I love it. She is one of the best sopranos I know... before Maria Callas, Joan Sutherland. They said she warm her voice before performing by listening to Callas, no wonder she was doing a good job ;-)
ME PARECE QUE COMPARAR A ESTAS DOS CANTANTES, EXTRAORDINARIAS, ESTÁ FUERA DE LUGAR. SÓLO, PIENSO YO, ES CUESTIÓN DE GUSTOS AUDITIVOS, LA BELLEZA DEL CANTO, Y SENSIBILIDAD " RENATA TEBALDI "Y LA EXPRESIVIDAD ESCÉNICA " MARIA CALLAS " SUS VOCES ERAN ABOLUTAMENTE DIFERENTES. YO ME INCLINO POR RENATA TEBALDI, SIN DESMERECER A LA GRAN MARIA CALLAS. A LA , QUE ADMIRO, Y ESCUCHO MUY A MENUDO, NO ME CIERRO A LOS BUENOS CANTANTES......
Difference between Maria Callas and Renata Tebaldi is they come from different schools. Maria comes from the "placement" school while Renata practices appoggio and sings in one register. Maria probably sings with much more passion though.
@GhostRaider18765 This has nothing to do with her singing ability, which I'm pretty sure you're blind to, if this idiotic reply you've typed up is reading correctly...
The entire Callas vs Tebaldi was ridiculous. Both Ladies were first class Prima Donna's and as different as plums from peaches! They both sang Aida, the Trovatore and Forza Leonora's, Traviata, Butterfly, Tosca, Maddalena in Chenier,but the musical approach and dramatic interpretation was as different as their temperaments.Each was gifted and posessed a genius of her very own. They are both gone now only the work remains and it is great work! Let them rest in peace and stop the feuding
@intelegentable - CÓMO TE DOY LA RAZÒN, LAS DOS FUERON COMPLETAMENTE DISTINTAS INTERPRETANDO Y LAS DOABSOLUTAMENTE MARAVILLOSAS, PONGAMOS SUS DISCOS Y VÍDEOS Y DELEITÉMOSNOS ESCUCHANDO UNAS VOCES, IRREPETIBLES,, EN ESTOS TIEMPOS DE CRISIS DE CANTANTES PARA LA HISTORIA DE LA LÍRICA,-
Perfect vocal control warm , passionate her sound is so unique I loved her I first heard her La Boheme. At Carnegie hall 1957 I sat on the stage and watched this great artist stun the audience.Toscanini was right "The voice of an angel."
@ColignyForever . All these armchair critics have probably never seen her perform live and sit behind their keyboards typing out a load of drivvle. I doubt that they would not know a B flat from and A sharp. She was an incredible soprano and had great voice control and could project her voice to the people sitting in ther back rows of the Audience. I wouldnt stress too much about these idiots on the YouTube forum they know less then 95% about good opera.
Granted everyone has their preferences, but I just love listening to the sheer power and talent of these ladies. I am always astounded by the fact this can come out of a human being.
If someone makes a statement that Tebaldi isn' "that great" the least he/she could do is to explain further and illustrate us about such a statement, Not that great, as compared to what or whom? I am also confused about the "sad:))))" comment. Does he/she feel sad for us, Tebaldi's fans, because he/she believes we are not intelligent enough to realize she is not "that great"?
I think this was real, it's hard to believe that someone could synthesize this melody and turn it into her own after all the countless renditions. Today with the amount of performers who mimic some of the great divas what a wonderful gift. I'd like to go visit the Museum dedicated to her and her voice.
What is all of this talk of Maria Callas. Callas was never in the league of Tebaldi. One only has to have ears to hear the difference. Tebaldi's singing is sublime. Callas on the other hand blew her voice out by singing roles she should have stayed away from. Callas also lowered the standards for singers today. Callas made bad singing accepatble, and thus the current sad state of the arts.
A parte il il fatto che si scrive Madama, poi credo che tu sia sordo o poco informato visto che quella strega della Callas dopo 3 volte che ha fatto Madama Butterfly le hanno detto "Lascia perdere che la fa meglio Renata" W RENATA TEBALDI la sola unica Butterfly !
@Neanderthalgirl Callas made remarks appreciative of Tebaldi, and vice versa. Callas said, "I admire Tebaldi's tone; it's beautiful—also some beautiful phrasing. Sometimes, I actually wish I had her voice." Tebaldi was once given a recording for a role shewas to play. Aware of the alleged rivalry, he recommended another version. Days later, he went to visit Tebaldi, to find her sitting by the speakers, listening to Callas' recording. She then asked, "Why didn't you tell me Maria's was the best"
@Neanderthalgirl Have you ever heard Callas' album of Puccini heroines? Great singing as well as characterization in my view. In one Puccini role, in particular, I believe she is supreme, namely Tosca. Have you heard the recording mentioned by paulostroff99 and what she does with the text? If not, it is well worth listening to.
I wholeheartedly agree... especially regarding Callas in the 1953 recording of Tosca with DiStefano , De Sabata conducting. ALL this aside, Tebaldi was a great artist in her own right, and this is certainly a fine performance!
@paulostroff99 I agree that Callas is a magnificent Tosca, and that first recording she made with di Stefano and Gobbi is the best performance of the opera I ever hope to hear. For Madama Butterfly, Callas has some rivals, including Tebaldi, de los Angeles, and Moffo. For Turandot, there is Nilsson. However, while Tebaldi, Milanov, and Crespin are also great as Tosca, Callas is the greatest!
She is superb in this performance! This performance brings tears to my eyes, look at her pose. A beautiful, talented, self-assured Diva. I love her beautiful, beautiful voice. She was one of the most talented Spintos to grace our world with her voice.
Para mí no es la más, sencillamente porque no lo puedo hacer particular sino general: Tebaldi, Callas y Labelle pese a que son muy diferentes entre sí.
Ok...a wonderfull voice... but that's it! And she doesn't have the high register so good as one would like... nevertheless, a wonderfull voice indeed...
This is like listening to an Angel singing...It is absolutely beautiful and will last for eternity..
If this song could be sent across the whole Universe... !... whoever would hear it , could not remain indifferent to it.. No words can describe the emotion felt .. Thank you so much for posting.
this performance is a shining example of what true lirico-spinto singing by a soprano sounds like. listen to the line, the phrasing, the intonation, the colors...(sighs) brava diva!...
Che grande emozione riascoltare , a mio giudizio, la più grande cantante lirica italiana di tutti i tempi. Grazie a Bendsito per aver inserito questo meraviglioso video. Ciccio Ragusa
He visto tanto video de esta canción, que me siento frustrado por no tener la capacidad de interpretarla, me tocó conformame con oirla y oirla y oirla, siempre una vez más...
If you like Puccini, check Paul Pottss studio version of Turandots NESSUN DORMA + 40 other operas by 40 other composers in my play list 20th CENTURY OPERAS ( including the world premiere of ARIA DEL CIRUJANO from Opera Opus Operatorum by Roberto Rius & Pedro Ipuche Riva )
20th CENTURY OPERAS : the MOST VIEWED and MOST COMPLETE last century opera playlist in YOU TUBE !
I think that Maria Callas and Renata Tebaldi both had amazing voices. I have been taking my first singing lesson for a few months now, and my teacher told me to listen to Tibaldi. I did happen to see Callas perform the week before. They are both good to study. They both have AMAZING voices, it really just depends on what kind of voice you like, because they both sound very different.
I commented earlier, negatively, on Tebaldi's Jewel Song from Faust here on Youtube (lack of trill, etc). But in this Un bel di she is certainly in her natural territory.
I've seen her past her prime, but with all her allure, at Espace Pierre Cardin in Paris in the late '70s. She was intelligent, fabulous and still the great star. She sang new stuff only because, she said, if you want to hear what I sounded like before, buy my records....
Recordings don't tell everything. Quality, size of voice, character, integrity, movement & the effect on an audience need describing too. Have you heard a great performance by this singer live, without a mic? If so please post an objective description to add the wonderful YouTube archive before the memory is lost for ever.
How I wish I could have been there to hear Farinelli entrance an audience with the power of a single note, but we do at least have Charles Burney's marvellous account.
Strepitosa , Magica Renata....!!! mai voce di soprano sarà pari alla tua...grazie per tutte le emozioni che mi fai vivere ascoltandoti in le tue interpretazioni che hai fatto.......
A dear friend introduced me to this song recently and since hearing it for the first time it has become an addiction..... Renata sings it with such passion.... I sit mesmerised and watch and listen over and over again.... truly a graceful lady and such a heart wrenching song..... thank you
Excellent presentation, beautiful woman, magnificent voice! More importantly, she carried herself with such grace and dignity ... a great lady. No wonder people loved her. The voice and temperament of an angel. HAPPY BIRTHDAY RENATA!!! Forever alive in our hearts. Thank-you so much Bendsito!!!
Che fantastica interpretazione e che voce sovraffino, proprio la voce di un angelo. Ogni volta che ascolto quest'aria cantata dalla Tebaldi mi vengono la pelle d'oca dall'emozione e le lacrime agli occhi...
La più bella voce di soprano per qualità, intonazione e potenza. La Callas non possedeva queste doti al massimo livello, anche se come espressività drammatica ed estensione le era superiore.
Today is Tebaldi's 4th anniversary of her death. But time will never erase the memory of this great soprano. Truly one of the greatest voices of the 20th century. Love you Renata!
Beautiful singing. Kind of "stiff" in the acting department. (What's with the elbows stuck out all the time?)
trschaefer 1 week ago
Callas was the best, Sutherland was next, Tebaldi is so far down the line, you'd need a week to find her!
jjj29871 3 weeks ago
@jjj29871 you are 19 and know nothing about singing go to play with the dolls and to impersonate Maria Callas ignorant little fag
neneorganico 3 weeks ago
I love it. She is one of the best sopranos I know... before Maria Callas, Joan Sutherland. They said she warm her voice before performing by listening to Callas, no wonder she was doing a good job ;-)
RonaldBarone 3 weeks ago
sexy jewish pum pum top rate me <3333333333333333333
neilneill1 1 month ago
LA MIA PREFERITA,BRAVA RENATA TEBALDI.
gvolpe100 1 month ago
PUCCINI, LE SCRIVEVA PER LE BELLE DONNE ,COME LA BELLISSIMA RENTA TEBALDI.SOPRANO.
gvolpe100 1 month ago
ME PARECE QUE COMPARAR A ESTAS DOS CANTANTES, EXTRAORDINARIAS, ESTÁ FUERA DE LUGAR. SÓLO, PIENSO YO, ES CUESTIÓN DE GUSTOS AUDITIVOS, LA BELLEZA DEL CANTO, Y SENSIBILIDAD " RENATA TEBALDI "Y LA EXPRESIVIDAD ESCÉNICA " MARIA CALLAS " SUS VOCES ERAN ABOLUTAMENTE DIFERENTES. YO ME INCLINO POR RENATA TEBALDI, SIN DESMERECER A LA GRAN MARIA CALLAS. A LA , QUE ADMIRO, Y ESCUCHO MUY A MENUDO, NO ME CIERRO A LOS BUENOS CANTANTES......
Maripudelmonaco 1 month ago
@Maripudelmonaco Totalmente de acuerdo
melibea56 2 weeks ago
@melibea56 - GRACIAS POR TU COMENTARIO- SALUDOS !!!
Maripudelmonaco 2 weeks ago
Emocionante ...
condorcito99 2 months ago
Difference between Maria Callas and Renata Tebaldi is they come from different schools. Maria comes from the "placement" school while Renata practices appoggio and sings in one register. Maria probably sings with much more passion though.
MrJackylimzw 2 months ago 2
At last I know who Frasier was on about....!!!
jonsmskin 3 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 Wow. Just wow.
I'm asking the uploader to remove this conversation because it has little to nothing to do with Tebaldi.
I thought that was obvious.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
Uploader, could you please remove the stupid convo between me and GhostRaider18765? If so, thanks.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 And now it's devolving into childish rhetoric. Nice.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
horrible comparer avec CALAS ICI SUR YOUTUBE AVEC CET NOM DE RECHERCHE " Maria Callas (Μαρία Κάλλας): Madama Butterfly - Puccini "
alexandrestark 4 months ago
@alexandrestark Non.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@MerlinsJester SI !!! waazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzaaaaaaa !!!
alexandrestark 4 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 And you think I'm actually going to listen? What are you, five?
You and your evasions of actually saying something relevant.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 This has nothing to do with her singing ability, which I'm pretty sure you're blind to, if this idiotic reply you've typed up is reading correctly...
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 Did I?
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@GhostRaider18765 I'll bite: what singer?
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
She will ALWAYS be the real deal! She and Maria are together now in a place where all our squabbling don't mean a thang.
God I love her singing!
MrGratefulheart 4 months ago
The entire Callas vs Tebaldi was ridiculous. Both Ladies were first class Prima Donna's and as different as plums from peaches! They both sang Aida, the Trovatore and Forza Leonora's, Traviata, Butterfly, Tosca, Maddalena in Chenier,but the musical approach and dramatic interpretation was as different as their temperaments.Each was gifted and posessed a genius of her very own. They are both gone now only the work remains and it is great work! Let them rest in peace and stop the feuding
intelegentable 5 months ago
@intelegentable - CÓMO TE DOY LA RAZÒN, LAS DOS FUERON COMPLETAMENTE DISTINTAS INTERPRETANDO Y LAS DOABSOLUTAMENTE MARAVILLOSAS, PONGAMOS SUS DISCOS Y VÍDEOS Y DELEITÉMOSNOS ESCUCHANDO UNAS VOCES, IRREPETIBLES,, EN ESTOS TIEMPOS DE CRISIS DE CANTANTES PARA LA HISTORIA DE LA LÍRICA,-
Maripudelmonaco 1 month ago
La piu grande di tutti i tempi
17doesit 7 months ago
Strength power and beauty. A voice for the ages.
Halcot 19
halcot19 8 months ago
diva per sempre....sublime
25MRsolo 8 months ago
I think she was a pretty class act.
Allotmenteer2 9 months ago 3
renata tebaldi was one of the greatest prima donnas ever!
amineurin 9 months ago
she is so fucking stiff. great singing though
SpaceCookie999 9 months ago
...
giloubreizh 10 months ago
Perfect vocal control warm , passionate her sound is so unique I loved her I first heard her La Boheme. At Carnegie hall 1957 I sat on the stage and watched this great artist stun the audience.Toscanini was right "The voice of an angel."
ajsbx 10 months ago
Can't understand a word she's saying. WTF?
WallyVanRiper1 10 months ago 14
@WallyVanRiper1 Learn Italian?
seektheforce 9 months ago 2
@WallyVanRiper1 it's in another language, man.
BrianRocksNow 9 months ago
@WallyVanRiper1 Another american retard.
jpmariachi 7 months ago
@jpmariachi In MY REAl NATIVE AMERICAN "woreds" (oh Shallow twit!-Shit!) Buzz the fawk off! You're a left of ZERO mentality asshole!
bigpoluka 6 months ago
@WallyVanRiper1 Perhaps because she's singing a foreign language? Oh gee.
MerlinsJester 4 months ago
@MerlinsJester Gee....ya think?
WallyVanRiper1 4 months ago
@WallyVanRiper1 of course!
Angeliciousxio 1 month ago
Beautiful but I don't understand the controversy vs Maria Callas. Callas' vocal control and bel canto, to my ear, is far more impressive.
entity3sf 11 months ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
39 people on here obviously do not have ears that function properly!
UncleSol7379 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Heaven.
DynamicMentalFitness 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
La stature, la présence!
giloubreizh 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Best Aida
missgreeneyes56 11 months ago
It annoys me that people compare Callas and Tebaldi. Appreciate them both for what they are. Both are different and both are very beautiful.
ColignyForever 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ColignyForever . All these armchair critics have probably never seen her perform live and sit behind their keyboards typing out a load of drivvle. I doubt that they would not know a B flat from and A sharp. She was an incredible soprano and had great voice control and could project her voice to the people sitting in ther back rows of the Audience. I wouldnt stress too much about these idiots on the YouTube forum they know less then 95% about good opera.
steinwaygrande1 1 year ago
Granted everyone has their preferences, but I just love listening to the sheer power and talent of these ladies. I am always astounded by the fact this can come out of a human being.
radicallytubular 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Chillona
EmiliaVeraSoprano 1 year ago
Bautiful!
Perfect!
La grande Tebaldi !
lamusicahera 1 year ago
You all should hear her sing Bach's Ave Maria. Amazing!
Bossmanrocks 1 year ago
What transcendent beauty and dignity!
eitnim 1 year ago 2
Veronica Villaroel es amazing. she is really good in "Un bel di vedremo"
DaniellefromChile 1 year ago
¡¡INSUPERABLE!!
bepegal 1 year ago
I always hold my breath from 3:50 to 4:15
it's so...impressive
MsFerna 1 year ago 3
Merci Callas de m'avoir fait connaître Tebaldi... Vous me faites pleurer!
FeeTurbule 1 year ago
Renata isn't that great like you guys think... sad :))))
amen5001 1 year ago 24
This has been flagged as spam show
@amen5001
If someone makes a statement that Tebaldi isn' "that great" the least he/she could do is to explain further and illustrate us about such a statement, Not that great, as compared to what or whom? I am also confused about the "sad:))))" comment. Does he/she feel sad for us, Tebaldi's fans, because he/she believes we are not intelligent enough to realize she is not "that great"?
amorodiez 1 year ago
@amen5001 And your standard is what?
MerlinsJester 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I guess Renata Tebaldi IS NOT Madama Butterfly AT ALL....
riannagreece21 1 year ago 29
I agree w/Count di Luna
rubyedelman 1 year ago
God bless you.
ididete 1 year ago
I think this was real, it's hard to believe that someone could synthesize this melody and turn it into her own after all the countless renditions. Today with the amount of performers who mimic some of the great divas what a wonderful gift. I'd like to go visit the Museum dedicated to her and her voice.
MrFalconford 1 year ago
Maravilloso, butterfly es Tebaldi. Con respeto, cariño y admiración para todas las demás.... Renata es la pasión y la dulzura ...
miralmaroctavia 1 year ago
Cio Cio San = Tebaldi
soyfilegonio 1 year ago
MAGNIFICENT !!!
astrumacontlae 1 year ago
Wow, this is the best performance of Un bel di vedremo I've ever come across. Thanks!
CountDiLuna 1 year ago
Un respiro ♫
NoDoyPieConBola 1 year ago
What is all of this talk of Maria Callas. Callas was never in the league of Tebaldi. One only has to have ears to hear the difference. Tebaldi's singing is sublime. Callas on the other hand blew her voice out by singing roles she should have stayed away from. Callas also lowered the standards for singers today. Callas made bad singing accepatble, and thus the current sad state of the arts.
Giovannifabuloso 1 year ago
Death by goosebumps! Wow!
nancydrew5 1 year ago 5
RENATA ERES UNA DIVA , SENCILLAMENTE SUBLIME
hector180784 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
una verdadera diva
hector180784 1 year ago
UNA VERDADERA DIVA
hector180784 1 year ago
She is my absolute favourite opera singer. Her voice just soars angelically- I can't find fault with anything about her singing.
amandanotmandy22 1 year ago
This is very beautiful!
nittori2 1 year ago 2
takes a while for her to really get into it, but when she does...magic.
yanreurriek 1 year ago
Lindíssimooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
donakyola 1 year ago
i can't get enough ...no doubts renata tebaldi was outstanding!
amineurin 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She breathes too often
andreea94a 1 year ago
This is awesome! What a voice! Fantastic.
purrrification 1 year ago
Awesome!
paulostroff99 1 year ago
Tebaldi has a voice that cuts like a blade . What more can you wish for !!
autogyro100 1 year ago 2
Merci, Renata.
SENAFOREVER 1 year ago
太棒了，害我全身發麻、直衝腦門！
jrbwind 1 year ago
Devine!
grenadian11 1 year ago
Renata does a great job, but Maria Callas is simply untouchable.Maria outshines everyone else, she is Madame Butterfly!
DeNTeD84 1 year ago
A parte il il fatto che si scrive Madama, poi credo che tu sia sordo o poco informato visto che quella strega della Callas dopo 3 volte che ha fatto Madama Butterfly le hanno detto "Lascia perdere che la fa meglio Renata" W RENATA TEBALDI la sola unica Butterfly !
stesondrio88 1 year ago
Questo è un commento di risposta a DeNTeD84, che evidentemente non se ne intende di lirica :
stesondrio88 1 year ago
@DeNTeD84
Hahaha........ good joke!
Callas is great but she couldn't sing Puccini!
Neanderthalgirl 1 year ago 3
@Neanderthalgirl -Then whose voice was it with GDS on those wonderful Tosca recordings-rated best of any by most critics.
paulostroff99 1 year ago
@paulostroff99
One word:
OVERRATED
Neanderthalgirl 1 year ago
@Neanderthalgirl -What are your qualifications-if any!!!!
paulostroff99 1 year ago
@paulostroff99
Study and singing education in Düsseldorf
Neanderthalgirl 1 year ago
@paulostroff99
AND YES ..........OVERRATED!!!
Neanderthalgirl 1 year ago
@Neanderthalgirl
OVERRATED? Be serious!
amineurin 1 year ago
@amineurin
It's CALLAS not Tebaldi, sorry!
Callas was overrated like Karajan .... only a media hype.
Neanderthalgirl 1 year ago 2
@Neanderthalgirl Callas made remarks appreciative of Tebaldi, and vice versa. Callas said, "I admire Tebaldi's tone; it's beautiful—also some beautiful phrasing. Sometimes, I actually wish I had her voice." Tebaldi was once given a recording for a role shewas to play. Aware of the alleged rivalry, he recommended another version. Days later, he went to visit Tebaldi, to find her sitting by the speakers, listening to Callas' recording. She then asked, "Why didn't you tell me Maria's was the best"
dunny201 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Neanderthalgirl Have you ever heard Callas' album of Puccini heroines? Great singing as well as characterization in my view. In one Puccini role, in particular, I believe she is supreme, namely Tosca. Have you heard the recording mentioned by paulostroff99 and what she does with the text? If not, it is well worth listening to.
meltzerboy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@meltzerboy
I wholeheartedly agree... especially regarding Callas in the 1953 recording of Tosca with DiStefano , De Sabata conducting. ALL this aside, Tebaldi was a great artist in her own right, and this is certainly a fine performance!
CurzonRoad 1 year ago
@CurzonRoad
.... sorry, how could I have ever left out Gobbi ?!
CurzonRoad 1 year ago
@meltzerboy -N-As good as any ever recorded-IMHO.
paulostroff99 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@paulostroff99 I agree that Callas is a magnificent Tosca, and that first recording she made with di Stefano and Gobbi is the best performance of the opera I ever hope to hear. For Madama Butterfly, Callas has some rivals, including Tebaldi, de los Angeles, and Moffo. For Turandot, there is Nilsson. However, while Tebaldi, Milanov, and Crespin are also great as Tosca, Callas is the greatest!
meltzerboy 1 year ago
She is superb in this performance! This performance brings tears to my eyes, look at her pose. A beautiful, talented, self-assured Diva. I love her beautiful, beautiful voice. She was one of the most talented Spintos to grace our world with her voice.
tenaciousgirl 1 year ago 6
video noire, mais l'émotion est intacte au niveau de la voix !
sauvagetbeau 1 year ago 3
Voce molto buona per questa aria.
ivapacetti 1 year ago 4
Meravigliosa interpretazione.
irons60 2 years ago 3
she is absolutely radiant here!
BernardProfitendieu 2 years ago 7
La mas maravillosa voz que ha existido en el mundo operistico. Sencillamente fabulosa.
ketestrujo 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
tissetatten 1 year ago
@ketestrujo
Para mí no es la más, sencillamente porque no lo puedo hacer particular sino general: Tebaldi, Callas y Labelle pese a que son muy diferentes entre sí.
jarochovera 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ketestrujo
Para mí no es la MAS sencillamente porque no lo puedo hacer particular sino general:
Caballé, Callas y Tebaldi pese a que son muy diferentes entre si.
jarochovera 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Im tearing up its so beautiful.
1SuperKawaii 2 years ago 14
i know! she gets to me every time too!
rutla 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ok...a wonderfull voice... but that's it! And she doesn't have the high register so good as one would like... nevertheless, a wonderfull voice indeed...
ricardocalado 2 years ago
Forever géniale! mieux que Callas... A mon avis...AV
ALEXISVASSILIEV 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
tissetatten 1 year ago
Meravigliosa ! Nessuno ha mai avuto un timbro così bello.
31122051 2 years ago 5
This is like listening to an Angel singing...It is absolutely beautiful and will last for eternity..
If this song could be sent across the whole Universe... !... whoever would hear it , could not remain indifferent to it.. No words can describe the emotion felt .. Thank you so much for posting.
winningsmile222 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
inoubliable et sublime "TEBALDI" belle performance MERCI ******
543693The 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
I absolutely adore Tebaldi...but, Ponselle is the greatest since Malibran...just my opinion.
russellcusick 2 years ago
this performance is a shining example of what true lirico-spinto singing by a soprano sounds like. listen to the line, the phrasing, the intonation, the colors...(sighs) brava diva!...
spinto12 2 years ago 6
Brava, brava, brava. La mejor
idornellas 2 years ago 6
Dios! Bravo Señora Tibaldi.... que emoción, que sentimiento... BRAVO!
peque1204 2 years ago 3
WONDERFUL!! She has that "tone" that is so crucial for this work. Leontyne has that "tone" and so does Renata
tdavidray 2 years ago 6
Yeah! That's right Leontyne and Renata have that incredible and unique voices. They're in a totally different league!
yodavidnavarro 2 years ago 3
Oggi ricorre il 5° anno dalla sua scomparsa. Ti prego Dio, prenditi cura di lei.
rossini90 2 years ago 4
Un'interpretazione storica!
rossini90 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
take a look at Eugenia Moldoveanu performance....she's the best Madame Butterfly in the world!
sergiu17 2 years ago
avete ragione...questa è la voce ke davvero Puccini avrebbe voluto per dar vita ai suoi personaggi ...ke voce....
Marcocucciolo91 2 years ago 3
Compare this to contemporary recordings and never buy post 1960 recordings again!
"...Voice of an Angel" quote of Puccini's pal Toscanini.
andrewmallon 2 years ago 2
When will we see/hear their like again?
andrewmallon 2 years ago 2
Though the sound recording is not very good I do like La Tebalti's rendetion.She was wonderful.
dacor31 2 years ago 2
Amazing!! Brava!!!!
Amelinda27 2 years ago 5
This is beautiful. Thanks for posting.
It was not only a beautiful voice , but a huge one as well. I heard her many times at the Met
Houndentenor1998 2 years ago 3
you are lucky, she is my favourite soprano and I think her Mimi is the ultimate but never saw her live !
ascoteagle 2 years ago 3
Che grande emozione riascoltare , a mio giudizio, la più grande cantante lirica italiana di tutti i tempi. Grazie a Bendsito per aver inserito questo meraviglioso video. Ciccio Ragusa
ciccioragusa 2 years ago
He visto tanto video de esta canción, que me siento frustrado por no tener la capacidad de interpretarla, me tocó conformame con oirla y oirla y oirla, siempre una vez más...
proxpor 2 years ago
watch her hands! they're so gracefull *sigh*
incorrigibleirises 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like Puccini, check Paul Pottss studio version of Turandots NESSUN DORMA + 40 other operas by 40 other composers in my play list 20th CENTURY OPERAS ( including the world premiere of ARIA DEL CIRUJANO from Opera Opus Operatorum by Roberto Rius & Pedro Ipuche Riva )
20th CENTURY OPERAS : the MOST VIEWED and MOST COMPLETE last century opera playlist in YOU TUBE !
upatoia 2 years ago
If you like Puccini and know what quality is you'd STAY AWAY from Paul Potts. That's for sure...
Turand0t 2 years ago 8
Amen to that!
NaratheStargazer 2 years ago
LOL! Well said.
mcigdem 2 years ago
The BEST Butterfly EVER!!!!!!!
LaBartoli 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
la voz de maria callas supera a la de la tebaldi y la prescencia de la callas tambien
angelmoxo0 2 years ago
Que voz tan excelsa maravillosa su voz excelente video muy bueno conmovedor realmente es fascinante
INTEGRA0023 2 years ago
I think Tebaldi is a great Butterfly and Mimi. Love Callas but thin in terms of emotional richness Renata always wins. Bit like Domingo v Pavarotti !
ascoteagle 2 years ago
You are right.
tebaldicallas 2 years ago 3
I think that Maria Callas and Renata Tebaldi both had amazing voices. I have been taking my first singing lesson for a few months now, and my teacher told me to listen to Tibaldi. I did happen to see Callas perform the week before. They are both good to study. They both have AMAZING voices, it really just depends on what kind of voice you like, because they both sound very different.
supernaturalfunkytow 2 years ago 2
PERFECT
kwonyoungim 2 years ago 4
I commented earlier, negatively, on Tebaldi's Jewel Song from Faust here on Youtube (lack of trill, etc). But in this Un bel di she is certainly in her natural territory.
Scalatti 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dalloway3 2 years ago
As far as I know, the highest number of octaves in opera is 11, while Umm Kolthoum reached 13 and Mohammad Al Quppanchi reached 18 :)
msmak56 2 years ago
veramente divina....
aircat29 2 years ago 5
I've seen her past her prime, but with all her allure, at Espace Pierre Cardin in Paris in the late '70s. She was intelligent, fabulous and still the great star. She sang new stuff only because, she said, if you want to hear what I sounded like before, buy my records....
LeTerrible2008 2 years ago
That MAGIC Renata touch...
cleanears 2 years ago 4
Recordings don't tell everything. Quality, size of voice, character, integrity, movement & the effect on an audience need describing too. Have you heard a great performance by this singer live, without a mic? If so please post an objective description to add the wonderful YouTube archive before the memory is lost for ever.
How I wish I could have been there to hear Farinelli entrance an audience with the power of a single note, but we do at least have Charles Burney's marvellous account.
CharlotteinWeimar 2 years ago 2
Strepitosa , Magica Renata....!!! mai voce di soprano sarà pari alla tua...grazie per tutte le emozioni che mi fai vivere ascoltandoti in le tue interpretazioni che hai fatto.......
albertogaruccio 2 years ago 3
Tebaldi, in her prime, singing Puccini, and particularly Madama Butterfly. Could it get much better than this?
meltzerboy 2 years ago 8
and... the best aria!
aghneyya 2 years ago 4
A dear friend introduced me to this song recently and since hearing it for the first time it has become an addiction..... Renata sings it with such passion.... I sit mesmerised and watch and listen over and over again.... truly a graceful lady and such a heart wrenching song..... thank you
stella13bella 3 years ago 8
I'm a fan of rock but this song make me feel like crying. Such a sad song.
fallenleaf25 3 years ago 3
Excellent presentation, beautiful woman, magnificent voice! More importantly, she carried herself with such grace and dignity ... a great lady. No wonder people loved her. The voice and temperament of an angel. HAPPY BIRTHDAY RENATA!!! Forever alive in our hearts. Thank-you so much Bendsito!!!
rosigattonero 3 years ago 3
What can I say - magnificent!
Thanks for sharing!
Cheers,
Nils
CountDiLuna 3 years ago 4
HAUNTINGLY ELEGANT!!
danguitarflorida 3 years ago 5
Просто супер!!!!!!!! Такие же эмоции вызывает исполнение Марии Пеллегринию Слушайте и наслаждайтесь!!!!!!!!!!!
SeeDGameGuru 3 years ago
con la callas..il meglio della lirica al femminile
Hellboy2088 3 years ago
senza dubbio
rossini90 3 years ago
Io ritengo che quest'aria sia una delle piu' belle composizioni della storia della musica
bachorg 3 years ago 3
Che fantastica interpretazione e che voce sovraffino, proprio la voce di un angelo. Ogni volta che ascolto quest'aria cantata dalla Tebaldi mi vengono la pelle d'oca dall'emozione e le lacrime agli occhi...
rivermaya666 3 years ago 6
La più bella voce di soprano per qualità, intonazione e potenza. La Callas non possedeva queste doti al massimo livello, anche se come espressività drammatica ed estensione le era superiore.
baritolo 3 years ago 2
Rénata Tébaldi est sans doute l'une des plus belles voix du siècle! Elle chante vraiment super bien.
DSDV57 3 years ago 6
Today is Tebaldi's 4th anniversary of her death. But time will never erase the memory of this great soprano. Truly one of the greatest voices of the 20th century. Love you Renata!
rosigattonero 3 years ago 8
Mamma mia...nel sentire queste voci mi vien voglia non solo di riascoltare ma anche di cantare lirica...se solo avessi studiato!
E la passione per le donne di Puccini traspare magnificamente nelle sue opere...fantastico!
WariITA 3 years ago 6
Non esisterà piu'nessuno come lei. Riposi in pace Signora.
alnboy90 3 years ago 7