He isn;t being original, he is just singing like JL - sorry, but it doesn't come close, in way of timbre, vocal styling, and it doesn't seem like he has really connected with the song and its meaning. Its meant to be about love, he just sat there like a robot
@lxiaolx You are so true bout the race thing. Mr. midnightromance didn't mention shit about race or being black to have soul. Maybe KIMYUNAROCKS is just someone who doesn't know shit about music
He was such a great singer, he definitely made an impact on me til this day to actually still hear his music even though he wasn't on the show for long. One of the VERY few people I actually grew to like on this stupid show.
Alex Lambert has a TON of Star-Quality...I think there are people out there who are intimidated by his formidable talent, good looks, and magnetic personality...
This guy has a good voice, no way to deny that.. But when it comes to john legend... I felt disappointed, he can sing.. but there isnt... a stage presence.. he lacks confidence, and it shows. He made his own version of the song, and thats great, but it isnt anywhere near the expertise of Mr legend.
why would you write a title like that for the vid? let people have their own opinions and respect john legend. maybe you see it as a compition? though you forgot something, music is about turning feelings into sound. if you ceonnected with alex lamberts version better so be it, but dont disrespect john legend.
maybe you're afraid that lambert will vanish? this doesnt really give him hype.. wish you all the best.
why would you write a title like that for the vid? let people have their own opinions and respect john legend. maybe you see it as a compition? though you forgot something, music is about turning feelings into sound. if you ceonnected with alex lamberts version better so be it, but dont disrespect john legend.
maybe you're afraid that lambert will vanish? this doesnt really give him hype.. wish you all the best.
I think they're equally good, I had never heard of John Legend until Alex sung this and now i'm a huge fan of them both, I think it's really hard to decide between both versions, they've both got really nice, original tones to their voices :)
no one can say alex is better than john because to be honest how can someone be better than ur own song you know like u wrote it yeah a cover can be so good but no one can beat the person who wrote and sang it but i love alex
You're always walking dangerous territory in saying "better than the original"...but personally I can't stand John Legend (pretentious, annoying douche) or his singing (his lisp annoys the shit out of me) so this is easily better to my ears. But whatever.
It does make sense to compare. Just because John is famous doesn't mean he has a better voice. That's like saying in this case that Kesha or Britney Spears has a better voice than Crystal Bowersox, which is also on this show. Alex just sounds better on this song, his voice matches it more. Just because the person is the original artist of the song doesn't mean they are the best at singing it.
Alex Lambert Aaron Kelly are 2 of the best ones on American Idol so why the HELL did he go home BRING HIM BACK WITH THE WILD CARD HES THE ONLY ONE THAT DESERVES IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If you ever signed the petition, make sure you get updates from the creator by emailing her. Jessica's email is in the petition as well or jess808 gmail com.
DeathCabForJordan, YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY WRONG! Alex's talents belong to the world!!! Who are you to say he belongs only in trendy coffee shops!??? I love and appreciate him, SO DO 19,000 people (and counting). YOU ARE CLUELESS just how much Alex is loved and appreciated in the U.S. and in other countries as well! You're being offensive to his fans! Just so you know, I happen to like John Legend as well. Enough said!
John Legend has so much more soul. Don't get me wrong, this guy's good, but honestly he belongs more in a trendy coffee shop then performing in front of millions of americans.
ALEX LAMBERT FANS: Go to the american idol website & vote 'the judges save: should be used in the semi finals' since alex was KICKED off during the semi finals, I think we have a chance to bring him back!
@tonipette me too i signed up the petition..AI soo boring I preferred to watch Glee AI just got lack of talents this season.. they've cut Alex Lambert and Angela Martin..what the!!!
I've noticed that most people that do songs that aren't really well known leave earlier than those that are constantly doing "Billboard" songs. Because I don't think people here them and say wow that's good singing but rather. Wow they did they did that song well.
Just my opinion, but I liked Alex Lambert's much better than John Legend. Alex, you are an American Idol to us regardless of what the show or their producers say. Keep singing Alex. Just please keep singing.
OK, i love Alex Lambert, and this performance is awesome. But how dare you all for saying this is better than the original. John Legend deserves much more respect than that.
how dare we? he IS better! listen to that voice. and his smile. i love how he smiles when he says i guess. haha
he's a good performer. they can't say he isn't.
are they gonna listen to the petition? did they say they would take him back? i hope he at least gets a record contract now he's been on AI, i mean it is a way to get noticed.
I would think John Legend would realize that this is the sincerest form of flattery. Who wrote the song? It's a perfect song for Alex's voice. The quiver in his voice may be from nerves, but it really enhances his voice. No disrespect to Legend!
I wish people would stop saying it's better than John Legend's or say even say he don't measure up to John's. Of course he doesn't. It's just a real cool take on the song. I like both versions, and Alex did a great job with it.
@desireechick i agree this is NOT BETTER THAN JOHN LEGEND...i've seen john live, ive seen him in sound check and i hve the albums...alex lambert did really well...i liked his version but its not better than john legend at all
I loved this song as sung by JL from the first time I heard it. But I also like the simplicity of AL's rendition. I won't go as far as to say that AL's version is "a million times bttr" but he does enunciate the words clearer, making it more heartfelt.
JL, as a singer, is more technically sound but in this case, AL's rendition is more heartfelt.
I completely disagree you dont have to be black to have soul....I have replayed this song 12 times already because it touches my soul when I hear it...Old sould singers had the same effect because they were singing of pain and from the heart, and "soul"..If it has that effect on you it's from the soul...I have not replayed...Legends version...on the other hand I replay Lauryn Hill all the time
please correct yourself when restating my words i didn't say you have to be black to have soul what kind of racist shit is that? i understand what your getting at but that's not what im getting at. what im saying is that i hear more soul in JL's voice for this particular song. mind you i didn't say it was bad i said he did good a good job period just not with the same emotion is all
all in all
this is more opinionated in everyones selective tastes so more respect to you :)
@KIMYUNAROCKS shut u a hater u punk cuz u aint black and that is true u dont have to be black to have soul but the black ppl have the most soul and soul isnta sound its a feeling u prolly dont even sing so plz u should have no say so and no one can sing JL songs better then the man himself
@KIMYUNAROCKS Thats absolutely not what he said, he said he lacked the emotion, the soul that John Legend puts in it, he diden't say there's not really soul in it because he's white i agree though it dosen't really touche me as much when John's sing is it, still good voice though
@MrMidnightRomance I disagree, i could feel the soul come through on AL's version and I am a huge JL fan. Try listening to it without watching the screen.
its easy to HEAR how great his voice is. Sad to me that sooo much is based on stage presents.
I understand why, cuz the stage is where the money really comes from.... most live stuff from super stars are bad voice wise...but u give them a pass cuz they are the artist..etc.
the best example is almost any guest performer on idol...lol jk well kinda.
if ppl are bugging me on stage i look away and listen to them...the last thing music for me is for the eyes. MTV proves my point everyday.
I agree he sang this song millions time better than john legend her voice fits this song have can revive this sond and make record,, because no one knew this song before,,, now seems like everybody is liking this song.. GO GO GO alex
... he looks like the guy off chronical!
LoganRicardoYbarra1 1 week ago
I COULD JUST LISTEN TO THIS OVER AND OVER.
luvmocha14 2 weeks ago
Wow.. You butchered that shit..
TheSnavenhoj 1 month ago
I dislike this for the mere fact that you said he sang it better than John Legend, um are you crazy??
Tengagedhahaha 1 month ago
Still listening to Alex!
nicoalcedera 1 month ago
Alex rocks!
ohmira27 2 months ago 2
He's good but not good as JL for sure!he cannot be better than JL neva ;)
alienesm 2 months ago 2
He isn;t being original, he is just singing like JL - sorry, but it doesn't come close, in way of timbre, vocal styling, and it doesn't seem like he has really connected with the song and its meaning. Its meant to be about love, he just sat there like a robot
MySassyfrass 2 months ago
Umm. John Legend is one of, if not the best soul singer of the modern era - to compare the two is a musical offence..lol
MySassyfrass 2 months ago
Not even close to John Legend. Kimyunarock's ears sucks apparently.
TheRealDynamitjanne 3 months ago
26 people are tim urban fans .
weaverren 3 months ago
lmfao at the title. this fuckin fagggot's version does not even come close to the Legends's.
usmanioa 4 months ago
He's good
MsCloudnine7 4 months ago
really? do we really need the comparison?? alex's is great, and john legend's is great, period.
dalusgembalus 5 months ago
Great voice. But the snare in this song just ruined the whole feel of it. HE did a good job, but that back-up band just messed it up for me.
chrischris091 5 months ago
definitely not better than john legend but i get if your a huge fan you would say that so i forgive you lol
RonChase21 5 months ago
And this is why he didn't win
SireKingofSorrow 6 months ago
he's good, but it's pretty ridiculous to compare him to John Legend.
xHassy30 6 months ago
Alex's voice IS better - its richer and more layered.. as he keeps gaining more performance experience, he will blow people away.
luckyer100 6 months ago
great voice but hes no Legend just sayin!!
Jonathan7645 6 months ago
nah not really john legend one is so much better
oliviannify 6 months ago
damn u can u sing i love it.
gracieboo231 7 months ago
@lxiaolx You are so true bout the race thing. Mr. midnightromance didn't mention shit about race or being black to have soul. Maybe KIMYUNAROCKS is just someone who doesn't know shit about music
SteveNashPho13 7 months ago
The only person I liked on this show.
Harmonator1000 7 months ago
Comment removed
eddiekemp3 8 months ago
He was such a great singer, he definitely made an impact on me til this day to actually still hear his music even though he wasn't on the show for long. One of the VERY few people I actually grew to like on this stupid show.
effthismofo1 8 months ago
Alex Lambert has a TON of Star-Quality...I think there are people out there who are intimidated by his formidable talent, good looks, and magnetic personality...
luckyer100 9 months ago
this video is gravely mislabelled
seriffaviator 10 months ago
he"s really2 gud..
egye89 10 months ago
stopped watching the show last year when he was voted off.
msgatotito 10 months ago 17
he's so good :) i wish he made the top 12 instead of casey...
xKLC94x 11 months ago
great song... the singer is great.. but: BETTER THAN JL??????????????
no way....
it just sounds great because the song is great anyway
Fredvanhalen 11 months ago
this dude have a crazy tune.. so unique
droga187 11 months ago
without john legend, he wouldn't have been able to do this performance.
mralx1234 11 months ago
This guy has a good voice, no way to deny that.. But when it comes to john legend... I felt disappointed, he can sing.. but there isnt... a stage presence.. he lacks confidence, and it shows. He made his own version of the song, and thats great, but it isnt anywhere near the expertise of Mr legend.
mshotwell4280 11 months ago
Amazing! :)
EarlyMorningsAndRain 1 year ago
That kid owned that song ! they screwed up his voice is rare ,
blinkdead 1 year ago 3
Better than Mr. Legends original. Sorry.
golfhack2007 1 year ago
He pronounces the word "harder" weird in the beginning. John Legend is much better
jerkingoff2you 1 year ago
ilovemesomealexlambert<3
Kaelee560 1 year ago
this kid is homeless
luvwee 1 year ago
@luvwee Nahh bruhh you misinterpreted his words..
Kaelee560 1 year ago
i love the version of this he did on the show. did a version of my own on my channel too!
RaulMorales5678 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why would you write a title like that for the vid? let people have their own opinions and respect john legend. maybe you see it as a compition? though you forgot something, music is about turning feelings into sound. if you ceonnected with alex lamberts version better so be it, but dont disrespect john legend.
maybe you're afraid that lambert will vanish? this doesnt really give him hype.. wish you all the best.
horkaveh 1 year ago
why would you write a title like that for the vid? let people have their own opinions and respect john legend. maybe you see it as a compition? though you forgot something, music is about turning feelings into sound. if you ceonnected with alex lamberts version better so be it, but dont disrespect john legend.
maybe you're afraid that lambert will vanish? this doesnt really give him hype.. wish you all the best.
horkaveh 1 year ago
I LOVE HIS VERSION...I LOVE HIM!!!
SEENAHM 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think they're equally good, I had never heard of John Legend until Alex sung this and now i'm a huge fan of them both, I think it's really hard to decide between both versions, they've both got really nice, original tones to their voices :)
babzamma 1 year ago
Hahahahhahahahahahahhaha what the fuck. This is no way near as good as John. Oh my god. People these days.
musiclegend07 1 year ago 13
ONE HUNDRED TIMES better than the original.
SolskjaerZA 1 year ago
no one can say alex is better than john because to be honest how can someone be better than ur own song you know like u wrote it yeah a cover can be so good but no one can beat the person who wrote and sang it but i love alex
TickleMebird 1 year ago
a great song plus a great voice equals an amazing performance...
this was great...
Mr16badz 1 year ago
You're always walking dangerous territory in saying "better than the original"...but personally I can't stand John Legend (pretentious, annoying douche) or his singing (his lisp annoys the shit out of me) so this is easily better to my ears. But whatever.
Ricearoni80 1 year ago
Alex Lambert is cool. But this version is NOT better than the original, sorry Yuna lady.
ImperialDecree 1 year ago
Half of you aren't even singers or musically minded, so shut up.
John Legend's version is better hands down..
kingdono1 1 year ago
Not better than John tho.
o0Smexy0o 1 year ago 2
better of john legend ????? hahahahahhahah this is ridicolus
3vilangelist 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
His nevousness is EXACTLY LIKE ME, and I love him. His voice is perfect.
freaknkrazy 1 year ago
holy shit
tayylornocon 1 year ago
no way
John Legend is much better
AAB1 1 year ago
ISN'T HE THE CUTEST THING YOU EVER SEEN IN YOUR LIFE?! yessss
haileyelizabeth13 1 year ago 5
Of course white people are gonna like this version better than the original Black Soul singers version .... its not rocket science
oglowke 1 year ago
he rocks
yubasa1992 1 year ago
Why the FUCK isn't he still on the show.?!
itskaylaaa23 1 year ago
It does make sense to compare. Just because John is famous doesn't mean he has a better voice. That's like saying in this case that Kesha or Britney Spears has a better voice than Crystal Bowersox, which is also on this show. Alex just sounds better on this song, his voice matches it more. Just because the person is the original artist of the song doesn't mean they are the best at singing it.
MRCrashFusion 1 year ago
I love his voice.
virtueisin 1 year ago
Alex Lambert Aaron Kelly are 2 of the best ones on American Idol so why the HELL did he go home BRING HIM BACK WITH THE WILD CARD HES THE ONLY ONE THAT DESERVES IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dArLeNewk 1 year ago
ATTN: Alex Lambert fans, he is now in a a website show called IF I CAN DREAM. Hurry and check it out!
deirlyramos 1 year ago
he snapped on the song!! good shit.. only thing i can say was bad was the last note where he says KNOOOOOWSSS it was off pitch
gool3m 1 year ago
Heartsdonthate, how ironic you give yourself that name when you have such potty mouth.
deirlyramos 1 year ago
If you ever signed the petition, make sure you get updates from the creator by emailing her. Jessica's email is in the petition as well or jess808 gmail com.
catstare 1 year ago
DeathCabForJordan, YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY WRONG! Alex's talents belong to the world!!! Who are you to say he belongs only in trendy coffee shops!??? I love and appreciate him, SO DO 19,000 people (and counting). YOU ARE CLUELESS just how much Alex is loved and appreciated in the U.S. and in other countries as well! You're being offensive to his fans! Just so you know, I happen to like John Legend as well. Enough said!
deirlyramos 1 year ago
hes not a fucking superhero calm down. hes just a good singer, and there are so many out there. i AGREE with deathcabforjordan.
Heartsdonthate 1 year ago
John Legend has so much more soul. Don't get me wrong, this guy's good, but honestly he belongs more in a trendy coffee shop then performing in front of millions of americans.
DeathCabForJordan 1 year ago
ALEX LAMBERT FANS: Go to the american idol website & vote 'the judges save: should be used in the semi finals' since alex was KICKED off during the semi finals, I think we have a chance to bring him back!
musicxcraze 1 year ago
Alex is awesome but i have to disagree, original is way better.
SimpleVisionVideos 1 year ago
Comment removed
musicxcraze 1 year ago
This is good.. but it is not better than John Legend..
xiongsnx 1 year ago
What an amazing talent.
scottstrong9 1 year ago
@ idolstar1
ive listened to it with my eyes open and closed John Legend is more suited imo
dont get me wrong hes good but i cant feel the same soul that was presented like JL did
MrMidnightRomance 1 year ago
i completely agree he sounds good but Legend has a soulful undertone that touches me
Aria591 1 year ago
i signed the petition on google to bring hin back to the show.
tonipette 1 year ago 21
@tonipette me too i signed up the petition..AI soo boring I preferred to watch Glee AI just got lack of talents this season.. they've cut Alex Lambert and Angela Martin..what the!!!
warcrashjay 1 year ago
I've noticed that most people that do songs that aren't really well known leave earlier than those that are constantly doing "Billboard" songs. Because I don't think people here them and say wow that's good singing but rather. Wow they did they did that song well.
xsh3ldonxppc 1 year ago
Just my opinion, but I liked Alex Lambert's much better than John Legend. Alex, you are an American Idol to us regardless of what the show or their producers say. Keep singing Alex. Just please keep singing.
Dorelliun 1 year ago 4
OK, i love Alex Lambert, and this performance is awesome. But how dare you all for saying this is better than the original. John Legend deserves much more respect than that.
tdogg98264 1 year ago
how dare we? he IS better! listen to that voice. and his smile. i love how he smiles when he says i guess. haha
he's a good performer. they can't say he isn't.
are they gonna listen to the petition? did they say they would take him back? i hope he at least gets a record contract now he's been on AI, i mean it is a way to get noticed.
LemonOdette 1 year ago
smile has nun tuh do wif his voice i like it but i dont htinks hez better at all to me therez something missin hez gud though :-)
Aria591 1 year ago
I would think John Legend would realize that this is the sincerest form of flattery. Who wrote the song? It's a perfect song for Alex's voice. The quiver in his voice may be from nerves, but it really enhances his voice. No disrespect to Legend!
anniemohon 1 year ago
I liked it better than John's version! For his age & inexperience hes awesome!
CajunCatherine 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Please everyone, go to w w w . change . org (no spaces) & sign the petition to bring Alex back to AI, he needs your votes!!
Anaidvideo 1 year ago
vote for him tonight! vote for him a lot [=
mle4realz 1 year ago
I wish people would stop saying it's better than John Legend's or say even say he don't measure up to John's. Of course he doesn't. It's just a real cool take on the song. I like both versions, and Alex did a great job with it.
desireechick 1 year ago 20
naw its better
KIMYUNAROCKS 1 year ago 3
@KIMYUNAROCKS nah, where's the soul
LittlJohn 1 year ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS Nah, it isn't better.
AwesomePeow 4 months ago 2
@desireechick i agree this is NOT BETTER THAN JOHN LEGEND...i've seen john live, ive seen him in sound check and i hve the albums...alex lambert did really well...i liked his version but its not better than john legend at all
armydime 1 year ago
@desireechick this way better than john "legend"
whtpwr 1 year ago
@desireechick i totally agree and they are so different. im sure they have mutual respect for each others vocal talent.
ChrisMcClain2011 1 year ago
I loved this song as sung by JL from the first time I heard it. But I also like the simplicity of AL's rendition. I won't go as far as to say that AL's version is "a million times bttr" but he does enunciate the words clearer, making it more heartfelt.
JL, as a singer, is more technically sound but in this case, AL's rendition is more heartfelt.
suziemclean 1 year ago 2
u suck fallintoruin!!..
do u have any idea of what a good voice is??
i believe, if you thought that alex ruined the song and he is horrible, i bet u can sing the song a way better, right????
soopachoops 1 year ago
I really like his voice!
ilj007 1 year ago 8
I Love Him.
P.S. You suck fallintoruin. Maybe you should fall into ruin.
squintlover4 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this was horrible i cant believe he ruined this song
FallintoRuin 1 year ago
I don't usually download these Idol performances from iTunes, but this one was a must-have. This was a brilliant performance!
nonabliss 2 years ago 4
Me too. Can't just get enough.
Checked on John's version, this is much better (i think).
rectrofans 2 years ago
@ KIMYUNAROCKS
i agree with you I REPLAY THIS SONG OVER AND OVER I CAN'T ENOUGH OF HIM
Hiltonmanik 2 years ago 3
love his version...♥
greiz09 2 years ago
OMG he is cute to be terrified on stage. :D::D:D
girlonline33 2 years ago 4
i looove how he puts so much emphases on the "R" 's in the songgg <3 :) hahahaha
loverlove911 2 years ago
he has a great voice hands-down but honestly that song lacked the soul JL put into it
thats why its JL's song :) great job tho man
MrMidnightRomance 2 years ago
I completely disagree you dont have to be black to have soul....I have replayed this song 12 times already because it touches my soul when I hear it...Old sould singers had the same effect because they were singing of pain and from the heart, and "soul"..If it has that effect on you it's from the soul...I have not replayed...Legends version...on the other hand I replay Lauryn Hill all the time
KIMYUNAROCKS 2 years ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS
please correct yourself when restating my words i didn't say you have to be black to have soul what kind of racist shit is that? i understand what your getting at but that's not what im getting at. what im saying is that i hear more soul in JL's voice for this particular song. mind you i didn't say it was bad i said he did good a good job period just not with the same emotion is all
all in all
this is more opinionated in everyones selective tastes so more respect to you :)
MrMidnightRomance 1 year ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS no one said you have to be black to have soul...dnt make this racial...btw JL's version IS better =)
vincane15 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KIMYUNAROCKS no one said you have to be black to have soul...dnt make this racial...btw JL's version IS better =)
vincane15 1 year ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS shut u a hater u punk cuz u aint black and that is true u dont have to be black to have soul but the black ppl have the most soul and soul isnta sound its a feeling u prolly dont even sing so plz u should have no say so and no one can sing JL songs better then the man himself
siloochenta 11 months ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS Thats absolutely not what he said, he said he lacked the emotion, the soul that John Legend puts in it, he diden't say there's not really soul in it because he's white i agree though it dosen't really touche me as much when John's sing is it, still good voice though
ikheetjason 11 months ago
@KIMYUNAROCKS when the fuck did race come into this? u clearly know nothing about music
lxiaolx 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KIMYUNAROCKS when the fuck did race come into this? u clearly know nothing about music
lxiaolx 9 months ago
@MrMidnightRomance I disagree, i could feel the soul come through on AL's version and I am a huge JL fan. Try listening to it without watching the screen.
idolstar1 2 years ago
Him and Lee Deewyze have the most unique voices of the guys this season.
spartyutube 2 years ago 4
not close to john legend, but i like him a lot.
itzmeeteddy 2 years ago
its easy to HEAR how great his voice is. Sad to me that sooo much is based on stage presents.
I understand why, cuz the stage is where the money really comes from.... most live stuff from super stars are bad voice wise...but u give them a pass cuz they are the artist..etc.
the best example is almost any guest performer on idol...lol jk well kinda.
if ppl are bugging me on stage i look away and listen to them...the last thing music for me is for the eyes. MTV proves my point everyday.
stewbonesk8r 2 years ago
OMG....never heard this song b4. He was amazing!!! Got chills from his performance. This was so much better than the Legend version. WOW!
lincolnfraga 2 years ago 2
I agree he sang this song millions time better than john legend her voice fits this song have can revive this sond and make record,, because no one knew this song before,,, now seems like everybody is liking this song.. GO GO GO alex
volkanlover 2 years ago
Yes he was much better than Legend, he was the best so far this year
46tricks 2 years ago 3