i am very outnumbered here but I completely detest this. I much prefer the Cathryn Pope and Felicity lot versions. Pope brings out all the beauty and lyricism in the music with a smoother vocal line, and Lott captures more of the urgency and despair in the situation whilst still appearing optimistic about her future. Upshaw is just screaming half the time, she doesn't connect up all the dots in the music
@katieboyd1 - Felicity Lott? You mean the 1975 version with the London Phil? Those are the most languid tempi I've ever heard called urgent.. and I think it's commendable that Dawn takes acting risks to approach a young, terrified, passionate version of Anne that I find to be plenty urgent.
saw it at its Metropolitan Opera première in 195X, dont remember, with Eugene Conley and Hilde Gueden. I loathed it. Then throughout the years I've started to appreciate it and now really love this unusual opera.
@papoocanada It really did bomb at the Met, didn't it? The avant-gardists hated it because the music was so deliberately simple, but it wasn't a crowd-pleaser either (even with show-stopping arias like this one) perhaps because it can seem so cold and intellectualized and ironic.
I loved the score from when I first heard it, but I can understand why it didn't take off originally. Though I don't quite know why it provoked so much anger at the time. Maybe it was the staging as well as the music.
But he does give the orchestra an incredible sense of vulnerability. Look. Most people just play these notes (see the recent Cardiff winner &co.). These people are actually saying something.
I really love this.. I've always really enjoyed Dawn Upshaw, but she has never been one of my "top" sopranos. This, however, is probably my favorite performance of this difficult aria. SHe plays it great, and, her voice works at this stuff. Brava!
This is certainly not the best I've heard Upshaw, but I still favored this video for her lovely interpretation of the piece and the wonderful staging.
She's amazing. She manages to keep the sound clear and forward, without distorting the vowels too much. Saw this opear at Covent Garden last night. The soprano was wonderful, but I couldn't hear a lot of her words. Upshaw shows that it can be done!
The scary thing is that along with being able to blow the audience away with a Stravinsky piece, she has the same effect with Glitter and be Gay, lighter jazz/musical theater-style music, and anything else from Berg to traditional cultural music.
I can't really think of anyone with more range than her. Kristin Chenowith is right up there, but I still prefer Upshaw.
Don't apologize; I can see where you're coming from. Kristin Chenowith has a slightly odd voice than can tend towards the shrill side...
I agree with you - Upshaw is my personal favorite either way.
I just had Chenowith's performance of Glitter and be Gay in my head, which I (personally) think is extremely good. Though Upshaw's is as good, in a different way. I really shouldn't compare them, they're really not that similar at all.
I've heard this piece many times but NEVER like this. Dawn Upshaw is absolutely brilliant. I have chills like its the first time I've ever heard it. Astonishing!
The wig is a disaster, don't know her real hair, but it must have fitted better!
phoenix0glance 3 months ago
she is amazing
bigboy1black 8 months ago in playlist Opera History Spring 2011 Listening Assignment #3
ah, what fun. kinda under on the C at the end, but hey, she's not afraid to act, at least.
luvbucket 1 year ago
Her diction is pristine.
anneayer 1 year ago
i am very outnumbered here but I completely detest this. I much prefer the Cathryn Pope and Felicity lot versions. Pope brings out all the beauty and lyricism in the music with a smoother vocal line, and Lott captures more of the urgency and despair in the situation whilst still appearing optimistic about her future. Upshaw is just screaming half the time, she doesn't connect up all the dots in the music
katieboyd1 1 year ago
@katieboyd1 - Felicity Lott? You mean the 1975 version with the London Phil? Those are the most languid tempi I've ever heard called urgent.. and I think it's commendable that Dawn takes acting risks to approach a young, terrified, passionate version of Anne that I find to be plenty urgent.
daniellesoprano 5 months ago
super.
fluffynamedkimba 1 year ago
she is the best
0lsenchannel 1 year ago
almost perfect
ReneeFlemingTheBest 1 year ago
Dawn Upshaw is the best anne trulove!!!!!! My favorite!!!
marcinhutek 1 year ago
saw it at its Metropolitan Opera première in 195X, dont remember, with Eugene Conley and Hilde Gueden. I loathed it. Then throughout the years I've started to appreciate it and now really love this unusual opera.
papoocanada 1 year ago
@papoocanada It really did bomb at the Met, didn't it? The avant-gardists hated it because the music was so deliberately simple, but it wasn't a crowd-pleaser either (even with show-stopping arias like this one) perhaps because it can seem so cold and intellectualized and ironic.
I loved the score from when I first heard it, but I can understand why it didn't take off originally. Though I don't quite know why it provoked so much anger at the time. Maybe it was the staging as well as the music.
squaresyourtrue 1 year ago
Every single time I hear her sing this, it gives me goose bumps! AMAZING!
heather3157 2 years ago 10
My favorite on youtube.
cdoggiefizzle 2 years ago 2
I've admired her recording of this aria for such a long time. I think she is just a perfect Anne.
nickbigd 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hah. She's cheating in at times. Funny.
Rudziewicz 2 years ago
Great performance, much better than her older version of it.
costa7902 2 years ago
she plays the character a little too frantic for my taste. She is the heroine and needs to act like one. Too much arm flailing.
laraandlars 2 years ago
HOLY PERM!!!
cocosanti69 2 years ago 13
this is a crazy hard aria.
kudos to Ms. Upshaw!
CrystalFlames 2 years ago 2
Oh my God.
This moves me.
bloodyIla 2 years ago
She is wonderful, superb performance!
JAYJAY1000000 2 years ago
This is amazing. My only critique is that the conductor did not pay attention to Stravinsky's metronome markings.. at all. But still, brava!
MattQ88 3 years ago
But he does give the orchestra an incredible sense of vulnerability. Look. Most people just play these notes (see the recent Cardiff winner &co.). These people are actually saying something.
g4thz 2 years ago
The LA Philharmonic played this song this year!
simply AMAZINGGGG
316xsteph 3 years ago
I really love this.. I've always really enjoyed Dawn Upshaw, but she has never been one of my "top" sopranos. This, however, is probably my favorite performance of this difficult aria. SHe plays it great, and, her voice works at this stuff. Brava!
lpw0021 3 years ago
This is certainly not the best I've heard Upshaw, but I still favored this video for her lovely interpretation of the piece and the wonderful staging.
urgrad03 3 years ago
She's amazing. She manages to keep the sound clear and forward, without distorting the vowels too much. Saw this opear at Covent Garden last night. The soprano was wonderful, but I couldn't hear a lot of her words. Upshaw shows that it can be done!
owenboi66 3 years ago
marvellous!!!!!
newhotmailit 3 years ago
could you please post the epilogue?
hillevifan 3 years ago
It is amazing to compare this version with her 1990 recording! A totally different take (especially in the aria), but equally valid and jaw-dropping.
The woman is flawless.
manidonno10 3 years ago
The scary thing is that along with being able to blow the audience away with a Stravinsky piece, she has the same effect with Glitter and be Gay, lighter jazz/musical theater-style music, and anything else from Berg to traditional cultural music.
I can't really think of anyone with more range than her. Kristin Chenowith is right up there, but I still prefer Upshaw.
Bendmac525 3 years ago
I(sorry)hate Kristin Chenowith as a singer but LOOVE her as an actor. Upshaw is THE better of the two- no question!
hillevifan 3 years ago 3
Don't apologize; I can see where you're coming from. Kristin Chenowith has a slightly odd voice than can tend towards the shrill side...
I agree with you - Upshaw is my personal favorite either way.
I just had Chenowith's performance of Glitter and be Gay in my head, which I (personally) think is extremely good. Though Upshaw's is as good, in a different way. I really shouldn't compare them, they're really not that similar at all.
Bendmac525 3 years ago
I've heard this piece many times but NEVER like this. Dawn Upshaw is absolutely brilliant. I have chills like its the first time I've ever heard it. Astonishing!
pinkpowerangervp 4 years ago
wowowowowwowowowo...Ya just gotta love Dawn!!!!!!!
It's so great to hear music done justice!
tealsinging 4 years ago
One of my favorite Dawn moments! What can be said? Everything is evident in the performance.
Song27 4 years ago
magnifique!
Foly90 4 years ago
where and when was this performance?
thanks!
emilyforddirks 4 years ago
thank you for posting! It´s splendid!!!
Liga123567 4 years ago 2
Splendid. Repays the effort to acquire a taste for this (to me) "New Music." Upshaw astounds
sagalat 4 years ago 2
Thanks!!!!! I've loved Dawn Upshaw since the first time I heard her in Die Zauberflote!!!!!!!
Thanks for posting!!!
hillevifan 4 years ago