You people need to stop making fun of her for two reasons:
#1-She was only 7 or 8 here and had'nt gone through puberty yet.
#2- One of the main reasons she ended up with bulimia and a cutting disorder is because, she was made fun of about her weight and it really upset her and drove her to do those things ! O.K do i need anymore reasons ?
It's sad how people judges a person on how they look. So what if this or that or you are more beautiful than her? After 40 years, everyone will look saggy. Don't be shallow. Physical appearance doesn't define a person, her/his personality does.
you can't hate if you don't even know her story. Like stfu, she was so cute then, you can't make fun of her if she has stupid baby fat, everyone has it.
everyone has a little puppy fat when their younger, seriously. i did, all kids do. :) it's natural. <3 she has a gift, she could seriously sing then, and now. :
@paloma131532 why don't you wan't somone to reply so bad? Afraid of the comments? You shouldnt put up a comment if you are scared of the responses...that means you don't really believe in what you are saying. Demi aside, I hope you get over your fear of confrontation for your own sake!
@paloma131532 I think that you are...but it's just my opinion. I don't personally know you, so I won't judge. By the way you may want to concentrate on your spelling too...people lose respect for you try to bring an arguement and don't use the right spelling and grammar...just another tip ;-)
@paloma131532 So you came on here, just to say that you hate Demi? That's like going to Mcdonalds and telling the manager "I hate Mcdonalds!" don't come on here if you don't like her...trolling isn't necessary, it just shows that you believe in Cyber Bullying which will lead to trouble in life ahead of you. Stay in school!
aww poor demi please dont bully her she was 7-8 years old whould u walk up to her when she was little and say he kid ur ugly i wouldnt becuz she was born like that she didnt choose to look like that she was a little girl and was made like that by gosh
She wore glasses, she has contacts, she was so happy the day she threw her glasses out, she litterally threw them in the trash can and was happy, then when she was 13, she decided it was nice to have glasses too, and she got a new pair. so she has contacts and glasses now! :)
OMG> i totally remember watching this when i was like 7. i had no idea that this little girl would grow up to be so successful and beautiful. WAY 2 GO DEMI!!
She looks way different I didn't know that was her untill she started singing....She looks way better now then back then. I think she dosn't look very cute with glasses.
Did it ever occur to you people that Demi looked the way she did partially because her Barney character called for it? I know that most kids on this long-running program are nearly true to form on camera, but there has to be some set ideas in the writing that suggests what roles, or day I say it labels, the kids should have. I personally cannot believe this is her, she looks darker and her features suggest mulatto. It's almost as if she switched bodies in the years since this first aired.
You would probably bash on her too if she wasn't "hot" right now, but still the chubby big kid as a girl. So you're actually being a retard as well. I actually wouldn't mind if she was that chubby self right now, her smile and great singing makes it up for all of it.
how stupid r u guys to call a 8 year old ugly!? yes its demi and she got made fun of wen she was in school! she doesnt need any more crap online so shut ur faces!
Hehe I see the gap tooth that demi talked about in her own video that miley and mandy made fun of. just to make clear: not an insult, just an observation. demi rocks :) before she was chubby and now she's pretty.
She's fake cuz in her songz you can totally tell it's not her voice, it's her voice but they totally changed in the studio, she is ugly, has really red big ugly lips, and is the worst actor on disney channel
you don't amuse anyone. If you wanna insult someone, then jsut tell the truth. Look her up, singing the national anthem. when i was watching that video, my whole household ran to me like "who is that?! its amazing!" na im like "demi lovato" and theyre all "she's ONLY 16?! with THAT voice??"
dude, get over it. she's talented and not fake. dont hate her because of jealousy or rumors about who she's dating or who's her rival or whatever....
Oh wow. I meant that YOU CAN'T JUDGE HER LIKE THAT IF YOU DONT EVEN KNOW YOU.
i dont even know you, at all. but hey ill just call you dumb and boring.
now, that isn't fair?[btw that was just an example]
look im not trying to change your opinion about demi but im just trying to tell you that the way you just blurt out "demi is immature" sounds a little...like something a 7 year old would say, considering you dont even know her. well yeah.. i guess thats just the end of it. :-) bye
and you need to say that why? compare yourself to demi, I'm sure your nearly not as pretty as she is next time you want to go and put people down go take a good look in the mirror because everyone knows your not perfect
i am laughing so hard right now just remember this is barney..little kids might watch this video so i would watch the language i dont even know why im replying to you all the time you want people to stop hating on miley then stop hating on everyone else for not liking her
like if you really answered barney!!!
mizstevey13 1 month ago
she isn't fat! she's adorable!
LILjazzjazz 2 months ago
@GoodLuckCharlieTVDIS ok she didn't cut herself until age 11, and how old is she in Barney? Uhm, yah definitely not 11 so stfu
Averyrox333 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
:) I love Demi Lovato:))
powkrt 6 months ago
AWW Demi's sooo cutee!!
turtlesxx3 6 months ago
Shes soo cute looking!!
agdollvideo777 7 months ago
@kryziaa go to hell and shut up!
Kadeebee089 7 months ago
demiiiiiiiiiiiiiii love you soo much you make me so strong!
redrosses95 7 months ago
HATERS GO TO HELL !!!
KimCamba 7 months ago
You people need to stop making fun of her for two reasons:
#1-She was only 7 or 8 here and had'nt gone through puberty yet.
#2- One of the main reasons she ended up with bulimia and a cutting disorder is because, she was made fun of about her weight and it really upset her and drove her to do those things ! O.K do i need anymore reasons ?
ash19964 8 months ago 2
jelly beans!! oh little jack lets go to rehab!!!:D:D:D
gago12335 8 months ago
@gago12335 Shut up jerk
turtlesxx3 6 months ago
demi is just amazing :D
xPrincessAriel101x 8 months ago
It's sad how people judges a person on how they look. So what if this or that or you are more beautiful than her? After 40 years, everyone will look saggy. Don't be shallow. Physical appearance doesn't define a person, her/his personality does.
charmzuy 8 months ago
you can't hate if you don't even know her story. Like stfu, she was so cute then, you can't make fun of her if she has stupid baby fat, everyone has it.
snowboarder997 9 months ago
because shes gross, abnoxious and...DEMI LAVATO!!!
featherfriends1 9 months ago
@featherfriends1 it helps if you can spell her name right, and i bet you don't even know what obnoxious means.
snowboarder997 9 months ago
@snowboarder997 It was a typing mistake, and I do know what obnoxious means. And just because I'm young, doesn't mean I'm dumber than you.
featherfriends1 9 months ago
@featherfriends1 STFU LITTLE DUMBASS !!
robstenfan021 8 months ago
GO DEMI!!!
TheMedbXx 9 months ago
I hate Demi Lovato eww
featherfriends1 10 months ago
@featherfriends1 why?
HaileyPinky 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SHE WAS AN AMAZING SINGER BACK THEN TOO!!!!!!!!!!! AND SHE WAS AN EXTREMELY GREAT ACTRESS BACK THEN TOO!!!!!!!!!!!! GO DEMI!!!!!!!
TaylorSwiftFan189 11 months ago
SHE WAS AN AMAZING SINGER BACK THEN TOO!!!!!!!!!!! AND SHE WAS AN EXTREMELY GREAT ACTRESS BACK THEN TOO!!!!!!!!!!!!
TaylorSwiftFan189 11 months ago
she has ugly duckling sydrome
kryziaa 11 months ago
u can see her cuts!!!!
GoodLuckCharlieTVDIS 11 months ago
everyone has a little puppy fat when their younger, seriously. i did, all kids do. :) it's natural. <3 she has a gift, she could seriously sing then, and now. :
OiSuportingNAndZ 11 months ago 4
DEMI IS ADORABLE SOOOO STOP HATING
mooaclaessson 11 months ago 3
ohhhhh
emelec2013 11 months ago
i watching this with my brother the other day and had no idea this was her
kaykay61894 1 year ago
gordaa!
luniiz49 1 year ago
O.M.F.G
mrwhiskersss 1 year ago
Demi!!you are soo cool..and cute too
dalisma96 1 year ago 7
Demi!!you are soo cool..
dalisma96 1 year ago 4
Demi sings better than BarnieXD
YaelJoB 1 year ago 7
dont judge demi was beautiful then and she is even more beautiful now.
wesupportDemilovato1 1 year ago
She had a beautiful voice with 8 years <3
And now*_* Wow! A great voice
ItsJuleeee 1 year ago
i am ungly withh i be pretty i am 10 yearold
pinkmemarmaid1 1 year ago
Demi has really transformed into a beautiful young lady...
myasiandramaify 1 year ago
Demi is such a cute kid <3 Now she is beautiful <3 !!
ItsMelissa15 1 year ago
I didn't know Demi was on here. (^_^)
Lenuhz 1 year ago
@Lenuhz Selena was also on here
pokemonxd789 1 year ago
@pokemonxd789 I knew that, I can tell easily by her face. :3
But I didn't know Demi was on there. :x
Lenuhz 1 year ago
Cuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuute!! :D
AriadneOfficialMusic 1 year ago
sh e waz six
cassie11743 1 year ago
sO SWEET...BUT SHE IS SO MUCH BEAUTIFUL NOW!
Programa24 1 year ago 3
i hate demi.
i now u dont and maybe u hate me for hating her but once someone reply me: we dont care if u dont like her.
if you dont care WELL THEN DONT REPLY!!!!
paloma131532 1 year ago
@paloma131532 why don't you wan't somone to reply so bad? Afraid of the comments? You shouldnt put up a comment if you are scared of the responses...that means you don't really believe in what you are saying. Demi aside, I hope you get over your fear of confrontation for your own sake!
melovesme19 1 year ago
@melovesme19 i'm not afraid but it seems like u have nothing better to do in your hole life!!!!!
paloma131532 1 year ago
@paloma131532 I think that you are...but it's just my opinion. I don't personally know you, so I won't judge. By the way you may want to concentrate on your spelling too...people lose respect for you try to bring an arguement and don't use the right spelling and grammar...just another tip ;-)
melovesme19 1 year ago
@melovesme19 srry about the spelling but i'm from Argentina so i don't know a lot of english.
paloma131532 1 year ago
@paloma131532 oh I'm sorry then...I thought you were a little kid that was too young to be on here. My apologies!
melovesme19 1 year ago
@paloma131532 So you came on here, just to say that you hate Demi? That's like going to Mcdonalds and telling the manager "I hate Mcdonalds!" don't come on here if you don't like her...trolling isn't necessary, it just shows that you believe in Cyber Bullying which will lead to trouble in life ahead of you. Stay in school!
iluvredvines 1 year ago
@iluvredvines Praise the Lord!
iajakpo 1 year ago
@iajakpo Lol. Tell 'em!
iluvredvines 1 year ago
she is still ugly until now..... hahahahahahaha :)
musicsaddicted2me 1 year ago
Ur such an asshole, you wish you can be as beautiful as her!!
Ana1197 1 year ago
OMG,demi done dat 2? WTF? I hope the one of the jonas brothers done barney.I want da jonas brothers kill barney.
TheNinastar 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate demiiiiiii!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
paloma131532 2 years ago
NOBODY CARES IF YOU HATE HER
forevermorezanessa 2 years ago
and we hate youuuuuuuuu demi is pretty and talanted
thejobros4eva 1 year ago
i agree with u:)
amyzcollazo 1 year ago
aww thank you i love her so much and i just like if you hate em why watch them on youtube why type it in so you can leave hate comments
thejobros4eva 1 year ago
Your welcome hun so i do she is a very talented young lady and her voice is amazing plus she is very funny too!!! Love her in Sonny with a chance:)
amyzcollazo 1 year ago
same she can act sing and dance i love her in that show to she is one of my idols
thejobros4eva 1 year ago
how cute was she?! awee!
khendlewilliams 2 years ago
he should play that song at 1 of her concerts as a joke!
SuperJustinbieberbab 2 years ago
Watch Theicami (: Our newest show!
Theicami 2 years ago
Aww she looks so small lol she dosent look anything like herself!! and for those pple saying shes ugly right there, shes not that ugly!? wtf!
CurlyBrunttexD 2 years ago
i rememnber this episode!
mcenzie90089 2 years ago
she was so cute
cutiepienat777 2 years ago
aww poor demi please dont bully her she was 7-8 years old whould u walk up to her when she was little and say he kid ur ugly i wouldnt becuz she was born like that she didnt choose to look like that she was a little girl and was made like that by gosh
011amy 2 years ago 4
oh please it not about looks she was a sweet cute kid
santasound11 2 years ago 36
lol (:
EternalMem0ries 2 years ago
kool. hope u hav fun wit dat.
meacharm101 2 years ago
ok kool
have fun wit dat.
ps. dont u hav any better com backs?
i mean seriosly, its pathetic.
meacharm101 2 years ago
ok then...
thats good 2 no.
but hey, at least i live in a house not in cow shit.
meacharm101 2 years ago
no,
i think she was a cute little kid
meacharm101 2 years ago
hey she wore glasses!! so does she were contacts now?? or dis she wear it only for the show??
teenagegals 2 years ago
She wore glasses, she has contacts, she was so happy the day she threw her glasses out, she litterally threw them in the trash can and was happy, then when she was 13, she decided it was nice to have glasses too, and she got a new pair. so she has contacts and glasses now! :)
THATSsoBRiNA 2 years ago
shes a lil chubb
nicoleeemxoo 2 years ago
Demi is prettier now. But I got to addmit she is cute in this video!!
jjvn1998 2 years ago 5
aww ahe sounded awesome back then too
luvyajoejonas 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
selena is still prettier then demi :P
12GaugeFaceLift 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is mad ugly then.. but its worse now
PurpleCrayonBox 2 years ago
so right for saying that!!!!!!!!!!!!
musicsaddicted2me 1 year ago
DEMI'S SISTER Madison Delagarza
IS IN DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES AS
GABYS DAUGHTER ND SHE LOOKS LIKE DEMI AS A CHILD A BIT !
NEVER KNEW THT LMAO
missjuicycouture1 2 years ago 2
SHE HAD A GREAT VOICE THEN TO
myselfandir1 2 years ago 29
my mom says i look like her then and NOW
demisister1998 2 years ago
kool : )
meacharm101 2 years ago
aw....
ilovelibertyTYC 2 years ago
so cute!!!
hahaha!!!
"Dianara gia Torres"
Dianaratorres 2 years ago
CUTEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
karmenlicious95 2 years ago 2
it's funny!!
i watched them then
and i watch them now <3
soo i basically grew up with selena and demi since i was a kid (:
bluemonkeys95 2 years ago 2
My Mum And Dad Say I Always Just tew Watch It
i So Dont Memeba Them Though !!
RanGa
demi834 2 years ago
my mom says i used to watch her and selena all the time but i dont really remember
jonandkateplus812 2 years ago
she's so cute and chuby!
shortieepantss 2 years ago
sehe looks the same people duh!
cutiestrudel4u 2 years ago
she was a good singer even when she was little. and now shes amazzinggg =]]
JONASluver119 2 years ago
she looks ugly here but good thng shes hot now
candygirl997 2 years ago
im NOT calling her fat or anything, but she looks "bigger" here.
mhr987654321 2 years ago
yes this is true=S but now she is thin=D
iitzeel007 2 years ago
Omg i remember watching this like 6 years ago AND I REMEMBER HER (and Selena!!)
(She's a bit chubbyish but she looks like my older sister when she was like 10)
But Demi now looks GREAT!
MusicLuhve 2 years ago 3
OMG> i totally remember watching this when i was like 7. i had no idea that this little girl would grow up to be so successful and beautiful. WAY 2 GO DEMI!!
princess4life27 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont care how demi looked when she was a boy i still like her
marija459 2 years ago
were is she is she that girl with the jelly beans person well she looks so much better now!!!!!!!
skateingdiva321 2 years ago
OMFG X.O SHE DEMI LOOKS SO DIF NAO X_X
jenny4680 2 years ago
she was sooooo fucken ugly
but now shes gorgeous
11puppies11 2 years ago
wtf !!! demi !
sanferdaniel 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
demi is a fag
welovemileyfan 2 years ago
do u even knw wat that is?
aledemifan613 2 years ago
She looks way different I didn't know that was her untill she started singing....She looks way better now then back then. I think she dosn't look very cute with glasses.
sunshinedark123 2 years ago
OMG, she use to be so fat and tall with glasses. She's what you call transformation in a good way from past to present
RoberthIsCALIBER 2 years ago 2
was she da one with glasses?
hippopeace65 2 years ago
more ungly demi lobato
mas fea demi lobato jeje
agusssgc 2 years ago
Comment removed
agusssgc 2 years ago
demi lovato played a MOM?!!? oh wow....
chickenyfood123 2 years ago
omg shes changed so much selna gomez never changeged a bit but demi did shes looks much better now
emmaandkt 2 years ago 2
Did it ever occur to you people that Demi looked the way she did partially because her Barney character called for it? I know that most kids on this long-running program are nearly true to form on camera, but there has to be some set ideas in the writing that suggests what roles, or day I say it labels, the kids should have. I personally cannot believe this is her, she looks darker and her features suggest mulatto. It's almost as if she switched bodies in the years since this first aired.
VaultMasterDBT 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh shes not soo sweet like selena
ArmeniaHsmLady 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
my gawd she was UGLY!!!
well, some things never change hehe
LifeAquaticStudios 3 years ago
i didnt recognise her at first she looks completely different i couldnt even tell that was her
lilrandomdudette28 3 years ago 2
she was ugly when she was a kid but know oh my god change like a dark choclate to a milk choclate wonderful and gorgeous
82212253 3 years ago
hahaa
she was fat
and now she's hot
there is hope!
JBxChequishaa11 3 years ago
dude I bet all the people who made fun of Demi Lavato probably feels fucking retarded...
Doesn't matter what she was.. SHE IS HOTT now!
mibella 3 years ago 3
You would probably bash on her too if she wasn't "hot" right now, but still the chubby big kid as a girl. So you're actually being a retard as well. I actually wouldn't mind if she was that chubby self right now, her smile and great singing makes it up for all of it.
gawshurface7924 3 years ago
ok now im pissed off!
how stupid r u guys to call a 8 year old ugly!? yes its demi and she got made fun of wen she was in school! she doesnt need any more crap online so shut ur faces!
happygr12 3 years ago 15
@happygr12 Well, I Think She Is Beautiful & Sexy, Then & Now!!
paddyjoejr1 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@happygr12 You shut your face
shonuxs 1 year ago
yepp im sry to demi too but she was an ugly little kid DX
pianoqueen0913 3 years ago
heh OMG (sorry Demi) but u were kinda a geeky kid but look what u became u r stunning honi!!
wowza01kiddo 3 years ago
sorry demi but u were UGLY as a kid and look at u now
thebribrishow 3 years ago
She looked like a geek when she was little!!!
oh...soooo cute :):):)
Converse250 3 years ago
Hehe I see the gap tooth that demi talked about in her own video that miley and mandy made fun of. just to make clear: not an insult, just an observation. demi rocks :) before she was chubby and now she's pretty.
Disneyxisxmyxlife 3 years ago
she changed so much.
B0yCRaZyX0xo 3 years ago
omg i wuold never know that was her! selena gomez looks the sameeee tho! woww
who'da thoughtt?! haha
DAxxTHIKxxMAMi 3 years ago
lol I know!
MadeToBeLoved 3 years ago
at least she looks good now!, lol.
and "funnybunny8", none taken.
rsnegotiator 3 years ago
She looks so different but she looks way way prettier now
edavemishie 3 years ago 2
she looks like she was black!! no offence...
funbunny8 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
omg, i hate DEMI! Yuck! She is a fake stupid idiot! I hate her and hope she.....
Jennad51 3 years ago
She's better than you! How is she fake? Idiot.
VictoriaBuBbLeGuMz 3 years ago 2
She's fake cuz in her songz you can totally tell it's not her voice, it's her voice but they totally changed in the studio, she is ugly, has really red big ugly lips, and is the worst actor on disney channel
Jennad51 3 years ago
r ya talking about demi lavoto... last time i insulted her all these people started freaking out at me lol
xJBluver456 3 years ago
*yawn*
you don't amuse anyone. If you wanna insult someone, then jsut tell the truth. Look her up, singing the national anthem. when i was watching that video, my whole household ran to me like "who is that?! its amazing!" na im like "demi lovato" and theyre all "she's ONLY 16?! with THAT voice??"
dude, get over it. she's talented and not fake. dont hate her because of jealousy or rumors about who she's dating or who's her rival or whatever....
JemixShanie 3 years ago
right........ i dont hate her for any of those reasons.... i hate her cuz she is just imature and fake
Jennad51 3 years ago
do you even know her ?
JemixShanie 3 years ago
What do u mean do i know her, I dont know her in person duh, man u guys are hard to deal with!!!!
Jennad51 3 years ago
Oh wow. I meant that YOU CAN'T JUDGE HER LIKE THAT IF YOU DONT EVEN KNOW YOU.
i dont even know you, at all. but hey ill just call you dumb and boring.
now, that isn't fair?[btw that was just an example]
look im not trying to change your opinion about demi but im just trying to tell you that the way you just blurt out "demi is immature" sounds a little...like something a 7 year old would say, considering you dont even know her. well yeah.. i guess thats just the end of it. :-) bye
JemixShanie 3 years ago
hey were on barney here
xJBluver456 3 years ago
she looks kinda BIG...
gaplover 3 years ago 3
She's much prettier now
minimelts1kath 3 years ago 5
que bellaaa te amooo demiiiiii
maale9 3 years ago
she does not look like demi
anggel1106 3 years ago
What is thnis song actually called?
TheVeronicas4evalove 3 years ago
Jellybeans i Think
BFFteam 3 years ago
god i grew up watching her on barney, she was my favorite and i didn't even know it was her.
hermioneandharry99 3 years ago 3
yeah her and selena I always wanted to be like her when I was like 8
Jonaslover247 3 years ago 2
i was 5 and i never even knew it was them!
rhedz526 3 years ago
cool haha
Jonaslover247 3 years ago
shes was so adorable!
aww, love demi!
DaysiFranco 3 years ago
Im sorry but barnie scaress me but I love demi.
xxxTishaNicholexxx 3 years ago
awwh! demi is awesomee
she so cuute
jemiRAWR 3 years ago
aww!
missfreshazimiz 3 years ago
so cute!!!! omg lov it so much!!!
i lov u demi lavato!!!
muziclovr0705 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
aww!she looked adorably fugly,fatass,with a gap and a butt chin
slivenne 3 years ago
aww! && yur a fugly jelouse bitch!
jemiRAWR 3 years ago
and you need to say that why? compare yourself to demi, I'm sure your nearly not as pretty as she is next time you want to go and put people down go take a good look in the mirror because everyone knows your not perfect
xDemiDLovatox 3 years ago 2
oww,stupid dumi fan,guess what im prettier than her,what's wrong she isnt that adorable or pretty when she was young
slivenne 3 years ago
then keep your opinion to yourself because no one wants to hear it seriously conceited much? and i really really doubt you are prettier than her
xDemiDLovatox 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i am,i dont have a butt chin,unless u have one just like her,i know dont blame u,fugly's loves fugly,fuck u mother fucker,fuck off
slivenne 3 years ago
i am laughing so hard right now just remember this is barney..little kids might watch this video so i would watch the language i dont even know why im replying to you all the time you want people to stop hating on miley then stop hating on everyone else for not liking her
xDemiDLovatox 3 years ago 3
like i said,fuck u mother fucker,stop replying ok!
slivenne 3 years ago
your a bitch for saying that you asshole!!!!!!!!!!
musicsaddicted2me 1 year ago
And if ur a boy... Well that was really fucked up as you and you definitely have bad taste in how people look. It shouldn't even matter!
Ana1197 1 year ago
ya she was the exact opposite
musicsaddicted2me 1 year ago
nice one
musicsaddicted2me 1 year ago
aww so cute !
she was such a cute lil actress & singer
gosh she kinda looks the same but i bet nobody wudve guessed shes be this amazing by now!
x3kaygirlJB 3 years ago
SO CUTE LOVED HER
TheRealJoselynGac 3 years ago
looking at her back then, i would have never guessed that she would have become so pretty
muhleenaw 3 years ago 3
She's so cute!
She sounds kinda similar now
koalakinzz 3 years ago