You know, I just discovered this band a few months ago. And I can't recall how many times I have already heard hints of Genesis, Yes, Kansas even King Crimson. This awesome cover just cements what my ears were already telling me.
God DAMN! Their cover just hits you like a wall of beautiful proggy sound. Nick's vocals are absolutely spot on, the instrumentation is AMAZING, overall just a perfect performance.
@themann141 well it IS a genesis song. of course it sounds different when it's not genesis playing it. SB does it good, but it would have sounded better if neal sang it.
@themann141 1. This was awesome. 2. Can you even play an instrument or sing as half as good as that? 3. Learn proper English-it's "doesn't " sound good. Sum total: keep your flap shut.
LIGHTS GO DARK, AUDIENCE CLAPPING, CHEERING, PHIL RUNNING ACROSS STAGE WITH A BEARD AND A HOCKEY STICK, 1975, AND THEN, "SQUONK" OPENING SONG, INGLEWOOD FORUM...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm old enough to hear that this is a bunch of good musicians but it's obvious that used something, wich reflects in the performance, wich is a pity...
There's No Need to Insult the man for his religious Ideas... We may not have the same beliefs as he or any other Humans have BUT you Have to RESPECT his Faith...If You Don't Then You Don't Understand his Phylosophy
While it is ignorant to press religion onto others (what many christians do) it is also ignorant to reject someone for believing in what he wants to believe.
Sorry guys, the overlying problem here is Neal left the band and took the heart out of what was once the greatest music making group ever. Forgive me for not sharing the same tolerance.... and further, do you REALLY think the band understands? The man claimed God told him to pack his bags. In reality, that is a whack job.
these guys rock! - in true genetalia tradition - the drummer sings (gabes and phil both bashed hides) Also they do it as a "song" and are lovin' it lovin' it lovin' it and not a genesis tribute with all the theatrics - what a band - do they gig?
Something with his daughter, she was seriously ill i think, and then was cured while Neal prayed. He makes great music still, my favorite composer and musician. Hope one day i will watch him live..
je les ai vus en 2001a paris au café de la danse, 3h de bonheur.....et aussi en 1ere partie de dream theater !!! en 2000; putain ils assurent graves........
But the Genesis/SB parallels are eerie: 6 studio albums, with the 6th being a double. Lead singer leaves band. Drummer takes over on lead vocals. Release two studio albums, then double live. And...Peter Gabriel also plays the drums.
This is probably a good point, but I do think Neal Morse was more important for Spock's Beard than Peter Gabriel was for Genesis. Neal Morse wrote most of the songs in his band, while the rest of Genesis wrote at least as many songs as Peter Gabriel did. Also, in 1975 the voices of Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins weren't totally different, while Nick D'Virgilio's voice is fairly different to Neal Morse's.
I have to disagree. I think the new Spock's Beard album is much more harder and progressive then the old, and i think that NIck's voice is better in many ways. Still dig the old, but won't ignore the new.
I disagree to some extent. Theres no one who stood a better chance of replacing Neil than Nick, its just the Neil is so amazing that the band has suffered an irreplacable loss. I would expect Neil to come back after some time though, probably just wants some time with his family while his kids are still growing up.
well, actually i wasn't clear enough. i DO think nick is a good singer (as this video shows) but what i think is missing is the creative input from nick.
i was actually lucky enough to be in the same city they were doing an acoustic set at (just neal/nick) i think it was 1999 (maybe 2000)
it was in germany, where i happened to be on vaction at the time :)
got the chance to get autographs, get drunk, and hang out with them during intermissions. cool guys!
Nice, thats awesome man. Yea I was supposed to check them out in NYC at the BB King Bar & Grill, and catch a Pat Metheny show @ Carnegie hall, but I couldnt book a flight, so everything went to hell.
Did you mean the creative input from Nick or Neil ? Either way, you're kind of right, theres something lacking in their songwriting department, I found Octane was a huge let down other than NYC, and while the self-titled was much better, there were times when it dragged on.
I discovered the Beard AFTER Neal left, and I find the newer music to be more compelling than the older stuff. The self-titled record is one of my favorite albums ever. I love the Neal stuff, but the newer stuff finds a way to be progressive and musically adventurous, but with the occasional killer hook.
I did NOT ask who sang the Genesis version, which I already know Phil sang on both "a trick of the tail" from 1975 and the live "seconds out" from 1977. My question is who sang in THIS video. For your information, this guy is NOT Phil Collins, in case you didn't know it.
Genesis lead singer Gabriel left band after 6th studio album, a double, and the drummer Collins took over on lead vocals.
Spocks' Beard lead singer Morse left after 6th album, a double, and then drummer D'Virgilio takes over on lead vocals.
Squonk, of course, is from the first Genesis album with Collins on lead vocals, so it's foreshadowing Morse's impending departure that he's singing it here (with Morse on drums!!!)
Good Job, But the song Doesn't Go Over when you're trying to be Cute on stage at the same time. Short version with dropped lyrics, anyway, Try leaving the Ego at home next time.
idiots
mamothcar1 4 months ago
terrible singing, terrible swashbucklers....this is no good. this is no good...
derneueuntergang 4 months ago
Wow, you guy's did a superb job on that tune! Thanks for the post for those that still love GENESIS
Ears14U 8 months ago
You know, I just discovered this band a few months ago. And I can't recall how many times I have already heard hints of Genesis, Yes, Kansas even King Crimson. This awesome cover just cements what my ears were already telling me.
tnhomeboy 9 months ago
God DAMN! Their cover just hits you like a wall of beautiful proggy sound. Nick's vocals are absolutely spot on, the instrumentation is AMAZING, overall just a perfect performance.
Kuromeshi 10 months ago
nick sings very well and neal is great on drums, nice version!
lorenic95 11 months ago
I absolutely love this version the Beard did... this is amazing... plus Nick's vocals sound so amazing
fabioadias 1 year ago
great performance!!!!
CarmineCapasso 1 year ago
This was painful to watch. Not even half as good as the original. This song just dont sound good without phil
themann141 1 year ago
@themann141 well it IS a genesis song. of course it sounds different when it's not genesis playing it. SB does it good, but it would have sounded better if neal sang it.
kingcrimson234 1 year ago
@themann141 1. This was awesome. 2. Can you even play an instrument or sing as half as good as that? 3. Learn proper English-it's "doesn't " sound good. Sum total: keep your flap shut.
gh9448 7 months ago
Great song but this cover is truly balls
ontherush77 1 year ago
LIGHTS GO DARK, AUDIENCE CLAPPING, CHEERING, PHIL RUNNING ACROSS STAGE WITH A BEARD AND A HOCKEY STICK, 1975, AND THEN, "SQUONK" OPENING SONG, INGLEWOOD FORUM...
firstbooob 1 year ago
Love this version of Squonk.
fabioadias 1 year ago
GREAT version!!! Guys look like they had a blast performing too!!!
CSXer 1 year ago
Justice well and truly done. Not many bands can cover Genesis well, but these guys are one of them!
nivblotsky 1 year ago
Nicely Done !
skiingrhino 1 year ago
Awesome song, nice little rendition by SB. Great to see the kids paying homage to their elders!
Pacisdiligo 1 year ago
Unbelievable musicians! Saw them in concert and it was one of the best I've been to besides Yes!!!!
bridgetjoycemusic 1 year ago
interesting version. A lot of energy put into it. I like it.
sjnorman2 1 year ago
You guys should induct Genesis into the R and R hall of fame!!
slugs2112 1 year ago
I am just glad someone is playing this great song!!!!! What a great tune!
bearhead3 2 years ago 7
this is way too slow and too jokey.. dude.. sounds ok.. but sorry
soulsistahmel 2 years ago
dude this is a more heavy metal version than progresive 70's rock version, i dont like it
angusyoung98 2 years ago
Where can I get this DVD??? I want to buy it now!
TheRealQuester 2 years ago
GENESIS music rules! Squonk!
dukestravel 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm old enough to hear that this is a bunch of good musicians but it's obvious that used something, wich reflects in the performance, wich is a pity...
muziekengeluid 2 years ago
Is Neal playing drums?
bokkie0001 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
1RaelMarty 2 years ago
@ bokkie0001: He is indeed.
1RaelMarty 2 years ago
Ha. He is!
CallMeDjm 2 years ago
Try again without Crack or Speed next time....
muziekengeluid 2 years ago
stupid comment! how old are you?
gnarlygneezer 2 years ago 3
fuck yeah! love nick's voice :D
jackpaice 2 years ago 3
On a lighter note, Neal Morse is actually a pretty good drummer- I'm starting to wonder if there's any instrument he can't play
Looneyboyo 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he's pretty good at sucking God's skin flute!
skumbuck 2 years ago
Oh har de har...seriously, enough with the anti-religion stuff okay?
Looneyboyo 2 years ago
ok sorry
skumbuck 2 years ago
Fair enough- and hey, we both like Spock's Beard, right? That makes up for anything else, in my book
Looneyboyo 2 years ago
Comment removed
skumbuck 2 years ago
really nice heavy version of this song
anejako 2 years ago 3
Neal Morse is one of the most talented musicians in the world. No doubt about it. Too bad he is chasing the false ideals of a fictitious being.
skumbuck 2 years ago
There's No Need to Insult the man for his religious Ideas... We may not have the same beliefs as he or any other Humans have BUT you Have to RESPECT his Faith...If You Don't Then You Don't Understand his Phylosophy
AgroDTOP 2 years ago
While it is ignorant to press religion onto others (what many christians do) it is also ignorant to reject someone for believing in what he wants to believe.
Jaemseh 2 years ago
Sorry guys, the overlying problem here is Neal left the band and took the heart out of what was once the greatest music making group ever. Forgive me for not sharing the same tolerance.... and further, do you REALLY think the band understands? The man claimed God told him to pack his bags. In reality, that is a whack job.
skumbuck 2 years ago
This is me giving you a thumb's down and telling you to fuck off.
Looneyboyo 2 years ago
your intelligence is overwhelming.
skumbuck 2 years ago
And so're your good manners- 'the false ideals of a fictitious being'? Not exactly the politest statement in the world is it?
Looneyboyo 2 years ago
truth is there is no god. Deal with it. Our destiny is to be eaten by worms.
skumbuck 2 years ago
If that's what you think, then...well, you're wrong.
Looneyboyo 2 years ago
AMEN :D
jackpaice 2 years ago
hell didnt know neal could play drums so well...never had actually seen him play! he rocks!
jackpaice 2 years ago
DRUMMERRRSSSBBAAADDDDD....
firstbooob 2 years ago
That's mostly because he's actually the lead singer/keyboard player. The fact that he plays drums as well is pretty impressive.
DullBullet 2 years ago
What cant these guys do?????? Oh yea get Neal back
ladyjawz 2 years ago
oh thats stupid... just move on.. nick has an excelent voice
jackpaice 2 years ago
GOOD JOB GUYS....
firstbooob 2 years ago
very good !!
alprog2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh God !!! How to kill a classic track or what???
engleby15 2 years ago
these guys rock! - in true genetalia tradition - the drummer sings (gabes and phil both bashed hides) Also they do it as a "song" and are lovin' it lovin' it lovin' it and not a genesis tribute with all the theatrics - what a band - do they gig?
sandprof 2 years ago
Great show, Spock's Beard is amazing band, even today without Neal. I especialy love Neal Morse, he is a great man first, then a great musician.
AleksandarGv83 2 years ago
NO, Genesis rule, and spock´s beard cover them!! does anyone know what happened to neal morse that a religious obsession befell him?
busisanclaire 2 years ago
Something with his daughter, she was seriously ill i think, and then was cured while Neal prayed. He makes great music still, my favorite composer and musician. Hope one day i will watch him live..
AleksandarGv83 2 years ago
Awesome!! I love it when bands switch their instruments up, its way cool. Spock's Beard and Genesis Rule!
ajpoulsen2112 2 years ago
wooooooooww!!!
GreenSheepYard 2 years ago
"squonkwow"...
firstbooob 2 years ago
drummersbadd...
firstbooob 2 years ago
thats due to the fact that the drummer aka neal morse is normally the lead singer, keyboard-player and sometimes guitarist
XarchetypeX 2 years ago
if you listen caerfilly, neal is actualltyplaying morse code on the drums
sandprof 2 years ago
ifwecanjustenjoytheperformance...
firstbooob 2 years ago
cananyonebeanymoreproudthankyoufor
meithink@least14timeslosangelesgreatestcaliforniaareatoxperiencegenesis4u2bee, among us....can anyone imagine....
firstbooob 2 years ago
xclnt cover guys!! the drumming sounds look Phil, and the vocals, a touch of Pete's version, moreso than Phil's in later shows... Well done guys!!
bigwo56 3 years ago
je les ai vus en 2001a paris au café de la danse, 3h de bonheur.....et aussi en 1ere partie de dream theater !!! en 2000; putain ils assurent graves........
sebbz08 3 years ago
I love his band so much
RSimusic 3 years ago
Great cover!
I LOVE that song ^^
MrProgrock 3 years ago
I really love those Neal's funny drumfills :D
And Ryo is rock&roll, as always
miguelosz 3 years ago
I love their version of Squonk!
fabioadias 3 years ago
Superb chaps.
Well done.
squonk
Liverpool
UK
laughingpines 3 years ago
I think this is AWESOME! I saw them at 3RP in Pittsburgh in August 2008 (I got to meet them as well) and they put on a fabulous show!
BustersMommy 3 years ago
They play it well enough musically, but JESUS, can we please do without all the "dig us aren't we cool" stage moves, gentlemen?
jhillst 3 years ago
I actually enjoyed that part.
Kind of.
Uaatu 3 years ago
Agreed. That - plus the shirt - makes Nick look like a protein powder salesperson at GNC or something.
kirklott 3 years ago
I don't think they're being serious. They're just having fun.
JulE0n 3 years ago
WHOS AT THE DRUMS?
mrsiix 3 years ago
Neal Morse, the former lead singer of Spock's Beard.
ThEpEsT 3 years ago
i reckoned him, but i didnt kwen he was a drummer
mrsiix 3 years ago
The guy can play anything.
KingCrimson776 3 years ago
i know, hes ... well, hes neal, enough said
mrsiix 3 years ago 4
he's neal. yes, indeed
miguelosz 3 years ago
Hmmm, my comment was a reply to the person making the Genesis/SB comparisons. Phil Collins/Nick, 6th album and so on...
goodandfruity 3 years ago
wow!! i didn't know that neal morse was a good drummer too ;) amazing ;)
pizz90 3 years ago
But the Genesis/SB parallels are eerie: 6 studio albums, with the 6th being a double. Lead singer leaves band. Drummer takes over on lead vocals. Release two studio albums, then double live. And...Peter Gabriel also plays the drums.
kirklott 3 years ago
This is probably a good point, but I do think Neal Morse was more important for Spock's Beard than Peter Gabriel was for Genesis. Neal Morse wrote most of the songs in his band, while the rest of Genesis wrote at least as many songs as Peter Gabriel did. Also, in 1975 the voices of Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins weren't totally different, while Nick D'Virgilio's voice is fairly different to Neal Morse's.
kaols72 3 years ago
I have to disagree. I think the new Spock's Beard album is much more harder and progressive then the old, and i think that NIck's voice is better in many ways. Still dig the old, but won't ignore the new.
profilercms 3 years ago
Is he trying to sound like a Vegas lounge singer?
apico 3 years ago
nick is fucking wasted. he's even more wasted in the version on the live at the whisky VHS.
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
Unlistenable!! Plus the 20 seconds I was able to get through, the "singer" got two lyrics wrong. Do people really like this S___?
Ron502008 3 years ago
Yes.
Uaatu 3 years ago
A Trick of The Tail Release Date: 2/2/1976
Wind in The Wuthering Release Date: December 27, 1976
squonkness 3 years ago
if u dont know this is not collins you are fuckin stupid
tperr63 3 years ago
Great cover.
TheRocinanteKid 3 years ago
Is that a Hammond XK-1?
EmersonsL100 3 years ago
decent drumming. the vocals are not off..but far from on.
memalley 3 years ago
Exceptional cover by these guys. Spock's Beard rule the Earth!
HolmzB124 3 years ago 3
I can't stop watching this now.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago 2
They ruled this song.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago
They ruled this song.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago
is nick and at the end became another collins from drums to vocals
junito52 3 years ago
the beard is not the same with nick singing. i can't get into their new music with him on the mic, he just doesn't fit.
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
I disagree to some extent. Theres no one who stood a better chance of replacing Neil than Nick, its just the Neil is so amazing that the band has suffered an irreplacable loss. I would expect Neil to come back after some time though, probably just wants some time with his family while his kids are still growing up.
Rendell05 3 years ago
well, actually i wasn't clear enough. i DO think nick is a good singer (as this video shows) but what i think is missing is the creative input from nick.
i was actually lucky enough to be in the same city they were doing an acoustic set at (just neal/nick) i think it was 1999 (maybe 2000)
it was in germany, where i happened to be on vaction at the time :)
got the chance to get autographs, get drunk, and hang out with them during intermissions. cool guys!
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
Nice, thats awesome man. Yea I was supposed to check them out in NYC at the BB King Bar & Grill, and catch a Pat Metheny show @ Carnegie hall, but I couldnt book a flight, so everything went to hell.
Did you mean the creative input from Nick or Neil ? Either way, you're kind of right, theres something lacking in their songwriting department, I found Octane was a huge let down other than NYC, and while the self-titled was much better, there were times when it dragged on.
Rendell05 3 years ago
oops that was a typo, i meant neal.
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
I discovered the Beard AFTER Neal left, and I find the newer music to be more compelling than the older stuff. The self-titled record is one of my favorite albums ever. I love the Neal stuff, but the newer stuff finds a way to be progressive and musically adventurous, but with the occasional killer hook.
KLanz123 3 years ago
Who is this singer? Doesn't sound like either Neal Morse or Nick.
vampiroangelico 3 years ago
Shows how much you know about Spock's Beard lol. It's Phil Collins singing on this version ;)
Mouse2113 3 years ago
Shows how much you understood my question.
I did NOT ask who sang the Genesis version, which I already know Phil sang on both "a trick of the tail" from 1975 and the live "seconds out" from 1977. My question is who sang in THIS video. For your information, this guy is NOT Phil Collins, in case you didn't know it.
vampiroangelico 3 years ago 2
ATToT is 1976
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
"Wind & Wuthering" is 1976.
vampiroangelico 3 years ago
like squonkness said, they're both 1976 releases. they were on a roll that year. :)
kingcrimson234 3 years ago
Are you stupid?
TheRocinanteKid 3 years ago
I love the beard, but these vocals suck.
Neal is amazing, spocks without him is same as Genesis without Collins
fancybollocks 3 years ago
Nick D Virgilo is simply amazing on this one.
Great cover, by the best progressive rock band in the world between 1995 and 2002.
IzzyTush 3 years ago
Good effort by Nick D'Virgilio but it is not extraordinary by any means!
ajittffcure 3 years ago
Saw them do this at the Troubador! As far as covers go, I like Squonk and Space Truckin'!!
kanstulbrass 4 years ago
Pretty amazing coincidence, but...
Genesis lead singer Gabriel left band after 6th studio album, a double, and the drummer Collins took over on lead vocals.
Spocks' Beard lead singer Morse left after 6th album, a double, and then drummer D'Virgilio takes over on lead vocals.
Squonk, of course, is from the first Genesis album with Collins on lead vocals, so it's foreshadowing Morse's impending departure that he's singing it here (with Morse on drums!!!)
kirklott 4 years ago 3
Yeah, interesting! But I am far from being anything like Chester Thompson. He's much taller!!!
goodandfruity 3 years ago
nick is incredibly drunk here
kingcrimson234 4 years ago
Personally it drags for me at this tempo.
DavieMarshall 4 years ago
good job best cover band for this song
tperr63 4 years ago
sounds good, always been a big beard fan but wtf they left out half of the damn song!!!
kingcrimson234 4 years ago
where's the damned mirror mirror on the wall part?
lauingen 4 years ago
damn...I didn't think I would say it but the slower tempo made this song sound kinda sexy...creepy huh?
mike584 4 years ago
Good Job, But the song Doesn't Go Over when you're trying to be Cute on stage at the same time. Short version with dropped lyrics, anyway, Try leaving the Ego at home next time.
pilyto21 4 years ago
I think you're taking it far more seriously than they did.
CallMeDjm 2 years ago
this version of this genesis song was great, but is missing some of the lyrics.
manning44070 4 years ago
Oh my my, that was great!!
progjohn 4 years ago
A fantastic version of one of the best classic Genesis tracks ever!
yesshows77 4 years ago
great cover
volendos2 4 years ago
brilliant fellas !
entangled1 4 years ago
great
volendos2 4 years ago
spock's beard+neal morse live together again for Snow performing? it's true?!!?
MrMetal84 4 years ago
Nice to see someone covering this great song by a great band!!!!!
rahtreelimbs 4 years ago