@bmillerdrums yeah I heard that before. They DID change a lot of the names and even killed of survivors (in the movie) who actually survived (in reality). SOme characters didnt even make the cut in the movie. Still though, this is the best version of this story. I really dont get how people say it's bad. It's ridiculous. Inaccurate is not the same thing as bad.
Bad acting....like any of the people saying can do any better. BTW A lot of these people (PERSONS BASED UPON) suffered the shock of the crash, therefore they barely reacted to the situation at first (Example Bobby Francois smoking casually near the crash site RIGHT AFTER they crashed, Pablo Montero asking if he was in any danger when CLEARLY he had a metal piece driven straight thru him, the mechanic's hostile behavior) The situation is bad enough to put ANYONE in diff. types of distress.
@shad0wMata Pablo Montero was actually Enrique Platero in the real story. I assume family members didnt want the real names of the victims to be in the movie it would be too difficult. Like Felipe who was sitting next to Nando was Panchito Abal. But there was a boy named Felipe Marriqurian{wrong spelling} who died the next day so its strange how the names are some what accurate yet also not accurate in terms of the story to the movie. This happens throughout the movie.
@Exentine Not funny. This is very serious. Say beef , its whats for dinner the next time your flying. This happened to real people its not appropriate to mock or joke about this in any form
Why are people hating that these are some english people and that the real incident consisted of people from Uraguay??? This is a MOVIE, not a documentary. It just so happens to be AMERICAs version of the incident. Nothing wrong with that.
listen u eat to live and if u think eating meat is wrong then the next time u eat at mcdonalds think that that was alive once i would eat to live and it is bad acting but good flim
@wafflewaffle90 Well, what was he supposed to tell him? "Yes, you're going to die." In medical school, one learns to instill confidence in one's patient.
It's sad that they did not know that 18 miles from them was a hotel. Even though it would have been very hard to get there plus they would have had to cross a large river.
@LyricalXilence i can't answer the first one. But the second.. my guess is that that rule is only for short term application to keep the person from bleeding to death before they get to a hospital. But once the person gets to a hospital it is removed immediately because the thing can't stay in there. Infection risk is too great. There is no hospital here. You're better dying from bloodletting than infection. I'm guessing this was the rationalization.
When I see something like this, I realize how much mobile phones are important! How many lives would have been saved if they had invented them earlier...
@Paulina86 Even if they had mobile phones they would of been completely usless since they were in a very remote place so there would of been no cell coverage.
I'd hate to imagine what would've happened to everyone had both the medical students died (especially if they were both sucked out of the plane when it broke in half...either that, or if both were killed on impact)
There already was an actual doctor on board, but he died along with his wife (the movie shows both dead underneath the seats)
@narutofan4545 You may say bad acting, but, what? This was real. I am uruguayan, and my father is friend of Nando Parrado, and... I hope you will never have to be in that situation. When the others said that the only escape was to eat human meat, he had to protected the bodies of his mother and sister for not to be eaten, and you say "This is some bad acting"??
@aCRISTOlagloria right. So doesn't that make the bad acting even more disrespectful??? It is bad acting. So? The comments don't take away from the event. But perhaps the bad acting does...
@IDontCare20101000 Oh shit!!!!! Me too lol cuz i didnt know how high up my sound was cuz at the beginning I couldn't hear anything so i tuned it up dammn now my hearts beating
Winter of 1848 a wagon train got trapped on their way to California and Oregon while in the Rocky Mountains. Two men fought over the path to take: Reid, who was pushed out, but promised to send help from San Francisco and Donner, who hired two native scouts who got them further lost.) Months later, in an extremely bad winter, Reid returned with help to find only 1/4 of them alive there. They admitted to canaballism. They were called the Donner Party. It's in the Wikipedia.
AMERICANS!!! PLEASE DON' BE ASHOLESSS!! ........THE URUGUAYANS ARE WHITES ........--- ITS VERY DIFFICULT UNDERSTAND THAT??? WHY DO YOU THINK THE EUROPEAN INMIGRATION ONLY HAPPENED IN UNITED STATES OF AMERICA???.....
@man290288 Sabías que esto le pasó a un grupo de jugadores de rugby uruguayos? Mi padre es amigo de Nando, y sabías que cuando decidieron por comer los cuerpos de los fallecidos, él tuvo que proteger los cuerpos de su madre y su hermana para que no se los comieran? Y vos decís "Esta pelicula es una garcha, yankees putos"??!
@aCRISTOlagloria Creo que el no se refiere a la películo, se refiere a los actores. No actúan con naturalidad, no se metieron en la piel de los que padecieron esta catástrofe... de pronto Ethan Hawke sí, y Josh Hamilton, pero los demás no, sobre todo el que hace de Carlitos joven (Bruce Ramsay). Esta película, con esta historia tan conmovedora, se merecía mejores actores
@gatolocoverga152 I don't think these assholes in the comments section are Americans. More like anti-Americans trying to put the blame on Americans for posing as other nationalities. I think the message you should get across instead is: NOT ALL WHITE PEOPLE ARE AMERICAN.
Alive is a book written by a mountain climber who researched the whole story.... Miracle in the Andes is the book written by Fernando Parrado. He is the guy who actually survived and climbed out of the Andes to rescue the remaining survivors
What you "could of" or "would of" have done is alot easier said than done...Don't judge these ppl for what they had to do to survive Only God can do that& these boys did no wrong....I was born the same yr this really did happend.These ppl are my heros...I will never forget hearing about this story..May all of them R.I.P.for those who didn't survive...
This movie doesn't give the tragedy justice. The acting and the script are insulting to the victims. I hope they redo this movie because it's a story that must be told, just better than this.
Um, this movie does have some great acting and some of the people used accents as was needed. they didnt all have to be tan, since some of the real people had light complexions. This movie isnt trying to impose religion, its just one of the main points of their individual story. say what you want, but these are truly amazing people and their story is very inspirational. saying bad things about it just makes you look dumb, to be honest. why dont we all try to be nice?
@blahface1357 What tans are you talking about, don't you know there was an european inmigration to south america in the past and as a result half or more of the people here are caucasian?
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
Quick question: Why did they all stay in the plane after the crash? I understand that they had to get the people out who were stuck, but I was always told the first thing you do after a crash is get away from the plane cause it could blow up...
@atomicoreo51 This is true about leaving the plane after the crash, but they were stuck in the most severe weather area of the Andes. They would not have survived as long as they did had they wondered off. They did not have the proper attire to sustain the cold.
@atomicoreo51 some of the younger ones did start walking away from the plane, but once they saw carlos valeta fall into a crevass, never to be seen again, and that the plane wasnt smoking up, they went back inside
Some of your comments are really out of line and so disrespectful. Remember that this isn't just a movie, but a true story. You all seem pretty good at judging them for the decisions that they made. They did the best that they could under the circumstances. I could have never played a part in allowing the copilot to take his life. If he knew how to fly a plane they wouldn't have crashed.
It was such an amazing movie. The human spirit is a force to be reckoned with. I saw the movie with my mom when it was in the theater and she said that she never could have survived. You don't know what you would do until you were in a situation like that. It seems impossible though but they did it. It amazes me how they lived out in the snow for ten weeks. The cold would have bothered me much more than the starvation. I can't imagine having to resort to cannibalism. They did what they had to.
This movie is so sick and brutal masterpiece.All though I gotta say I would started walking earlier before half of them died and we had to resort to cannibalism.
@Massimo1GK well said well said, i like the way people getting brave here thinking it was so easy to be in the middle of moitains n walking out of them like its nothing
@Avatar7811 they waited because they had hopes of being rescued and they couldn't walk earlier than the did because of the bad weather. They had to wait for the weather to improve.
@Avatar7811 They couldn't walk earlier because of the bad weather and because they thought they were going to be rescued. They only went walking when there was no other choice.
@Avatar7811 well, they were counting on rescue and the only one who really wanted to walk out was nando. others would think he was being suicidal to climb a mountain, but as time passed, they saw that something had to be done, so they tried everything except climb the mountain. when everything failed, they had to wait the weather out. they had to resort to cannabilism even before walking out was an option.
Laguerra the co-pilot suffered in freezing agony with the plane's instruments buried into his chest for over 30 hours before he died. And all that time - apart from that brief visit about the radio- he was alone. He died alone whilst the others clung together. Whatever else one feels or believes, whatever the circumstances - by me this is a golden rule: no-one should ever be left to die alone.
They left him and yet they wouldnt even let him end his agony - thanks to the Papal bullshit rule
@krakenwave Well, they couldnt stay with him cause they had to stay warm,nor could they move him so they had no choice.Perhaps someone should have checked on him from time to time but thats all they could do.I read the book but cant remember if they found the gun.Even if they had, how could they kill him? If he could have moved his hand they could have let him shoot himself.Seeing as how they ate the dead, would it have been such a crime to put him out of his misery?
They didn't have to "put him out of his misery" but could've given him the gun for "protection"- a pretend-justification like the bodies being a "Eucharist". But they refused to look for the gun because of RC anti suicide. Hate to criticize survivors because they heroes but I read book & remember actual event - & the painful, lonely death of the pilot (added to all his mental anguish of guilt - "We Passed Curico!") was a tragedy made worse by RC superstition- & it haunts me still.
@krakenwave I couldn't be a part of helping someone to kill themselves. The accident was caused by the copilots error. He couldn't see because of the weather and he descended the plane too early. He used what is called dead reckoning. The judge how far you've traveled based on the amount of time you've been in the air, but he didn't take the winds slowing them down into account. He needed to stay up in the air longer before descending.
@krakenwave They didn't let him end his agony not because of the Papal rule. According to Zerbino, Once the rest of the survivors had known that there was a loaded gun in the plane, some of the desperate ones would have preferred to kill themselves rather than fight for survival, especially once they knew the rescuing efforts were abandonned. So Zerbino hid the bullets and Canessa hid the gun. But for the rest of your comment, I agree with you, that they should have stayed with him at least
I cannot blame them for not staying with him - not in their situation
But I feel it should be a moral principle - a rule - that guides feelings and actions - and its a better one than "no mercy killing."
The Piers Paul Read book (1974): he asked for his gun to end his life but Canessa and Zerbino couldn't find it nor would have given it for "as Catholics they could not condone suicide".
I think Zerbino later changed the version of this incident because they felt bad about it.
And "some of the desperate ones would have preferred to kill themselves "? 1)This was the first night after the crash - they knew nothing about rescue attempts. 2) Later they could fire the bullets if they worried. And in no accounts was mentioned suicide. Resigned to their deaths, yes, but not by their own hand. They were religious & suicide was against the groupthink
The Read book "Alive" is IMO the best source - memories were fresh & the guys wanted the truth to be known.
@krakenwave I guess you're right... I'm only citing Zerbino's testimony in the Pablo Vierci book called "La Sociedad de la Nieve", on which the documentary "Stranded" is based. The book was written at the same time cameras were rolling. "On the afternoon of the accident, the pilot requested his gun to kill himself (...) Someone has the revolver and I have the bullets. We told everybody: don't look 4 it, because is not available. There r no bullets to kill yourselves 'coz life's the only option"
@krakenwave If you had done your research you would of realized he was completely trapped and pinned by the wreckage. There was absolutely no way of getting him out whatsoever. I know what your saying and i feel you to a certain extent but it was just one of those things they could not do anything to help him. Thats why he asked for his gun so he could kill himself it was that bad. Im sure if they could of got him out and helped him they would of. These were very good people that did so much...
It's hard to believe anyone would survive the crash! Why were they flying so low, I guess I'll look it up and for those that think the acting is lame there was a movie of this made in the 70's and jmo I thought it better.
They weren't "low" they just went through a normal flight path across the Andes when the weather was crap and then they got confused about when to turn North to descend into Chile Santiago. The plane turned early and hence too low for the huge great mountains still in front of them - they hit some and...here they are
@JACKOTACO I agree. I saw the Alive Documentary on the history channel and man this story is so amazing. The actual survivors had accents. I wonder why they didnt have the actors at least use accents.
Yup, I saw it last night as well. I mean at least make it in Spanish.. It is hard to believe somebody nicknamed Nando(Fernando) and speaks English without an accent.
@ronin29607 Americans are known to do poor accents anyways even English accents xD (though English actors do very well American accents methinks). Anyways this movie is an american movie & it was made for the american audience so the english language would be easier to comprehend, it's understandable. I think it would be the same situation with actors/accents if uruguayans made a movie based on non-native personalities; actors that can do accents are hard to find that you just do away with it.
Jesus is fake. The real religion is of Indigenous culture such of Native Americans and Kiratas of the Himalayas. Native Americans and Kiratas worship mother nature, land and ancestors. Check thevideo ==> "Kirat Temple"
@mamon363 well did you saw him(jesus)?jesus was a bedtime story created by Jews and became a white man religion later. today the white man is trying to impose their religion on others.
this happen in 1972, but if it were to happen today they problably would had been carrying cellphones and use them to call for help, and maybe a laptop to contact friends on facebook or twitter.
@robiking011 you are right, see what happened with the chilean miners, they didn't had all that but once they were found they were provided with everything, even a tv and a special everyday diet!!!
@martineizer1 yes I'm argentinian and white, besides these boys were not exactly poor, most upper and middle-class people in Argentina and Uruguay are white, but in South America overall most people are dark-skinned I think. It's the aboriginal blood.
i enjoyed this movie and i am 13 my family told me what happend in real life and it shocked me words cant explain what they felt but i think my favorite part is when that guy got up and yelled jesus but awesome movie
0:09 scared the crap out of me
Operation781 2 weeks ago
@bmillerdrums yeah I heard that before. They DID change a lot of the names and even killed of survivors (in the movie) who actually survived (in reality). SOme characters didnt even make the cut in the movie. Still though, this is the best version of this story. I really dont get how people say it's bad. It's ridiculous. Inaccurate is not the same thing as bad.
shad0wMata 1 month ago
Bad acting....like any of the people saying can do any better. BTW A lot of these people (PERSONS BASED UPON) suffered the shock of the crash, therefore they barely reacted to the situation at first (Example Bobby Francois smoking casually near the crash site RIGHT AFTER they crashed, Pablo Montero asking if he was in any danger when CLEARLY he had a metal piece driven straight thru him, the mechanic's hostile behavior) The situation is bad enough to put ANYONE in diff. types of distress.
shad0wMata 1 month ago
@shad0wMata Pablo Montero was actually Enrique Platero in the real story. I assume family members didnt want the real names of the victims to be in the movie it would be too difficult. Like Felipe who was sitting next to Nando was Panchito Abal. But there was a boy named Felipe Marriqurian{wrong spelling} who died the next day so its strange how the names are some what accurate yet also not accurate in terms of the story to the movie. This happens throughout the movie.
bmillerdrums 1 month ago
@bmillerdrums Antonio is Marcelo & Misters Alfonsin is Misters Mariani
yugoxixe2 4 days ago
Dam, when he said "JESUS", I thought he was Jesus and he was just letting everyone know he was there
ELconchesumare 2 months ago
Bad acting but good film
AmericanRattlesnake 2 months ago
ommmg! i hoppe this to no one, even to my enemis, this is so sad :( R.I.P victime of this plane crash, may god bless y'all
queenJonas1 2 months ago
beef, its whats for dinner?
Exentine 2 months ago
@Exentine Not funny. This is very serious. Say beef , its whats for dinner the next time your flying. This happened to real people its not appropriate to mock or joke about this in any form
bmillerdrums 1 month ago
Why are people hating that these are some english people and that the real incident consisted of people from Uraguay??? This is a MOVIE, not a documentary. It just so happens to be AMERICAs version of the incident. Nothing wrong with that.
toonman81 2 months ago
all i could tink of when they gave him the snow was nooo bear grills says noo let it melt
cocomango5189 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
AWH man I hate that! I was so concentrated on what was going on that at 0:08 that guy scared the fuck outta me!!
MiCHAELJLYSSAPAC 3 months ago
Comment removed
MiCHAELJLYSSAPAC 3 months ago
Comment removed
MiCHAELJLYSSAPAC 3 months ago
4m Don't worry about it.You got a new limb growing out you'r midsection. I guess they could of left it their to eat later
bledoutrain 3 months ago
pilot: water
606JC 3 months ago
11 likes loves Titanic
naniniish 3 months ago
okay i know this movie is from the early 90s but cmon i mean a guy has a fucking pipe carved into his stomach and he is fine??
aerofores 4 months ago
@aerofores Well, this really happened so it must've been like that !
VelvetViolator 3 months ago
listen u eat to live and if u think eating meat is wrong then the next time u eat at mcdonalds think that that was alive once i would eat to live and it is bad acting but good flim
KingSamsonXL 4 months ago
PABLO: is it serious?
ME: damn straight its freaking serious! you have a PIPE in your ABDOMEN.
wafflewaffle90 4 months ago
@wafflewaffle90 Well, what was he supposed to tell him? "Yes, you're going to die." In medical school, one learns to instill confidence in one's patient.
GIROBOTII 3 days ago
It's sad that they did not know that 18 miles from them was a hotel. Even though it would have been very hard to get there plus they would have had to cross a large river.
SolarisDeLuna 4 months ago
Comment removed
SolarisDeLuna 4 months ago
What a lovely, happy film
travelstella 4 months ago
um....hot guys.
MrCouchTuber 5 months ago
And I'm surprised none of them are really crying after the crash O.O I'd be sobbing if I saw that many of my friends dead
artmusicplz 5 months ago 2
@artmusicplz Shock?
hockey6467 5 months ago in playlist More videos from Massimo1GK
@hockey6467 i guess so. But even afterward they had pretty straight faces :X
artmusicplz 5 months ago
am I the only one who thought of spongebob when that lady said "MY LEG!" at 2:24?
artmusicplz 5 months ago
Just a few questions, sorry if they have been asked already.
1. How in the heck did that ladies legs get in such a position where metal is literally wrapped around them?
2. Wasn't it a bad idea for the metal to be pulled out of that one survivors abdomen? Was leaving the object in not common practice in the early 70s?
LyricalXilence 5 months ago
@LyricalXilence i can't answer the first one. But the second.. my guess is that that rule is only for short term application to keep the person from bleeding to death before they get to a hospital. But once the person gets to a hospital it is removed immediately because the thing can't stay in there. Infection risk is too great. There is no hospital here. You're better dying from bloodletting than infection. I'm guessing this was the rationalization.
groovylocks 4 months ago
When I see something like this, I realize how much mobile phones are important! How many lives would have been saved if they had invented them earlier...
Paulina86 5 months ago
@Paulina86 Even if they had mobile phones they would of been completely usless since they were in a very remote place so there would of been no cell coverage.
SolarisDeLuna 4 months ago 4
Oh my God i rather die than to suffer like the Pilot's situation! :(
unikka26 7 months ago
I'd hate to imagine what would've happened to everyone had both the medical students died (especially if they were both sucked out of the plane when it broke in half...either that, or if both were killed on impact)
There already was an actual doctor on board, but he died along with his wife (the movie shows both dead underneath the seats)
HA1290 7 months ago
@HA1290 Oops sorry, they weren't underneath seats...they were underneath suitcases @ 2:03
HA1290 7 months ago
this is the team rugby from uruguay !!!!
don't forget !
SirTaichi 7 months ago
couldnt they just weld the plane back together? the wings and engines were in one piece. then take off
TheDEATHSTARIII 7 months ago
@TheDEATHSTARIII That is honestly one of the stupidest comments I have read.
0lozi0 7 months ago 3
@0lozi0 it was supposed to be
TheDEATHSTARIII 7 months ago
This is some bad acting
narutofan4545 8 months ago 3
@narutofan4545 You may say bad acting, but, what? This was real. I am uruguayan, and my father is friend of Nando Parrado, and... I hope you will never have to be in that situation. When the others said that the only escape was to eat human meat, he had to protected the bodies of his mother and sister for not to be eaten, and you say "This is some bad acting"??
aCRISTOlagloria 8 months ago 18
@aCRISTOlagloria I know this happend but the actors in the movie arent the best
narutofan4545 8 months ago
@aCRISTOlagloria right. So doesn't that make the bad acting even more disrespectful??? It is bad acting. So? The comments don't take away from the event. But perhaps the bad acting does...
groovylocks 4 months ago
I jumped 10 feet in the air when the boy got up and yelled JESUS! lol.scared me too death!
IDontCare20101000 8 months ago 16
@IDontCare20101000 Oh shit!!!!! Me too lol cuz i didnt know how high up my sound was cuz at the beginning I couldn't hear anything so i tuned it up dammn now my hearts beating
oscarhood10 4 months ago
@IDontCare20101000
he looks like phil hellmuth by the way LOL!
123Nikodemus 2 months ago
Esta pelicula es una garcha
man290288 9 months ago
Winter of 1848 a wagon train got trapped on their way to California and Oregon while in the Rocky Mountains. Two men fought over the path to take: Reid, who was pushed out, but promised to send help from San Francisco and Donner, who hired two native scouts who got them further lost.) Months later, in an extremely bad winter, Reid returned with help to find only 1/4 of them alive there. They admitted to canaballism. They were called the Donner Party. It's in the Wikipedia.
wingseclipsed 9 months ago 4
AMERICANS!!! PLEASE DON' BE ASHOLESSS!! ........THE URUGUAYANS ARE WHITES ........--- ITS VERY DIFFICULT UNDERSTAND THAT??? WHY DO YOU THINK THE EUROPEAN INMIGRATION ONLY HAPPENED IN UNITED STATES OF AMERICA???.....
gatolocoverga152 9 months ago 6
Comment removed
man290288 9 months ago
@man290288 Sabías que esto le pasó a un grupo de jugadores de rugby uruguayos? Mi padre es amigo de Nando, y sabías que cuando decidieron por comer los cuerpos de los fallecidos, él tuvo que proteger los cuerpos de su madre y su hermana para que no se los comieran? Y vos decís "Esta pelicula es una garcha, yankees putos"??!
aCRISTOlagloria 8 months ago
@aCRISTOlagloria Creo que el no se refiere a la películo, se refiere a los actores. No actúan con naturalidad, no se metieron en la piel de los que padecieron esta catástrofe... de pronto Ethan Hawke sí, y Josh Hamilton, pero los demás no, sobre todo el que hace de Carlitos joven (Bruce Ramsay). Esta película, con esta historia tan conmovedora, se merecía mejores actores
heymissdeejay 6 months ago
@gatolocoverga152 I don't think these assholes in the comments section are Americans. More like anti-Americans trying to put the blame on Americans for posing as other nationalities. I think the message you should get across instead is: NOT ALL WHITE PEOPLE ARE AMERICAN.
NeoSoftwarePWNXORZ 8 months ago
May I know the tittle of the book. i want to read it
vividrainbow84 10 months ago
Alive is a book written by a mountain climber who researched the whole story.... Miracle in the Andes is the book written by Fernando Parrado. He is the guy who actually survived and climbed out of the Andes to rescue the remaining survivors
simmer357 10 months ago
THIS MOVie has haunted me since my childhood
foldedintobeauty3 10 months ago
JESUS!
sparkyinbath 11 months ago
this movie is raw and real! My goodness! I just said 4 prayers thanking God for my life! RIP the those lives lost from this plane crash!
pamperedgurl 11 months ago 4
@pamperedgurl yeah ok we get it, can u shutup now and stop yelling
chessinfantry 10 months ago
@chessinfantry someone is bitter....
pamperedgurl 10 months ago
@pamperedgurl yeah, ur moms pussy tasted bitter last night
chessinfantry 9 months ago
What you "could of" or "would of" have done is alot easier said than done...Don't judge these ppl for what they had to do to survive Only God can do that& these boys did no wrong....I was born the same yr this really did happend.These ppl are my heros...I will never forget hearing about this story..May all of them R.I.P.for those who didn't survive...
kiowaangeleyes 11 months ago
I swear the guy at 0:08 looks like messi's twin lol
FGaribay7 11 months ago
This movie doesn't give the tragedy justice. The acting and the script are insulting to the victims. I hope they redo this movie because it's a story that must be told, just better than this.
hoofreak7 11 months ago
uhmmmm,
they didnt seem all that upset that there friends died..
kaseyandjackie 1 year ago
Um, this movie does have some great acting and some of the people used accents as was needed. they didnt all have to be tan, since some of the real people had light complexions. This movie isnt trying to impose religion, its just one of the main points of their individual story. say what you want, but these are truly amazing people and their story is very inspirational. saying bad things about it just makes you look dumb, to be honest. why dont we all try to be nice?
blahface1357 1 year ago
@blahface1357 What tans are you talking about, don't you know there was an european inmigration to south america in the past and as a result half or more of the people here are caucasian?
Fucklesticks 10 months ago
@Fucklesticks i meant that some people were expecting them all to be tan and complained when they werent. i knew some were caucasian.
blahface1357 10 months ago
nice
orestes2051992 1 year ago
why is the audio so low :l
jennyarcon 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
PinkAmy25 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
PinkAmy25 1 year ago
I would definitely recommend the book. Although it is a lot better as it goes into a lot more detail, this film is very accurate to how the book is written. A fantastic film, thankyou so much for putting it on You Tube
PinkAmy25 1 year ago
8:14 you can clearly see there not cold as bad as they are outside
they should sleep inside the plain with the blankets they made.
GeneB1992 1 year ago
Pilot loos like steve railsback.
GeneB1992 1 year ago
Quick question: Why did they all stay in the plane after the crash? I understand that they had to get the people out who were stuck, but I was always told the first thing you do after a crash is get away from the plane cause it could blow up...
atomicoreo51 1 year ago
@atomicoreo51 This is true about leaving the plane after the crash, but they were stuck in the most severe weather area of the Andes. They would not have survived as long as they did had they wondered off. They did not have the proper attire to sustain the cold.
qokoon 1 year ago
@atomicoreo51 some of the younger ones did start walking away from the plane, but once they saw carlos valeta fall into a crevass, never to be seen again, and that the plane wasnt smoking up, they went back inside
blahface1357 1 year ago
canessa had feelings for suzanna??
christine10121997 1 year ago
What gets me? The pilot was exposed to the snow just as long as the passengers, but why does he already have frost on his face ?
codysmith80 1 year ago
@codysmith80 maybe because the pilot area was stucked already in a snowy area as u can see how high the snow are already ..
jennyarcon 1 year ago
these people are evil, sinful vampies. . .
outlawscumfuck667 1 year ago
@outlawscumfuck667 No. They did what they did to survive under appalling circumstances.
oisinparis 1 year ago
1969 is the year of the pig.
outlawscumfuck667 1 year ago
@outlawscumfuck667 nice screen name by the way, it says a lot about you. 1969 is also the year that man walked on the moon.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
Some of your comments are really out of line and so disrespectful. Remember that this isn't just a movie, but a true story. You all seem pretty good at judging them for the decisions that they made. They did the best that they could under the circumstances. I could have never played a part in allowing the copilot to take his life. If he knew how to fly a plane they wouldn't have crashed.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
It was such an amazing movie. The human spirit is a force to be reckoned with. I saw the movie with my mom when it was in the theater and she said that she never could have survived. You don't know what you would do until you were in a situation like that. It seems impossible though but they did it. It amazes me how they lived out in the snow for ten weeks. The cold would have bothered me much more than the starvation. I can't imagine having to resort to cannibalism. They did what they had to.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago 2
Great movie, and i fell with the persons.
wUPZIzOR 1 year ago
Simpsons did it best:
Man 1: No thanks to the plane, many of us are still...
Everyone: Alive! Man 2: [through full mouth] We certainly are. [chews] Man 3: Pass me another hunk of copilot.
ronpaulbot 1 year ago
Simpsons did it best:
Man 1: No thanks to the plane, many of us are still...
Everyone: Alive! Man 2: [through full mouth] We certainly are. [chews] Man 3: Pass me another hunk of copilot.
ronpaulbot 1 year ago
These fools got exactly what they deserved. I'm a genius.
outlawscumfuck667 1 year ago
@outlawscumfuck667 you're a jackass, not a genius.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
JEZUS!!!!!!!!
takujings11 1 year ago
0:21 dat guy always die in every movie
SOyouTHINKurFUNNY 1 year ago
This movie is so sick and brutal masterpiece.All though I gotta say I would started walking earlier before half of them died and we had to resort to cannibalism.
Avatar7811 1 year ago
@Avatar7811 you wouldn't,you would have waited for the rescue like they did and every other sane human being would have done.
Massimo1GK 1 year ago 35
@Massimo1GK well said well said, i like the way people getting brave here thinking it was so easy to be in the middle of moitains n walking out of them like its nothing
born2ball1991 1 year ago
@Massimo1GK
I agree, because waiting for rescue usually has higher survival rate.
iamyourteddybear 11 months ago
@Massimo1GK unless you are the guys from Dual Survival
Jetkillr 7 months ago
@Avatar7811 they waited because they had hopes of being rescued and they couldn't walk earlier than the did because of the bad weather. They had to wait for the weather to improve.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
@nikkidanielle1969 it was because it was the winter
darkski11ed 1 year ago
@Avatar7811 They couldn't walk earlier because of the bad weather and because they thought they were going to be rescued. They only went walking when there was no other choice.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
@Avatar7811 fat ass!
scrambledpenis 1 year ago
@Avatar7811 well, they were counting on rescue and the only one who really wanted to walk out was nando. others would think he was being suicidal to climb a mountain, but as time passed, they saw that something had to be done, so they tried everything except climb the mountain. when everything failed, they had to wait the weather out. they had to resort to cannabilism even before walking out was an option.
blahface1357 1 year ago
@Avatar7811 I would of joined those two and smoked and drank some wine...if the crash didn't kill me or take off a leg
treveroo87 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Avatar7811 I would of joined those two and smoked and drank some wine...if the crash didn't kill me or take off a leg
treveroo87 11 months ago
@Avatar7811 plus a lot of them had broken legs, or wounded legs,. what are they just gonna leave them there to die?
TheStraightboy 11 months ago
@Avatar7811 it was too cold, you stupid fuck. How are you going to walk out when you would die on the first night?
tittyj2020 9 months ago
@Avatar7811 It's not cannibalism .... a canibal is a person who kills to eat.
Tamive 5 months ago
Laguerra the co-pilot suffered in freezing agony with the plane's instruments buried into his chest for over 30 hours before he died. And all that time - apart from that brief visit about the radio- he was alone. He died alone whilst the others clung together. Whatever else one feels or believes, whatever the circumstances - by me this is a golden rule: no-one should ever be left to die alone.
They left him and yet they wouldnt even let him end his agony - thanks to the Papal bullshit rule
krakenwave 1 year ago 9
@krakenwave Well, they couldnt stay with him cause they had to stay warm,nor could they move him so they had no choice.Perhaps someone should have checked on him from time to time but thats all they could do.I read the book but cant remember if they found the gun.Even if they had, how could they kill him? If he could have moved his hand they could have let him shoot himself.Seeing as how they ate the dead, would it have been such a crime to put him out of his misery?
Tempe1962 1 year ago
@Tempe1962
They didn't have to "put him out of his misery" but could've given him the gun for "protection"- a pretend-justification like the bodies being a "Eucharist". But they refused to look for the gun because of RC anti suicide. Hate to criticize survivors because they heroes but I read book & remember actual event - & the painful, lonely death of the pilot (added to all his mental anguish of guilt - "We Passed Curico!") was a tragedy made worse by RC superstition- & it haunts me still.
krakenwave 1 year ago
@krakenwave They could only give him the gun if they had it. I dont think it was found.
Tempe1962 1 year ago
@Tempe1962 they wouldn't do it because they were Roman Catholics and mercy killing is against their religion.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
@Tempe1962 I know that.My point is I dont think they found the gun so its rather pointless to bring up what they would have done.
Tempe1962 1 year ago
@krakenwave I couldn't be a part of helping someone to kill themselves. The accident was caused by the copilots error. He couldn't see because of the weather and he descended the plane too early. He used what is called dead reckoning. The judge how far you've traveled based on the amount of time you've been in the air, but he didn't take the winds slowing them down into account. He needed to stay up in the air longer before descending.
nikkidanielle1969 1 year ago
@krakenwave They didn't let him end his agony not because of the Papal rule. According to Zerbino, Once the rest of the survivors had known that there was a loaded gun in the plane, some of the desperate ones would have preferred to kill themselves rather than fight for survival, especially once they knew the rescuing efforts were abandonned. So Zerbino hid the bullets and Canessa hid the gun. But for the rest of your comment, I agree with you, that they should have stayed with him at least
heymissdeejay 6 months ago
@heymissdeejay
I cannot blame them for not staying with him - not in their situation
But I feel it should be a moral principle - a rule - that guides feelings and actions - and its a better one than "no mercy killing."
The Piers Paul Read book (1974): he asked for his gun to end his life but Canessa and Zerbino couldn't find it nor would have given it for "as Catholics they could not condone suicide".
I think Zerbino later changed the version of this incident because they felt bad about it.
krakenwave 6 months ago
@heymissdeejay
And "some of the desperate ones would have preferred to kill themselves "? 1)This was the first night after the crash - they knew nothing about rescue attempts. 2) Later they could fire the bullets if they worried. And in no accounts was mentioned suicide. Resigned to their deaths, yes, but not by their own hand. They were religious & suicide was against the groupthink
The Read book "Alive" is IMO the best source - memories were fresh & the guys wanted the truth to be known.
krakenwave 6 months ago
@krakenwave I guess you're right... I'm only citing Zerbino's testimony in the Pablo Vierci book called "La Sociedad de la Nieve", on which the documentary "Stranded" is based. The book was written at the same time cameras were rolling. "On the afternoon of the accident, the pilot requested his gun to kill himself (...) Someone has the revolver and I have the bullets. We told everybody: don't look 4 it, because is not available. There r no bullets to kill yourselves 'coz life's the only option"
heymissdeejay 6 months ago
@krakenwave If you had done your research you would of realized he was completely trapped and pinned by the wreckage. There was absolutely no way of getting him out whatsoever. I know what your saying and i feel you to a certain extent but it was just one of those things they could not do anything to help him. Thats why he asked for his gun so he could kill himself it was that bad. Im sure if they could of got him out and helped him they would of. These were very good people that did so much...
bmillerdrums 5 months ago 3
It's hard to believe anyone would survive the crash! Why were they flying so low, I guess I'll look it up and for those that think the acting is lame there was a movie of this made in the 70's and jmo I thought it better.
msjosephine2 1 year ago
@msjosephine2
They weren't "low" they just went through a normal flight path across the Andes when the weather was crap and then they got confused about when to turn North to descend into Chile Santiago. The plane turned early and hence too low for the huge great mountains still in front of them - they hit some and...here they are
krakenwave 1 year ago
@krakenwave I understand bad weather but I hope I'm never on a fight were the pilot gets confused
msjosephine2 1 year ago
The acting is atrocious.
mharrin5507 1 year ago
damn, 10 minutes in the cold and he turns into an insane toddler
longfootbuddy 1 year ago
lol i love this movie but the acting is just so lame
MrKartoon18 1 year ago
@MrKartoon18 in real life, the acting is just as lame..
Uuuurk 1 year ago
@MrKartoon18 well wf would you react like in this sitsuation?
chorley250894 1 year ago
JESUS!!!!!!
crezzymonkey 1 year ago
wow...do you really need to use the word F***OT with such a sensitive matter on the screen. jeeze.
xviciousxrottenx 1 year ago
I can't see how this part is violent, the most violent part so far is when they crash and when the poor fella fly into the wall.
MannenQ18plus 1 year ago 2
they were inexplicably lucky to land that way in the midst of the rocks!!!
MoveOverCasanova 1 year ago
roberto canessa is like bad ass
olg06 1 year ago
what moron flagged this?;S
Nonchelanteful 1 year ago 4
@Nonchelanteful one who was born with a cell phone in the cradle))
MoveOverCasanova 1 year ago
i saw the documentary on the history channel and i never felt this emotional like EVER! i even cried.
mhector3500 1 year ago 15
The acting is quite poor in this movie. They should redo it, because it is such an amazing story.
JACKOTACO 1 year ago
@JACKOTACO I agree. I saw the Alive Documentary on the history channel and man this story is so amazing. The actual survivors had accents. I wonder why they didnt have the actors at least use accents.
ronin29607 1 year ago
@ronin29607
Yup, I saw it last night as well. I mean at least make it in Spanish.. It is hard to believe somebody nicknamed Nando(Fernando) and speaks English without an accent.
JACKOTACO 1 year ago
@ronin29607 Americans are known to do poor accents anyways even English accents xD (though English actors do very well American accents methinks). Anyways this movie is an american movie & it was made for the american audience so the english language would be easier to comprehend, it's understandable. I think it would be the same situation with actors/accents if uruguayans made a movie based on non-native personalities; actors that can do accents are hard to find that you just do away with it.
olg06 1 year ago
hmm...this movie had a lot more potential, the acting its just not that great, but still it's a true story and its still great
superaweosome91 1 year ago
Yall ever seen my tevo alternative to this year book
Allenburn 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jesus is fake. The real religion is of Indigenous culture such of Native Americans and Kiratas of the Himalayas. Native Americans and Kiratas worship mother nature, land and ancestors. Check thevideo ==> "Kirat Temple"
and
"Sakela~ the Greatest festival of Kirat people"
diliprai 1 year ago
@diliprai jesus is real!!!!!!
mamon363 1 year ago
@mamon363 well did you saw him(jesus)?jesus was a bedtime story created by Jews and became a white man religion later. today the white man is trying to impose their religion on others.
diliprai 1 year ago
JESUS!
onassi2 1 year ago
jesus!!!!!!
MyAgia 1 year ago
jesus!!!!!!
MyAgia 1 year ago
0:10
Never seems to make me stop laughing
XxDarkVailxX 1 year ago
To the cast and crew of this great depiction/movie....KUDOS!! ! !! great acting
stephen1622 1 year ago
such a terrible reenactment, like people would be that calm after people were ripped out of a plane and all that. fuck
macaframa12 1 year ago
@macaframa12 Hey I just crashed in the Andes LOL CALL HELP KTHXBAI
cyclist14 1 year ago
One of those guys looks like Lionel Messi.
offerp84 1 year ago 3
this happen in 1972, but if it were to happen today they problably would had been carrying cellphones and use them to call for help, and maybe a laptop to contact friends on facebook or twitter.
robiking011 1 year ago 3
@robiking011 you are right, see what happened with the chilean miners, they didn't had all that but once they were found they were provided with everything, even a tv and a special everyday diet!!!
caporacinguista 1 year ago
Comment removed
robiking011 1 year ago
Im confused.. so which is safer? the front or the back of the plane?
minq 1 year ago
@minq the middle
mamon363 1 year ago
planes should have blow bags for the pilots ^^
webaward 1 year ago
Hey I talked with Roberto yesterday...
Believe it or not he came to my school and gave a seminar and the movie is dead on to what he told us....
And for the record he was very white, and whoever is as ignorant as to think south Americans are brown are plain racist and prejudiced
martineizer1 1 year ago 4
@martineizer1 yes I'm argentinian and white, besides these boys were not exactly poor, most upper and middle-class people in Argentina and Uruguay are white, but in South America overall most people are dark-skinned I think. It's the aboriginal blood.
caporacinguista 1 year ago
LMFAO ! The Mechanic is funny as fuck . xD
FourteenOnly 1 year ago 3
Lol these actors are awfully freakin' calm considering what just happened lol
goyanks1302 1 year ago
@goyanks1302 i was thinking he exact same thing.
CheeseIsHxC 1 year ago
i enjoyed this movie and i am 13 my family told me what happend in real life and it shocked me words cant explain what they felt but i think my favorite part is when that guy got up and yelled jesus but awesome movie
MrGameman87 1 year ago