I'm trying to imagine the creative process that came up with THIS as the best possible idea for a clip... So there are very white bikers and they all have underwear on their heads - because it's cool? Also, the "Ha HAA" Jermaine utters at 3:04... was that the take the director said "CUT! perfect!!!"?!? Man, the 80's were weird! :)
When the rain begins to fall Ihr wollt es haben?! Ich habs so 6:07 min in Superquali,addet mich.Oder macht Euch mal mühe besorgt Euch die Maxi über EBAY zB und gebt für n vernüftigen Vorverstärker und Plattenspieler so 150 bis 200 Euros aus.Oder "addet"mich.ok.cu all.machts gut.
imagine this: there comes a obviously pissed motorcycle gang(although gay looking in this video), stops in front of you and their leader asks you this and offends your hometown - and then you start singing this song, of course with that high voice!
I love this song. Has something really heart-catchy!!
Love the melody and the text. also the video was made with much fantasy. I wish the actual song videos would have more of this fantasy and wouldn't be that stereotype like they're...
Jebana szmata, najpierw go podrywa, śpiewa z nim, udaje, że go kocha a potem wraca z tym lalusiem na motorku.. typowa kobieta, powinien sobie kupic lepszy motor niz tamta pizda. Wracajac do teledysku, był świetny a te efekty specjalne pochłonęły mnie całkowicie.. brakowało tylko krwi
@LedgerRsx Such a shame... Now I've listened almost all covers of Patty Smith's "Because the night" and they're all great. That's how U recognize really great song. This song also got some nice covers and is awesome itself.
the 80's were so deliciously wrong, the hair, the mad max wannabe bad guys, the jackson wannabe bad guys (with kicks this time)...cause cool bad guys dance and know karate (mr miyagi anyone??)...the DX7 synth sounds....love it
and when the rain begins to fall you're on my rainbow in the sky - and i will catch you if you fall, you never have to ask me why, and when the rain begins to fall, i'll be the sunshine in your life ... GREAT!!! :) 2:30
Im glad, I suppose, that Zadora ultimately returned to her own tribe. I , however, would not have wanted her back. In short, I would have left her with the nigger, the cool song notwithstanding.
Apes in the wild dont court gazelles or peacocks, why human animals decide to breach racial lines remains a mystery to me. The outcome on a massive scale, however, would be the end of western civilization and the dawning of inept mongrel nation.
@celtoantico LOL, mixed breeding makes the human race stronger and its good for the gene pool.
look what happend to england, inbreds.
if you keep having an exclusive group mate, they will end up with diseases or birth defaults. do some research about it. we need to mix, im happy cause i love choclate ladys and asians!
Voilà les jeunes, ça ne sert à rien de se battre pour une pute. Non seulement ça l'excite mais en plus tu te bats pour rien. Si ta meuf veut se taper son keubla, laisse la faire, elle n'en vaut pas la peine. hahahahhaaa
ok this trying to tell us how impossible is a love between a black gang chiefe member with a white gang chiefe member.. it also trys to pass the message that girls should fall in love with the boys that they have power and money.... crappy shitty video clip... the music is great...
I dont know where you are all from but start to use your F***ing Brains. You dont have to find a bad intention in everything.. After all i remember this song from back then and we were just dancing, we didnt care that there was a black guy or a white guy. Thats why the song was written. Who cares about the story of the video clip...
@discouniverse What do you mean "as always?" Do you know, I just took this video as a depiction of rival gangs in a fantasy/sci-fi setting. I never even noticed that one gang was primarily black and the other white; I was just enjoying the song and the drama.
Besides, if you watch the video, nobody beats anybody; it ends in a stalemate.
partner. When Lies only one time would have made a marriage better, there won't be so much divorces ! Honesty is altruism, because people can rely on !
The song is very nice but I was dissappointed when seeing the video for the first time. It has the taste of manipulating/manipulation because saying to a woman that the she doesn't see right in -her- view/feelings isn't very honest. If you want, give me now thumbs down but when someone really loves a person, no one do that !
girl chooses everytime the chief gang, its a real love or just a power love????
I have noticed that blacks and whites are never in love together in a american movie or clip. And when they are, like in this clip, their love is never show (kiss, etc...) and cant continued.... I think american opinion could be shock.
It doesn't matter about black or white ! I am angry about that the guy says to the woman that she doesn't see right in her way to feel.
I think a woman has the right to choose what she likes -without- manipulation or making tricks. When it would have been real love, they wouldn't have divorced. So the doctrine is : Never cheat and allways be honest with feelings of others. Honesty is the best policy !
hahhaha divorce principal cause it s just because people say everytime with honesty what they want..... and finally opinion are not the same. Hypocrisie and play comedy can make a better married long time a go. Honesty is egoisme.
@chrisbreizh29 wow i am shocked..this is so true.. this is what it actually trying to say without making us realise it...a girl should choose a man with ''power and money''
@chrisbreizh29 answere for your first break: its because those guys have a special charisma...a girl think they have power, strengh, will always protect them. a girl just thinks they are real men...to lean on when she needs it. but often they realize fast that those guys are just assholes xDD
jermaine is hoot :D
bananabonbon 1 week ago
I'm trying to imagine the creative process that came up with THIS as the best possible idea for a clip... So there are very white bikers and they all have underwear on their heads - because it's cool? Also, the "Ha HAA" Jermaine utters at 3:04... was that the take the director said "CUT! perfect!!!"?!? Man, the 80's were weird! :)
StrangeUnicorn1 1 week ago
i love this song <333333333333333333333333
CeezeCookieLike 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
Comment removed
Urmel64 1 month ago
When the rain begins to fall Ihr wollt es haben?! Ich habs so 6:07 min in Superquali,addet mich.Oder macht Euch mal mühe besorgt Euch die Maxi über EBAY zB und gebt für n vernüftigen Vorverstärker und Plattenspieler so 150 bis 200 Euros aus.Oder "addet"mich.ok.cu all.machts gut.
KongoWalter 1 month ago
warum verlässt sie ihn warum nur...
CeezeCookieLike 1 month ago
behold the might that is the 80's. Shame though they had to properly fight in the end instead of a far more stilish dance stand off :)
Fifafu1 1 month ago
best part 2:45-2:58
eirinaki1985 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
wieso hat das lied noch keine 100000 klicks
didelidudeli2011 2 months ago
uum crazy man
jedisteven1 2 months ago in playlist Einfach Geil
I'm lovin'it!!
sabsepaparazze 2 months ago
geiles video :D
Silvidanski 3 months ago
Das Liedchen ist einfach nur geil!!!
Dopaminist 3 months ago
Was für eine abgefahrene lange Version.... never heard before.
Pure79er 3 months ago
@Pure79er
schlechte Quali bekommst Du nur auf Maxi Platte!! Oder adde mich, vielleicht lass ich Dich des hören.
KongoWalter 1 month ago
@KongoWalter ...Danke, so wichtig ist es mir nicht, dass ich Dich dann adden muss...
Ausserdem hatte ich mich nie über die Qualität geäussert.
Danke aber trotzdem.
Pure79er 1 month ago
michael jackson would've been as beautiful as jermaine if he had left his skin brown!
miesermogelvogel 3 months ago
cool song,
and the German VIVA at the end ;-)
Daniel234H 4 months ago
FRIGGIN LOVE THIS SONG !!!!!! What a great FEEL-GOOD song !
MJFAN100100 4 months ago
Is there a bar in this scumfucking town?
Like the sand can seep right through your fingers so can all your days.
IMakeULoveMe 4 months ago
@IMakeULoveMe
imagine this: there comes a obviously pissed motorcycle gang(although gay looking in this video), stops in front of you and their leader asks you this and offends your hometown - and then you start singing this song, of course with that high voice!
epic fail oder badass?
ThePuschkin1986 4 months ago
@ThePuschkin1986 and you also sing a 6.31 minutes song throughout the day... :b
McKolivan 4 months ago
I'm in a RainyMood...
umoeder0 5 months ago
das lied hat was
MrStitzi01 5 months ago
i love 80ssssssssssssssssssssss!!!!!!!!!
nikosDivas 5 months ago 2
Die Liebe fragt nicht nach dem Sinn – sie erfüllt sich...
Lichtstern im Herzen grüßt euch alle.
Biss bald Peros Liebeslied
LichtsternimHerzen2 6 months ago in playlist Pop/Balladen
wait mtv playin real music
dsgh51 6 months ago
Lichtstern im Herzen die deutschsprachige Pop Ballade grüßt alle,
Biss bald Peros Liebes
lied,
LichtsternimHerzen2 6 months ago in playlist Pop/Balladen
میں نہیں کرنا چاہتا ہوں کہ اس گانے کے ساتھ مردہ پایا جائے
MrLocorio 6 months ago
بھاڑ میں جاؤ
MrLocorio 6 months ago
I wasn't even born in this time, but I like it :]
MrOMWTF 6 months ago
"total cheesy aber irg. wie cool ne?" Was lief denn da falsch %))
HannesZane 6 months ago
the video is like traditional videos of michael jackson.... soo long... powerfull song!
MrRippJay 6 months ago
Me gusta
lovingyaru 7 months ago
Favourite from the 80s. :)
TheBlabester 7 months ago
Das ist ja sowas von 80er......muhahaha geil!!!
IronRat74 7 months ago
This song is great! and it was also edited in Spanish...
sommermannbt 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tunhari maa ka bhosda
le0sphere 8 months ago
Merveilleux! <3
MleLizzy 8 months ago
I saw white people
I saw black people
I saw a fight
I saw some dancing
Yndi18 9 months ago 25
2:00
Ogamer93 9 months ago
hey isn't that pre-white Michael Jackson? This must be one of his lesser known songs
TechnoDevotee 9 months ago
@TechnoDevotee xD his brother :D
Googaify 9 months ago
@TechnoDevotee : man, it's JERMAINE NOT MICHAEL ;)
rdsone 6 months ago 33
@TechnoDevotee : and this is a very known song!
Aaah, I'm so glad to be an eighties child :-)
sm555 6 months ago
میں نہیں کرنا چاہتا ہوں کہ اس گانے کے ساتھ مردہ پایا جائے
MrLocorio 6 months ago
@MrLocorio
And I would rather die than ever have to speak this language.
wimpie25 4 months ago
@TechnoDevotee and plus this song is really famous
gjfdell 3 weeks ago
This song reminds me of my classmates ! We used to sing it all the time.. It brings such wonderful memories...
in4etuy 10 months ago
i love this song! Does anybody knows something about the motorcycles they used in this video?
TheFreestyleJumper 10 months ago
wow is this the original version of this song i know papa bear done a version
EMRAHsays 10 months ago
@EMRAHsays yes this is the original, produced by a german^^
TWMusicBerlin 9 months ago
it's really cute ! :3
l0ris21 10 months ago
cultissime !
chanapan 10 months ago
omfg i thought alex k made this song :O
YOKO4LIFE 11 months ago
@YOKO4LIFE rofl, u made my day!
aspect847 10 months ago
@YOKO4LIFE rofl, u made my day!
aspect847 10 months ago
you know something s wrong when a black dude starts singin at your girlfriend XD
RubenNunes93 11 months ago
I enjoy
Joulcak 11 months ago
I love this song. Has something really heart-catchy!!
Love the melody and the text. also the video was made with much fantasy. I wish the actual song videos would have more of this fantasy and wouldn't be that stereotype like they're...
LUVABBA1974 1 year ago
3:06 HAHA!
Xanoto 1 year ago 3
BEST SONG EVAAA
LichtAssassin 1 year ago
i love this song
TheSandrine59100 1 year ago 2
Haha! That was awesome, I love the 80's! :)
skatty14 1 year ago 2
"total cheesy aber irgendwie cool"
So ein Affe!!!
Die deutsche Sprache wird mir langsam zu lächerlich!!!
bushoisa 1 year ago 3
@bushoisa die "deutsche" :D
bonanzke 1 year ago
this song is just amazing.I GROW UP WITH THIS SONG ....i just dont understand why two people cant be together it doesnt mater the colour if its love
nertial 1 year ago
5:13 Kampf der Giganten xD ,ach und wirklich tolles Lied :D
MsSchwabbelBubble106 1 year ago 2
This song is more than a SONG for me !!!! It's my live omg +-+
ErikaFunShow 1 year ago
Jebana szmata, najpierw go podrywa, śpiewa z nim, udaje, że go kocha a potem wraca z tym lalusiem na motorku.. typowa kobieta, powinien sobie kupic lepszy motor niz tamta pizda. Wracajac do teledysku, był świetny a te efekty specjalne pochłonęły mnie całkowicie.. brakowało tylko krwi
Windsofthewild 1 year ago
Oh god , why i'ved born on hanna montana's and justin bieber's age ?
LedgerRsx 1 year ago 136
@LedgerRsx same here... :/:(
Googaify 9 months ago
@LedgerRsx how old are you?
flo372 8 months ago
@LedgerRsx Such a shame... Now I've listened almost all covers of Patty Smith's "Because the night" and they're all great. That's how U recognize really great song. This song also got some nice covers and is awesome itself.
16klamca16 3 months ago
@LedgerRsx
I am really sorry for you :)
but
you have youtube still, so you can taste the 80s music
Stagiryta 1 month ago
@LedgerRsx you are sooo right!!
Dusselman100 3 weeks ago
Michael war stolz auf seinen Bruder
Lionforever1860 1 year ago
the 80's were so deliciously wrong, the hair, the mad max wannabe bad guys, the jackson wannabe bad guys (with kicks this time)...cause cool bad guys dance and know karate (mr miyagi anyone??)...the DX7 synth sounds....love it
mailbishie 1 year ago
@mailbishie how should its wrong? it was modern this time. in 20 years people laughin about us.
Just1CriZ 1 year ago
80s was awesome
ingraman 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
but people im not a racist but if we white people want we rule the whole world
mrweening 1 year ago
Comment removed
mrweening 1 year ago
0:57 OMG LOOK AT HER GLASSES!!! I personally think everyone was drugged out in the 80's LOL!
cMARVEL360 1 year ago
Comment removed
mrweening 1 year ago
i wish i have a group right now and make a song & clip like that . it would be like a dessert rose.
germiyan80 1 year ago
einfach der geilste refrain auf der welt. soooo ein ohrwurm
BeNeath0 1 year ago
Ditz, schäm dich.. ich bleib lieber beim Spandau Ballet
Epiphling 1 year ago
at 2:28 his smile is wonderful. love u Germain and Pia !
xrysa87al 1 year ago
Oh God. There is nothing like the '80s.
zimnomel 1 year ago
Superbe souvenir
HelisRules 1 year ago 3
j adore cette chanson plein de peps et de dynamisme....quel punch!!
fleuristeoise 1 year ago 3
@fleuristeoise
Trop géniale!!
On en fait plus des chansons comme ça de nos jours :(
20 ans et nostalgique d'une époque que j'ai pas connue!
PinkCat45 1 year ago 2
Klasyka:)
lukasznon 1 year ago
Esta canción es lo máximo. no me canso de escucharla
gallinacero 1 year ago
and when the rain begins to fall you're on my rainbow in the sky - and i will catch you if you fall, you never have to ask me why, and when the rain begins to fall, i'll be the sunshine in your life ... GREAT!!! :) 2:30
pkrunX 1 year ago 2
@pkrunX best chorus in the world
BeNeath0 1 year ago 2
Love that song
imane111 1 year ago
i love this song !
letmego8707 1 year ago
The best clip ever is thriller by michael jackson
1988novita 1 year ago
la chanson est bien, mais le clip est a chier !
kinout69 1 year ago
Tiramisu.P
zbyniusz7777 1 year ago
how "80's" can you get it!! fame,flashdance, mad max, the warriors,... every second of this video screams 80's!!
kito7 1 year ago
MJ Copy
saltbear 1 year ago
thank you. this is one of my favorite songs.
nightmaredad81 1 year ago
OMG One of the best songs on this world.... its so fantastic.. so very very very teriffic!!!
♥♥♥
amazinqqirly 1 year ago
Im glad, I suppose, that Zadora ultimately returned to her own tribe. I , however, would not have wanted her back. In short, I would have left her with the nigger, the cool song notwithstanding.
Apes in the wild dont court gazelles or peacocks, why human animals decide to breach racial lines remains a mystery to me. The outcome on a massive scale, however, would be the end of western civilization and the dawning of inept mongrel nation.
celtoantico 1 year ago
@celtoantico LOL, mixed breeding makes the human race stronger and its good for the gene pool.
look what happend to england, inbreds.
if you keep having an exclusive group mate, they will end up with diseases or birth defaults. do some research about it. we need to mix, im happy cause i love choclate ladys and asians!
Wubba83 1 year ago
gros trip!!! la musique bof mais le clip mdr, en favori direct!
789champignon 1 year ago
good song but is he trying to be like his brother Micheal much hmmm ? ? you decide
Natethacker 1 year ago
@Natethacker
Not at all, he had a totaly different style.
wimpie25 1 year ago
good song, strange video
gonzothegreatest 1 year ago
Voilà les jeunes, ça ne sert à rien de se battre pour une pute. Non seulement ça l'excite mais en plus tu te bats pour rien. Si ta meuf veut se taper son keubla, laisse la faire, elle n'en vaut pas la peine. hahahahhaaa
orcaminh 1 year ago
Finally i saw the ending of this video, on TV it always ended at about 4:44 min.
Wondermike42 1 year ago
ok this trying to tell us how impossible is a love between a black gang chiefe member with a white gang chiefe member.. it also trys to pass the message that girls should fall in love with the boys that they have power and money.... crappy shitty video clip... the music is great...
kwstas1995 1 year ago
je l'ai entendu dans le film Cyprien avec elie semoun trop rigolo
fandessimpson 1 year ago
2:09
epameinondastube 1 year ago
Comment removed
epameinondastube 1 year ago
So beautyful and wonderful!!!
Jermaine Jackson looks so sexy and hottie!!Realy cute!!!
-xxx-xxx-xxx-
Amber the biggest fan of Jermaine Jackson!!!
JermaineLoveAmber 2 years ago
Oh Jermaine. You sing almost like Michael
mrreman 2 years ago
But he sings exactly like Jermaine.
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
haha those glasses are great
IMSICKOFMYUSERNAME 2 years ago
I get this song never out of my head!!!
TheColourGirl 2 years ago
isn't this the same fight scene from beat it?
mojo71mojo 2 years ago
Who's been adding audio to these clips? It's on three of them
What gives?
Perizada 2 years ago 2
@discouniverse
No, its a song. You chose to see it like that.. If it was two white people would you make a comment?? I would guess no...
@Everyone
I dont know where you are all from but start to use your F***ing Brains. You dont have to find a bad intention in everything.. After all i remember this song from back then and we were just dancing, we didnt care that there was a black guy or a white guy. Thats why the song was written. Who cares about the story of the video clip...
LagunaLoire24 2 years ago 27
True :)
4r5z3n1q 2 years ago
Comment removed
llllExTreMellll 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
true !
i'm with you man !
why make it political? IT'S A SONG !
and a good one with "great memories" !
don't know where they get that racist stuff actually.
llllExTreMellll 2 years ago
@LagunaLoire24 Damn right...its a damn song...why race has to be rammed in by these boneheads is beyond me to be honest!!!
turnex1 1 year ago
Great song, which i was searching for a long time!
voltaspeeder17 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nigger's dreaming...Boring
DrMengele2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
video is racistic it's about black supremacists
discouniverse 2 years ago
why do you have to put everything on political basis?? cant this just be a video clip and nothing more??
LagunaLoire24 2 years ago 4
@LagunaLoire24
could be, but it isn't, it's a racistic hatred towards whites
discouniverse 2 years ago
The word is "racist," not "racistic." And I don't see it at all. If it was, Pia's character wouldn't be a sympathetic one.
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
if white gang would beat blacks then you would consider it racist...as always
discouniverse 1 year ago
@discouniverse What do you mean "as always?" Do you know, I just took this video as a depiction of rival gangs in a fantasy/sci-fi setting. I never even noticed that one gang was primarily black and the other white; I was just enjoying the song and the drama.
Besides, if you watch the video, nobody beats anybody; it ends in a stalemate.
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
oh my... I know the song by heart : I 've never seen the video !
Ycrimiss 2 years ago
jermaine was so sexy there!
Renimeni666 2 years ago
Hypocrisy only shows less respect for a
partner. When Lies only one time would have made a marriage better, there won't be so much divorces ! Honesty is altruism, because people can rely on !
Sportschuetze84 2 years ago
True, but is that relevant to this MV?
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
I LIKE so kitch and ridiculous.
chrisbreizh29 2 years ago
if only he had a gun. this wouldnt have happened.
RyonsVids 2 years ago
He's a good guy; good guys don't kill.
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
The song is very nice but I was dissappointed when seeing the video for the first time. It has the taste of manipulating/manipulation because saying to a woman that the she doesn't see right in -her- view/feelings isn't very honest. If you want, give me now thumbs down but when someone really loves a person, no one do that !
Sportschuetze84 2 years ago
girl chooses everytime the chief gang, its a real love or just a power love????
I have noticed that blacks and whites are never in love together in a american movie or clip. And when they are, like in this clip, their love is never show (kiss, etc...) and cant continued.... I think american opinion could be shock.
chrisbreizh29 2 years ago 31
It doesn't matter about black or white ! I am angry about that the guy says to the woman that she doesn't see right in her way to feel.
I think a woman has the right to choose what she likes -without- manipulation or making tricks. When it would have been real love, they wouldn't have divorced. So the doctrine is : Never cheat and allways be honest with feelings of others. Honesty is the best policy !
Sportschuetze84 2 years ago 3
Hypocrity is the ciment of the society.
chrisbreizh29 2 years ago
You meant hypocrisy ? That's the thing, if he would have been more honest to her, they wouldn't have had a divorce.
Sportschuetze84 2 years ago
hahhaha divorce principal cause it s just because people say everytime with honesty what they want..... and finally opinion are not the same. Hypocrisie and play comedy can make a better married long time a go. Honesty is egoisme.
chrisbreizh29 2 years ago
And honesty is to accept a woman how she is
and not to say her, she is in this wrong and in that wrong and pretending to know everything better.
This is oppression and not love, try to accept the reality.
Sportschuetze84 2 years ago
@chrisbreizh29 wow i am shocked..this is so true.. this is what it actually trying to say without making us realise it...a girl should choose a man with ''power and money''
a boy should choose a girl just like barbie...
kwstas1995 1 year ago
@chrisbreizh29 Actually Madonna did it... and yes, the public was shocked :)
ParkourTV 1 year ago
@chrisbreizh29 watch the movie save the last dance!
Yggdrasilthrone 1 year ago
@chrisbreizh29 a powerlove ;)
MichaelJackson30650 1 year ago
@chrisbreizh29 answere for your first break: its because those guys have a special charisma...a girl think they have power, strengh, will always protect them. a girl just thinks they are real men...to lean on when she needs it. but often they realize fast that those guys are just assholes xDD
magicalFrogOfDarknes 10 months ago
@Sportschuetze84 I don't see what you're seeing; could you explain a little further?
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
You'll notice at 5:22 they had a special appearance by the Rockettes doing their famous high kick line.
lasktguy 2 years ago
Kudos to the songwriter! 10+ stars!
jsbach15 2 years ago
jermaine?? wooaahh....;) heavy
ElberethMiss 2 years ago
GREAT wonderful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kim42610 2 years ago
hahahahah can't stop laughing at the guy's face when she looks at the girl the moment our guy starts singing xDDDDD
xunap 2 years ago
jermaine and pia are the max,. video is a little movie. i love it.
summereyes1 2 years ago
One of the best songs ever !!!
xunap 2 years ago
Sau geil !!!!!!
bitone2k 2 years ago
this is an SUBLIMINAL CLIP of ILLUMINATI
song for devil !!!!!!!
even is nice one
BRRUUUAAHHable 2 years ago
right.....
tsioyman 2 years ago
he looks a little bit like Michael =)
MazineXXS 2 years ago
@MazineXXS Actually, as he's the elder of the two, it would be more accurate to say Michael looked a little bit like him.
MaskedMan66 1 year ago
@MaskedMan66 ja ok
MazineXXS 1 year ago
i Know a Group of
power Metal that sing this song!!...is amazing....
metalerita91 2 years ago
the Group is Heavenly!!!..
metalerita91 2 years ago
le clip bof mais la musice sUper !!
slipknot18150 2 years ago
das lied is von jermaine jackson oO
wusste ich gar net x'D
serenityvampire 2 years ago