Added: 1 year ago
From: Kahvm17
Views: 121,489
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (183)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She needs to sing a studio version omfg

  • Lady GaGa is amazing. She knocks this classic ballad out of the park. Please release this on itunes, Gaga!!

  • 1:13 wow

  • you would gaga, you would. and i just fell even more in love with you x

  • i cant believe so many people are talking! if i was that close to her at a surprise performance i wouldnt say a word!

  • Her voice is so strong

  • First 25 seconds sounded good. Legit jazzy.

    The rest sounded like your typical poptart-y dying cat bullshit.

  • @inasexymood and ur a typical jackass. lets hear u sing better than her and then u can criticize.

  • @oneandonly2997 what? didn't i praise the 1st 25 seconds of your goddess?

  • @inasexymood

    Lol. Let's see/hear you do that well. If you're going to criticize her, don't be unintelligent about it. Like you could say, oh, all of the belts above G4 were strained, or you could just say, I don't think what she was singing was really jazz (which is bullshit, just like your comment, but less rude (because who are you to say what particular vocal stylings are pop and not jazz? I'm sure Billy Holiday sounded like she was yelling quite often)). Just some suggestions.

  • @Astariel2525 If you can not recognize the difference between the first 25 seconds and the rest, I'm not sure who's the unintelligent one here.

  • @inasexymood

    I apologize. Wow. I wrote that at 2 a.m. after another existential crisis. Proceed with ignoring my bullshit. I'm glad that you acknowledged that Gaga is capable of 25 seconds of jazz (also there's a video of her scatting in Philadelphia if you care). And by unintelligent, I meant specific. That was a fault on my part. Again, sorry. Heh. :)

  • @Astariel2525 Thank you. I do recognize her capabilities. It just still too often spills over into a sea of unnecessary foolishness for me to call her fully capable of jazz atm. These first 25 seconds were a pretty sufficient shot at jazz, while her Lady Is A Tramp cover/duet was a pretty sufficient shot at swing. If she was to release a jazz album, I'd like her to fully dedicate her time to studying the dynamics of jazz. I mean, I'm sure she can pull something off.

  • @inasexymood

    Just wondering, what's that "unnecessary foolishness"?

  • She sounds like a doggie squeak toy being stepped on repeatedly. Nothing at all compelling here.

  • @tricolaola You're a tool

    

  • Who are these assholes talking during her performance.

  • @xrubypazzx Because the performance is anemic and uninteresting. You could hear something better in any high school gymnasium on talent night.

  • She's the most amazing performer ever <3

  • How could these fools be talking??!!!! 

  • what an angelic voice... GaGa's not rivals

  • what an angelic voice... GaGa's not rivals

  • well that was kinda beautiful i really cant stand her pop music it just sounds like disposable crap to me BUT! what a beautiful voice and i have heard some of her music when she was not gaga she has a lot of talent its just a shame she had to change so much for people to realize

  • Can someone explain to me why there are so many people talking in the background :@

  • @Trasdeno She was in the oak room ;p

  • @Micha499 if gaga was playing a surprise performance where i was, i would definitely make sure everyone stfu! :P

  • so soulful x

  • Ohhhhh Gaga!!! I adore her so much <333333

    Can't wait for "Born This Way"!!! (Friday gonna be a good day~~)

  • The angel sings

  • her voice sounds AMAZING here.

  • she's a great live performer and a very very talented artist. her voice is the best is the best of all..no one has her talent and no one works so hard. think of her sitting on the piano writing and singing those wonderful songs. great musician. madonna, britney, rihanna, katy, ke$ha, christina..i don't think they work so hard and they're that talented. that's why Gaga is and should be the queen of pop. you feel so much fire in her music. good luck on your way, Gaga you will blow them all away.

  • Yeah, so why cant see preform great standards like this all the time, instead of the crap that she usually dose. Now I see that she has a great voice, but you cant tell that with poker face or gagagagagaga. Please continue doing great songs like this and make an album of standards!

  • gostei ela estava muito linda :)

  • Christina would ruin it with her annoying vocal gyrations.

    Sometimes less is more...

  • @IHaveNoDoubt EXACTLY. She knows what sounds good and doesn't feel like she has to prove anything when she sings like Christina did. Don't get me wrong, i LOVED the Stripped album, and Christina is a fine pop artist. But what I could never quite get past was her insisting on screaming in every song to the point where it sounded like she was damaging her throat. Gaga gives that awesome, rich, smokey yet powerful sound while keeping it pleasing to the ear.

  • Fuck, she shouldnt do POP!

  • Katy could never. Ke$ha could never. Britney could never. Rihanna could never. Christina.....maybe could. lol. but STILL...Gaga truly has an amazing voice.

  • @yellowtents Christina MAYBE could? Christina would blow this bitch away. lol

  • @UhOhhItsJojo I think it's unfair to say that Christina would blow her away. Christina and Gaga each have a unique quality to their voices. Gaga is much more classical and R/B, Ragtime, and Rock and Roll, as well as a lower sound. Christina is a master of vibrato and vocal fluctuation and they each produce a really unique sound that shows off both their amazing talents. I think this particular song fits Gaga's style better than Christina. Not saying that applies to EVERYTHING

  • @x51havoc That's true BUT saying "maybe Christina" is a bit much and that's what I was commenting on, we all know what Christina sings like. I'm not saying that it applies to EVERYTHING either.

  • @x51havoc i'm not talking about styles or genres, i'm talking about vocals. she said MAYBE Christina. that's just dumb beyond belief.

  • @x51havoc

    I loved this performance of Gaga.

    To my point, in my opinion and from my observations, Christina doesn't have the same vocal control as Gaga. Christina definitely has a larger range but gets quite off key at times, especially holding two whole notes or more with vibrato. She then tends to scream which I can barely understand her at that point.

  • why were those crazy people talking??

  • britney cant sing like that..hahha love u gaga!!

  • 1:11 to 1:18 is fucking amazing i really lover voice <3 i love gaga so much she really is the most talented person and i am so proud to be a little monster =D

  • Great voice. She shouldn't be a pop star....

  • I wish there was more light, she kinda looks like Britney spears when the lights flash on her

  • I absolutley love lady gaga. no question about it. my mom says she takes things to far in her vids, but i really dont care! she has the greatest voice ever! i hate it when people judge her as a bad person cuz shes different. YOU GO GAGA! KEEP BEING YURSELF!! :)

  • Jus Had to put up the LEAKED VERSION to this the full EXTENTED part. HIT me up before it gets removed

  • I drown in her river of fucking beautiful music...it's perfect suicide.

  • Unexpectedly good \m/

    Marshall

  • I'm dying. That was freakin amazing. :D

  • this is beautiful I ABSOULUTLY LOVE GAGA!!!! IM STILL MAD THAT THE PCA DIDNT EVEN INVITE THE QUEEN OF POP GAGA BUT INVITES SKINNY AZZ TAYLOR SWIFT UGHHHH WE LOVE U GAGA AND YES YOU DO HAVE HETEROSEXUAL FANS THAT FIGHT AGAINST HOMOPHOBIA.......LOVE YAAA

  • LADY INSPIRATIONGA 

  • I WISH GAGA NEW SHE HAS A LOT OF STRAIGHT FANS THAT FIGHT FOR HER EVERYDAY AND LOVES EVERYBODY AND FIGHTS AGAINST HOMOPHOBIA EVERY DAY, WE ALL LOVE YOU GAGA NOT JUST THE GAYS

  • @littlemonsterkg18 I'm very sure she knows that :)

  • @littlemonsterkg18

    She knows, but gays need more support :S

    You don't have to deal with what I have to...

  • @galigal2 wowww, dont make us fags look like winy wet pussies...we can be strong and help ourselves..Everyone deals with shit, were not handicaped, we like dick so what...dont make us look weak...GaGa helps us be brave...you be braver little monster

  • @Modzokilla

    Do stragiht guys have to deal with "straightophobia" every day?

    We have a lot more problems to deal with comparing to straights,

    so yeah, I need my mother monster to help me be brave.

  • I f***ing love her beautiful heart and soul !!! I have 21 years and I never imagined that someone could be idol who is alive from the known celebrity ppl and with someone I can admire so much, but three years ago appeared the little blonde and everything changed, and I think that there is no better celebrity stars from her! Big respect and love for her! ♥

  • Lady Gaga is not just an "image" like everyone says she is. She is a TRUE MUSICIAN. She trumps pretty much every other singer that is out there right now, if not every other singer in the past 10 years or so. Theres a reason why so many music legends are supporting her, like Elton John, Alice Cooper, Madonna, Michael & Janet Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, Boy George, Sting, Bruce Springsteen, etc, and thats because she has RAW TALENT. Haters can go fuck themselves, this woman is the future of music!

  • I love her voice

  • To all the real Broadway and aspiring Broadway singers who are in NYC and know they could kick all over this version... bless you. Keep on singing. If it can happen to her...

  • Gaga I love youuuuuuu

  • Wow, thanks so much for posting. 

  • Is that gaga? Wow she has eaten a lot during the Holidays :o (and I don't mean this in a bad way)

  • @JoyBrit Haha yeah huh! i have seen her in her latex dress, the one she sings lovegame in, and her tits were smashed, twas hot though <3 <3

  • MADONNA CANT SING LIKE THAT!!!

  • So talented :)

  • Love it, honestly love it.

  • No matter how one feels about her music, there is no denying that she has genuine, raw talent. I can understand why some people think she's overrated, but the haters take it way too far when they say stuff like "she can't sing, she's talentless". You don't have to like someone to give credit where credit is due. She's got pipes, and actually sounds better singing songs like this than her own tunes, something that you can say only for a very, very few number of pop stars these days.

  • Gaga is going to be my Wife one day!

  • To the people clicked dislike: I'm sorry that you're deaf, but it's ok, you were probably born this way :/

  • Vintage Gaga Rears Its Ferocious Head :P Love Ya Mommy Monster!

  • Her voice makes me come in my pants!~

  • amy winehouse also sings this beautifully...when she's sober. 

  • Go Gaga :) everyone says she's all bubble gum pop. Uh no. She's all EPIC is what she is. (I don't think any of her music is "bubble gum" pop by the way) can't wait for her new music!!

  • @SkyRay93 Uh, her music IS bubblegum pop. She's just capable of doing more with that voice.

  • Lady GaGa doesn't just make music, she is music! She is definetly one of the most amazing ppl on planet Earth! She is a very talented singer! The best slow song she has sung is Speechless... And that's the best part, she SINGS!!! Little Monsters rock!!! See everyone, you don't have to be gay to be a fan of GaGa!!! I'm weird in how I think but bitch I was Born This Way!!!!!

  • @hhnguy I'm straight but I was Born This Way!!!!!!!! mosterhug ♥ :)

  • @anchiii89 Maybe if you didn't say you were straight people wouldn't assume you're gay. Just saying

  • @Pimpboy50 I'm straight, but annoying as the album title for gay ppl (I'm not homophobic but what about the straight fans?)

  • @anchiii89 No I guess everybody can relate to the album.....

  • @PlyMood the first time when she talked about the album, said that is for gay ppl and one month later says that for anyone, so nothing is left to us to wait until May :) or wait for the next year when it will be album of straight ppl :D

  • @anchiii89 OH YEAH!:) 

  • A pop icon who can sing and bring the house down, minimal backup, no engineering, and no gimmicks... And she's got serious piano chops too.

    There may be hope for American culture yet.

  • Super Talented I Love Her So Much :D 

  • Talent. Period. Hater....suuuck it! Shes amaaaaziiing!

  • Gaga's got a strong powerful voice--and it's a lot more soulful than I realized. This is a really nice version of a classic--wish we could've heard more of it.

  • Gaga is amazing :)

    the BEST!

  • I always thought she had a great voice and now I know it. Great song choice, too!

  • wow ppl stop talking in the background hahaa so rude my wife is trying to sing here!!!

  • Definitely she's more than just another pop star, actually she can REALLY sing, that's why i'm her unconditional fan. <3

  • Wow her voice owns all categories of music. Sing it Gaga! :) I have a feeling #BornThisWay will have a few songs that sound jazzy.

  • she looks weird here

  • awesome gaga!!!!!

  • PCA was a joke.

  • Gaga is just the best! Can you imagine seeing/hearing Gaga in a small nightclub belting out jazz standards and some blues stuff? Amazing! Gaga creates excitement wherever she goes! And what a voice! Gaga has a stunning, beautiful voice!

    -Eric Chicago

  • Lady Gaga Is My Sexy Bitch! I Love You Gaga <3!

    Fuckers Mother Monster *--*

  • She sounds nice. Shitting on anything she has released. She should learn some more about jazz improv and put some of that on her album.

  • GaGa is so gorgeous here!

  • suck it haters

  • here is rare gaga

  • The title is WRONG. The song is "Someone To Watch Over Me", not SOMEBODY... it is SOMEONE. Written by Ira & George Gershwin and IMO, one of the best songs ever written.

  • She looks terrible in the stills from this performance. She has self-tanner all over the palms of her hands. I don't get why she felt the need to use sunless tanner. She looks fine being pale..no reason to go Christina Aguilera-orange.....

  • @babygaga4421 she does it on purpose, bb.

  • @babygaga4421 no reason to hate asswipe

  • So talented! Lucky people, wish I were there.

  • Greaaat performance and voice,, too bad we can't see her beautiful face in this ):

  • Forget pop, she is a true Acoustic/Jazz musican at heart! FUCK YEAH!!!!!

  • A voz dela é muito linda, puta que pariu.

  • Our Mother Monster is so talented... I'd die to see her perform in such a small venue like that.

    The only thing I don't get is the people! They're talking so much! Lady Gaga is performing for you. Shut your mouths.

  • LOVE YOU GAGA XXXXX

  • her voice is so amazing...i love you <3

  • I'm a big fan of Gaga singing Someone to Watch Over Me, she sings it BEAUTIFULLY. Omg, great performance! <3

  • Amazing as always :) She's an incredible artist. Love you Gaga X <3

  • She should do stuffs like this more often. :)

  • I DON'T GET IT how can people talk WHILE she's singing?! If I were there I COULDN'T BE ABLE to speak.

  • Damn! I want to see a video of the full performance! Amazing, as usual. <3 Gaga Little Monsters for fucking life!

  • this is what real artists do instead of attending the people's choice awards. pca was absolutely ridiculous... but it's okay, lady gaga doesn't need to win an award to prove she's the best. besides, she has a billion already stacked up. the pcas are just a joke - they always have been.

  • she's the epitome of perfection in every way...

  • She sounds awesome!

  • omfg i love gaga so much and her voice is so powerful and amazing i love it =D

  • Comment removed

  • did she do this in the dark?????

  • kaitlyn... im so jealous

  • its awesome love u mother monster <3

  • OMG, this is beautiful

  • What a voice.

  • Did anybody get any pics with her or anything signed ? Also she should start doing more jazz stuff and ballads instead of dance records. I have got her old album red and blue ep and other unrealsed. Songs and there better then her dance records by far x

  • truly an outstanding performance. SO glad to have been able to witness it.

  • why are people TALKING during this performance!!?!?!

  • I love her. Moments like this are why she will always be an exceptional artist, entertainer, and woman. :)

  • I have tears in my eye, i love her so much<3

  • i love you GAGA !!!!!

  • voice of a goddess! chills!

  • GaGa never ceases to amaze me

  • LADY GAGA SHITS ON OTHER BASIC POP BITCHES. I AM NOT WORTHY.

  • @ohitsryan Bitch please the only thing larry gaga shits on is his ugly ass face with his fat ass witch nose! lmfaoooo

  • @acowartt08 that was your best insult? i wasn't aware we were 6 years old and live on the school playground. try again.

  • @acowartt08 i love how you took the time to search this video only to insult her... you must love her a lot deep down ;)

  • @acowartt08 You're so fucking FUNNY! I'm dying.... (SARCASM)

  • @acowartt08 Really? 'Cause no ONE cares!

  • Thanks so much for posting this. All of us hungry for Gaga singing jazz standards at small NYC clubs have never gotten footage until now. She sounds spectacular and I hope that some point in her career she releases an acoustic album, or one in which there is a distinct blues influence. This girl has it in her soul.

  • I HOPE SHE NEVER STOPS DOING THESE SURPRISE PERFORMANCES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!! they're SO so amazing. I love her bluesy-jazz voice. please let there be one of this genre on born this way<3<3

    ps. ridiculously jealous of you. saw this on ggdaily and cursed myself for not living/being in nyc:(

  • she can sing her ass off

  • i would kill to see an intimate performance by Gaga <33 gosh, i love her ♥

  • You go girl!!!! I love you! <3

  • my ears are not worthy....

  • thanks for posting, this literally made my day, i needed a dose of gaga and her raw talent.

  • AMAZING!! I HOPE BORN THIS WAY INCLUDES THIS... ya know like as a cover. just like how maxwell put this womans work on his "now" album

  • @Kahvm17 You're world is about to get rocked by how many views this is going to get!

  • nooooooo fuck MMMEEEEEE!!! LMAO OMG GAGASM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This is amazing!! Thank you so much for posting this! I love you Gaga!! <333

  • FUCK ME GAGA! I love you!

  • Your video views are about to skyrocket! Thanks again for posting.

  • I feel so blessed and lucky to have been there. xox Gaga

  • SHE IS AMAZING!!!

  • Omg beautiful voice!!! LOVE U GAGA!

  • God that is so old-school, she can do so very much that people have no clue about. This classic jazz/blues style is so beautiful.

  • I Love it!! Gaga you are the best ♥.♥

  • She is so beautiful!!! I bet she would have had a dreadful time at the People's Choice awards. =P She sings this song so passionately. I never gut tired of it. Its a shame it was so dark. But thanks for the video anyways.

  • She has a great voice.

  • her voice is so sexy

  • Awesome!!!

  • 1:13 - Sing it, gurl!