the womb of his mother for

forty days. He then remains like this as a clot of blood for another forty days. In the same manner, he then takes the form of a piece of flesh, after which Allaah dispatches an angel who is charged with recording four things viz. his

actions, his sustenance, his lifespan and whether he will be a good person or a wretch.'"

[mohammedislam12]

Example 2:

40 Salaats in Masjid e Nabawi.

Hadhrat Anas bin Maalik RA reports that Rasulullaah S.A.W said, "Whoever performs forty salaah in this Masjid of mine without missing a single salaah is

assured exemption from Jahannam, exemption from punishment and exemption from hypocrisy."

[Ahmad -Vol.3 Pg.155; as quoted in Targheeb wat Tarheeb Vol.2 Pg.215; Majma'uz Zawaa'id Vol.4 Pg.8]

[mohammedislam12]

There are many Ahadeeth relating to the figure 40:

Example 1: Benefit of 40 days salaah with Jamaat with Takbeer Ula.

-Hadhrat Anas bin Maalik RA narrates that Rasulullaah S.A.W said, "When a person performs salaah solely for Allaah's pleasure for forty days in congregation and with the first Takbeer, two exemptions are written for him; (these are) exemption from Jahannam and exemption from hypocrisy." [Tirmidhi - Hadith 241]

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Another example for "why '10 days'?" - the last 10 days of ramadhan is a well-known juristic fact that I'tikaaf is Sunnah-e-Mu'akkadah ala Kifayah. The numerous spiritual benefits attained by those performing I'tikaaf are well documented. The one who goes out in jamaat for 10 days, making i'tikaaf in various masjids earn similar spiritual benefits and rewards. Do you now see the common-factor method in relation to '10 Days'?

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Why '10 days'? - Nabi S.A.W spent 10 days in Ta'if, conveying the message to the people. This is sufficient proof for any muslim to spend 10 spend days in da'wah (inviting) and tabligh (propagating), and not for any other purpose. And this is evidence for jamaats to remain 10 days in the area for some real constructive work to take place. Musa A.S remained 30 days on the mountain and Allah extended his stay a further 10 days (completing as 40 days in total)

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral [continued]..of Allah descended on the nation). Yunus A.S was a messenger of Allah and therefore Ma'soom (innocent) from sins. This is why 3 days, an individual can focus on Allah (away from the hustle of business, from the computer, internet etc and the general, chaotic and busy life). One is relaxed and therefore has some peace of mind to think about the reality of life.

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Example 2 for the '3 days': Prophet Yunus A.S stayed in the belly of the big fish for 3 days and 3 nights (72 hours), in that duration Yunus A.S was fully focused on Allah. In this state of peace and tranquility, he gained even more nearness to Allah and secured Allah's forgiveness for the error in his decision (i.e. leaving nineveh prior to the order of Allah, thinking that the responsibility of conveying the message had been completed and he now had to move away before the wrath..

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral One cannot say that because the car has 4 wheels therefore i will go out for 4 days, this is because there is no correlation to justify the 4 days. Understand this well.

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Likewise, when someone goes out in jamaat also, there is adequate time for one to deliberate on one's condition, spiritual state, moral condition, educational level, purpose of creation, direction to choose in life, future projections and a good reasonable proper assessment can be made of one's life as a whole - 3 days in jamaat is also for self-deliberation and self-contemplation.

[mohammedislam12]

@alfizirri2 if make bad remarks about their lecturers or teachers they would simply do the same to ours, by the way one cannot just be a tablighi member (tablighis, as so-called people call them in rude way), dawah to muslims and non-muslims is a part of islam.

[alfizirri2]

it also dont make any sense how a justin bieber baby - face wahabi's can judge like an IBLIS give judgement.

[alfizirri2]

May be this ustaz only know to say the right thing but in reality his attitudes are poor (F), humbleness (F) , akhlak (F), rudeness(A+), following sunnah (C), fluentness (B), understanding other people (F) , baby-face(A+), tendency for facial-cream model (A+), relation with justin Bieber (A)

[alfizirri2]

the above ustaz attitude is some sort like telling people that other peoples are not as good as him...in the other words that relecting that " I am better than others" and this is the attitude of IBLIS laknatullah. I am not tabligis but most my tablighis friend in my country tend to say " these are my fault...i am the one who responsible..other peoples are better compare to me..." and this is the attitudes of Nabi SAW. The above "baby-face ustaz should join tabligh" then he will be more humble.

[alfizirri2]

the above ustaz should go door to door (the method of sunnah) rather than preaching under the aircond room and being recorded with a video cam and posted in this youtube (which filled with naked women) iam not tablighis buat i love their way of preaching (the method of rasul) and full with qurbani. The above ustaz cute face and baby face not sufficient to gain most people's symphaty. He should be a facial cream model.

[alfizirri2]

these salafis - wahabies people just have an itchy buttock...they cannot stand with other peoplecomfort and peacefullness. Their intention only to create war among muslims and not intended for unity and peace. and this is an obvious bid'ah. I am not tablighis but tabligh are people who preach for peace and unity. That is why they can spread for whole over the world. Wahabis in my place is like the dog which being thrown by stones by my muslim inmates.

[mohammedislam12]

@alfizirri2 Bro show no hatred to these people who say tablighi ppl are ahle-bidah, just make sure when you make du's that you include these brothers of ours in our du'as. Make sure you ask Allah to give them an open-mind. As when Khaalid Bin Waleed RA was a non-believer before becoming a muslim, the Prophet S.A.W said to the nearest meaning O Khaalid, keep an open-mind, and through this khaalid bin waleed became a great muslim and as he did not choose to hear the rumours about Islam

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral, those people of today who refer themselves as ahle-hadith or salafies are very much confused in gathering the correct knowledge to understand someone. for example the guy who's giving the advise, on all his bayaans he just seems so confused when asked about t-jamaat. Barelvis and deobandis both may follow the Hanafi school of thought but both are totally different, barelvis don't accept t-jamaat but they say its ok to make du'a to the Prophet S.A.W

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

making dua is a act of ibadah and making to other allah is shirk

and im saying that tableeghs have the right intention but some of their doings are wrong

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

“Say (O Muhammad): This is my way; I invite unto Allaah (i.e. to the Oneness of Allaah — Islamic Monotheism) with sure knowledge”

[Yoosuf 12:108]

i.e., with knowledge, because the caller must know that to which he calls people, what is obligatory, mustahabb, haraam and makrooh. He has to know what shirk, sin, kufr, immorality and disobedience are; he has to know the degrees of denouncing evil and how to do it.

[RDD2012]

Also the deen revolves on what the Ulema think, not what you yourself think. If you cant trust the ulema to get the deen right who can you trust....

[RDD2012]

It is also Bidat to go around asking people where allah is!!

[RDD2012]

Another person who doesnt know the difference between shirk and bidat.

You cannot put a person who does bidat on the same level as someone who does shirk. Study the deen well and you will know what im talking about.

[HikmaProductions]

Indeed !

[nimrahg]

IGNORE HIM.

IGNORE TABLEEGHI JAMAAT.

THY TRYING TO LEAD US TO HELL.

[pathan786khany]

@nimrahg whos they. are you even listerning to what he says?

[nimrahg]

yes!!! he is absolutely wrong...

he is such a stuppid and Jaahil...

I should say that he might be from the nasl of ABU JAHAL.

[manarab]

plzzzzz search for the trurh brother....thats why in islam our nabi muhammad s.a.w says that islam will break into 73 firqah.....do you know why....it is because there are so many people like you who just spend your whole life to blame other people....for that people say that you are the truth.....and yet you cannot make this one ummah to be good....and try to think what you have done when you give lactures about bidaah when 90% of our islam brothes and sisters are dont pray and do haram things

[acoktang]

this crazy and stupid guy....!

[TheTableeghisareliar]

Mulla Ali al-Qari al-Hanafi says (as reported by al-Masumi): It is not obligatory upon anyone from the Ummah to be a Hanafi, or a Maliki, or a Shafii, or a Hanbali; rather, it is obligatory upon everyone, if he is not a scholar, to ask someone from Ahl al-Dhikr (people of knowledge), and the four Imams are from amongst the Ahl al-Dhikr

[mohammedislam12]

According to this lecturer's point of view:

a good bid'ah= 1. the lecturer has allowed the person to film - where are the evidences of filming in the sunnah? 2. the lecturer is using a microphone - is it sunnah?

a Bad bid'ah= sitting in the company of the people of the masjid, calling people to the masjid, giving bayaan on imaan and yaqeen, the greatness of Allah, life ater death, making regular effort in our community

[TheTableeghisareliar]

@mohammedislam12 Shaah Waleeullaah Muhaddith Dehlawee said; "The one who does Raf al-Yadain is more beloved to me than the one who does not because, there are many Ahadeeth for performing Raf al-Yadain and they are authentic."

In Hujjatullah al-Baalighah (2/10), also in Kifaayah Liman Lahu Diraayah

[fahfeez]

@TheTableeghisareliar I am always shocked seeing so many people having dedicated their life to spreading hatred.

I am 100 percent with mohammedislam12 on his pointing out of the use of picture there are a lot of Hadith's refraining from the use of Picture if one is so much against biddah then he should at least not do something that is forbidden, or is it just that you people don't count the clearly forbidden things as biddah and doing them is just a sin so its ok to do this in your logic.

[fahfeez]

@TheTableeghisareliar << Please don't take my words as offence but I said that just for the sake of argument and expect a logical argumentative reply to it.

The other question is regarding following an Imaam, I am not a Alim/scholar but I can understand it by simple analogy of internet protocol if you change a single rule in the set of rules in a protocol it would change the entire protocol and we are suppose to give it a new name.

[fahfeez]

@TheTableeghisareliar A scholar (Immam) whom we might be following as you call it Ahl al-Dhikr would have explained the rules of life according to his understanding of the deen and his knowledge which is definitely far greater than that of ours,

By accepting the explanation of that Scholar in one deed or matter of life and denying it in another we are not only practically rejecting the the scholars authority over the understanding of Deen but we are claiming to have a better understanding

[fahfeez]

@TheTableeghisareliar of Deen than the scholar himself and hence we should either not follow him in the first place or follow him in every deed/matter or we should be following whatever we understand by ourselves and claim to be a scholar ourselves and that's exactly what we do when we follow one scholar in one matter and the other in the other matter, hence we actually follow whatever we like to follow not what we should be following.

[fahfeez]

@TheTableeghisareliar and by following and therefore defining different set of rules in different matter we are going to be constantly in the process of defining new protocols i.e. new fiqha each time we choose to switch from on scholar to another, each person having his own fiqha which would also be a huge problem in governing process i.e. judiciary and management in practical life would be very difficult. unless you define a set of rules for yourself.

[alfizirri2]

@mohammedislam12 yes ...absolute while i am watching his lecture in the youtube, i noticed a popped up commercial of naked women hanging upside down. This preaching is not "bid'ah" at all..this is the haraam way. I am not tablighis but i prefer tablighis ways of doing da'wah rather than this "so-called sunnah knight" but doing da'wah using the yahood's youtube.

[pathan786khany]

@alfizirri2 hes no the one who puts them advertisement up its youtube. stop trying ta find a fault.

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

brother bidah is regards to the deen using a microphone isnt part of the deen

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral

if something is not part of deen then why do you need to use it. the concept of Tablighi Jamaat is made up of a combinations of what the Prophet S.A.W did to conveyed the message and what he told his sahabas 2do. What about the use of picture and the advancing technology of picture (video), was there not a hadith related by The Prophet S.A.W about making and having pictures, or do you somehow in your own understanding regard this as something acceptable and not an innovated idea?

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

“Say (O Muhammad): This is my way; I invite unto Allaah (i.e. to the Oneness of Allaah — Islamic Monotheism) with sure knowledge”

[Yoosuf 12:108]

i.e., with knowledge, because the caller must know that to which he calls people, what is obligatory, mustahabb, haraam and makrooh. He has to know what shirk, sin, kufr, immorality and disobedience are; he has to know the degrees of denouncing evil and how to do it.

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral In T-jamaat, there are always pious people, and usually pious people are chosen as ameers (leaders) as they have the most experience in knowledge and actions, they have the responsibility in helping us learn the basic obligatories, mustahabbs, and the clear haraam and halaal things mentioned by Allah and his Rasool (S.A.W).

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Now when it comes to topics that have a difference of opinion from Scholars amongst the As-Salifus Saliheen, these are avoided because the main purpose of t-jamaat is to reform oneself by being punctual in his salah, being punctual in reciting qur'an, being able to get use to good company, and what better company is there than coming and staying in the house of Allah?

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral T-jamaat is about reforming others around him, and not waste time in arguing over matters that will leave a growing throb of hatred for his fellow brother. And that is why sometimes it is good to remain silent. Now since Islam has spread to the 4 corners of the World, why is that Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world? Why is it that many are embracing Islam but can't even and choose not to carry out the basic obligatories? And who will help and encourage them?

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

The kind of going out that distracts people from seeking knowledge is wrong, because seeking knowledge is an obligation, and it can only be achieved by learning, not by inspiration. This is one of the misguided Sufi myths, because action without knowledge is misguidance, and hoping to acquire knowledge without learning is an illusion.

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral WOW...i really don't think you know much about t-Jamaat, you might have some how undergone one thing with jamatees that happened to you and now you are relating your situation with someelse's that all these reformers are people of innovation...and who acts without knowledge - what a silly thing to say? today many of us know what is right and wrong, but how do you know that you are in the right? Has Allah made it such to you that you are on haq?

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral - And are we both not a part of Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama'ah? You say "action without knowledge is misguidance", shouldn't you be worried that maybe something you have said (your action) will be accounted greatly against you...

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral What 'kind' of going out are you talking about? if you mean jhola (gasht) then specify this, and how does jhola cause distraction when you are merely acting on command of The Prophet S.A.W. One cannot just seek knowlegde and just bottle it in their mind and not share it...we know what punishment that person will get - and if you don't know, yh just find that out yourself since you think that t-jamaat is not about 1. learning, 2. practicing and 3. preaching. Islam is a way of life

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral A way of life includes everything, and including the verses of Allah and the traditions and comands of the Prophet S.A.W. If you simply can't act upon what the prophet S.A.W said to the nearest meaning that if a person knows even one ayah, then he should convey it. Then maybe you haven't come across this knowledge but now you know - you can't ignore this! Everyday, our brains are filled with oceans and oceans of knowledge, but do we really know what is necessary and what isn't?

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Allah says in the Qur'an to the nearest meaning, a reminder is beneficial for the believers. and this is a fact. we are a race that forget, and we need to be constantly reminded by others arounds us who too, are reaching for the same destination. Muslims of today are comdemning other muslims, and this is one of the reasons why muslims with weak imaan deviate and in the short-term become apostates

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12 Going out to call people to Allaah cannot be limited to a certain number of days, rather one should call people to Allaah according to one's abilities, without limiting that to a group or to forty days or more or less than that.

Similarly the daa’iyah must have knowledge. It is not permissible for a person to call people to Allaah when he is ignorant. Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Who said calling people to Allah is limited to a number of days? and if you are referring to the 3 days, 10 days, 40 days then you should already know that there is significance found in these number of days, surely you have come across the sunnah of the Prophet S.A.W. very well otherwise quoting the verse of Allah is in some way will play against you for not having the knowledge on something you cannot provide evidence for.

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral why '3 days'?- when the Prophet S.A.W would instruct those ameers of expeditions it would be as brief as: go to this tribe or that and give them three choices, and allow them to contemplate for 3 days then take necessary action. the choices being: 1. accept islam, 2. pay jizya and live under islam in peace and prosperity, 3. get ready to fight to resist the take-over. thus '3 days' were given, and were sufficient for deliberation, discussion and contemplation

[mohammedislam12]

@cyberspiral Tablighi Jamaat helps us reform ourselves and those around us. You may think its innovated but this means you have not gone out of your way to understand where this concept of reformation has come from. If you feel that this is bid'ah then surely shed some light on what you would have done according to the sunnah on reforming muslims, reforming societies/countries etc. and even conveying the message of Allah and His Rasool (S.A.W) to non-muslims.

[cyberspiral]

@mohammedislam12

what your trying to say is that dont use a car dont use air conditioning dont use electricty since its not part of the deen and it wasnt there at the time of the sahaba and rasool

first understand what is bidah and then come back

[mrwaqy]

No, he is wrong.

Did Rasoolallah (s.a.w) or the Sahabah have fixed prayer times?

Did they teach the qaidah?

Did they have lines in the masjid?

Bidat is when you make something WAJIB in ISLAM.

[TheTableeghisareliar]

@mrwaqy if you make something wajib in islam that would be commiting kuffer

[mrwaqy]

@TheTableeghisareliar Bidat is when you make something like sunnat or mustahab WAJIB in Islam, go to watch Molana Abdur raheem Abu Nauman Lecturer of ahadeeth gave the answer to what bidat really is.

Hanafifiqh channel

[afg96]

@TheTableeghisareliar How about The Salatu Wither. It is 3 rikaths Isha prayer. People call it Wither Wajib

[boxermaf]

@TheTableeghisareliar what does this have to do with tablighis? we dont believe in good bidah like barelvis do. you remind me of choudhury1231 who manipulates things aimed at barlevis against tablighi jamaat. same with this joke of a guy in another one of his videos. he is not even a salafi scholar just a throne cementer who works for a dawah centre in jeddah