Added: 2 years ago
From: Churikoff
Views: 9,425
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (21)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hogarths voice is certainly aging better than Fish's but this will always be his song

  • What A KNOB, leave the FISH era of Marillion where it is, in the past. Marillion died when Fish left. FACT.

  • @jasonctennant Spoken like a true pratt...

  • Check out Marbles  - probably the best prog album they ever did withot trying to emulate Gabriel's Genesis

  • @ocean686. So, you mean that all bands in the sameish genre tries to emulate, thus copying, some original group? I believe that was this weeks dumbest end most unintelligent comment. Please, stop listening to quality music immediately. You, as a listener, is not worth the sheet of paper it was written on!

  • @ocean686 Marbles: One of the best albums ever! Such darn good quality both in the lyrics and in the music. It must be a jewel for anyone who's ever heard it.

  • Marillion with Fish was taking the band down some Scottish roots which was becoming a bit of a disaster for them , when Hogarth appeared on the scene Marillion had another bite at the cherry. Long may they continue .

  • What??? THey were in RIGA, LATVIA> Where the fuck was I? Why wasn't their concert advrtised????? why didn't i know about it???????

  • @RudolphAlder Because the estonian promoters didn't bother with advertising! That's why there were only about 300 people in the audience:(

  • Very sensitive song, makes me cry ;(

  • But the rest of the band can play 'em, so wat ya gonna do?

  • Yes Hogy cant sing Any Fish songs

  • @TheCredo77. So he "faked" it for 20 odd years? Come on, get over it.

  • @flashchrome Yes, I can't believe there's still people who say things like this... 1988-2011: a great number of years to forgive Fish for leaving the band! Hogarth brought it back to life and he is just brilliant!

  • i quite enjoy hearing hogarth singing this song,

    i love fish, but hogarth is a better singer(techiically), i dont doubt that. but he misses fish's venom.

    basically what im saying is, enjoy the older tunes too.

  • "he sings it in a way to show off his voice"--no shit, Sherlock; he's a singer. Your comment makes no sense whatsoever. :P

    Btw, I love this song with both singers and think it's the best Fish-era song h sings.

  • Fish was a dominant personality , H is a great singer and the song is awesome.Simple!

  • Steve is not fish, and maybe this song doesnt sound like before, but this song is a little soppy and lame,like mostly marillion's song when fish was singing. Fortunately for Marillion, H is coming

  • I really wish Steve Hogarth would leave the Fish era stuff alone. He doesn't (in any of his interviews) have any time for it and he sings it in a way to show off his voice, just sounds soppy and lame.

  • I agree.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more