As a revolutionary war reenactor I must say that every reenactment will produce slightly different answers to questions but generally the same. I can gaurentee that you will learn more about specific topics and fine details then you will with any school history book.
i think its funny that when i saw the general the first name that came to mind was "Granny" Gates and when he talks its obvious he could care less about his men. i personally thank god that the congress did not replace General Washington with gates.
1:10... BAAHAHAHAHAHA!! omg. "Run away!!" "These guy's look mean!" Seriously... No wonder students find this stuff drab and boring. Jeez, if you want people to be interested in History, at LEAST have the visuals look the part. I mean, if you're a teacher, like me - For the love of whatever you hold dear; don't make your students watch this...
@jmn07965 I am just a college student. i had to work with the visuals at hand when i shot this. i could only film so much of this reenactment. all this film is original. i appreciate your feedback but you were very disrepectful in your response. i kno this part of the video isnt the most convincing but what can i do? its all i had to work with at the time. btw where is your video on the NY campaign of 1777??? i would like to see it since mine is apparently not appropriate to be shown to students
jmn07965 is not a teacher. There is nothing constructive in that post. He/she implies that he/she knows what the real troops looked like, but doesn't describe how they should look. I certainly HOPE this person isn't a teacher, anyway.
Also, if they were a teacher they would probably know that in 1777 the Continental Army was undisciplined and poorly trained, indeed a joke of a fighting force. It wasn't until the arrival of Baron von Steuben in 1778 that the Army became legitimate. So this reenactment is, in fact, historically accurate.
i find it jokes how they used to stand X feet away from each other and just wait to be shot by them muskets LOL ''load the gun powder, take aim, hold...FIRE!'' ''fuck! i missed....AGAIN'' lol drop the guns lads and fightttt
@toxic2k7 The intended effect of mass musket fire was more psychological than physical. Do enough damage to scare the crap out of the enemy and make them run away. If that didn't work, the commanding officer would order a timely bayonet charge. The bayonet was the real killer in 18th century warfare.
Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is Liberty! The wicked flee when noone pursues, but the righteous are bold as a lion. Do NOT associate with those given to Change. The Lord has made all for Himself, Yes, even the wicked for the day of doom. Do NOT be afraid of sudden terror, Nor of trouble from the wicked when it comes, For the Lord will be your confidence, And will keep your foot from being caught. - Proverbs
No, i know. That was my point. i defended the Brits. Every great nation had a imperialistic past. I just wanted to remind the American that they are not as peaceful as he wants to make me believe they are. (sorry, bad english)
definitely, George Washington was all for the crown and fought in 7 years war all gung-ho fro Britain and the monarchy, until afterward when he was refused a commission in the regular army (being a militia Colonel was obviously a lower social status) and Washington was all about social status
Well, Well, Well,....These are the men who went to the post offices, school houses, goverment buildings or anywhere else they could and ripped down their countrys flag and replaced it with their own. They took all of the Forts and everything in them....and killed their fellow countrymen wholesale...all in the name of freedom. As Freemen, they have a God given right to do so. Few years later they denied their Southern Brothers this same right. I guess thaty God is a Northerner.
As a revolutionary war reenactor I must say that every reenactment will produce slightly different answers to questions but generally the same. I can gaurentee that you will learn more about specific topics and fine details then you will with any school history book.
soup460 1 week ago
i think its funny that when i saw the general the first name that came to mind was "Granny" Gates and when he talks its obvious he could care less about his men. i personally thank god that the congress did not replace General Washington with gates.
Yorgar 5 months ago
@SandNBones
i stopped reading after you said "american won this war"
USMarineRifleman0311 7 months ago
@SandNBones Hey, a win is a win :D
TheImperialistStates 10 months ago
where do you guys get your boots
TheJrobles15 10 months ago
1:10... BAAHAHAHAHAHA!! omg. "Run away!!" "These guy's look mean!" Seriously... No wonder students find this stuff drab and boring. Jeez, if you want people to be interested in History, at LEAST have the visuals look the part. I mean, if you're a teacher, like me - For the love of whatever you hold dear; don't make your students watch this...
jmn07965 1 year ago
@jmn07965 I am just a college student. i had to work with the visuals at hand when i shot this. i could only film so much of this reenactment. all this film is original. i appreciate your feedback but you were very disrepectful in your response. i kno this part of the video isnt the most convincing but what can i do? its all i had to work with at the time. btw where is your video on the NY campaign of 1777??? i would like to see it since mine is apparently not appropriate to be shown to students
PatrizioXC76 1 year ago
@PatrizioXC76
jmn07965 is not a teacher. There is nothing constructive in that post. He/she implies that he/she knows what the real troops looked like, but doesn't describe how they should look. I certainly HOPE this person isn't a teacher, anyway.
KayBeeEee1983 11 months ago
@KayBeeEee1983 thank you so much for this comment :)
PatrizioXC76 11 months ago
@PatrizioXC76
Also, if they were a teacher they would probably know that in 1777 the Continental Army was undisciplined and poorly trained, indeed a joke of a fighting force. It wasn't until the arrival of Baron von Steuben in 1778 that the Army became legitimate. So this reenactment is, in fact, historically accurate.
KayBeeEee1983 11 months ago
OMG...Maj Gen Dave
DARRELLENGLISH58 1 year ago
fffffffffffffffffffffffffffaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaatttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
calderdoragio4 1 year ago
How ,in Gods name did this bunch of ,short-sighted, overweight nerds ever win a war?
jimpomac 1 year ago
Comment removed
HaloReachSpot 1 year ago
@HaloReachSpot Why so troll you asshat?
vintagedesert 1 year ago
i find it jokes how they used to stand X feet away from each other and just wait to be shot by them muskets LOL ''load the gun powder, take aim, hold...FIRE!'' ''fuck! i missed....AGAIN'' lol drop the guns lads and fightttt
toxic2k7 1 year ago
@toxic2k7 The intended effect of mass musket fire was more psychological than physical. Do enough damage to scare the crap out of the enemy and make them run away. If that didn't work, the commanding officer would order a timely bayonet charge. The bayonet was the real killer in 18th century warfare.
KayBeeEee1983 11 months ago
yep the guys fukin fat
MrCharzar123 1 year ago
Retardation is here ^^^^^
HarryPotterismyhome 1 year ago
Federal troops?
Taffer20 1 year ago
i like it but i have some bad thoughts cause they make us look like uppa lummpas dude.
Patriotfighter1770 1 year ago
Wow. I think this video is making fun of us rather then showing history. Everyone looks like they eat Micky D's seven times a day.
shadowhunter388 1 year ago 11
@shadowhunter388 LOL!
25kingjack 1 year ago
There are times when I wished people would just accept the past, learn from it, and move on...
SmartyBre7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is Liberty! The wicked flee when noone pursues, but the righteous are bold as a lion. Do NOT associate with those given to Change. The Lord has made all for Himself, Yes, even the wicked for the day of doom. Do NOT be afraid of sudden terror, Nor of trouble from the wicked when it comes, For the Lord will be your confidence, And will keep your foot from being caught. - Proverbs
FEAR NOT, PRAY FOR YOUR ENEMY - Jesus
See NWO Solution
Godisyoursolution 1 year ago
i blame the french
filthmonger171 2 years ago 3
@filthmonger171 I blame your mum
beatelsthenew 1 year ago
@beatelsthenew how did you know she was french? (not really)
filthmonger171 1 year ago
my god they are fat
dumgum222 2 years ago 20
Two bitter losers posted here. One a Brit imperialist, the other a neo-Confederate rube. How quaint.
ronnie12398 2 years ago 2
I am not a Neo-Confederate rube...Im am old Confederate rube.
I dont think that you can call one thing that the Confederate States goverment is guilty of that the goverment of the United States goverment is not.
meetman3 2 years ago
@meetman3 How about guilty of having terrible accents?
BloodskullMannoroth 1 year ago
@meetman3 wholeheartedly supporting slavery
gobabygo90809 1 year ago
@ronnie12398 Confederate was Civil War.
FrozenEMT 1 year ago
@ronnie12398
yeah. Not enirely correct. Wouldnt you call US-foreign-policy as "imperialistic"??? Just wanna be fair here;)
Nogger86Germany 1 year ago
@Nogger86Germany The United States as acountry in basically an Empire.
grobo11 1 year ago
@grobo11
yeah whatever. see my comment in context. i posted to another guy who claimed the british to be imperialistic.
Nogger86Germany 1 year ago
@Nogger86Germany Well, we were. I'm not ashamed of it. And the USA was imperialistic also.
grobo11 1 year ago
@grobo11
No, i know. That was my point. i defended the Brits. Every great nation had a imperialistic past. I just wanted to remind the American that they are not as peaceful as he wants to make me believe they are. (sorry, bad english)
Nogger86Germany 1 year ago
@Nogger86Germany No, you're English is fine. It amazes me as to how many German people can speak fluent English.
grobo11 1 year ago
@grobo11
Hey thanks. appreciate it!
Nogger86Germany 1 year ago
@grobo11 your
RugbyFANsean 1 year ago
@grobo11 your Germans and you Scandinavians most speak good English.
Dogmeat1950 1 year ago
Traitors
steve1mufc 2 years ago 4
@steve1mufc
definitely, George Washington was all for the crown and fought in 7 years war all gung-ho fro Britain and the monarchy, until afterward when he was refused a commission in the regular army (being a militia Colonel was obviously a lower social status) and Washington was all about social status
magyar51288 1 year ago
Well, Well, Well,....These are the men who went to the post offices, school houses, goverment buildings or anywhere else they could and ripped down their countrys flag and replaced it with their own. They took all of the Forts and everything in them....and killed their fellow countrymen wholesale...all in the name of freedom. As Freemen, they have a God given right to do so. Few years later they denied their Southern Brothers this same right. I guess thaty God is a Northerner.
meetman3 2 years ago
Take THAT society!
depechemallrat 2 years ago
good job
xymotic 2 years ago