I wonder about the use of "inegal," the unequal length of same-valued notes. It's not really rubato or tempo variation. Can the roll itself be examined to see if that quality is "programmed" into the performance?
This piece is always heard at a rapid, but basically even pace, which seems to work well. It's fascinating to hear someone as illustrious as Reinecke do it so differently.
The "lumpiness" of some of the rhythms is what you get when the roll is played too slowly. If not twice this speed, this does need to played quite a lot faster nonetheless.
Words can't describe how beautiful that performance is. I'd also like to hear it at the suggested speed. This speed sounds right for most of it but theres places where it seems unnaturally fast for the particular interpretation.
19 th century MIDI !!
linceed87 9 months ago
I wonder about the use of "inegal," the unequal length of same-valued notes. It's not really rubato or tempo variation. Can the roll itself be examined to see if that quality is "programmed" into the performance?
This piece is always heard at a rapid, but basically even pace, which seems to work well. It's fascinating to hear someone as illustrious as Reinecke do it so differently.
gatesurfer 1 year ago
@gatesurfer i think, like all romantics liked to use a lot of rubato
linceed87 9 months ago
Theatrical playing , the tempo is here and it has freedom ,it is like a baroque playing,great
tuxedomoon 1 year ago
A very interesting historical recording. Note the freedom of tempos and textual accuracy.
gerardbedecarter 1 year ago
The "lumpiness" of some of the rhythms is what you get when the roll is played too slowly. If not twice this speed, this does need to played quite a lot faster nonetheless.
d60944 2 years ago
tempo all over the place......
flugelmaniac 2 years ago 2
I think this tempo is too slow comparing to Wanda Landowska's 1920's harpsicord version. I also want to hear the suggested tempo.
Would you please post it?
Thanks!
LouisLeeKH 2 years ago
Words can't describe how beautiful that performance is. I'd also like to hear it at the suggested speed. This speed sounds right for most of it but theres places where it seems unnaturally fast for the particular interpretation.
themfromspace 2 years ago
CAN YOU PLEASE POST A VERSION WITH SUGGESTED TEMPO?
I'd love to hear it!
acortot 2 years ago
very interesting to hear it played like this. very different from most recordings done now.
pianoman1984 3 years ago