Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (50)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Diana was too busy to be on the album, but let's also remember the album was also recorded before the writers decided to put Quinn and Sam together. Kurt's lines and blocking very likely would have reflected a building relationship with Sam, which was what had originally been intended before they realized he and Quinn had good chemistry. (Which -- good thing they did. If not we never would have gotten Darren Criss.)

  • ugh when i listened to the other version and kurt sung that i was like "hold up, who are you and where the hell is dianna??" like no thats not working out, must find the other version.

  • @shelbyteresak You said it perfectly.

  • Kurt does sound like a girl... To bad Dianna was to busy :/ she would of made it better just saying...

  • Quinn's voice is really nice :D Kurt's voice in the album is like a girl :(

  • Dianna wasn't part of the christmas album because she was filming I Am Number Four (:

  • -"a dolly for sue"- quinns voice is so pretty!

  • Why did they put Kurt in the album version? I mean I love him but Dianna's so much better at that part.

  • @SamIAm2197 It's because Dianna is Jewish, so she doesn't celebrate Christmas. :)

  • Quinn <3

    I love her voice in this song :)

  • I prefer Dianna's version of this...Kurt's version was kinda...creepy

  • Also compare to Kurt's lines, which seem to pop out (too gleeful) on his version, Diane's voice harmonizes with the others perfectly for this song. Ironically Tina seems to have a perfect voice for Christmas songs. Her voice seems to be prominent among the cast in these songs.

  • I love Diane's voice as it has a kind of old-school sultry voice that was very popular during the 40's. Her voice reminds me a bit of the Andrews sisters.

  • @Vortex51x Dianna has a great voice but they don't always use it correctly I think.

  • Quinn's voice in this is just perfect!

  • Quinn 1000 times ! I love Quinn <3

  • I prefer Quinn

  • I LOVE Chris's voice, but this song didn't suit him at all :( Mostly just on the "wake up! Don't you know that it's time to come out?" part. Dianna sounds lovely <3 best wishes to both.

  • Omg, Quinn's voice is much better suited than Kurt's. When Quinn sings, it's childish and whimsical. When Kurt sings, it's a little creepy and just doesn't sound right at all.

  • I love Quinn!!!!! :)

  • 0:00 Replay :D

  • I love this version! I was kinda upset when I first found out Kurt sang Dianna's part in the album...Why did they replace her with Kurt anyway??

  • Dianna's voice is so cute in this

    I love Chris Colfer's voice but Dianna's just suits this better

  • Aww Dianna's voice is soo cute :3!

  • kurts not in the new directions when they sing this though? because he sings with blaine? :)

  • Does anyone else think that Quinn's voice sounds like one of those 1930's singers? <3

  • I rarely say anything against Kurt solos, but here, Quinn's is much better.

  • Quin is better for this version considering the lines

  • i always love Chris and his voice

    but this song's lines? ONLY FOR QUINN :X

  • @Cafeblanx WHAAAAAAAT? Really >.< Wow so much fail....Okay I guess we learn something new every day. Thanks for pointing that out....

  • @Cafeblanx LOL wow fail...Somehow I've always thought her name was Diane....Diana Agron. I got it now XD

  • I like this version SO much better. I love Diane's voice. I really don't think people give her enough credit.

  • @RedBunnyFromMars It's Dianna

  • @RedBunnyFromMars It's Dianna

  • Why is it 'Quinn's' version? =D

  • @bestfwiends4eva on the album version Kurt sings Quinn's part :D i prefer this version tho :)

  • @swnnyy Definitely :)

  • Comment removed

  • it's not kurt, it's lauren who does quinns part

  • @AldenProduction No. It is not.

  • @AldenProduction No, it's Kurt.

  • @bestfwiends4eva because the lines which Artie sings in the album version, here is Quinn

    also, this is the version from the episode :)

  • @leahloading its Kurt not Artie

  • @bestfwiends4eva because it's Quinn version buddy

    just kidding, beause this's from the episode scence

    you can see in album version, Kurt sings Quinn's lines ;D

  • Thank you so much for putting this on :) miles better than the album. xx

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more