[Perf] 111207 After School - Because of You, Interview & Shampoo @ 2011 Volunteer Day Festival

[pansitkantonify]

I really think Bekah's parts near 1st verse should've been for Nana or Lizzy then the part with English lines were for Kahi since those expressed stronger emotions which our Boss can.

[jexejx26]

Bekah's rap was BETTER! ♥

[ractep]

@jexejx26 stop comparing any of them to bekah. we know the fact and saying it will just hurt other Playgirlz like me.

[glamgal2227]

kahi should have done bekah's rap because she's the only one who has enough power to carry the rap nana's voice is too soft.

[ciberBAC]

Bekahhhhhhhhhh.... not here, no es lo mismo sin ella, se supone que Lizzy tenia que rapear que paso??????, eso no quiere decir q no sean las numero uno.

[xmochilove]

I'm sorry I don't hate E-Young or anything but it's been like a year and she STILL looks awkward with After School. She honestly doesn't belong tbh. :/

[nelielkpop97]

lol nana and juyeon look likes twin

[7StarDustz]

i love after school

love long-version live of shampoo

[FourVTS]

Lizzy ดูโกรธๆนะ - -*

[iloveafterschool100]

They could have gave E-Young uee's second verse instead of lizzy she already got a part.

[yoonasnsdlove120]

Jooyeon finally decided to do somwthing on her hair..love it!! GORGEOUS!!

[qonitahusttb]

Where's Uee?

[Estonian4life]

ppl srsly need to stfu. They did a good job covering up Bekah's lines. What else were they suppose to do? Pretend like there was an imaginery Bekah performing with them? If you hate seeing AS members covering up her parts and trying to move on without her, send Bekah a letter to give up on her studying and to come back to Korea and reunite with AS... It's really hard to move on when there are some crybabys who don't like this and that...

[GreekMorrison]

nana did a good job, in my opinion. but than, they played bekhas voice in this song... not good!

[gohliver]

nana juyeon so cute. ^_^

[wawa3180]

I really miss the old after school and Bekahs's rap!!! Because of you is my favorite song, it feels like this song never gets old, but it really is not complete without Bekah. I like their old songs rather than some of their newest ones. I really hope in the future, they could make more songs that's like the same type of because of you!!! But anyways, they still did a good job and I will supporting them! Fighting \(^0^)/ Looking forward for they Japaneses ver. of the song!!

[narukarliithaxD]

Wiii...!!! Lizzy rap ^^ Fighting Lizzy ♥♥♥ >.<

[55tester]

no UEE?

[GermanottaDavid]

@55tester UEE was workin in her tv-drama this day :P

[GreekMorrison]

and kahis rap as bekhas rap .... omg she destroxed the song ... im sorry kahi but that was not good :(

[glamgal2227]

@GreekMorrison

that was nana rapping bekah's part not kahi. not to be mean just saying

[Kahi520]

@GreekMorrison You're funny!!!

[GreekMorrison]

bekha is missing. nana is cool, i like her .. but the rap .. no ... just bekha ! :-(

[xiaoyu1508]

BEKAH :'( 

[chazaki2]

sexy girls i love after school :D

[iloveafterschool100]

Im kinda mad that Nana couldnt finish her rap that was weird.

[jadensuh]

E-Young has no part for Because of You... Ugh I am so sick of this!

[KynoPygan]

@jadensuh Well, why would she? She wasn't part of the group when Because of You was released and there are no parts to replace. Kind of like when Uee, Nana and Raina performed Ah! with the others.

[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

Nana's mic isn't working in the half of the rap ... They used the old BOY Backup song

[Fankyfy1]

that awkward moment when Bekah's voice comes out of Nana... O_o

[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

@ShahMagpies Yeah she raps great in Funny Hunny, But nana's rap in Shanghai Romance & Shampoo id so much better. Lizzy's better stick with Vocal. Lizzy's voice is powerful & she is One of the best singer in AS.

[TheCokiies]

nana

[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

I hope nana or eyoung will replace Bekah's Part in Jap Ver of BOY, I'm tired of listening to kahi's rap, And Lizzy's rap is awful... Raina can rap but she is already a main vocalist, JungAh is the same.. So i hope Nana/E-Young will rap in Jap BOY :)

[ShahMagpies]

@AndreGayPlayBoyz Lizzy is a great rapper.. just listen to Funny Hunny, OC's new digital single.. she can raps

[abcdefgh6893]

nana is so cute..i mean her rapping part..hihihihi..like it..~_~

[ractep]

to whoever Playgirlz here, could we be more considerate? it's true no one can replace Bekah's part..but please, the rap just doesn't suit other members well. can we just appreciate whoever taking over bekah's part w/out comparing her to bekah or ask bekah to comeback?i'm sorry but it's kind of disrespect since the fact is bekah has left n the other member's had to work hard since then..i'm so sad with this kind of attitude from Playgirlz. we should be more supportive, not condemn them..

[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

Why don't They just give E-Young 1 of Kahi's rap.. Or The 'Ajikdo Na Geudaereul Ichi Mothae' Part!!!

[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

NANA's rap is AMAZING compared to LIZZY'S But it's nothing if compared to Bekah

[honeymango90]

UEE is busy with her filming for Ojakgyo Brothers/Family. Hope that helps those whose asking for UEE. :D Yeah I miss to see her in this performance too.

[vitastring01315]

I'm a die hard fan of them. BUT NANA CAN'T REPLACE BEKAH. :|

[landaxGila]

oh please...it's true no one can't replace Bekah part rap but someone have to do it no matter how you like it or not, can we just not make this a big deal

[KiiMSamia]

Im sorry but Nana cant replace Bekah's part rap !!



[AndreGayPlayBoyz]

i hope the composer give the members an equal part in jap version. and i hope they won't add crazy electro or something like that in BOY Jap.Version

[XxJoCaRxX]

i wonder how will be the lines distributed in the Japanese Version of this song.. I hope they distribute it fair..

[yume816]

I can't believe Jung Joori is Mcing and so poised. I feel like any second now, she is going to burst out and do a funny dance. lol

[lLette27]

E-Young who.....-_-

[veebo]

where's uee?

[StephyTangFan]

It was random when Bekah's rap suddenly appeared right after Nana was done her rap part.

[hqqed]

ok my bad. first song nana covered bekah parts while kahi did the second.

[hqqed]

FYI it was nana who did bekah part not kahi

[WarClaud]

I don't get why they didn't give E-Young at least one UEE line

[ubergamer2010]

Whoever produced this concert did a horrible job with the audio and the sound system. The only people I could hear were Jungah and Raina because they were loud enough to hear over the backtrack. Kahi had no backtrack so you could hear her. But for Nana and Lizzy, I couldn't hear them because of the loud backtrack! Not impressed with the editing and production of this concert, but good job After School.

[zmil3z]

oh!

the all-black costume!

have i seen them in this b4.. hmm, during Shampoo's promotion..

[princessViolet1602]

no UEE?? again??? T-T

[Kimeru0902]

nana!!! rap~~~~ duno why i love her rap side so much xD

[zhaowei05]

jung ah omma, hwaiting!!! ^_^

[ajehsapik]

i love it when nana rap!

[NanaLizzyAS]

jooyoen look beautiful here!like the hairstyle!

[shuddupboi]

Jooyeon look like Nana from some angle with her perm hair tied up :o Cos Nana have the same hairstyle before, AND IT WAS AWESOME

[greenminded3]

well, what can i say? jooyeon is the face of the group from the start till then!!! fighting jooyeon kyeopta saranghaeyo!!!

[h5119uy]

Nana ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

[weizhi35]

Juyeon look so pretty now.. :D

[EverlastingPlayGirlz]

Juyeon looks really pretty with her hair up!

[MrDambiSchool]

Kahi needs to take her fierce juice again. Her raps arent as powerful as they used to be. In BOY she use to be so explosive so powerful and full of emotion. AS has been doing too much soft and cute lately I felt this BOY performance wasnt as fully out as I would of liked it =(

[yotaubanguyen2010]

@MrDambiSchool i think the only reason why they didnt sing powerful enough is they were so tired.just that

[cherista]

jung juri...jung juri...miss that girL and her crazy funny days...love you too<3 lol

[cherista]

awwww...my two fave song...where is Uee...i wish she was here...she is probably too busy with her drama...because of you isnt the same without her and bekah...<3..but beside that afterschool is gorgeous in the mini black dress...<3

[fullerene61Jr]

Yeeeeeey!! Juyeon juyeon Fighteeeeen!!!!!!!

[akumademoiselle]

Love Jung Ah and Juyeon's hair. Nana and Jung Ah sounds sick (or maybe it's just Jung Ah's natural husky voice). I miss Bekah even more when suddenly I could hear her voice (lol, I thought I was imagining things).

[zlau818]

LOL Bekah's voice suddenly appeared in BOY...sigh...

what did they talk about Raina in the interview part?

[iamapersonish]

@zlau818 I think they are talking about Ulsan(the place they perform here),which is Raina's hometown, then she said her parents are here too(? sth like that :)

[officialkimchiguy]

JUYEON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[l0vehong89]

Oh NOOoooo~ Nana, are you alright?? Don't get sick, please take good care of your health... if you sick, i'll sick too~~

Nana, 사랑해!

[sarrski]

why do I suddenly hear Bekah's voice?.... :"""( I miss her so bad.

[xamaewee]

wah Because of You!!! :'D i love this song! i became a fan 'coz of this. i really miss BoY era... very different... TT^TT miss Bekah's rap but at the same time, i love Nana's rap. she has such a unique voice and also has this swag when she sings or rap. :) hmmm... i hope there will be a better quality vid out there soon... XD

[memoriesinmyhead]

Bekah T.T

[StrawberryxPain]

Bekah ;__________________; Bekah ;___________;

[jeany138]

OH MY GOD I LOVE BECAUSE OF YOU SO MUCH XD GLAD THAT THEY PERFORM THIS AGAIN XD AND OFC WITH NANA'S RAP REPLACE BEKAH >O< I REALLY LOVE IT but wait a minute why is suddenly become playback?? (because i can hear Bekah's rap on Nana's :(

[CHUNGZZZZ]

I really love Shampoo...

[afieyzaini]

Wait what? why did nana's voice suddenly change to bekah's halfway at b.o.y.? not that im complaining... Is making me miss Bekah more ;/

[bumboomable]

them so beautiful^-^

no uieT_T

[MTV327]

Aww... Gahee is not suitable to replace Bekah's part ... no one can do it except Bekah herself ... bekah comeback please....

[yotaubanguyen2010]

@MTV327 she left AS to reach her dream.Bekah will be sad if she sees your comment.I'm sure that AS's members are really sad,too

[gimmiemycookies111]

@yotaubanguyen2010 Not trying to stir the pot but you obviously don't know the real story. Look it up.

[yotaubanguyen2010]

@gimmiemycookies111 how can i know the real story?bcause i'm not a member of AS and i'm not working in Pledis.And you too.we cant know wat happened to Bekah or AS.but i know that other members were really sad..before Bekah left AS,Kahi,JungAh,Juyeon tweeted many negative things.However,if you are a real Playgirlz/Playboyz,plz support AS instead of saying those things

[MTV327]

Aww... why they dont give E-young solo part in because of you?

[ractep]

i love their hairs like this..but if jungah has it longer, it would be more than nice!! :D

nice performance!~

[MinhyMoon]

Oh my JungAh you seem so tired here but still gorgeous !!! Jung Ah <3