Added: 3 years ago
From: Jakk53
Views: 417,723
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (652)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 88people does not have a wonderwall

  • I heard Oasis did a cover of this?

  • Comment removed

  • @BMTH1498 You're doing this on purpose, aren't you?

  • @BMTH1498 I heard that you're a retarded thumbs up whore. Fucking prick just enjoy the music.

  • @BMTH1498 hahaha. plan backfired.

  • original by oasis.

    sounds very oasis-y at the beginning.

    but better in the end :3

  • Beautiful:) 

  • 88 losers heard this

  • Great...now i have to scroll through pages to find out what tigerterrones said. >:/

  • @IncidentalEnding Or just click all comments. Then hit ctrl-F and then type in tigerterrones

  • I agree w/ ransting. Excellent job. Not only did it spring back memories but it felt like I was listening to the original. Just happier. Haha

  • I actually like this version. It doesn't over shadow the original, but they could sit right next to each other and be respected. Excellent take of the song.

  • Goosebumps.....

  • It sounds like Simple Plan doing this cover

  • There live performance was so much better.

  • Not bad.

  • no cover would ever be better then the original but this isn't bad :)

  • IMO this is better than the original

  • dont sound very punk rock to me

  • I like their AOL session performance of this way way better!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Not happy with this.

  • Does anyone know if this song was done before oasis?

    thanks!:)

  • @missmangolove of course not. It's a cover.

  • @missmangolove oasis did it first

  • Whoops, *cudos. Stupid iPad auto-correct

  • Personally, I like this one better. It doesn't have that annoying voice in the chorus like Oasis. Cud's to them for creating it in the first place though(:

  • I agree that this is not better than the original, but I still enjoy it on its own. :)

  • Is there any way I can dislike this more than once?

  • i like this version better then the original, its probably because i heard this version first and am a fan of cartel, but w/e, i really like the song

  • I love how everyone's saying it ruined the original. No cover is usually better than the original. They started it, they touched hearts, but to sit there and say that they don't have any right to cover it? I mean come on now.. it's a fucking cover. Grow up, if you don't like it then don't listen to it. It's that simple.

  • Comment removed

  • okay really guys? let's just get along. first off he's entitled to say this is shit, even though I beg to differ, it's his opinion, who cares it's not like it's going to affect your daily living. second off, your argument sounds pretty immature,, America was made for anyone to come to. We have freedom of speech, not if you're going to threaten someones life though, (not saying you are) Malaysia has nothing to do with this song or anything, and saying I hope US kills you, really?? grow up guys.

  • @cuddlecow5 People are morons... I'm sure the reader you intended for didn't even read it, either...

  • @genericallyaccepted Actually I did you ass mongrel.

  • @crawford714 Shuddap, hosebeast.

  • @cuddlecow5 Fuck you bitch

  • I love both apparently.

  • TOTTALLY SHIT!!!!!!!!!! go kill yourself

  • @TheButtermore You first, faggot.

  • @crawford714 SHUT UP BELIEBERS!!!! go fuck your self

  • @TheButtermore You're calling me a belieber? Fuck you. I was listening to Cartel when they were underground, go fuck your faggot "punk" ass. I fuckin' found your problem, you're from Malaysia. I can't wait for the U.S. to get to you and fuckin' kill you. If I had it my way, you'd be off the map. Get your foreign ass out of here. This is America.

  • @crawford714 well this is internet right?? so..do the math will ya??

    this is not YOU ASS( US) network..i can say whatever i want u believe in democracy right?? what makes u think that US is not foreign??

    pathetic loser..like u go eat and shit bricks!! so so BELIEBERS!!

  • @TheButtermore Fuck off

  • @crawford714 dont have idea to say is it?? i tought so....

    so so BELIEBERS..OASIS has done a tremendous job composing this song...and some cartel band claims that they qualified enough to cover this masterpiece??

  • @TheButtermore Translation: Don't have any idea what to say, do you? I though so.

    So [I'm assuming this is an insult using Justin Beiber], Oasis has done a tremendous job composing this song, and some Cartel band claims that they are qualified enough to cover this masterpiece?

    Bands don't need to live up to anyone's expectations but their own.

    And @crawford714, judging by your public youtube channel, and the comments you've been posting, you enjoy offending others. So please, try me? :3

  • @johns1307 I. LOVE. YOU.

  • So I hope you guys know that covers don't need to match the original... Each person, band, etc. has their own style and can do whatever they want.

    Let them be!

  • This is not a bad cover, I'm honestly not trying to insult them but I just thought that Oasis's sound suited the lyrics better.

  • cartel did way better on the lyrics.

  • Hmmm, I was afraid this was going to be a cover of this song. lol

  • Pitch needs to be up to the original, then it might be ok

  • you guys...it's just a cover. calm down.

  • I'd honestly like to see anyone who commented about how "Shitty" this song was do a better job than Cartel. Unless you're Noel Galligher your comments aren't even relevant.

  • @DieForSniping about that...has Noel ever commented on this cover?

  • I love the original but I also love this one... It is a bit more upbeat, and I know that the song isn't really suppose to be, but I like that about it...

  • Cartel did a better job on the chorus, no offense.

  • This is okayish.

  • so...they totally fucked this song up!

  • I love the original, and this isn't too bad either. Love me some Oasis AND some Cartel! ;D

  • great...they've gone and ruined Oasis* 90s music is best as it is so don't fk it up..

  • Cartel took this and made it their own. Whether it's better or worse than the original, I don't know. They weren't aiming for either. This song is simply an interpretation. And I love it regardless. :)

  • @tigerterrones Are you stupid? Oasis has an even more winey voice, so using that as a reason why this version isn't good would be really futile and stupid. And winey does not always mean worse. Maybe it's how the vocalist shows his emotion in the song. I don't see you making music and getting millions of views on YouTube or tons of money and tours worldwide. So if you want to argue about the quality of a song, please keep your ignorant opinions to yourself and shut the fuck up.

  • With circumstances in my life how they are now, I should honestly be depressed. But blaring this song makes me forget all of my problems. Wonderwall <3 Oasis AND Cartel.

  • Am I the only one confused about the cover of the album being a punk rendition of a Nirvana cover? I mean, sure, Nirvana was big in the 90's, but they are neither punk nor pop. a-what the hell?

  • @alykat912 Nobody ever said they were punk or pop. Where did you get that from? This album is made up of punk bands covering songs from the 90's. Nirvana, and Nevermind in particular, were big in the 90's. That's where the album cover comes from. Nobody said Nirvana was punk. Nor did they say that they were pop.

  • Comment removed

  • @VinceValentyne182  Oh I see, I misread the title and thought it was another one of those "Punk goes Pop" albums. Hence my confusion of why there was a Nirvana cover.

  • @alykat912 It's cool. Everybody makes mistakes.

  • this was uploaded on my birthday :)

  • Hmm, sounds like they just distorted the guitars and played teh same exact shit as the original. and Cartel is NOT FUCKING PUNK.

  • When I read "punk goes 90s" I thought this would be a punk rendition of the song, not a cover by a pop punk band in the same vein as the original.

  • @TheHawkdaddy kinda is punk-y though?

  • everyone has different music tastes....not EVERYONE is going to like this. that doesnt mean you have to complain though. :\

  • song sucks. the origional is always best. oasis cant be replaced. their a less faumous beatle. and leave punk to england cuz this sucks. they sound like they r wineing.a million other bands that have his voice, not like monkey or morrisey. stop putting childish teens to stardom. and congrats to CARTEL you just got told by a 13 year old. =p

  • @tigerterrones lol, i neither agree nor disagree, but could you learn how to spell before you start running your mouth?

  • @tigerterrones congrats for being 13 and spelling like you're 8. You kow nothing about music. Take the complaints to mommy, mmkay? I'm sure she's proud that you can actually use YouTube.

  • @tigerterrones you have no understanding of emotion, music, or the english language. congrats you're an idiot.

  • i like this band but not this cover :/

  • Oasis is so wannabe John Lennon

  • This is a REALLY gay version... This isn't Punk, not even close. Original is the best 

  • The original is unbeatable but this comes close

  • I will forever b in love with this song<3

  • fuck that cover.. it's plagiatrism

  • @Lenjaful It is not plagiarism, they did their own version of the song for the compilation called ''Punk goes 90's'', a compilation of today's band covering 90's bands.

  • @MPF24SP right.. sounds like plagiarism to me lol

  • @Lenjaful Hardly. Music isn't the same as writing works. It can be bought and copyrighted. Also, I'm sure on the covers it has the copyrights. The Punk Goes compilations are very popular, and if there was a problem, they wouldn't be making them. It's only plagiarism if original sources aren't cited or are claimed as their own. Cartel isn't claiming Oasis as their own song. Simply a cover.

    Plagiarism is a bad thing though. Don't do it, kids! Now one wants a lawsuit.

  • @katetasticable No* one wants a lawsuit.

  • I like both. -shrugs-

    o w o

  • This sounds like a cat shitting. I prefer the orginal.

  • nice

    

  • i like it

  • I would like just once for one of these comps to have ANYTHING to do with punk. Isn't this more like Emo goes 90's?

  • how the fuck can you say this is better than the original

  • @proficientbeezy You can't hear it well here, but the solo is fantastic. That alone sets it apart from the original. Now don't get me wrong, I love Oasis and the original, however this is one of those rare cases in which a cover takes the song to new heights. This is not just another second rate knock off, Cartel are clearly very able musicians and it's obvious a lot of effort went into perfecting this. The quality speaks for itself.

  • @proficientbeezy Pretty easily, really.

  • @proficientbeezy everyone is entitled to their own opinions

  • @proficientbeezy Its not, its so amazing but in a different way.

  • I enjoy the original more, I really like this though, the intro had a really epic build up, and I love cartel!! :)

  • lol Yeah,this aint punk. But it is a good cover of the song. So what if I like the original,and the cover of it?lol Good song anyways.

  • This is a terrible cover. Its that high pop voice that really ruins it for me.

  • not bad

    never be anywhere as legendary as Oasis

    but a good cover indeed

  • Voice is nothing special, but it's not bad.

  • ....... that wasnt punk.... that was american punk rock drivel....

  • This song and Plain White T's version of Song 2 are the only good songs on this CD. I was surprised that I actually like this version. I still prefer the original though.

  • Comment removed

  • CARTEL AIN"T PUNK!!!! sorry i just had to say it. its a good cover but its not punk in the slightest.

  • @ANBUblackops666 Neither is 95% of the bands on the Punk Goes Series.

  • @DerekLikesToParty True. because no actual punk band you do this shit ha

  • Obviously Oasis does it better just because of this Cartel guys punky voice, but this isnt half bad.

  • The guys in Oasis are dicks... XD

  • @naileyke More to each other than anything else. xD

  • They closed with this song at their concert in Cleveland :)

  • really great for me it´s better than the original

  • this is a pretty good cover

  • were the sounds at the beginning from Pink Floyd?

  • Oh God, this cover sucks.

  • oasis is the best band in the world and they will live forever.

    beside that this is an awesome cover

  • This one literally made me cry. I hate my self so much right now, its unbelievable. But I will keep listening to this song, even if it kills me.

  • This version has a more relaxing tone for me. I mean, the original one gives out the emotions and this one kinda calms your emotions. Man, I really love this song. :)

  • I like this version, but I have to say that Oasis's version is better.

  • much better than Oasis !

  • NONE. OF. THESE. BANDS. ARE. PUNK.

  • @rg813 they are all great bands, but none of them are punk. i agree.

  • Wow, I was totally expecting this to be a lot heavier...this sounds awesome though :D

  • I like the original better, but this one is awesome!

  • Haters gonna hate but I'm sure they have to admit that Will's voice is flawless

  • this kind of sucks... they messed up the timing

  • I heard this version before the Oasis version, and it's really not all that bad. If you don't like it, then listen to the Oasis version. I love both.

  • oasis is crying this is so terrible...

  • @3rhymeswithpee your mom is crying cause she has to keep you

  • @beerealisgood4u and thats coming from the six year old with bad comebacks who instigates fights on youtube. you're sooooooo cool. last time i checked this was america and i could have my own opinion. idiot.

  • @3rhymeswithpee i wasnt instigating anything haha and if i was really trying to insult you you wouldnt have had anything to say back. i am cool. you dont belong in america, and nobody gives two fucks about your shitty opinion. nigger :)

  • @beerealisgood4u wooooooo, im so offended. did you come up with that by yourself? if so, im impressed and i might go cry now. id also rather be a nigger than a completely ignorant douchebag who has zero friends, gets no buns, and has shitty taste in music :).

  • @3rhymeswithpee oh damn haha that must be true since its coming out of your mouth and your such an important part of society. get a life little girl and do the world a favor and bash your head into a concrete wall for thinking your better than you are. and i can tell YOUR the one who gets no buns haha your in a shitty as way with the world so get over yourself and stop trying to be a cool guy cause its not working.

  • I prefer this version

  • oasis wrote a great song but it left a lot of room for improvement and i think cartel definitely did it justice. i love this version.

  • Not a bad cover. Even though Cartel is pop punk i dont think i would of put this song on Punk Goes 90's

  • this is really good but i think i sort like the origanal slightly better =P

  • guys Cartel is a Pop-Punk, more Alt Rock but still Pop-Punk

  • Niceeeee

  • this is from punk goes 90's??! nice btw..

  • good song but no punk dude!

  • how is this punk?

  • this cover is actually better than oasis's version. oasis is just extremely overrated to begin with though, but we already knew that :)

  • They chenged it, but they didnt murder it. I give props. Not bad at all, though it is hard to do poorly with such a well written song.

  • You guys. This is AWESOME. His voice is sexy, they changed it up a bit, and they did a very good job. So stop hating just because it isn't an exact copy of the original.

  • not bad..not bad..

  • personally i like it. it's a close second to the original. oasis has a little bit of a better feel for the song :)

  • @HeyHoKato Good for you.

  • this was really good, i like it.

  • Guys Yeah Oasis Is Better But Give Em a bit of credit Like mistymaykiko said they new it would not be better than the original :D

  • I got a fetish for all these cover albums. Just can't get enough.

  • personally... i think this is better than the original. sorry haters

  • @runig14 I agree.

  • Why are people whining about a cover song that they were asked to do...

  • good cover original is best but give em credit for trying it

    allow these haters tho chill the fuck out

  • Okay, seriously wtf? Cartel are great. Wonderwall is a classic song. So just shut the fuck up and enjoy it or gtfo :') I can't believe people are getting so uptight about a fucking cover...

  • @LessThanJak seriously. people need to shut up and listen to it. Cartel is wonderful

  • @tigerterrones, So if they suck so much, why are you here? you're time would be much better spent somewhere that isn't here.

  • How about we just listen to the music and not complain?

    If you don't like it, then don't listen, simple as that(:

  • @kennytang54 thank you!!!!!

  • @tigerterrones i agree but im a teenager does that meen i shouldnt sing? :P though i dnt sound like this

  • @tigerterrones i agree but im a teenager does that meen i shouldnt sing? :P though i dnt sound like this...ohh ur right this isnt real punk..try rise agaisnt (: