It's been two and a half years since this performance, probably about three years since I first heard this song, and I still cry every single time that I hear it. David is such a great performer, but beyond that, he seems like an even better person. I give him SO much respect for going on stage and being able to perform any song, but especially this one, so soon after his brother died. David may not be the most successful Idol winner, but by far, he's the best in my book!
David is in such a different league than everyone else has been on Idol. He pours his heart out into anything that he sings, and he is the strongest person I know of.
This means so much to me right now... I've lost so many people at my church this year and David's music has always been there to listen to. I'm grieving just as much as he is/has. Blessed be.
@fkutwo When he performed this, he brother had already passed away. That's why he has the black band around his arm. He was mourning. He tears up throughout the performance. It really is sad to watch, but I have a great respect for him.
This for me is still the best American Idol live performance. So so touching, emotional, with David's voice - Saw it live (when it first aired) and it was truly touching.
i remembered how i tried to impersonate his raspy and sultry voice when i first heard he sing on Idol. of course, i failed. love his voice and this song is one of the powerful songs by him
@devildevil444 ....I know the 'ginger' jokes are supposed to be funny, but please. I'm a so-called 'ginger' and this song moves me to tears every time I hear it. =/
This had to of been sooooo hard to sing, I haven't cried over this song in the longest time and I now did. I just had to think, his brother had died a couple weeks earlier...R.I.P Adam Cook
The emotion behind the writing of this song is astounding and it shows in the lyrics and the music... this is an amazingly written song... and he is certainly an amazing artist to capture all of that in one song so well...
I have David Cook's album and every time i listened to this song i would get chocked up because it is so genuine and pure and while listening you feel every emotion behind it but now...actually watching this video with him performing it i cant stop crying
man that must have been so hard for him to sing. when he stopped at the second verse and walked away for a second and his band covered for him to let him get his composure back you can't blame the guy. if anyone blamed him for that then they are friggan pricks who needed to get theres asses curb stomped. the guy's brother just friggan died, how the hell can you expect him to sing it with a straight face? i'm tryin to learn it on piano now :). it would be the first time i've ever played piano.
@Breadon92 All through the first verse you can see that he's trying to hold back the tears. I know that he loved his brother and he wrote this song specially for him...i believe every time he sings this a little part of him dies with it
Thinking about David and his family on this anniversary of Adam's passing. David, this beautiful song continues to inspire and comfort so many with its message of love.
No matter how much we dream and hope and pray, life isn't permanent. There's gonna be that one day in everyone's lifetime when things get the best of them and they have to leave. It's the thought of "what if" that haunts me and you and everyone else. What if my day comes too soon? What if it doesn't come soon enough? It's a terrible thing that you just can't control. That's why you have to live for life, not for death, because one day it will be your day.
You can feel his pain through out the entire song. Anyone who's ever lost someone to cancer feels exactly what he's feeling every time they hear it. Rest in peace to all the fighters of this destructive disease who didn't live to finish the fight.
You can feel his pain through out the entire song. Anyone who's ever lost someone to cancer feels exactly what he's feeling every time they hear it. Rest in peace to all the fighters of this destructive disease who didn't live to finish the fight.
@troubleswipp No tour schedule is available yet - his official web site WILL be up to date as soon as there are events to post. David is in the studio phase now - finishing new record. It's expected to be out in next couple of months, with tour to follow.
This performance never fails to move me. David has such an amazing voice and this song is so poignant. And for anyone being a little critical, please give the guy a break...he was emotional b/c this song is about his brother who had just died from cancer. That emotion showed at times in his voice. That doesn't change the fact that he has a powerful and amazing voice and that this is a powerful and beautiful song!
david cook has a way of making an amazing studio version of a song and singing it even better live. He is soooo underrated. He has such an amazing voice!
i almost cry every time i hear this song!! when i knew that his brother died i heard this song and almost cry!! he knows how to make people feel his pain!! love the song...
@pweller5 I was so disappointed when he didn't get nominated for Best New Artist or whatever the category's called. He's so much better than most up-and-coming - or even successful - artists. I only hope he continues to create good music and maintain that authenticity I've loved since his American Idol days.
Initially, I wasn't a big fan of this song, but it's grown on me. He just has such a fantastic voice.
I love David Cook for the same reasons I love Adam Lambert. He puts so emotion into all of his songs, no matter what they're about. Whether its in his voice or in his face you can always see/hear it. I also love the fact that he can sing with outstanding pitch and not go flat randomly. It's so refreshing after seeing so many people that cannot do that.
This is my favorite ballad of all time!! Not only does it have a special meaning for David being written in honor of his brother Adam, it also touches my heart because my Mother was going through hell at the same time. Hopefully the two of them met one another in heaven.
David has said he is learning to play piano. I really hope he will sing this song again while playing the piano!!!!!!! This song deserves a GRAMMY!!!!!!
@1sushichef This isn't his season. He was invited back on idol to perform. The thing was I never saw this performance, either. I turn on the TV and just missed it!!!
i love this song and his big brother is very prod of him on what david is doing it takes alot of guts to get up on stage after his brother died couple of weeks befor this performance
It's been two and a half years since this performance, probably about three years since I first heard this song, and I still cry every single time that I hear it. David is such a great performer, but beyond that, he seems like an even better person. I give him SO much respect for going on stage and being able to perform any song, but especially this one, so soon after his brother died. David may not be the most successful Idol winner, but by far, he's the best in my book!
courtyd 2 days ago
I just heard this on American Idol being sung during audition!!! Brought me to tears.
gluedtotheboobtube 1 week ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
David is in such a different league than everyone else has been on Idol. He pours his heart out into anything that he sings, and he is the strongest person I know of.
dcms300 1 month ago 2
Comment removed
dcms300 1 month ago
Comment removed
dcms300 1 month ago
Why is he using a mic?? Not sure why he needs one with a godly voice like that!!!!
DisposableHeros423 1 month ago
is this first time when people heard this song?
This made me cry too... David is wonderful person with wonderful voice.
Taurus2190 1 month ago
This means so much to me right now... I've lost so many people at my church this year and David's music has always been there to listen to. I'm grieving just as much as he is/has. Blessed be.
alisonbroadway 2 months ago
this song is gut wrenching...he knows his brother is dying from cancer yet he gives it his all...GOD bless him and his family!!
fkutwo 2 months ago 3
@fkutwo When he performed this, he brother had already passed away. That's why he has the black band around his arm. He was mourning. He tears up throughout the performance. It really is sad to watch, but I have a great respect for him.
MoiraeAtropos 2 weeks ago 2
@fkutwo his brother dies about 2 weeks earlier
lilbussy 6 days ago
I have deep sympathy for him :'(
alexhicks9624 3 months ago
cool
redithesable123 3 months ago
i feel his pain and sadness ='(
smkdlian 3 months ago
Goosebumps....Literally... Goosebumps..
But don't worry, it's the good kind:D
baileyyy223 4 months ago 4
This for me is still the best American Idol live performance. So so touching, emotional, with David's voice - Saw it live (when it first aired) and it was truly touching.
kellybsblover 4 months ago 6
elite likes, 1337 =]
weewayne 4 months ago
Those people look so idiotic swinging their arms in the air in the front rows.
Branigan4ever 5 months ago 2
this song just gives me the goosebumps then i cry TT_TT~
majoy8YGbias 5 months ago
wow what a great job
redace1315 5 months ago
i remembered how i tried to impersonate his raspy and sultry voice when i first heard he sing on Idol. of course, i failed. love his voice and this song is one of the powerful songs by him
kelvinpyaeko 5 months ago
Ok who ever disliked this apperently have no emtions so they must be ginger
devildevil444 6 months ago 3
@devildevil444 ....I know the 'ginger' jokes are supposed to be funny, but please. I'm a so-called 'ginger' and this song moves me to tears every time I hear it. =/
A7Xfan1724 4 months ago
11 people never faced a challenging time.
Seppala864 6 months ago
10 people aren't permanent
mariapaz0102 6 months ago 5
This had to of been sooooo hard to sing, I haven't cried over this song in the longest time and I now did. I just had to think, his brother had died a couple weeks earlier...R.I.P Adam Cook
SparrowBird369 6 months ago 5
The emotion behind the writing of this song is astounding and it shows in the lyrics and the music... this is an amazingly written song... and he is certainly an amazing artist to capture all of that in one song so well...
jdclrk0485 6 months ago 6
Dude gives me the chills with this song!! The rock version has more feeling than just the regular piano.
1992HappyFeet 6 months ago
he's the real idol for all season.. this made me cry!!!
rctan06 6 months ago 6
this made me cry...
BalalangLamang 7 months ago 6
imho, he was the last great winner of the show. This song showed why.
TomCollinsgirl 7 months ago 6
голос супер)))
1980blonda 7 months ago
I have David Cook's album and every time i listened to this song i would get chocked up because it is so genuine and pure and while listening you feel every emotion behind it but now...actually watching this video with him performing it i cant stop crying
musician4000 7 months ago
DAVID COOK IS NOT GOOD HE IS AMAZING!!!!
dirkimy 7 months ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Adam Lambert only <3
Travelingwilbury92 8 months ago
OMG, I really want David come to here Finland! Really wanna see him perfom live.
liikaaliikaa 8 months ago
man that must have been so hard for him to sing. when he stopped at the second verse and walked away for a second and his band covered for him to let him get his composure back you can't blame the guy. if anyone blamed him for that then they are friggan pricks who needed to get theres asses curb stomped. the guy's brother just friggan died, how the hell can you expect him to sing it with a straight face? i'm tryin to learn it on piano now :). it would be the first time i've ever played piano.
Breadon92 8 months ago 3
@Breadon92 All through the first verse you can see that he's trying to hold back the tears. I know that he loved his brother and he wrote this song specially for him...i believe every time he sings this a little part of him dies with it
musician4000 7 months ago
@musician4000 i wouldn't be surprised. i know if i were him i sure as heck wouldn't be able to hold back the tears very easily.
Breadon92 7 months ago
i like his hair here. quite blonde
popsyzoom 8 months ago
As much emotion is pouring off the stage, the teenage girls waving their arms and screaming really take away from it.
vicfurth1 8 months ago 12
8 people want a permanent torture!
aranguren12 8 months ago
So emotional....!!!!!
irontoyvn 8 months ago
8 people were crying when they heard this song & missed the like button.
0iLovemusic2 8 months ago 5
speechless
DaBolToe 8 months ago
goose bumps...
love you david..
ladyflirt2288 8 months ago
I love how he could even twist his own songs. Best Idol Ever.
scarredbanner 8 months ago 2
wow!!!! just wow!!!
this song made me get the chills!!
i cried at the end of it!!! i love you david!!!!
shopoholic995 8 months ago
Thinking about David and his family on this anniversary of Adam's passing. David, this beautiful song continues to inspire and comfort so many with its message of love.
cougar40n 8 months ago
8 people are gingers and dont have souls....
mridular 9 months ago 4
Who the hell disliked this video? They obviously dont know what the meaning of this song is....
TheDavidCooklover 9 months ago 3
This song is just amazing.....
jimmyjojoJrshabadoo 9 months ago
8 little faggots
vialani 9 months ago
David Cook is the bomb! I love, love, love his sexy voice!!!
janimarie 9 months ago
I absolutely love the piano in this song! It's an awesome song!
TheCCcheerleader 9 months ago
this song is amazing but i always want to cry while i listen to it
birdlovr100 9 months ago
this song is amazing bu ti always want to cry while i listen to it
birdlovr100 9 months ago
This is still my favorite version. I love how they "rock it" at 2:03! Very moving.
CreativeReese 9 months ago
JAMES <3 <3 <3 <3. XXXXX
jensen895 9 months ago
i don't understand why he's not more famous
IXLoveXMusicX24X7 9 months ago 2
7 dislikes? really?
pensfanmrssidcrosby 9 months ago
He's my favourite American Idol winner!! Adam Lambert is the most talented from them all tho.
limelime19 9 months ago
makes me cry every time
JayJayLee959 9 months ago
David Cook has the best balance of passion, great vocals, sexy looks and those piercing eyes are really.... spellbounding
cdelani 9 months ago 4
So far, of all the idol winners i've seen, Cook still remains the best.
KJRA2009 9 months ago 40
That was so beautiful :'-(
trueblu00 9 months ago
i cannot find a perfect cover of this song.. cook can only sing this song... no one else..
jetromus143 9 months ago
galing talaga ng kakambal ko!!! hehe !! go brother!
luciloamor1 10 months ago
I cannot believe that anyone disliked this! Are people out there really that heartless? I guess they've never lost someone they loved. Ugh!
courtforscrubs 10 months ago 2
he is awsome!!!!!!!
avaglambert 10 months ago
he is .....i can't find word.....
avaglambert 10 months ago
Search for Estonian Idol winner 2009 Ott Lepland. He also sang Permanent
PeeterPihlakas 10 months ago
No matter how much we dream and hope and pray, life isn't permanent. There's gonna be that one day in everyone's lifetime when things get the best of them and they have to leave. It's the thought of "what if" that haunts me and you and everyone else. What if my day comes too soon? What if it doesn't come soon enough? It's a terrible thing that you just can't control. That's why you have to live for life, not for death, because one day it will be your day.
thatstopmotionkid 10 months ago
amazing... this song makes me cry everytime...
buckNfatass 10 months ago
Amazing, always makes me want to cry when I listen to it.
MattGiraudFan4Ever 10 months ago
the most amazing voice i've ever heard !!!
Nourhanne2012 10 months ago 2
i love seeing Simon get up really fast....
beautiful
MiChiDeCaLi 10 months ago 10
David is amazing. I beat cancer, but lost my Mom to it. I'm looking forward to his new album. He is pure.
marcialarsen 10 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@marcialarsen he has a new album coming out
neenee6664 10 months ago
You can feel his pain through out the entire song. Anyone who's ever lost someone to cancer feels exactly what he's feeling every time they hear it. Rest in peace to all the fighters of this destructive disease who didn't live to finish the fight.
MelanieCarnley 10 months ago 3
You can feel his pain through out the entire song. Anyone who's ever lost someone to cancer feels exactly what he's feeling every time they hear it. Rest in peace to all the fighters of this destructive disease who didn't live to finish the fight.
MelanieCarnley 10 months ago
i love this song
Lara2James2Adam 10 months ago
great song great lyrics , amazing , 7 people don't like this song? i don't know why , this is one of the best songs ever
JoaoMonteiroMusic 10 months ago 4
THIS SONG !
sofi96sofi 10 months ago
7 ppl dont have a hand to hold.
MANDIBABE97 11 months ago 5
Comment removed
4cplatinum1 11 months ago
@4cplatinum1 Lol, dead girl.
ohcanada1218 11 months ago
he is one of the rear winners, who actually deserved to win.
RikaMelne 11 months ago 4
all i can do is cry...
RikaMelne 11 months ago 2
wow, so meaningful and beautiful!
wonderfully sung!
shopoholic995 11 months ago
he reminds me of a mexican singer named yahir, although david is muucccchh better tho hehe
Spiderfrankie 11 months ago
7 ppl apparently dont have a heart!
TarrantXAlice 11 months ago 2
can someone tell me where to find his perfomance schedule for july, his official page is not up to date. thanks!
troubleswipp 11 months ago
@troubleswipp No tour schedule is available yet - his official web site WILL be up to date as soon as there are events to post. David is in the studio phase now - finishing new record. It's expected to be out in next couple of months, with tour to follow.
cougar40n 11 months ago
nvery nice song) MY favourite)
Lameryable 1 year ago
6 persons missed the "like" button
AfonsoOliveira12 1 year ago 3
Free replay button:
0:00
AfonsoOliveira12 1 year ago 4
Epic face: 2:37
AfonsoOliveira12 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
AfonsoOliveira12 1 year ago
the piano guy is hot
webelonghere 1 year ago
ALways makes me cry everytime i listen to this..And I listen to this all the time so I cry all the time, too.
ladyinredvi 1 year ago
he's falsing.i prefer to listen recorded version.
TheGrammy2015 1 year ago
@TheGrammy2015 His brother had just died. I don't think so.
ilovekelly75 9 months ago
I need more song from you nothing beats this year of IDOLS 2009 all are talented but now the rest failed my expectations...
wowongful 1 year ago
how can people dislike this song? wow
abcsoapfan2432 1 year ago 2
This performance never fails to move me. David has such an amazing voice and this song is so poignant. And for anyone being a little critical, please give the guy a break...he was emotional b/c this song is about his brother who had just died from cancer. That emotion showed at times in his voice. That doesn't change the fact that he has a powerful and amazing voice and that this is a powerful and beautiful song!
mainedcfan1 1 year ago
Amazing song and amazing singer but he was offkey so many times maybe he just got a little emotional =\
Gavinatorius 1 year ago
Maybe this is his best live performance ever. Better than the studio version.
What a voice!! He's so talented.
tnssinginglover 1 year ago
david cook has a way of making an amazing studio version of a song and singing it even better live. He is soooo underrated. He has such an amazing voice!
preciousangel18 1 year ago 5
5 people were crying so hard they hit the dislike button on accident...
yousuckers1 1 year ago 60
@yousuckers1 11 now. why ?
gersfan1988 5 months ago
@gersfan1988 not sure. I guess because this song is so deep?
yousuckers1 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fake and Gay
MrEdHizay 1 year ago
@MrEdHizay That's what your Mom said when you were born ;D
MRKENNEDY07126 1 year ago 33
I like this version way better than the studio
FrAnCiSaNdi 1 year ago
one of the best performances ever on a Idol stage.
tjhazukiv1 1 year ago 6
I almost cried. Wow.
littlecat0908 1 year ago
Im crying stupidly now.
crazyjumpjump 1 year ago
i never get tired of watching this video....2 thumbs up!!!
liontamer16 1 year ago 4
i wonder what happen to him... he seems quiet nowadays.. is he recording new stuff ?on tour?? anything at all? i wanna hear more of him!!
confusedain 1 year ago
@confusedain He took some time off to write the new music for his sophomore CD. Last I heard he's almost done recording and it's due out next year.
shpei88 1 year ago
@shpei88 great! thanks shpei88:D
confusedain 1 year ago
@confusedain All I know is that he's working on a new album :)
Can't wait!
hwrw4ever 1 year ago
5 people have never lost a loved one.
SpecialBoyHunturd 1 year ago
can the grammy nomination trades lady gaga to david cook?
Bshorty1 1 year ago
5 people have no heart if they knew what this song was about.
SorrelStream 1 year ago 4
i love this song
301myjason1 1 year ago
A living reminder that cancer isn't always defeated. God bless.
MadHatterGeek 1 year ago 2
I want more music from david cook like this one
dirkimy 1 year ago
very emotional the best song of david cook
dirkimy 1 year ago
best song ever
rozanfernandez 1 year ago
God bless you david cook...
xSoFtBaLLxChIcKx10 1 year ago
oh i want the piano sheets for this song. i love it xD
animeash 1 year ago
He was a tough trooper singing this after his brother passed
meekiou 1 year ago 3
my favorite song , my favorite singer and my favorite performance :)
Cordiform89 1 year ago 4
Hes so cute,
r.i.p 4 his bro
prudduck 1 year ago
Hes so cute,
prudduck 1 year ago
Not nearly as popular as he should be.
sciguy0504 1 year ago 23
This has been flagged as spam show
wich is the highest note he hits in the breakdown?
TrincadoJavier 1 year ago
wich is the highest note he hits in the breakdown?
TrincadoJavier 1 year ago
@TrincadoJavier high a
TheTaylorsoccer2 1 year ago
super good
slimshady624 1 year ago
this song remind me for someone...
denny041192 1 year ago
damn i always skipped to 2:21 onwards. monsterous!
elcorto 1 year ago
i almost cry every time i hear this song!! when i knew that his brother died i heard this song and almost cry!! he knows how to make people feel his pain!! love the song...
larguezajunior02 1 year ago 6
This man should have gotten a Grammy nom at least for this
pweller5 1 year ago 185
@pweller5 i know right?
MegzWassup1215 11 months ago
@pweller5 I was so disappointed when he didn't get nominated for Best New Artist or whatever the category's called. He's so much better than most up-and-coming - or even successful - artists. I only hope he continues to create good music and maintain that authenticity I've loved since his American Idol days.
Initially, I wasn't a big fan of this song, but it's grown on me. He just has such a fantastic voice.
dreamthief10 10 months ago 3
@pweller5 Damn Right
Immamazed 9 months ago
amzing song n an amazing artist..
Nuha13 1 year ago 2
my fav song of all times
jbunny4life1 1 year ago 4
Tunesky
molecularmadness 1 year ago
I can't believe this song didn't do so much better. I expected this song to be a huge smash.. amazing song.. For his Brother correct?
coverme77 1 year ago 8
I love David Cook for the same reasons I love Adam Lambert. He puts so emotion into all of his songs, no matter what they're about. Whether its in his voice or in his face you can always see/hear it. I also love the fact that he can sing with outstanding pitch and not go flat randomly. It's so refreshing after seeing so many people that cannot do that.
fantasmic75 1 year ago 6
Well that explains why he won.....
Caitlin232323 1 year ago 10
David made people feel his pain through this song and that's what makes a great artist.
lizet750 1 year ago 5
AWESOME!! n touching
jayish 1 year ago
i love this song <3
RuskaFinnbert 1 year ago
you can eally feel the passion coming off of him here
dcfan2222 1 year ago
that's so goofey how people sway their arms in the air. They fail to realize that it's not about them.
Branigan4ever 1 year ago
I know he's living in hell every single day
And so I ask, Oh God is there some way for me to take his place
And when they say it's so touch and go
I wish I could make it go away, but still you say
1996jks2 1 year ago
Will you think that you're all alone
When no one's there to hold your hand
When all you know seems so far awayAnd everything is temporary, rest your head
I'm permanent
1996jks2 1 year ago
Permanent
Is this the moment where I look you in the eye?
Forgive my broken promise that you'll never see me cryAnd everything it will surely change even if I
Tell you I won't go away today
1996jks2 1 year ago
love it!
MarianaPortovedo 1 year ago
omg i'm in love this guy sing a lot :)
brunovaz14 1 year ago
david cook: my favorite american idol winner
MiChiDeCaLi 1 year ago 3
Best three minutes of my life.
scarredbanner 1 year ago 4
I love this video.
xxshiyanne08xx 1 year ago
Amazing.
caseystyle555 1 year ago
David wrote this song for his brother who died coz of brain cancer.. I love the message of the song, hits hard.
kirnale09 1 year ago
This is my favorite ballad of all time!! Not only does it have a special meaning for David being written in honor of his brother Adam, it also touches my heart because my Mother was going through hell at the same time. Hopefully the two of them met one another in heaven.
David has said he is learning to play piano. I really hope he will sing this song again while playing the piano!!!!!!! This song deserves a GRAMMY!!!!!!
CookVoter 1 year ago 4
An awesome performer
acongleton 1 year ago 2
gosh.. makes me cry everytime... ;( clearly sung from the heart...
nhera3 1 year ago 2
i don't even remember him singing this on idol. i love it. and i watched the whole season. lol.
1sushichef 1 year ago
@1sushichef This isn't his season. He was invited back on idol to perform. The thing was I never saw this performance, either. I turn on the TV and just missed it!!!
sparxspiderisback 1 year ago
i love this song and his big brother is very prod of him on what david is doing it takes alot of guts to get up on stage after his brother died couple of weeks befor this performance
gummie1066 1 year ago 2
i dont care how many times i hear this song it always brings tears to my eyes
mrstbear103 1 year ago 5
Nothing short of sensational.
RyanYouAreMighty 1 year ago 5
can i have a copy of this?
00004MERVIN 1 year ago