Added: 4 years ago
From: celtic426
Views: 208,479
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (407)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • El wrongo sir

  • Good job

  • be a pianist or not be? this is the shit

  • fuck... I made a song just like this and thought I was a freaking genius... now all is lost since it has already been made... and better :(

  • Oh....my....god... That's awsome!

  • your good, but just play the fucking song.. stop doing all ur random shit that isnt in the song

  • marry me and then teach me to play the piano then we'll get divorced and i'll take the piano with me (: and yea kgreat

  • fuckin idiot thats not like that, with right hand strting is just la and do no parece nada pinche ibmecil bo sabes tocar

  • Your shit and your improvisation is bollocks

  • Heard A flute in the backgroud :D

  • no mames we eso no se parese en nada pinchi bato tonto!!

  • maybe we should see this as a kind of own interpretation, a bit different of the original

    thats what real componists do, get away from the original, put own limits, no rules

    what is more beautiful than a free mind ? ;)

  • @MrGeneralHack  a beautiful woman of course

  • WTF?O-O

    

  • his playing is so wrong this video should be banned.

  • @vengadorsky Well if you know so much about how to play this song then...? why are u here

  • ta que âge ?

  • The piano is out of tune. :/

  • its wrong.. it goes ac ac ac not ace

  • jemand sollte das kla4 stimmen.... ziemlich verstimmt...

  • very very nice. do you speak german?

    

  • you are a brother's malcom 

  • Hey man tht is really cool but about half of it was the actual music... What u made up sounds really cool tho but it's nothing like wats in the soundtrack

  • hey good job!!!

    subscribe back plz!!!!

  • dude that was dirty

  • i like your version better

  • That's not right...

    Also, you piano is in desperate need of a tuning.

  • @cochra27 i agree. its not right.

  • che gasato fffiga

  • Comment removed

  • Stupid!!!!

  • Please do not watch this. It is wrong. I do appreciate you tried though.

  • fantastic

  • wow your piano looks so clean!!

  • This is wrong, it's the other way around. E-A-C-A, although, there's much more too it. Right chords though :) very nice song

  • even though this is good....its not exacly the right way...i'll make a tutorial to show u exacly how. however good job :)

  • Talented you are. Keep it up. I wish I could play like that, but after years of construction, I do not think I can be taught something as gentle as the piano. Love the magic it produces in someone with talent's hands though. Cheers...

  • YOU MORON :L at begging it says Am (A-C-E) And ur playing A-E-C :L

  • You poor faggets trying to troll him as if u could play better than him THAN POST A FUCKING VIDEO RESPONSE! if i had a camera i would. So shut the fuck up.

  • Don't call your nerdy self-expression a tutorial!

  • @adriezee STOP HATIN ASSEHOLE CAN U DO THAT

  • whatever to these people. youre uhmayzyng!

  • Not good.

  • @SlappyHours82 this is great

  • wow tune that fuckin thing

  • i think its cool that he makes his own version, the chords are pretty simple and so is a minor..

  • dfgasg

  • you are all fucking stupid. this is a great version of the original. its his own version and still it sounds awesome. i bet none of you fucks can do this as good as he did. so fuck off. =]

  • Sounds like being stabbed - that piano is horrible and so are you - the reverberation of that piano sounds nothing like the original -- it also sounds out of tune or ur playing it incorrectly

  • what is this?? a tutorial or a show-off conference??

  • @macmac031680 he did show us part of it but then he wanted to play some and it was great

  • AWESOME....made it easy for me...thanks!

  • WRONG

  • wonderful cover at the end, stunning

  • douche

  • wow.. this sucks big time...

  • Yeah this isn't right at all. Some of the notes are right (or at least in the right key), but this still isn't the right song.

  • sorry but its completely wrong

  • this song sounds alot like the meadow from new moon

  • Что-то не очень похоже.

  • Dont forget the emphasis on some notes.....

  • @DuranXL

    1:47 lol

    camera goes crazy.

    I hope theres not a unperceptive critic out there that cant see hes clearly having fun with this song.

    great job

  • Damn,, u can play, and it sound good!! (thumbs up)

  • es incorrecto sin embargo suena genial ^^

  • genau

    tu mal die seite mit noten oder so ich will das auch hinbekommen zu spielen

  • Very nice tutorial, thanks, I learned it all

  • sounds like a fuckin circus...

  • not saying it sounds bad but it kinda does in the begining lol.................thanx for taking your time to making this video thanx!!! ur awesome

  • das war ja mal nichts, schau in die noten ;)

  • wo kriegt man die denn?

  • meistens muss man die kaufen, ich lese nur links mit 7€ und so. wenn du was gefunden hast würd mich über n link freun

  • Are you foreing? Your piano sounds as weird as shit!!

  • out of tune, or the video sound quality is to low

  • que mierda es esto?

  • I'm a working jazzguitarist, and I say to you:

    learn the chordpattern. then the scales that go with em.

    if you want to learn how to sightread,

    very good, but keep in mind that without further knowledge of music, no stage will accept you, for jazzmusicians will beat you to death with your own arrangement. (musically speaking).

    please learn music instead of copying it. carly's emotions towards the piece are not your own. you're free to add those, and that, my friends, is playing a piece right.

  • This is 100% incorrect. I have the sheet music. Search for another video.

  • not 100% correct, i have the sheets too, its like 90-95% ok.. if you know how to read a music sheet ;)

  • where did you get sheet music for this?

  • Thank you for the first and only intelligent tutorial for this song on youtube. I hate waching tutorials that look like they're aimed at audiences with about 4 hrs of piano experience.

  • @gators12707 hell yeah xD you mean something like those two-part 10 min tutorials for left and right hand, right?

  • @gators12707 This is just fooling around and NOT a tutorial....it's cover of the song and just of the beginning..... this doesn't help me....

  • parkinson ?

  • There's only two notes in the right hand, and generally 2 notes in the left hand. Changes when you get out of the repeat zone in the first bit.

    Overall, I'd just get the sheet music.

  • THANK U THAT TUTORIAL WAZ AWSOME

  • Although the improvising was excellent the notes you play with your right handare wrong. The order is wrong n you can tell by listening to the original n the yours...wrong!

  • if you dont lke this video, then watch my video. If u like this vid, good luck learning!

  • 1. Your piano is out of tune

    2. Why this improshit? The original song sounds better.

    3. That's not a tutorial, that's show...

  • Comment removed

  • @snake018joe- He did a chord progression you idiot. And if you want to consider yourself an accomplished pianist that should be enough for you to decipher the song for yourself. There are some of us who actually want to learn the progressions to improve our own repertoire, and don't appreciate people like you flaming on our vids :)

  • Comment removed

  • you are so good, i would love to play like you

  • Lol, stop posting "thats wrong" and do it better.

  • wrong wrong wrong

  • if its wrong could u please make right one?

  • this is totally wrong

  • well obviously its "wrong", its called IMPROVISING. while its not exactly like the original, it still sounds awsome. so yes technically it is wrong, but not in a bad way. Don't criticize him just because he didn't play it like the original.

  • I wish I had your talent.. it's beautiful.

  • incorrect!!

  • Good improvising. I like your style. :D Keep it up.

  • dude theres no e note in the beggining its just A and C note

  • dats wrong !!!

  • muy buena tema amigo

  • pon algo bueno hijo de perra no tus babosadas son of beash bish

  • el hijo de perra eres tu MMG ese es un buen tema que tu vas a saber de sonidos

  • actually it was pretty good twist you out to it

  • close...but not the correct notes

  • i've really liked the jam you've made! great!

  • thanks!!

  • maybe if u played it slower it may help at the start

  • Nice but not the real song... and therefore no tutorial at all.

  • this is sikk..ur really good....

  • Wooooooooo thankssss

  • nice tutorial, thx mate ;)

  • this is really good but since im like a newbie at it can you do one just a little slower cuz i cant really catch it but cudos on the song cuz u play really well.

  • Piano is out of tune.

  • -_- I find this idiotic criticisers such assholes, I mean like seriously unless you can even bother to take out your time to make tutorial videos for songs, then fuck off.

    THIS IS A TUTORIAL, just appreciate it. If you're here to talk like you're some piano professionals then go prove to us something. You want this song done emotionally? Go search somewhere else.

    Thanks Celtic :)

  • 1. you are stupid

    that is all

  • well you are mean!

  • sorry, but that IS stupid..

    nevertheless, did it work? ;-)

  • 4:25 sounds a bit awful

  • dude u have the same piano as me

    mines shitty like urs and always goes out of tune

  • Great tutorial very clear and easy to follow, thanx!

  • i love the way he plays...

    i wish he could teach me:/

    i see emotion.

  • Tune your piano please...

  • I'm sorry to say this, but you don't play with any emotion at all...

  • he's not trying to perform it with emotion he's trying to teach it with clarity. (I'm sorry to say!)

  • even when your teaching you should have pasion

  • not important when you're just trying to teach the correct notes really

  • actually ur playing it wrong, see 2:22 and compare it to the real song

  • if u had audio of your voice saying the keys that would be helpful

  • just great

  • never heard the song but like it , all the people that say its 'wrong' and 'its your version', well its his version, i play piano and when i play a piece i often put my own bit in it, its his version so give the guy some credit....AWSOME , i loved it

  • vailiant effort but it sucks bro

  • may rktm

  • your like stabbing the piano with your finger, just say NOT ACCURATE on the name because its basically your own way of playing it

  • read the video description

  • Thats so fucking wrong WTF but nice try its a,c not a,c,e only 2 listen to the song

  • wrong notes

  • nice

  • Very well played.

  • Comment removed

  • You should consider hand modeling

  • I love how you play with the scales :)

  • Sounds real good man, thanks for the notes

  • i bet half of us here just want to learn this song cuz it was on the nba comercials comon dont lie you know

  • I actually did learn it from the NBA commercials. LA Lakers!!!! Yeaahhh Lakers fan and I'm not a loser that lives in Boston and roots for the Lakers I live in fucking LA like all the Lakers fans!!!

  • I do not watch basketball. I listen to music.

  • Not the better version more like the real but still inaccurate version.

  • wow... tune your piano

  • Its sounds terrible with these notes. How about uploading a tutorial thats in the right key instead of misleading a lot of people who watched this vid

  • his piano is just a little untuned noob

  • Love this song !!!

  • bad!

    wrongggg notes

    fail

    DO NOT WATCH THISSSS

  • I made a full tutorial on this song. Look in my profile. Enjoy! :)

  • hahahaa worst shit i ever have seen lol!!!!!!

  • hahahahahahaha

  • Why are all these replies receiving thumbs down?? It's the truth.

  • you obviously did this by ear or something, this is nothing like the song haha you suck...

  • ok i guess

    but isnt it supposed to be one octave lower?

  • beastin

  • im afraid you've played it wrong, check the sheet music

  • I love this song...

  • Wow.  You are a prodigy my friend. A little to complex for my blood.

  • Whaaaaa????? Is this the end part?? Cause this is not the beginning party for sure.

  • Damn! Its a lotta HATERS out there! It may not have been the original but sound good enough. Bringing down other people makes some people feel better I guess.

  • he took out the other hand people, that's why it just sounds like this...

  • Hmm... not that impressive at all. A young amateur at best. Your rushing it, and aren't playing the right notes. If your gunna make a tutorial about a piece, dont add your own stuff. Say 'Everyday" improv or something.

  • Wow, I love where you took the original. How nicely you play around with it. Beautiful. 5 stars.