Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (142)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Alright, I admit it. I used to watch American Idol...Why? Because quite often the contestants were of a high standard (Taylor Hicks to name but one) the house band was excellent, and once in a while there was a gem like this! Here in England there isn't exactly an abundance of good music on television.

    Listen to it and if you don't know already, know that Jeff Beck is an extraordinary talent - and that Kelly Clarkson really has what it takes.

  • So inspiring and shows me just how far I have to go. Thanks to Patty Griffin for writing this wonderful song that we love so much. And for Martin Luther King showing us how to live.

  • I'm only here cuz of JEFF BECK!

  • i like how probably half the people in the crowd dont know who Jeff Beck is haha, they were truly lucky and i dont think they even realize that haha but what an amazing performance

  • Not sure it has anything over what Heather Evans and 12 year old guitar prodigy Caden Davis have on here. Check em out and tell me if I'm wrong.

  • SIMPLY AMAZING!!!!!!

  • I can hear Jeff Beck's guitar weeping. This is a divine performance of both of them.

  • The one and ONLY real AMERICAN IDOL! Love this Woman!!

  • Carrie Underwho?

  • Kelly Clarkson with Jeff Beck equals perfection.

    I doubt it will ever be better than this folks.

  • where can we buy the studio version mp3 of this? it's not on iTunes anywhere :(

  • @f1hideous The only version is the live version seen here....it was available on i-tunes for a short time. I'm sure you can still find it on the web somewhere.

  • ahh, two of the best. We're singing this in my choir :)

  • she is just amazing! a wonderful singer/writter!!! but the most important thing, she really has good feelings!!! like saving anilmals that the state would kill and not wanting to sing "never again" on idol gives back!!!! and i think she was really touched by the charity stuff and proubed in the song!!!! AMAZING!!! YOU ARE THE BEST IDOL !!!!!!!!!!! KELLY ALL THE WAY!

  • i sometimes think if i sqeeze my eyes just right i can see angels touching her while she sings...

    sublime

  • even though her album my december was tanking... she refused to promote it and promote herself by singing a song off the album... she instead chose to sing a song towards a good cause! she just proves that she is a class act and why she deserves to be the one and only kelly clarkson! amazing!

  • Oh my god! It must the 50 times I watch this video and like an idiot I jut realized that the woman behind the piano is Kelly! So stupid! lol

  • Jeff's making that guitar sing

  • I am a DIE HARD KC FAN. I have seen her in concert 5 times, met her 2 times.. been here since she first opened her mouth on idol... and THIS PERFORMANCE.... well this performance is something of a wonder that most humans will never experience in their lifetime. The raw emotion and sincerity this woman pours into this performance, is something from out of this world! I truly and whole heartily believe that Kelly Clarkson is the VOICE of our generation, and that this is only the beginning.

  • The first two vocal lines are given to the audience, then she closes her eyes and we are no longer there. She is the song, she is not going to shriek or dance to get your attention. Moments of true beauty can't be wasted.

  • @earsmcgee Very, very well said. :)

  • f***ing brilliant, chills , not one "run" in her performance. to all singers its about THE SONG not how you can show off your ability. Mariah used to sing way stronger until she got" run " happy and started whispering her lyrics. Kelly uses her voice to compliment this song so well the audience is compelled to applaude, TWICE, in the middle of it. Also love how the crowd is so captivated with her that you dont hear one clap until the last note drifts away wish i was there

  • Great MLK tribute

  • As someone said before, she could have been in woodstock. I agree 100%. Kelly Clarkson on this song, it just goes above and beyond.

  • She can really sing, he can really play, the song is really meaningful - this performance really takes off. what a cool way to use jeff beck and her amazing vocal chords.

    i just can't stand american idol, but heck - if they found her, i guess it can't be that bad, as long as i don't have to watch it.

  • brilliant

  • 3:35 thunk...thunk...PING!...third time's the charm.

  • @strandwolf Sometimes harmonics are real bastards!

  • when she sings that song...Jesus shows up where I am......its all beautifullllllllll

  • she is fucking good!!!

  • I don't know if anyone else felt that.... but Jesus came into the room as I was hearing that song.....wow.....beautifully sweet......wow....

  • @kawfer1  Actually....i beleive it was Muhammad.

  • @atomic3939 it doesn't matter if you think it was muhammad or not... truth is truth wether you choose to beleive it or not.....

  • She shouldn't even be on the same stage as JB.

  • I hate to be mean but getting the men to wear condoms would go a hell of a lot further than 10 bucks

  • Kelly Calrkson sounds great and Jeff Beck is Beck noyhing more to say there. We need to also listen to the lyrics and remember the man the song is about. Doctor Martin Luther KIng was a friend to all people no matter what their skin color was. He was what I would call a cool guy. He loved people because they are here and we are suppose to love each. He did practice what he preached. Great song.

  • are u kidding me?? if this hear sick voice sounds like then she should fall 'sick' more often (not that i ever wanted her to fall sick, omg i always pray for her)...she's sound incredible and perfect!!!

  • i couldn't stop seeing this over and over...her voice just magnificent!!! she's indeed belong here in the industry....such a god given talent~~~

  • Chokes me up every time i hear this. The songs from My December - "Maybe, Be Still, Yeah and Irvine", not enough words. She is not appreciated enough! She should record songs like "Up to the Mountain, Natural Woman, Stuff like that there, Why" and i'll buy it. She covers songs like NOBODY else. She is the ONE for me. Comparisons to Celine Dion notwithstanding. To me Celine Dion, though a Great Singer, sings word with an accent which puts me off (i am prepared for the brickbats now)

  • im crying

  • Comment removed

  • Amazing ...!! The last Guitar Note sends chills!! WOW

  • Kelly is WOW I love her Voice and she is so Beautiful !

    Jeff Beck's sound is incendiar 

  • real good jo by kelly clarkson,but if you don't think crystal bowersox version is better you just don't get it !!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i really like kelly clarkson and she sang this well but crystal bowersox's version was so much better!! crystal has so much soul she's amazing

  • An Awesome song played by an equally awesome Jeff Beck. WOW

  • her and reba mcentire are my favourtie

  • WAYYYYYY BETTER THAN CRYSTAL

  • @stephrox26 i know. no comparison

  • screechy and unpleasant at 3:00

  • @34jlta are you kidding? that's one of the highlights of the performance.

  • @EvFan1985 Sorry - not a fan.

  • @34jlta oh. griffin fan- no wonder.

  • @EvFan1985 I prefer Griffin's performance to Clarkson's. You prefer Clarkson's to Griffin's. That's what makes the world go round.

  • @34jlta the fact that you would make that statement shows you know nothing about music

  • @defasabat456 How little YOU know. It's all a matter of what floats your boat.  Clarkson has a nice, big, powerful voice without nuance. Find her boring.

  • @34jlta i understand what you mean but what i was refering to was that you pointed out 1 second of the song to bitch about.

  • @34jlta i understand what you mean and i agree but what i was refering to was the fact you picked 1 second of the song to say it was unpleasant judge on the hole song not just a moment you don't like.

  • @defasabat456 Yes, that was unpleasant, but the fact is, sadly, I just don't like her voice. I've gone through her work and downloaded just one, "If No One Will LIsten" - sort of apropos as I didn't listen after the first few times. Tried my best because so many like her, but just didn't jell. I'm sure there are singers that I like that you wouldn't. Makes life interesting - no?.

  • @34jlta i have to admit you are right and iam wrong you do have the right to your opinion and i had no right saying you don't know music i guess as a musican myself i took it the wrong way (thought you were nitpicking) in short i spoke in hast and if i came across like an ass i apologize.

  • @defasabat456 Really appreciate your reply post - you're a class act.

  • @34jlta LMAO! Without nuance? Are you kidding? Me thinks ye need to get yer ears checked!

    Every single moment of this performance is nuanced, but on a MUCH higher musical level than most, so maybe you aren't used to the true art of singing? I have played CM for many famous singers, and this girl has an incredible voice.

  • Good job Kelly, great song. And Jeff Beck can do no wrong.

  • 3:10 to 3:15 is absolutely gorgeous. Love her.

  • @daveorawk2 yes i have to agree !;)

  • She truly is AMA-ZA-ZING lol

  • does anyone know how these two got together for this show?

  • I still get choked up. She is really moving.

  • Whew!

  • I wanna marry her.

  • what an incredible singer! her voice is amazing! she is one of the best known singers in the world! idol is lucky to have found her!

  • this is so fantastic

  • the truth is that not a single winner of any season of american idol even comes close to kelly clarkson's level, and to be honest i doubt any contestant ever will. she is simply incomparable.

  • oh absolutely!!! kelly owns in the vocal department!!!

  • @tflynn17 What exactly has Kelly released that is "strange"?

  • yeah, but kelly is an international artist.....carrie..not so much

  • @BobBarkersLoveChild yeah carrie is not known everywhere..kelly is a world wide sensation..incredible talent with a lot of charisma..super talented and very very likable...super funny too w/c makes her more lovable..

  • So true!

  • I'm wondering if the Kelly Clarkson fans here realise the significance of the guy she's performing with. Jeff Beck is a legend in the Rock Music. He is widely regarded as one the the 4 or 5 greatest rock guitarists ever. He can also play almost any style of music, jazz, blues, whatever. He is in Rock and Roll Hall of Frame-twice, once with Yardbirds and then as a solo artist. Notice the sublty way he plays here with such style and taste. He's my favorite guitarist.

  • Jeff Beck on American Idol. Who would have thought?

  • Were singing this song for our showchior its so beautiful!!

  • could you imagine having this kind of talent? my god...what a natural gift

  • she is the shit

  • Kelly Clarkson almost deserves Jeff Beck.

  • Kelly Clarkson really does not get enough recognition!! This is just pure divinity in song right here!! AMAZING!

  • This is, hands down, the best performance from her. Her singing from 3:10-3:15 is the most beautiful singing I have ever had the pleasure of hearing. I can't stop listening to it.

    And I'm not a religious person, but this deeply moves me.

    <3

  • you are so right. from 3:10 to 3:15 just eats my soul.

  • This rendition brings me to teers,kelly feels what she sings,and as a guitar player I know jeff is inspired by the vocal performance as well.Well done young lady,well done! A true,pure,inspiring moment in time when all the cares of this world go away,I will watch this again and again.

  • Jeff Beck is amazing (as always)! Kelly sings it beautifully. She's at her best right here, her voice nice and rested. I miss that Kelly...

  • patty griffin should sign the rights over to that song to kelly cause she made it her own. kelly should do more covers of patty griffin, this song is killer!

  • This is indeed a Classic moment right here.....

  • wanna know wat i dont understand? how kelly has vocals like that? they're perfect, she didnt miss a single note here, like this girl was given one of the biggest gifts ever!! like i didnt grow up around like aretha and lennox and all those ppl, but i can guarentee if kelly was famous back then she'd be up there cuz i know in todays music, she is one of the greatest music sensations ever, she can actually sing live and it's jaw droping, shes got a voice of an angel

  • she's wearing a nightdress

  • i have this on my ipod, and i was playing it the other day and my dad was like DAMN kelly! lol and i know who jeff beck is :) im only 17 but i know my music...AMAZING vocals and guitar playing all together, incredible performance and yeahh no one could pull this off except kelly clarkson(and jb)!! :) lol ellen is kool and very funny..

    kc fan in missouri~

  • Jeff Beck is one of the all time great rock guitarists. And he can also play blues and jazz as well. He isn't as famous as Eric Clapton because he doesn't sing (can't sing) but he is just as significant a force with the innovations he made. He is the guitar player''s guitar player. For the people who know music in his genre no one is more respected than Jeff Beck. If you ever get a chance to see him live, take it. You won't be disappointed. Watch some Ytube videos of him. He's amazing.

  • One of the best vocals by Kelly Clarkson to date. Very soulful. It's good to hear her performing something other than pop. They should record this one.

  • @MajorHaze sure man, what i find funny, is how pretty much all motown singers were at this level, and that was going back 40 to 50 years. its amazing how little its changed really.

  • absolutely flawless! I doubt that any other idol winner could pull this off better than her. I dont think anyone should attempt to sing this song again, because it belongs to kelly now. =) and jeff beck's guitar playing is awesome!!!!

  • AMAZING!!!!!

  • Blew them away! Different league!

  • Excellent! Kelly all the way! The OG American Idol!

  • Jeff Beck! Jeff Beck!

  • I wonder if the Kelly Clarkson fans know the significance of the guy who is playing guitar. For once Ellen go something correct. Jeff Beck is a legend in the Rock World. He is the guitar player's guitar player.

  • They probably don't, but isn't that the beauty of such shows as American Idol and the Grammys? They help educate younger audiences, such as myself.

  • @juscurious you are absolutely right my brother. Beck is a legend..and so humble! Did you see how he was standing to the side after the performance? That, right there, is the sign of a great musician and human being. I love kelly and this is absolutely one of the best she ever did.

  • @juscurious i wonder if jeff beck fans know the significance of the girl who is singing on stage.

    She is an amazing singer and she is so underrated with that voice.

  • @juscurious He is indeed. I'm 19, been playing guitar for eight years now and I finally saw the man live this weekend. There is no other guitar player alive right now, with the exception of Chuck Berry who is greater than him. He is the man the master, the legend.

  • @bluesboy25000 Then you must have seen in SF, April 16. A friend of mine was at the show. I saw him last spring and was traveling so I couldn't see him this past time. It's good to see that the younger people are appreciating good music. I must disagree with you about Chuck Berry. Berry wrote great guitar riffs but really wasn't a that great a player. He influenced R&R as much as anyone.

  • @juscurious Nope saw him the day after at the Nokia Theater in Los Angeles

  • @juscurious not to seem pedantic but im a massive kelly fan but av know about jeff eck since way before i was a kelly fan lol and not just him!! like joe perry i was like hell yeah when i saw him n kelly together lol

  • @sjcgriffiths They don't make them like Jeff Beck anymore. There have been just a handful of guitar players who have really changed R&R. Beck isn't as well know as Clapton or Hendrix but in a lot of ways he was just as influential. He was never a recognized name because he can't (and doesn't) sing and that's a great handicap. He has influenced many of the great guitarists of his era and has earned the recognition as the guitar player's guitar player. His music is for serious people.

  • @juscurious jeff is a legens, very few are as versatile as him, he plays his heart out on evry song, very rare these days, i can think of 3 or 4 others who still play with feeling and actually have the technical ability to suport it!!

  • @juscurious I don't know anyone that doesn't know who Jeff Beck is, and I am classical! I think he is more well known than you think.....

  • @juscurious Right on...except, funny thing is Beck can sing, has a pretty good voice, but obviously never uses it

  • @juscurious well if they didnt before this performance... they do now.

  • I think this really pushes her into the Janis Joplin bracket of vocalists

  • Didn't know she could sing but to be honest I was just listening to Beck nail the track, amazing guitar.

  • Wow. Jeff Beck's playing is jaw-dropping.

  • I love Jeff's playing on this - a lot like the stuff he did for Scorsese's Red White and Blues documentary

  • I agree, goose bumps every time I watch it.

  • that is chemestry. pure soul. bravo to kelly and jeff

  • Awesome - good as it gets.

  • lol u comment on jeff beck u should comment on the singer kely clarkson but sure jeff beck is awesome but kelly clarkson sure as hell nailed this. Best version by far i like origina lbut i like this more her vocal performance is just omg amazing she is so good.

  • In my opinion, this is the best vocal performance of her career.

  • @daveorawk2

    Are you kidding? She sounds sick here. Her voice is really scratchy and pitchy when trying to reach the high notes. Definitely not.

  • @Hells2TheYea it doesnt mean she is sick its called raspy and she is putting hella emotion in it,the high note i see nothing at alllllll sounds like that becdause its so much soul and emotion in it added rasp

  • @KellyFan4Lyfe08,

    Yes it does matter because it affects the song. She came out publicly and said she was sick when she sang this. It's not horrible but it's not amazing either. She didn't get sick on purpose. So that obviously affects her range and voice for the song.

  • @Hells2TheYea it doesnt not affect the song she sang it the best susan nor crystals version are not good compared to this,im one of kellys biggest fans and i dont recall her ever sayin she was sick if she was sick she was sick if she wasnt she wasnt,regardless she nailed it,so much emotion and soul love the rasp,and it didnt affect her,she got praised for this peformance thank u,and she still hit 3 F#5s,most artist cant even hit one F#5 muchless 3 in one song

  • @BladeAndSoul Kelly Clarkson gets enormous amounts of attention. She's popular and very well known. Jeff Beck is one of the unsung heros of R&R. He helped to revolutionize guitar playing and when Jimi Hendrix went to England, Beck & Clapton were the guys he wanted to meet. But Beck is not a household Name. He doesn't sing (or can't) so he had to take a different career path. He is a legend among guitar players and his influence is huge.

  • @juscurious There isn't a guitar player who doesn't owe a huge debt to Jeff Beck. He's an incomparable guitarist. His recordings in the Yardbirds and Rod Stewart set the Template for Zeppelin and Sabbath

  • Out goes the Pop Star and here comes the beginning of a Diva. I am blown away. I watch this I don't know how many times and its obvious to me that both Jeff Beck soulful blues playing and Kelly Clarkson soulful and spiritive singing complimented each other. Bravo!!!

  • Jeff Beck is THE GOD OF GUITAR !

    Bow Down Mofos !!!

  • Great to see a true musical genius up there on stage. That's Jeff Beck I'm talking about, of course!

  • Kelly Rocks!!

  • hummmm

    Im the frst to comment.. eheh

    maybe the unique? lol

    kelly clarkson is awsome!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more