@LoomVideos hi friend... I love this marvellous song, but Billy said that all songs from that period (except Owata and As Rome Burns, teorically) won't take part of Teargarden... anyway you can always listen to it whenever you want... here on ytube (;)
To me these Chris Isaak performances are kind of a perfect representation of where Billy seems to be heading with the new Teargarden material! I remember Billy saying that the American Gothic EP is a good glimpse into where he kind of plans to take his music, and that's so exciting, especially after hearing the instrumentation on the first two new Teargarden songs!
I only hope that he puts this song on the album! It's so good!
Unfortuantely, the first two teargarden songs do not sound anywhere near as good as this or any of the other "american gothic" type songs. The new one seems to be an improvement, but billy is producing material that is nowhere near the quality of that that was Gish, Siamese Dream, and Mellon Collie
@guifen0 - I hear that too much... Sure, they made great albums back in the day, but they're still making great music. Why compare? It's good in its own light...
Of course every new song that BC and the Pumpkins release is going to be good in its own light, but unfortunately, Billy released American Gothic, brilliantly crafted album that showcased his writing and instrumental abilities, and now Teargarden, an album that has failed to do so, when comparing it to American Gothic of course. So yeah, I could keep spitting the whole "pumpkins aren't as good as they used to be" deal, but I my point was to aim for more of a recent time frame, not the past.
failed to do so? come on man. the first EP didn't even came, it's only 4 songs. (+2 songs on Vinyl), and by that, it's too early to judge the WHOLE Teargarden album.
I personally think it's about how you come to make it so far within your live (like his progress with his music career), but regardless of you've done for you people, there can always be a momnet where you lose them, and yoiu just can't understand why.
I might agree with "s0ss" that it may be about his fans. It was written during his residency show in San Francisco, where they weren't really getting any great reception from the attendees.
@nicholsjoshua15 -- The best I can do on an MP3 are the live versions that were available as part of the VIP packages from the 20th Anniversary tour.
...i don't know what to think of the harmonica, but i'm sorta out on harmonicas in general...billy looked like he was really laboring during the harmonica part...i guess imo, not enough 'bang for buck'...also, anyone notice that 9 out of 10 times, the lead singer gets stuck playing the harmonica? you'd think the bassist or backup guitar-guy could help out...the guy's mouth is already busy....y'know?!
he shoulda released this :|
irishbull777 9 months ago
one of the finest song billy has ever written
ArvidFalk86 9 months ago
tears
back2thefutre 1 year ago
What key is that harmonica in, some please tell me :D!
PurpleFyr3 1 year ago
@PurpleFyr3
F i think
ColoredPig 9 months ago
@PurpleFyr3 i think it's in G, but i might be wrong
ArvidFalk86 9 months ago
wonder if this will be on the Teargarden LP?
LoomVideos 1 year ago
@LoomVideos It won't be.
crashcarstar 1 year ago
@LoomVideos hi friend... I love this marvellous song, but Billy said that all songs from that period (except Owata and As Rome Burns, teorically) won't take part of Teargarden... anyway you can always listen to it whenever you want... here on ytube (;)
fieldpool 1 year ago
Don't call me daughter da da laaa....oh wait its not that one pearl jam song.....Oooowata!!
NosferatuNite 1 year ago
I miss Jimmy
satellax 1 year ago 2
This sounds like Ryan Adams
satellax 2 years ago
To me these Chris Isaak performances are kind of a perfect representation of where Billy seems to be heading with the new Teargarden material! I remember Billy saying that the American Gothic EP is a good glimpse into where he kind of plans to take his music, and that's so exciting, especially after hearing the instrumentation on the first two new Teargarden songs!
I only hope that he puts this song on the album! It's so good!
easternmind 2 years ago
Unfortuantely, the first two teargarden songs do not sound anywhere near as good as this or any of the other "american gothic" type songs. The new one seems to be an improvement, but billy is producing material that is nowhere near the quality of that that was Gish, Siamese Dream, and Mellon Collie
guifen0 2 years ago
@guifen0 - I hear that too much... Sure, they made great albums back in the day, but they're still making great music. Why compare? It's good in its own light...
easternmind 2 years ago 2
Of course every new song that BC and the Pumpkins release is going to be good in its own light, but unfortunately, Billy released American Gothic, brilliantly crafted album that showcased his writing and instrumental abilities, and now Teargarden, an album that has failed to do so, when comparing it to American Gothic of course. So yeah, I could keep spitting the whole "pumpkins aren't as good as they used to be" deal, but I my point was to aim for more of a recent time frame, not the past.
guifen0 2 years ago
@guifen0
failed to do so? come on man. the first EP didn't even came, it's only 4 songs. (+2 songs on Vinyl), and by that, it's too early to judge the WHOLE Teargarden album.
lemonscure 1 year ago
best Corgan' song since Mary Star of The Sea
ArvidFalk86 2 years ago
@ArvidFalk86
I just might agree with you. In my opinion Mary Star of the Sea is one of the greatest songs ever.
alibabaschultz 1 year ago 2
This is the best song they've made since Machina II
Virex99 2 years ago 3
Yeah I'd probably agree with that
cjtudor 2 years ago
thanks, this is a great version. cool vibe. xo
cbis4133 2 years ago
great song, this version is a bit faster.......i like it slower better from if all goes wrong
meesterperfect 2 years ago
Damn Billy, you are a beast.
ngaudio021 2 years ago 2
what cd can i find this on?
jcyn21 2 years ago
Just bootlegs, official or not, or the DVD. It's only been played live.
jonesov 2 years ago
u could find it on the tonigt, tonight single album
FullmetalFan500 2 years ago
I'm not a SP fan at all but this song here is very good.
airdriver 2 years ago
try their song rose march..... its good too..^_^
before i dont like them.. coz of what other people say...
but now. i'm a fan..^_^
kebyonatin 2 years ago
The 'Chris Isaak Hour'? How cutting edge..............and yodely.
stephenp1968 2 years ago
Beautiful indeed....my new favourite
09elly1 2 years ago
El calvo Corgan, maestro!
PureCore 2 years ago
not bad
FruscianteLennon311 2 years ago
I first thought this was about someone being trapped in the WTC towers-"99 Floors and no where to go" get it?? But obv. its not about that.
Awesome song thou :)
blindbaby96 2 years ago
its probably about his fans
s0ss 2 years ago
I personally think it's about how you come to make it so far within your live (like his progress with his music career), but regardless of you've done for you people, there can always be a momnet where you lose them, and yoiu just can't understand why.
I might agree with "s0ss" that it may be about his fans. It was written during his residency show in San Francisco, where they weren't really getting any great reception from the attendees.
AWM05 2 years ago
This song is ace.
malder83 2 years ago 3
ur ace
s0ss 2 years ago
One of the best bands to see live. I love this song.
malice676767 2 years ago 2
just beautiful!!!!
reggaeluv2000 2 years ago
i hope billys new "pumpkins" album will have this kind of feel to it. honest heartfelt lyrics like he used to write 14-16 years ago!!!!!
mcd1302 2 years ago 2
Some of those lyrics remind me of how I feel about Billy Corgan. But this is a great song. ;) xD
FollyxXxFallen 2 years ago
possibly the best thing the smashing pumpkins have ever produced...heartfelt, stinging, and relevent.
billy is a genius.
mywillyisfood 2 years ago 17
@mywillyisfood Where can I MP3 this song
nicholsjoshua15 1 year ago
@nicholsjoshua15 -- The best I can do on an MP3 are the live versions that were available as part of the VIP packages from the 20th Anniversary tour.
Jee814 1 year ago
@mywillyisfood LLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLL that gotta be a joke :D
allrain 7 months ago
This is my favorite residency song :) I missed this when it aired, thanks so much for posting.
chrislvsp 2 years ago
...i don't know what to think of the harmonica, but i'm sorta out on harmonicas in general...billy looked like he was really laboring during the harmonica part...i guess imo, not enough 'bang for buck'...also, anyone notice that 9 out of 10 times, the lead singer gets stuck playing the harmonica? you'd think the bassist or backup guitar-guy could help out...the guy's mouth is already busy....y'know?!
xctrlx 2 years ago
holy moly this is amazing. amazing performance of an amazing song.
dukkookim7 2 years ago 4
i sure hope to see more of that harmonica man
TheObnubilators 2 years ago 2
Proof that Billy still has it.
rilokiley555 2 years ago 19
There's more than enough proof of that.
JTristesse 2 years ago 6
lol @ harmonica
gustoheat 2 years ago 2