Added: 4 years ago
From: ipcioz
Views: 64,997
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (561)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ravi shankar, the book is your creation, a product of your ignorance, and now that you are being recognized by your mistake, you blame your mistake on the shortness of time in which the book was written, you ask the book to be pardoned and you preach of how there is goodness in every religion, which is already an established fundamental of the argument. ravi ka kaam hooo gaya! =D

  • allah is given capablity to zakir to finesh fake peoples who is misguding inocent peoples like us

  • Canany one help me to find out where dr.Zakir's next debate venue or when will be in India,,, please please I want to clarify some doubts ...

    LOKAH SAMASTHA SUKHINO BHAVANTHU

    

  • @689711 for clarification you dont need to wait for another debate. just visit Islamic research foundation web site and get the their address in mumbai. contact them directly.

  • Dr. Zakir like persons have the ability to use his talent for good things, like to fight against terrorism and spread the message of Islam 'way to peace'. I like this concept of Muslim that the purpose of existence is to worship God.

    But in practical they r making fight and debate in the name of him.. even blood war

  • Comment removed

  • Islam & hindu culture are entirely different, hinduism often called the "oldest living religion" or the "oldest living major religion" in the world came from generations B.C. 1500–500 BCE) but islam only after birth of hinduism.'Islam means way to peace' but way not to be in peace, i respect Quran its teaching , but instead muslims surrender to GOd they r surrendering to religion fame and in name of GOD they are killing people, but not all muslims i am saying,

  • Other famous texts of Hinduism include those of the bhakti yoga school (loving devotion to God) such as the Ramcharitmanas of Tulsidas , the Gita Govinda of Jayadeva , Adi Shankara's commentaries and other works, Ramanujacharya's nine books including "Sri Bhasya", Madhvacharya's commentaries and the Devi Mahatmya (the tales of Devi, the mother goddess, in her many forms as Shakti, Durga, Parvati, my goodness my hindu people plz understand our strength of hindu culture

  • Sr. Zakir is saying that he had made comparative study between religious books of hindus & muslims (ie. between Vedas, upanishdas, Post-Vedic Hindu scriptures, The Bhagavad Gita, The Puranas, The Tevaram Saivite hymns e.t.c with Quran ) even he want to give 100 more births to have a well knowledge on these books, I think those hindu people who debate with him have no knowledge on these, even dont know sanskrit, asking silly questions, he is giving foolsih answers seeking no scientific explanatio

  • lanaaat on clapping

  • if everyone accept their mistake and improve it like sri ravishankar did.everyone would b living together..happily..his positive intentions are neglected..he just wanted all of the people to be together...not to hurt feelings..

  • Muslims Hindu Christian many others all pray to one almighty god

    But it is the politicians who prays to wealth

    So brothers and sisters let's just believe in one god and pray for our sin

    Forget about modern scholar of religion

    As every one says ( amen )

  • why ravi shankar is writing those kind of books? where he doesnt have knowledge of hinduism itself, he should not say his personal words, if have something show with religious scripture reference.. why giving personal openion?

  • i'm dead sure that this questioner is planted... his point of him converting to islam is already fixed...i can make out both from his body language and of naik dude's

  • dr zakir naik is a gandu islamic mental case and need s some treatment

  • @americanbomb007 don't disrespect him if you don't know him. learn to respect all the religions

  • @santoshtelugu i respect all religions but dr zakir naik is a fraud and desh drohi and a true follower of jihad osama and isi pakistan who actually does not respect other religion and is actually a orthodox muslim like osama please

    watch dr zakir naik exposed or zakirnaik fraud on u tube then u will know dr zakir naik is a true follower of osama and isi pakistan dr zakir naik is a mental case who only tries to find errors in bible gita and other non islamic religious books

    to preach islam .

  • @americanbomb007 I agree with you. Sri Sri Ravi

    Shankar have made a comment on what had happened that day. He said that he agreed with him that there are mistakes because he didn't want to make more trouble. He said that it wouldn't have solved the purpose that he was there. To me Sri Sri Ravi Shankar is a truly wise person unlike Dr. Zakir. Dr. Zakir has absolutely no respect for any other religion. What ever he says is right just because he said it. Conceited much ?

  • @Shyamalacruise its internet not english class ever heard of common sense

  • @fazkool1 Given the fact that we are all portraying our opinions with English as the medium, I honestly do think it is critical that you do utilize proper English. Honestly, I could never take seriously an illiterate person who is trying to argue. It just shows me how uneducated you really are.

  • @Shyamalacruise americans have killed more muslims then muslims have killed americans americas killed millions and the ones who bomb themselves i dont blame them america put so much hate in muslims america started it first then other countries joined what should muslims do i dont think they should bomb themsleves theres more good muslims in the world then there is bad

  • @Shyamalacruise You might call your homemade thing Allah, but you can name it whatever you want because it won't be the real Almighty Allah SWT. The most important thing as a muslim, is to believe that there is One Allah, and to pray only for Him, and only worship Him and noone else!

  • if you know there's mistakes then why you publish it... *caught red handed*

  • If these two self proclaimed ambassadors of peace really care about peace they shut up and stop ranting their "mine is better than yours" masochistic fairy tales.

  • @harrywsu Actually, if you were to watch this video again, you'd see that Sri Sri Ravi Shankar did try to end the arguing. He accepted whatever Dr.Zakir had said just so that there would be peace.

  • shit man .... people are ready to rip each others skin to print their books for peace with authentic quotations .

  • 5:58 Yes it will solve the problem.

    No offence but when this guy was studying to get his Bsc from Banglore university, did they not teach him to be critical over references? His book wouldn't be accepted by any non-Muslim professor of comparative religion or linguist. How embarassing...

    This guy should just stick to promoting peace and tolerance between Hindus and Muslims. Not to deceive Indian Muslims by saying their faith roots in the Vedas.

  • No RELIGION will make you better person....

    It is all depends on your "KARMA"...

    Religion is a shelter that will provide us with comfortable atmosphere to flourish ourself.

    Having lived in one shelter does not mean that other shelters are not as comfortable and educational as yours.

  • mr sherkhan. plz mind ur language...

    we r not here to keep on criticizing neone religion...

    we need to bridge the gap between our understanding and the misconceptions we have...

    i wouls sincerely like to advice you not to blame a religion.. it is not the religion that is fowl its the followers who misinterpret it for theis selfish reasons

  • Do not afraid hindu brothers and brothers other than muslims because GOD ALMIGHTY loves you .You are human heart filled with kindness,spiritual,feel others pain as your own .these mulla have only one book in there treasure and only they want to explain and analyze it but due to rigid and poor brain activity they only misinterpret this one book .See this cast is suffering severely and making this world HELL in the hope of heaven.pity on them but they are not capable for pity even.GOD will punish

  • zakir naik is a devil in human body. he is converting peace loving muslims into terrorsits ( extemists ). Zakir naik -- for your information - what you think of islamic fundamentalism is nothing but terrorism... you can aregue a zillion times and have your fools clapped for you.. but truth never changes and it is --islamic fundamentalism is nothing but terrorism

  • lolz Zakir pwned our sri sri ravi sankar.

    but yea both r cool :D

  • can any one tell me where did the arab people made learning .i got more confused when i read sayal ul okul.specially page 235 on wards.i get copnfused that wether naik is true or the bok written far earlier than islam came to existence

  • sri ravi shankar why the hell do u write a book with mistakes.? this is not the way u make people come toghether, it will create more conflicts

  • that hindu is crying now. Fuck you, why did you write that shit book at first place?? Only to confuse muslims. Now he is crying" drop that book , don't mentioned about that book". hahahahaha. drink your urine

  • plz view full video u will know y not ques hazrat mohamad intentions y he put his name on the verse la ilaha and y there is no development in muslim countries and y there is no secularism plz read voltaire and rousseau views on islam and then ask naik saying wrong things again does not make him correct even the ppl of mecca were converted by force godwords will encourage anybody to do such nasty things only the devil can

  • to all non muslims

    even a child can understand what this great scholar is saying

    this is truth and if u dont accept it it does not do ant thing

    inteligent non muslims are accepting the truth

    but some fools write the comments only

  • @vishnubhakthi We Muslims don't say anything..

    GOD himself said in his final revelation that this is the only religion that I will accept..

    Read ur vedas, do they even mention the words 'hinduism'??? Or do they ever say that it is the right religion??

    What we say that Vedas may have been written by messengers of GOD, but they were only for that time and today we all should follow the last book, the Quran..

  • @vishnubhakthi

    VISHNU is always with you JUST close your eyes & pray to him he is with you always ........ he is with me he is with US ..

  • @9831522174 he is nowhere and doesn not exist

  • @fazkool1

    Shut up Illiterate terrorist ...

  • @9831522174 hahahahha illiterate some thing is burning there i think

  • @vishnubhakthi.. y pplz like sri ravi misguide pplz writting something which hes himself not sure abt!!... n jihad it self have diferent means, say, if u r fighting with ur own bad deeds n wills .. its jihad!.. n if a person himslef acceptin he has written some mistake he shud replace it n not publish it n e more!

  • @vishnubhakthi

    Well, only a Muslim can understand the joy of having a nonMuslim revert back to the true, proper path. If you think all religions should be equal in their worth then aren't you being a hypocrite??? Why prefer one religion over another if religion doesn't matter at all?

    If you think Muslims are biased out of ignorance, against other religions then you need to study Islam (The Quran and Ahadiths) and judge for yourself.

  • @vishnubhakthi do you know the real meaning of jihad it means struggle it does not mean killing and bombing and suicide but most hindu families put into their childs mind that is islam is wrong when it isnt also media puts in people mind that islam is wrong it isnt if you read the Quran it does not say kill ypourself and bomb yourself for Allah in islam were not allowed to kill ourselves or indulge in things that will harm us

  • @vishnubhakthi Vishnu? Who is he, there's  only one God, Allah. :)

  • mother fucker sickender .... i want to fuck your doughter in her mouth and have a hinduu boy

  • he is sick, leave him. he is so arrogant

  • Religion is the worst possible man made crap on the face of earth

  • This is so stupid to compare religion...

    All religions are ways to reach God, so why some peoples go to others and do proselitism?

    The Budhists,the Hindus,the Muslims,the Jews,the Jains,the Sikhs,the Christians etc... everybody have the right to practice according to his own nature and believes...

    Sri Ramakrishna was correct about this...

    So everybody stop to argues about my religion is best etc...this is a sin, this is stupid and only divide people.

    Respect each others and pray together.

  • why people gave u -? they are dumb. u said so correctly.

  • 1000 of things about Muhammad......heh

    lol@pakiboy103

    this guy Mr. JOKER NAIK is not the man who really help humanity by eliminating the casteisim and religion constraints but he is A SHOPKEEPER WHO KNOWS WHICH THING CAN MAKE HIM POPULAR AND WHICH THING CAN FILL HIS POCKET NO MATTER HOW BAD IS THAT FOR THE HUMANITY AND THE PEOPLES....

  • fucking sulle terrorist, how dare you guys

    even talk about sri sri ravi shankar.........

  • In the context of Zakir mulla's view "SUFI saint" were not not actual muslim because they gave preachings about GOODNESS of all religions Music is not allowed in ISLAM but "SUFI SAINT' every time enjoyed music as part of devotion to the "ALLAH"and Equality of all creatures before "ALLAH".So meanness and selfish motives of these type of kathhamulla spreads wrong dialogue in the innocent muslims and give wrong directions for ISLAM and gaining bread butter with blood of innocent peoples.

  • @rj15121

    its not mr zair naik who views sufi saint as non-muslim. I am sure around 88percent of Muslim world adhere to Sunni sect, most of us do accept Shia as muslims, but Sufi s commit things that are vital against the mainstream of Islam. Dont blame Zakir, its same opinion in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Saudi, Egypt or Africa,

  • Krishna and Radha is one, not two. Radha is Krishna energies. Krishna is formless but take form or incarnate. Krishna wives is Radha expansion born in many families. for you to have an idea, Watch in youtube

    The original form of lord shree krishna

  • Comment removed

  • Sri Sri trying to bring people together, trying to compliment a culture, and Nair is hung up on semantics. The urgent need today is for people to find their common points, which is why someone like Sri Sri will release a book showing how beautiful both cultures are. That is wisdom. Zakir Nair is clearly an intelligent man, but if he'd apply that intelligence to bringing people together rather than highlighting their differences, he could starting making as useful an impact as Sri Sri.

  • ur only saying that because ur not a muslim, so u dont really understand the truth behind dr naiks statements

  • Poo5e.

    lolz. Is that all your logic tell you? wt a stupit things eeevil give u and u pple get satasfiy. muslims tryng hard for you kind of pple to save u from hell and u pple jus want to jump in fire. how pathtic is this.

    zakri naik reading from ur own hindo book in thousands of things about Muahammad saw but still u dont belive. surpriseing u even dont belive ur own books

  • Perfect answer from Ravi Shankar......U dont have to be Danish to eat Danish Cookies......

  • month of meditation sounds as a better derivation of ramadan.....than cooking of the earth by the sun......

  • another tactic spreading corruption

  • Ashvet is non-white, truly a sanskrit word.

    Dr. Naik's explanation for the word is not correct.

  • bullshit more to the point stop running away into caves and fight face to face

  • why write a book in a hurry in the first place .

  • this home grown story must b taught by Mr.Bush type pop in us church like mr.bush made story about 9/11 and started to kill 100000s of innocents. u christians remember 2000 people killed in 9/11(those who did 9/11 should be burnt alive though) where is ur justice wen it comes to israel/kashmir etc.? infact u have own agenda. and for your kind information that slave girls were considered same as wife in arab culture. although it is not true but still if such things had happened then no wonder

  • Dear Sheaky,

    Part 2 of my comment.

    There are hundreds of mosques in India where hindus are allowed to enter and worship their deity. Muslims know that it was hindu temple earlier and they allow hindus to enter.

    Unfortunately these are not disclosed by mullas like the one Dr. Zakir, or Bukhari or hindu secularists. You hate RSS and BJP but wait, they are the only people who talks truth. They reveal these informations.

    RSS reveals good muslims and criticises the bad one. US does opp

  • Dear Sheaky 420,

    You and also muslims in india are not taught the true history. Converting hindus was not easy. There were fighting till britishers conquired india.

    Please check indian history. Do you know why Sikh people wear pagri? That is oath to save hindus from muslims. Rajputs faught against muslims, maratha's faught till 1700-1800 against muslim leaders to save hindus.

    India was fully conquired by muslims completely is a wrong notion. Thousands of fighting went on for 1000 year

  • brother

    what you said is extremely new for me , i never heard of it in my life , if i start from my side then there will be another long debate ,

    you are in your place and i am right at mine

    as while growing up i was forced to hate hindus the same case will be 100% yours

    my teenage was in pakistan and now i am in london,i have many hindu friends and we are best friends,and we never had any debate about this topic instead they are my friends better than pakistanis i have seen on internet that

  • I was also braught up in india but as hindus we are forced to learn compromise. Because as you know hinduism is not a religion, it is a culture which asks to adopt philosophy of your choice, hinduism itself has many contradictory philosophies.

    Do you know Puri RathYatra is one of the greatest event for hindus. And that chariot carrying hindu lords stops in front of a mosque, worship takes place by mullah in the lords deity and then Chariot goes again.

    There are several hundreds of

  • only native indians/pakistanis are fighting with eachother over nothing , so leave every thing

    cool down ;)

  • Dear Sheaky 420,

    Here is the second part.

    You seems to be liberal. Check history of somnath temple, now existing kashi mathura temple, all have accompanied mosque. The muslims living near somnath helped removing the mosque and creating temple in 1950.

    Muslims near babri mosque never entered into the mosque since it was RAM temple. Please verify my statements. Babar after destroying the temple 500 years back himself kept ramlala inside the mosque.

    BJP has excavated temple beneath it

  • Dear Sheaky,

    Literature exists as evidences where muslim leaders describe how brilliantly they destroy temples and burn books.

    Hindu literatures and knowledge books used to be kept in the temples. When muslims destroyed nalanda, it took months after months to burn all the books in the temples.

    Thousands and thousands of womens were raped and taken forcefuly.

    The Taj mahal is built for Noor Jahan. She was a hindu bengali lady with a kid and husband, taken forcefully by shahjahan

  • yeah you are right bro

    people islam spread by swords i agreed with it

    but infact people convert by ther own WILL

    in ancient days(swords/jevelin) it was a custom of battles so muslims use to go on battles conquer their countries,but they didnot force anyone to convert,we muslims have our own rules of battlling

    not to kill woman/child/old age

    not to cut a fruitful tree

    not to kill anyone by giving him pains(kill him in an instance)

    like that type of many rules

  • well according to your statemnt of noorjahan i have no idea about it , so i cant comment on that

    and saying that thousand of women were raped

    so is no clue or evidence,or i didnt heard about it

    there is one sentence of all of your questions

    that if muslims warriors kill non muslims in hindustan (ancient days) then there will be muslims everywhere in subcontinent

    but still there is majority of hindus

  • Dr. Naik says "dont look at muslims they may be bad but kuran is good"

    And he criticises hindus and christians. Why doesnt he read their books those are also good.

    Somebody writes a good book and go on killing is that good?

  • Dr. Naik is a cheater.

    1. He made a video, where sankaracharya is saying that Islam is for peace.

    That Sankaracharya is not real. I have checked thoroughly.

    Such a person should not do this things

  • brother its better if you upload the video instead of telling us that you have the prove

  • Dear Sheaky,

    Just put in youtube Sankaracharya and Zakir Naik

    If you dont get it please comment I will paste that link in your channel.

    Your comment that islam spreaded peacefully is not true. You muslims know that very well but never accept.

    This is why everybody hates muslims. They kill and cook story how peaceful they are.

    Thousands of mosques in india still there which are built by breaking the temples. Evidences are there.

  • well well

    i checked the video (fake and real both)you gave me hints

    well there are two points here

    -that guy is talking in favour of islam/muzlims , and everyone watchin,(solid proof)

    -someone upload a part of his video and add comments on the bottom that this guy is not real n he is a fake infact he is a muslim

    well the thing is that the guy talking in favour of islam and this is real (looks like real)

    but about its a fake,they should upload the video that shoud declare that this guy is a fake

  • Dear Sheaky 420,

    Some people tried to comment and reply video but those are deleted.

    I give you another proof to understand this person is fake. There are four sankaracharya, according to rule established couple of thousands of years a go there should always be four.

    This person is the fifth one. if you search google then you will find details of the four.

    Four are joshi, puri sringeri dwaraka, there is no sankarachaya of venaras as said in the video. This guy is muslim.

  • where is evidance? BJB or RSS? those who planned gujrat riots then exposed? u beleive in those people? islam spread peacefully for this u serach on utube "islamic converts" and u will find many white people converting infact fastest religion from 1934-1984 which war was taken place in this time in West or US? even they r bashing muslims but still people embracing islam.infact they come to comment on islam after listening BBC/CNN but find dat truth is opposite as they say.i gave u facts.can u?

  • Dr. naik was Hafidul quran (memorized whole quran with understanding) therefore he knew arabic.

    thank you

  • Then why did he avoided telling the true meaning of hajrat?????

    Origin of words is not known to him. If he knew he would have said original meaning

  • what do you mean bro ?

    every one knows meaning of hijrat ,,

    even i little muslim child knows

    huh

  • @abrahamjalm u guys must no that dr naik s just ignorant. the word of the bible n quoran n any order religion s 2 creat peace. no one s better than the order. let us b with all that bulshit prick comment. creat peace period

  • Does Dr Naik know that Arabic, Persian and Sanskrit have one origin?

  • lmao every one knows it ,

    infact persian , sanskrit , hindi , urdu , are derived from arabic language , (and some more)

    the subcontinent (indo-pak) was hindustan before muhammad bin qasim a 17 year old warrior invaded hindustan , and at time there were many religions included hinduism , and they all converted to islam by their own WILL at the preach of muslims ,

  • sheaky420, do u read anything else besides Islamic literature. the languages are not derived from Arabic but Indo-European language. Sanskrit is older language than Arabic, ask any philologist.

    2) India was not called Hindustan. It was called Bharat, is still called Bharat.

    3) Not all Indians converted to Islam, you dickhead. And there are still many religions in India. Do us a favour. Keep your fucking mouth shut if you don't know the facts and don't believe in all that your Mullahs tell you.

  • ass whole you are getting out control , did i abuse you , so you showd me your reality who you are !!

    chill karo ,

    lol

  • well, i didn't abuse you. i just wanted to shake you out of stupidity. use your brain. utilize the gift which your Allah has given you. your mind. and don't be a dumbass.

  • these is usual practice of non-muslims that when they dont have any prove then they start abusing bcoz they also hear what Mr.bush says:) their eyes/ears r closed so mouth only speaks bad.

  • You know you are lying when you say that only non-muslims do this.

  • infact u r dickhead + testes ho alwys remain under dick so dnt shout.u only listen to bbc/cnn or ibn.u people r so absent mind dat u make idol 1st then worship him:) it proves ur dickheadness. u just read home grown stories. go and read Micheal heart,karen armstrong n many others about islam. they dont belong to arab world.ther is problem wid u hindus dat u dnt study ur vedas even n start debating.nobody wants to burn in hell even hes hindu/muslim/chris but problem lies dat v r not truth seekers

  • sansikrat is not included bro:)

  • Dr Naik,

    Please behave properly. Hindu's and Shri Shri stretch out hands for friendship. And you find out faults in the documents?

    Does not it show that muslims dont want friendship. They requires only isolation?

    Any muslim here, could u please tell me that by uploading this video u are basically showing how dirty islam is.

    Isnt it?

  • When you are people got effended you started saying rude word is that how religion affected you

  • Muslims are ignorant are beyond belief, just because the etymology is different it doesn't mean this Zakir guy is right. Sri Sri is right at the end of the day words are fickle like Muslims so the intention is the key. The funniest thing is you talk about how we have many gods and how we pray to dieties in form and its somehow blasphemous. Yet ironically Muslims call god omnipotent and omnipresent yet deny his existence in form. See the paradox? Uneducated propaganda is causing the fall of Islam

  • sri sri ravi shankar should come back and have a dialogue again..instead of weeping at his home and on videos on youtube that Dr.Zakir Naik insulted him..

  • The guys who said he converted is a fake guy.. He is a bastard.. Zakir Sucks

  • chut chut ravi shankar..!!!!

  • When we talk aloud in public, to the public, and in the interest of the common man, I think, we should have our statistics corrected before hand, or else avoid coming in public eye!

    Sri Sri Ravi Shankar needs to change his politically correct (& statistically wrong) notions abt The Art of Living, & life itself!!

  • how can someone write a book without intelectual knowledge & responsability. All Sri Ravi did will misguide people eventhough intentionally is good. For me to be on stage is so shameful when the competency is not there, failed to backup his stand.

  • This fool zakir naik is a jihadi terrorist he should be prosecuted for making religious radical mullahs! you bloody mullah go and live in pakistan India is Hindu country. Pakistan mulahs after the election Indian bomb is ready for you wait for that stupid mullahs

  • We are the original real indians we ruled india 1000 years, the rulers did not do their job they should have converted all on sward and power to make hole india muslims, you deserve what brahmins treat you and follow the manu smriti

  • Ravi shankar is a professional person, whose business is to sell religion to people, he look fraud. He is no match for Zakir Naik.

  • i honestly can make you cry but i think you are still ignorant, that's why you should read more like what your prophet said. go till china to get education he said.

  • Zakir Nayak is a liar. He says against koran. Orthodox muslims will not accecpt this. on one occasion he told that men get 72 virgins. but when a women asked what will they get, he told that they too will get 72 virgin men !!!

  • I dont want to be rude but i will frankly tell u that Islam or parts of Islam can never come from a religion that worships;

    Monkeys!

    Rats!

    Elephants!

    The followers even create their own statues out of clay & worship it!

    U ask any muslim in the world how many gods do u have?The answer will be 1

    U ask any hindu how many gods u have?Some will say 1,others will say 10,others will say 100 & u will get some that say everything is god.

    Islam can never cum 4rm a belief as stupid as that!

  • and wich religion do u think can worchip?

  • Humanity

  • See, there are innumerable possiblities that can be explored only by OPEN MINDED and non biased analysis.

    I am very sure they must have had a personal discussion on this before the function. The soul objective of Mr Zakir in this occasion was to be cocky and put down his fellow speaker in front of an audience... I am sure he did it on purpose

  • When ravi shankar wrote the misleading false book,did he consult muslim scholars to ask them if what he stated in his book that indicates Islam came from Hinduism?

    Did he ask muslims how they would feel b4 he distributed it to thousands of people?

    Answer is NO,he thought he was smart but underestimated Islam.

    Why should zakir naik take him into a corner without thousands of people around if ravi shankar didnt giv a crap about distributing a false book on Islam to thousands..

  • dude... this isnt going anywhere as we are going in circles...am windin up.. :-)

    cheers!

  • No hard feelings & its all in the name of fun.

    I couldnt care less what u follow.Take care!

  • sure dude! you too take care..

  • And see This topic has a really good scope of analysis and debate as to what the 'real' origin is. I really cannot make a statement now as i dont consider myself a scholar.

    The reason why i say this is open to debate is bcause vedas and sanskrit date back much older and with older demographics there are chances of cultural exchanges that shaped the world as it is today.

    It cannot be guaranteed 100% that it came from Arabic...what if it was taken from sanskrit to arabic and then back to urdu?

  • You take the opponent to the folowing position:

    "YOU ARE WRONG... Now justify it".

    A justification of this would lead to topics which CANNOT be discussed with such a gathering due to obvious reasons and inevitably Mr Ravi had to take a position of defence by putting himslef down. Zakir clearly knew it and shrewdly cornered Ravi

    He was clearly trying to be cool at his guests expense and used it as a method to publicise his new book as well...

  • anishcp - jus face the facts m8!! his book is a load of crap, he just said the whole book is wrong , so hes contradicting himself .. "bring ppl together" reading contradting verses and wrong .... dont make no sense !!!!

  • y u proud? he invented the telephone???

  • Alhamdu lillah i am so proud of our muslim scholars!

    Whenever thay debate someone they show them who the boss is(Allah).Lol

    I dont blame the hindu's 4 getting so aggitated over watching one of their renowned scholars turned into a pumpkin.

  • LOL do u call this a debate??.. sri sri was invited and virtually insulted!...extremely celf centred.. this is not a debate... he is doing "I will win at any cost"... Mr Ravi shankar dint want to get into this silly squabble.. do check out what he had to tell about this later on... :-)

  • "AJ9996" Its meant to be a debate or a dialogue but i guess ur ravi shankar got humiliated because he wrote misleading & false things about Islam.Dr zakir naik did it in a peaceful way without any violence so save ur excuses.

    Did ravi shankar think he would gat away with it?

    Its nothing to do with squibble squabble but just putting forward facts & if ravi shankar is going 2 start crying like a baby then he shouldnt have written the book & biggest mistake was facing our scholar on stage.Lol

  • Looking at the backdrop... This was meant to be a "similarity" discussion... on patterns that can be seen in two religions. You know the goody goody kinds...

    Where people explore more aboout a differnt beleif system. And see.. Zakir has pointed out that the origins of teh words were differnt from what ravi had said.. point taken!.. but coouldnt there be a possiblity of common source of origin for both the words.

  • There are innumerable possiblities which Mr. Zakir wouldnt even care to look.. cuz he is desperately and vehemantly protecting his stance... This closed approach is not good for any philosophy/relegion or debate as it restricts it growth... THIS CLOSED MINDED and FUNDAMENTALIST approach is what I am against. Once again..

  • the purpose of this talk was not whose religion is better! but Mr Zakir is BLATANTLY biased towards his religion when a dispassionate approach is caled for.. Mr RAvi took a Gentlemanly stance.. and bailed out of the IMMATURE and CHILDISH squabble...

    If he had challeneged teh totally uncalled for attack, it would be folowed by a retalliation... and an inevitable communication break down..

  • I am sorry to say ... this is a poor way to treat your fellow speaker; especially when it comes to sensitive topics like faith!!! I hope he and the other people who support him realise this instead of applauding and saying "hey! we won!!".. for god sake this was't a cricket match!!!

  • If it was about similarities ur scholar ravi shankar made a book about similarities trying to indicate Islam came from hinduism but dr zakir naik corrected him because he was wrong & he did it in a nice way aswell so star crying when a mistake is corrected?He didnt shout or make aggressive comments towards him.

    Just accpet he cudnt take zakir naik revealing ravi shankars falsehhod & manipulating which is why he started crying & which is why ur crying aswell.Go & put a dummy in ur mouth!

  • Every religion has a wright ro defend their religion if someone is distributing false information about their religion.

    Ravi shankar created a lie about Islam & was spreading that lie so our scholar proved & corrected his lie which ravi shankar acknowledged.We cant discuss similarities based on alse propaganda like ravi shankars book so he showed him whi the Daddy is..

    STOP WINGING & EMRACE ISLAM

  • Buddy, i can take decisons on what faith I should embrace... and I consider religion as only a means of reaching the higher realm of sprituality. It doesnt matter which religion you chose... So You are perfectly fine if you follow Islam or whatever you feel like. (I personally donot follow rituals of any religion). I dont want to drag myself into these religious superiority debates.

  • I comented here as I felt the manner of argumentation inappropriate (I am not a follower of Mr. Ravi as well.. but felt bad at the way he was dealt with)! but i guess the way your faith functions... definitely not my cup of tea!But what matters is if it works for u, and it seems to!.. so cheers n good luck!

  • A response from xakir naik about a book spreading wrong info about Islam isnt anything bad but good.He did it in a nice way just told him that what he wrote is not correct so icant seem to understand what all of a sudden the fuss is about.

    If he pointed a gun at him or started throwing swear & horrible insults at him then u have a case but this dialogue was conducted in a peaceful manner.

  • LOL...during a debate among intellectuals of the higehst caliber the above mentioned things would never ever crop in (These arent two thugs debating)!!! they are men with reputation and caliber. What I am saying is: there are more subtle courtesies and way of presenting an argument or disagreement for facts instead of what was done out here. This wasnt possibly not the smartest move Ravi made... He should have been vary of attacks and a hostile response!

  • During a debate between 2 intellectuals regarding similarities in Islam & Hinduism,then if 1 of the speakers writes or has written a book on similarites & that book is false & misleading then it is a responsibility for the other scholar to point out that mistake so the other speaker has a chance to refute it infront of him but as we know lies cannot be defended like in ravi shankars book & just accept it ur ravi shankar is based on lies & ur upset coz his lies got revealed to the world..Lol

  • U keep on winging like a baby saying u felt bad the way ravi shankar was dealt with but i have seen this debate many times & it looked very peaceful so i cant understand what ur still winging about.If it was the other way around hindus would have byn all over muslims but because we wipe the floor with u,u cant take it.

    Since ur saying zakir naik treated him badly then break it down & lets find out,

    what was it that he said?

    how did he say it?

    How did he humiliate him & words used?

  • OK heres how I would suggest to handle it:

    1. The whole thing could have been ended by Mr Zakir by saying that he had to disagree with some of the points in book of which he will present a detailed book review; instead of 5 minutes 25 seconds of opposition with the person sitting there and a huge gathering. Ravi had to break in to stop Mr Zakir from going on.

    This is IMPOLITE... If you cant realize it, then I cant help it

  • 1st of all u cannot give me references as to what he said or words he used which made u feel that he wasnt dealt with correctly because he didnt.

    Secondly ur winging because dr zakir naik corrected ravi shankars misleading,false claims that he wrote in a book about similarities.

    Ur not making any sense at all.Its a dialogue on similarities & dr zakir naik spoke on the subject & told him he was wrong about the book he wrote on similarities.Whats the problem..

  • U have a right to choose ur own path & destiny so lets hope u choose the best path.

  • he does not point out the confusing parts, he just analyses certain verses.

  • Great answer Zakir BHI

  • on top of everything... he is more familiar with arabic(originated from midle east) than sanskrit(originated from INDIA) why can he go to middle east and try to bring some peace within his muslim brother's there? lol never happens

  • lol i still cant understand why he is worried about other relegions. ravishankar has a lot of disciples around the world from all the relegions. can this stupid fellow have thatmuch people to listen to him? and this idiot speaks only about islam whereas ravishankar speaks about human beings.

  • zakir naik doesnt understand the scriptures he memorizes the scriptures

  • totally agree with that !! well said,,,

  • many people have come with videos that revealed his fraudness,anyway i respect his memory power but that wont help him to destroy the TRUTH

  • thanks dude ,zakir can fight everything about islam,but there one thing he cant fight for it,the inscription of king aaditya in a gold dish hung in kaaba,it says that he[aaditya] brought light to the place and so on,king aaditya was a hindu so,what is he gonna say about this

  • I agree with you. He does not have the knowledge to interpret the Vedas as he is just an MBBS. But he tries to does so.

  • No One Know the Truth about Shiva Ligaum muslims Preach all bad things of it As their Thinking is cheap they also Worship the Black Box and Moon god How do you feel that i am igroant of your religion right TRUE same i feel about you guys So Understand The Truth

  • i think ur thingking is good n u have a great knowledge of hindusm so tell what is shiva ligaum..i like to know n tell me how good u n ur relegion r

  • shiva linga worship is superior because it makes the worship simple because of the form while maintaining the truth that God is not having any definite form. There are a lot more marvelous principles behind the shiva linga worship which could be found in detail in standard scriptures.

  • God is formless, attributeless and omnipresent. This state is called arUpa (formless). For the benefit of the pashus,He took the form of shiva li.ngam which is neither form nor formless but is a symbol. This symbol of Him is called arUparUpam (formless form). He took many forms out of His mercy to bless all,which are called rUpams. (2)shaivam worships the God in all these three states. The oldest form that the formless God took namely the shiva lingam is called sadAshiva mUrtam and is worshipped

  • The Bible very vividly divulge that the Sivalinga worship was in vogue in as much as six places viz., Bethel, Shechem, Gilgal, Mizpah, Dan and Ebenezer. In the same manner, the worship that was initiated by Ibrahim at Mecca, the only temple for the universal Muslims, is the Sivalinga worship of the Hindus. Anyone who could closely observe the holy stone at Kabha can easily decipher that it is a Sivalinga and the manner of its worship is the worship of the Hindus

  • Hindutva is different and Hindu religion is different altogether.Infact the Hindu religion refers to Saivism and Vaishnavism.But Hindutva refers to the hegemony of caste inequality. Sir William Jones who had translated the Manu Dharma Sastra,into the European language which was useful forthe English people,was acclaimed and was honoured by way ofthe installation of his statue,holding the Manu Dharma Sastra in his hand,at St.Pauls Cathedral atLondon this statue is very much there inthe Cathedral

  • The Jews are the descendants of Abraham, the worshipper of one-God.There is a very close relationship between Abraham and the Dravidian race.Because it was only during the middle of the 20th century the glory and the antiquity of the Dravidians were unearthed through the research findings of the Indus Valley excavations and since the Brahmins who are in power in the Indian politics resort to ruin this truth through various unethical means the antiquity and glory of the Hindus are camouflaged

  • Brother Some truth are Better Left Buried So lets not Dig out the Grave Request you to Stop Following Misunderstood souls like Zakhir and Please Namaz Allah and Read glorious Koran As We Meditate Upon Formless Sivam and Worship His Form Mahadev

    Har Har Mahadev Om Tat Sat

  • if i don't lisen to zakir(pbuh) then whom i listen this sri sri hah??? who accepted his mistakes...who don't have knowledge about his religion hah?? bro just stop this non sense thing...i listen to hindus also n i never abuse then whether they r wrong....like so y r abusing zakhir(PBUH) just stop it man...hope u understand

  • You still don't understand what i say i am saying Don't follow Stupids like zakhir or ravi shankar they both are imperfect to comment or others Religions i can find ample number of lies told by zakhir and simple copy pasting from unauthorised source in Ravi shankars books at least he was great person top accept his mistakes he practices what he preaches that's ravi shankars greatness but i ask you to just read Koran and follow Allah not to fall for cheap tricks of this so called gurus or mullahs

  • Sri Sri is too gentle and humble to lock head with this moron Dr naik. I will refute Naik's logic here about the languages, Arabic and Sanskrit. Even a ignorant and arrogant individual like Naik should know which one is the oldest language? Arabic is a language which is an offshoot of Hebrew, Sanskrit is the mother of all Indo European languages. How old is Islam? 1300 yrs. Now, its natural that old language will influence the new one, Arabic is merely an offshoot of hebrew, will he get it?

  • What is the need to convert? bro no one wants to convert u, we only convey the message from the almighty.

  • only fools will convert themselves! you are 100% correct, do u know why, cuz only allah can revert u to islam! may allah guide u all amiin read ur scripture and compare with koran and u see who teaches hatered etc

  • why write a book in a hurry.. you have to accept the responsibilities as people will be reading it.. or call it a fiction so that people will not be taking it seriously as ravi ji himself is asking from everyone.. not a reflection on the brother though..good heart.. everyone needs to make a living init..;)

  • muslim fuckers

  • Dr. Zakir claims to reply the questions.. Would you please say something on the fact the the QURAAN says that someone who kills a non-muslim (kafir) will go to heaven??

    If you can please clarify...