"Her name was Rose" (Doctor Who) Rose Tyler Tribute

[TJKnepper]

Not to run the peril of hijacking the page, here's my opinion (my arsehole if you will): Although I am not much on the sentimentality stuff, this tribute can be described in one word (quoting from the Tennant doctor), BRILLIANT!!!

[TJKnepper]

You wankers really have a go at it.

Who the F*** cares, it is a TV series.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

if you want this to stop why comment and try to restart it, when we had made our last comments, and i hardly think they are over rated, its not like the character has some past that we dont know about, they are fictional and what people think about them is their opinion.

[TJKnepper]

Are you talking to me or that other guy?

I don't know what you and the other guy diatribe about opinions, shmopinitions are. Opinions are like arsehole, everyone has one and my arsehole says best companion is Brig Lethbridge-Stewart just like yours is Sarah Jane and Roseshipper boy is Rose.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

fine i thing the brig was good too, the point is, me and him had stopped argueing and then you had to start for no reason

[TJKnepper]

yeah... I got sick of whatever boogaloo you guys are throwing at. I am not talking just about you and Roseboy, but every other site, it is the same bloody thing, Rose-this, companion-this, Peri-that. I just came in to watch Rose's Tribute, which I think is great, but seeing all these melee, I just gave my 2 pences about it and quite frankly, maybe I shouldn't be here commenting about other companions as this page is more about Rose, who has one of the better music themes for a character IMHO.

[TJKnepper]

Blimey, "Sarah Jane" is back!!! At least "Rose" really shut it. Keep on moaning, sweetheart. I was being a sarcastic prick as you, "Sarah Jane" and "Rose" started to sound like that episode. Keep it coming, "Sarah Jane Smith".

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

@TJKnepper its you who keeps going on, you keep talking to me, when i've stopped. you've got problems. now can this stupid arguement stop, all i said was that i thought sarah was better and you lot started this, just give it a rest, its my opinion.

[TJKnepper]

Rose and Sarah Jane were good, but they are really over-rated.

[MegaPat1982]

rose is the best companion and my favourite.

[atemuamadare]

Ending is beautiful.

This line was so heartbreaking.

[bhpfan]

I love the ending too. The Doctor was almost about to cry.

[youaremydoctor]

The ending is perfect- beautiful. Well done!

[ShannonInOurHearts]

Sooo beautiful. Love the video.

[cupidsheart1936]

Loved it! :D Hey, I sort of made a fan fiction like this, okay if I send it to u just to see ur opinion? :D Thx! Oh, and if you can, plz reply!

[profsmrfld]

Really terrific. Tender.

[TheChrnosMiko]

Wow... this is beautiful! Certainly one of the best tributes to this character that I have ever seen. Amazing!

[katebien]

2:02 was such a great move to make!!!! i loved how you did the quick little flash back!

[jammiedman212]

il miss her an she is so fit

[Lexiechicklovesyou]

rose tyler you were the best !

well so was martha and donna, tbh

but you were great i still tear up :"(

[xXTardisDreamerXx]

beautiful, xx

[TheUnknown2007]

i still haven't got over the fact shes gone. and its now 2009. Rose was the best companion ever. Love her.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

Rose was not the best companion ever,sarah jane was.

[dtsfangirl]

no way Donna was =D

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

have you even watched any of the original doctor whos?

[bhpfan]

I admit Sarah Jane was arguably the best and the most popular companion, but

IRose was the one who got his hearts right now. Who knows if River Song will be the same, but so far, only Rose was the one who kept a "Doctor" (the half-human 10th Doctor).

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

what do you mean "got his hearts right now"?and the fact that she got to keep the human doctor means nothing, no other companion got the chance as he was the only one ever made. and dont you think its weird that the doctor only gave her the human doctor and didnt let her stay with him (it would seem he was getting rid of her) original fans know that the doctor doesnt "love" companions in the normal sence of the word, its diffenent, he only truly loved his wife and it would seem river song.

[bhpfan]

"got his hearts right now" - Obviously you did not see how emotional he gets in regards to Rose throughout series 3 and 4. By right now, I mean at the moment (10th Doctor) as we have not seen anything happening after he regenerated. BTW, he surely wasn't affected emotionally when he left Sarah Jane during his 4th incarnation.

"the fact that she got to keep the human doctor means nothing" - If that's the case, why he not keep his part-human version traveling with him then?

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

he didnt keep the part human doctor because he said the part human doctor was too dangerous, wern't you paying attention?and the older doctors didnt realy say good bye to his companions because he found it hard.

[bhpfan]

"it's weird that the doctor only gave her the human doctor and didnt let her stay with him" - If that human doctor was never created, would he let her stay with him?

Who knows.

"doesnt love companions in the normal sence of the word, its different, he only truly loved his wife" - Funny that he never mentioned "his wife" (though he made reference of having a family once ) nor mentioned of "Sara Jane" to Rose, Martha and Donna, but makes mention of Rose to Martha and Donna.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

you obviously havent watched the older series or you would know he had a granddaughter.

[bhpfan]

Finally, to AccidentallyOPurpose:

Hey, everyone has a right to their opinions or not, huh?

If you don't like it, tough.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

and all i said was that i thought sarah jane was better, it was you who started having a go at my opinion.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

your really starting to get stressed, i said my opinion that i thought sarah was better, then it was you who started having a go at me, you didnt ever have to say anything, but you did.

[Aqua3marine]

i cant choose for me itll be rose AND donna AND sarah jane :)

[Aqua3marine]

yes maybe in the old series but this is the totally revamped new one so the old ones dont appeal to the some of the new young generation but in the sense of the new series which evryone is talking about sarah does not count as she hasnt been an official conpanion to him in the revamped version sinse 2005 so far...

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

well you cant realy say that, seeing as every doctor is meant to be the same person, in the same tardis, so she was a companion whether you like it or not. its all one thing, just because theres a gap it makes no difference, and any real doctor who fan would agree with that, thats even what DWM says.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

well sarah jane does count because its not meant to be seen as old and new, its meant to continue (this is what DWM says)

[takeitorleaveit100]

she is so very pretty and loyal... and i think she is the best companion ever, whatever anybody says.

[AccidentallyOPurpose]

Sarah Jane was better

[emeraldbitch]

its dredful i woulnt want to leave the doctor like rose did on domsday that bit and the end is fantabulous luv it!

[newmannaylor]

very emotianal

[emeraldbitch]

what happened on doomsday

gor i cried !!!!!!

[doctorwho1590]

very good

[SexyWizardBabe]

the end is the best... i love it.

[sommersprechen]

this was really beautiful and the ending was perfect!

[CrazyGood88]

love rose...love her theme song-brilliantly beautiful-loved this vid!! thank you!!

[ItWasMyButton]

Aw this is lovely

I think the end bit "Her name was rose" should have been a little softer but the video is amazing, well done. :)

[boruchcm]

I love this video. Perfect use of scenes along with the sad theme that represents her tragic separation from the Doctor.

I think Rose and the Doctor belong together forever and i don't accept Journey's End because I don't believe she would ever leave her real doctor for a less-capable copy. She promised him forever and I think she'd do everything in her power to keep that promise.

[SevenfoldistSkater94]

my name is rose.[x

[EllenRebecca3]

The editing on that Doctor/Rose swap over with the Tardis was so clever and it just blew me away. This video is wonderful, it's like a home-made video made by The Doctor of Rose in a Love Actually style: "It's a self preservation thing." I hope you've seen Love Actually to know what I'm talking about, others who have seen it will know. :-) 5/5 stars and favourited

[tombothompson]

i love rose

[ladymiie]

Omg :')

[papado21]

AMAZING!!!

[xxSindarinelfxx]

beautiful, absolutely beautiful

[eeflien0909]

@ Savedbygrace015

it is!

[Savedbygrace015]

OMG!! so I have listened to Martha and Donna's theme songs, and Rose's by far is the best one!! Its soooo sad. Martha and Donna's theme are more upbeat abit, and suit them, but this is sad cause was devastating when she left

[UnforgivenRose]

OMG this is perfect, just so simple, yet beautiful! I love it and its really amazing. Rose and the Doctor Forever <33

[bobdaemod]

that was really g i mean really gd omg i'm crying again typical lol but how do u make these videos because i've tried i have i tried everything i just can't

[urGUARDIANangl98]

OMG i freakin' love this video... her theme is just so touching and fitting... its amazing its like it tells the story of her life its slow and suttle and first and then breaks into the middle and becomes like a fairytale with romance and adventure and then dies down becomes sad and happy and like its just perfect!!

[punk0star]

yeh, i agree. thats really good!

[xwCLOwx]

i dunno why, but i just found the clip at 1:03 - 1:05 really good, like i said, dunno why out of the whole video that stands out to me, but that's just me then! amazing fnnish!

[Chloeb2009]

great ending!

[UnforgivenRose]

I love this video, it is really beautiful! Love the music, reminds me of all the happy times on doctor who :P

5* and Faved

[EternalDolor]

Beautifully sad

[forthewin93]

the end was fabulous... just gorgeous

[starrynight06]

God that was perfect. Beautiful.

[madgirl6]

OMG that was beautiful. Nearly cried.

My mum said I'm infatuated with Billie Piper and this reminded me why. She was so great. The day after tomorrow shes back in it woo!

[Moniquebr]

You made me cry. That was beautiful.

I just started on the 3rd season so the Doctor and I are still a little sad that Rose is not with him anymore. Thank you for this.

[Seady93]

i dont kno if i've sed this or not but wen the doctor tells donna who the 'friend' is he says "her names rose" thers no 'was'

[AnamariaSparrow]

so it'll make you happy if I change the name of the video??? You're not the first one to write that.. so I do know it, but I really don't think it's that important.. that's the name I gave the video, so why should I change ot just because it's not what he says..!? I don't mean to sound rude, I'm just writing what I'm thinking...

[Seady93]

lol sorry, no it wont make me happy i was just wondering if u knew. plus i dont mind u being rude, the docs rude and i still like him

[AnamariaSparrow]

haha.. lol, okay XD

[BulletsForTheRoses]

I keep hearing her name WAS rose. I must have a hearing problem. :P

[RoseTylerForever]

Becasue in this universe she metorforically died soo tHE dOCTOR FEELS SHE DID ANYWAY AND THATS WHY HE SAYS IT...

[Seady93]

he says 'her names rose'

its cos hes crying it sounds like 'was' to everyone else but it isnt cos he still misses her and he knows that shes alive without him :(

[AnamariaSparrow]

Seady93: I don't really care what anyone says.. watch the official released BBC version of the DVD with subtitles, and you'll see that it says "her name WAS Rose" ;D

[BlackKitten21]

That was really good. What system do you use?

[ILYDOCTORWHO]

That was really good :)

the bit of the end with thedoctor/rose standing just inside the tardis was really good i thought.

How do you do these? i want to do one but i cant find clips? can u comment my profile to help please??

[AngelsFallFirst757]

That was so beautiful.

Very, very heart-breaking.

[AngelsFallFirst757]

That was so beautiful.

Very, very heart-breaking.

[TheUnknown2007]

After i tell you tis you will probably think im incredibly sad. But after i watched Doomsday i cried for 3hrs Non-stop almost was sick. But that video.. blimey... soo sad. Last bit at the end was brilliant and their standing in the same spot. Fantastic. ='] She coming back yay! The ood this saturday was freak. " Everysong must end."

[Marcovka]

For me the goodbye scene was the saddest thing i have ever seen on tv.

[damonrule]

im looking forward to rose as much as a man is looking forward to his 18th b'day the next day. i mean how good will it be, martha,rose and donna in the tardis at once? the doctor will be thrilled!

[MissxStefani]

ano that was so clever at the end!! woo anyone see partners in crime? rose yay!!!! n in the pompaei one sum1 sez the one you seek is returning doctor! i was like yay!!

[spockezri]

I didn't know Rose had such a beautiful theme! I'm officially getting that CD and forcing tthe other violins to help me figure out that violin part.

Spockezri

[CrazyBoutBillie]

beautiful

and i cant believe rose was in partners in crime

i sooo wasnt expecting it!

what program did u do this on?

[THEpowerOFme]

Aww that was beautiful and so sad! :(

[wendyalyse123]

what happened to her did she die?!?!?!?!?!

[HyperGirl94]

no, she got trapped in a parellel universe with her family and mickey. she's still alive though...

[Seady93]

the doctor doesnt say "was" he says her names rose.

[HyperGirl94]

That was AMAZING!!! It brought tears to my eyes! Brilliantly put together.

[SoulRythm]

Breathtakingly beautiful. YOu've done an wonderfully. *weeps for Rose*

[MomDaegmorgan]

Beautiful!

You made me cry.

[ballerketballer]

So well done... I didn't realize Rose's theme was so sad... Beautiful.....

[CrazyBoutBillie]

what software did u do this on?

[dfalan]

Love this video! I cried so much the first

 time watching it. Reminded me of Rose and the Doctor's final goodbye on the episode Doomsday.

[kattyivey]

Her theme is very sweet and sad and very innocent. I like it quite a lot and your vid di a great job of matching clips to music.

[jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ]

i was giving teary smiles all the ay through that-i av 2 say it woz absolutely brilliant!!! hw did u do that? How do you even make video's coz i dont no how!!! but well done well dnoe!, im putting this on my favourites! x

[patty803]

ok...i literallly cried. i never cried. doctor who always makes me cry! doomsday had me sobbing and the fan vids. they just stopped making me upset knowing she was coming back and then i watch this and i am crying.

[EvannaLillyPotter]

Rose is coming back. its on the BBC website.

[madgirl132]

Jeeeeeeze, i love this :]

[VsWomen]

Christ I achelly sobbed when he said "her name was Rose" bloody hell I wasn't excepting to do that, it's been just over a year now since she was lost to him, oh boy! *takes a deep breath* lovely my dear, wonderfully well compiled. :D

[bannerdb]

Fantastic video! Very fitting tribute! Loved the video effects also! Well done! Five stars from me!

[OldClay]

So well done... I didn't realize Rose's theme was so sad... Beautiful.....

[mchun]

amazing and beautiful

[Karastarw]

Good job...I love it...although it makes me really sad...I love the ending!!

[AsarathWitch]

The clips were very suting and a throughly enjoysble video. The music and chosen scenes fit lovely and I loved the effects used. I will efinately be checking out other videos made by you.

[Rosetylermad111]

WELL DONE!

[RosesAreLovee]

Awesome! Especially the video in the end! I'm so delighted to see Rose coming back!

[kryptonitegrace]

What a beautiful video!  That ending was just perfect with the Doctor and Rose cut scene. Great job!!

[heathertee]

this was amazing.

i miss rose being in.

i think martha is brill too.

but i miss the chemistry the doctor and rose ahd it just worked so well :]

good job

Xx.Heathzie:].xX

[seduff]

I love the shots of Rose you have chosen here. So beautiful in their simplicity and emotion. Really captured all of her traits. Nice work. :)

[Riss0528]

OMG I love it!!!!!  You've got me on the verge of tears here girly lol.

[DWDeb]

That was amazing, I'm glad you didn't over do it with effects. Nice and simple always looks good. I really like the ending :)

[takeabananatoaparty]

This was heartbreaking. And so gloriously Rose. All her moments when she is at her most-Rose~ish, you've put in there.

I was crying. And the ending made it worse, cause it was so perfect.

[ILoveChrisHalliwell]

what did you use to do this? its amazing, i love how she's talking through it.. amazing.

[PurebloodProductions]

oh how cool. though I don´t even know that, I totally felt like I got the atmosphere!!!!

[xxTIFFANYYxx]

wow that is amazing!

[TeamMD]

Great xD

[CILLEXD]

JUBIII "!!!!!! Den er sååå overgod ! Elsker den melodi !! ♥♥ ;D Den er sååå sød ;D *klapper* 5 Stjerne , faved og osse i V-Log ! <333

[AnamariaSparrow]

yay! du kan lide den! :P ♥♥ haha.. synes osse selv den er ret sød, men den kunne godt have været bedre :S men kan rigtig godt lide slutningen, hvor Rose og Doctoren står præcis det samme sted (i Tardisen altså :P) hehe.. men tak for kommentaren ! <33

BTW: Kommer ikke på msn idag, har været på arbejde fra kl. 05-21 :S ville være gået tidligere, men så var der en der meldte sig syg, og så kunne jeg ikke gå :( øv-bøv!

[CILLEXD]

Den er vildt sød <3 Liige til et tudefjæs :P ♥ Haha , anyway .. <3 Men ja , slutningen er rigtig sød ! <33333

[SlightlyEmoMoriko101]

omg!

i NEARLY CRIED AS WELL!

Touching, sad, but awsome vid!!

It almost feels like she's dead, she'l neva come back, and we'l probably neva c her again.

Aw!

Now im basically crying again!

500/5

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

Ohhh!!!

That was soo amazing.

And beautiful.

Brilliant.

Now I need to go find some tissues to wipe away my tears.

Here "theme" is sooo sad :)

[spinoutofcontrol]

that was beautiful i almost cried i miss rose so much