Never played this game: This is exactly why. I don't want to be a complete ass but I really, really find it painfully obvious, -gasp spoilers- that this is indeed a woman. The voice is just awful. Husky woman? Sure, MAYBE. But that's NOT A MAN. Not in any way.
Naoto's voice sounds husky and more mature but not to to boyish, it's a good English VA in my opinion she makes a good looking guy though AND a pretty hawt chick. She's good.
you can tell by that she is really a girl I saw her where a school uniform a girls on and once she takes that hat off he or should say she look like a girl I know all this stuff beacause well I have the limit editon artbook
and you can actually have her as a girlfreind
I bet some people well think the main caracter is gay lol then again it happaend to kanji.
seems like it, when I heard he is a SHE, I thought like "OMG what a major spoiler I just got to see URGH" but now that I hear HER talk... it's just like "huh, could have figured that out myself... INSTANTLY!"
A few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the babysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this letter on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand;sorry i didnt want that happening to me
When I saw Naoto in the opening, I suspected he*ahem* she would be those kinds of people who objects the main character's justice and become an antagonist.
Let's hope I'm right =) And I'll hear no spoiling from ANYBODY!
that's based on jeolousy. I meant Naoto might object the main character's "justice" literally, resulting in two opposing protagonists. Happens in most anime too.
i like it..! it matches "him" perfectly..! definitley makes u think she could be a girl instead of thinking definitely a girl..! didnt know this was the VA for blackrose in the dot hack games and T.K. from digimon..!
so obviously female... i knew this was a female before i even found out she was. i only found out she was female by reading the comments below. they could have done better... but voice actors for both p3 were pretty damn good, and i doubt they'd be any less for this game. though they could have done better, it's cool though, that the voice hints to you that he may be female by listening closely or if you can sense it... vs boys that just turn out to be girls
I think the reason why Naoto poses as a boy is to taken more seriously since she is in a profession stereotypically done by men .Her fear is not being taken seriously, so this is most likely the case.
Spoilers (DON'T READ THEM IF YOU DON'T WANT TO BE SPOILED...) :
It is a girl. She just has a lot of issues hiding her small chest. Oh well... It's not a big problem, I already scene many scenes from the japanese version.
did anyone actually think naoto was a boy?
wizofgaming99 3 months ago
I am Naoto Shirogane and I am a lesbian
juLailgun 4 months ago
Did someone say, "girls"?!
DramaKingMan0 8 months ago 5
NAOTO'S VOICE IS JUST PLAIN SEXY.
spongefan1 11 months ago
"DID SOMEONE SAY GIRLS? Because I'm a boy. Just so you know."
Kwanzinator 1 year ago 23
him?
qkrqudxo91 1 year ago
Never played this game: This is exactly why. I don't want to be a complete ass but I really, really find it painfully obvious, -gasp spoilers- that this is indeed a woman. The voice is just awful. Husky woman? Sure, MAYBE. But that's NOT A MAN. Not in any way.
OrangeBandanna 1 year ago
OH NOES. ITS THE HAT WEARING BOY WHO CONVENIENTLY LOOKS LIKE A GIRL!
beserkmaster 1 year ago
wearing a hat makes you a boy
Decembirth 1 year ago 6
@Decembirth
I think wearing a penis and hair on the chest makes you a boy. :D
MrSutefan 1 year ago
IT'S A TRA--
*shot*
OEGSProductions 1 year ago 4
naoto shirogane boy or girl ?_?
cutiemimio69 2 years ago
Boy.
LunarxStar 2 years ago
@cutiemimio69 BOTH!!! ^_^
CalicoVall 9 months ago
now im fucking confused it MUST be a girl not guy? O_o
OblivionKnight457 2 years ago
I really don't see how you could mistake Naoto for a guy.
CalBro 3 years ago
her japanese voice sounds like a guy. :D i got the undubbed version
migeru23 2 years ago
i did, lol O_o
wesieboy56 2 years ago
i love naoto
my fav persona i like the part where on the school trip rise and yukiko think they are drunk and she is like it is isn't alcohol lol love naoto
emmamallay 3 years ago
wow..man..I think persona 3 is the best..the team of Persona 4 is exactly like the same as 3-different appearances but same personalities.
wingedprinceofrose 3 years ago
All part of the Arcana, really.
envy400 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah, but it still is a bit different, games like Final Fantasy kinda gave up creating new characters at all
FarelThirteen 3 years ago
I doubt it. P4's characters are much more realistic with different personalities, in my opinion.
unit1990 3 years ago 6
Naoto's voice sounds husky and more mature but not to to boyish, it's a good English VA in my opinion she makes a good looking guy though AND a pretty hawt chick. She's good.
haha
elephantlawst 3 years ago 27
you can tell by that she is really a girl I saw her where a school uniform a girls on and once she takes that hat off he or should say she look like a girl I know all this stuff beacause well I have the limit editon artbook
and you can actually have her as a girlfreind
I bet some people well think the main caracter is gay lol then again it happaend to kanji.
5150hold 3 years ago
When does the party find out Naoto is a girl and not a boy?
AnarchicAnimeFan51 3 years ago
i think when they go to the hot springs or they already knew
shadowmageman 3 years ago
they find out in Naoto's dungeon.. the secret underground lab.
Exoduso8 3 years ago
It happens at the end of Secret Lab Dungeon.
StrikeZeroX25 3 years ago
Could anyone not fucking spoil while responding to a video?
Yes you're cool for knowing that, now fuck off.
Lobster222 3 years ago 31
Naoto sounds very femenine to pretend she is a guy.
l3o2828 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Naoto IS a girl, haha
HyouHazard 3 years ago
Duh, i know...
that´s why i said "pretend to eb a boy"
l3o2828 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
in the jap version she sound alittle boyish aluts messed it up for the us version
shadowmageman 3 years ago
seems like it, when I heard he is a SHE, I thought like "OMG what a major spoiler I just got to see URGH" but now that I hear HER talk... it's just like "huh, could have figured that out myself... INSTANTLY!"
FarelThirteen 3 years ago
They really couldn't have gotten a dude to play this role? Seriously? The voice alone will fool me the entire game.
Ziabatsu 3 years ago
Well us Americans are lucky cause we don't usually have female sounding men unlike the Japanese who had to keep guessing.
MrWiiPS360 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
A few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the babysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this letter on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand;sorry i didnt want that happening to me
faeriegirl09 3 years ago
When I saw Naoto in the opening, I suspected he*ahem* she would be those kinds of people who objects the main character's justice and become an antagonist.
Let's hope I'm right =) And I'll hear no spoiling from ANYBODY!
envy400 3 years ago
but what about in P3 with junpei there very heavy hints suggesting that he would be the one to betray them but it turned out to be someone else
412356 3 years ago
that's based on jeolousy. I meant Naoto might object the main character's "justice" literally, resulting in two opposing protagonists. Happens in most anime too.
Light and L (Death Note)
Kazuma and Ryuho (s-CRY-ed)
Lelouch and Suzaku (Code Geass)
envy400 3 years ago
i understand what you were saying
but i'm just saying that they might have another twist like in P3
412356 3 years ago
yeah, most likely.
envy400 3 years ago
is it just me or her voice has a similarity to aegis voice what do u guys think
tonbogiri666 3 years ago
It's you, Naoto doesn't remind me of Aegis.
faalq 3 years ago
i agree, her voice seems nothing like aegis'
RoadToTheDawn 3 years ago
Naoto is good at hiding her genree. :3
iXAyaX 3 years ago
leave it to the Queen of Voice Acting to pull that off. :)
envy400 3 years ago
Oh wow Naoto's voice is really awesome.
Faizrider 3 years ago
Yeah I agree, glad they didn't mess it up. Her character looks awesome possum. I like her hat to :}
elephantlawst 3 years ago
seems like atlus hides her genre pretty well
jp2605 3 years ago
I think Naoto Shirogane sound like Miho Karasuma from Witch Hunter Robin.
docerberus7 3 years ago
I just received my copy of this game.
I am so excited to play to this over the
break!
sushiplaza 3 years ago
raawr I love him/her!!!!! I can't wait to play
daydreamie6 3 years ago
it's "her" she's a (G)(a)(L) woopps
dsOnTheRun 3 years ago
NO!.. WAY!.. PERFECT! xD
AzerotH568 3 years ago
naoto is a girl not a boy. if u need proof then look up the persona 4 hot spring video and the chrismas video with naoto
swordaxe 3 years ago
Uggg, I'm aware of it too, but can you guys really tone it down with the spoilers. Even if it can be seen as fairly obvious, a spoiler is a spoiler.
PrinceLionheart 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Naoto a boy.
He just has a androgynous appearance. ._.
And.. Voice. xD
MiyukiRainbowCandy 3 years ago
i like it..! it matches "him" perfectly..! definitley makes u think she could be a girl instead of thinking definitely a girl..! didnt know this was the VA for blackrose in the dot hack games and T.K. from digimon..!
uchihafan8082 3 years ago
so obviously female... i knew this was a female before i even found out she was. i only found out she was female by reading the comments below. they could have done better... but voice actors for both p3 were pretty damn good, and i doubt they'd be any less for this game. though they could have done better, it's cool though, that the voice hints to you that he may be female by listening closely or if you can sense it... vs boys that just turn out to be girls
viataliy 3 years ago
Amazon shipped my pre-ordered game today.
I am so excited to get it by tues or wednesday!
sushiplaza 3 years ago
I think the reason why Naoto poses as a boy is to taken more seriously since she is in a profession stereotypically done by men .Her fear is not being taken seriously, so this is most likely the case.
irock730 3 years ago
the va its good, but, you can easly tell who really is naoto, its sound better when "he" ask about rise
Dante0397 3 years ago
nice VA...i commend atlus for casting good voices on P4.
cant w8 to play P4
yuriking23 3 years ago
I love the voice. Obviously a bit more feminine, but good enough to pass for a more effeminate male in the beginning. I like! :D
rainofwar 3 years ago
awesome voice and it also is a fitting voice for a girl posing as a guy.
animehero402 3 years ago
yes plz
SatoKiba 3 years ago
god so confusing...guy, girl, guy, girl...this is drivning me crazy!
kevincorp32 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Kevincorp32: Naoto is a girl.
Real707 3 years ago
FYI on the voice actor
TK from Digimon
Faye Valentine from Cowboy Bebop
Haruhi Suzumiya from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
BlackRose from .Hack// series
DivineRonin 3 years ago
Seriously? That's a surprise...
The voice was pretty bland.
SigurdKing 3 years ago
Wendee Lee?
DragonFoce140 3 years ago
Yup.
hangjebat21 3 years ago
In the words of Raven from Tales of Vesperia:
"Yes! Oh god yes!"
Sry 'bout that, It out of my system now :P
Shadowz596 3 years ago
i know how u feel lol :)
Hellbornchaos 3 years ago
nice VA
vangphillip 3 years ago
badass sweetest voice. yes yes yeeeesss.
ilovethesickness17 3 years ago
Its a girl obviously
WoodenSwordL 3 years ago
Spoilers (DON'T READ THEM IF YOU DON'T WANT TO BE SPOILED...) :
It is a girl. She just has a lot of issues hiding her small chest. Oh well... It's not a big problem, I already scene many scenes from the japanese version.
flintmarkios 3 years ago
um, yeah
why did you respond to my comment with that... why not respond to the people actually asking, instead of me, who knows already
WoodenSwordL 3 years ago
He really does... Unless he's actually a dude? I don't think Atlus could miss the mark by that much...
chuckethy 3 years ago
4 more days.
lol nice Naoto definitely doesn't sound like a guy..right?
bmkharuhiism 3 years ago