@ocean686. So, you mean that all bands in the sameish genre tries to emulate, thus copying, some original group? I believe that was this weeks dumbest end most unintelligent comment. Please, stop listening to quality music immediately. You, as a listener, is not worth the sheet of paper it was written on!
@ocean686 Marbles: One of the best albums ever! Such darn good quality both in the lyrics and in the music. It must be a jewel for anyone who's ever heard it.
Marillion with Fish was taking the band down some Scottish roots which was becoming a bit of a disaster for them , when Hogarth appeared on the scene Marillion had another bite at the cherry. Long may they continue .
@flashchrome Yes, I can't believe there's still people who say things like this... 1988-2011: a great number of years to forgive Fish for leaving the band! Hogarth brought it back to life and he is just brilliant!
Steve is not fish, and maybe this song doesnt sound like before, but this song is a little soppy and lame,like mostly marillion's song when fish was singing. Fortunately for Marillion, H is coming
I really wish Steve Hogarth would leave the Fish era stuff alone. He doesn't (in any of his interviews) have any time for it and he sings it in a way to show off his voice, just sounds soppy and lame.
Hogarths voice is certainly aging better than Fish's but this will always be his song
Lukester2307 2 months ago
What A KNOB, leave the FISH era of Marillion where it is, in the past. Marillion died when Fish left. FACT.
jasonctennant 3 months ago 3
@jasonctennant Spoken like a true pratt...
petesapwell 2 months ago
Check out Marbles - probably the best prog album they ever did withot trying to emulate Gabriel's Genesis
ocean686 6 months ago
@ocean686. So, you mean that all bands in the sameish genre tries to emulate, thus copying, some original group? I believe that was this weeks dumbest end most unintelligent comment. Please, stop listening to quality music immediately. You, as a listener, is not worth the sheet of paper it was written on!
flashchrome 4 months ago
@ocean686 Marbles: One of the best albums ever! Such darn good quality both in the lyrics and in the music. It must be a jewel for anyone who's ever heard it.
Cristinact 3 months ago
Marillion with Fish was taking the band down some Scottish roots which was becoming a bit of a disaster for them , when Hogarth appeared on the scene Marillion had another bite at the cherry. Long may they continue .
tich95081 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yes Hogy cant sing Any Fish songs definitely
Marillion without Fish it´s very poor, mediocre. sincerely!!!!
Gomestech 7 months ago
What??? THey were in RIGA, LATVIA> Where the fuck was I? Why wasn't their concert advrtised????? why didn't i know about it???????
RudolphAlder 10 months ago
@RudolphAlder Because the estonian promoters didn't bother with advertising! That's why there were only about 300 people in the audience:(
Churikoff 10 months ago
Very sensitive song, makes me cry ;(
mariangeorgiev1 1 year ago
But the rest of the band can play 'em, so wat ya gonna do?
InternationalNobody 1 year ago
Yes Hogy cant sing Any Fish songs
TheCredo77 1 year ago
@TheCredo77. So he "faked" it for 20 odd years? Come on, get over it.
flashchrome 4 months ago
@flashchrome Yes, I can't believe there's still people who say things like this... 1988-2011: a great number of years to forgive Fish for leaving the band! Hogarth brought it back to life and he is just brilliant!
Cristinact 3 months ago
i quite enjoy hearing hogarth singing this song,
i love fish, but hogarth is a better singer(techiically), i dont doubt that. but he misses fish's venom.
basically what im saying is, enjoy the older tunes too.
dickyhart 2 years ago
"he sings it in a way to show off his voice"--no shit, Sherlock; he's a singer. Your comment makes no sense whatsoever. :P
Btw, I love this song with both singers and think it's the best Fish-era song h sings.
shayebreed 2 years ago
Fish was a dominant personality , H is a great singer and the song is awesome.Simple!
afficionado2004 2 years ago
Steve is not fish, and maybe this song doesnt sound like before, but this song is a little soppy and lame,like mostly marillion's song when fish was singing. Fortunately for Marillion, H is coming
arnopaul 2 years ago
I really wish Steve Hogarth would leave the Fish era stuff alone. He doesn't (in any of his interviews) have any time for it and he sings it in a way to show off his voice, just sounds soppy and lame.
shimmer1 2 years ago
I agree.
timtunes42 2 years ago