Arnold Schoenberg deveria ser condenado por tentativa de musicídio. Este é um claro exemplo do engôdo que o charlatão-mor tenta impor. Fora, Schoenberg!
@Paulocandido1000 Estamos a falar da mesma pessoa que escreveu a "Noite Transfigurada" e os "GurreLieder", por isso acho que nao devemos dizer "Fora, Schoenberg!" com essa ligeireza. Penso que, no Pierrot Lunaire, ainda se consegue encontrar alguma ordem e musicalidade. Na sua musica serial (que nao e' o caso desta), e' que me e' mais dificil.
Yes yes, pound notes randomly, without any form or rhythm, devoid of any sort of melody, and call it art. Modern "expressionism" surely must cause actual artists to roll around in their graves.
Randomly? No. Expressionism uses a system, a 12 note chromatic scale. A LOT of effort and time goes into making an expressionist piece, and to the untrained ear, it does sound like crap. Everyone appreciates different things in different ways. (this isn't a modern piece either)
I'll never be able to appreciate Schoenberg...
MidgarMerc 1 year ago 7
Arnold Schoenberg deveria ser condenado por tentativa de musicídio. Este é um claro exemplo do engôdo que o charlatão-mor tenta impor. Fora, Schoenberg!
Paulocandido1000 1 year ago
@Paulocandido1000 Estamos a falar da mesma pessoa que escreveu a "Noite Transfigurada" e os "GurreLieder", por isso acho que nao devemos dizer "Fora, Schoenberg!" com essa ligeireza. Penso que, no Pierrot Lunaire, ainda se consegue encontrar alguma ordem e musicalidade. Na sua musica serial (que nao e' o caso desta), e' que me e' mais dificil.
xpto228 4 months ago
¡Qué cosa tan horrísona!
Eso es música ascontemporánea.
vahotito 2 years ago
@vahotito Tambien pensava como tu, pero he oido esta musica un par de veces e he encontrado expression donde antes solo ohia asco.
xpto228 4 months ago
I don't think that soprano has a firm understanding of what "Sprechstimme" is.
JoshuaMazur 2 years ago 2
Deliciously unnerving. Brava, brava!
coloratura518 2 years ago
I have always loved this composition...
KateEmilyFrankenwolf 2 years ago
that sounds TERRIBLE
Paenguru 2 years ago
its expressionism.. its SUPPOSED to un-nerve you and make you feel uncomfortable.
Most powerful kind of music for emotion control of the audience
KateEmilyFrankenwolf 2 years ago
Yes yes, pound notes randomly, without any form or rhythm, devoid of any sort of melody, and call it art. Modern "expressionism" surely must cause actual artists to roll around in their graves.
CronoDyne 2 years ago
Randomly? No. Expressionism uses a system, a 12 note chromatic scale. A LOT of effort and time goes into making an expressionist piece, and to the untrained ear, it does sound like crap. Everyone appreciates different things in different ways. (this isn't a modern piece either)
KateEmilyFrankenwolf 2 years ago 6
@KateEmilyFrankenwolf This is not a 12-tone composition.
MeterNYC 6 months ago
@CronoDyne have you ever heard of serialism ?
Spudrock2009 1 year ago
@Spudrock2009
This piece is not serial
darthdidious 1 year ago
@CronoDyne
That's a profoundly ignorant thing to say. This piece was anything but the pounding of random notes.
darthdidious 1 year ago
who is singing? Schafer ? I see painting of Chagall, Schiele, Munch, Gericaullt
chrizosthemis 2 years ago
Patricia Rideout...
almost shure.
pestilleta 2 years ago
@chrizosthemis. Il y a aussi des peintures de Bruegel et de Bacon. =)
alambixeden 10 months ago
Great interpretation
vladimirgligoric 3 years ago
una delicia de fotomontaje.los cuadros son tremendos. nunca había oído nada de schoenberg, como sea todo así termino en el hospital, ja ja.
analoquita 3 years ago