The best Holmes ever -- pity his work was controlled by the war department and he lacked the freedom and resources of the later Granada series. Brett was too over the top and didn't look like Holmes; Basil WAS Holmes.
That was the one disguise in the Sherlock Holmes films where you didn't see him and think 'that'll be Holmes' - just so,,,UNEXPECTED that it turned out to be him!!!
Mmmmm now was he British (English) or South African? I now know where Dick Van Dyke got his awful cockney accent from!!! Nice performance though Basil!
Its a pity that he didnt make more Holmes films after dressed to kill. Thank goodness that he made many more radio shows that we can still enjoy today
@kevinkards1 IMHO, I'm not sure you can compare them...they are so different and they are both awesome...but different acting styles, production techniques and capabilities and 40 years stand between them...the great thing about Holmes is that he is such a great character that both actors (and others) can get a large piece of him...but nobody gets him completely. Depends on which Holmes you are in the mood for...I love both and couldn't choose between them.
I once heard that of all the "characters" that Sherlock Holmes disguised himself as throughout the film series, Basil Rathbone considered this dance hall singer to be his personal favorite. It must have been a fun day on the set.
Great clip, looks like an attempt at colorization. This movie was the only Rathbone one not made from a Conan Doyle story. This was adapted from a play by the actor William Gillette. Reminds me of the Lone Ranger. My favorites were always the ones where the Ranger appeared in disguises for part of the story.
Haha! I love that he can do this and be the best villain EVER, too!
I'm not a big fan of the Rathbone/Bruce Holmes films, (they were a product of their time, and while 30s-40s cinema was brilliant, book adaptations were often weak...at least that's my opinion) but I think Rathbone is the best Holmes ever!
This is one of my favorite movies from the Rathbone-Bruce series. Thank God for Basil Rathbone. He was a Shakespearean actor, but he never passed up an opportunity to ham it up. :)
Also, I don't think it's fair to say that Rathbone was better than Brett, or vice-versa. Everyone's opinion is different, but that doesn't mean any of them are wrong. Or that one's own opinion is the ONLY right one, for that matter. Why not just say, "Rathbone is MY favorite Holmes" and leave it at that?
I remember when I first rented this movie and I saw this scene I must have watched it about.... two hundred and seventy two times before I could move on. Its just perfect!
The Character Ann is played by Ida Lupino. Considered to be her first film. The only 2 Holmes films released by Fox is this one and the severely edited "The Hound of the Baskervilles" (Watson the Needle!) Every other Holmes film in the series was thru Universal.
He was far too versatile to become typecast as Holmes and i get the feeling he enjoyed the times when he could break away a little and have a bit of fun like this.
I think he MUST have enjoyed doing this, even though it was one of the first Holmes films. I have around 50 of the radio shows he did with Nigel Bruce, and twice when he is supposed to be disguised as a cockney-type gent, you hear him singing this song again (without piano!) He must have really loved doing this song...
They corresponded after the war,possibly up to Basils death. I have signed photo's of when he was in Hollywood. I don't know how close they were. My grandfather died when I was around 8. The only army memory I remember from his lips was the time his unit ran through the snow stark naked! My grandfather was awarded the Military Medal,Basil was awarded the Military Cross(officer). They and someone else went into the German trench and brought back a prisoner.
These Holmes series really didn't stick to the book-but I don't care!
basil rathbone, for me will always be the definitive Sherlock. so masculine and decisive while still being a gentleman..he fully brought to life the Victorian mentality of the times.
And yes, it is Rathbone, you can sort of tell in some inflection vocally, and the last shot of him from upstage you can tell that's his, um backside. But man, what a brave and hilarious moment. As far as the stage makeup, easy to change shape of nose with cotton wadding. Icky, but easy.
Yes, it IS Basil Rathbone. He's in character makeup, it's from the "Adventures of Sherlock Holmes". This is when actors could do anything. Mr. Rathbone played Sherlock Holmes, Richard the III, Dr. Wolf von Frankenstein and even costarred in a movie with Danny Kaye. These "pretty boys" today don't have 1/89th the talent nor ability.
he played a great villain also, it was always strange to me as a watching basil in sherlock holmes and associating him as a good guy who could never be anyone but good but after seeing him play the villain in a few movies he made with errol flynn was a big suprise
He was a much, much better fencer than Errol Flynn ever was! But because he played the heavy (Sheriff of Nottingham) he had to let Flynn kill him off, for the story.
You know what you are so true when you say that! Although Flynn was the dashing action hero of the 30's, Rathbone could have easily whipped him any day, just he was cast as the villains...but I'd route for him! Plus Flynn could never be Holmes!
Flynn was no swordsman at all and Rathbone was trained in the English tradition of acting to be an expert swordsman. There is a famous story of Rathbone and Flynn at a party that Niven tells...
Rathbone: You realize, of course, Errol, that while you always win our swordfights, that I can kill you at any time I wish?
Once you get over the fact that the word "one," as in a person, is used waaay too many times, it's a very entertaining read. If you can find if for under $300 I highly recommend it. (I "lost" a first edition copy from my public libray. Replacement fee-established in '69- was $4.95)
Whoa thats totally cool!!....I hope ya dont mind me sayin so but your great great great uncle-in-law is very hot and very handsome and I wish I could've met him
Ansuzie, then you and i are related (as you say vaguely) Basil is a distant uncle on my mothers side. alo the block island Rathbones, etc =) there is a complete family history if you're interested =)
Did rathbone really perform this number?? I always thought it was another actor pretending to be Holmes pretending to be a another guy ala MISSION IMPOSSIBLE.
@lioness901 I would too. He's just too gorgeous and intelligent and I love his manner. I would date him too if he was alive, and closer to my age, and if I was a bit older than fifteen in a half.... :)
I'm not altogether positive that that IS Basil Rathbone. Ears, size and shape of body, free-moving posture, and a completely different singing register. He speaks in Rathbone voice afterwards and appears in ill-lit conversation with Ms. Lupino, however it seems a diff. person; the ill-lit moment may have THEN been BR dressed as this performer, but not before.
If you've ever seen the illustrations for the original Strand magazine stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, it's funny to notice Basil Rathbone is the spitting image of Sidney Pagett's characterization Sherlock Holmes! And I'm not even sure he'd been born yet.
Hooey! I'm sure that's what some Athenians said after Thespis of Icaria had passed away 26 centuries ago. There have always been, and there will always be, great actors and actresses. Rathbone was surely one of them. But since his death other actors and actresses have rendered great performances. In fact, another great actor, who is quite reminiscent of Rathbone, and who likewise portrayed Holmes, passed away earlier this year, namely Ian Richardson.
adictive song
AndresIGLB 5 hours ago in playlist My Vlog
Whenever I'm feeling sad, I watch this video, and suddenly everything is okay again.
IncurablePessimist 2 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
The best Holmes ever -- pity his work was controlled by the war department and he lacked the freedom and resources of the later Granada series. Brett was too over the top and didn't look like Holmes; Basil WAS Holmes.
KnownastheMoss 1 week ago
That was the one disguise in the Sherlock Holmes films where you didn't see him and think 'that'll be Holmes' - just so,,,UNEXPECTED that it turned out to be him!!!
SneverusSnapers 4 weeks ago
I think his voice cracked a little around 0:46. O.o made me fall of my chair laughing.
BazilBentley 1 month ago
@BazilBentley :p yeah, I see - funnier if you keep pressing 0:46 again and again! :p
SneverusSnapers 4 weeks ago
GTA episodes from Liberty city brought me here from Lost and THe Damned :).
ShieldLessLink 2 months ago
Always thought it was a Freddie Mercury composition
enemywon 3 months ago
queen II
y0hita 3 months ago
brilliant basil!!!!!!!!!!!! xxxx
juneh1967 5 months ago
This is so delightful. :)
jazzandmint 7 months ago
This is so Mary Poppins. BTW who's the hottie around 0:50 #t=0m50s
FluxCurrent 7 months ago
@FluxCurrent The actress' name is ida Lupino.
1axalove 7 months ago
THAT was Basil Rathbone?!
CriticalListener 7 months ago
He's Holmes alright but so much more judging by this.
wendyverdades 8 months ago
Comment removed
Ellthom 9 months ago
Imagine trying to entertain people today with this kind of crap!
vincentprice121 10 months ago
youre all wrong vasily livanov is the best sherlock holmes. but i love rathbone and this vid makes me so happy x3
darkhorsegeorge 11 months ago
Mmmmm now was he British (English) or South African? I now know where Dick Van Dyke got his awful cockney accent from!!! Nice performance though Basil!
jonjamg 1 year ago
Its a pity that he didnt make more Holmes films after dressed to kill. Thank goodness that he made many more radio shows that we can still enjoy today
rarebutgreat 1 year ago
jermany breet is the best holmes mr rathbone is 2nd
kevinkards1 1 year ago
@kevinkards1 IMHO, I'm not sure you can compare them...they are so different and they are both awesome...but different acting styles, production techniques and capabilities and 40 years stand between them...the great thing about Holmes is that he is such a great character that both actors (and others) can get a large piece of him...but nobody gets him completely. Depends on which Holmes you are in the mood for...I love both and couldn't choose between them.
misterbell1969 1 year ago
I once heard that of all the "characters" that Sherlock Holmes disguised himself as throughout the film series, Basil Rathbone considered this dance hall singer to be his personal favorite. It must have been a fun day on the set.
RavenHouseMystery 1 year ago
This is "Sherlock's"best disguise and Bail's most memorable performance on screen.BTW:That is Ida Lupino watching "Holmes" as a song and dance man.
143AC 1 year ago
Great clip, looks like an attempt at colorization. This movie was the only Rathbone one not made from a Conan Doyle story. This was adapted from a play by the actor William Gillette. Reminds me of the Lone Ranger. My favorites were always the ones where the Ranger appeared in disguises for part of the story.
CarlDuke 1 year ago
i sang this song in our school talent show and i won evryone love me they were screeming
danbroad9 1 year ago
I love this soooooong!
godkingRoss 1 year ago
Haha! I love that he can do this and be the best villain EVER, too!
I'm not a big fan of the Rathbone/Bruce Holmes films, (they were a product of their time, and while 30s-40s cinema was brilliant, book adaptations were often weak...at least that's my opinion) but I think Rathbone is the best Holmes ever!
gamgee87 1 year ago
This is one of my favorite movies from the Rathbone-Bruce series. Thank God for Basil Rathbone. He was a Shakespearean actor, but he never passed up an opportunity to ham it up. :)
Also, I don't think it's fair to say that Rathbone was better than Brett, or vice-versa. Everyone's opinion is different, but that doesn't mean any of them are wrong. Or that one's own opinion is the ONLY right one, for that matter. Why not just say, "Rathbone is MY favorite Holmes" and leave it at that?
FlippinBooks 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Rathbone was infinitely better than the overacting homosexual NUTTER Brett.
JuanMacready 1 year ago
@JuanMacready - WhAt?!?!?!? >:o
JHandcock1111 1 year ago
@JHandcock1111 Rathbone was the best Holmes by far.
JuanMacready 1 year ago
I remember when I first rented this movie and I saw this scene I must have watched it about.... two hundred and seventy two times before I could move on. Its just perfect!
sokwest 1 year ago 2
Basil Rathbone was far better than the overacting Brett.
FrankClanton 2 years ago 5
@FrankClanton I totally agree!!! Basil is king as Sherlock, no question!!
sokwest 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i watched this movie at W W W . TV-Video . us
ancisobazil 2 years ago
Rathbone was far better than Jeremy Brett.
PeterFirthFan 2 years ago 3
WHA WHA WHA WHAT? =8-)
BarnabasFrid 2 years ago
Rathbone was a far better Holmes than Brett.
PeterFirthFan 2 years ago
hmmmm
BarnabasFrid 2 years ago
Brett was the worst Holmes ever.
PeterFirthFan 2 years ago
That's why they make vanilla and chocolate...
BarnabasFrid 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Brett was just an overacting homosexual NUTTER.
PeterFirthFan 2 years ago
Kinda like Holmes... hm. Last comment from me.
BarnabasFrid 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Also he didn't even look like Holmes.
PeterFirthFan 2 years ago
@PeterFirthFan that is a vile ignorant bigoted stupid offensive thing to say!!! I can only assume that you have issues and are an ignorant d**k!!!
baftamember99 2 years ago
!YES!
jameswipps 2 years ago
The Character Ann is played by Ida Lupino. Considered to be her first film. The only 2 Holmes films released by Fox is this one and the severely edited "The Hound of the Baskervilles" (Watson the Needle!) Every other Holmes film in the series was thru Universal.
78timothy 2 years ago
Seven Seas of Rhye
fr0zenbear 3 years ago 5
That's what got me into this song. One good song often leads to another.
HookedOnSonics518 2 years ago
Basil was by far the best Holmes.
HarveyCartwright 3 years ago 22
This comment has received too many negative votes show
english gays! USA BABY!!!!!!
whowantstotestme 3 years ago
i have this episode. love it.
bluedragon1836 3 years ago
<3 gotta love Basil Rathbone
1992KCWolf 3 years ago 5
He was far too versatile to become typecast as Holmes and i get the feeling he enjoyed the times when he could break away a little and have a bit of fun like this.
9to5boyz 3 years ago
I think he MUST have enjoyed doing this, even though it was one of the first Holmes films. I have around 50 of the radio shows he did with Nigel Bruce, and twice when he is supposed to be disguised as a cockney-type gent, you hear him singing this song again (without piano!) He must have really loved doing this song...
ghostfanX2 2 years ago
ha ha ha I say what jolly good fun wat!!
Westyrulz 3 years ago 2
Where the brass bands play: "Fack Off Dundee"
carhandle 3 years ago
She seems unimpressed to me, he had promised her it was an Oasis concert.
feelOlucky 3 years ago
He was the business. Although Jeremy Brett was pretty good. My grandfather served with Basil Rathbone in World War 1.
j1o2h3n4n5y 3 years ago 4
How did he find Basil? Where they close?
woodyqpr 3 years ago
They corresponded after the war,possibly up to Basils death. I have signed photo's of when he was in Hollywood. I don't know how close they were. My grandfather died when I was around 8. The only army memory I remember from his lips was the time his unit ran through the snow stark naked! My grandfather was awarded the Military Medal,Basil was awarded the Military Cross(officer). They and someone else went into the German trench and brought back a prisoner.
j1o2h3n4n5y 3 years ago
These Holmes series really didn't stick to the book-but I don't care!
basil rathbone, for me will always be the definitive Sherlock. so masculine and decisive while still being a gentleman..he fully brought to life the Victorian mentality of the times.
charminsouthernbelle 3 years ago 3
Which Basil Rathbone mystery is this in??
lioness901 3 years ago
The Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes. Its the one where Moriarty plans to steal the Crown Jewels.
vonkrolok2008 3 years ago
Which Basil Rathbone mystery is this in??
lioness901 3 years ago
Which Basil Rathbone mystery is this in??
lioness901 3 years ago
hooray! I love seeing this.
And yes, it is Rathbone, you can sort of tell in some inflection vocally, and the last shot of him from upstage you can tell that's his, um backside. But man, what a brave and hilarious moment. As far as the stage makeup, easy to change shape of nose with cotton wadding. Icky, but easy.
Cheers to you!
mycaprice 4 years ago
aman.. firmos!!!
avrillolcyp 4 years ago
Yes, it IS Basil Rathbone. He's in character makeup, it's from the "Adventures of Sherlock Holmes". This is when actors could do anything. Mr. Rathbone played Sherlock Holmes, Richard the III, Dr. Wolf von Frankenstein and even costarred in a movie with Danny Kaye. These "pretty boys" today don't have 1/89th the talent nor ability.
NorbertZF 4 years ago 7
he played a great villain also, it was always strange to me as a watching basil in sherlock holmes and associating him as a good guy who could never be anyone but good but after seeing him play the villain in a few movies he made with errol flynn was a big suprise
nookiboi 3 years ago
The Sherrif of Nottingham. He was as good a swordsman as Errol Flynn.
toobyu2859 2 years ago
IKR! He was the best there. But I guess he couldn't match up to Errol Flynn (sadley) because he ended up being slain! :*(
arisztidoltz 2 years ago
He was a much, much better fencer than Errol Flynn ever was! But because he played the heavy (Sheriff of Nottingham) he had to let Flynn kill him off, for the story.
dedebelle 2 years ago 2
You know what you are so true when you say that! Although Flynn was the dashing action hero of the 30's, Rathbone could have easily whipped him any day, just he was cast as the villains...but I'd route for him! Plus Flynn could never be Holmes!
arisztidoltz 2 years ago
Toobyu, Toobyu, Toobyu, you foolish child!
Flynn was no swordsman at all and Rathbone was trained in the English tradition of acting to be an expert swordsman. There is a famous story of Rathbone and Flynn at a party that Niven tells...
Rathbone: You realize, of course, Errol, that while you always win our swordfights, that I can kill you at any time I wish?
LazlosPlane 2 years ago 3
and not to question your pick, but this doesnt look like Basil Rathbone, not even the same nose.
oblayus 4 years ago
A picture of him in this outfit is in his autobiography.
aretrospection 4 years ago
wow, it just doesnt look like him at all. and i never read his auto =)
oblayus 4 years ago
Once you get over the fact that the word "one," as in a person, is used waaay too many times, it's a very entertaining read. If you can find if for under $300 I highly recommend it. (I "lost" a first edition copy from my public libray. Replacement fee-established in '69- was $4.95)
aretrospection 4 years ago
@oblayus He has nose putty on to make his nose look different. It's definitely him...
Nergaladdictchic 1 year ago
Maybe only 2 Greats
Ansuzie 4 years ago
This may sound stupid to you but it's true. I'm related to Basil Rathbone (admittedly in a very vague way, but proud of it anyway)
He's my Great Great Great uncle-in-law.
See, sounds silly but I like it.
Ansuzie 4 years ago
Whoa thats totally cool!!....I hope ya dont mind me sayin so but your great great great uncle-in-law is very hot and very handsome and I wish I could've met him
lioness901 4 years ago 3
Ansuzie, then you and i are related (as you say vaguely) Basil is a distant uncle on my mothers side. alo the block island Rathbones, etc =) there is a complete family history if you're interested =)
oblayus 4 years ago
ooo yes please! I'm linked by my brother-in-law (his last name is Rathbone) I think he'll also find that quite interesting. Thank you
Ansuzie 4 years ago
Did rathbone really perform this number?? I always thought it was another actor pretending to be Holmes pretending to be a another guy ala MISSION IMPOSSIBLE.
deadpool2099 4 years ago
I would date him if he was alive
lioness901 4 years ago 5
@lioness901 I would too. He's just too gorgeous and intelligent and I love his manner. I would date him too if he was alive, and closer to my age, and if I was a bit older than fifteen in a half.... :)
I luvs u Basil!
Nergaladdictchic 1 year ago 2
my favourite actor of all time and this was him singing, in fact the only time he ever sang on film.
Winner of MC and proud Englishman, they don't make 'em like that anymore!!
woodyqpr 4 years ago
I never heard he won the MC, but that was not something they just stuck in cereal boxes. He must have been quite brave
teenonator 4 years ago
I'm not altogether positive that that IS Basil Rathbone. Ears, size and shape of body, free-moving posture, and a completely different singing register. He speaks in Rathbone voice afterwards and appears in ill-lit conversation with Ms. Lupino, however it seems a diff. person; the ill-lit moment may have THEN been BR dressed as this performer, but not before.
diddymuck 4 years ago
If you've ever seen the illustrations for the original Strand magazine stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, it's funny to notice Basil Rathbone is the spitting image of Sidney Pagett's characterization Sherlock Holmes! And I'm not even sure he'd been born yet.
Boltneck13 4 years ago 4
Rathbone is so much like Paget's illustrations of Holmes. That is why Rathbone IS Sherlock Holmes :)
ericthefrootbat 2 years ago 19
Basil Rathbone, legend. bygone age that will sadly never be repeated.
AlannTH 4 years ago 2
Hooey! I'm sure that's what some Athenians said after Thespis of Icaria had passed away 26 centuries ago. There have always been, and there will always be, great actors and actresses. Rathbone was surely one of them. But since his death other actors and actresses have rendered great performances. In fact, another great actor, who is quite reminiscent of Rathbone, and who likewise portrayed Holmes, passed away earlier this year, namely Ian Richardson.
berliita 4 years ago
Of course you hate him, a brilliant actor, raconteur and and not least of all a reluctant war hero. Whats there to like?
PLScotland 4 years ago 2
Wow...Ive never seen Rathbone sing. If this is in a Shrelock Holmes I sure dont remember it.
andrewdl007 4 years ago
How can you hate him?
He was ONE of the best Sherlocks ever!
crazyaznnutter 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Rathbone... God how I hate him!
MadameAdam 4 years ago
OH MY GOSH!! I LOVE HIM!! HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY HATE HIM?? HES HOT MAN!! got a cute butt to..
lioness901 4 years ago
@lioness901 He's a VERY HOTT man!! He totally has a cute butt... Just makes me wanna pinch it, and run away giggling like a little girl...
Nergaladdictchic 1 year ago 4
you hate him? did you know him personally? did he run over your cat? grow up
oblayus 4 years ago 3