Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,938)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love it when i kill with Jack this Bastard Edgar Ross. I've done it ever with Mauser. So I can put 15 Bullets in his head!

  • R.I.P JOHN MARSTON WE LOVE YOU

  • When ever I play this game befor I go and murder anyone I stop by johns grave to pay my respects

  • @muskeldundret It won game of the year twice I think

  • i cried when john died

  • @dylansgonecrazy didn't we all :(

  • such a good game+r.i.p john

  • rip john marston... we miss u FUK YOU EDGER ROSS FUK YOU

  • we will miss you john RIP

  • (R.I.P John Abigail And Uncle) :'( Best game ever 1 of the best endings and the best songs still crying ever tho i beat this game 60000 times i still cry about the death I wish my family is like Johns when im 37 ,Because he has a beautiful wife and a charming son and Uncle.R.I.P John every misses you :"""""""""""""(

  • 28 trolls :(

  • he will be missed RIP john marston:'(

  • if i try to sing this ima start crying im surprised that the guy singing this didnt cry

  • Dear Rockstar games,

    please stop making such endings. I thought you want to make the player excited not crying.Happy ends are always a good choice so please ...

  • @Picolini333 Thats exactly why they made the ending the way it was. It was very sad, but undoubtedly memorable.

  • @Picolini333

    You didn't kill Edgar Ross as Jack? That made me pretty happy.

  • why does this song reminds me of the movie The Donner Party (2009)

  • everyones mentioning john, may god rest his soul, but not how you end up with some dumb kid named jack, kid was a total knob.

  • this song always makes me sad

  • even chuck norris cried at the end of this game :`(

  • R.I.P John Marston :"( ...... B.I.H (BURN IN HELL) ROSS you sick twisted B*****D....

    I've never cried at the end of a video game until this one :"(

  • I read in the newspaper that Irish accidentally shot himself in a outhouse lol

  • @millerhighlife2112 Irish deserved to die. Hated his freaking guts

  • John reminds me of my dad, minus the murderous tendencies and gang filled past.

  • I have never cried after playing a video game. But when this started to play, that all changed. I had become so attached to John while he fought to regain those he loved. Even to this day, I hear this song, and my chest gets tight. Sure sign that game was gorgeous and the story wonderful: if it still makes you emotional months after finishing it.

  • how the hell did they make me feel bad about a guy that never existed?

  • go fuck yourself ross!

  • What I found amazing in Redemption's story--Each act shows what John will do for his family. In the first one, he helps West Dickens cheat and lie--and boy does he kill for a cause. In the second act, he freely swaps sides between the Mexican army and rebels, depending on who can help him more--and he tortures De Santa. In the third arc, he goes against a man who's as good as his own father. In Act 4 Marston dies for his family, to let them be free of the persecution that'd follow them otherwise

  • i will play this at my funeral, since i was born originally in the west

  • i honestly welled up with tears when john was killed. he was such a rugged figure, yet, had a soothingness to him

  • John did not deserve to die... i am gonna make blackwater a ghost town by killing everyone there... thumbs up if you will to. John will be avenged!!

  • @TheInsanity9

    Don't take it out on Blackwater. Take it out on Edgar Ross in the final mission as Jack.

  • The sad thing is, he distracted the cops so his family could get away

  • ROCKSTAR GAMES ARE THE BEST

  • Lmao! I love how tou guys are like "rest in peace john" and he's not even real! That shows how fuckin awesome this game was. It had us crying about a little digital man! :D x

  • red dead is the best game i have ever played. storyline and gameplay. and i have more respect to john marston than any "real" person

  • Easily the best game..

  • shit...i know john marston is a fictional characters....but rockstar made him alive...shit...i was so fucked up when i find out that he died died...

  • Goodnight John Marston, wherever you are.

  • theres something about jack that u just have to beat hiim thn as u play as him u got to kill him or get him killed

  • @TheWalkingDeadMan147 that´s because it´s Jack Marston

  • This will be my funeral song.It must be..

  • R.I.P john u did good work for ur family

  • i played nearly every rockstar game ever and characters came and gone but this is the only one i'm sad about never getting to play as again

  • Oh god RDR of all games have the epicest storyline, thumbs up if agree! :D

  • @MsSandmaster i would rather thumb up quality posts, stalk thumbwhoring

  • I dont want Jack i want John back!!!!!!!!!

  • I cried over a song. What a sad death, even in a video game....

  • wow this song makes me so sad! i want john back! he was not always the best man in his life but he bettered himself for his family and should not have died! he did not deserve it! R.I.P JOHN MARSTON YOU HAVE BEEN AVENGED goodbye from a fellow scottish american! thumbs up if you agree

  • @coxenherrerajames19 he stiil alive in undeadnight mare hes a zombie

  • I don't care how they do it. I want John back.

  • @Virk1997 have you played undead nightmare?

  • @Virk1997 well you get to be john again

  • @MrKalashnikov96 I know that but I want a full RD that has him in it.

  • This Song is for a man that may not have always done the right thing in life. But as he grew and realized that his family was the most important thing in this life , he started to turn a corner and that is what we all got to see . A man that would give the shirt off his back to a complete stranger . A man that would lend a hand to anyone who was doing the right thing . We could all learn alot from Mr. Marston

    R.I.P John god knows we miss ya

  • @Leafs4eva1986 its a character from a game seriously people take this way to serious

  • @sweenkingandwow2 you ever played the game?

  • @denno2407 finished it 2 times why??

  • @sweenkingandwow2 That's how you know the writers did their job right. When people are so invested in the plot that when something happens to the character that they have to stop and think about things. It's not over reacting, it's exactly what writers want you to do.

  • @Metalhead197 yeah its a sad and a very well done ending

  • @sweenkingandwow2 Well, you could learn a lot from John Marston, he's right about that, but he's a little bit overreacting when he says R.I.P.

  • This song reminds me of Jeremiah Johnson. Which makes even more badass.

  • Dear Santa,

    All i want for Christmas is for you to please bring John Marston back to us.

  • This made my eyes sweat

  • i cried of coures

  • I'd pay £20 for a alternative ending:L i loved john... then i was heartbroken... i was stuck with... jack...:/

  • Z3ko no that would make no sense and be dumb considering what happend in the first one and only first one mayb like a map pack but thats it

  • They should make a prequel to RDR, where John is with his old gang and what they did and how he met abigale. Itd be pretty sick.

  • @Z3koD3vo theres another red dead.. red dead revolver

  • Beautiful Choice Of Words, John Tried To Change But What Goes Around Comes Around:( I Want 2!

  • @rutinzx You mean 3? Red Dead Redemption is the second game in the Red Dead series. The first was Red Dead Revolver.

  • (LANOIRE SPOILER) Much sadder than Phelps dying. Phelps was kind of a douche.

  • @MxOxRxRxIxS

    Actually it is not clear that Phelps died, he got washed up in the sewer but I think said they didn't find his body so, who knows?

  • @TheWholtz He got washed away in an over flowing sewer. He drowned.

  • @MxOxRxRxIxS all cole said was goodbye

  • @carren1z He said "Good-blub blub blub blub..."

  • i broke down when the ending came T.T

  • I want then to make a prequell to rdr!

  • well technically john had reached redemption ie red dead redemption

  • ahhh why John !! :´(

  • i cryed when i saw john marstons grave

  • this song is a good song, and if you don't respect it, or play red dead redemption, then you have not lived.

  • R.I.P John Marston :(

  • @TheKillerFishTKF99 right?! that is the saddes ending to any movie or game i've ever seen. but it was genious. i jst beat the game my girl played it with me she almost cried i felt bad i laughed a little at her but i mean i was high come on. one of the best games i've ever played.

  • Why'd they bury him on the lone prairie if his dying wish was not to be buried there? Jerks.

  • oh my god i hate my friend for never playin this not even undead nightmare all he plays is black ops like what the fuck his name is kreazaykid997 or somethin like that and i need everyone to go to his channel and tell him to get it

  • I wish people on the internet didn´t ruin the ending for me..

  • I started this game determined to turn Marston into a psychotic, mass murdering asshole (Just like I did with Niko Bellic). But the more I played the more he grew on me... After awhile I found myself unable to choose my typical 'asshole' actions because I genuinely wanted John to find redemption. The ending left me emotionally drained. It was one of the saddest endings Ive seen in the long time.

  • @tobs001 On the plus side, John's tragic sacrifice due to the govt's backstabbing ways made my subsequent massacres as his son feel totally justified :D

  • @tobs001 I love how he killed himself so his son wouldn't end up like him and he could have a good life.But I still went around killing people,

  • fuck the guy who killed john he is an asshole this song made me cry. i love the game . its my favorite game and always will be long live john marston!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @IndianaJoker

    i am sorry because i ALMOST cried. after it ended, i started swearing, and talking about how a fucking awesome game it was

  • You Govrenment Bastards!!! He did what you wanted and you killed after you promised he could have his wife and son back!!! Damn You!! God damn You ALL to HELL!!! If only his friends showed up he met when he was away then you all be sorrry! Bonnie, Drew, Abraham, Marshal, West Dickens, Seth, Irish, Landon, Macdoogal, Johna, Eli, the Rebels, Ranch hands as an army, then lets see how you like YOUR Family being captured then when we give em back We fiil you all with lead.

  • john i thought u have DYNAMITE !!!!!!!

  • Fucking Edgar Ross John should killed that bastard

  • WHY DIDN'T YOU STAY IN THE DAMN BARN JOHN?!

  • @OfTehMedia WHY JOHN WHY?

  • This ending and Metal Gear Solid 4 one are the most epic and yet the most emotional I've ever exprienced

  • amazing the amount of emotion for a bunch of pixels, but john marston was extremly cool.

  • R.I.P John Marston you are the only one

  • Die in Bed at the Break of day.............. or get shot 100 times by US army R.I.P john

  • I killed Edgar Ross's wife.. I knifed his brother, and I put one in between his eyes. Justice served. Although $400 dollars isn't enough to bring back John. :[

  • I know like over videos i can see why people can dislike them, but this video I just simply don't how it is even possible to dislike it.

  • @maroon391 they probably couldn't stand remembering the ending.

  • i hunted edgar rosses family and let ross life so he knows how it feels to lose someting

  • @lildemon131 really? I didn't think that was an option. Everything I've seen of people just shooting his gun out always leaves the player dead.

  • @lildemon131 I shot ross in the face so he knows whats its like to be shot in the face.....

  • At least John comes back as a Zombie afterwards XD 

  • @matthew345 nah he dunt

  • when John died and i got control of his son i hunted down and murdered the bitch Edgar Ross and all his family :P i was a bit mad and wanted revenge :( damn and even that was not enough i went into Blackwater and slaughtered some Lawmen :D im a pacifist BTW :D

  • @InterSonoCampioni Thats exactly what I did. After I took out the Ross family I rode to Blackwater and massacared everyone in that damn town. 

  • I miss him.... ):

  • @InterSonoCampioni that made my day

  • i was a little releaved that he did die because if you did play on you would need to be abl to travel all over the country to keep away from ross

  • i gotta say i was depressed for a month because of this game, haha!, like what they say you just get close John and in the end, he dies like that, just simply depressing!, damn it rockstar, LOL!

  • ok we get it you dont wanna get buried on the prarie.......or do you? O.o

    im confused he didnt wanna get buried on the prarie and he did anyways.

    now thats someething to think about

  • best game in the world such a sad ending to such a wild character i cried when he died its just a video game but you get so attached to the characters WELL ROCKSTAR BEST GAME BY FAR and keep making them

  • the most epic game i ever playd

  • Getting to know John, and love him. And get attached to him. And then he has to die such a dramatic and devastating way. Damn you RockStar...

  • I didnt even played this game, just watched ending and this song made me cry

  • I have never been so touched by game before and while jacks revenge was great it just doesnt quite make up for johns death.

    Rest In Peace, John Marston

  • E P I C when you (SPOILER) get to the end and standing expecting to see uncles grave and then see your name there! then in the rain standing there you see your jack, the boy. i got on my horse, and just kept riding, i dont know where, just rode

  • @teamopticairsoft So did I. I just, couldn't deal with it haha

  • Comment removed

  • fuck edgar ross

  • The ending was amazing. It truly showed the west dying. It was made even more powerful by Jack's final revenge. Its just... damn.... survivng all of the shit John went through, he knew for his family, it was time to give up.

    So you will understand my IMMENSE anger at Undead Nightmare's ending.

  • @captaintylersparrow I saw undead nightmares ending as non canon. Kind of like The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror type of thing.

  • ThelmaginableUndead eres un parguela! onde me vas llorar dice...

  • sad sad sad i cried

  • i shot edgar ross 21 times in the head teabag him raped his wife and tortured his brother !!!!!!!!!! IT WAS SUCH A SHOCK R.I.P. John marston

  • @lekim004 how could you rape her?

  • Jesus, what a depressing game...

  • @JEFFRAAYY dear friend, although the long and difficult story of jhon marston may have been depressing, it was a good ride, the true tale of a man in a world full of liars, cheaters, and degenerates, those who can and cannot be trusted, and above all, how those men can change. jhon was never a bad man. he was lost out there, with no one to guide him but those untrustworthy. in the end all that matters is that the trail he left behind was full of the blood of those men who refused to change.

  • @JEFFRAAYY then the person who wrote it has writen a good country western song

  • john he is a example for everybody

    he can be a stonecold killer

    he can be a gentleman

    he's trying to do everything good and do favors for people 

  • I see John Marston as my alter ego. Hate to see him die...

  • They Should Make Red Dead Revenge... with his son getting revenge against the army...... and later more Challenges come after him

  • @RKOHEARSTHEVOICES no they shouldn't

  • @EoLoLoIoOoT who asked you...... um thats the question you should ask yourself

  • @EoLoLoIoOoT who asked you its my opinion that i love Games like RDR i want them to make more.... at least one more with new guns and Towns damn... man

  • @RKOHEARSTHEVOICES Surely even you can realise that wouldnt work

  • @EoLoLoIoOoT duh.......... im just saying i wish ok.... funny how you come out of no where saying no they shouldn't but whatever i cant play RDR over and over again im done with it

  • THE BEST EVER

    

  • I felt so good when i took revenge as jack, i emtyied all my guns of the bastard killing me rawr

  • where can i download this song??

  • I want this song played at my funeral

  • John Marston The Hero of The West The man Honor R.I.P

  • :(........rockstar shud make more games like this and i just don't mean western games, they shud make games that have such a good story it makes you cry

  • landon ricketts died in his sleep also... :(

  • Comment removed

  • @adam100115 cole phelps?

  • This song is actually in a hateful spite against the west for the east. There was a woman and a husband who became rich ranching in the western Canadian plains. When the husband was still young and rich he died. The woman always hated the west and selfishly moved east saying, "Bury me not on the lone prairie."In her absence the cows, bulls, and horses all died of starvation.

  • Rest in pieces. John Marston.

  • @MrdPredator that's not even funny :)

  • Comment removed

  • @mrCRAZYzombie99 hate to break it to you man... but marshal leigh johnson retired and has moved as far away from armadillo as possible. irish died by accidentally shooting himself in the armadillo saloon. seth propably just wouldn't give a shit about john. bonnie got married. west dickens probably would just try and sell jack some tonic. reyes is president and doesn't care about anybody. the professor went cookoo. maybe marisa "luisa's sister" would help jack, then a love interest would form.

  • @chuckmangionefan18 yes lol i read that in the blackwater newspaper. but it could just be a what-if scenario i don't know man. it is possible that marisa could develop a love intrest with him. or it could just be an entire new story. with new characters and all that shit. if so it probably would be called something like "red dead revenge". or maybe it could be a prequel with john marstons outlaw days with dutch and williamson. or red harlow could return with something like red dead revelations.

  • Comment removed

  • John knew it would end this way. In the back of his head he could only hope it wouldn't. The final chapter of his life wasn't about revenge or proving his skill. It was redemption plain and simple. He hoped that killing Bill and Dutch he could save more innocent lives then he himself had ended. Some say video games can't evoke real emotions. But goddamn it John Marston you're more of a man than I can ever be.

  • @Weston5564  After finishing red dead I had to go lay down a while.

  • @Weston5564 Your comment was beautiful

  • It's more cool to kill and hogtie people and put them in the train track with john. Jack is fun but it ain't the same.