i disliked this. not because i dislike the song because im a HUGE fan of jim brickman, but because i dont think it shouldve been bellas lullabye. just because something is good doesnt mean it belongs in twilight.
How dare you try and make a connection between anything Brickman has done and the vomit-factory reject that is the Twilight franchise. Please keep this talented composer away from this series hack writer.
I dont know Why this piece is so much Fascinating to me ...When i hear it i just enter a new world a beautifull world where evrything looks perfect and lovely ... I dont know how this song admires you all people or how u listen to it but it is very important to me ........
For anyone trying to learn this song on the piano, it is NOT as difficult as it sounds. Just keep trying and eventually the rythm will become natural. Keep the end in sight!!
Omg !! ALL BELLA LULLABYS ARE AWESUM EVEN THE FAKE ONES LIKE THIS !! am obeseseed with them all !! , Rob you look So much fun to be around :) , Especially Because Your my Guy idol !
-keep up your awesum work and i dunno what am going to do when twilight saga finishes ! ILL DIIE XD !! LOVE YOU ROB !!!
This song is the original song that showed up when one tried to find a lullaby before the movie came out. Lol, I know almost all of the first real fans had this song downloaded. Anyways, I like this way better, I listened to this while reading the book and I was taken away, it's just perfect.
@aardbeienwaterijsje This song is actually Lake Erie Rainfall, composed and performed by Jim Brickman, and has absolutely NOTHING to do with the Twilight franchise.
@WyndWalker02 I know that and I know that it is not composed by Claude Debussy either. I just downloaded a bunch of stuff of Debussy and this was in between.
When the hype about the film was floating around, i downloaded this song, under the title of "bella's lullaby" and was convinced (until the movie quite blatantly proved otherwise) that this was the offical Bella's lullaby,
It's sooo pretty !!
Anyway, i have been hunting for the real title ever since then. At first i thought it was the 'The River Flows in You" Song. Nope.
Thank you soo much for posting ! Now i have the name (after considerable searching!) i can learn it! ^_^
Nah I think the song that was picked was a good representation of the movie itself. The context of the music fit with the music in the rest of the movie. This doesn't capture the moment like the music he used.
i've just spent about 30 minutes looking for the title of this song! I downloaded it as Bella's Lullaby, but I wanted to get the real name. Thank you!
ive just spent about an hour searching for what this song is called, i dowloaded it from a site and it was called bellas lullaby, but whenever i searched for alternate versions of the lullaby it just came up with 'the river flows in you' or whatever its called. THANK YOU i always thought this was so beautiful i wanted to know what it was!
Actuality I was as well confused, this Son is Call Lake Erie Rainfall. I bought the film Twilight along with the soundtrack; BIG disappointment. It's not on the album.. Cheeres
OH MY GOD i just spent 45 minutes looking for this song. this should have been the actual llullaby. when i saw someone comment, saying that this was what they thought should have been the lullaby, i didnt at all think that this would be the one i was looking for. 45 minutes. at last.
This song is beautiful, I'm sitting here writing my college application essay to this because it is bringing so many thoughts in my head as to what I can write! ;) haha
I just played the first two minutes of this song for my uncles wedding. They had me play it during the lighting of the candle... which worked nice if you cut it where we did
This is so beautiful. I can't play it on the piano it sounds really bad. But this is amazing, definitely good enough for Bella's Lullaby. It's so much better than the one in the movie.
es wäre eigentlich perfekt gewesen für Bella's Lullaby....Doch Summit wollte ja unbedingt dieses Stück von Carter Burwell...naja, vielleicht sehen sie es ja wenigstens noch ein....
I had this song in my phone as Bellas lullaby be because I didn't know the actual name of it so thanks for the real name!!!!!!!! Its such a beautiful and peaceful song!!!!!!!
I love this song, it's beautiful ... why didn't they pick it or river flows in you or trees???? I mean, I don't hate carter burwells lullaby but this song is so much better^^
Yurima wrote the river flows in you and well I am sure this is not the actual lullaby for the movie and I would not want it to be spoiled by that because I hear this song and think of it as my own and that no one but me knows about it (not like I am possessive but no one in my school listens to music like this but me)
I wish this was the official lullaby for Bella and I agree with redhot654. Lake Erie Rainfall fits Twilight so well and it alone is very beautiful. Whenever I hear this it immediately makes me feel so relaxed and reminds me of the lovely series Twilight. :)
this is so beautiful, the actual bella's lullaby was too intrumental. This is so deep and beautiful, it actually makes you think, and it fits twilight perectly. Sometimes after watching the movie, I forget the mood of the actual book. This reminds me of the twilight I fell in love with <3
I completely agree...this should have been the lullaby for Bella. Everytime I play/hear this song her and Edward pop into my mind. Such a beautiful piece.
my friend sent me bella's lullabye and she sent me this thinking it was the real one and i was like omgg thats so beyond amazing!! and then i realised it was nt the right one and i was like ohhh :( dont get me wrong i do like the real one .. so i was like okay dont need that anymroe but i could nt delete this song ... its too beautiful i wanted 2 cry lol
I think this would be a great lullaby for Bella. It's so soft, beautiful and relaxing, powerful too, in a way. I do like this more than River Flow In You. :P This is perfect for the lullaby. :)
i think i like this better than River Flows in you (: Because RFIY is...too strong and kinda rough compared to this one. This is gentle, high-pitched and reallyreally sweet.
I really don't like this song as Bella's lullaby. It doesn't sound very lullabyish to me. Although it is a very pretty piece, I prefered River Flows in You. Cause remember he has to hum this to her, (or he hums it to her in the book at least, don't know if he will in the movie), and that might be pretty hard with this song.
YIRUMA-RIVER FLOWS IN YOU,,,if you listen to it it is way to sad...why would edward be sad if he has bella now? its too fast also to be a lullaby, i tried sleeping to it, doesn't work. it's like bella died or something and edward is remembering her.
A BETTER SONG IS BY
JIM BRICKMAN- ALL I EVER WANTED
It is the best choice because the song expresses RELIEF, JOY and an ETERNAL LIFE WITH BELLA. PLus it is slower to be a lullaby. Relief that edward finally found bella..its not expressing sorrow
Well I haven't heard "All I ever wanted" but if you remember Edward always felt "guilty" for liking Bella.He doesn't think he should (I guess its that prey-predator thing) thats why he left her in the first place, he didn't think it was safe for her.He has never wanted to make Bella a vampire so the whole eternal life doesn't seem to work either.The only thing that works is joy, bc nobody can deny that he is very happy & in love with Bella.Anyways I'll listen to the song & tell you what I think.
Well I just listened to it and I still like "River flows in you" better. I feel like this one is too slow. Its a nice piece but I don't think its the right piece for Bella's lullaby. & anyway I'm not even sure if they're going to use any outside pieces, I thought Rob was going to make his own lullaby(at least that was the plan).
I understand that Edward feels bad that he is (might be) taking away Bella's human life and the fact that he left her is sad too.., but the truth is that Edward loves Bella and really does want to be with her forever. Anyways, sadness isn't something I would choose for a lullaby... She needs something slower..Edward really had a STRONG connection with Bella the first time he saw her..and he is expressing that relief that he isn't alone for eternity once you find someone after decades, ur not sad
YIRUMA-RIVER FLOWS IN YOU,,,if you listen to it it is way to sad...why would edward be sad if he has bella now? its too fast also to be a lullaby, i tried sleeping to it, doesn't work. it's like bella died or something and edward is remembering her.
A BETTER SONG IS BY
JIM BRICKMAN- ALL I EVER WANTED
It is the best choice because the song expresses RELIEF, JOY and an ETERNAL LIFE WITH BELLA. PLus it is slower to be a lullaby. Relief that edward finally found bella..its not expressing sorrow
@WyndWalker02 Alright love calm down
xLILMISSCUPCAKEx 1 year ago
i disliked this. not because i dislike the song because im a HUGE fan of jim brickman, but because i dont think it shouldve been bellas lullabye. just because something is good doesnt mean it belongs in twilight.
JennieRebecca1 1 year ago 3
How dare you try and make a connection between anything Brickman has done and the vomit-factory reject that is the Twilight franchise. Please keep this talented composer away from this series hack writer.
WyndWalker02 1 year ago 4
I dont know Why this piece is so much Fascinating to me ...When i hear it i just enter a new world a beautifull world where evrything looks perfect and lovely ... I dont know how this song admires you all people or how u listen to it but it is very important to me ........
Ringing88keys 1 year ago
How could you put this together with Twilight? stupid
SainttheObvious 1 year ago 3
this song is for gays
17nitox 1 year ago
i think the same two people disliked both this and rocket to the moon. what a-holes this such a great song
bamadude94 1 year ago
For anyone trying to learn this song on the piano, it is NOT as difficult as it sounds. Just keep trying and eventually the rythm will become natural. Keep the end in sight!!
nubcake29 1 year ago
@nubcake29
Thanks :) I really really want to play it.
It sooo beautifull
i can hear it a hundred times and its still ... lovely.. <3
xMysterique 1 year ago
Omg !! ALL BELLA LULLABYS ARE AWESUM EVEN THE FAKE ONES LIKE THIS !! am obeseseed with them all !! , Rob you look So much fun to be around :) , Especially Because Your my Guy idol !
-keep up your awesum work and i dunno what am going to do when twilight saga finishes ! ILL DIIE XD !! LOVE YOU ROB !!!
PrincessChecheCyrus 1 year ago
This song is the original song that showed up when one tried to find a lullaby before the movie came out. Lol, I know almost all of the first real fans had this song downloaded. Anyways, I like this way better, I listened to this while reading the book and I was taken away, it's just perfect.
NeyxChaos 1 year ago
@Desafortunadamente31 It's not so difficult. But I think you have figured it out by now :)
aardbeienwaterijsje 1 year ago
This song is so beautiful.
I'm confused to as why I had it in my iTunes named "Twilight Lullaby - Claude Debussy"
aardbeienwaterijsje 1 year ago
@aardbeienwaterijsje This song is actually Lake Erie Rainfall, composed and performed by Jim Brickman, and has absolutely NOTHING to do with the Twilight franchise.
WyndWalker02 1 year ago
@WyndWalker02 I know that and I know that it is not composed by Claude Debussy either. I just downloaded a bunch of stuff of Debussy and this was in between.
aardbeienwaterijsje 1 year ago
I acutlaly love you.
When the hype about the film was floating around, i downloaded this song, under the title of "bella's lullaby" and was convinced (until the movie quite blatantly proved otherwise) that this was the offical Bella's lullaby,
It's sooo pretty !!
Anyway, i have been hunting for the real title ever since then. At first i thought it was the 'The River Flows in You" Song. Nope.
Thank you soo much for posting ! Now i have the name (after considerable searching!) i can learn it! ^_^
yunachan06 1 year ago
This piece is now associated with Twilight? DAMNIT NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
atester42 1 year ago
oh ♥ when i ve heard the start...i know, that this song is one of the best..:))♥thanks
DreamDancerIrish 1 year ago
Nah I think the song that was picked was a good representation of the movie itself. The context of the music fit with the music in the rest of the movie. This doesn't capture the moment like the music he used.
aceangel5891 2 years ago
i love this song it is so beautiful and peaaceful and serene. they really should have put this and the song in the movie
twilightjunky101 2 years ago
Ah maaannnn. This song is so beautiful. The picture kinda almost ruined it for me though. Now I'm gonna think of twilight every time I hear it. >:[
johnnybee31 2 years ago
i love it, so much that im learning it on my piano now :D
zofia522smiley 2 years ago
you are right twilight fan 28!!!!!!!!!!!
musicfortheworldgirl 2 years ago
this song is really amazing.. but i really like the original one though..
musicaddict126 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BELLA AND EDWARD CAN GO DIE!
fortunecookie247 2 years ago
Maybe they do.. you should read the book and find out =P
Moppie38 2 years ago
haha lol i love the books but i just hate the movie =P i've read all of them ;)
fortunecookie247 2 years ago
wow this song is absolutely beautiful! it totally reminds me of Bella
dulcetserenity 2 years ago
i've just spent about 30 minutes looking for the title of this song! I downloaded it as Bella's Lullaby, but I wanted to get the real name. Thank you!
AngelicaH28 2 years ago
It's called Lake Erie Rainfall. (: I love it.
taylor33love 2 years ago
ive just spent about an hour searching for what this song is called, i dowloaded it from a site and it was called bellas lullaby, but whenever i searched for alternate versions of the lullaby it just came up with 'the river flows in you' or whatever its called. THANK YOU i always thought this was so beautiful i wanted to know what it was!
Lexi961 2 years ago
@Lexi961
Actuality I was as well confused, this Son is Call Lake Erie Rainfall. I bought the film Twilight along with the soundtrack; BIG disappointment. It's not on the album.. Cheeres
rwashi 2 years ago
OH MY GOD i just spent 45 minutes looking for this song. this should have been the actual llullaby. when i saw someone comment, saying that this was what they thought should have been the lullaby, i didnt at all think that this would be the one i was looking for. 45 minutes. at last.
Iem2qt 2 years ago
i also agree. ive loved this song for ages, and when i finally read twilight, I just knew this song had to be Bella's lullaby :)
but i think Carters version is good too dont get me wrong! XD
JackLovesIanto 2 years ago
This song is beautiful, I'm sitting here writing my college application essay to this because it is bringing so many thoughts in my head as to what I can write! ;) haha
Hondurankid92 2 years ago
i always say i don´t want to marry in my life.
but in case i do, why ever ..i want exactly THIS song to play when i walk into the church!! :)
it´s amazing!!
NovoStar86 2 years ago 3
I just played the first two minutes of this song for my uncles wedding. They had me play it during the lighting of the candle... which worked nice if you cut it where we did
amazedbyitall07 2 years ago
i dont like it at medium
msdavitt100 2 years ago
I NEVER get tired of listening to this melody! It's just so beautiful =D
iretei93 2 years ago 5
its jst so beautiful
EzaCh1va 2 years ago
wow (spechless)
EzaCh1va 2 years ago
its jst so beautiful
EzaCh1va 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lovely song! :'-)! Watch my video response plz plz plz Plz!!
LaughingSpanner 2 years ago
this is... beautiful. Thankyou, Jim Brickman
peper1881 2 years ago 5
This is so beautiful. I can't play it on the piano it sounds really bad. But this is amazing, definitely good enough for Bella's Lullaby. It's so much better than the one in the movie.
Bluefire111Twilight 2 years ago 2
Dieses Lied ist so schöön <33
es wäre eigentlich perfekt gewesen für Bella's Lullaby....Doch Summit wollte ja unbedingt dieses Stück von Carter Burwell...naja, vielleicht sehen sie es ja wenigstens noch ein....
aber dieses Lied.......himmlisch <33
Fabiizenx3 2 years ago
E' bellissima
babelenne 2 years ago
wow
^^
9eSmiLe9 2 years ago 5
This reminds me of the beautiful, deep, touching Twilight that I fell in love with. Thank You, Jim Brickman.
squishyanimals1 2 years ago 4
i love this song.....it is good for twilight. i really like the river flows in you, but this would definitely be my second choice.
nicolegirl789 2 years ago 4
I can play the river flows in you on the piano. I will put me playing it on my channel soon!
LaughingSpanner 2 years ago
soo beautiful, i wish i can play this song..
RETROxSOCKS 2 years ago 2
It's soo beautiful. I cry every time I hear it!
iretei93 2 years ago
emm... Do you know whare I can have the tutorial of this song?? PLEASEEE HELPME..
PD. I'm sorry for my english..
mariu2nc 2 years ago 2
I don't know were you can get it but you can always google it..
iretei93 2 years ago 3
I had this song in my phone as Bellas lullaby be because I didn't know the actual name of it so thanks for the real name!!!!!!!! Its such a beautiful and peaceful song!!!!!!!
weirdisnewcool 2 years ago
Search Jmmet15 He's good
He's from Cleveland
violingirl8735 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i luv this song but its not the lullaby. good vid though. and rob pattinson didnt rite the final one either.
qtcakes66 2 years ago
even though this is not the real lullaby...i still love it!!!!!!!!!!!11
wcd3496 2 years ago 16
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This one is written by Robert Pattinson.... i don't understand it anymore... from whjo is this really???
Elimat777 2 years ago
Robert Pattinson did NOT write this Jim Brickman did
TwilightFan28 2 years ago 12
I love this song, it's beautiful ... why didn't they pick it or river flows in you or trees???? I mean, I don't hate carter burwells lullaby but this song is so much better^^
HarleeMcKyn 2 years ago 7
Yurima wrote the river flows in you and well I am sure this is not the actual lullaby for the movie and I would not want it to be spoiled by that because I hear this song and think of it as my own and that no one but me knows about it (not like I am possessive but no one in my school listens to music like this but me)
Cullenkiss529 2 years ago 2
oh .... but these songs are more beautiful than the offfica. lullaby of bellas, so don't waht to hurt you but it's a fact^^
HarleeMcKyn 2 years ago 3
this actually sounds like it could be something written for renesmee from edward, too.
iluvpuppies1395 2 years ago 5
i think this should definitely be bella's lulllaby. love it!!
iluvpuppies1395 2 years ago 4
plz can you post another time the download link? Yhe site tell me that is impossible!
BrokenDreamGC 3 years ago
now I can download =)
BrokenDreamGC 3 years ago
I wish this was the official lullaby for Bella and I agree with redhot654. Lake Erie Rainfall fits Twilight so well and it alone is very beautiful. Whenever I hear this it immediately makes me feel so relaxed and reminds me of the lovely series Twilight. :)
Valerie217 3 years ago 2
this is so beautiful, the actual bella's lullaby was too intrumental. This is so deep and beautiful, it actually makes you think, and it fits twilight perectly. Sometimes after watching the movie, I forget the mood of the actual book. This reminds me of the twilight I fell in love with <3
redhot654 3 years ago 10
This...is...amazing...If I didn't know the real lullaby that they chose I would have thought this was it :D
hihosilver45 3 years ago
I completely agree...this should have been the lullaby for Bella. Everytime I play/hear this song her and Edward pop into my mind. Such a beautiful piece.
besler15 3 years ago 4
Did anyone every listen to this AND to STYX's "Lady" - tell me what you think.
garysmelcer 3 years ago
this is the most beautiful lullaby ever!
izzycochrane111 3 years ago 4
chech out river flows in you by yiruma. its so beautiful. this is cute too
CrazyKanga5035 3 years ago 3
I wish someone would make a tutorial for this song, I want to learn it so bad.
I'm not good at reading notes anymore though, I'm getting rusty.
xxaem23 3 years ago
jim brickman is amazing this is my favorite piano piece ever!
lolchick95 3 years ago
it is so peaceful <<3 i love it^^
girlymoesister 3 years ago 2
beautiful
PaigeDH 3 years ago
my friend sent me bella's lullabye and she sent me this thinking it was the real one and i was like omgg thats so beyond amazing!! and then i realised it was nt the right one and i was like ohhh :( dont get me wrong i do like the real one .. so i was like okay dont need that anymroe but i could nt delete this song ... its too beautiful i wanted 2 cry lol
TeamEdward52 3 years ago
i'm a huge twilight and jim brickman fan...this would be my second choice too.
EdwardCullen1010 3 years ago
yeah i thought this song was called beautiful mind.
bobetbobbober14 3 years ago
you're thinking of the soundtrack of the film a beautiful mind!
saragarthxo 3 years ago
I love this...but i also love 'river flows in you' I love the sound of this ine but...oh, i just cant decide! Loe them both!
lovethedramatic 3 years ago
what is this song called?
I mean other than Bellas lullaby
gothicgal000 3 years ago
if you would have read the info then you would know that its called lake erie rainfall by jim brickman
itsASHgotit 3 years ago
<3 love love love
personally my favorite representation of her song
:)
asdjasdnnasds
Magic!
ilvmusic77 3 years ago
okay, i live river flows in you better as a song.
but as bella's lullaby, this is a little better. slower. relaxing. like a lullaby.
*tearful eyes*
xRockStarx13 3 years ago 2
ome i love this song so much! i think this would be perfect as bella's lullaby!!! *tearful eyes* ♥
o0MissMurder 3 years ago 3
I think this would be a great lullaby for Bella. It's so soft, beautiful and relaxing, powerful too, in a way. I do like this more than River Flow In You. :P This is perfect for the lullaby. :)
Valerie217 3 years ago 3
i think i like this better than River Flows in you (: Because RFIY is...too strong and kinda rough compared to this one. This is gentle, high-pitched and reallyreally sweet.
xXvanessaaa 3 years ago 6
its soo pretty this is what i sorta thought it sounded like but i also like River Flows In You by Yiruma but this would be my first pick
iluvfroggys 3 years ago 3
I love this song! Its so moving! thanks 4 uploading this! I have the music to this and I'm playing this... it sounds so pretty!
riverbend49 3 years ago 3
lovly, but i think its alittle to up tempo for Bella Lullaby
eava123 3 years ago 4
this is way better than Yiruma, Yiruma is too saddd.......give me one reason why edward would be sad that he found bella??? and its way too fast
littleflowwer 3 years ago 3
one reason: he thought Bella would be off better without him in her life. Remember?!!!
riverbend49 3 years ago 3
I really don't like this song as Bella's lullaby. It doesn't sound very lullabyish to me. Although it is a very pretty piece, I prefered River Flows in You. Cause remember he has to hum this to her, (or he hums it to her in the book at least, don't know if he will in the movie), and that might be pretty hard with this song.
jmendoza1087 3 years ago
true. river flows in you OR kiss the rain would be absolutely moving as a lullaby to bella
ToT
riverbend49 3 years ago
YIRUMA-RIVER FLOWS IN YOU,,,if you listen to it it is way to sad...why would edward be sad if he has bella now? its too fast also to be a lullaby, i tried sleeping to it, doesn't work. it's like bella died or something and edward is remembering her.
A BETTER SONG IS BY
JIM BRICKMAN- ALL I EVER WANTED
It is the best choice because the song expresses RELIEF, JOY and an ETERNAL LIFE WITH BELLA. PLus it is slower to be a lullaby. Relief that edward finally found bella..its not expressing sorrow
littleflowwer 3 years ago 3
Well I haven't heard "All I ever wanted" but if you remember Edward always felt "guilty" for liking Bella.He doesn't think he should (I guess its that prey-predator thing) thats why he left her in the first place, he didn't think it was safe for her.He has never wanted to make Bella a vampire so the whole eternal life doesn't seem to work either.The only thing that works is joy, bc nobody can deny that he is very happy & in love with Bella.Anyways I'll listen to the song & tell you what I think.
jmendoza1087 3 years ago 2
Well I just listened to it and I still like "River flows in you" better. I feel like this one is too slow. Its a nice piece but I don't think its the right piece for Bella's lullaby. & anyway I'm not even sure if they're going to use any outside pieces, I thought Rob was going to make his own lullaby(at least that was the plan).
jmendoza1087 3 years ago 4
I understand that Edward feels bad that he is (might be) taking away Bella's human life and the fact that he left her is sad too.., but the truth is that Edward loves Bella and really does want to be with her forever. Anyways, sadness isn't something I would choose for a lullaby... She needs something slower..Edward really had a STRONG connection with Bella the first time he saw her..and he is expressing that relief that he isn't alone for eternity once you find someone after decades, ur not sad
littleflowwer 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
YIRUMA-RIVER FLOWS IN YOU,,,if you listen to it it is way to sad...why would edward be sad if he has bella now? its too fast also to be a lullaby, i tried sleeping to it, doesn't work. it's like bella died or something and edward is remembering her.
A BETTER SONG IS BY
JIM BRICKMAN- ALL I EVER WANTED
It is the best choice because the song expresses RELIEF, JOY and an ETERNAL LIFE WITH BELLA. PLus it is slower to be a lullaby. Relief that edward finally found bella..its not expressing sorrow
littleflowwer 3 years ago
I ♥ this song! I played it @ my piano recital and a lot of ppl told me i nneded 2 be a musician when i grow up. tehe:)
riverbend49 3 years ago
yay=]
thesuzymonster 3 years ago
Amazing ;) Soo beautiful...
scorphagos 3 years ago
ONE WORD = BEAUTIFUL =)
OfficialMG08 3 years ago