100428 IU - In My Fading Memory (Park Ji Yoon cover)

[stars70097]

IU haters will choose SNSD

[mynameistitam]

again, people compare between IU and Taeyeon... They're different and unique in their own way... Please, stop compare... I go to Taeyeon's video when she covered this song and NO ONE mentioned IU's name at there... This is not fair, You guys always mentioned "Taeyeon" in every IU's video when they sang a same song and always compare them and tell that "Taeyeon is better than IU or whatever..." Please, stop it... Please, just appreciate what IU has done in this song... Thank You!

[LuverNaNa95]

Taeyeon and IU voice is really soft when they sing this song ^^

I'm really thankful whoever make this song!!!

Not to forget Park Jiyoon unique voice too~

Really touching..

[dspark1101]

Taeyeon's video had better background music.. but IU is clearly the better singer...

[oakes4574]

Both Taeyeon and IU sing well for an 'IDOL', but their voices sound plain. On the contrary, Park Ji-Yoon is not a skillful signer, but she has a unique voice. That's what made this song so special. So comparing two 'IDOL' singers over this beautiful ballad is meaningless.

[Iiiyurh]

IU IU ^^ 최고

[charlenepatrice]

i like tete's version more. Iu sang it with no emotions or whatsoever! And its too fast plus the song doesnt fit her voice!;p tete jjang!^^

[apple343525]

IU+TAEYEON=??

TAEU?

[tinafreak1991]

i m big fan of snsd..but iu and taeyeon are one of the best vocalist in kpop right now....if they ever do duet i think it would win over everybody...amazing.... :)) but yeah this songs suits better taeyeon but i think iu did amazing

[Voidli]

Taeng and IU need a duet. It'll be mindblowing :)

[nutchay16]

I love this cover

[Feliaudrey]

Taeyeon's version is more touching :')

[kangaroo1002]

IU are you secretly a fan of Tae? lol I didnt realise IU also covered this song. IU fighting! Love IUs voice, but I still prefer Taes cover. Maybe Tae and IU should have a duet.

[TsukushiKyoko]

IU 's the best:x

[alterna]

IU did great, but I do prefer Taeng's cover. I like the instrumentals (by Mate!) better in Taeng's cover. IU has a terrific voice and she sounds fantastic. But one thing she's lacking is emotions in her singing.

[kimanipunisher4]

Taeyeon is closer to Ji Yoon's... Simply because the texture of her voice compliments the song well; unlike IU's airy-ish take of the song...

[sumiji888]

Just found it...I feel IU suits better for this song than Taeyeon...sometimes..it's the other way around.

[sumiji888]

Taeyeon sings this too??

[bluefate543]

i don't get why people compare them all the time

in IU's vid but i love both of them <3

[thelordofthelinks]

i agreed with Lvil111 ... Taeyeon version have better live back up. However they both are great.

[FuCaDak]

*--*Good

[dongtaengster]

I like this cover. Props to IU :) It's definitely a different style than Taeyeon's--but you can't blame that, since they have different voices. IU's is closer to the original because her voice is more like Park Ji Yoon's (it has that airy sound), but Taeyeon's is still good. Both are good, but no lies, Park Ji Yoon's version trumps both.

The opening of this video made me laugh though-- Pirates of the Caribbean music, haha.

[JeNduth]

what taeyeon cover IU do a cover too.. what a friend.. :D

both are awesome singer.. <3

[quf24]

park ji yoon pwns both of them.

[MsManless]

When she sing this , she was 16years old

[ilovesnsd12309]

MY dreams came true.. :)) Make more duets..

English songs next...

[hcammari]

you forget that she has only 18 years so the feeling is diferent...each singer has a powerful voice (taeyeon, park and IU)so IU fighting!!!

[hensempig]

different feel as compared to ty! equally good!

[junkacc11]

All IU covers have too much reverb.

[tykz]

I've got a mix of IU and Taeyeon singing this song and i love it!!!!

[homegirl131]

IU somehow always ends up covering the same songs that Taeyeon also covered. For this song I liked Taeyeon's version better but IU's is good too.

[Cleon1986]

@homegirl131 I would agree with you. Taeyeon's cover had so much emotion in it. It makes me sad just listening to it.

[zazremedy]

@homegirl131 well i prefer the original, the real emotion doesn't convey in both IU n Taeyon's cover

[YJIDOL]

when i listen to IU's cover i like taeyeon more,but when i listen to taeyeon's cover i feel IU is better...lol

[KstineCHris]

love IU buy Love Taeyeon's cover more!

[histatemike]

oops i mean IU's....

[histatemike]

i listened to the original by Park Ji Yoon. Much respect to her...but I like UI's version just slightly better. :)

[parkjan123]

woah she's good

[nuttynud]

nice!but unni's of course is better =D

[hoodstrmm]

IU is amazing but no one can beat Park Ji Yoon's voice on this song

[GomChingu]

@hoodstrmm taeyeon's was pretty damn good as well 

[cstrcmp]

awesome