@mrChasenMONEY is that some sort of sick joke? ian curtis was dead before brandon flowers was even born..who do you think originally wrote it sherlock?
though I can see why fans of the original dislike it because they totally transformed the song (I think they pulled it off ) but The Killers even said so themselves, they said it sounded more like New Order than JD :-)
I'm sorry but the guitar is completely butchered. Not to mention at 2:22 they start playing Ceremony. What? The vocals are different, but they are good. Joy Division just had a way of making their music so heavy and punk, this just sounds like something I would hear at a mall...
para toda la jente de Lima - Peru 9 de noviembre una de las mejores bandas del indie the killers tours 2009 atoda esa full jente del indie ya saven viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers viva el indie the killers
i like the killers version better cause i like it in a different way. i like joy division cause its like garagy and raw. the kiilllers one is like dark synthy upbeat which is really awesome
Both versions are good. You can't really compare and decide which one is better because even though it's the same song, the styles are completely different.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
killers version is ok......I doubt they even know what this song is about. Only Ian could deliver this song in it's rightful meaning with such force and passion. This is why covers usually fail in my book, they aren't the true minds behind the lyrics.
thanks v much for this. their live performance of this at nme awards was cruelly removed. yes JD version is better but boy does flowers feel it and the bass is amazing. thanks again
i wouldn't say its better.. its different both are great in their own way. i think you can't doubt ian's emotion, the lyrics really were from his heart. the killers version is insanely good though.
Well I think that this is great performance, not just this song but the concert in general too. I also think that Brandons voice holds up really well too... So i'm confused how this is bad =s
Man, I hope so. Nobody will ever top Freddy, but if Brandon can get up there on the same level as him, I will be overjoyed. He's not there yet, but some day, maybe!
No no no he's definitely not the new Freddie Mercury. He was waaay better at singing, and that's a fact. There's a big difference between what Freddie sang and what Brandon sings. Brandon sings good and I totally love The Killers, but Freddie was better and that's a fact. Brandon sings false from time to time, which Freddie almost never did. But, who the hell cares!? It's indie rock and fucking roll and that's gods musical gift to earth, Killers for the win!
how can you say that? it's a cover, a cover is with another band style.. am really in a bad mood so that's why i'm cranky, you don't live the killers moron, you're just a big talker fuckface..
wanky version.
Photonzos 5 months ago
Ian Curtis is GOD!
MmhhmmXD 8 months ago
This is like watching Pat Butcher go down on Pauline Fowler, it's just fucking wrong!...
jhmufc 11 months ago
wait? so who originally wrote the song? the killers or joy division?
mrChasenMONEY 11 months ago
@mrChasenMONEY is that some sort of sick joke? ian curtis was dead before brandon flowers was even born..who do you think originally wrote it sherlock?
xxbamesxxjurke 10 months ago 6
yo estube ahi! I was there! genial The Killers!
romiautumn 11 months ago
ewww
Oaksie2394 1 year ago
The Killers took it from a good song to an imense song!!! :D
RyanTerpstra93 1 year ago 3
@RyanTerpstra93 LOL NO
TodImJanuar 1 year ago
JOY DIVISION FOR EVER !
Tincho730 1 year ago
though I can see why fans of the original dislike it because they totally transformed the song (I think they pulled it off ) but The Killers even said so themselves, they said it sounded more like New Order than JD :-)
ShareTheMadness 1 year ago
I am a huge Joy Division fan and also a huge fan of The Killers. I don't prefer this version but it is still pretty fucking amazing in my opinion.
ShareTheMadness 1 year ago
I'm sorry but the guitar is completely butchered. Not to mention at 2:22 they start playing Ceremony. What? The vocals are different, but they are good. Joy Division just had a way of making their music so heavy and punk, this just sounds like something I would hear at a mall...
yrureadingthisname 1 year ago
Joys is mush better
classicbritpop 1 year ago
Wow, WHy all the thumb downs on the people who like the Joy Division version better?
The killers did it okay
But Joy Division did it much better.
StevenIsGone 2 years ago
Big JD fan here , Killers cover is way so better but technology has moved on since 79.
suzban600 1 year ago
@suzban600 totally agree with ya
JizzFace27 1 year ago
stage is to dark??
but marks solo is beeeeeeaaaaaaaassssstttttttttttt...
ganderlord 2 years ago
I like the killers cover of this song
Allissa7694 2 years ago 3
Play this all the time on bass. It's so much fun.
BrambletalonWarrior 2 years ago
Temon! Aguante Joy Division, muy buena version.
sas147741 2 years ago 2
I like this more than Joy Division no offense
heartcrossbonez 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
They wish they were Joy Division - never gonna happen.
lagowski 2 years ago
they don't. they just play a song that they love.
botneva 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
esta cancion es de JOY DIVISION, y esta pobre gente de killers parece ke no tiene letras propias!!
javiccdxt 2 years ago
se llama "hacer un cover"
znallely01 2 years ago 5
pelotudazo... hay cosas q se llaman tributos, covers...infeliz
jairowairo 2 years ago
se llaman influencias...hacer triubutos a las canciones que los dejaron marcados como banda propia..!
Lizka88 2 years ago 2
los amooo!! y amo esa kancion
princesskaliux 2 years ago
the killer AT LASTT IN COLOMBIA!! coming soon, indie rock and roll for me!!!!!
sergioth88 2 years ago
FALTA POCO PARA VERLOS EN PERU.....
diablomanuel 2 years ago
solo 2 dias mas =D
000csr000 2 years ago
The Killers are the best thing to come out of the States since i went home after my visit there,
I think other bands there should take a leaf out of their book and create a unique sound because they are the only ones there not stuck in the past..
whenitwaz 2 years ago
XxU2ferxX 2 years ago
lulz people hate because the killers aren't "raw," what more do you need? They are almost perfect live.
MarcusKiner 2 years ago
No one can play this song like Joy Division. No other voice like Ian Curtis's. He was a fucking genius!
Btw, I like The Killers (no their last album). They used to be funny...
Ev1ta 2 years ago
i like the killers version better cause i like it in a different way. i like joy division cause its like garagy and raw. the kiilllers one is like dark synthy upbeat which is really awesome
AshwinR 2 years ago 2
i like the killers..but it think joy division's version is better, it is raw and original. hehe
espilehiyo 2 years ago 5
Both versions are good. You can't really compare and decide which one is better because even though it's the same song, the styles are completely different.
TheTinaKid 2 years ago 5
awesome performance!!
caligirl2191 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the real joy division is much better
Jurgi173 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ahaha, no. fail. no crappy synth pop band should touch Joy Division songs because of Ian's sheer genius voice. Brandon Flowers ftl on this vid
Helixish 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ahhhhhhhhhhh puto cover apesta !!!!! parece que estan gimiendo maldios pendejos comerciales
pimentelg4400 2 years ago
nel. Para mi es basura. Hacen que la canción se escuche comercial. Y aparte creo que muchos conocen más la de killers que la de joy division
RoCkForeVeR117 2 years ago
This one goes out to Ian Curtis, 24 hung him self, but he had problems bad ones.......
totospirits 2 years ago 4
I thought it was 23
I mean
just read his lyrics and picture a 22 year old carrying around dose thoughts
gusta20 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
killers version is ok......I doubt they even know what this song is about. Only Ian could deliver this song in it's rightful meaning with such force and passion. This is why covers usually fail in my book, they aren't the true minds behind the lyrics.
diobolikal 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
agree with you
nevenko91 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is a joke ?
MaJaRo08 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i say this over Joy division
yejuan23 2 years ago
if u pepole would click this video, to listen and not to criticize u would see that version is awsome in Killers kinda way....
bjondji 2 years ago 22
i knoww!!
unknownZizo 2 years ago
thanks v much for this. their live performance of this at nme awards was cruelly removed. yes JD version is better but boy does flowers feel it and the bass is amazing. thanks again
iamatwat 2 years ago 2
i like this one , so much more :/
xfakemousx 2 years ago 4
ian curtis rules 4ever
elulli101 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I've always tried to remain positive about this cover, but fuck.. Why did they add that stupid: "WHO WHO WHO WHO WHO WHO" shit to the start?
XellKamikaze 2 years ago
i like the killers' version better.
maddiexsaurus 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
this is shite, ian curtis is well better
Jpac07 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Atrocious...Ian Curtis must be turning in his grave.
ChrisCarter1983 2 years ago
Gives me shivers all over. Brandon has a presence. Great musican he is.
Katzenfreundin 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lacks the air of menace of the original. An inferior guitar solo to boot. Still, they are not a bad band.
BourneLippy 3 years ago
great cover...respect to joy division
fzsb 3 years ago 31
how is 'who who who, who who who who' more emotion into the song? give me a break!
kurtnovells 3 years ago
no its not impossible the killers rock this song out way better there the best in the business
bricac21 3 years ago 6
joy division is more better!
but i still love The killers!
panicoanimal 3 years ago
me two!! i like them both
phanthomboy 2 years ago 2
alrights...
fbty74 3 years ago
I think this version is better than Joy Division's. I justy think the arangement is better and the singer puts more emotion into it that Ian.
GS336 3 years ago
Ian put an insane amount of emotion into every song, don't ever forget it. The Killers did this song great too..
regulardude123 3 years ago 8
they put "more emotion into it" than IAN? Are you serious? ugh....
popartpunx 3 years ago
well as Ian had a terrible voice yes they do!
sofiafrgreece 2 years ago
i wouldn't say its better.. its different both are great in their own way. i think you can't doubt ian's emotion, the lyrics really were from his heart. the killers version is insanely good though.
timetunnelpro 3 years ago 4
Wow (L)
tournico 3 years ago
the killers do this song way better then joy division
bricac21 3 years ago 2
yeahh
fatbroccoli 3 years ago
THATS IMPOSSIBLE
alistahr 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the killers are joke, i can't believe thought they could do a joy division justice
danamquinn1 3 years ago
ian curtis told them to cover it
hippiesmurphy 3 years ago 2
he doesnt sound that great in this vid
it saddens me greatly to say such a thing
but it's true
and it's probably just because he's tired
but i love him anyway and he rocks any other time
jessicaisthebessica 3 years ago
Well I think that this is great performance, not just this song but the concert in general too. I also think that Brandons voice holds up really well too... So i'm confused how this is bad =s
supercamel0 3 years ago
The Killers are awesome. This rocks.
GS336 3 years ago 2
Falto el Grito
Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh :D
The Killers !!!!!!!! i love it
tournico 3 years ago 2
Flowers kinda sounds bad in here, but over all, the Killers are a pretty good band.
bertrand1049 3 years ago
both version are great! and both bands great
RolandCasey 3 years ago 8
At 3:45 The lights plays an allusion b/c it looks like Ronnie is get stomped on or sumthin LOL good performance!
donuts911 3 years ago 3
awesome, i like this version better than the original.
skyline777 3 years ago 6
brandon flowers is the new freddy mercury fantastic vocal range ,stage presence ,flambouyance
leecox321 3 years ago 12
Man, I hope so. Nobody will ever top Freddy, but if Brandon can get up there on the same level as him, I will be overjoyed. He's not there yet, but some day, maybe!
RhymesWithEmpty 3 years ago 8
No no no he's definitely not the new Freddie Mercury. He was waaay better at singing, and that's a fact. There's a big difference between what Freddie sang and what Brandon sings. Brandon sings good and I totally love The Killers, but Freddie was better and that's a fact. Brandon sings false from time to time, which Freddie almost never did. But, who the hell cares!? It's indie rock and fucking roll and that's gods musical gift to earth, Killers for the win!
Alex4uall 3 years ago
JD are better but i do like this cover
nield8 3 years ago 4
hahaaha i agree
MegaMuffin4568 3 years ago
Grande The Killers mejor banda presente!!!!! Awsome!!!!
Rafa0607 3 years ago 2
mierda, esta weno el video, pero pense que se hiba a echar su bailesito como el ke se avienta en el video
Musssgo 4 years ago
cual bailecito?? el no baila en el video!!
las imagenes dl wey bailando son d la pelicula Control, idiota!!
kikotoes 3 years ago
a huevo jaja, como hay gente pendeja no?
user0name9 3 years ago
great!
Kata1123 4 years ago
That looks like one of their best shows. Brandon sounds great & the energy is wild.
meowkatt2002 4 years ago
i was there
bananarockera 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
love The Killers, but this cover really destroys the original
johnyexhale 4 years ago
how can you say that? it's a cover, a cover is with another band style.. am really in a bad mood so that's why i'm cranky, you don't live the killers moron, you're just a big talker fuckface..
user0name9 3 years ago 4
AWsome!
mervin3x 4 years ago 2
perfect=)
jennykahrs 4 years ago 2