x factor 4 hope hurt showdown

[jhamblin23]

ew this is really bad. i can sing it better lol

[nichi93]

Is not she's song. Don't like it.

[bestgrimbarianever]

phoebe was gorgeous, i had such a crush on her ;)

[56nfm]

@bestgrimbarianever : search Bruno Mars cover by Phoebe Brown!! :)

[jayomafia]

you also cant spell,out of tune maybe but still a beautiful voice

[hawk670]

Phoebe did so well singing this :):)

[pemie2]

listen carefully 0:14 , 0:17, 0:30, 1:43 those are too bad for the ears...and the others are tolerable....

[pemie2]

this is maybe their weakest week phoebe is getting several flats and sharp// its better for them to sing with the harmony 

[D1amondFOREVA13]

why does simon keep lookin back hes the H8TR around here

[bex18xx]

Get phoebe to sing this now! she would be the bollocks! <33

Phoebe Jo brown! <3 xx

[thecrew221]

Its nice to see that Some Husbands,Let their Wives out and have some fun.I guess having Babies and cooking can get boring at times.

[fleurdefietska]

I don't feel anything when she sings this song but when christina sings it I can cry my eyes out. I don't really like them and the lead-singer was off-key a lot!

[96raindrop96]

why r they only 5 when they were 6 in bootcamp??? did some1 leave???

[hawk670]

Awsome video hope were amazing

[DiamondMimiF]

the lead singer... i forgot her name... looks a lot like annie from 90210 in this video

[Sworn90]

yeaaa..... totally flat.. lol

[XgreenjacketX]

very out of tune at the start...but look how pretty she is!!

[hawk670]

this is so amazing :D

[Rhia7770b]

She's a good singer but completely flatt.

[lmcn88]

Ouch...she sounds like a cat being strangled!

[KekkoNeoliceale]

sorry but i think she isn't as good to sing this song,, she's good but a christina's song is too much for her i suppose.. she's out of tune

[thelucy53]

She's absolutley amazing, what you on about!!!!

[hawk670]

phoebe is stunning and such a good singer

[krizdoyle21]

phoebe is so gorgeous xx

[rachel2j]

Pheobe In "Girls Cant Catch"

[im1funkyfish]

Phoebe was carrying the whole band

[titchhibbert]

she was shit.

[flopster69]

wow..painfully out of tune

[hondacrazy123]

she is hot the one in the middle lol

[MusicProductions4321]

lucie was better in bootcamp!!!!

[thelucy3703]

It is a little out of tune but it still sends shivers down teh spine!!!

[Alex4u]

out of tune. aguilera overshadows everyone

[hondacrazy123]

who gives a monkys they are beautiful

[darksterboy]

yup i agree... out of tune since the very first line... the lead singer is not good enough...

[CharleeeeEmm]

urm. did they others not want to sing ?

[mikebenjislove123]

they wanted Phoebe aka the strong voice only to sing to carry the group if not it will be a disaster

[hawk670]

love this proformance, i love phoebes voice its amazing

[beccaRed11]

out of tune and flat... and she sounds like she strugling

[PushTenBaby1994]

Phoebe Brown, is fantastic, she is so pritty too. Check out Girls Cant Catch, her new Group, theyre amazing !

[dabrat80]

phoebe is hot

[diiiaaannneee]

they remind me of the saturdays

[paul105424]

cann't agree more.she was out of tune alote of times

[armhartwell]

.....esp. after just just listening to christina aguilera's version

[helen94x]

i know they wanted to show them at their strongest so they used phoebe, as she was a really good singer, but i don't think it was right to put her doing a solo act.

[bcrocker33]

i am probably the only one that thinks phoebe isn't so fabulous...she can be very flat at times. there is a reason they put them together as a group from solo artists.

[bluemoon307]

her vocals sound forced and not natural

[bcrocker33]

2:16 wonder what simon was responding too. apparently she has gotten better now

[pacinoexhale]

the blonde one needs to get bent over and slammed ragged!! shes hot!!

[angelblu123]

ouch!

[hawk670]

phoebe is brilliant

[abidkhan13]

fhfjfhlfoifdlfifjhhfkfjkfijlfd­odddhkdjddbffbdddffhfflfoopfff­hgfhfujffoooffhffjhfnbjhjf0f0o­fliflfjhflnfedbgdbbbbbbbbbbbhb­fjfjnhfffffffffffkfjmfjkkfkfkk­kkkjfkjfkj,mj,ppoffjllij-fhffj­hddlldddddliddjhffdooodkjytrdj­hrdgeddegdgdhdbhesngedyjhddhgg­gggghhhjjj

[alongcamesummer]

lol ve had days like that

[buntybabii]

she looks so old for 16, im 16 and me and every1 in my year look so much younger than she did at our age lol

[singingsuperstarr]

...continued!!! also she is flat or out of tune which really makes it sound bad

[bcrocker33]

agree

[singingsuperstarr]

i never liked them on the x factor sheis now in a group called girls cant catch but on x factor she cudnt sing i duno how they got as far as they did take this song for example she is screaming down the mic.

[samwellfoden]

she can't sing for shit.

she can't do trills either

[ThaRealMckoy3]

she sings soo out of tune lol

[holpin95]

that girl that sang first is in the new group girls cant catch and there well good

[SarahBaybiiOx99Ox]

what about leona lewis? :)

[TheyWaitAtTheDoor]

hmmm, thats interesting. Why do you think American Idol is much more of a serious talent search? I've only seen a few individual X-factor performances on youtube so I can't really compare for myself. By the way, are some of the groups on X factor comprised of rejects from the solo auditions?

[TheyWaitAtTheDoor]

uh I stll dont know. She wasn't horrible or anything, but she would never cut it on American Idol. Her tone is fine, it just sounds to me like she needs work with her technique, so she clearly needs vocal lessons. And before, I never understood why someone would need vocal lessons. I thought you just sing, but apparently its not that simple.

She needed lessons or just shouldn't have sang lead at that time. :)

[TheyWaitAtTheDoor]

Well obviously you know what I meant: she is not good enough to be singing lead in a group for as much as she does in this performance.

[TheyWaitAtTheDoor]

Why is this girl singing?

[loverofhannahmontana]

i used to really like these girls but then i listen to them 2 years on and think woow they are so out of timee

but they did try there best

[pavcy]

OUT OF KEY!!!

[PrincessGraciousX]

Very off key.... Eeek

[markymoo22]

She was excellent and also is now in a group called Girls Can't Catch supporting Girls Aloud on this years tour....i think they will do really well Girls Can't Catch, you heard it here first :O)

Good luck girl

[princessicing]

Personaly i kno this is a very hard song bit theve come quite far and they should ave got there harmonys and solos better innit so,i think its kindaa outta tunee: x

Buh bless them for trying

[ALnXfactor]

all you can hear is phoebe... it's like it's her solo performance and shes got a few backing singers...

[charlottesmithx]

they were amazing!!!!!

[MGirlsAloudFan]

I think they were one of the best acts last year, love them :)

[EmmerB9]

I Though They Were Really Good .......

I Though This Was A Hard Song

I Was Wrong

x

[xxxinterludexxx]

So fuckin out fo tune!!!

[nfm56]

xxxInterludexxx-I was in the audience. Superb live performance.Each to their fucking own- to use your phrase......

[xxmadxx378]

ok so yeh phoebe ain't no christina, but damn she did well!!! she did really really well!!!

[BamAtticusFreegrove]

phoebe rocks. nuff said.

[gnorm22]

OK, she's no Christina Aguilera but it's a tough vocal. How the hell did Leon win!! My farts are more tuneful than him!!

[KirstySpencer1991]

@gnorm22 Leon won because of a small thing called TALENT. Yes. Phoebe is amazingly talented, but so is Leon.

[gnorm22]

@KirstySpencer1991 I think we'll have to agree to differ on the Leon thing Kirsty!

[KirstySpencer1991]

@gnorm22 Well I saw Leon at his gig last week, so I heard his talent live.

[gnorm22]

@KirstySpencer1991 Life's all about differing opinions. Glad you enjoyed the gig though

[xxxjessrules01xxx]

luv it!!

[rikkiwonka75]

Unfortunately they were not very good. They are fit though! They give me the horn!

[martinobrien87]

i agree, they should have won

[nfm56]

She was 16 at the time! A realist who took time to come on here a year later & listen. They obviously stuck in your mind........

[joyofjoyuk]

well said!

[hawk670]

hope are amazing phoebe did a fantastic job on lead

[xtarabarryx]

hope so should have won!

way better than leon

[fahd1951]

Damn Best ever

[unrealboot1]

pheobe is oen of the hottest girls eva

[hawk670]

very true

[71A08]

Phoebe was the best<3

Did Hope split up?

[xA1Mzx]

Nopee there still together =D

[71A08]

ok thanks :)

[hawk670]

no there still going

[xxxjessrules01xxx]

i liked it

[101safa]

PHOEBE IS AMAZING!!!

[garfield266]

love's it!!

[bkp2012]

hope were amazing - and I love pheobe. :)

If they weren't going to win x factor then no group will.

They had power, enthusiasm, emotion and a sense of fun.

Also love umbrella

[tetronell]

really liked that song...and also umbrella too....

[Votel]

I'm so hapy to find this clip on here...it's my favourite X Factor performances in all of the series. Phoebe is stunning, puts so much emotion into it. Plus she's absolutely beautiful...and I'm a gay man!

[nfm56]

What a lovely comment!

Her mum

[Votel]

OH mum!!! Hello...you've done such a great job. Just have an inkling your daughter is going to mighty big if she sticks at it. Her 'hurt' performance truly brings me to tears whenever I watch it...and I do get out and about - not a saddo! Phil

[nfm56]

It was my favourite performance, too. But I know I am biased. She sang it at her audition & it's such a hard song. I get so fed up with people on here saying she's rubbish!Still, they are entitled to their opinions-that's why we have forums. But Phoebe has a career in the music business, of that I'm sure!!

Her Mum......again!!

[yaspaige]

its shit

[sweetinsanity416]

i dont understand what all the hype is about this girl. she's really nothing great, at all.

now leona lewis, that's a remarkable talent.

[hawk670]

hi every one when i said phoebes crap i did not mean it i was replying to someones comment

[hawk670]

i wouldnt say enything bad about phoebe shes fantastic

[hawk670]

oh right soz

[phoebebrownhopefan]

Favourite performance from the whole series! Phoebe was AMAZING on this song! Phoebe and all the girls are beautiful ladies!!!

[xA1Mzx]

This performance was brilliant!

[AlexHowes93]

Phoebe is beautiful

[hedgecutter]

I loved the emotion she put into that performance, a true talent!

[soapfan43]

phoebe is a well gd singer she wud do beta on her own i fink

[cassiebrookes76]

oh shut up just coz shes a gd singer..no need to get jelous now..but ill agree tht tall 1 is good and phoebe is pretty

[belkproductions]

completely wrong song.

worst performance by them.

that girl was taking over that band, cant you let the tall girl sing, shes proberbly the best. plus throughout the whole series, there was no speeking from her, that phobe person is quite ugly to b honest.

taking over the group.

[nfm56]

OMG Belkproductions-this is hysterical! Is that all you can think to say? Commenting that someone is ugly when you can't think of anything else to say is profoundly childish! Playground fodder. Made me laugh though!

[carebear4841]

can anybody please tell who is simon looking at (at 2:17) thanks

[carebear4841]

can anybody please put the judge comment thanks

[eleisha92]

this is the showdown, there weren't any comments

[carebear4841]

thanks

[wayneabc123]

i didnt think she was as good as people made out she was like in this song she out of tune alot , and i think it was unfair on the other 4 because near the end they were turned into backup singers

[dasisbabe]

i'm sorry but thats rubbish. she was in tune the entire song. yes a different song prob would have been better as it would have been more inclusive, but it would have been silly to try and get all five singing this together.

[BGrade15]

I agree, and what's more...a 16 year old girl to keep in control of that melody and pull off a Christina song is amazing!

[LilyLuu13]

I Agree With SameDifferenceNo1

[hayleyflear]

was they in last years x factor or year befor

[SameDifferenceNo1]

Phoebe should of been a solo artist she would of went far couldnt you see the passion like dannii said

[xyzizzle]

Phoebe has a nice voice, but she was hyped up way too much in the group. Also, I didn't think this was the greatest performance. She was hitting it very flat. Plus, she was pushing her voice too much. It would've been a lot better if she sang a different song.

[RoxyGirlFlowers]

Hi can sum1 please tell me wat the track is called 4 dis song dat dey are singing 2. thanks i wud appricate it....

[xA1Mzx]

Its called Hurt

=)

[hluiscp]

and its hurts me =*(....oh....

[dudefromskye]

Phoebe looks alot better without the blonde bit on her hair!

[MissLKS]

yeah phoebe isnt great.. every one said she was amazing but she really wasnt :S

[xA1Mzx]

She is great!

[BabyMimi00]

why did they let her sing christina aguilera?

[baileyleo]

phoebes fuckin crap!!!!

[nfm56]

All I will say is you will all eat your negativewords. Hope are gonna be HUGE!!

nm

[hawk670]

phoebes crap what are u on phoebes fantastic

[nfm56]

Daniel-I think your comment is being mis-interpreted! If you put a full stop after 'crap' & a question mark after 'on' it changes the whole meaning of what you are trying to say!! HOPE you don't mind me pointing this out!!!

[hawk670]

phoebes  vocals are great

[tew2007]

peerless vocals

[amz1990]

So... where did the rest of the group come into it then?

[minime111112]

poor phoboe sung her heart out